-
How crowd accidents are reported in the news media: Lexical and sentiment analysis
Authors:
Claudio Feliciani,
Alessandro Corbetta,
Milad Haghani,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
The portrayal of crowd accidents by the media can influence public understanding and emotional response, sha** societal perceptions and potentially impacting safety measures and preparedness strategies. This paper critically examines the portrayal of crowd accidents in news coverage by analyzing the texts of 372 media reports of crowd accidents spanning 26 diverse news sources from 1900 to 2019.…
▽ More
The portrayal of crowd accidents by the media can influence public understanding and emotional response, sha** societal perceptions and potentially impacting safety measures and preparedness strategies. This paper critically examines the portrayal of crowd accidents in news coverage by analyzing the texts of 372 media reports of crowd accidents spanning 26 diverse news sources from 1900 to 2019. We investigate how media representations of crowd accidents vary across time and geographical origins. Our methodology combines lexical analysis to unveil prevailing terminologies and sentiment analysis to discern the emotional tenor of the reports. The findings reveal the prevalence of the term "stampede" over "panic" in media descriptions of crowd accidents. Notably, divergent patterns are observable when comparing Western versus South Asian media (notably India and Pakistan), unveiling a cross-cultural dimension. Moreover, the analysis detects a gradual transition from "crowd stampede" to "crowd crush" in media and Wikipedia narratives in recent years, suggesting evolving lexical sensitivities. Sentiment analysis uncovers a consistent association with fear-related language, indicative of media's propensity towards sensationalism. This fear-infused narrative has intensified over time. The study underscores the potential impact of language and sentiment in sha** public perspectives on crowd accidents, revealing a pressing need for responsible and balanced reporting that moves beyond sensationalism and promotes a nuanced understanding. This will be crucial for increasing public awareness and preparedness against such accidents.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2023; v1 submitted 25 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Social aspects of collision avoidance: A detailed analysis of two-person groups and individual pedestrians
Authors:
Adrien Gregorj,
Zeynep Yücel,
Francesco Zanlungo,
Claudio Feliciani,
Takayuki Kanda
Abstract:
Pedestrian groups are commonly found in crowds but research on their social aspects is comparatively lacking. To fill that void in literature, we study the dynamics of collision avoidance between pedestrian groups (in particular dyads) and individual pedestrians in an ecological environment, focusing in particular on (i) how such avoidance depends on the group's social relation (e.g. colleagues, c…
▽ More
Pedestrian groups are commonly found in crowds but research on their social aspects is comparatively lacking. To fill that void in literature, we study the dynamics of collision avoidance between pedestrian groups (in particular dyads) and individual pedestrians in an ecological environment, focusing in particular on (i) how such avoidance depends on the group's social relation (e.g. colleagues, couples, friends or families) and (ii) its intensity of social interaction (indicated by conversation, gaze exchange, gestures etc). By analyzing relative collision avoidance in the ``center of mass'' frame, we were able to quantify how much groups and individuals avoid each other with respect to the aforementioned properties of the group. A mathematical representation using a potential energy function is proposed to model avoidance and it is shown to provide a fair approximation to the empirical observations. We also studied the probability that the individuals disrupt the group by ``passing through it'' (termed as intrusion). We analyzed the dependence of the parameters of the avoidance model and of the probability of intrusion on groups' social relation and intensity of interaction. We confirmed that the stronger social bonding or interaction intensity is, the more prominent collision avoidance turns out. We also confirmed that the probability of intrusion is a decreasing function of interaction intensity and strength of social bonding. Our results suggest that such variability should be accounted for in models and crowd management in general. Namely, public spaces with strongly bonded groups (e.g. a family-oriented amusement park) may require a different approach compared to public spaces with loosely bonded groups (e.g. a business-oriented trade fair).
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Analysis and modelling of macroscopic and microscopic dynamics of a pedestrian cross-flow
Authors:
Francesco Zanlungo,
Claudio Feliciani,
Zeynep Yücel,
Katsuhiro Nishinari,
Takayuki Kanda
Abstract:
In this work we investigate the behaviour of a human crowd in a cross-flow. We first analyse the results of a set of controlled experiments in which subjects were divided into two groups, in such a way to explore different density settings, and asked to walk through the crossing area. We study the results of the experiment by analysing, along with traditional indicators such as density and velocit…
▽ More
In this work we investigate the behaviour of a human crowd in a cross-flow. We first analyse the results of a set of controlled experiments in which subjects were divided into two groups, in such a way to explore different density settings, and asked to walk through the crossing area. We study the results of the experiment by analysing, along with traditional indicators such as density and velocity, also walking and body orientation, studying how these microscopic observables are influenced by density. Furthermore, we report a preliminary but quantitative analysis on the emergence of self-organising stripes in the crossing area.
We also try to reproduce the empirical results using a hierarchy of models, which differ in the details of the body shape (using a disk-shaped body vs a more realistic elliptical shape) and in how collision avoiding is performed (using only information regarding "centre of mass" distance and velocity, or actually introducing body shape information). We verified that the most detailed model (i.e., using body shape information and an elliptical body) outperforms in a significant way the simplest one (using only centre of mass distance and velocity, and disk-shaped bodies). Furthermore, we observed that if elliptical bodies are introduced without using such information in collision avoidance, the performance of the model is relatively poor. Nevertheless, the difference between the different models is relevant only in describing the "tails" of the observable distributions, suggesting that the more complex models could be of practical use only for describing high density settings. We also verified that "stripe formation" emerges in all models.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Some considerations on crowd Congestion Level
Authors:
Francesco Zanlungo,
Claudio Feliciani,
Zeynep Yucel,
Katsuhiro Nishinari,
Takayuki Kanda
Abstract:
The concept of (crowd) Congestion Level ($CL$) was introduced in Feliciani et al (Transportation Research, 2018) and presented at the PED 2018 conference by C. Feliciani. Following the PED presentation, along with appreciation for the novel contribution, a few interesting questions were raised, concerning the integral/differential nature of the definition of $CL$, and the possibility of defining a…
▽ More
The concept of (crowd) Congestion Level ($CL$) was introduced in Feliciani et al (Transportation Research, 2018) and presented at the PED 2018 conference by C. Feliciani. Following the PED presentation, along with appreciation for the novel contribution, a few interesting questions were raised, concerning the integral/differential nature of the definition of $CL$, and the possibility of defining a related pure number. In these short notes we are going, although with no attempt at rigour or formality, to present some considerations suggesting that the two problems are related, and providing a possible solution. Furthermore, using both theoretical arguments and analysis of simulated data in complex scenarios, we will try to shed further light on the meaning and applications of this concept. Finally, we analyse some results of an experiment performed with human participants in a ``crossing-flows'' scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Experimental study on the evading behavior of individual pedestrians when confronting with an obstacle in a corridor
Authors:
Xiaolu Jia,
Claudio Feliciani,
Daichi Yanagisawa,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
In this paper, controlled experiments have been conducted to make deep analysis on the obstacle evading behavior of individual pedestrians affected by one obstacle. Results of Fourier Transform show that with the increase of obstacle width, the frequency and amplitude of body sway would barely be affected while the lateral deviation of walking direction would largely increase. On the one hand, the…
▽ More
In this paper, controlled experiments have been conducted to make deep analysis on the obstacle evading behavior of individual pedestrians affected by one obstacle. Results of Fourier Transform show that with the increase of obstacle width, the frequency and amplitude of body sway would barely be affected while the lateral deviation of walking direction would largely increase. On the one hand, the relation among the extracted gait features including body sway, stride length, frequency and speed has been illustrated. On the other hand, the walking direction can be featured by three critical evading points where apparent change of walking direction could be observed. Gaussian function has been used to fit the walking direction, thus allowing to estimate the three critical points and examine their variation with the increase of obstacle size. Furthermore, the direct-indirect evading and left-right turning preference as well as the possible psychological motivations behind have been analyzed. It is indicated that direct-evading pedestrians have a higher walking efficiency and right-turning pedestrians have a stronger tendency to behave `direct'. Results of this paper are expected to provide practical evidence for the modeling of pedestrian dynamics affected by obstacles.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Body-rotation behavior of pedestrians for collision avoidance in passing and cross flow
Authors:
Hiroki Yamamoto,
Daichi Yanagisawa,
Claudio Feliciani,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
We observe body-rotation behavior of pedestrians to avoid others when they are moving in congested situations. In such cases, body orientation often differs from walking direction, i.e., pedestrians step sideways.
In this paper, we focused on a deviation between body orientation and walking direction during collision avoidance by body rotation for counter-flows in narrow corridors quantitatively…
▽ More
We observe body-rotation behavior of pedestrians to avoid others when they are moving in congested situations. In such cases, body orientation often differs from walking direction, i.e., pedestrians step sideways.
In this paper, we focused on a deviation between body orientation and walking direction during collision avoidance by body rotation for counter-flows in narrow corridors quantitatively. We conducted simple experiments in which two pedestrians passed each other. We found that pedestrians rotated their bodies when the width of the corridor was smaller than the sum of the widths of the two pedestrians. This behavior was explained by analyzing the geometry of two ellipses circumscribing each other in a narrow corridor. Moreover, we developed a preliminary model and succeeded to simulate the deviation between body orientation and walking direction during passing observed in the experiments.
Furthermore, we performed a cross-flow experiment, which is much more complex and realistic than the passing experiments and confirmed that body-rotation behavior is also an indispensable factor for complex and realistic scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2019; v1 submitted 18 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Social Groups and Pedestrian Crowds: Experiment on Dyads in a Counter Flow Scenario
Authors:
Andrea Gorrini,
Luca Crociani,
Claudio Feliciani,
Pengfei Zhao,
Katsuhiro Nishinari,
Stefania Bandini
Abstract:
The calibration and validation of pedestrian simulations require the acquisition of empirical evidences of human behaviour. The current work presents the results of an experiment focused on the potentially combined effect of counter flow and grou** on pedestrian dynamics. In particular, we focused on: (i) four different configurations of flow ratio (the rate between the minor flow and the total…
▽ More
The calibration and validation of pedestrian simulations require the acquisition of empirical evidences of human behaviour. The current work presents the results of an experiment focused on the potentially combined effect of counter flow and grou** on pedestrian dynamics. In particular, we focused on: (i) four different configurations of flow ratio (the rate between the minor flow and the total flow in bidirectional scenarios); (ii) dyads, as the most frequently observed and basic social groups of crowds. Results showed that the increase of flow ratio negatively impacted the speed of pedestrians. Dyads walked significantly slower than singletons, due to the difficulty in movement coordination among group members (proxemics) in case of counter flow. The collected results represent an useful contribution towards the validation of pedestrian simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Pedestrians rotation measurement in bidirectional streams
Authors:
Claudio Feliciani,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
This study presents an experimental measurement of pedestrians' body rotation in bidirectional streams. A mock-up corridor monitored using a camera placed on azimuthal position is used to study pedestrians' behavior in unidirectional and bidirectional flows. Additionally, a commercial tablet is fixed on the chest of sample pedestrians to examine their body rotation (or yawing) which cannot be obta…
▽ More
This study presents an experimental measurement of pedestrians' body rotation in bidirectional streams. A mock-up corridor monitored using a camera placed on azimuthal position is used to study pedestrians' behavior in unidirectional and bidirectional flows. Additionally, a commercial tablet is fixed on the chest of sample pedestrians to examine their body rotation (or yawing) which cannot be obtained using position tracking alone. Angular velocity is recorded and simultaneously stored in a central location using a wireless network, thus allowing the analysis of body movements with a high sampling rate and a limited delay. To investigate the influence of major/minor flow proportion (flow-ratio) on bidirectional streams two different situations were tested: the balanced configuration (with equal flows in both directions) and an unbalanced configuration (with different major and minor flow). Results clearly show that unidirectional flow is more stable compared to the bidirectional case, requiring less time to cross the experimental section and showing a very small amount of rotation during the whole experiment. Both bidirectional configurations showed high values of body rotation, in particular during lane formation and dissolution. Finally, rotation directly measured on pedestrians' body was compared with the one obtained indirectly by analyzing pedestrians' trajectories. The comparison shows that, at least from a qualitative point of view, both methods are in agreement, thus suggesting that even properties which can only be measured by motion sensing could be obtained indirectly through the analysis of trajectories. Concluding, it has been suggested that while lanes help smooth out bidirectional flows, larger instabilities are observed compared to the unidirectional case. Lane separation and/or appropriate guidance are therefore required.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2018; v1 submitted 23 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
