-
Physical Limits on Raman Scattering: The Critical Role of Pump and Signal Co-design
Authors:
Alessio Amaolo,
Pengning Chao,
Thomas J. Maldonado,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We present a rigorous method for deriving limits on Raman scattering in structured media. We exploit this framework to constrain the maximum Raman signal resulting from a planewave incident on two experimentally relevant systems, consisting of either a single Raman molecule in the vicinity of a structured medium or a designable Raman medium (a distribution of Raman molecules). Results pertaining t…
▽ More
We present a rigorous method for deriving limits on Raman scattering in structured media. We exploit this framework to constrain the maximum Raman signal resulting from a planewave incident on two experimentally relevant systems, consisting of either a single Raman molecule in the vicinity of a structured medium or a designable Raman medium (a distribution of Raman molecules). Results pertaining to metallic and dielectric structures illustrate the efficacy of structural optimization and the importance of accounting and co-designing for the nonlinear interplay between pump and signal fields. In particular, we show that treating the pump-focusing and signal-extraction processes separately, as has been done in prior works, leads to highly unrealistic predictions of achievable enhancements. The formulation could readily find applications in guiding further improvements on surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) sensitivity and Raman-assisted lasing.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Suppressing electromagnetic local density of states via slow light in lossy quasi-1d gratings
Authors:
Benjamin Strekha,
Pengning Chao,
Rodrick Kuate Defo,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We propose a spectral-averaging procedure that enables computation of bandwidth-integrated local density of states (LDOS) from a single scattering calculation, and exploit it to investigate the minimum extinction achievable from dipolar sources over finite bandwidths in structured media. Structure-agnostic extinction bounds are derived, providing analytical insights into scaling laws and fundament…
▽ More
We propose a spectral-averaging procedure that enables computation of bandwidth-integrated local density of states (LDOS) from a single scattering calculation, and exploit it to investigate the minimum extinction achievable from dipolar sources over finite bandwidths in structured media. Structure-agnostic extinction bounds are derived, providing analytical insights into scaling laws and fundamental design tradeoffs with implications to bandwidth and material selection. We find that perfect LDOS suppression over a finite bandwidth $Δω$ is impossible. Inspired by limits which predict nontrivial $\sqrt{Δω}$ scaling in systems with material dissipation, we show that pseudogap edge states of quasi-1d bullseye gratings can -- by simultaneously minimizing material absorption and radiation -- yield arbitrarily close to perfect LDOS suppression in the limit of vanishing bandwidth.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2024; v1 submitted 27 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Fundamental limits on $χ^{(2)}$ second harmonic generation
Authors:
Jewel Mohajan,
Pengning Chao,
Weiliang **,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Recent advances in fundamental performance limits for power quantities based on Lagrange duality are proving to be a powerful theoretical tool for understanding electromagnetic wave phenomena. To date, however, in any approach seeking to enforce a high degree of physical reality, the linearity of the wave equation plays a critical role. In this manuscript, we generalize the current quadratically c…
▽ More
Recent advances in fundamental performance limits for power quantities based on Lagrange duality are proving to be a powerful theoretical tool for understanding electromagnetic wave phenomena. To date, however, in any approach seeking to enforce a high degree of physical reality, the linearity of the wave equation plays a critical role. In this manuscript, we generalize the current quadratically constrained quadratic program framework for evaluating linear photonics limits to incorporate nonlinear processes under the undepleted pump approximation. Via the exemplary objective of enhancing second harmonic generation in a (free-form) wavelength-scale structure, we illustrate a model constraint scheme that can be used in conjunction with standard convex relaxations to bound performance in the presence of nonlinear dynamics. Representative bounds are found to anticipate features observed in optimized structures discovered via computational inverse design. The formulation can be straightforwardly modified to treat other frequency-conversion processes, including Raman scattering and four-wave mixing.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Can photonic heterostructures provably outperform single-material geometries?
Authors:
Alessio Amaolo,
Pengning Chao,
Thomas J. Maldonado,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Recent advances in photonic optimization have enabled calculation of performance bounds for a wide range of electromagnetic objectives, albeit restricted to single-material systems. Motivated by growing theoretical interest and fabrication advances, we present a framework to bound the performance of photonic heterostructures and apply it to investigate maximum absorption characteristics of multila…
▽ More
Recent advances in photonic optimization have enabled calculation of performance bounds for a wide range of electromagnetic objectives, albeit restricted to single-material systems. Motivated by growing theoretical interest and fabrication advances, we present a framework to bound the performance of photonic heterostructures and apply it to investigate maximum absorption characteristics of multilayer films and compact, free-form multi-material scatterers. Limits predict trends seen in topology-optimized geometries -- often coming within factors of two of specific designs -- and may be exploited in conjunction with inverse designs to predict when heterostructures are expected to outperform their optimal single-material counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2023; v1 submitted 2 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Maximum Electromagnetic Local Density of States via Material Structuring
Authors:
Pengning Chao,
Rodrick Kuate Defo,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro Rodriguez
Abstract:
The electromagnetic local density of states (LDOS) is crucial to many aspects of photonics engineering, from enhancing emission of photon sources to radiative heat transfer and photovoltaics. We present a framework for evaluating upper bounds on LDOS in structured media that can handle arbitrary bandwidths and accounts for critical wave scattering effects with no heuristic approximations. The boun…
▽ More
The electromagnetic local density of states (LDOS) is crucial to many aspects of photonics engineering, from enhancing emission of photon sources to radiative heat transfer and photovoltaics. We present a framework for evaluating upper bounds on LDOS in structured media that can handle arbitrary bandwidths and accounts for critical wave scattering effects with no heuristic approximations. The bounds are solely determined by the bandwidth, material susceptibility, and device footprint, with no assumptions on geometry. We derive an analytical expression for the maximum LDOS consistent with the conservation of energy across the entire design domain, which upon benchmarking with topology-optimized structures is shown to be nearly tight for large devices. Novel scaling laws for maximum LDOS enhancement are found: the bounds saturate to a finite value with increasing susceptibility and scale as the quartic root of the bandwidth for semi-infinite structures made of lossy materials, with direct implications on material selection and design applications.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2022; v1 submitted 18 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Trace Expressions and Associated Limits for Non-Equilibrium Casimir Torque
Authors:
Benjamin Strekha,
Sean Molesky,
Pengning Chao,
Matthias Krüger,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We exploit fluctuational electrodynamics to present trace expressions for the torque experienced by arbitrary objects in a passive, non-absorbing, rotationally invariant background environment. Specializing to a single object, this formalism, together with recently developed techniques for calculating bounds via Lagrange duality, is then used to derive limits on the maximum Casimir torque that a s…
▽ More
We exploit fluctuational electrodynamics to present trace expressions for the torque experienced by arbitrary objects in a passive, non-absorbing, rotationally invariant background environment. Specializing to a single object, this formalism, together with recently developed techniques for calculating bounds via Lagrange duality, is then used to derive limits on the maximum Casimir torque that a single object with an isotropic electric susceptibility can experience when out of equilibrium with its surrounding environment. The maximum torque achievable at any wavelength is shown to scale in proportion to body volumes in both subwavelength (quasistatics) and macroscopic (ray optics) settings, and come within an order of magnitude of achievable torques on topology optimized bodies. Finally, we discuss how to extend the formalism to multiple bodies, deriving expressions for the torque experienced by two subwavelength particles in proximity to one another.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Factors that control stability, variability, and reliability issues of endurance cycle in ReRAM devices: a phase field study
Authors:
Arijit Roy,
Min-Gyu Cho,
Pil-Ryung Cha
Abstract:
The morphological evolution of the conducting filament (CF) predominantly controls the electric response of the resistive random access memory (ReRAM) devices. However, the parameters -- in terms of the material and the processing -- which control the growth of such CF are plenty. Extending the phase field technique for ReRAM systems presented by Roy and Cha [J. Appl. Phys. 128, 205102 (2020)], we…
▽ More
The morphological evolution of the conducting filament (CF) predominantly controls the electric response of the resistive random access memory (ReRAM) devices. However, the parameters -- in terms of the material and the processing -- which control the growth of such CF are plenty. Extending the phase field technique for ReRAM systems presented by Roy and Cha [J. Appl. Phys. 128, 205102 (2020)], we could successfully model the complete SET (low resistance state) and RESET (high resistance state) sates due to the application of swee** voltage. The key parameters that influence the stability of the multi-cycle \emph{I-V} response or the endurance behavior are identified. The computational findings of the presented model ReRAM system are practical in correlating the multi-parametric influence with the stability, variability, and reliability of the endurance cycle that affect the device performance and also lead to the device failure. We believe that our computational approach of connecting the morphological changes of the CF with the electrical response, has the potential to further understand and optimize the performance of the ReRAM devices.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2022; v1 submitted 28 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Physical limits on electromagnetic response
Authors:
Pengning Chao,
Benjamin Strekha,
Rodrick Kuate Defo,
Sean Molesky,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Photonic devices play an increasingly important role in advancing physics and engineering, and while improvements in nanofabrication and computational methods have driven dramatic progress in expanding the range of achievable optical characteristics, they have also greatly increased design complexity. These developments have led to heightened relevance for the study of fundamental limits on optica…
▽ More
Photonic devices play an increasingly important role in advancing physics and engineering, and while improvements in nanofabrication and computational methods have driven dramatic progress in expanding the range of achievable optical characteristics, they have also greatly increased design complexity. These developments have led to heightened relevance for the study of fundamental limits on optical response. Here, we review recent progress in our understanding of these limits with special focus on an emerging theoretical framework that combines computational optimization with conservation laws to yield physical limits capturing all relevant wave effects. Results pertaining to canonical electromagnetic problems such as thermal emission, scattering cross sections, Purcell enhancement, and power routing are presented. Finally, we identify areas for additional research, including conceptual extensions and efficient numerical schemes for handling large-scale problems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Fully Implicit Spectral Boundary Integral Computation of Red Blood Cell Flow
Authors:
Pei Chuan Chao,
Ali Gürbüz,
Frederick Sachs,
M. V. Sivaselvan
Abstract:
An approach is presented for implicit time integration in computations of red blood cell flow by a spectral boundary integral method. The flow of a red cell in ambient fluid is represented as a boundary integral equation (BIE), whose structure is that of an implicit ordinary differential equation (IODE). The cell configuration and velocity field are discretized with spherical harmonics. The IODE i…
▽ More
An approach is presented for implicit time integration in computations of red blood cell flow by a spectral boundary integral method. The flow of a red cell in ambient fluid is represented as a boundary integral equation (BIE), whose structure is that of an implicit ordinary differential equation (IODE). The cell configuration and velocity field are discretized with spherical harmonics. The IODE is integrated in time using a multi-step implicit method based on backward difference formulas, with variable order and adaptive time-step** controlled by local truncation error and convergence of Newton iterations. Jacobians of the IODE, required for Newton's method, are implemented as Jacobian matrix-vector products that are nothing but directional derivatives. Their computation is facilitated by the weakly singular format of the BIE, and these matrix-vector products themselves amount to computing a second BIE. Numerical examples show that larger time steps are possible and that the number of matrix-vector products is comparable to explicit methods.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
$\mathbb{T}$-Operator Limits on Optical Communication: Metaoptics, Computation, and Input-Output Transformations
Authors:
Sean Molesky,
Pengning Chao,
Jewel Mohajan,
Wesley Reinhart,
Heng Chi,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We present an optimization framework based on Lagrange duality and the scattering $\mathbb{T}$ operator of electromagnetism to construct limits on the possible features that may be imparted to a collection of output fields from a collection of input fields, i.e., constraints on achievable optical transformations and the characteristics of structured materials as communication channels. Implication…
▽ More
We present an optimization framework based on Lagrange duality and the scattering $\mathbb{T}$ operator of electromagnetism to construct limits on the possible features that may be imparted to a collection of output fields from a collection of input fields, i.e., constraints on achievable optical transformations and the characteristics of structured materials as communication channels. Implications of these bounds on the performance of representative optical devices having multi-wavelength or multiport functionalities are examined in the context of electromagnetic shielding, focusing, near-field resolution, and linear computing.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Hierarchical Mean-Field $\mathbb{T}$ Operator Bounds on Electromagnetic Scattering: Upper Bounds on Near-Field Radiative Purcell Enhancement
Authors:
Sean Molesky,
Pengning Chao,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We show how the central equality of scattering theory, the definition of the $\mathbb{T}$ operator, can be used to generate hierarchies of mean-field constraints that act as natural complements to the standard electromagnetic design problem of optimizing some objective with respect to structural degrees of freedom. Proof-of-concept application to the problem of maximizing radiative Purcell enhance…
▽ More
We show how the central equality of scattering theory, the definition of the $\mathbb{T}$ operator, can be used to generate hierarchies of mean-field constraints that act as natural complements to the standard electromagnetic design problem of optimizing some objective with respect to structural degrees of freedom. Proof-of-concept application to the problem of maximizing radiative Purcell enhancement for a dipolar current source in the vicinity of a structured medium, an effect central to many sensing and quantum technologies, yields performance bounds that are frequently more than an order of magnitude tighter than all current frameworks, highlighting the irreality of these models in the presence of differing domain and field-localization length scales. Closely related to domain decomposition and multi-grid methods, similar constructions are possible in any branch of wave physics, paving the way for systematic evaluations of fundamental limits beyond electromagnetism.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Inverse-designed photon extractors for optically addressable defect qubits
Authors:
Srivatsa Chakravarthi,
Pengning Chao,
Christian Pederson,
Sean Molesky,
Andrew Ivanov,
Karine Hestroffer,
Fariba Hatami,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez,
Kai-Mei C. Fu
Abstract:
Solid-state defect qubit systems with spin-photon interfaces show great promise for quantum information and metrology applications. Photon collection efficiency, however, presents a major challenge for defect qubits in high refractive index host materials. Inverse-design optimization of photonic devices enables unprecedented flexibility in tailoring critical parameters of a spin-photon interface i…
▽ More
Solid-state defect qubit systems with spin-photon interfaces show great promise for quantum information and metrology applications. Photon collection efficiency, however, presents a major challenge for defect qubits in high refractive index host materials. Inverse-design optimization of photonic devices enables unprecedented flexibility in tailoring critical parameters of a spin-photon interface including spectral response, photon polarization and collection mode. Further, the design process can incorporate additional constraints, such as fabrication tolerance and material processing limitations. Here we design and demonstrate a compact hybrid gallium phosphide on diamond inverse-design planar dielectric structure coupled to single near-surface nitrogen-vacancy centers formed by implantation and annealing. We observe device operation near the theoretical limit and measure up to a 14-fold broadband enhancement in photon extraction efficiency. We expect that such inverse-designed devices will enable realization of scalable arrays of single-photon emitters, rapid characterization of new quantum emitters, sensing and efficient heralded entanglement schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2020; v1 submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Global $\mathbb{T}$ operator bounds on electromagnetic scattering: Upper bounds on far-field cross sections
Authors:
Sean Molesky,
Pengning Chao,
Weiliang **,
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
Abstract:
We present a method based on the scattering $\mathbb{T}$ operator, and conservation of net real and reactive power, to provide physical bounds on any electromagnetic design objective that can be framed as a net radiative emission, scattering or absorption process. Application of this approach to planewave scattering from an arbitrarily shaped, compact body of homogeneous electric susceptibility…
▽ More
We present a method based on the scattering $\mathbb{T}$ operator, and conservation of net real and reactive power, to provide physical bounds on any electromagnetic design objective that can be framed as a net radiative emission, scattering or absorption process. Application of this approach to planewave scattering from an arbitrarily shaped, compact body of homogeneous electric susceptibility $χ$ is found to predictively quantify and differentiate the relative performance of dielectric and metallic materials across all optical length scales. When the size of a device is restricted to be much smaller than the wavelength (a subwavelength cavity, antenna, nanoparticle, etc.), the maximum cross section enhancement that may be achieved via material structuring is found to be much weaker than prior predictions: the response of strong metals ($\mathrm{Re}[χ] < 0$) exhibits a diluted (homogenized) effective medium scaling $\propto |χ| / \mathrm{Im}[χ]$; below a threshold size inversely proportional to the index of refraction (consistent with the half-wavelength resonance condition), the maximum cross section enhancement possible with dielectrics ($\mathrm{Re}[χ] > 0$) shows the same material dependence as Rayleigh scattering. In the limit of a bounding volume much larger than the wavelength in all dimensions, achievable scattering interactions asymptote to the geometric area, as predicted by ray optics. For representative metal and dielectric materials, geometries capable of scattering power from an incident plane wave within an order of magnitude (typically a factor of two) of the bound are discovered by inverse design. The basis of the method rests entirely on scattering theory, and can thus likely be applied to acoustics, quantum mechanics, and other wave physics.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2020; v1 submitted 30 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Robust increase in supply by vessel dilation in globally coupled microvasculature
Authors:
Felix J. Meigel,
Peter Cha,
Michael P. Brenner,
Karen Alim
Abstract:
Neuronal activity induces changes in blood flow by locally dilating vessels in the brain microvasculature. How can the local dilation of a single vessel increase flow-based metabolite supply, given that flows are globally coupled within microvasculature? Solving the supply dynamics for rat brain microvasculature, we find one parameter regime to dominate physiologically. This regime allows for robu…
▽ More
Neuronal activity induces changes in blood flow by locally dilating vessels in the brain microvasculature. How can the local dilation of a single vessel increase flow-based metabolite supply, given that flows are globally coupled within microvasculature? Solving the supply dynamics for rat brain microvasculature, we find one parameter regime to dominate physiologically. This regime allows for robust increase in supply independent of the position in the network, which we explain analytically. We show that local coupling of vessels promotes spatially correlated increased supply by dilation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The Stochastic Replica Approach to Machine Learning: Stability and Parameter Optimization
Authors:
Patrick Chao,
Tahereh Mazaheri,
Bo Sun,
Nicholas B. Weingartner,
Zohar Nussinov
Abstract:
We introduce a statistical physics inspired supervised machine learning algorithm for classification and regression problems. The method is based on the invariances or stability of predicted results when known data is represented as expansions in terms of various stochastic functions. The algorithm predicts the classification/regression values of new data by combining (via voting) the outputs of t…
▽ More
We introduce a statistical physics inspired supervised machine learning algorithm for classification and regression problems. The method is based on the invariances or stability of predicted results when known data is represented as expansions in terms of various stochastic functions. The algorithm predicts the classification/regression values of new data by combining (via voting) the outputs of these numerous linear expansions in randomly chosen functions. The few parameters (typically only one parameter is used in all studied examples) that this model has may be automatically optimized. The algorithm has been tested on 10 diverse training data sets of various types and feature space dimensions. It has been shown to consistently exhibit high accuracy and readily allow for optimization of parameters, while simultaneously avoiding pitfalls of existing algorithms such as those associated with class imbalance. We very briefly speculate on whether spatial coordinates in physical theories may be viewed as emergent "features" that enable a robust machine learning type description of data with generic low order smooth functions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2018; v1 submitted 18 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.