-
A One-Dimensional Tearing Mode Equation for Pedestal Stability Studies in Tokamaks
Authors:
J. W. Connor,
R. J. Hastie,
C. Marchetto,
C. M. Roach
Abstract:
Starting from expressions in Connor et al. (1988) [1], we derive a one-dimensional tearing equation similar to the approximate equation obtained by Hegna and Callen (1984) [2] and by Nishimura et al (1998) [3], but for more realistic toroidal equilibria. The intention is to use this approximation to explore the role of steep profiles, bootstrap currents and strong sha** in the vicinity of a sepa…
▽ More
Starting from expressions in Connor et al. (1988) [1], we derive a one-dimensional tearing equation similar to the approximate equation obtained by Hegna and Callen (1984) [2] and by Nishimura et al (1998) [3], but for more realistic toroidal equilibria. The intention is to use this approximation to explore the role of steep profiles, bootstrap currents and strong sha** in the vicinity of a separatrix, on the stability of tearing modes which are resonant in the H-mode pedestal region of finite aspect ratio, shaped cross-section tokamaks, e.g. JET. We discuss how this one-dimensional model for tearing modes, which assumes a single poloidal harmonic for the perturbed poloidal flux, compares with a model that includes poloidal coupling by Fitzpatrick et al (1993) [4].
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2018; v1 submitted 10 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Collisionless microinstabilities in stellarators. IV. The ion-driven trapped-electron mode
Authors:
G. G. Plunk,
J. W. Connor,
P. Helander
Abstract:
Optimised stellarators and other magnetic-confinement devices having the property that the average magnetic curvature is favourable for all particle orbits are called maximum-$J$ devices, and have recently been shown to be immune to trapped-particle instabilities driven by the density gradient. Gyrokinetic simulations reveal, however, that another instability can arise, which is also associated wi…
▽ More
Optimised stellarators and other magnetic-confinement devices having the property that the average magnetic curvature is favourable for all particle orbits are called maximum-$J$ devices, and have recently been shown to be immune to trapped-particle instabilities driven by the density gradient. Gyrokinetic simulations reveal, however, that another instability can arise, which is also associated with particle trap** but causes less transport than typical trapped-electron modes. The nature of this instability is clarified here. It is shown to be similar to the "ubiquitous mode" in tokamaks, and is driven by ion free energy but requires trapped electrons to exist.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Gyrokinetic stability theory of electron-positron plasmas
Authors:
Per Helander,
J. W. Connor
Abstract:
The linear gyrokinetic stability properties of magnetically confined electron-positron plasmas are investigated in the parameter regime most likely to be relevant for the first laboratory experiments involving such plasmas, where the density is small enough that collisions can be ignored and the Debye length substantially exceeds the gyroradius. Although the plasma beta is very small, electromagne…
▽ More
The linear gyrokinetic stability properties of magnetically confined electron-positron plasmas are investigated in the parameter regime most likely to be relevant for the first laboratory experiments involving such plasmas, where the density is small enough that collisions can be ignored and the Debye length substantially exceeds the gyroradius. Although the plasma beta is very small, electromagnetic effects are retained, but magnetic compressibility can be neglected. The work of a previous publication (Helander, 2014) is thus extended to include electromagnetic instabilities, which are of importance in closed-field-line configurations, where such instabilities can occur at arbitrarily low pressure. It is found that gyrokinetic instabilities are completely absent if the magnetic field is homogeneous: any instability must involve magnetic curvature or shear. Furthermore, in dipole magnetic fields, the stability threshold for interchange modes with wavelengths exceeding the Debye radius coincides with that in ideal MHD. Above this threshold, the quasilinear particle flux is directed inward if the temperature gradient is sufficiently large, leading to spontaneous peaking of the density profile.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
The Effect of Plasma Beta on High-n Ballooning Stability at Low Magnetic Shear
Authors:
J W Connor,
C J Ham,
R J Hastie
Abstract:
An explanation of the observed improvement in H-mode pedestal characteristics with increasing core plasma pressure or poloidal beta, as observed in MAST and JET, is sought in terms of the impact of the Shafranov shift, d', on ideal ballooning MHD stability.
An explanation of the observed improvement in H-mode pedestal characteristics with increasing core plasma pressure or poloidal beta, as observed in MAST and JET, is sought in terms of the impact of the Shafranov shift, d', on ideal ballooning MHD stability.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Resilience of quasi-isodynamic stellarators against trapped-particle instabilities
Authors:
J. H. E. Proll,
P. Helander,
J. W. Connor,
G. G. Plunk
Abstract:
It is shown that in perfectly quasi-isodynamic stellarators, trapped particles with a bounce frequency much higher than the frequency of the instability are stabilizing in the electrostatic and collisionless limit. The collisionless trapped-particle instability is therefore stable as well as the ordinary electron-density-gradient-driven trapped-electron mode. This result follows from the energy ba…
▽ More
It is shown that in perfectly quasi-isodynamic stellarators, trapped particles with a bounce frequency much higher than the frequency of the instability are stabilizing in the electrostatic and collisionless limit. The collisionless trapped-particle instability is therefore stable as well as the ordinary electron-density-gradient-driven trapped-electron mode. This result follows from the energy balance of electrostatic instabilities and is thus independent of all other details of the magnetic geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Magnetic compressibility and ion-temperature-gradient-driven microinstabilities in magnetically confined plasmas
Authors:
A. Zocco,
P. Helander,
J. W. Connor
Abstract:
The electromagnetic theory of the strongly driven ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) instability in magnetically confined toroidal plasmas is developed. Stabilizing and destabilizing effects are identified, and a critical $β_{e}$ (the ratio of the electron to magnetic pressure) for stabilization of the toroidal branch of the mode is calculated for magnetic equilibria independent of the coordinate alon…
▽ More
The electromagnetic theory of the strongly driven ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) instability in magnetically confined toroidal plasmas is developed. Stabilizing and destabilizing effects are identified, and a critical $β_{e}$ (the ratio of the electron to magnetic pressure) for stabilization of the toroidal branch of the mode is calculated for magnetic equilibria independent of the coordinate along the magnetic field. Its scaling is $β_{e}\sim L_{Te}/R,$ where $L_{Te}$ is the characteristic electron temperature gradient length, and $R$ the major radius of the torus. We conjecture that a fast particle population can cause a similar stabilization due to its contribution to the equilibrium pressure gradient. For sheared equilibria, the boundary of marginal stability of the electromagnetic correction to the electrostatic mode is also given. For a general magnetic equilibrium, we find a critical length (for electromagnetic stabilization) of the extent of the unfavourable curvature along the magnetic field. This is a decreasing function of the local magnetic shear.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
The Role of Thermal Conduction in Tearing Mode Theory
Authors:
J. W. Connor,
C. J. Ham,
R. J. Hastie,
Y. Q. Liu
Abstract:
The role of anisotropic thermal diffusivity on tearing mode stability is analysed in general toroidal geometry. A dispersion relation linking the growth rate to the tearing mode stability parameter, Delta, is derived. By using a resistive MHD code, modified to include such thermal transport, to calculate tearing mode growth rates, the dispersion relation is employed to determine Delta in situation…
▽ More
The role of anisotropic thermal diffusivity on tearing mode stability is analysed in general toroidal geometry. A dispersion relation linking the growth rate to the tearing mode stability parameter, Delta, is derived. By using a resistive MHD code, modified to include such thermal transport, to calculate tearing mode growth rates, the dispersion relation is employed to determine Delta in situations with finite plasma pressure that are stabilised by favourable average curvature in a simple resistive MHD model. We also demonstrate that the same code can also be used to calculate the basis-functions [C J Ham, et al, Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 54 (2012) 105014] needed to construct Delta.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
High-m Kink/Tearing Modes in Cylindrical Geometry
Authors:
J. W. Connor,
R. J. Hastie,
I. Pusztai,
P. J. Catto,
M. Barnes
Abstract:
The global ideal kink equation, for cylindrical geometry and zero beta, is simplified in the high poloidal mode number limit and used to determine the tearing stability parameter, $Δ^\prime$. In the presence of a steep monotonic current gradient, $Δ^\prime$ becomes a function of a parameter, $σ_0$, characterising the ratio of the maximum current gradient to magnetic shear, and $x_s$, characterisin…
▽ More
The global ideal kink equation, for cylindrical geometry and zero beta, is simplified in the high poloidal mode number limit and used to determine the tearing stability parameter, $Δ^\prime$. In the presence of a steep monotonic current gradient, $Δ^\prime$ becomes a function of a parameter, $σ_0$, characterising the ratio of the maximum current gradient to magnetic shear, and $x_s$, characterising the separation of the resonant surface from the maximum of the current gradient. In equilibria containing a current "spike", so that there is a non-monotonic current profile, $Δ^\prime$ also depends on two parameters: $κ$, related to the ratio of the curvature of the current density at its maximum to the magnetic shear, and $x_s$, which now represents the separation of the resonance from the point of maximum current density. The relation of our results to earlier studies of tearing modes and to recent gyro-kinetic calculations of current driven instabilities, is discussed, together with potential implications for the stability of the tokamak pedestal.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Collisionless microinstabilities in stellarators III - the ion-temperature-gradient mode
Authors:
G. G. Plunk,
P. Helander,
P. Xanthopoulos,
J. W. Connor
Abstract:
We investigate the linear theory of the ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) mode, with the goal of develo** a general understanding that may be applied to stellarators. We highlight the Wendelstein 7X (W7-X) device. Simple fluid and kinetic models that follow closely from existing literature are reviewed and two new first-principle models are presented and compared with results from direct numerical…
▽ More
We investigate the linear theory of the ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) mode, with the goal of develo** a general understanding that may be applied to stellarators. We highlight the Wendelstein 7X (W7-X) device. Simple fluid and kinetic models that follow closely from existing literature are reviewed and two new first-principle models are presented and compared with results from direct numerical simulation. One model investigates the effect of regions of strong localized shear, which are generic to stellarator equilibria. These "shear spikes" are found to have a potentially significant stabilizing affect on the mode; however, the effect is strongest at short wavelengths perpendicular to the magnetic field, and it is found to be significant only for the fastest growing modes in W7-X. A second model investigates the long-wavelength limit for the case of negligible global magnetic shear. The analytic calculation reveals that the effect of the curvature drive enters at second order in the drift frequency, confirming conventional wisdom that the ITG mode is slab-like at long wavelengths. Using flux tube simulations of a zero-shear W7-X configuration, we observe a close relationship to an axisymmetric configuration at a similar parameter point. It is concluded that scale lengths of the equilibrium gradients constitute a good parameter space to characterize the ITG mode. Thus, to optimize the magnetic geometry for ITG mode stability, it may be fruitful to focus on local parameters, such as the magnitude of bad curvature, connection length, and local shear at locations of bad curvature (where the ITG mode amplitude peaks).
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2014; v1 submitted 9 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Tearing mode stability calculations with pressure flattening
Authors:
C J Ham,
J W Connor,
S C Cowley,
R J Hastie,
T C Hender,
Y Q Liu
Abstract:
Calculations of tearing mode stability in tokamaks split conveniently into an external region, where marginally stable ideal MHD is applicable, and a resonant layer around the rational surface where sophisticated kinetic physics is needed. These two regions are coupled by the stability parameter. Pressure and current perturbations localized around the rational surface alter the stability of tearin…
▽ More
Calculations of tearing mode stability in tokamaks split conveniently into an external region, where marginally stable ideal MHD is applicable, and a resonant layer around the rational surface where sophisticated kinetic physics is needed. These two regions are coupled by the stability parameter. Pressure and current perturbations localized around the rational surface alter the stability of tearing modes. Equations governing the changes in the external solution and - are derived for arbitrary perturbations in axisymmetric toroidal geometry. The relationship of - with and without pressure flattening is obtained analytically for four pressure flattening functions. Resistive MHD codes do not contain the appropriate layer physics and therefore cannot predict stability directly. They can, however, be used to calculate -. Existing methods (Ham et al. 2012 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 54 025009) for extracting - from resistive codes are unsatisfactory when there is a finite pressure gradient at the rational surface and favourable average curvature because of the Glasser stabilizing effect. To overcome this difficulty we introduce a specific pressure flattening function that allows the earlier approach to be used. The technique is first tested numerically in cylindrical geometry with an artificial favourable curvature. Its application to toroidal geometry is then demonstrated using the toroidal tokamak tearing mode stability code T7 (Fitzpatrick et al. 1993 Nucl. Fusion 33 1533) which uses an approximate analytic equilibrium. The prospects for applying this approach to resistive MHD codes such as MARS-F (Liu et al. 2000 Phys. Plasmas 7 3681) which utilize a fully toroidal equilibrium are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Electromagnetic effects in the stabilization of turbulence by sheared flow
Authors:
M. D. J. Cole,
S. L. Newton,
S. C. Cowley,
N. F. Loureiro,
D. Dickinson,
C. Roach,
J. W. Connor
Abstract:
We have extended our study of the competition between the drive and stabilization of plasma microinstabilities by sheared flow to include electromagnetic effects at low plasma $β$ (the ratio of plasma to magnetic pressure). The extended system of characteristic equations is formulated, for a dissipative fluid model developed from the gyrokinetic equation, using a twisting mode representation in sh…
▽ More
We have extended our study of the competition between the drive and stabilization of plasma microinstabilities by sheared flow to include electromagnetic effects at low plasma $β$ (the ratio of plasma to magnetic pressure). The extended system of characteristic equations is formulated, for a dissipative fluid model developed from the gyrokinetic equation, using a twisting mode representation in sheared slab geometry and focusing on the ion temperature gradient mode. Perpendicular flow shear convects perturbations along the field at the speed we denote as $Mc_s$ (where $c_s$ is the sound speed). $M > 1/ \sqrtβ$ is required to make the system characteristics unidirectional and inhibit eigenmode formation, leaving only transitory perturbations in the system. This typically represents a much larger flow shear than in the electrostatic case, which only needs $M>1$. Numerical investigation of the region $M < 1/\sqrtβ$ shows the driving terms can conflict, as in the electrostatic case, giving low growth rates over a range of parameters. Also, at modest drive strengths and low $β$ values typical of experiments, including electromagnetic effects does not significantly alter the growth rates. For stronger flow shear and higher $β$, geometry characteristic of the spherical tokamak mitigates the effect of an instability of the shear Alfvén wave, driven by the parallel flow shear.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
The Stochastic Field Transport associated with the Slab ITG Modes
Authors:
J W Connor,
R J Hastie,
A Zocco
Abstract:
Many models for anomalous transport consider the turbulent ExB transport arising from electrostatic micro-instabilities. In this paper we investigate whether the perturbed magnetic field that is associated with such instabilities at small but finite values of {beta} can lead to significant stochastic magnetic field transport. Using the tearing parity, long wave-length ion temperature gradient (ITG…
▽ More
Many models for anomalous transport consider the turbulent ExB transport arising from electrostatic micro-instabilities. In this paper we investigate whether the perturbed magnetic field that is associated with such instabilities at small but finite values of {beta} can lead to significant stochastic magnetic field transport. Using the tearing parity, long wave-length ion temperature gradient (ITG) modes in a plasma slab with magnetic shear as an example, we calculate the amplitude of the perturbed magnetic field that results at the resonant surface for the case when the plasma dissipation is given by the semi-collisional electron model. The resulting stochastic field transport is estimated and also compared with an estimate for the ExB transport due to the ITG mode.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Improved Criterion for Sawtooth Trigger and Modelling
Authors:
A. Zocco,
J. W. Connor,
C. G. Gimblett,
R. J. Hastie
Abstract:
We discuss the role of neoclassical resistivity and local magnetic shear in the triggering of the sawtooth in tokamaks. When collisional detrap** of electrons is considered the value of the safety factor on axis, $q(0,t)$, evolves on a new time scale, $τ_{*}=τ_ην_{*}/(8\sqrtε)$, where $τ_η=4πa^{2}/[c^{2}η(0)]$ is the resistive diffusion time, $ν_{*}=ν_{e}/(ε^{3/2}ω_{te})$ the electron collision…
▽ More
We discuss the role of neoclassical resistivity and local magnetic shear in the triggering of the sawtooth in tokamaks. When collisional detrap** of electrons is considered the value of the safety factor on axis, $q(0,t)$, evolves on a new time scale, $τ_{*}=τ_ην_{*}/(8\sqrtε)$, where $τ_η=4πa^{2}/[c^{2}η(0)]$ is the resistive diffusion time, $ν_{*}=ν_{e}/(ε^{3/2}ω_{te})$ the electron collision frequency normalised to the transit frequency and $ε=a/R_{0}$ the tokamak inverse aspect ratio. Such evolution is characterised by the formation of a structure of size $δ_{*}\simν_{*}^{2/3}a$ around the magnetic axis, which can drive rapid evolution of the magnetic shear and decrease of $q(0,t)$. We investigate two possible trigger mechanisms for a sawtooth collapse corresponding to crossing the linear threshold for the $m=1,n=1$ instability and non-linear triggering of this mode by a core resonant mode near the magnetic axis. The sawtooth period in each case is determined by the time for the resistive evolution of the $q$-profile to reach the relevant stability threshold; in the latter case it can be strongly affected by $ν_*.$
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2013; v1 submitted 27 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Ion Landau Dam** on Drift Tearing Modes
Authors:
J. W. Connor,
R. J. Hastie,
A. Zocco
Abstract:
Kinetic treatments of drift-tearing modes that match an inner resonant layer solution to an external MHD region solution, characterised by $Δ^{\prime}$, fail to properly match the ideal MHD boundary condition on the parallel electric field, $E_{\parallel}.$ In this paper we demonstrate how consideration of ion sound and ion Landau dam** effects achieves this and place the theory on a firm footin…
▽ More
Kinetic treatments of drift-tearing modes that match an inner resonant layer solution to an external MHD region solution, characterised by $Δ^{\prime}$, fail to properly match the ideal MHD boundary condition on the parallel electric field, $E_{\parallel}.$ In this paper we demonstrate how consideration of ion sound and ion Landau dam** effects achieves this and place the theory on a firm footing. As a consequence, these effects contribute quite significantly to the critical value of $Δ^{\prime}$ for instability of drift-tearing modes and play a key role in determining the minimum value for this threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2012; v1 submitted 23 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Micro-tearing modes in the Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak
Authors:
D J Applegate,
C M Roach,
J W Connor,
S C Cowley,
W Dorland,
R J Hastie,
N. Joiner
Abstract:
Recent gyrokinetic stability calculations have revealed that the spherical tokamak is susceptible to tearing parity instabilities with length scales of a few ion Larmor radii perpendicular to the magnetic field lines. Here we investigate this 'micro-tearing' mode in greater detail to uncover its key characteristics, and compare it with existing theoretical models of the phenomenon. This has been a…
▽ More
Recent gyrokinetic stability calculations have revealed that the spherical tokamak is susceptible to tearing parity instabilities with length scales of a few ion Larmor radii perpendicular to the magnetic field lines. Here we investigate this 'micro-tearing' mode in greater detail to uncover its key characteristics, and compare it with existing theoretical models of the phenomenon. This has been accomplished using a full numerical solution of the linear gyrokinetic-Maxwell equations. Importantly, the instability is found to be driven by the free energy in the electron temperature gradient as described in the literature. However, our calculations suggest it is not substantially affected by either of the destabilising mechanisms proposed in previous theoretical models. Instead the instability is destabilised by interactions with magnetic drifts, and the electrostatic potential. Further calculations reveal that the mode is not significantly destabilised by the flux surface sha** or the large trapped particle fraction present in the spherical tokamak. Its prevalence in spherical tokamak plasmas is primarily due to the higher value of plasma β, and the enhanced magnetic drifts due to the smaller radius of curvature.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
Unified theory of the semi-collisional tearing mode and internal kink mode in a hot tokamak: implications for sawtooth modelling
Authors:
J. W. Connor,
R. J. Hastie,
A. Zocco
Abstract:
In large hot tokamaks like JET, the width of the reconnecting layer for resistive modes is determined by semi-collisional electron dynamics and is much less than the ion Larmor radius. Firstly a dispersion relation valid in this regime is derived which provides a unified description of drift-tearing modes, kinetic Alfven waves and the internal kink mode at low beta. Tearing mode stability is inves…
▽ More
In large hot tokamaks like JET, the width of the reconnecting layer for resistive modes is determined by semi-collisional electron dynamics and is much less than the ion Larmor radius. Firstly a dispersion relation valid in this regime is derived which provides a unified description of drift-tearing modes, kinetic Alfven waves and the internal kink mode at low beta. Tearing mode stability is investigated analytically recovering the stabilising ion orbit effect, obtained previously by Cowley et al. [Phys. Fluids (29) 3230 1986], which implies large values of the tearing mode stability parameter "Delta prime" are required for instability. Secondly, at high beta it is shown that the tearing mode interacts with the kinetic Alfven wave and that there is an absolute stabilisation for all "Delta prime" due to the shielding effects of the electron temperature gradients, extending the result of Drake et. al [Phys. Fluids (26) 2509 1983] to large ion orbits. The nature of the transition between these two limits at finite values of beta is then elucidated. The low beta formalism is also relevant to the m=n=1 tearing mode and the dissipative internal kink mode, thus extending the work of Pegoraro et al. [Phys. Fluids B (1) 364 1989] to a more realistic electron model incorporating temperature perturbations, but then the smallness of the dissipative internal kink mode frequency is exploited to obtain a new dispersion relation valid at arbitrary beta. A diagram describing the stability of both the tearing mode and dissipative internal kink mode, in the space of "Delta prime" and beta, is obtained. The trajectory of the evolution of the current profile during a sawtooth period can be plotted in this diagram, providing a model for the triggering of a sawtooth crash.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2012; v1 submitted 11 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.