-
Optimized simulations of 50Ti(p,α) and 49Ti(d,α) reactions for hospital-cyclotron production of 47Sc
Authors:
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
Y. Lashko,
L. Zangrando
Abstract:
The production of 47Sc, a promising radioisotope for targeted radionuclide therapy, by means of hospital-cyclotron reactions is investigated. Two possible routes are considered: the proton-induced reaction on enriched 50Ti targets and the deuteron-induced reaction on enriched 49Ti targets. The cross-sections of the reactions are calculated using the TALYS code with optimized parameters and compare…
▽ More
The production of 47Sc, a promising radioisotope for targeted radionuclide therapy, by means of hospital-cyclotron reactions is investigated. Two possible routes are considered: the proton-induced reaction on enriched 50Ti targets and the deuteron-induced reaction on enriched 49Ti targets. The cross-sections of the reactions are calculated using the TALYS code with optimized parameters and compared with the available experimental data. The optimal energy ranges for the production of 47Sc are determined by taking into account the thick-target yields and the purity of the product. The results show that both reactions can provide high yields and high purity of 47Sc. The feasibility of producing 47Sc with a hospital cyclotron is demonstrated by performing realistic simulations of the irradiation for both 50Ti(p,α) and 49Ti(d,α) reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
155Tb production by cyclotrons: what level of 155Gd enrichment allows clinical applications?
Authors:
Francesca Barbaro,
Luciano Canton,
Nikolay Uzunov,
Laura De Nardo,
Laura Melendez-Alafort
Abstract:
BACKGROUND: 155Tb represents a potentially useful radionuclide for diagnostic medical applications, but its production remains a challenging problem. A recent experimental campaign, conducted with low-energy proton beams im**ing on a 155Gd target with 91.9% enrichment, demonstrated a significant co-production of 156gTb, a contaminant of great concern since its half-life is comparable to that of…
▽ More
BACKGROUND: 155Tb represents a potentially useful radionuclide for diagnostic medical applications, but its production remains a challenging problem. A recent experimental campaign, conducted with low-energy proton beams im**ing on a 155Gd target with 91.9% enrichment, demonstrated a significant co-production of 156gTb, a contaminant of great concern since its half-life is comparable to that of 155Tb and its high-energy gamma emissions severely impact on the dose released and on the quality of the SPECT images. Herein, the isotopic purity of the enriched 155Gd target necessary to minimize the co-production of contaminant radioisotopes, in particular 156gTb, was explored using various computational simulations. RESULTS: Starting from the recent data obtained with the 155Gd-enriched target, the co-production of other Tb radioisotopes besides 155Tb has been evaluated using the TALYS code. It was found that 156Gd, with an isotopic content of 5.87%, was the principal contributor to the co-production of 156gTb. The analysis also demonstrated that the maximum amount of 156Gd admissible for 155Tb production with a radionuclidic purity higher than 99% was 1%. A less stringent condition was obtained through computational dosimetry analysis, suggesting that a 2% content of 156Gd in the target can be tolerated to limit the dose increase to the patient below the 10% limit. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that the imaging properties of the produced 155Tb are not severely affected by this level of impurity in the target. CONCLUSIONS: 155Tb can be produced with a quality suitable for medical applications using low-energy proton beams and 155Gd-enriched targets if the 156Gd impurity content does not exceed 2%. Under these conditions, the dose increase due to the presence of contaminant radioisotopes remains below the 10% limit and good quality images, comparable to those of 111In, are guaranteed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The innovative $^{52g}$Mn for PET imaging: production cross section modeling and dosimetric evaluation
Authors:
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
M. P. Carante,
A. Colombi,
L. De Nardo,
A. Fontana,
L. Meléndez-Alafort
Abstract:
Background: Recently, the reaction $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn has been proposed as a possible alternative to the standard $^{nat}$Cr($p$,x)$^{52g}$Mn one, but improvements in the modeling were needed to better compare the two production routes.
Purpose: This work focuses on the development of precise simulations and models to compare the $^{52g}$Mn production from both reactions in terms of amou…
▽ More
Background: Recently, the reaction $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn has been proposed as a possible alternative to the standard $^{nat}$Cr($p$,x)$^{52g}$Mn one, but improvements in the modeling were needed to better compare the two production routes.
Purpose: This work focuses on the development of precise simulations and models to compare the $^{52g}$Mn production from both reactions in terms of amount of activity and radionuclidic purity (RNP), as well as in terms of dose increase (DI) due to the co-produced radioactive contaminants, with respect to a pure $^{52g}$MnCl$_2$ injection.
Methods: The nuclear code Talys has been employed to optimize the $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn cross section by tuning the parameters of the microscopic level densities. Dosimetric assessments of [$^{xx}$Mn]Cl$_2$ have been accomplished with OLINDA software 2.2.0 using female and male phantoms. At the end, the yield of $^{xx}$Mn radioisotopes estimated for the two production routes have been combined with the dosimetric results, to assess the DI at different times after the end of the irradiation.
Results: Good agreement was obtained between cross sections calculations and measurements. The comparison of the two reaction channels suggests that $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn leads to higher yield and higher purity, resulting in a less harmful impact on patients' health in terms of DI.
Conclusions: Both $^{nat}$V($α$,x) and $^{nat}$Cr($p$,x) production routes provide clinically acceptable $^{52g}$MnCl$_2$ for PET imaging. However, the $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn reaction provides a DI systematically lower than the one obtainable with $^{nat}$Cr($p$,x)$^{52g}$Mn and a longer time window in which it can be used clinically (RNP $\ge$ 99\%).
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
New results on proton-induced reactions on Vanadium for $^{47}$Sc production and the impact of level densities on theoretical cross sections
Authors:
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
M. P. Carante,
A. Colombi,
L. De Dominicis,
A. Fontana,
F. Haddad,
L. Mou,
G. Pupillo
Abstract:
New data for the $^\mbox{nat}$V(p,x) reactions have been measured in the range 26-70 MeV, with production of the nuclides $^{47}$Sc, $^{43}$Sc, $^{44m}$Sc, $^{44g}$Sc, $^{46}$Sc, $^{48}$Sc, $^{42}$K, $^{43}$K, $^{48}$V, $^{48}$Cr, $^{49}$Cr, and $^{51}$Cr. The focus is on the production of $^{47}$Sc, a $β^-$-emitter suitable for innovative radiotheranostic applications in nuclear medicine. The mea…
▽ More
New data for the $^\mbox{nat}$V(p,x) reactions have been measured in the range 26-70 MeV, with production of the nuclides $^{47}$Sc, $^{43}$Sc, $^{44m}$Sc, $^{44g}$Sc, $^{46}$Sc, $^{48}$Sc, $^{42}$K, $^{43}$K, $^{48}$V, $^{48}$Cr, $^{49}$Cr, and $^{51}$Cr. The focus is on the production of $^{47}$Sc, a $β^-$-emitter suitable for innovative radiotheranostic applications in nuclear medicine. The measured cross sections for this radionuclide and its contaminants are compared with the theoretical excitation functions calculated with the TALYS code. In view of novel radiopharmaceutical applications, it is essential to accurately describe these cross-sections for the evaluation of yields, purities, and dose releases. Hence, we optimize the level-density parameters of the microscopic models in the TALYS code to obtain the best possible descriptions of the new data. We consider different irradiation conditions to estimate the production yields from the cross sections determined in this work.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Production of high purity $^{52g}$Mn from $^{nat}$V targets with $α$-beams at cyclotrons
Authors:
A. Colombi,
M. P. Carante,
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
A. Fontana
Abstract:
Radioisotope $^{52g}$Mn is of special interest for multimodal imaging. Using state-of-art nuclear reaction codes, we study the alternative nuclear reaction route $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn in comparison with the standard production routes based upon the use of chromium targets. The integral yields of $^{52g}$Mn and contaminants have been evaluated. The main outcome of this investigation is that th…
▽ More
Radioisotope $^{52g}$Mn is of special interest for multimodal imaging. Using state-of-art nuclear reaction codes, we study the alternative nuclear reaction route $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn in comparison with the standard production routes based upon the use of chromium targets. The integral yields of $^{52g}$Mn and contaminants have been evaluated. The main outcome of this investigation is that the production of the main contaminant isotope $^{54}$Mn is expected to be lower than with $^{nat}$Cr. The study also reveals a large spread in the cross-section data set and points out the need of more precise measurements of the reaction $^{nat}$V($α$,x)$^{52g}$Mn as well as the need of a more accurate theoretical description.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Modeling Nuclear Reactions for PET/MRI MultiModal Imaging: the innovative use of 52gMn
Authors:
A. Colombi,
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
M. P. Carante,
A. Fontana
Abstract:
MultiModal Imaging is an innovative technique that consists in the combination of diagnostic exams based on different physical processes, to obtain a unique image with more detailed clinical information. The possibility of a simultaneous use of PET and MRI could be achieved by using a particular radioisotope: 52gMn. The main route to produce this isotope is the reaction 52Cr(p,n)52gMn which is the…
▽ More
MultiModal Imaging is an innovative technique that consists in the combination of diagnostic exams based on different physical processes, to obtain a unique image with more detailed clinical information. The possibility of a simultaneous use of PET and MRI could be achieved by using a particular radioisotope: 52gMn. The main route to produce this isotope is the reaction 52Cr(p,n)52gMn which is theoretically investigated in this study by means of three nuclear reaction codes. An analysis of the cross sections and a computation of the production rates and time evolution of the produced radioisotopes are performed, to identify the optimal production parameters. The procedure described for this reaction has a general validity and is applied also to other reactions, such as 52Cr(d,2n)52gMn and natV(alpha,x)52gMn.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A Statistical Description of Nuclear Reaction Models for Medical Radionuclides: the Paradigmatic Case of $^{47}$Sc Production with Thick Vanadium Targets
Authors:
M. P. Carante,
F. Barbaro,
L. Canton,
A. Colombi,
A. Fontana
Abstract:
We have introduced a tool to describe in a simple and efficient way the outcomes of known nuclear reaction codes. It differs from the customary use where typically a specific single model is selected and the remaining disregarded. The use of simple statistical procedures allows to introduce a more general theoretical evaluation with quantitative uncertainty, constructed on the variability of the b…
▽ More
We have introduced a tool to describe in a simple and efficient way the outcomes of known nuclear reaction codes. It differs from the customary use where typically a specific single model is selected and the remaining disregarded. The use of simple statistical procedures allows to introduce a more general theoretical evaluation with quantitative uncertainty, constructed on the variability of the built-in theoretical models. We apply the technique to study the production of $^{47}$Sc (a radio-nuclide with potential theranostic applications in nuclear medicine) with a proton beam im**ing on a thick natural Vanadium target. We find an energy range with significant production of $^{47}$Sc, and a minimum co-production of $^{46}$Sc, the radioactive contaminant that has to be avoided as much as possible because of its much longer half life than $^{47}$Sc (83.79 d vs 3.3492 d).
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
