-
Unifying thermophotovoltaic performance metrics with technoeconomics
Authors:
Shomik Verma,
Kyle Buznitsky,
Asegun Henry
Abstract:
Thermophotovoltaics (TPV) are becoming a promising new heat engine with rapid recent gains in performance. Their performance is characterized by two metrics: efficiency and power density. As we bridge the gap between lab-scale and system-scale devices, we need to understand how each of these metrics impacts the technoeconomics of a TPV system. In this work, we develop a technoeconomic metric based…
▽ More
Thermophotovoltaics (TPV) are becoming a promising new heat engine with rapid recent gains in performance. Their performance is characterized by two metrics: efficiency and power density. As we bridge the gap between lab-scale and system-scale devices, we need to understand how each of these metrics impacts the technoeconomics of a TPV system. In this work, we develop a technoeconomic metric based on the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) to understand how the metrics should be weighted relative to each other in terms of importance. We find that systems with high infrastructure and fuel costs should prioritize TPV efficiency, while systems where the TPV cell cost dominates should prioritize power density. We then evaluate how concrete cell improvements could improve the technoeconomics of five example systems, identifying the most impactful specific properties. Namely, improving spectral control with sub-bandgap reflectance is the most effective at reducing LCOE in systems with high infrastructure cost, while increasing view factor and reducing series resistance are most critical in systems with high TPV cell cost. Improving just 1-2 of these properties can reduce the LCOE by 30-50%. This study therefore helps researchers understand which performance metric is more important for their application and how to achieve high values of this performance metric.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Designing for effective heat transfer in a solid thermal energy storage system
Authors:
Shomik Verma,
Colin Kelsall,
Kyle Buznitsky,
Alina LaPotin,
Ashwin Sandeep,
Asegun Henry
Abstract:
Thermal energy storage using sensible heating of a solid storage medium is a potential low-cost technology for long-duration energy storage. To effectively get heat in and out of the solid material, channels of heat transfer fluid can be embedded within the storage material. Here we present design principles to improve performance of channel-embedded thermal energy storage systems, and we apply th…
▽ More
Thermal energy storage using sensible heating of a solid storage medium is a potential low-cost technology for long-duration energy storage. To effectively get heat in and out of the solid material, channels of heat transfer fluid can be embedded within the storage material. Here we present design principles to improve performance of channel-embedded thermal energy storage systems, and we apply these principles to a high-temperature system using graphite as the storage material and liquid tin as the heat transfer fluid. We first analyze the impact of geometry and material properties on the performance of the system, determining the ideal channel spacing and length to achieve high (dis)charge temperature uniformity. We then analyze how controlling the fluid flowrate, heating infrastructure, and heat engine can increase discharge power uniformity and accelerate charging. Finally, we model 100 high-temperature graphite storage blocks using a porous media approximation and implement the developed design principles to demonstrate significant improvement in performance for both discharging (constant discharge power for >90% of rated duration) and charging (>90% charged within 4 hours). Overall, the hierarchical design procedure presented here enables the design of cheap yet high-performing solid thermal energy storage systems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Thermophotovoltaic Efficiency of 40%
Authors:
Alina LaPotin,
Kevin L. Schulte,
Myles A. Steiner,
Kyle Buznitsky,
Colin C. Kelsall,
Daniel J. Friedman,
Eric J. Tervo,
Ryan M. France,
Michelle R. Young,
Andrew Rohskopf,
Shomik Verma,
Evelyn N. Wang,
Asegun Henry
Abstract:
We report the fabrication and measurement of thermophotovoltaic (TPV) cells with efficiencies of >40%, which is a record high TPV efficiency and the first experimental demonstration of the efficiency of high-bandgap tandem TPV cells. TPV efficiency was determined by simultaneous measurement of electric power output and heat dissipation from the device via calorimetry. The TPV cells are two-junctio…
▽ More
We report the fabrication and measurement of thermophotovoltaic (TPV) cells with efficiencies of >40%, which is a record high TPV efficiency and the first experimental demonstration of the efficiency of high-bandgap tandem TPV cells. TPV efficiency was determined by simultaneous measurement of electric power output and heat dissipation from the device via calorimetry. The TPV cells are two-junction devices comprising high-quality III-V materials with band gaps between 1.0 and 1.4 eV that are optimized for high emitter temperatures of 1900-2400°C. The cells exploit the concept of band-edge spectral filtering to obtain high efficiency, using high-reflectivity back surface reflectors to reject unusable sub-bandgap radiation back to the emitter. A 1.4/1.2 eV device reached a maximum efficiency of (41.1 +/- 1)% operating at a power density of 2.39 W/cm2 under an irradiance of 30.4 W/cm2 and emitter temperature of 2400°C. A 1.2/1.0 device reached a maximum efficiency of (39.3 +/- 1)% operating at a power density of 1.8 W/cm2 under an irradiance of 20.1 W/cm2 and emitter temperature of 2127°C. These cells can be integrated into a TPV system for thermal energy grid storage (TEGS) to enable dispatchable renewable energy. These new TPV cells enable a pathway for TEGS to reach sufficiently high efficiency and sufficiently low cost to enable full decarbonization of the grid. Furthermore, the high demonstrated efficiency also gives TPV the potential to compete with turbine-based heat engines for large-scale power production with respect to both cost and performance, thereby enabling possible usage in natural gas or hydrogen-fueled electricity production.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2021; v1 submitted 21 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Technoeconomic Analysis of Thermal Energy Grid Storage Using Graphite and Tin
Authors:
Colin C. Kelsall,
Kyle Buznitsky,
Asegun Henry
Abstract:
Energy storage is needed to enable dispatchable renewable energy supply and thereby full decarbonization of the grid. However, this can only occur with drastic cost reductions compared to current battery technology, with predicted targets for the cost per unit energy (CPE) below…
▽ More
Energy storage is needed to enable dispatchable renewable energy supply and thereby full decarbonization of the grid. However, this can only occur with drastic cost reductions compared to current battery technology, with predicted targets for the cost per unit energy (CPE) below $20/kWh. Notably, for full decarbonization, long duration storage up to 100 hrs will be needed at such low costs, and prior analyses have shown that in such high renewable penetration scenarios, CPE is more critical than other parameters such as round trip efficiency or cost per unit power when comparing the costs of different technologies. Here, we introduce an electricity storage concept that stores electricity as sensible heat in graphite storage blocks and uses multi-junction thermophotovoltaics (TPV) as a heat engine to convert it back to electricity on demand. This design is an outgrowth of the system proposed by Amy et al. in 2019, which has been modified here to use a solid graphite medium and molten tin as a heat transfer fluid rather than silicon as both. The reason for this is two-fold: (1) the CPE of graphite is almost 10X lower than that of silicon, which derives from the lower cost per unit mass (i.e., $0.5/kg vs. $1.5/kg) and the higher heat capacity per unit mass (2000 J/kg-K vs. 950 J/kg-K); and (2) the melting point tin and solubility of tin in graphite are much lower than that of silicon, which lessens the number of issues that have to overcome along the research and development pathway. The usage of graphite also eliminates the need for a second tank, but the main disadvantage of using a solid medium is that one cannot easily provide a steady discharge rate, as the power output from the storage will change with time, as the graphite cools during discharge. Thus, the objective of this work is to examine how these changes in the system design effect the overall technoeconomics.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 14 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
