Showing 1–50 of 55 results for author: Cassak, P

Simulation Models for Exploring Magnetic Reconnection

Authors: Michael Shay, Subash Adhikari, Naoki Beesho, Joachim Birn, Jorg Buechner, Paul Cassak, Li-Jen Chen, Yuxi Chen, Giulia Cozzani, Jim Drake, Fan Guo, Michael Hesse, Neeraj Jain, Yann Pfau-Kempf, Yu Lin, Yi-Hsin Liu, Mitsuo Oka, Yuri A. Omelchenko, Minna Palmroth, Oreste Pezzi, Patricia H. Reiff, Marc Swisdak, Frank Toffoletto, Gabor Toth, Richard A. Wolf

Abstract: Simulations have played a critical role in the advancement of our knowledge of magnetic reconnection. However, due to the inherently multiscale nature of reconnection, it is impossible to simulate all physics at all scales. For this reason, a wide range of simulation methods have been crafted to study particular aspects and consequences of magnetic reconnection. This chapter reviews many of these… ▽ More Simulations have played a critical role in the advancement of our knowledge of magnetic reconnection. However, due to the inherently multiscale nature of reconnection, it is impossible to simulate all physics at all scales. For this reason, a wide range of simulation methods have been crafted to study particular aspects and consequences of magnetic reconnection. This chapter reviews many of these methods, laying out critical assumptions, numerical techniques, and giving examples of scientific results. Plasma models described include magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), Hall MHD, Hybrid, kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC), kinetic Vlasov, Fluid models with embedded PIC, Fluid models with direct feedback from energetic populations, and the Rice Convection Model (RCM). △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: Chapter 5.2 of ISSI Book on Magnetic Reconnection, submitted to Space Science Reviews

Ohm's Law, the Reconnection Rate, and Energy Conversion in Collisionless Magnetic Reconnection

Authors: Yi-Hsin Liu, Michael Hesse, Kevin Genestreti, Rumi Nakamura, Jim Burch, Paul Cassak, Naoki Bessho, Jonathan Eastwood, Tai Phan, Marc Swisdak, Sergio Toledo-Redondo, Masahiro Hoshino, Cecilia Norgren, Hantao Ji, TKM Nakamura

Abstract: Magnetic reconnection is a ubiquitous plasma process that transforms magnetic energy into particle energy during eruptive events throughout the universe. Reconnection not only converts energy during solar flares and geomagnetic substorms that drive space weather near Earth, but it may also play critical roles in the high energy emissions from the magnetospheres of neutron stars and black holes. In… ▽ More Magnetic reconnection is a ubiquitous plasma process that transforms magnetic energy into particle energy during eruptive events throughout the universe. Reconnection not only converts energy during solar flares and geomagnetic substorms that drive space weather near Earth, but it may also play critical roles in the high energy emissions from the magnetospheres of neutron stars and black holes. In this review article, we focus on collisionless plasmas that are most relevant to reconnection in many space and astrophysical plasmas. Guided by first-principles kinetic simulations and spaceborne in-situ observations, we highlight the most recent progress in understanding this fundamental plasma process. We start by discussing the non-ideal electric field in the generalized Ohm's law that breaks the frozen-in flux condition in ideal magnetohydrodynamics and allows magnetic reconnection to occur. We point out that this same reconnection electric field also plays an important role in sustaining the current and pressure in the current sheet and then discuss the determination of its magnitude (i.e., the reconnection rate), based on force balance and energy conservation. This approach to determining the reconnection rate is applied to kinetic current sheets of a wide variety of magnetic geometries, parameters, and background conditions. We also briefly review the key diagnostics and modeling of energy conversion around the reconnection diffusion region, seeking insights from recently developed theories. Finally, future prospects and open questions are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: Submitted to Space Science Reviews. This is a review paper as an outcome of the 2022 Magnetic Reconnection Workshop in the International Space Science Institute

Higher-order nonequilibrium term: Effective power density quantifying evolution towards or away from local thermodynamic equilibrium

Authors: M. Hasan Barbhuiya, Paul A. Cassak, Subash Adhikari, Tulasi N. Parashar, Haoming Liang, Matthew R. Argall

Abstract: A common approach to assess the nature of energy conversion in a classical fluid or plasma is to compare power densities of the various possible energy conversion mechanisms. A forefront research area is quantifying energy conversion for systems that are not in local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), as is common in a number of fluid and plasma systems. Here, we introduce the ``higher-order non-equ… ▽ More A common approach to assess the nature of energy conversion in a classical fluid or plasma is to compare power densities of the various possible energy conversion mechanisms. A forefront research area is quantifying energy conversion for systems that are not in local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), as is common in a number of fluid and plasma systems. Here, we introduce the ``higher-order non-equilibrium term'' (HORNET) effective power density that quantifies the rate of change of departure of a phase space density from LTE. It has dimensions of power density, which allows for quantitative comparisons with standard power densities. We employ particle-in-cell simulations to calculate HORNET during two processes, namely magnetic reconnection and decaying kinetic turbulence in collisionless magnetized plasmas, that inherently produce non-LTE effects. We investigate the spatial variation of HORNET and the time evolution of its spatial average. By comparing HORNET with power densities describing changes to the internal energy (pressure dilatation, $\rm{Pi-D}$, and divergence of the vector heat flux density), we find that HORNET can be a significant fraction of these other measures (8\% and 35\% for electrons and ions, respectively, for reconnection; up to 67\% for both electrons and ions for turbulence), meaning evolution of the system towards or away from LTE can be dynamically important. Applications to numerous plasma phenomena are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 19 pages (including references), 7 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review E 109, 015205 (2024)

Unveiling plasma energization and energy transport in the Earth Magnetospheric System: the need for future coordinated multiscale observations

Authors: A. Retino, L. Kepko, H. Kucharek, M. F. Marcucci, R. Nakamura, T. Amano, V. Angelopoulos, S. D. Bale, D. Caprioli, P. Cassak, A. Chasapis, L. -J. Chen, L. Dai, M. W. Dunlop, C. Forsyth, H. Fu, A. Galvin, O. Le Contel, M. Yamauchi, L. Kistler, Y. Khotyaintsev, K. Klein, I. R. Mann, W. Matthaeus, K. Mouikis , et al. (9 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Energetic plasma is everywhere in the Universe. The terrestrial Magnetospheric System is a key case where direct measures of plasma energization and energy transport can be made in situ at high resolution. Despite the large amount of available observations, we still do not fully understand how plasma energization and energy transport work. Key physical processes driving much plasma energization an… ▽ More Energetic plasma is everywhere in the Universe. The terrestrial Magnetospheric System is a key case where direct measures of plasma energization and energy transport can be made in situ at high resolution. Despite the large amount of available observations, we still do not fully understand how plasma energization and energy transport work. Key physical processes driving much plasma energization and energy transport occur where plasma on fluid scales couple to the smaller ion kinetic scales. These scales (1 RE) are strongly related to the larger mesoscales (several RE) at which large-scale plasma energization and energy transport structures form. All these scales and processes need to be resolved experimentally, however existing multi-point in situ observations do not have a sufficient number of measurement points. New multiscale observations simultaneously covering scales from mesoscales to ion kinetic scales are needed. The implementation of these observations requires a strong international collaboration in the coming years between the major space agencies. The Plasma Observatory is a mission concept tailored to resolve scale coupling in plasma energization and energy transport at fluid and ion scales. It targets the two ESA-led Medium Mission themes Magnetospheric Systems and Plasma Cross-scale Coupling of the ESA Voyage 2050 report and is currently under evaluation as a candidate for the ESA M7 mission. MagCon (Magnetospheric Constellation) is a mission concept being studied by NASA aiming at studying the flow of mass, momentum, and energy through the Earth magnetosphere at mesoscales. Coordination between Plasma Observatory and MagCon missions would allow us for the first time to simultaneously cover from mesoscales to ion kinetic scales leading to a paradigm shift in the understanding of the Earth Magnetospheric System. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: A White Paper submitted for the Decadal Survey for Solar and Space Physics (Heliophysics) 2024-2033

Scale Filtering Analysis of Kinetic Reconnection and its Associated Turbulence

Authors: Subash Adhikari, Yan Yang, William H. Matthaeus, Paul A. Cassak, Tulasi N. Parashar, Michael A. Shay

Abstract: Previously, using an incompressible von Kármán-Howarth formalism, the behavior of cross-scale energy transfer in magnetic reconnection and turbulence was found to be essentially identical to each other, independent of an external magnetic (guide) field, in the inertial and energy-containing ranges (Adhikari et al., Phys. Plasmas 30, 082904, 2023). However, this description did not account for the… ▽ More Previously, using an incompressible von Kármán-Howarth formalism, the behavior of cross-scale energy transfer in magnetic reconnection and turbulence was found to be essentially identical to each other, independent of an external magnetic (guide) field, in the inertial and energy-containing ranges (Adhikari et al., Phys. Plasmas 30, 082904, 2023). However, this description did not account for the energy transfer in the dissipation range for kinetic plasmas. In this letter, we adopt a scale-filtering approach to investigate this previously unaccounted-for energy transfer channel in reconnection. Using kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations of antiparallel and component reconnection, we show that the pressure-strain (PS) interaction becomes important at scales smaller than the ion inertial length, where the nonlinear energy transfer term drops off. Also, the presence of a guide field makes a significant difference in the morphology of the scale-filtered energy transfer. These results are consistent with kinetic turbulence simulations, suggesting that the pressure strain interaction is the dominant energy transfer channel between electron scales and ion scales. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

The Importance of Heat Flux in Quasi-Parallel Collisionless Shocks

Authors: Colby C. Haggerty, Damiano Caprioli, Paul A. Cassak, M. Hasan Barbhuiya, Lynn Wilson III, Drew Turner

Abstract: Collisionless plasma shocks are a common feature of many space and astrophysical systems and are sources of high-energy particles and non-thermal emission, channeling as much as 20\% of the shock's energy into non-thermal particles. The generation and acceleration of these non-thermal particles have been extensively studied, however, how these particles feed back on the shock hydrodynamics has not… ▽ More Collisionless plasma shocks are a common feature of many space and astrophysical systems and are sources of high-energy particles and non-thermal emission, channeling as much as 20\% of the shock's energy into non-thermal particles. The generation and acceleration of these non-thermal particles have been extensively studied, however, how these particles feed back on the shock hydrodynamics has not been fully treated. This work presents the results of self-consistent hybrid particle-in-cell simulations that show the effect of self-generated non-thermal particle populations on the nature of collisionless, quasi-parallel shocks. They contribute to a significant heat flux density upstream of the shock. Non-thermal particles downstream of the shock leak into the upstream region, taking energy away from the shock. This increases the compression ratio, slows the shock down, and flattens the non-thermal population's spectral index for lower Mach number shocks. We incorporate this into a revised theory for the Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions that include this effect and it shows excellent agreement with simulations. The results have the potential to explain discrepancies between predictions and observations in a wide range of systems, such as inaccuracies of predictions of arrival times of coronal mass ejections and the conflicting radio and x-ray observations of intracluster shocks. These effects will likely need to be included in fluid modeling to accurately predict shock evolution. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, a lot of appendix

Quantifying Energy Conversion in Higher Order Phase Space Density Moments in Plasmas

Authors: Paul A. Cassak, M. Hasan Barbhuiya, Haoming Liang, Matthew R. Argall

Abstract: Weakly collisional and collisionless plasmas are typically far from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), and understanding energy conversion in such systems is a forefront research problem. The standard approach is to investigate changes in internal (thermal) energy and density, but this omits energy conversion that changes any higher order moments of the phase space density. In this study, we c… ▽ More Weakly collisional and collisionless plasmas are typically far from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), and understanding energy conversion in such systems is a forefront research problem. The standard approach is to investigate changes in internal (thermal) energy and density, but this omits energy conversion that changes any higher order moments of the phase space density. In this study, we calculate from first principles the energy conversion associated with all higher moments of the phase space density for systems not in LTE. Particle-in-cell simulations of collisionless magnetic reconnection reveal that energy conversion associated with higher order moments can be locally significant. The results may be useful in numerous plasma settings, such as reconnection, turbulence, shocks, and wave-particle interactions in heliospheric, planetary, and astrophysical plasmas. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures, includes both main paper and supplementary material

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters, 130, 085201 (2023) (Editor's Suggestion)

Statistics of Pressure Fluctuations in Turbulent Kinetic Plasmas

Authors: Subash Adhikari, William H. Matthaeus, Tulasi N. Parashar, Michael A. Shay, Paul A. Cassak

Abstract: In this study we explore the statistics of pressure fluctuations in kinetic collisionless turbulence. A 2.5D kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation of decaying turbulence is used to investigate pressure balance via the evolution of thermal and magnetic pressure in a plasma with beta of order unity. We also discuss the behavior of thermal, magnetic and total pressure structure functions and thei… ▽ More In this study we explore the statistics of pressure fluctuations in kinetic collisionless turbulence. A 2.5D kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation of decaying turbulence is used to investigate pressure balance via the evolution of thermal and magnetic pressure in a plasma with beta of order unity. We also discuss the behavior of thermal, magnetic and total pressure structure functions and their corresponding wavenumber spectra. The total pressure spectrum exhibits a slope of -7/3 extending for about a decade in the ion-inertial range. In contrast, shallower -5/3 spectra are characteristic of the magnetic pressure and thermal pressure. The steeper total pressure spectrum is a consequence of cancellation caused by density-magnetic field magnitude anticorrelation. Further, we evaluate higher order total pressure structure functions in an effort to discuss intermittency and compare the power exponents with higher order structure functions of velocity and magnetic fluctuations. Finally, applications to astrophysical systems are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: Submitted to MNRAS

Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection Spreading in Current Sheets of Non-Uniform Thickness

Authors: Milton Arencibia, P. A. Cassak, M. A. Shay, Jiong Qiu, Steven M. Petrinec, Haoming Liang

Abstract: Magnetic reconnection in naturally occurring and laboratory settings often begins locally and elongates, or spreads, in the direction perpendicular to the plane of reconnection. Previous work has largely focused on current sheets with a uniform thickness, for which the predicted spreading speed for anti-parallel reconnection is the local speed of the current carriers. We derive a scaling theory of… ▽ More Magnetic reconnection in naturally occurring and laboratory settings often begins locally and elongates, or spreads, in the direction perpendicular to the plane of reconnection. Previous work has largely focused on current sheets with a uniform thickness, for which the predicted spreading speed for anti-parallel reconnection is the local speed of the current carriers. We derive a scaling theory of three-dimensional (3D) spreading of collisionless anti-parallel reconnection in a current sheet with its thickness varying in the out-of-plane direction, both for spreading from a thinner to thicker region and a thicker to thinner region. We derive an expression for calculating the time it takes for spreading to occur for a current sheet with a given profile of its thickness. A key result is that when reconnection spreads from a thinner to a thicker region, the spreading speed in the thicker region is slower than both the Alfvén speed and the speed of the local current carriers by a factor of the ratio of thin to thick current sheet thicknesses. This is important because magnetospheric and solar observations have previously measured the spreading speed to be slower than previously predicted, so the present mechanism might explain this feature. We confirm the theory via a parametric study using 3D two-fluid numerical simulations. We use the prediction to calculate the time scale for reconnection spreading in Earth's magnetotail during geomagnetic activity. The results are also potentially important for understanding reconnection spreading in solar flares and the dayside magnetopause of Earth and other planets. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Accepted to JGR - Space Physics, March 2, 2023

Pressure-Strain Interaction: II. Decomposition in Magnetic Field-Aligned Coordinates

Authors: Paul A. Cassak, M. Hasan Barbhuiya, H. Arthur Weldon

Abstract: In weakly collisional and collisionless magnetized plasmas, the pressure-strain interaction describes the rate of conversion between bulk flow and thermal energy density. In this study, we derive an analytical expression for the pressure-strain interaction in a coordinate system with an axis aligned with the local magnetic field. The result is eight groups of terms corresponding to different physi… ▽ More In weakly collisional and collisionless magnetized plasmas, the pressure-strain interaction describes the rate of conversion between bulk flow and thermal energy density. In this study, we derive an analytical expression for the pressure-strain interaction in a coordinate system with an axis aligned with the local magnetic field. The result is eight groups of terms corresponding to different physical mechanisms that can contribute to the pressure-strain interaction. We provide a physical description of each term. The results are immediately of interest to weakly collisional and collisionless magnetized plasmas and the fundamental processes that happen therein, including magnetic reconnection, magnetized plasma turbulence, and collisionless shocks. The terms in the field-aligned coordinate decomposition are likely accessible to measurement with satellite observations. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 1 figure, accepted to Physics of Plasmas

Pressure-Strain Interaction: I. On Compression, Deformation, and Implications For Pi-D

Authors: Paul A. Cassak, M. Hasan Barbhuiya

Abstract: The pressure-strain interaction describes the rate per unit volume that energy is converted between bulk flow and thermal energy in neutral fluids or plasmas. The term has been written as a sum of the pressure dilatation and the collisionless analogue of viscous heating referred to as ${\rm Pi-D}$, which isolates the power density due to compressible and incompressible effects, respectively. It ha… ▽ More The pressure-strain interaction describes the rate per unit volume that energy is converted between bulk flow and thermal energy in neutral fluids or plasmas. The term has been written as a sum of the pressure dilatation and the collisionless analogue of viscous heating referred to as ${\rm Pi-D}$, which isolates the power density due to compressible and incompressible effects, respectively. It has been shown that ${\rm Pi-D}$ can be negative, which makes its identification as collisionless viscous heating troubling. We argue that an alternate decomposition of pressure-strain interaction can be useful for interpreting the underlying physics. Since ${\rm Pi-D}$ contains both normal deformation and shear deformation, we propose grou** the normal deformation with the pressure dilatation to describe the power density due to converging/diverging flows, with the balance describing the power density purely due to shear deformation. We then develop a kinetic theory interpretation of compression, normal deformation, and shear deformation. We use the results to determine the physical mechanisms that can make ${\rm Pi-D}$ negative. We argue that both decompositions can be useful for the study of energy conversion in weakly collisional or collisionless fluids and plasmas, and implications are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 16 pages, 4 figures, accepted to Physics of Plasmas

Pressure-Strain Interaction: III. Particle-in-Cell Simulations of Magnetic Reconnection

Authors: M. Hasan Barbhuiya, Paul A. Cassak

Abstract: How energy is converted into thermal energy in weakly collisional and collisionless plasma processes such as magnetic reconnection and plasma turbulence has recently been the subject of intense scrutiny. The pressure-strain interaction has emerged as an important piece, as it describes the rate of conversion between bulk flow and thermal energy density. In two companion studies, we presented an al… ▽ More How energy is converted into thermal energy in weakly collisional and collisionless plasma processes such as magnetic reconnection and plasma turbulence has recently been the subject of intense scrutiny. The pressure-strain interaction has emerged as an important piece, as it describes the rate of conversion between bulk flow and thermal energy density. In two companion studies, we presented an alternate decomposition of the pressure-strain interaction to isolate the effects of converging/diverging flow and flow shear instead of compressible and incompressible flow, and we derived the pressure-strain interaction in magnetic field-aligned coordinates. Here, we use these results to study pressure-strain interaction during two-dimensional anti-parallel magnetic reconnection. We perform particle-in-cell simulations and plot the decompositions in both Cartesian and magnetic field-aligned coordinates. We identify the mechanisms contributing to positive and negative pressure-strain interaction during reconnection. This study provides a roadmap for interpreting numerical and observational data of the pressure-strain interaction, which should be important for studies of reconnection, turbulence, and collisionless shocks. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 7 figures, accepted to Physics of Plasmas

Advancing Theory and Modeling Efforts in Heliophysics

Authors: Fan Guo, Spiro Antiochos, Paul Cassak, Bin Chen, Xiaohang Chen, Chuanfei Dong, Cooper Downs, Joe Giacalone, Colby C. Haggerty, Hantao Ji, Judith Karpen, James Klimchuk, Wen Li, Xiaocan Li, Mitsuo Oka, Katharine K. Reeves, Marc Swisdak, Weichao Tu

Abstract: Heliophysics theory and modeling build understanding from fundamental principles to motivate, interpret, and predict observations. Together with observational analysis, they constitute a comprehensive scientific program in heliophysics. As observations and data analysis become increasingly detailed, it is critical that theory and modeling develop more quantitative predictions and iterate with obse… ▽ More Heliophysics theory and modeling build understanding from fundamental principles to motivate, interpret, and predict observations. Together with observational analysis, they constitute a comprehensive scientific program in heliophysics. As observations and data analysis become increasingly detailed, it is critical that theory and modeling develop more quantitative predictions and iterate with observations. Advanced theory and modeling can inspire and greatly improve the design of new instruments and increase their chance of success. In addition, in order to build physics-based space weather forecast models, it is important to keep develo** and testing new theories, and maintaining constant communications with theory and modeling. Maintaining a sustainable effort in theory and modeling is critically important to heliophysics. We recommend that all funding agencies join forces and consider expanding current and creating new theory and modeling programs--especially, 1. NASA should restore the HTMS program to its original support level to meet the critical needs of heliophysics science; 2. a Strategic Research Model program needs to be created to support model development for next-generation basic research codes; 3. new programs must be created for addressing mission-critical theory and modeling needs; and 4. enhanced programs are urgently required for training the next generation of theorists and modelers. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: White paper submitted to Heliophysics 2024 Decadal Survey

Scaling of electron heating by magnetization during reconnection and applications to dipolarization fronts and super-hot solar flares

Authors: M. Hasan Barbhuiya, Paul. A. Cassak, Michael. A. Shay, Vadim Roytershteyn, Marc Swisdak, Amir Caspi, Andrei Runov, Haoming Liang

Abstract: Electron ring velocity space distributions have previously been seen in numerical simulations of magnetic reconnection exhausts and have been suggested to be caused by the magnetization of the electron outflow jet by the compressed reconnected magnetic fields [Shuster et al., ${\it Geophys.~Res.~Lett.}, {\bf 41}$, 5389 (2014)]. We present a theory of the dependence of the major and minor radii of… ▽ More Electron ring velocity space distributions have previously been seen in numerical simulations of magnetic reconnection exhausts and have been suggested to be caused by the magnetization of the electron outflow jet by the compressed reconnected magnetic fields [Shuster et al., ${\it Geophys.~Res.~Lett.}, {\bf 41}$, 5389 (2014)]. We present a theory of the dependence of the major and minor radii of the ring distributions solely in terms of upstream (lobe) plasma conditions, thereby allowing a prediction of the associated temperature and temperature anisotropy of the rings in terms of upstream parameters. We test the validity of the prediction using 2.5-dimensional particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations with varying upstream plasma density and temperature, finding excellent agreement between the predicted and simulated values. We confirm the Shuster et al. suggestion for the cause of the ring distributions, and also find that the ring distributions are located in a region marked by a plateau, or shoulder, in the reconnected magnetic field profile. The predictions of the temperature are consistent with observed electron temperatures in dipolarization fronts, and may provide an explanation for the generation of plasma with temperatures in the 10s of MK in super-hot solar flares. A possible extension of the model to dayside reconnection is discussed. Since ring distributions are known to excite whistler waves, the present results should be useful for quantifying the generation of whistler waves in reconnection exhausts. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics

Journal ref: Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, Vol. 127, Issue 8, e2022JA030610 (22pp); 2022 August 08

First-Principles Theory of the Rate of Magnetic Reconnection in Magnetospheric and Solar Plasmas

Authors: Yi-Hsin Liu, Paul Cassak, Xiaocan Li, Michael Hesse, Shan-Chang Lin, Kevin Genestreti

Abstract: The rate of magnetic reconnection is of the utmost importance in a variety of processes because it controls, for example, the rate energy is released in solar flares, the speed of the Dungey convection cycle in Earth's magnetosphere, and the energy release rate in harmful geomagnetic substorms. It is known from numerical simulations and satellite observations that the rate is approximately 0.1 in… ▽ More The rate of magnetic reconnection is of the utmost importance in a variety of processes because it controls, for example, the rate energy is released in solar flares, the speed of the Dungey convection cycle in Earth's magnetosphere, and the energy release rate in harmful geomagnetic substorms. It is known from numerical simulations and satellite observations that the rate is approximately 0.1 in normalized units, but despite years of effort, a full theoretical prediction has not been obtained. Here, we present a first-principles theory for the reconnection rate in non-relativistic electron-ion collisionless plasmas, and show that the same prediction explains why Sweet-Parker reconnection is considerably slower. The key consideration of this analysis is the pressure at the reconnection site (i.e., the x-line). We show that the Hall electromagnetic fields in antiparallel reconnection cause an energy void, equivalently a pressure depletion, at the x-line, so the reconnection exhaust opens out, enabling the fast rate of 0.1. If the energy can reach the x-line to replenish the pressure, the exhaust does not open out. In addition to heliospheric applications, these results are expected to impact reconnection studies in planetary magnetospheres, magnetically confined fusion devices, and astrophysical plasmas. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 4 figures, accepted in Communications Physics

Scaling Theory of 3D Magnetic Reconnection Spreading

Authors: Milton Arencibia, Paul A. Cassak, Michael A. Shay, Eric R. Priest

Abstract: We develop a first-principles scaling theory of the spreading of three-dimensional (3D) magnetic reconnection of finite extent in the out of plane direction. This theory addresses systems with or without an out of plane (guide) magnetic field, and with or without Hall physics. The theory reproduces known spreading speeds and directions with and without guide fields, unifying previous knowledge in… ▽ More We develop a first-principles scaling theory of the spreading of three-dimensional (3D) magnetic reconnection of finite extent in the out of plane direction. This theory addresses systems with or without an out of plane (guide) magnetic field, and with or without Hall physics. The theory reproduces known spreading speeds and directions with and without guide fields, unifying previous knowledge in a single theory. New results include: (1) Reconnection spreads in a particular direction if an x-line is induced at the interface between reconnecting and non-reconnecting regions, which is controlled by the out of plane gradient of the electric field in the outflow direction. (2) The spreading mechanism for anti-parallel collisionless reconnection is convection, as is known, but for guide field reconnection it is magnetic field bending. We confirm the theory using 3D two-fluid and resistive-magnetohydrodynamics simulations. (3) The theory explains why anti-parallel reconnection in resistive-magnetohydrodynamics does not spread. (4) The simulation domain aspect ratio, associated with the free magnetic energy, influences whether reconnection spreads or convects with a fixed x-line length. (5) We perform a simulation initiating anti-parallel collisionless reconnection with a pressure pulse instead of a magnetic perturbation, finding spreading is unchanged rather than spreading at the magnetosonic speed as previously suggested. The results provide a theoretical framework for understanding spreading beyond systems studied here, and are important for applications including two-ribbon solar flares and reconnection in Earth's magnetosphere. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: Accepted in AIP Physics of Plasmas, appearing in Volume #: 28, Issue #: 8, Issue: 2021-08-02. Ref. POP21-AR-00492

Dissipation measures in weakly-collisional plasmas

Authors: O. Pezzi, H. Liang, J. L. Juno, P. A. Cassak, C. L. Vasconez, L. Sorriso-Valvo, D. Perrone, S. Servidio, V. Roytershteyn, J. M. TenBarge, W. H. Matthaeus

Abstract: The physical foundations of the dissipation of energy and the associated heating in weakly collisional plasmas are poorly understood. Here, we compare and contrast several measures that have been used to characterize energy dissipation and kinetic-scale conversion in plasmas by means of a suite of kinetic numerical simulations describing both magnetic reconnection and decaying plasma turbulence. W… ▽ More The physical foundations of the dissipation of energy and the associated heating in weakly collisional plasmas are poorly understood. Here, we compare and contrast several measures that have been used to characterize energy dissipation and kinetic-scale conversion in plasmas by means of a suite of kinetic numerical simulations describing both magnetic reconnection and decaying plasma turbulence. We adopt three different numerical codes that can also include interparticle collisions: the fully kinetic particle-in-cell VPIC, the fully kinetic continuum Gkeyll, and the Eulerian Hybrid Vlasov-Maxwell (HVM) code. We differentiate between (i) four energy-based parameters, whose definition is related to energy transfer in a fluid description of a plasma, and (ii) four distribution function-based parameters, requiring knowledge of the particle velocity distribution function. There is an overall agreement between the dissipation measures obtained in the PIC and continuum reconnection simulations, with slight differences due to the presence/absence of secondary islands in the two simulations. There are also many qualitative similarities between the signatures in the reconnection simulations and the self-consistent current sheets that form in turbulence, although the latter exhibits significant variations compared to the reconnection results. All the parameters confirm that dissipation occurs close to regions of intense magnetic stresses, thus exhibiting local correlation. The distribution function-based measures show a broader width compared to energy-based proxies, suggesting that energy transfer is co-localized at coherent structures, but can affect the particle distribution function in wider regions. The effect of interparticle collisions on these parameters is finally discussed. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2021; v1 submitted 3 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication on MNRAS

Journal ref: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 505(4), 4857-4873 (2021)

Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena in Solar and Heliospheric Plasmas

Authors: H. Ji, J. Karpen, A. Alt, S. Antiochos, S. Baalrud, S. Bale, P. M. Bellan, M. Begelman, A. Beresnyak, A. Bhattacharjee, E. G. Blackman, D. Brennan, M. Brown, J. Buechner, J. Burch, P. Cassak, B. Chen, L. -J. Chen, Y. Chen, A. Chien, L. Comisso, D. Craig, J. Dahlin, W. Daughton, E. DeLuca , et al. (83 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagen… ▽ More Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagency/international partnerships, and close collaborations of the solar, heliospheric, and laboratory plasma communities. These investments will deliver transformative progress in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena including space weather events. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 4 pages (including a title page), white paper submitted to Helio2050 workshop at https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/helio2050/. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2004.00079

Kinetic Entropy-Based Measures of Distribution Function Non-Maxwellianity: Theory and Simulations

Authors: Haoming Liang, M. Hasan Barbhuiya, P. A. Cassak, O. Pezzi, S. Servidio, F. Valentini, G. P. Zank

Abstract: We investigate kinetic entropy-based measures of the non-Maxwellianity of distribution functions in plasmas, i.e., entropy-based measures of the departure of a local distribution function from an associated Maxwellian distribution function with the same density, bulk flow, and temperature as the local distribution. First, we consider a form previously employed by Kaufmann and Paterson [{\it J.~Geo… ▽ More We investigate kinetic entropy-based measures of the non-Maxwellianity of distribution functions in plasmas, i.e., entropy-based measures of the departure of a local distribution function from an associated Maxwellian distribution function with the same density, bulk flow, and temperature as the local distribution. First, we consider a form previously employed by Kaufmann and Paterson [{\it J.~Geophys.~Res.,} {\bf 114}, A00D04 (2009)], assessing its properties and deriving equivalent forms. To provide a quantitative understanding of it, we derive analytical expressions for three common non-Maxwellian plasma distribution functions. We show that there are undesirable features of this non-Maxwellianity measure including that it can diverge in various physical limits and elucidate the reason for the divergence. We then introduce a new kinetic entropy-based non-Maxwellianity measure based on the velocity-space kinetic entropy density, which has a meaningful physical interpretation and does not diverge. We use collisionless particle-in-cell simulations of two-dimensional anti-parallel magnetic reconnection to assess the kinetic entropy-based non-Maxwellianity measures. We show that regions of non-zero non-Maxwellianity are linked to kinetic processes occurring during magnetic reconnection. We also show the simulated non-Maxwellianity agrees reasonably well with predictions for distributions resembling those calculated analytically. These results can be important for applications, as non-Maxwellianity can be used to identify regions of kinetic-scale physics or increased dissipation in plasmas. △ Less

Submitted 15 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 29 pages, 9 figures

Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena throughout the Universe

Authors: H. Ji, A. Alt, S. Antiochos, S. Baalrud, S. Bale, P. M. Bellan, M. Begelman, A. Beresnyak, E. G. Blackman, D. Brennan, M. Brown, J. Buechner, J. Burch, P. Cassak, L. -J. Chen, Y. Chen, A. Chien, D. Craig, J. Dahlin, W. Daughton, E. DeLuca, C. F. Dong, S. Dorfman, J. Drake, F. Ebrahimi , et al. (75 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process. This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure, white paper submitted to both Plasma 2020 and Astro 2020 Decadal Surveys

Decomposition of Plasma Kinetic Entropy into Position and Velocity Space and the Use of Kinetic Entropy in Particle-in-Cell Simulations

Authors: Haoming Liang, Paul A. Cassak, Sergio Servidio, Michael A. Shay, James F. Drake, Marc Swisdak, Matt R. Argall, John C. Dorelli, Earl E. Scime, William H. Matthaeus, Vadim Roytershteyn, Gian Luca Delzanno

Abstract: We describe a systematic development of kinetic entropy as a diagnostic in fully kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations and use it to interpret plasma physics processes in heliospheric, planetary, and astrophysical systems. First, we calculate kinetic entropy in two forms -- the ``combinatorial'' form related to the logarithm of the number of microstates per macrostate and the ``continuous'' f… ▽ More We describe a systematic development of kinetic entropy as a diagnostic in fully kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations and use it to interpret plasma physics processes in heliospheric, planetary, and astrophysical systems. First, we calculate kinetic entropy in two forms -- the ``combinatorial'' form related to the logarithm of the number of microstates per macrostate and the ``continuous'' form related to $f \ln f$, where $f$ is the particle distribution function. We discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each and discuss subtleties about implementing them in PIC codes. Using collisionless PIC simulations that are two-dimensional in position space and three-dimensional in velocity space, we verify the implementation of the kinetic entropy diagnostics and discuss how to optimize numerical parameters to ensure accurate results. We show the total kinetic entropy is conserved to three percent in an optimized simulation of anti-parallel magnetic reconnection. Kinetic entropy can be decomposed into a sum of a position space entropy and a velocity space entropy, and we use this to investigate the nature of kinetic entropy transport during collisionless reconnection. We find the velocity space entropy of both electrons and ions increases in time due to plasma heating during magnetic reconnection, while the position space entropy decreases due to plasma compression. This project uses collisionless simulations, so it cannot address physical dissipation mechanisms; nonetheless, the infrastructure developed here should be useful for studies of collisional or weakly collisional heliospheric, planetary, and astrophysical systems. Beyond reconnection, the diagnostic is expected to be applicable to plasma turbulence and collisionless shocks. △ Less

Submitted 23 August, 2019; v1 submitted 7 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 20 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Physics of Plasmas 26, 082903 (2019)

Transition from ion-coupled to electron-only reconnection: Basic physics and implications for plasma turbulence

Authors: P. Sharma Pyakurel, M. A. Shay, T. D. Phan, W. H. Matthaeus, J. F. Drake, J. M. TenBarge, C. C. Haggerty, K. Klein, P. A. Cassak, T. N. Parashar, M. Swisdak, A. Chasapis

Abstract: Using kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations, we simulate reconnection conditions appropriate for the magnetosheath and solar wind, i.e., plasma beta (ratio of gas pressure to magnetic pressure) greater than 1 and low magnetic shear (strong guide field). Changing the simulation domain size, we find that the ion response varies greatly. For reconnecting regions with scales comparable to the ion… ▽ More Using kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations, we simulate reconnection conditions appropriate for the magnetosheath and solar wind, i.e., plasma beta (ratio of gas pressure to magnetic pressure) greater than 1 and low magnetic shear (strong guide field). Changing the simulation domain size, we find that the ion response varies greatly. For reconnecting regions with scales comparable to the ion Larmor radius, the ions do not respond to the reconnection dynamics leading to ''electron-only'' reconnection with very large quasi-steady reconnection rates. The transition to more traditional ''ion-coupled'' reconnection is gradual as the reconnection domain size increases, with the ions becoming frozen-in in the exhaust when the magnetic island width in the normal direction reaches many ion inertial lengths. During this transition, the quasi-steady reconnection rate decreases until the ions are fully coupled, ultimately reaching an asymptotic value. The scaling of the ion outflow velocity with exhaust width during this electron-only to ion-coupled transition is found to be consistent with a theoretical model of a newly reconnected field line. In order to have a fully frozen-in ion exhaust with ion flows comparable to the reconnection Alfvén speed, an exhaust width of at least several ion inertial lengths is needed. In turbulent systems with reconnection occurring between magnetic bubbles associated with fluctuations, using geometric arguments we estimate that fully ion-coupled reconnection requires magnetic bubble length scales of at least several tens of ion inertial lengths. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

The Reduction of Magnetic Reconnection Outflow Jets to Sub-Alfvénic Speeds

Authors: Colby C. Haggerty, Michael A. Shay, Alexandros Chasapis, Tai D. Phan, James F. Drake, Kittipat Malakit, Paul A. Cassak, Rungployphan Kieokaew

Abstract: The outflow velocity of jets produced by collisionless magnetic reconnection is shown to be reduced by the ion exhaust temperature in simulations and observations. We derive a scaling relationship for the outflow velocity based on the upstream Alfvén speed and the parallel ion exhaust temperature, which is verified in kinetic simulations and observations. The outflow speed reduction is shown to be… ▽ More The outflow velocity of jets produced by collisionless magnetic reconnection is shown to be reduced by the ion exhaust temperature in simulations and observations. We derive a scaling relationship for the outflow velocity based on the upstream Alfvén speed and the parallel ion exhaust temperature, which is verified in kinetic simulations and observations. The outflow speed reduction is shown to be due to the firehose instability criterion, and so for large enough guide fields this effect is suppressed and the outflow speed reaches the upstream Alfvén speed based on the reconnecting component of the magnetic field. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Assessing the time dependence of reconnection with Poynting's theorem: MMS observations

Authors: Kevin J. Genestreti, Paul A. Cassak, Ali Varsani, James L. Burch, Rumi Nakamura, Shan Wang

Abstract: We investigate the time dependence of electromagnetic-field-to-plasma energy conversion in the electron diffusion region of asymmetric magnetic reconnection. To do so, we consider the terms in Poynting's theorem. In a steady state there is a perfect balance between the divergence of the electromagnetic energy flux $\nabla \cdot \vec{S}$ and the conversion between electromagnetic field and particle… ▽ More We investigate the time dependence of electromagnetic-field-to-plasma energy conversion in the electron diffusion region of asymmetric magnetic reconnection. To do so, we consider the terms in Poynting's theorem. In a steady state there is a perfect balance between the divergence of the electromagnetic energy flux $\nabla \cdot \vec{S}$ and the conversion between electromagnetic field and particle energy $\vec{J} \cdot \vec{E}$. This energy balance is demonstrated with a particle-in-cell simulation of reconnection. We also evaluate each of the terms in Poynting's theorem during an observation of a magnetopause reconnection region by Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS). We take the equivalence of both sides of Poynting's theorem as an indication that the errors associated with the approximation of each term with MMS data are small. We find that, for this event, balance between $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}=-\nabla\cdot\vec{S}$ is only achieved for a small fraction of the energy conversion region at/near the X-point. Magnetic energy was rapidly accumulating on either side of the current sheet at roughly three times the predicted energy conversion rate. Furthermore, we find that while $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}>0$ and $\nabla\cdot\vec{S}<0$ are observed, as is expected for reconnection, the energy accumulation is driven by the overcompensation for $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}$ by $-\nabla\cdot\vec{S}>\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}$. We note that due to the assumptions necessary to do this calculation, the accurate evaluation of $\nabla\cdot\vec{S}$ may not be possible for every MMS-observed reconnection event; but if possible, this is a simple approach to determine if reconnection is or is not in a steady-state. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2018; v1 submitted 31 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: Resubmitted to GRL after minor rev. on 1 February 2018

Localized Oscillatory Dissipation in Magnetopause Reconnection

Authors: J. L. Burch, R. E. Ergun, P. A. Cassak, J. M. Webster, R. B. Torbert, B. L. Giles, J. C. Dorelli, A. C. Rager, K. -J. Hwang, T. D. Phan, K. J. Genestreti, R. C. Allen, L. -J. Chen, S. Wang, D. Gershman, O. Le Contel, C. T. Russell, R. J. Strangeway, F. D. Wilder, D. B. Graham, M. Hesse, J. F. Drake, M. Swisdak, L. M. Price, M. A. Shay , et al. (4 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Data from the NASA Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission are used to investigate asymmetric magnetic reconnection at the dayside boundary between the Earth's magnetosphere and the solar wind (the magnetopause). High-resolution measurements of plasmas, electric and magnetic fields, and waves are used to identify highly localized (~15 electron Debye lengths) standing wave structures with large ele… ▽ More Data from the NASA Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission are used to investigate asymmetric magnetic reconnection at the dayside boundary between the Earth's magnetosphere and the solar wind (the magnetopause). High-resolution measurements of plasmas, electric and magnetic fields, and waves are used to identify highly localized (~15 electron Debye lengths) standing wave structures with large electric-field amplitudes (up to 100 mV/m). These wave structures are associated with spatially oscillatory dissipation, which appears as alternatingly positive and negative values of J dot E (dissipation). For small guide magnetic fields the wave structures occur in the electron stagnation region at the magnetosphere edge of the EDR. For larger guide fields the structures also occur near the reconnection x-line. This difference is explained in terms of channels for the out-of-plane current (agyrotropic electrons at the stagnation point and guide-field-aligned electrons at the x-line). △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

MMS observation of asymmetric reconnection supported by 3-D electron pressure divergence

Authors: Kevin J. Genestreti, Ali Varsani, Jim L. Burch, Paul A. Cassak, Roy B. Torbert, Rumi Nakamura, Robert E. Ergun, Tai D. Phan, Sergio Toledo-Redondo, Michael Hesse, Shan Wang, Barbara L. Giles, Chris T. Russell, Zoltan Vörös, Kyoung-Joo Kim, Jonathan P. Eastwood, Benoit Lavraud, C. Philippe Escoubet, Robert C. Fear, Yuri Khotyaintsev, Takuma Nakamura, James M. Webster, Wolfgang Baumjohann

Abstract: We identify a dayside electron diffusion region (EDR) encountered by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission and estimate the terms in generalized Ohm's law that controlled energy conversion near the X-point. MMS crossed the moderate-shear (130 degrees) magnetopause southward of the exact X-point. MMS likely entered the magnetopause far from the X-point, outside the EDR, as the size of the rec… ▽ More We identify a dayside electron diffusion region (EDR) encountered by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission and estimate the terms in generalized Ohm's law that controlled energy conversion near the X-point. MMS crossed the moderate-shear (130 degrees) magnetopause southward of the exact X-point. MMS likely entered the magnetopause far from the X-point, outside the EDR, as the size of the reconnection layer was less than but comparable to the magnetosheath proton gyro-radius, and also as anisotropic gyrotropic "outflow" crescent electron distributions were observed. MMS then approached the X-point, where all four spacecraft simultaneously observed signatures of the EDR, e.g., an intense out-of-plane electron current, moderate electron agyrotropy, intense electron anisotropy, non-ideal electric fields, non-ideal energy conversion, etc. We find that the electric field associated with the non-ideal energy conversion is (a) well described by the sum of the electron inertial and pressure divergence terms in generalized Ohms law though (b) the pressure divergence term dominates the inertial term by roughly a factor of 5:1, (c) both the gyrotropic and agyrotropic pressure forces contribute to energy conversion at the X-point, and (d) both out-of-the-reconnection-plane gradients (d/dM) and in-plane (d/dL,N) in the pressure tensor contribute to energy conversion near the X-point. This indicates that this EDR had some electron-scale structure in the out-of-plane direction during the time when (and at the location where) the reconnection site was observed. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2018; v1 submitted 22 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: Submitted to JGR Space Physics (November 2017), resubmitted after 1st round of minor revisions (January 2018)

On the collisionless asymmetric magnetic reconnection rate

Authors: Yi-Hsin Liu, M. Hesse, P. A. Cassak, M. A. Shay, S. Wang, L. -J. Chen

Abstract: A prediction of the steady-state reconnection electric field in asymmetric reconnection is obtained by maximizing the reconnection rate as a function of the opening angle made by the upstream magnetic field on the weak magnetic field (magnetosheath) side. The prediction is within a factor of two of the widely examined asymmetric reconnection model [Cassak and Shay, Phys. Plasmas 14, 102114, 2007]… ▽ More A prediction of the steady-state reconnection electric field in asymmetric reconnection is obtained by maximizing the reconnection rate as a function of the opening angle made by the upstream magnetic field on the weak magnetic field (magnetosheath) side. The prediction is within a factor of two of the widely examined asymmetric reconnection model [Cassak and Shay, Phys. Plasmas 14, 102114, 2007] in the collisionless limit, and they scale the same over a wide parameter regime. The previous model had the effective aspect ratio of the diffusion region as a free parameter, which simulations and observations suggest is on the order of 0.1, but the present model has no free parameters. In conjunction with the symmetric case [Liu et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 085101, 2017], this work further suggests that this nearly universal number 0.1, essentially the normalized fast reconnection rate, is a geometrical factor arising from maximizing the reconnection rate within magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)-scale constraints. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Localized and intense energy conversion in the diffusion region of asymmetric magnetic reconnection

Authors: M. Swisdak, J. F. Drake, L. Price, J. L. Burch, P. A. Cassak, T. -D. Phan

Abstract: We analyze a high-resolution simulation of magnetopause reconnection observed by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission and explain the occurrence of strongly localized dissipation with an amplitude more than an order of magnitude larger than expected. Unlike symmetric reconnection, wherein reconnection of the ambient reversed magnetic field drives the dissipation, we find the annihilation of… ▽ More We analyze a high-resolution simulation of magnetopause reconnection observed by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission and explain the occurrence of strongly localized dissipation with an amplitude more than an order of magnitude larger than expected. Unlike symmetric reconnection, wherein reconnection of the ambient reversed magnetic field drives the dissipation, we find the annihilation of the self-generated, out-of-plane (Hall) magnetic field plays the dominant role. Electrons flow along the magnetosheath separatrices, converge in the diffusion region, and jet past the X-point into the magnetosphere. The resulting accumulation of negative charge generates intense parallel electric fields that eject electrons along the magnetospheric separatrices and produce field-aligned beams. Many of these features match MMS observations. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2018; v1 submitted 12 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: Accepted version

A Review of the 0.1 Reconnection Rate Problem

Authors: P. A. Cassak, Y. -H. Liu, M. A. Shay

Abstract: A long-standing problem in magnetic reconnection is to explain why it tends to proceed at or below a normalized rate of 0.1. This article gives a review of observational and numerical evidence for this rate and discusses recent theoretical work addressing this problem. Some remaining open questions are summarized. A long-standing problem in magnetic reconnection is to explain why it tends to proceed at or below a normalized rate of 0.1. This article gives a review of observational and numerical evidence for this rate and discusses recent theoretical work addressing this problem. Some remaining open questions are summarized. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 16 pages, 4 figures, the manuscript was prepared for the first Journal of Plasma Physics Frontiers in Plasma Physics Conference, accepted to Journal of Plasma Physics, August 2017

The effect of a guide field on local energy conversion during asymmetric magnetic reconnection: MMS observations

Authors: Kevin Genestreti, Jim Burch, Paul Cassak, Roy Torbert, Bob Ergun, Ali Varsani, Tai Phan, Barbara Giles, Chris Russell, Shan Wang, Mojtaba Akhavan-Tafti, Robert Allen

Abstract: We compare case studies of Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS)-observed magnetopause electron diffusion regions (EDRs) to determine how the rate of work done by the electric field, $\vec{J}\cdot(\vec{E}+\vec{v}_e\times\vec{B})\equiv\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$, and electron dynamics vary with magnetic shear angle. We provide an in-depth analysis of an MMS-observed EDR event with a guide field approximately t… ▽ More We compare case studies of Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS)-observed magnetopause electron diffusion regions (EDRs) to determine how the rate of work done by the electric field, $\vec{J}\cdot(\vec{E}+\vec{v}_e\times\vec{B})\equiv\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$, and electron dynamics vary with magnetic shear angle. We provide an in-depth analysis of an MMS-observed EDR event with a guide field approximately the same size as the magnetosheath reconnecting field, which occurred on 8 December 2015. We find that $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ was large and positive near the magnetic field reversal point, though patchy lower-amplitude $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ also occurred on the magnetosphere-side EDR near the electron crescent point. The current associated with the large $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ near the null was carried by electrons with a velocity distribution function (VDF) resembling that of the magnetosheath inflow, but accelerated in the anti-parallel direction by the parallel electric field. At the magnetosphere-side EDR, the current was carried by electrons with a crescent-like VDF. We compare this 8 December event to four others with differing magnetic shear angles. This type of dual-region $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ was observed in another intermediate-shear EDR event, whereas the high-shear events had a strong positive $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ near the electron crescent point and the low-shear event had a strong positive $\vec{J}\cdot\vec{E}'$ near the in-plane null. We propose a physical relationship between the shear angle and mode of energy conversion where (a) a guide field provides an efficient mechanism for carrying a current at the field reversal point (streaming) and (b) a guide field may limit the formation of crescent eVDFs, limiting the current carried near the stagnation point. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2017; v1 submitted 26 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Global three-dimensional simulation of Earth's dayside reconnection using a two-way coupled magnetohydrodynamics with embedded particle-in-cell model: initial results

Authors: Yuxi Chen, Gabor Toth, Paul Cassak, Xianzhe Jia, Tamas I. Gombosi, James A. Slavin, Stefano Markidis, Ivy Bo Peng, Vania K. Jordanova

Abstract: We perform a three-dimensional (3D) global simulation of Earth's magnetosphere with kinetic reconnection physics to study the flux transfer events (FTEs) and dayside magnetic reconnection with the recently developed magnetohydrodynamics with embedded particle-in-cell model (MHD-EPIC). During the one-hour long simulation, the FTEs are generated quasi-periodically near the subsolar point and move to… ▽ More We perform a three-dimensional (3D) global simulation of Earth's magnetosphere with kinetic reconnection physics to study the flux transfer events (FTEs) and dayside magnetic reconnection with the recently developed magnetohydrodynamics with embedded particle-in-cell model (MHD-EPIC). During the one-hour long simulation, the FTEs are generated quasi-periodically near the subsolar point and move toward the poles. We find the magnetic field signature of FTEs at their early formation stage is similar to a `crater FTE', which is characterized by a magnetic field strength dip at the FTE center. After the FTE core field grows to a significant value, it becomes an FTE with typical flux rope structure. When an FTE moves across the cusp, reconnection between the FTE field lines and the cusp field lines can dissipate the FTE. The kinetic features are also captured by our model. A crescent electron phase space distribution is found near the reconnection site. A similar distribution is found for ions at the location where the Larmor electric field appears. The lower hybrid drift instability (LHDI) along the current sheet direction also arises at the interface of magnetosheath and magnetosphere plasma. The LHDI electric field is about 8 mV/m and its dominant wavelength relative to the electron gyroradius agrees reasonably with MMS observations. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Turbulence in Three-Dimensional Simulations of Magnetopause Reconnection

Authors: L. Price, M. Swisdak, J. F. Drake, J. L. Burch, P. A. Cassak, R. E. Ergun

Abstract: We present detailed analysis of the turbulence observed in three-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations of magnetic reconnection at the magnetopause. The parameters are representative of an electron diffusion region encounter of the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission. The turbulence is found to develop around both the magnetic X line and separatrices, is electromagnetic in nature, is charac… ▽ More We present detailed analysis of the turbulence observed in three-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations of magnetic reconnection at the magnetopause. The parameters are representative of an electron diffusion region encounter of the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission. The turbulence is found to develop around both the magnetic X line and separatrices, is electromagnetic in nature, is characterized by a wave vector $k$ given by $kρ_e\sim(m_eT_e/m_iT_i)^{0.25}$ with $ρ_e$ the electron Larmor radius, and appears to have the ion pressure gradient as its source of free energy. Taken together, these results suggest the instability is a variant of the lower hybrid drift instability. The turbulence produces electric field fluctuations in the out-of-plane direction (the direction of the reconnection electric field) with an amplitude of around $\pm 10$~mV/m, which is much greater than the reconnection electric field of around $0.1$~mV/m. Such large values of the out-of-plane electric field have been identified in the MMS data. The turbulence in the simulations controls the scale lengths of the density profile and current layers in asymmetric reconnection, driving them closer to $\sqrt{ρ_eρ_i}$ than the $ρ_e$ or $d_e$ scalings seen in 2-D reconnection simulations, and produces significant anomalous resistivity and viscosity in the electron diffusion region. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2018; v1 submitted 5 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 122, 11086--11099 (2017)

Why does steady-state magnetic reconnection have a maximum local rate of order 0.1?

Authors: Yi-Hsin Liu, M. Hesse, F. Guo, W. Daughton, H. Li, P. A. Cassak, M. A. Shay

Abstract: Simulations suggest collisionless steady-state magnetic reconnection of Harris-type current sheets proceeds with a rate of order 0.1, independent of dissipation mechanism. We argue this long-standing puzzle is a result of constraints at the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) scale. We perform a scaling analysis of the reconnection rate as a function of the opening angle made by the upstream magnetic fields… ▽ More Simulations suggest collisionless steady-state magnetic reconnection of Harris-type current sheets proceeds with a rate of order 0.1, independent of dissipation mechanism. We argue this long-standing puzzle is a result of constraints at the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) scale. We perform a scaling analysis of the reconnection rate as a function of the opening angle made by the upstream magnetic fields, finding a maximum reconnection rate close to 0.2. The predictions compare favorably to particle-in-cell simulations of relativistic electron-positron and non-relativistic electron-proton reconnection. The fact that simulated reconnection rates are close to the predicted maximum suggests reconnection proceeds near the most efficient state allowed at the MHD-scale. The rate near the maximum is relatively insensitive to the opening angle, potentially explaining why reconnection has a similar fast rate in differing models. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Submitted to PRL for review on 08/17/2016. This article is a revision of arXiv:1605.05654. https://arxiv.longhoe.net/abs/1605.05654

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 085101 (2017)

Spacecraft observations and analytic theory of crescent-shaped electron distributions in asymmetric magnetic reconnection

Authors: J. Egedal, A. Le, W. Daughton, B. Wetherton, P. A. Cassak, L. -J Chen, B. Lavraud, R. B. Trobert, J. Dorelli, D J Gershman, L. A. Avanov

Abstract: Supported by a kinetic simulation, we derive an exclusion energy parameter $\cal{E}_X$ providing a lower kinetic energy bound for an electron to cross from one inflow region to the other during magnetic reconnection. As by a Maxwell Demon, only high energy electrons are permitted to cross the inner reconnection region, setting the electron distribution function observed along the low density side… ▽ More Supported by a kinetic simulation, we derive an exclusion energy parameter $\cal{E}_X$ providing a lower kinetic energy bound for an electron to cross from one inflow region to the other during magnetic reconnection. As by a Maxwell Demon, only high energy electrons are permitted to cross the inner reconnection region, setting the electron distribution function observed along the low density side separatrix during asymmetric reconnection. The analytic model accounts for the two distinct flavors of crescent-shaped electron distributions observed by spacecraft in a thin boundary layer along the low density separatrix. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 185101 (2016)

Particle-in-cell simulation study of the scaling of asymmetric magnetic reconnection with in-plane flow shear

Authors: C. E. Doss, P. A. Cassak, M. Swisdak

Abstract: We investigate magnetic reconnection in systems simultaneously containing asymmetric (anti-parallel) magnetic fields, asymmetric plasma densities and temperatures, and arbitrary in-plane bulk flow of plasma in the upstream regions. Such configurations are common in the high-latitudes of Earth's magnetopause and in tokamaks. We investigate the convection speed of the X-line, the scaling of the reco… ▽ More We investigate magnetic reconnection in systems simultaneously containing asymmetric (anti-parallel) magnetic fields, asymmetric plasma densities and temperatures, and arbitrary in-plane bulk flow of plasma in the upstream regions. Such configurations are common in the high-latitudes of Earth's magnetopause and in tokamaks. We investigate the convection speed of the X-line, the scaling of the reconnection rate, and the condition for which the flow suppresses reconnection as a function of upstream flow speeds. We use two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations to capture the mixing of plasma in the outflow regions better than is possible in fluid modeling. We perform simulations with asymmetric magnetic fields, simulations with asymmetric densities, and simulations with magnetopause-like parameters where both are asymmetric. For flow speeds below the predicted cutoff velocity, we find good scaling agreement with the theory presented in Doss et al., J.~Geophys.~Res., 120, 7748 (2015). Applications to planetary magnetospheres, tokamaks, and the solar wind are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 17 pages, 4 figures, submitted to Physics of Plasmas

The local dayside reconnection rate for oblique interplanetary magnetic fields

Authors: Colin M. Komar, Paul A. Cassak

Abstract: We present an analysis of local properties of magnetic reconnection at the dayside magnetopause for various interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) orientations in global magnetospheric simulations. This has heretofore not been practical because it is difficult to locate where reconnection occurs for oblique IMF, but new techniques make this possible. The approach is to identify magnetic separators, t… ▽ More We present an analysis of local properties of magnetic reconnection at the dayside magnetopause for various interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) orientations in global magnetospheric simulations. This has heretofore not been practical because it is difficult to locate where reconnection occurs for oblique IMF, but new techniques make this possible. The approach is to identify magnetic separators, the curves separating four regions of differing magnetic topology, which map the reconnection X-line. The electric field parallel to the X-line is the local reconnection rate. We compare results to a simple model of local two-dimensional asymmetric reconnection. To do so, we find the plasma parameters that locally drive reconnection in the magnetosheath and magnetosphere in planes perpendicular to the X-line at a large number of points along the X-line. The global magnetohydrodynamic simulations are from the three-dimensional Block-Adaptive, Tree Solarwind Roe-type Upwind Scheme (BATS-R-US) code with a uniform resistivity, although the techniques described here are extensible to any global magnetospheric simulation model. We find that the predicted local reconnection rates scale well with the measured values for all simulations, being nearly exact for due southward IMF. However, the absolute predictions differ by an undetermined constant of proportionality, whose magnitude increases as the IMF clock angle changes from southward to northward. We also show similar scaling agreement in a simulation with oblique southward IMF and a dipole tilt. The present results will be an important component of a full understanding of the local and global properties of dayside reconnection. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures, 1 table, Submitted to Journal Geophysical Research Space Physics February 12, 2016; Revised April 28, 2016

The Effects of Turbulence on Three-Dimensional Magnetic Reconnection at the Magnetopause

Authors: L. Price, M. Swisdak, J. F. Drake, P. A. Cassak, J. T. Dahlin, R. E. Ergun

Abstract: Two- and three-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations of a recent encounter of the Magnetospheric Multiscale Mission (MMS) with an electron diffusion region at the magnetopause are presented. While the two-dimensional simulation is laminar, turbulence develops at both the x-line and along the magnetic separatrices in the three-dimensional simulation. The turbulence is strong enough to make the m… ▽ More Two- and three-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations of a recent encounter of the Magnetospheric Multiscale Mission (MMS) with an electron diffusion region at the magnetopause are presented. While the two-dimensional simulation is laminar, turbulence develops at both the x-line and along the magnetic separatrices in the three-dimensional simulation. The turbulence is strong enough to make the magnetic field around the reconnection island chaotic and produces both anomalous resistivity and anomalous viscosity. Each contribute significantly to breaking the frozen-in condition in the electron diffusion region. A surprise is that the crescent-shaped features in velocity space seen both in MMS observations and in two-dimensional simulations survive, even in the turbulent environment of the three-dimensional system. This suggests that MMS's measurements of crescent distributions do not exclude the possibility that turbulence plays an important role in magnetopause reconnection. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2016; v1 submitted 27 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: Revised version accepted by GRL

Kinetic signatures of the region surrounding the X-line in asymmetric (magnetopause) reconnection

Authors: M. A. Shay, T. D. Phan, C. C. Haggerty, M. Fujimoto, J. F. Drake, K. Malakit, P. A. Cassak, M. Swisdak

Abstract: Kinetic particle-in-cell simulations are used to identify signatures of the electron diffusion region (EDR) and its surroundings during asymmetric magnetic reconnection. A "shoulder" in the sunward pointing normal electric field (EN > 0) at the reconnection magnetic field reversal is a good indicator of the EDR, and is caused by magnetosheath electron meandering orbits in the vicinity of the x-lin… ▽ More Kinetic particle-in-cell simulations are used to identify signatures of the electron diffusion region (EDR) and its surroundings during asymmetric magnetic reconnection. A "shoulder" in the sunward pointing normal electric field (EN > 0) at the reconnection magnetic field reversal is a good indicator of the EDR, and is caused by magnetosheath electron meandering orbits in the vicinity of the x-line. Earthward of the X-line, electrons accelerated by EN form strong currents and crescent-shaped distribution functions in the plane perpendicular to B. Just downstream of the X-line, parallel electric fields create field-aligned crescent electron distribution functions. In the immediate upstream magnetosheath, magnetic field strength, plasma density, and perpendicular electron temperatures are lower than the asymptotic state. In the magnetosphere inflow region, magnetosheath ions intrude resulting in an Earthward pointing electric field and parallel heating of magnetospheric particles. Many of the above properties persist with a guide field of at least unity. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: Submitted to Geophysical Research Letters

Asymmetric magnetic reconnection with a flow shear and applications to the magnetopause

Authors: C. E. Doss, C. M. Komar, P. A. Cassak, F. D. Wilder, S. Eriksson, J. F. Drake

Abstract: We perform a theoretical and numerical study of anti-parallel 2D magnetic reconnection with asymmetries in the density and reconnecting magnetic field strength in addition to a bulk flow shear across the reconnection site in the plane of the reconnecting fields, which commonly occurs at planetary magnetospheres. We predict the speed at which an isolated X-line is convected by the flow, the reconne… ▽ More We perform a theoretical and numerical study of anti-parallel 2D magnetic reconnection with asymmetries in the density and reconnecting magnetic field strength in addition to a bulk flow shear across the reconnection site in the plane of the reconnecting fields, which commonly occurs at planetary magnetospheres. We predict the speed at which an isolated X-line is convected by the flow, the reconnection rate, and the critical flow speed at which reconnection no longer takes place for arbitrary reconnecting magnetic field strengths, densities, and upstream flow speeds, and confirm the results with two-fluid numerical simulations. The predictions and simulation results counter the prevailing model of reconnection at Earth's dayside magnetopause which says reconnection occurs with a stationary X-line for sub-Alfvenic magnetosheath flow, reconnection occurs but the X-line convects for magnetosheath flows between the Alfven speed and double the Alfven speed, and reconnection does not occur for magnetosheath flows greater than double the Alfven speed. We find that X-line motion is governed by momentum conservation from the upstream flows, which are weighted differently in asymmetric systems, so the X-line convects for generic conditions including sub-Alfvenic upstream speeds. For the reconnection rate, while the cutoff condition for symmetric reconnection is that the difference in flows on the two sides of the reconnection site is twice the Alfven speed, we find asymmetries cause the cutoff speed for asymmetric reconnection to be higher than twice the asymmetric form of the Alfven speed. The results compare favorably with an observation of reconnection at Earth's polar cusps during a period of northward interplanetary magnetic field, where reconnection occurs despite the magnetosheath flow speed being more than twice the magnetosheath Alfven speed, the previously proposed suppression condition. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 46 pages, 7 figures, abstract abridged here, accepted to Journal of Geophysical Research - Space Physics

Comparative Analysis of Dayside Reconnection Models in Global Magnetosphere Simulations

Authors: C. M. Komar, R. L. Fermo, P. A. Cassak

Abstract: We test and compare a number of existing models predicting the location of magnetic reconnection at Earth's dayside magnetopause for various solar wind conditions. We employ robust image processing techniques to determine the locations where each model predicts reconnection to occur. The predictions are then compared to the magnetic separators, the magnetic field lines separating different magneti… ▽ More We test and compare a number of existing models predicting the location of magnetic reconnection at Earth's dayside magnetopause for various solar wind conditions. We employ robust image processing techniques to determine the locations where each model predicts reconnection to occur. The predictions are then compared to the magnetic separators, the magnetic field lines separating different magnetic topologies. The predictions are tested in distinct high-resolution simulations with interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) clock angles ranging from 30 to 165 degrees in global magnetohydrodynamic simulations using the three-dimensional Block-Adaptive Tree Solarwind Roe-type Upwind Scheme (BATS-R-US) code with a uniform resistivity, although the described techniques can be generally applied to any self-consistent magnetosphere code. Additional simulations are carried out to test location model dependence on IMF strength and dipole tilt. We find that most of the models match large portions of the magnetic separators when the IMF has a southward component, with the models saying reconnection occurs where the local reconnection rate and reconnection outflow speed are maximized performing best. When the IMF has a northward component, none of the models tested faithfully map the entire magnetic separator, but the maximum magnetic shear model is the best at map** the separator in the cusp region where reconnection has been observed. Predictions for some models with northward IMF orientations improve after accounting for plasma flow shear parallel to the reconnecting components of the magnetic fields. Implications for observations are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 15 page, 14 figures, accepted to Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics December 15, 2014, published January 20, 2015

Journal ref: J. Geophys. Res. Space Physics, 120, 276-294

Fast Magnetic Reconnection Due to Anisotropic Electron Pressure

Authors: P. A. Cassak, R. N. Baylor, R. L. Fermo, M. T. Beidler, M. A. Shay, M. Swisdak, J. F. Drake, H. Karimabadi

Abstract: A new regime of fast magnetic reconnection with an out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field is reported in which the key role is played by an electron pressure anisotropy described by the Chew-Goldberger-Low gyrotropic equations of state in the generalized Ohm's law, which even dominates the Hall term. A description of the physical cause of this behavior is provided and two-dimensional fluid simulation… ▽ More A new regime of fast magnetic reconnection with an out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field is reported in which the key role is played by an electron pressure anisotropy described by the Chew-Goldberger-Low gyrotropic equations of state in the generalized Ohm's law, which even dominates the Hall term. A description of the physical cause of this behavior is provided and two-dimensional fluid simulations are used to confirm the results. The electron pressure anisotropy causes the out-of-plane magnetic field to develop a quadrupole structure of opposite polarity to the Hall magnetic field and gives rise to dispersive waves. In addition to being important for understanding what causes reconnection to be fast, this mechanism should dominate in plasmas with low plasma beta and a high in-plane plasma beta with electron temperature comparable to or larger than ion temperature, so it could be relevant in the solar wind and some tokamaks. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, accepted for publication as a letter in Physics of Plasmas

Electron Heating During Magnetic Reconnection: A Simulation Scaling Study

Authors: M. A. Shay, C. C. Haggerty, T. D. Phan, J. F. Drake, P. A. Cassak, P. Wu, M. Oieroset, M. Swisdak, K. Malakit

Abstract: Electron bulk heating during magnetic reconnection with symmetric inflow conditions is examined using kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations. The degree of electron heating is well correlated with the inflowing Alfvén speed $c_{Ar}$ based on the reconnecting magnetic field through the relation $ΔT_e = 0.033 \,m_i\,c_{Ar}^2$, where $ΔT_{e}$ is the increase in electron temperature. For the range… ▽ More Electron bulk heating during magnetic reconnection with symmetric inflow conditions is examined using kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations. The degree of electron heating is well correlated with the inflowing Alfvén speed $c_{Ar}$ based on the reconnecting magnetic field through the relation $ΔT_e = 0.033 \,m_i\,c_{Ar}^2$, where $ΔT_{e}$ is the increase in electron temperature. For the range of simulations performed, the heating shows almost no correlation with inflow total temperature $T_{tot} = T_i + T_e$ or plasma $β$. An out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field of similar magnitude to the reconnecting field does not affect the total heating, but it does quench perpendicular heating, with almost all heating being in the parallel direction. These results are qualitatively consistent with a recent statistical survey of electron heating in the dayside magnetopause, which also found that $ΔT_e$ was proportional to the inflowing Alfvén speed. The net electron heating varies very little with distance downstream of the x-line. The simulations show at most a very weak dependence of electron heating on the ion to electron mass ratio. In the antiparallel reconnection case, the largely parallel heating is eventually isotropized downstream due a scattering mechanism such as stochastic particle motion or instabilities. The study highlights key properties that must be satisfied by an electron heating mechanism: (1) Preferential heating in the parallel direction; (2) Heating proportional to $m_i\,c_{Ar}^2$; (3) At most a weak dependence on electron mass; and (4) An exhaust electron temperature that varies little with distance from the x-line. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 27 pages, 1 table, 7 figures. Submitted to Physics of Plasmas

On the 3-D structure and dissipation of reconnection-driven flow-bursts

Authors: J. F. Drake, M. Swisdak, P. A. Cassak, T. D. Phan

Abstract: The structure of magnetic reconnection-driven outflows and their dissipation are explored with large-scale, 3-D particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations. Outflow jets resulting from 3-D reconnection with a finite length x-line form fronts as they propagate into the downstream medium. A large pressure increase ahead of this ``reconnection jet front'' (RJF), due to reflected and transmitted ions, slows th… ▽ More The structure of magnetic reconnection-driven outflows and their dissipation are explored with large-scale, 3-D particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations. Outflow jets resulting from 3-D reconnection with a finite length x-line form fronts as they propagate into the downstream medium. A large pressure increase ahead of this ``reconnection jet front'' (RJF), due to reflected and transmitted ions, slows the front so that its velocity is well below the velocity of the ambient ions in the core of the jet. As a result, the RJF slows and diverts the high-speed flow into the direction perpendicular to the reconnection plane. The consequence is that the RJF acts as a thermalization site for the ion bulk flow and contributes significantly to the dissipation of magnetic energy during reconnection even though the outflow jet is subsonic. This behavior has no counterpart in 2-D reconnection. A simple analytic model predicts the front velocity and the fraction of the ion bulk flow energy that is dissipated. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2014; v1 submitted 27 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

A New Electric Field in Asymmetric Magnetic Reconnection

Authors: Kittipat Malakit, Michael A. Shay, Paul A. Cassak, David Ruffolo

Abstract: We present a theory and numerical evidence for the existence of a previously unexplored in-plane electric field in collisionless asymmetric magnetic reconnection. This electric field, dubbed the "Larmor electric field," is associated with finite Larmor radius effects and is distinct from the known Hall electric field. Potentially, it could be an important indicator for the upcoming Magnetospheric… ▽ More We present a theory and numerical evidence for the existence of a previously unexplored in-plane electric field in collisionless asymmetric magnetic reconnection. This electric field, dubbed the "Larmor electric field," is associated with finite Larmor radius effects and is distinct from the known Hall electric field. Potentially, it could be an important indicator for the upcoming Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission to locate reconnection sites as we expect it to appear on the magnetospheric side, pointing Earthward, at the dayside magnetopause reconnection site. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, to be published in Physical Review Letters

Tracing magnetic separators and their dependence on IMF clock angle in global magnetospheric simulations

Authors: C. M. Komar, P. A. Cassak, J. C. Dorelli, A. Glocer, M. M. Kuznetsova

Abstract: A new, efficient, and highly accurate method for tracing magnetic separators in global magnetospheric simulations with arbitrary clock angle is presented. The technique is to begin at a magnetic null and iteratively march along the separator by finding where four magnetic topologies meet on a spherical surface. The technique is verified using exact solutions for separators resulting from an analyt… ▽ More A new, efficient, and highly accurate method for tracing magnetic separators in global magnetospheric simulations with arbitrary clock angle is presented. The technique is to begin at a magnetic null and iteratively march along the separator by finding where four magnetic topologies meet on a spherical surface. The technique is verified using exact solutions for separators resulting from an analytic magnetic field model that superposes dipolar and uniform magnetic fields. Global resistive magnetohydrodynamic simulations are performed using the three-dimensional BATS-R-US code with a uniform resistivity, in eight distinct simulations with interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) clock angles ranging from 0 (parallel) to 180 degrees (anti-parallel). Magnetic nulls and separators are found in the simulations, and it is shown that separators traced here are accurate for any clock angle, unlike the last closed field line on the Sun-Earth line that fails for southward IMF. Trends in magnetic null locations and the structure of magnetic separators as a function of clock angle are presented and compared with those from the analytic field model. There are many qualitative similarities between the two models, but quantitative differences are also noted. Dependence on solar wind density is briefly investigated. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, 10 figures, Presented at 2012 AGU Fall Meeting and 2013 Geospace Environment Modeling (GEM) Workshop

Journal ref: Journal of Geophysical Research - Space Physics, 118, 2013

On the Cause of Supra-Arcade Downflows in Solar Flares

Authors: P. A. Cassak, J. F. Drake, J. T. Gosling, T. -D. Phan, M. A. Shay, L. S. Shepherd

Abstract: A model of supra-arcade downflows (SADs), dark low density regions also known as tadpoles that propagate sunward during solar flares, is presented. It is argued that the regions of low density are flow channels carved by sunward-directed outflow jets from reconnection. The solar corona is stratified, so the flare site is populated by a lower density plasma than that in the underlying arcade. As th… ▽ More A model of supra-arcade downflows (SADs), dark low density regions also known as tadpoles that propagate sunward during solar flares, is presented. It is argued that the regions of low density are flow channels carved by sunward-directed outflow jets from reconnection. The solar corona is stratified, so the flare site is populated by a lower density plasma than that in the underlying arcade. As the jets penetrate the arcade, they carve out regions of depleted plasma density which appear as SADs. The present interpretation differs from previous models in that reconnection is localized in space but not in time. Reconnection is continuous in time to explain why SADs are not filled in from behind as they would if they were caused by isolated descending flux tubes or the wakes behind them due to temporally bursty reconnection. Reconnection is localized in space because outflow jets in standard two-dimensional reconnection models expand in the normal (inflow) direction with distance from the reconnection site, which would not produce thin SADs as seen in observations. On the contrary, outflow jets in spatially localized three-dimensional reconnection with an out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field expand primarily in the out-of-plane direction and remain collimated in the normal direction, which is consistent with observed SADs being thin. Two-dimensional proof-of-principle simulations of reconnection with an out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field confirm the creation of SAD-like depletion regions and the necessity of density stratification. Three-dimensional simulations confirm that localized reconnection remains collimated. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2013; v1 submitted 15 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures, accepted to Astrophysical Journal Letters in August, 2013. This version is the accepted version

Guide Field Dependence of 3D X-Line Spreading During Collisionless Magnetic Reconnection

Authors: L. S. Shepherd, P. A. Cassak

Abstract: Theoretical arguments and large-scale two-fluid simulations are used to study the spreading of reconnection X-lines localized in the direction of the current as a func- tion of the strength of the out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field. It is found that the mech- anism causing the spreading is different for weak and strong guide fields. In the weak guide field limit, spreading is due to the motion of… ▽ More Theoretical arguments and large-scale two-fluid simulations are used to study the spreading of reconnection X-lines localized in the direction of the current as a func- tion of the strength of the out-of-plane (guide) magnetic field. It is found that the mech- anism causing the spreading is different for weak and strong guide fields. In the weak guide field limit, spreading is due to the motion of the current carriers, as has been pre- viously established. However, spreading for strong guide fields is bi-directional and is due to the excitation of Alfvén waves along the guide field. In general, we suggest that the X-line spreads bi-directionally with a speed governed by the faster of the two mecha- nisms for each direction. A prediction on the strength of the guide field at which the spread- ing mechanism changes is formulated and verified with three-dimensional simulations. Solar, magnetospheric, and laboratory applications are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, Submitted to JGR

Model for Incomplete Reconnection in Sawtooth Crashes

Authors: Matthew T. Beidler, Paul A. Cassak

Abstract: A model for incomplete reconnection in sawtooth crashes is presented. The reconnection inflow during the crash phase of sawteeth self-consistently convects the high pressure core toward the reconnection site, raising the pressure gradient there. Reconnection shuts off if the diamagnetic drift speed at the reconnection site exceeds a threshold, which may explain incomplete reconnection. The relaxat… ▽ More A model for incomplete reconnection in sawtooth crashes is presented. The reconnection inflow during the crash phase of sawteeth self-consistently convects the high pressure core toward the reconnection site, raising the pressure gradient there. Reconnection shuts off if the diamagnetic drift speed at the reconnection site exceeds a threshold, which may explain incomplete reconnection. The relaxation of magnetic shear after reconnection stops may explain the destabilization of ideal interchange instabilities reported previously. Proof-of-principle two-fluid simulations confirm this basic picture. Predictions of the model compare favorably to data from the Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak. Applications to transport modeling of sawteeth are discussed. The results should apply across tokamaks, including ITER. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, accepted for publication in PRL

Three-dimensional simulations of the orientation and structure of reconnection X-lines

Authors: R. Schreier, M. Swisdak, J. F. Drake, P. A. Cassak

Abstract: This work employs Hall magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations to study the X-lines formed during the reconnection of magnetic fields with differing strengths and orientations embedded in plasmas of differing densities. Although random initial perturbations trigger the growth of X-lines with many orientations, at late time a few robust X-lines sharing an orientation reasonably consistent with the di… ▽ More This work employs Hall magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations to study the X-lines formed during the reconnection of magnetic fields with differing strengths and orientations embedded in plasmas of differing densities. Although random initial perturbations trigger the growth of X-lines with many orientations, at late time a few robust X-lines sharing an orientation reasonably consistent with the direction that maximizes the outflow speed, as predicted by Swisdak and Drake [Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, L11106, (2007)], dominate the system. The existence of reconnection in the geometry examined here contradicts the suggestion of Sonnerup [J. Geophys. Res., 79, 1546 (1974)] that reconnection occurs in a plane normal to the equilibrium current. At late time the growth of the X-lines stagnates, leaving them shorter than the simulation domain. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2010; originally announced September 2010.

Comments: Accepted by Physics of Plasmas

Comparison of secondary islands in collisional reconnection to Hall reconnection

Authors: L. S. Shepherd, P. A. Cassak

Abstract: Large-scale resistive Hall-magnetohydrodynamic (Hall-MHD) simulations of the transition from Sweet-Parker (collisional) to Hall (collisionless) magnetic reconnection are presented, the first to separate effects of secondary islands from collisionless effects. Three main results are described. There exists a regime in which secondary islands occur without collisionless effects when the thickness of… ▽ More Large-scale resistive Hall-magnetohydrodynamic (Hall-MHD) simulations of the transition from Sweet-Parker (collisional) to Hall (collisionless) magnetic reconnection are presented, the first to separate effects of secondary islands from collisionless effects. Three main results are described. There exists a regime in which secondary islands occur without collisionless effects when the thickness of the dissipation regions exceed ion gyroscales. The reconnection rate with secondary islands is faster than Sweet-Parker but significantly slower than Hall reconnection. This implies that secondary islands are not the cause of the fastest reconnection rates. Because Hall reconnection is much faster, its onset causes the ejection of secondary islands from the vicinity of the X-line. These results imply that most of the energy release occurs during Hall reconnection. Coronal applications are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2010; v1 submitted 9 June, 2010; originally announced June 2010.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures. Accepted to Phy. Rev. Letters, June 2010