-
Business models to assure availability of advanced superconductors for the accelerator sector and promote stewardship of superconducting magnet technology for the US economy
Authors:
Lance Cooley,
Kathleen Amm,
Whitney Hischier,
Steven Rotkoff,
David Larbalestier
Abstract:
Stakeholders representing concerns of national and global leadership, industries that use superconducting magnets in products, manufacturers of superconducting wires and tapes that supply to industries, and innovation generators from small businesses and universities came together to address stewardship of superconducting magnet technology and assurance of supply of advanced superconductors to the…
▽ More
Stakeholders representing concerns of national and global leadership, industries that use superconducting magnets in products, manufacturers of superconducting wires and tapes that supply to industries, and innovation generators from small businesses and universities came together to address stewardship of superconducting magnet technology and assurance of supply of advanced superconductors to the accelerator sector. This report outlines potential public-private partnerships that develop and enhance domestic capabilities to meet the needs of science facilities in the accelerator systems sector and in the broader commercial ecosystem.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Conceptual design of 20 T hybrid accelerator dipole magnets
Authors:
P. Ferracin,
G. Ambrosio,
M. Anerella,
D. Arbelaez,
L. Brouwer,
E. Barzi,
L. Cooley,
J. Cozzolino,
L. Garcia Fajardo,
R. Gupta,
M. Juchno,
V. V. Kashikhin,
F. Kurian,
V. Marinozzi,
I. Novitski,
E. Rochepault,
J. Stern,
G. Vallone,
B. Yahia,
A. V. Zlobin
Abstract:
Hybrid magnets are currently under consideration as an economically viable option towards 20 T dipole magnets for next generation of particle accelerators. In these magnets, High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) materials are used in the high field part of the coil with so-called insert coils, and Low Temperature Superconductors (LTS) like Nb3Sn and Nb-Ti superconductors are used in the lower fie…
▽ More
Hybrid magnets are currently under consideration as an economically viable option towards 20 T dipole magnets for next generation of particle accelerators. In these magnets, High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) materials are used in the high field part of the coil with so-called insert coils, and Low Temperature Superconductors (LTS) like Nb3Sn and Nb-Ti superconductors are used in the lower field region with so-called outsert coils. The attractiveness of the hybrid option lays on the fact that, on the one hand, the 20 T field level is beyond the Nb3Sn practical limits of 15-16 T for accelerator magnets and can be achieved only via HTS materials; on the other hand, the high cost of HTS superconductors compared to LTS superconductors makes it advantageous exploring a hybrid approach, where the HTS portion of the coil is minimized. We present in this paper an overview of different design options aimed at generating 20 T field in a 50 mm clear aperture. The coil layouts investigated include the Cos-theta design (CT), with its variations to reduce the conductor peak stress, namely the Canted Cos-theta design (CCT) and the Stress Management Cos-theta design (SMCT), and, in addition, the Block-type design (BL) including a form of stress management and the Common-Coil design (CC). Results from a magnetic and mechanical analysis are discussed, with particular focus on the comparison between the different options regarding quantity of superconducting material, field quality, conductor peak stress, and quench protection.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Challenges and Lessons Learned from fabrication, testing and analysis of eight MQXFA Low Beta Quadrupole magnets for HL-LHC
Authors:
G. Ambrosio,
K. Amm,
M. Anerella,
G. Apollinari,
G. Arnau Izquierdo,
M. Baldini,
A. Ballarino,
C. Barth,
A. Ben Yahia,
J. Blowers,
P. Borges De Sousa,
R. Bossert,
B. Bulat,
R. Carcagno,
D. W. Cheng,
G. Chlachidze,
L. Cooley,
M. Crouvizier,
A. Devred,
J. DiMarco,
S. Feher,
P. Ferracin,
J. Ferradas Troitino,
L. Garcia Fajardo,
S. Gourlay
, et al. (33 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
By the end of October 2022, the US HL-LHC Accelerator Upgrade Project (AUP) had completed fabrication of ten MQXFA magnets and tested eight of them. The MQXFA magnets are the low beta quadrupole magnets to be used in the Q1 and Q3 Inner Triplet elements of the High Luminosity LHC. This AUP effort is shared by BNL, Fermilab, and LBNL, with strand verification tests at NHMFL. An important step of th…
▽ More
By the end of October 2022, the US HL-LHC Accelerator Upgrade Project (AUP) had completed fabrication of ten MQXFA magnets and tested eight of them. The MQXFA magnets are the low beta quadrupole magnets to be used in the Q1 and Q3 Inner Triplet elements of the High Luminosity LHC. This AUP effort is shared by BNL, Fermilab, and LBNL, with strand verification tests at NHMFL. An important step of the AUP QA plan is the testing of MQXFA magnets in a vertical cryostat at BNL. The acceptance criteria that could be tested at BNL were all met by the first four production magnets (MQXFA03-MQXFA06). Subsequently, two magnets (MQXFA07 and MQXFA08) did not meet some criteria and were disassembled. Lessons learned during the disassembly of MQXFA07 caused a revision to the assembly specifications that were used for MQXFA10 and subsequent magnets. In this paper, we present a summary of: 1) the fabrication and test data of all the MQXFA magnets; 2) the analysis of MQXFA07/A08 test results with characterization of the limiting mechanism; 3) the outcome of the investigation, including the lessons learned during MQXFA07 disassembly; and 4) the finite element analysis correlating observations with test performance.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Towards 20 T Hybrid Accelerator Dipole Magnets
Authors:
P. Ferracin,
G. Ambrosio,
D. Arbelaez,
L. Brouwer,
E. Barzi,
L. Cooley,
L. Garcia Fajardo,
R. Gupta,
M. Juchno,
V. Kashikhin,
V. Marinozzi,
I. Novitski,
E. Rochepault,
J. Stern,
A. Zlobin,
N. Zucchi
Abstract:
The most effective way to achieve very high collision energies in a circular particle accelerator is to maximize the field strength of the main bending dipoles. In dipole magnets using Nb-Ti superconductor the practical field limit is considered to be 8-9 T. When Nb3Sn superconductor material is utilized, a field level of 15-16 T can be achieved. To further push the magnetic field beyond the Nb3Sn…
▽ More
The most effective way to achieve very high collision energies in a circular particle accelerator is to maximize the field strength of the main bending dipoles. In dipole magnets using Nb-Ti superconductor the practical field limit is considered to be 8-9 T. When Nb3Sn superconductor material is utilized, a field level of 15-16 T can be achieved. To further push the magnetic field beyond the Nb3Sn limits, High Temperature Superconductors (HTS) need to be considered in the magnet design. The most promising HTS materials for particle accelerator magnets are Bi2212 and REBCO. However, their outstanding performance comes with a significantly higher cost. Therefore, an economically viable option towards 20 T dipole magnets could consist in an hybrid solution, where both HTS and Nb3Sn materials are used. We discuss in this paper preliminary conceptual designs of various 20 T hybrid magnet concepts. After the definition of the overall design criteria, the coil dimensions and parameters are investigated with finite element models based on simple sector coils. Preliminary 2D cross-section computation results are then presented and three main layouts compared: cos-theta, block, and common-coil. Both traditional designs and more advanced stress-management options are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Challenges and opportunities to assure future manufacturing of magnet conductors for the accelerator sector
Authors:
Lance Cooley,
David Larbalestier,
Kathleen Amm
Abstract:
We take a comprehensive look at conductors used in superconducting magnets for the accelerator sector and explore the ramifications of the present marketplace for supply of conductor to future accelerator facilities. While there are thousands of superconductors, many of which have promising properties for applications, we outline the journey a promising material must take to become a magnet conduc…
▽ More
We take a comprehensive look at conductors used in superconducting magnets for the accelerator sector and explore the ramifications of the present marketplace for supply of conductor to future accelerator facilities. While there are thousands of superconductors, many of which have promising properties for applications, we outline the journey a promising material must take to become a magnet conductor that is manufactured at the scale needed for an accelerator facility. Among the few materials that actually reach this scale, Nb$_{3}$Sn is arguably the workhorse conductor for the next generation of accelerators. Yet, a marketplace pull equivalent to the medical imaging magnet industry, which consumes close to 1000 tons of commodity-scale Nb-Ti conductor per year, has not emerged. This aspect greatly complicates the steps that must be taken to assure readiness of manufacturing for the next accelerator facility. Meanwhile, high-temperature superconductors (HTS), which are capable of extremely high fields at low temperature, are advancing rapidly as magnet conductors, and the long horizons of large physics projects could provide time for them to emerge and displace Nb-based materials. We close by examining in more detail the ecosystem that connects accelerator magnet conductors with broader industry applications, in particular areas that are presently in rapid development such as fusion and wind turbines and which would potentially require hundreds of tons of conductor.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Key directions for research and development of superconducting radio frequency cavities
Authors:
S. Belomestnykh,
S. Posen,
D. Bafia,
S. Balachandran,
M. Bertucci,
A. Burrill,
A. Cano,
M. Checchin,
G. Ciovati,
L. D. Cooley,
G. Dalla Lana Semione,
J. Delayen,
G. Eremeev,
F. Furuta,
F. Gerigk,
B. Giaccone,
D. Gonnella,
A. Grassellino,
A. Gurevich,
W. Hillert,
M. Iavarone,
J. Knobloch,
T. Kubo,
W. K. Kwok,
R. Laxdal
, et al. (31 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Radio frequency superconductivity is a cornerstone technology for many future HEP particle accelerators and experiments from colliders to proton drivers for neutrino facilities to searches for dark matter. While the performance of superconducting RF (SRF) cavities has improved significantly over the last decades, and the SRF technology has enabled new applications, the proposed HEP facilities and…
▽ More
Radio frequency superconductivity is a cornerstone technology for many future HEP particle accelerators and experiments from colliders to proton drivers for neutrino facilities to searches for dark matter. While the performance of superconducting RF (SRF) cavities has improved significantly over the last decades, and the SRF technology has enabled new applications, the proposed HEP facilities and experiments pose new challenges. To address these challenges, the field continues to generate new ideas and there seems to be a vast room for improvements. In this paper we discuss the key research directions that are aligned with and address the future HEP needs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2022; v1 submitted 3 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
A Strategic Approach to Advance Magnet Technology for Next Generation Colliders
Authors:
G. Ambrosio,
K. Amm,
M. Anerella,
G. Apollinari,
D. Arbelaez,
B. Auchmann,
S. Balachandran,
M. Baldini,
A. Ballarino,
S. Barua,
E. Barzi,
A. Baskys,
C. Bird,
J. Boerme,
E. Bosque,
L. Brouwer,
S. Caspi,
N. Cheggour,
G. Chlachidze,
L. Cooley,
D. Davis,
D. Dietderich,
J. DiMarco,
L. English,
L. Garcia Fajardo
, et al. (52 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Colliders are built on a foundation of superconducting magnet technology that provides strong dipole magnets to maintain the beam orbit and strong focusing magnets to enable the extraordinary luminosity required to probe physics at the energy frontier. The dipole magnet strength plays a critical role in dictating the energy reach of a collider, and the superconducting magnets are arguably the domi…
▽ More
Colliders are built on a foundation of superconducting magnet technology that provides strong dipole magnets to maintain the beam orbit and strong focusing magnets to enable the extraordinary luminosity required to probe physics at the energy frontier. The dipole magnet strength plays a critical role in dictating the energy reach of a collider, and the superconducting magnets are arguably the dominant cost driver for future collider facilities. As the community considers opportunities to explore new energy frontiers, the importance of advanced magnet technology - both in terms of magnet performance and in the magnet technology's potential for cost reduction - is evident, as the technology status is essential for informed decisions on targets for physics reach and facility feasibility.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
White Paper on Leading-Edge technology And Feasibility-directed (LEAF) Program aimed at readiness demonstration for Energy Frontier Circular Colliders by the next decade
Authors:
G. Ambrosio,
G. Apollinari,
M. Baldini,
R. Carcagno,
C. Boffo,
B. Claypool,
S. Feher,
S. Hays,
D. Hoang,
V. Kashikhin,
V. V. Kashikhin,
S. Krave,
M. Kufer,
J. Lee,
V. Lombardo,
V. Marinozzi,
F. Nobrega,
X. Peng,
H. Piekarz,
V. Shiltsev,
S. Stoynev,
T. Strauss,
N. Tran,
G. Velev,
X. Xu
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In this White Paper for the Snowmass 2021 Process, we propose the establishment of a magnet Leading-Edge technology And Feasibility-directed Program (LEAF Program) to achieve readiness for a future collider decision on the timescale of the next decade.
The LEAF Program would rely on, and be synergetic with, generic R&D efforts presently covered - in the US - by the Magnet Development Program (MD…
▽ More
In this White Paper for the Snowmass 2021 Process, we propose the establishment of a magnet Leading-Edge technology And Feasibility-directed Program (LEAF Program) to achieve readiness for a future collider decision on the timescale of the next decade.
The LEAF Program would rely on, and be synergetic with, generic R&D efforts presently covered - in the US - by the Magnet Development Program (MDP), the Conductor Procurement and R&D (CPRD) Program and other activities in the Office of HEP supported by Early Career Awards (ECA) or Lab Directed R&D (LDRD) funds. Where possible, ties to synergetic efforts in other Offices of DOE or NSF are highlighted and suggested as wider Collaborative efforts on the National scale. International efforts are also mentioned as potential partners in the LEAF Program.
We envision the LEAF Program to concentrate on demonstrating the feasibility of magnets for muon colliders as well as next generation high energy hadron colliders, pursuing, where necessary and warranted by the nature of the application, the transition from R&D models to long models/prototypes. The LEAF Program will naturally drive accelerator-quality and experiment-interface design considerations. LEAF will also concentrate, where necessary, on cost reduction and/or industrialization steps.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
MQXFA Final Design Report
Authors:
Giorgio Ambrosio,
Kathleen Amm,
Mike Anerella,
Giorgio Apollinari,
Maria Baldini,
Anis Ben Yahia,
James Blowers,
Ruben Carcagno,
Daniel Cheng,
Guram Chlachidze,
Lance Cooley,
Sandor Feher,
Paolo Ferracin,
Henry Hocker,
Susana Izquierdo Bermudez,
Piyush Joshi,
Vito Lombardo,
Vittorio Marinozzi,
Joseph Muratore,
Michael Naus,
Fred Nobrega,
Heng Pan,
Marcellus Parker,
Ian Pong,
Soren Prestemon
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The MQXFA Quadrupole magnets will be installed in High Luminosity LHC to form the Q1 and Q3 inner triplet optical elements in front of the interaction points 1 (ATLAS) and 5 (CMS). A pair of MQXFA units is assembled in a stainless steel helium vessel, including the end domes, to make the Q1 Cold Mass or the Q3 Cold Mass. The US HL LHC Accelerator Upgrade Project* is responsible for the design, man…
▽ More
The MQXFA Quadrupole magnets will be installed in High Luminosity LHC to form the Q1 and Q3 inner triplet optical elements in front of the interaction points 1 (ATLAS) and 5 (CMS). A pair of MQXFA units is assembled in a stainless steel helium vessel, including the end domes, to make the Q1 Cold Mass or the Q3 Cold Mass. The US HL LHC Accelerator Upgrade Project* is responsible for the design, manufacturing and test of the Q1/Q3 Cold Masses and the complete MQXFA magnets. CERN provides the cryostat components and is responsible for integration and installation in HL LHC. The MQXFA quadrupoles have 150 mm aperture, 4.2 m magnetic length, nominal gradient of 132.2 T/m, and coil peak field of 11.3 T. They use Nb_3Sn conductor and a support structure made of segmented aluminum shells pre-loaded by using bladders and keys. This report presents the final design of the MQXFA quadrupole magnets.
*Supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The 2020 Updated Roadmaps for the US Magnet Development Program
Authors:
Soren Prestemon,
Kathleen Amm,
Lance Cooley,
Steve Gourlay,
David Larbalestier,
George Velev,
Alexander Zlobin
Abstract:
The US Magnet Development Program brings together teams from the leading US accelerator magnet research programs to develop the next generation of magnet technology for future collider applications. Sponsored by the DOE Office of High Energy Physics, the program strives to maintain and strengthen US Leadership in the field, while nurturing cross-cutting activities from other programs to further st…
▽ More
The US Magnet Development Program brings together teams from the leading US accelerator magnet research programs to develop the next generation of magnet technology for future collider applications. Sponsored by the DOE Office of High Energy Physics, the program strives to maintain and strengthen US Leadership in the field, while nurturing cross-cutting activities from other programs to further strengthen the research and its impact to the DOE Office of Science. The US MDP was initiated in 2016, and there has been significant progress on the original program roadmaps and major advancements in magnet science. These advances, together with the addition of Brookhaven National Laboratory to the MDP in 2019 and the onset of the next Snowmass community planning effort for High Energy Physics in early 2020, motivate a review and renewal of the program roadmaps. The updated roadmaps presented here are the result of significant discussion and planning with the MDP research staff, along with guidance from our Technical Advisory Committee, outreach to colleagues from the International Community, and feedback from DOE-OHEP.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Fermilab experience of post-annealing losses in SRF niobium cavities due to furnace contamination and the ways to its mitigation: a pathway to processing simplification and quality factor improvement
Authors:
A. Grassellino,
A. Romanenko,
A. Crawford,
O. Melnychuk,
A. Rowe,
M. Wong,
C. Cooper,
D. Sergatskov,
D. Bice,
Y. Trenikhina,
L. D. Cooley,
C. Ginsburg,
R. D. Kephart
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of high temperature treatments followed by only high-pressure water rinse (HPR) of superconducting radio frequency (SRF) niobium cavities. The objective is to provide a cost effective alternative to the typical cavity processing sequence, by eliminating the material removal step post furnace treatment while preserving or improving the RF performance. The studies have been…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of high temperature treatments followed by only high-pressure water rinse (HPR) of superconducting radio frequency (SRF) niobium cavities. The objective is to provide a cost effective alternative to the typical cavity processing sequence, by eliminating the material removal step post furnace treatment while preserving or improving the RF performance. The studies have been conducted in the temperature range 800-1000C for different conditions of the starting substrate: large grain and fine grain, electro-polished (EP) and centrifugal barrel polished (CBP) to mirror finish. An interesting effect of the grain size on the performances is found. Cavity results and samples characterization show that furnace contaminants cause poor cavity performance, and a practical solution is found to prevent surface contamination. Extraordinary values of residual resistances ~ 1 nOhm and below are then consistently achieved for the contamination-free cavities. These results lead to a more cost-effective processing and improved RF performance, and, in conjunction with CBP, open a potential pathway to acid-free processing.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2013; v1 submitted 9 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Proximity breakdown of hydrides in superconducting niobium cavities
Authors:
A. Romanenko,
F. Barkov,
L. D. Cooley,
A. Grassellino
Abstract:
Many modern and proposed future particle accelerators rely on superconducting radio frequency cavities made of bulk niobium as primary particle accelerating structures. Such cavities suffer from the anomalous field dependence of their quality factors Q0. High field degradation - so-called high field Q-slope - is yet unexplained even though an empirical cure is known. Here we propose a mechanism ba…
▽ More
Many modern and proposed future particle accelerators rely on superconducting radio frequency cavities made of bulk niobium as primary particle accelerating structures. Such cavities suffer from the anomalous field dependence of their quality factors Q0. High field degradation - so-called high field Q-slope - is yet unexplained even though an empirical cure is known. Here we propose a mechanism based on the presence of proximity-coupled niobium hydrides, which can explain this effect. Furthermore, the same mechanism can be present in any surface-sensitive experiments or superconducting devices involving niobium.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2013; v1 submitted 13 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
