-
Characterizing active learning environments in physics using latent profile analysis
Authors:
Kelley Commeford,
Eric Brewe,
Adrienne Traxler
Abstract:
The vast majority of research involving active learning pedagogies uses passive lecture methods as a baseline. We propose to move beyond such comparisons to understand the mechanisms that make different active learning styles unique. Here, we use COPUS observations to record student and instructor activities in six known styles of active learning in physics, and use latent profile analysis to clas…
▽ More
The vast majority of research involving active learning pedagogies uses passive lecture methods as a baseline. We propose to move beyond such comparisons to understand the mechanisms that make different active learning styles unique. Here, we use COPUS observations to record student and instructor activities in six known styles of active learning in physics, and use latent profile analysis to classify these observations. Latent profile analysis using two profiles successfully groups COPUS profiles into interactive lecture-like and other. Five latent profiles successfully sorts observations into interactive lecture-like, Modeling Instruction, ISLE labs, Context-Rich problems labs, and recitation/discussion-like. This analysis serves as a proof of concept, and suggests instructional differences across pedagogies that can be further investigated using this method.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Characterizing active learning environments in physics using network analysis and COPUS observations
Authors:
Kelley Commeford,
Eric Brewe,
Adrienne Traxler
Abstract:
This study uses social network analysis and the Classroom Observation Protocol for Undergraduate STEM (COPUS) to characterize six research-based introductory physics curricula. Peer Instruction, Modeling Instruction, ISLE, SCALE-UP, Context-Rich Problems, and Tutorials in Introductory Physics were investigated. Students in each curriculum were given a survey at the beginning and end of term, askin…
▽ More
This study uses social network analysis and the Classroom Observation Protocol for Undergraduate STEM (COPUS) to characterize six research-based introductory physics curricula. Peer Instruction, Modeling Instruction, ISLE, SCALE-UP, Context-Rich Problems, and Tutorials in Introductory Physics were investigated. Students in each curriculum were given a survey at the beginning and end of term, asking them to self-identify peers with whom they had meaningful interactions in class. Every curriculum showed an increase in the average number of student connections from the beginning of term to the end of term, with the largest increase occurring in Modeling Instruction, SCALE-UP, and Context-Rich Problems. Modeling Instruction was the only curriculum with a drastic change in how tightly connected the student network was. Transitivity increased for all curricula except Peer Instruction. We also spent one week per research site in the middle of the term observing courses using COPUS. From these observations, the student COPUS profiles look nearly the same for Tutorials, ISLE recitations, and Context-Rich Problems discussion sections. This is likely due to the large resolution of activities that can be coded as "other group activity", suggesting the need for a more detailed observation instrument.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2021; v1 submitted 12 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Network positions in active learning environments in physics
Authors:
Adrienne L. Traxler,
Tyme Suda,
Eric Brewe,
Kelley Commeford
Abstract:
This study uses positional analysis to describe the student interaction networks in four research-based introductory physics curricula. Positional analysis is a technique for simplifying the structure of a network into blocks of actors whose connections are more similar to each other than to the rest of the network. This method describes social structure in a way that is comparable between network…
▽ More
This study uses positional analysis to describe the student interaction networks in four research-based introductory physics curricula. Positional analysis is a technique for simplifying the structure of a network into blocks of actors whose connections are more similar to each other than to the rest of the network. This method describes social structure in a way that is comparable between networks of different sizes and densities and can show large-scale patterns such as hierarchy or brokering among actors. We detail the method and apply it to class sections using Peer Instruction, SCALE-UP, ISLE, and context-rich problems. At the level of detail shown in the blockmodels, most of the curricula are more alike than different, showing a late-term tendency to form coherent subgroups that communicate actively among themselves but have few inter-position links. This pattern may be a network signature of active learning classes, but wider data collection is needed to investigate.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The PROSPECT Reactor Antineutrino Experiment
Authors:
PROSPECT Collaboration,
J. Ashenfelter,
A. B. Balantekin,
C. Baldenegro,
H. R. Band,
C. D. Bass,
D. E. Bergeron,
D. Berish,
L. J. Bignell,
N. S. Bowden,
J. Boyle,
J. Bricco,
J. P. Brodsky,
C. D. Bryan,
A. Bykadorova Telles,
J. J. Cherwinka,
T. Classen,
K. Commeford,
A. Conant,
A. A. Cox,
D. Davee,
D. Dean,
G. Deichert,
M. V. Diwan,
M. J. Dolinski
, et al. (64 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum Experiment, PROSPECT, is designed to make both a precise measurement of the antineutrino spectrum from a highly-enriched uranium reactor and to probe eV-scale sterile neutrinos by searching for neutrino oscillations over meter-long baselines. PROSPECT utilizes a segmented $^6$Li-doped liquid scintillator detector for both efficient detection of reacto…
▽ More
The Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum Experiment, PROSPECT, is designed to make both a precise measurement of the antineutrino spectrum from a highly-enriched uranium reactor and to probe eV-scale sterile neutrinos by searching for neutrino oscillations over meter-long baselines. PROSPECT utilizes a segmented $^6$Li-doped liquid scintillator detector for both efficient detection of reactor antineutrinos through the inverse beta decay reaction and excellent background discrimination. PROSPECT is a movable 4-ton antineutrino detector covering distances of 7m to 13m from the High Flux Isotope Reactor core. It will probe the best-fit point of the $\barν_e$ disappearance experiments at 4$σ$ in 1 year and the favored regions of the sterile neutrino parameter space at more than 3$σ$ in 3 years. PROSPECT will test the origin of spectral deviations observed in recent $θ_{13}$ experiments, search for sterile neutrinos, and address the hypothesis of sterile neutrinos as an explanation of the reactor anomaly. This paper describes the design, construction, and commissioning of PROSPECT and reports first data characterizing the performance of the PROSPECT antineutrino detector.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2019; v1 submitted 31 July, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Performance of a segmented $^{6}$Li-loaded liquid scintillator detector for the PROSPECT experiment
Authors:
J. Ashenfelter,
A. B. Balantekin,
H. R. Band,
C. D. Bass,
D. E. Bergeron,
D. Berish,
N. S. Bowden,
J. P. Brodsky,
C. D. Bryan,
A. Bykadorova Telles,
J. J. Cherwinka,
T. Classen,
K. Commeford,
A. Conant,
D. Davee,
G. Deichert,
M. V. Diwan,
M. J. Dolinski,
A. Erickson,
B. T. Foust,
J. K. Gaison,
A. Galindo-Uribarri,
K. Gilje,
B. Hackett,
K. Han
, et al. (41 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This paper describes the design and performance of a 50 liter, two-segment $^{6}$Li-loaded liquid scintillator detector that was designed and operated as prototype for the PROSPECT (Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum) Experiment. The two-segment detector was constructed according to the design specifications of the experiment. It features low-mass optical separators, an integrated source a…
▽ More
This paper describes the design and performance of a 50 liter, two-segment $^{6}$Li-loaded liquid scintillator detector that was designed and operated as prototype for the PROSPECT (Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum) Experiment. The two-segment detector was constructed according to the design specifications of the experiment. It features low-mass optical separators, an integrated source and optical calibration system, and materials that are compatible with the $^{6}$Li-doped scintillator developed by PROSPECT. We demonstrate a high light collection of 850$\pm$20 PE/MeV, an energy resolution of $σ$ = 4.0$\pm$0.2% at 1 MeV, and efficient pulse-shape discrimination of low $dE/dx$ (electronic recoil) and high $dE/dx$ (nuclear recoil) energy depositions. An effective scintillation attenuation length of 85$\pm$3 cm is measured in each segment. The 0.1% by mass concentration of $^{6}$Li in the scintillator results in a measured neutron capture time of $τ$ = 42.8$\pm$0.2 $μs$. The long-term stability of the scintillator is also discussed. The detector response meets the criteria necessary for achieving the PROSPECT physics goals and demonstrates features that may find application in fast neutron detection.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018; v1 submitted 23 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
The PROSPECT Physics Program
Authors:
J. Ashenfelter,
B. Balantekin,
H. R. Band,
G. Barclay,
C. D. Bass,
D. Berish,
N. S. Bowden,
A. Bowes,
C. D. Bryan,
J. P. Brodsky,
J. J. Cherwinka,
R. Chu,
T. Classen,
K. Commeford,
D. Davee,
D. Dean,
G. Deichert,
M. V. Diwan,
M. J. Dolinski,
J. Dolph,
J. K. Gaison,
A. Galindo-Uribarri,
K. Gilje,
A. Glenn,
B. W. Goddard
, et al. (39 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum Experiment, PROSPECT, is designed to make a precise measurement of the antineutrino spectrum from a highly-enriched uranium reactor and probe eV-scale sterile neutrinos by searching for neutrino oscillations over meter-long distances. PROSPECT is conceived as a 2-phase experiment utilizing segmented $^6$Li-doped liquid scintillator detectors for both…
▽ More
The Precision Reactor Oscillation and Spectrum Experiment, PROSPECT, is designed to make a precise measurement of the antineutrino spectrum from a highly-enriched uranium reactor and probe eV-scale sterile neutrinos by searching for neutrino oscillations over meter-long distances. PROSPECT is conceived as a 2-phase experiment utilizing segmented $^6$Li-doped liquid scintillator detectors for both efficient detection of reactor antineutrinos through the inverse beta decay reaction and excellent background discrimination. PROSPECT Phase I consists of a movable 3-ton antineutrino detector at distances of 7 - 12 m from the reactor core. It will probe the best-fit point of the $ν_e$ disappearance experiments at 4$σ$ in 1 year and the favored region of the sterile neutrino parameter space at $>$3$σ$ in 3 years. With a second antineutrino detector at 15 - 19 m from the reactor, Phase II of PROSPECT can probe the entire allowed parameter space below 10 eV$^{2}$ at 5$σ$ in 3 additional years. The measurement of the reactor antineutrino spectrum and the search for short-baseline oscillations with PROSPECT will test the origin of the spectral deviations observed in recent $θ_{13}$ experiments, search for sterile neutrinos, and conclusively address the hypothesis of sterile neutrinos as an explanation of the reactor anomaly.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Light Collection and Pulse-Shape Discrimination in Elongated Scintillator Cells for the PROSPECT Reactor Antineutrino Experiment
Authors:
J. Ashenfelter,
B. Balantekin,
H. R. Band,
G. Barclay,
C. D. Bass,
D. Berish,
N. S. Bowden,
A. Bowes,
J. P. Brodsky,
C. D. Bryan,
J. J. Cherwinka,
R. Chu,
T. Classen,
K. Commeford,
D. Davee,
D. Dean,
G. Deichert,
M. V. Diwan,
M. J. Dolinski,
J. Dolph,
D. A. Dwyer,
J. K. Gaison,
A. Galindo-Uribarri,
K. Gilje,
A. Glenn
, et al. (41 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A meter-long, 23-liter EJ-309 liquid scintillator detector has been constructed to study the light collection and pulse-shape discrimination performance of elongated scintillator cells for the PROSPECT reactor antineutrino experiment. The magnitude and uniformity of light collection and neutron/gamma discrimination power in the energy range of antineutrino inverse beta decay products have been stu…
▽ More
A meter-long, 23-liter EJ-309 liquid scintillator detector has been constructed to study the light collection and pulse-shape discrimination performance of elongated scintillator cells for the PROSPECT reactor antineutrino experiment. The magnitude and uniformity of light collection and neutron/gamma discrimination power in the energy range of antineutrino inverse beta decay products have been studied using gamma and spontaneous fission calibration sources deployed along the cell long axis. We also study neutron-gamma discrimination and light collection abilities for differing PMT and reflector configurations. Key design features for optimizing MeV-scale response and background rejection capabilities are identified.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
