-
Dual-comb correlation spectroscopy of thermal light
Authors:
Eugene J. Tsao,
Alexander J. Lind,
Connor Fredrick,
Ryan K. Cole,
Peter Chang,
Kristina F. Chang,
Dahyeon Lee,
Matthew Heyrich,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Franklyn Quinlan,
Scott A. Diddams
Abstract:
The detection of light of thermal origin is the principal means by which humanity has learned about our world and the cosmos. In optical astronomy, in particular, direct detection of thermal photons and the resolution of their spectra have enabled discoveries of the broadest scope and impact. Such measurements, however, do not capture the phase of the thermal fields--a parameter that has proven cr…
▽ More
The detection of light of thermal origin is the principal means by which humanity has learned about our world and the cosmos. In optical astronomy, in particular, direct detection of thermal photons and the resolution of their spectra have enabled discoveries of the broadest scope and impact. Such measurements, however, do not capture the phase of the thermal fields--a parameter that has proven crucial to transformative techniques in radio astronomy such as synthetic aperture imaging. Over the last 25 years, tremendous progress has occurred in laser science, notably in the phase-sensitive, broad bandwidth, high resolution, and traceable spectroscopy enabled by the optical frequency comb. In this work, we directly connect the fields of frequency comb laser spectroscopy and passive optical sensing as applied to astronomy, remote sensing, and atmospheric science. We provide fundamental sensitivity analysis of dual-comb correlation spectroscopy (DCCS), whereby broadband thermal light is measured via interferometry with two optical frequency combs. We define and experimentally verify the sensitivity scaling of DCCS at black body temperatures relevant for astrophysical observations. Moreover, we provide comparison with direct detection techniques and more conventional laser heterodyne radiometry. Our work provides the foundation for future exploration of comb-based broadband synthetic aperture hyperspectral imaging across the infrared and optical spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Temperature, Pressure, Velocity, and Water Vapor Mole Fraction Profiles in a Ramjet Combustor using Dual Frequency Comb Spectroscopy and a High Temperature Absorption Database
Authors:
David Yun,
Scott C. Egbert,
Nathan A. Malarich,
Ryan K. Cole,
Jacob J. France,
Jiwen Liu,
Kristin M. Rice,
Mark A. Hagenmaier,
Jeffrey M. Donbar,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Sean C. Coburn,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
Accurate diagnostics of the combustor region of ramjet engines can improve engine design and create benchmarks for computational fluid dynamics models. Previous works demonstrate that dual frequency comb spectroscopy can provide low uncertainty diagnostics of multiple flow parameters in the non-combusting regions of ramjets. However, the high temperatures present in the combustor present a challen…
▽ More
Accurate diagnostics of the combustor region of ramjet engines can improve engine design and create benchmarks for computational fluid dynamics models. Previous works demonstrate that dual frequency comb spectroscopy can provide low uncertainty diagnostics of multiple flow parameters in the non-combusting regions of ramjets. However, the high temperatures present in the combustor present a challenge for broadband spectroscopic absorption models that are used to interpret measurements in these regions. Here, we utilize a new water vapor absorption database created for high temperature water-air mixtures to fit spectra measured in a ground-test ramjet engine with a broadband near-infrared dual comb absorption spectrometer. We extract 2D profiles of pressure, temperature, water mole fraction, and velocity using this new database. We demonstrate that the new database provides the lowest fit residuals compared to other water vapor absorption databases. We compare computational fluid dynamics simulations of the combustor with the measured data to demonstrate that the simulations overpredict heat release and water vapor production.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Precision Doppler Shift Measurements with a Frequency Comb Calibrated Laser Heterodyne Radiometer
Authors:
Ryan K. Cole,
Connor Fredrick,
Newton H. Nguyen,
Scott A. Diddams
Abstract:
We report precision atmospheric spectroscopy of $CO_2$ using a laser heterodyne radiometer (LHR) calibrated with an optical frequency comb. Using the comb-calibrated LHR, we record spectra of atmospheric $CO_2$ near 1572.33 nm with a spectral resolution of 200 MHz using sunlight as a light source. The measured $CO_2$ spectra exhibit frequency shifts by approximately 11 MHz over the course of the f…
▽ More
We report precision atmospheric spectroscopy of $CO_2$ using a laser heterodyne radiometer (LHR) calibrated with an optical frequency comb. Using the comb-calibrated LHR, we record spectra of atmospheric $CO_2$ near 1572.33 nm with a spectral resolution of 200 MHz using sunlight as a light source. The measured $CO_2$ spectra exhibit frequency shifts by approximately 11 MHz over the course of the five-hour measurement, and we show that these shifts are caused by Doppler effects due to wind along the spectrometer line of sight. The measured frequency shifts are in excellent agreement with an atmospheric model, and we show that our measurements track the wind-induced Doppler shifts with a relative frequency precision of 100 kHz (15 cm/s), equivalent to a fractional precision of a few parts in $10^{10}$. These results demonstrate that frequency-comb-calibrated LHR enables precision velocimetry that can be of use in applications ranging from climate science to astronomy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Supersonic Combustion Diagnostics with Dual Comb Spectroscopy
Authors:
David Yun,
Nathan A. Malarich,
Ryan K. Cole,
Scott C. Egbert,
Jacob J. France,
Jiwen Liu,
Kristin M. Rice,
Mark A. Hagenmaier,
Jeffrey M. Donbar,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Sean C. Coburn,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
Supersonic engine development requires accurate and detailed measurements of fluidic and thermodynamic parameters to optimize engine designs and benchmark computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations. Here, we demonstrate that dual frequency comb spectroscopy (DCS) with mode-locked frequency combs can provide simultaneous absolute measurements of several flow parameters with low uncertainty acros…
▽ More
Supersonic engine development requires accurate and detailed measurements of fluidic and thermodynamic parameters to optimize engine designs and benchmark computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations. Here, we demonstrate that dual frequency comb spectroscopy (DCS) with mode-locked frequency combs can provide simultaneous absolute measurements of several flow parameters with low uncertainty across a range of conditions owing to the broadband and ultrastable optical frequency output of the lasers. We perform DCS measurements across a 6800-7200 cm-1 bandwidth covering hundreds of H2O absorption features resolved with a spectral point spacing of 0.0067 cm-1 and point spacing precision of 1.68 x 10-10 cm-1. We demonstrate 2D profiles of velocity, temperature, pressure, water mole fraction, and air mass flux in a ground-test dual-mode ramjet at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base. The narrow angles of the measurement beams offer sufficient spatial resolution to resolve properties across an oblique shock train in the isolator and the thermal throat of the combustor. We determine that the total measurement uncertainties for the various parameters range from 1% for temperature to 9% for water vapor mole fraction, with the absorption database/model that is used to interpret the data typically contributing the most uncertainty (leaving the door open for even lower uncertainty in the future). CFD at the various measurement locations show good agreement, largely falling within the DCS measurement uncertainty for most profiles and parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022; v1 submitted 5 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Spatially resolved mass flux measurements with dual comb spectroscopy
Authors:
David Yun,
Ryan K. Cole,
Nathan A. Malarich,
Sean C. Coburn,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Jiwen Liu,
Jacob J. France,
Mark A. Hagenmaier,
Kristin M. Rice,
Jeffrey M. Donbar,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
Providing an accurate, representative sample of mass flux across large open areas for atmospheric studies or the extreme conditions of a hypersonic engine is challenging for traditional intrusive or point-based sensors. Here, we demonstrate that laser absorption spectroscopy with mode-locked frequency combs can simultaneously measure all of the components of mass flux (velocity, temperature, press…
▽ More
Providing an accurate, representative sample of mass flux across large open areas for atmospheric studies or the extreme conditions of a hypersonic engine is challenging for traditional intrusive or point-based sensors. Here, we demonstrate that laser absorption spectroscopy with mode-locked frequency combs can simultaneously measure all of the components of mass flux (velocity, temperature, pressure, and species mole fraction) with low uncertainty, spatial resolution corresponding to the laser line of sight, and no supplemental sensor readings. The low uncertainty is provided by the broad spectral bandwidth, high resolution, and extremely well-known and controlled frequency axis of stabilized, mode-locked frequency combs. We demonstrate these capabilities using dual frequency comb spectroscopy (DCS) in the isolator of a ground-test supersonic propulsion engine at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base. The mass flux measurements are consistent within 3.6% of the facility-level engine air supply values. A vertical scan of the laser beams in the isolator measures the spatially resolved mass flux, which is compared with computational fluid dynamics simulations. A rigorous uncertainty analysis demonstrates a instrument uncertainty of ~0.4%, and total uncertainty (including non-instrument sources) of ~7% for mass flux measurements. These measurements demonstrate DCS with mode-locked frequency combs as a low-uncertainty mass flux sensor for a variety of applications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022; v1 submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Demonstration of a uniform, high-pressure, high-temperature gas cell with a dual frequency comb absorption spectrometer
Authors:
Ryan K. Cole,
Anthony D. Draper,
Paul J. Schroeder,
Cameron M. Casby,
Amanda S. Makowiecki,
Sean C. Coburn,
Julie E. Steinbrenner,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
Accurate absorption models for gases at high pressure and temperature support advanced optical combustion diagnostics and aid in the study of harsh planetary atmospheres. Develo** and validating absorption models for these applications requires recreating the extreme temperature and pressure conditions of these environments in static, uniform, well-known conditions in the laboratory. Here, we pr…
▽ More
Accurate absorption models for gases at high pressure and temperature support advanced optical combustion diagnostics and aid in the study of harsh planetary atmospheres. Develo** and validating absorption models for these applications requires recreating the extreme temperature and pressure conditions of these environments in static, uniform, well-known conditions in the laboratory. Here, we present the design of a new gas cell to enable reference-quality absorption spectroscopy at high pressure and temperature. The design centers on a carefully controlled quartz sample cell housed at the core of a pressurized ceramic furnace. The half-meter sample cell is relatively long compared to past high- pressure and temperature absorption cells, and is surrounded by a molybdenum heat spreader that enables high temperature uniformity over the full length of the absorbing gas. We measure the temperature distribution of the sample gas using in situ thermocouples, and fully characterize the temperature uniformity across a full matrix of conditions up to 1000 K and 50 bar. The results demonstrate that the new design enables highly uniform and precisely known conditions across the full absorbing path length. Uniquely, we test the new gas cell with a broadband, high-resolution dual frequency comb spectrometer that enables highly resolved absorption spectroscopy across a wide range of temperature and pressure conditions. With this system, we measure the spectrum of CO$_2$ between 6800 and 7000 cm$^{-1}$ at pressures between 0.2 and 20 bar, and temperatures up to 1000 K. The measurements reveal discrepancies from spectra predicted by the HITRAN2016 database with a Voigt line shape at both low- and high-pressure conditions. These results motivate future work to expand absorption models and databases to accurately model high-pressure and -temperature spectra in combustion and planetary science research.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Cepstral Analysis for Baseline-Insensitive Absorption Spectroscopy Using Light Sources with Pronounced Intensity Variations
Authors:
Christopher S. Goldenstein,
Garrett C. Mathews,
Ryan K. Cole,
Amanda S. Makowiecki,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
This manuscript presents a data-processing technique which improves the accuracy and precision of absorption-spectroscopy measurements by isolating the molecular absorbance signal from errors in the baseline light intensity (Io) using cepstral analysis. Recently, cepstral analysis has been used with traditional absorption spectrometers to create a modified form of the time-domain molecular free-in…
▽ More
This manuscript presents a data-processing technique which improves the accuracy and precision of absorption-spectroscopy measurements by isolating the molecular absorbance signal from errors in the baseline light intensity (Io) using cepstral analysis. Recently, cepstral analysis has been used with traditional absorption spectrometers to create a modified form of the time-domain molecular free-induction decay (m-FID) signal which can be analyzed independently from Io. However, independent analysis of the molecular signature is not possible when the baseline intensity and molecular response do not separate well in the time domain, which is typical when using injection-current-tuned lasers (e.g., quantum cascade lasers) and other light sources with pronounced intensity tuning. In contrast, the method presented here is applicable to all light sources since it determines gas properties by least-squares fitting a simulated m-FID signal to the measured m-FID signal in the time domain. This method is insensitive to errors in the estimated Io which vary slowly with optical frequency and, therefore, decay rapidly in the time domain. The benefits provided by this method are demonstrated via scanned-wavelength direct-absorption measurements acquired with a distributed-feedback (DFB) quantum-cascade laser (QCL). The wavelength of a DFB QCL was scanned across CO's P(0,20) and P(1,14) absorption transitions at 1 kHz to measure the gas temperature and concentration of CO. Measurements were acquired in a gas cell and in an ethylene-air flame at 1 atm. The measured spectra were processed using the new m-FID-based method and two traditional methods which rely on inferring the baseline error within the spectral-fitting routine. The m-FID-based method demonstrated superior accuracy in all cases and a measurement precision that was 1.5 to 10 times smaller than that provided using traditional methods.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
11-μs Time-resolved, Continuous Dual-Comb Spectroscopy with Spectrally Filtered Mode-locked Frequency Combs
Authors:
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Ryan K. Cole,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
Broadband dual-comb spectroscopy (DCS) based on portable mode-locked fiber frequency combs is a powerful tool for in situ, calibration free, multi-species spectroscopy. While the acquisition of a single spectrum with mode-locked DCS typically takes microseconds to milliseconds, the applications of these spectrometers have generally been limited to systems and processes with time changes on the ord…
▽ More
Broadband dual-comb spectroscopy (DCS) based on portable mode-locked fiber frequency combs is a powerful tool for in situ, calibration free, multi-species spectroscopy. While the acquisition of a single spectrum with mode-locked DCS typically takes microseconds to milliseconds, the applications of these spectrometers have generally been limited to systems and processes with time changes on the order of seconds or minutes due to the need to average many spectra to reach a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Here, we demonstrate high-speed, continuous, fiber mode-locked laser DCS with down to 11 $μ$s time resolution. We achieve this by filtering the comb spectra using portable Fabry-Perot cavities to generate filtered combs with 1 GHz tooth spacing. The 1 GHz spacing increases the DCS acquisition speed and SNR for a given optical bandwidth while retaining a sufficient spacing to resolve absorption features over a wide range of conditions. We measure spectra of methane inside a rapid compression machine throughout the 16 ms compression cycle with 133 cm$^{-1}$ bandwidth (4000 comb teeth) and 1.4 ms time resolution by spectrally filtering one of the combs. By filtering both combs, we measured a single-shot, 25 cm$^{-1}$ (750 comb teeth) spectrum of CO around 6330 cm$^{-1}$ in 11 $μ$s. The technique enables simultaneously high-speed and high-resolution DCS measurements, and can be applied anywhere within the octave-spanning spectrum of robust and portable fiber mode-locked frequency combs.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Analysis of Deep Complex-Valued Convolutional Neural Networks for MRI Reconstruction
Authors:
Elizabeth K. Cole,
Joseph Y. Cheng,
John M. Pauly,
Shreyas S. Vasanawala
Abstract:
Many real-world signal sources are complex-valued, having real and imaginary components. However, the vast majority of existing deep learning platforms and network architectures do not support the use of complex-valued data. MRI data is inherently complex-valued, so existing approaches discard the richer algebraic structure of the complex data. In this work, we investigate end-to-end complex-value…
▽ More
Many real-world signal sources are complex-valued, having real and imaginary components. However, the vast majority of existing deep learning platforms and network architectures do not support the use of complex-valued data. MRI data is inherently complex-valued, so existing approaches discard the richer algebraic structure of the complex data. In this work, we investigate end-to-end complex-valued convolutional neural networks - specifically, for image reconstruction in lieu of two-channel real-valued networks. We apply this to magnetic resonance imaging reconstruction for the purpose of accelerating scan times and determine the performance of various promising complex-valued activation functions. We find that complex-valued CNNs with complex-valued convolutions provide superior reconstructions compared to real-valued convolutions with the same number of trainable parameters, over a variety of network architectures and datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020; v1 submitted 3 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Baseline-free Quantitative Absorption Spectroscopy Based on Cepstral Analysis
Authors:
Ryan K. Cole,
Amanda S. Makowiecki,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
The accuracy of quantitative absorption spectroscopy depends on correctly distinguishing molecular absorption signatures in a measured transmission spectrum from the varying intensity or "baseline" of the light source. Baseline correction becomes particularly difficult when the measurement involves complex, broadly absorbing molecules or non-ideal transmission effects such as etalons. We demonstra…
▽ More
The accuracy of quantitative absorption spectroscopy depends on correctly distinguishing molecular absorption signatures in a measured transmission spectrum from the varying intensity or "baseline" of the light source. Baseline correction becomes particularly difficult when the measurement involves complex, broadly absorbing molecules or non-ideal transmission effects such as etalons. We demonstrate a technique that eliminates the need to account for the laser intensity in absorption spectroscopy by converting the measured transmission spectrum of a gas sample to a modified form of the time-domain molecular free induction decay (m-FID) using a cepstral analysis technique developed for audio signal processing. Much of the m-FID signal is temporally separated from and independent of the source intensity, and this portion can be fit directly with a model to determine sample gas properties without correcting for the light source intensity. We validate the new approach in several complex absorption spectroscopy scenarios and discuss its limitations. The technique is applicable to spectra obtained with any absorption spectrometer and provides a fast and accurate approach for analyzing complex spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2019; v1 submitted 27 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Broadband Dual Frequency Comb Spectroscopy in a Rapid Compression Machine
Authors:
Anthony D. Draper,
Ryan K. Cole,
Amanda S. Makowiecki,
Jeffrey Mohr,
Andrew Zdanawicz,
Anthony Marchese,
Nazanin Hoghooghi,
Gregory B. Rieker
Abstract:
We demonstrate fiber mode-locked dual frequency comb spectroscopy for broadband, high resolution measurements in a rapid compression machine (RCM). We apply an apodization technique to improve the short-term signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR), which enables broadband spectroscopy at combustion-relevant timescales. We measure the absorption on 24345 individual wavelength elements (comb teeth) between 5967…
▽ More
We demonstrate fiber mode-locked dual frequency comb spectroscopy for broadband, high resolution measurements in a rapid compression machine (RCM). We apply an apodization technique to improve the short-term signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR), which enables broadband spectroscopy at combustion-relevant timescales. We measure the absorption on 24345 individual wavelength elements (comb teeth) between 5967 and 6133 cm-1 at 704 microsecond time resolution during a 12-ms compression of a CH4-N2 mixture. We discuss the effect of the apodization technique on the absorption spectra, and apply an identical effect to the spectral model during fitting to recover the mixture temperature. The fitted temperature is compared against an adiabatic model, and found to be in good agreement with expected trends. This work demonstrates the potential of DCS to be used as an in situ diagnostic tool for broadband, high resolution, measurements in engine-like environments.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2018;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Auger decay of 1σg and 1σu hole states of N2 molecule: disentangling decay routes from coincidence measurements
Authors:
S. K. Semenov,
M. S. Schöffler,
J. Titze,
N. Petridis,
T. Jahnke,
K. Cole,
L. Ph. H. Schmidt,
A. Czasch,
D. Akoury,
O. Jagutzki,
J. B. Williams,
T. Osipov,
S. Lee,
M. H. Prior,
A. Belkacem,
A. L. Landers,
H. Schmidt-Böcking,
Th. Weber,
N. A. Cherepkov,
R. Dörner
Abstract:
Results of the most sophisticated measurements in coincidence of the angular resolved K-shell photo- and Auger-electrons, and of two atomic ions produced by dissociation of N2 molecule, are analyzed. Detection of photoelectrons at certain angles allows separating the Auger decay processes of the 1σg and 1σu core hole states. The Auger electron angular distributions for each of these hole states ar…
▽ More
Results of the most sophisticated measurements in coincidence of the angular resolved K-shell photo- and Auger-electrons, and of two atomic ions produced by dissociation of N2 molecule, are analyzed. Detection of photoelectrons at certain angles allows separating the Auger decay processes of the 1σg and 1σu core hole states. The Auger electron angular distributions for each of these hole states are measured as a function of the kinetic energy release of two atomic ions and are compared with the corresponding theoretical angular distributions. From that comparison one can disentangle the contributions of different repulsive doubly charged molecular ion states to the Auger decay. Different kinetic energy release values are directly related to the different internuclear distances. In this way one can trace experimentally the behavior of the potential energy curves of dicationic final states inside the Frank-Condon region. Presentation of the Auger electron angular distributions as a function of kinetic energy release of two atomic ions opens a new dimension in the study of Auger decay.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.