-
The Sun's Alfven Surface: Recent Insights and Prospects for the Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere (PUNCH)
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
Rohit Chhiber,
Chris R. Gilly,
Iver H. Cairns,
Robin C. Colaninno,
David J. McComas,
Nour E. Raouafi,
Arcadi V. Usmanov,
Sarah E. Gibson,
Craig E. DeForest
Abstract:
The solar wind is the extension of the Sun's hot and ionized corona, and it exists in a state of continuous expansion into interplanetary space. The radial distance at which the wind's outflow speed exceeds the phase speed of Alfvenic and fast-mode magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves is called the Alfven radius. In one-dimensional models, this is a singular point beyond which most fluctuations in the…
▽ More
The solar wind is the extension of the Sun's hot and ionized corona, and it exists in a state of continuous expansion into interplanetary space. The radial distance at which the wind's outflow speed exceeds the phase speed of Alfvenic and fast-mode magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves is called the Alfven radius. In one-dimensional models, this is a singular point beyond which most fluctuations in the plasma and magnetic field cannot propagate back down to the Sun. In the multi-dimensional solar wind, this point can occur at different distances along an irregularly shaped "Alfven surface." In this article, we review the properties of this surface and discuss its importance in models of solar-wind acceleration, angular-momentum transport, MHD waves and turbulence, and the geometry of magnetically closed coronal loops. We also review the results of simulations and data analysis techniques that aim to determine the location of the Alfven surface. Combined with recent perihelia of Parker Solar Probe, these studies seem to indicate that the Alfven surface spends most of its time at heliocentric distances between about 10 and 20 solar radii. It is becoming apparent that this region of the heliosphere is sufficiently turbulent that there often exist multiple (stochastic and time-dependent) crossings of the Alfven surface along any radial ray. Thus, in many contexts, it is more useful to make use of the concept of a topologically complex "Alfven zone" rather than one closed surface. This article also reviews how the Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere (PUNCH) mission will measure the properties of the Alfven surface and provide key constraints on theories of solar-wind acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Estimates of Proton and Electron Heating Rates Extended to the Near-Sun Environment
Authors:
R. Bandyopadhyay,
C. M. Meyer,
W. H. Matthaeus,
D. J. McComas,
S. R. Cranmer,
J. S. Halekas,
J. Huang,
D. E. Larson,
R. Livi,
A. Rahmati,
P. L. Whittlesey,
M. L. Stevens,
J. C. Kasper,
S. D. Bale
Abstract:
A central problem of space plasma physics is how protons and electrons are heated in a turbulent, magnetized plasma. The differential heating of charged species due to dissipation of turbulent fluctuations plays a key role in solar wind evolution. Measurements from previous heliophysics missions have provided estimates of proton and electron heating rates beyond 0.27 au. Using Parker Solar Probe (…
▽ More
A central problem of space plasma physics is how protons and electrons are heated in a turbulent, magnetized plasma. The differential heating of charged species due to dissipation of turbulent fluctuations plays a key role in solar wind evolution. Measurements from previous heliophysics missions have provided estimates of proton and electron heating rates beyond 0.27 au. Using Parker Solar Probe (PSP) data accumulated during the first ten encounters, we extend the evaluation of the individual rates of heat deposition for protons and electrons in to a distance of 0.063 au (13.5 solar radii), in the newly formed solar wind. The PSP data in the near-Sun environment show different behavior of the electron heat conduction flux from what was predicted from previous fits to Helios and Ulysses data. Consequently, the empirically derived proton and electron heating rates exhibit significantly different behavior than previous reports, with the proton heating becoming increasingly dominant over electron heating at decreasing heliocentric distances. We find that the protons receive about 80% of the total plasma heating at ~ 13 solar radii, slightly higher than the near-Earth values. This empirically derived heating partition between protons and electrons will help to constrain theoretical models of solar wind heating.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Magnetohydrodynamic Mode Conversion in the Solar Corona: Insights from Fresnel-like Models of Waves at Sharp Interfaces
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
Momchil E. Molnar
Abstract:
The solar atmosphere is known to contain many different types of wavelike oscillation. Waves and other fluctuations (e.g., turbulent eddies) are believed to be responsible for at least some of the energy transport and dissipation that heats the corona and accelerates the solar wind. Thus, it is important to understand the behavior of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves as they propagate and evolve in…
▽ More
The solar atmosphere is known to contain many different types of wavelike oscillation. Waves and other fluctuations (e.g., turbulent eddies) are believed to be responsible for at least some of the energy transport and dissipation that heats the corona and accelerates the solar wind. Thus, it is important to understand the behavior of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves as they propagate and evolve in different regions of the Sun's atmosphere. In this paper, we investigate how MHD waves can affect the overall plasma state when they reflect and refract at sharp, planar interfaces in density. First, we correct an error in a foundational paper (Stein 1971) that affects the calculation of wave energy-flux conservation. Second, we apply this model to reflection-driven MHD turbulence in the solar wind, where the presence of density fluctuations can enhance the generation of inward-propagating Alfven waves. This model reproduces the time-averaged Elsasser imbalance fraction (i.e., ratio of inward to outward Alfvenic power) from several published numerical simulations. Lastly, we model how the complex magnetic field threading the transition region between the chromosphere and corona helps convert a fraction of upward-propagating Alfven waves into fast-mode and slow-mode MHD waves. These magnetosonic waves dissipate in a narrow region around the transition region and produce a sharp peak in the heating rate. This newly found source of heating sometimes exceeds the expected heating rate from Alfvenic turbulence by an order of magnitude. It may explain why some earlier models seemed to require an additional ad-hoc heat source at this location.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Electron Heat Flux in the Solar Wind: Generalized Approaches to Fluid Transport with a Variety of Skewed Velocity Distributions
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
Avery J. Schiff
Abstract:
In the solar corona and solar wind, electron heat conduction is an important process that transports energy over large distances and helps determine the spatial variation of temperature. High-density regions undergoing rapid particle-particle collisions exhibit a heat flux described well by classical Spitzer-Harm theory. However, much of the heliosphere is closer to a more collisionless state, and…
▽ More
In the solar corona and solar wind, electron heat conduction is an important process that transports energy over large distances and helps determine the spatial variation of temperature. High-density regions undergoing rapid particle-particle collisions exhibit a heat flux described well by classical Spitzer-Harm theory. However, much of the heliosphere is closer to a more collisionless state, and there is no standard description of heat conduction for fluid-based (e.g., magnetohydrodynamic) models that applies generally. Some proposed models rely on electron velocity distributions that exhibit negative values of the phase-space density. In this paper, we explore how positive-definite velocity distributions can be used in fluid-based conservation equations for the electron heat flux along magnetic-field lines in the corona and solar wind. We study both analytic forms of skewed distributions (e.g., skew-normal distributions, two-sided bi-Maxwellians, and constant-collision-time electrostatic solutions) and empirical fits to measurements of core, halo, and strahl electrons in interplanetary space. We also present example solutions to a generalized conservation equation for the heat flux in the solar wind, with some limiting cases found to resemble known free-streaming approximations. The resulting values of the electron heat flux vary as a function of radial distance and Knudsen number in ways that resemble observed data. We note that this model does not include the effects of kinetic instabilities (which may impose saturation limits when active), so for now its regime of applicability is limited to collisionless heat-flux evolution away from the known instability boundaries in parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Turbulent generation of magnetic switchbacks in the Alfvénic solar wind
Authors:
Munehito Shoda,
Benjamin D. G. Chandran,
Steven R. Cranmer
Abstract:
One of the most important early results from the Parker Solar Probe (PSP) is the ubiquitous presence of magnetic switchbacks, whose origin is under debate. Using a three-dimensional direct numerical simulation of the equations of compressible magnetohydrodynamics from the corona to 40 solar radii, we investigate whether magnetic switchbacks emerge from granulation-driven Alfvén waves and turbulenc…
▽ More
One of the most important early results from the Parker Solar Probe (PSP) is the ubiquitous presence of magnetic switchbacks, whose origin is under debate. Using a three-dimensional direct numerical simulation of the equations of compressible magnetohydrodynamics from the corona to 40 solar radii, we investigate whether magnetic switchbacks emerge from granulation-driven Alfvén waves and turbulence in the solar wind. The simulated solar wind is an Alfvénic slow-solar-wind stream with a radial profile consistent with various observations, including observations from PSP. As a natural consequence of Alfvén-wave turbulence, the simulation reproduced magnetic switchbacks with many of the same properties as observed switchbacks, including Alfvénic v-b correlation, spherical polarization (low magnetic compressibility), and a volume filling fraction that increases with radial distance. The analysis of propagation speed and scale length shows that the magnetic switchbacks are large-amplitude (nonlinear) Alfvén waves with discontinuities in the magnetic field direction. We directly compare our simulation with observations using a virtual flyby of PSP in our simulation domain. We conclude that at least some of the switchbacks observed by PSP are a natural consequence of the growth in amplitude of spherically polarized Alfvén waves as they propagate away from the Sun.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2021; v1 submitted 23 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Proton, Electron, and Ion Heating in the Fast Solar Wind from Nonlinear Coupling Between Alfvenic and Fast-Mode Turbulence
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
Adriaan A. van Ballegooijen
Abstract:
In the parts of the solar corona and solar wind that experience the fewest Coulomb collisions, the component proton, electron, and heavy ion populations are not in thermal equilibrium with one another. Observed differences in temperatures, outflow speeds, and velocity distribution anisotropies are useful constraints on proposed explanations for how the plasma is heated and accelerated. This paper…
▽ More
In the parts of the solar corona and solar wind that experience the fewest Coulomb collisions, the component proton, electron, and heavy ion populations are not in thermal equilibrium with one another. Observed differences in temperatures, outflow speeds, and velocity distribution anisotropies are useful constraints on proposed explanations for how the plasma is heated and accelerated. This paper presents new predictions of the rates of collisionless heating for each particle species, in which the energy input is assumed to come from magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence. We first created an empirical description of the radial evolution of Alfven, fast-mode, and slow-mode MHD waves. This model provides the total wave power in each mode as a function of distance along an expanding flux tube in the high-speed solar wind. Next we solved a set of cascade advection-diffusion equations that give the time-steady wavenumber spectra at each distance. An approximate term for nonlinear coupling between the Alfven and fast-mode fluctuations is included. For reasonable choices of the parameters, our model contains enough energy transfer from the fast mode to the Alfven mode to excite the high-frequency ion cyclotron resonance. This resonance is efficient at heating protons and other ions in the direction perpendicular to the background magnetic field, and our model predicts heating rates for these species that agree well with both spectroscopic and in situ measurements. Nonetheless, the high-frequency waves comprise only a small part of the total Alfvenic fluctuation spectrum, which remains highly two-dimensional as is observed in interplanetary space.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Electron and proton heating by solar wind turbulence
Authors:
B. Breech,
W. H. Matthaeus,
S. R. Cranmer,
J. C. Kasper,
S. Oughton
Abstract:
Previous formulations of heating and transport associated with strong magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence are generalized to incorporate separate internal energy equations for electrons and protons. Electron heat conduction is included. Energy is supplied by turbulent heating that affects both electrons and protons, and is exchanged between them via collisions. Comparison to available Ulysses d…
▽ More
Previous formulations of heating and transport associated with strong magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence are generalized to incorporate separate internal energy equations for electrons and protons. Electron heat conduction is included. Energy is supplied by turbulent heating that affects both electrons and protons, and is exchanged between them via collisions. Comparison to available Ulysses data shows that a reasonable accounting for the data is provided when (i) the energy exchange timescale is very long and (ii) the deposition of heat due to turbulence is divided, with 60% going to proton heating and 40% into electron heating. Heat conduction, determined here by an empirical fit, plays a major role in describing the electron data.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Empirical Constraints on Proton and Electron Heating in the Fast Solar Wind
Authors:
Steven R. Cranmer,
William H. Matthaeus,
Benjamin A. Breech,
Justin C. Kasper
Abstract:
We analyze measured proton and electron temperatures in the high-speed solar wind in order to calculate the separate rates of heat deposition for protons and electrons. When comparing with other regions of the heliosphere, the fast solar wind has the lowest density and the least frequent Coulomb collisions. This makes the fast wind an optimal testing ground for studies of collisionless kinetic p…
▽ More
We analyze measured proton and electron temperatures in the high-speed solar wind in order to calculate the separate rates of heat deposition for protons and electrons. When comparing with other regions of the heliosphere, the fast solar wind has the lowest density and the least frequent Coulomb collisions. This makes the fast wind an optimal testing ground for studies of collisionless kinetic processes associated with the dissipation of plasma turbulence. Data from the Helios and Ulysses plasma instruments were collected to determine mean radial trends in the temperatures and the electron heat conduction flux between 0.29 and 5.4 AU. The derived heating rates apply specifically for these mean plasma properties and not for the full range of measured values around the mean. We found that the protons receive about 60% of the total plasma heating in the inner heliosphere, and that this fraction increases to approximately 80% by the orbit of Jupiter. A major factor affecting the uncertainty in this fraction is the uncertainty in the measured radial gradient of the electron heat conduction flux. The empirically derived partitioning of heat between protons and electrons is in rough agreement with theoretical predictions from a model of linear Vlasov wave dam**. For a modeled power spectrum consisting only of Alfvenic fluctuations, the best agreement was found for a distribution of wavenumber vectors that evolves toward isotropy as distance increases.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
