-
On the width of a collisionless shock and the index of the cosmic rays it accelerates
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Asaf Pe'er
Abstract:
Despite being studied for many years, the structure of collisionless shocks is still not fully determined. Such shocks are known to be accelerators of cosmic rays, which, in turn, modify the shock structure. The shock width $λ$ is known to be connected to the cosmic rays (CRs) spectral index, $a$. Here, we use an instability analysis to derive the shock width in the presence of CRs. We obtain an a…
▽ More
Despite being studied for many years, the structure of collisionless shocks is still not fully determined. Such shocks are known to be accelerators of cosmic rays, which, in turn, modify the shock structure. The shock width $λ$ is known to be connected to the cosmic rays (CRs) spectral index, $a$. Here, we use an instability analysis to derive the shock width in the presence of CRs. We obtain an analytical expression connecting the shock width to the CRs index and to the fraction of upstream particles that are accelerated. We find that when this fraction becomes larger than $\sim$~30\%, a new instability becomes dominant. The shock undergoes a transition where its width increases by a factor $\sim 8- 10$, and the CRs acceleration effectively ends. Our analysis is valid for strong, non-relativistic and unmagnetized shocks. We discuss the implication of these results to the expected range of CRs spectra and flux observed, and on the structure of non-relativistic collisionless shocks.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Density jump for oblique collisionless shocks in pair plasmas: physical solutions
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Colby C. Haggerty,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks are frequently analyzed using the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) formalism, even though MHD assumes a small mean free path. Yet, isotropy of pressure, fruit of binary collisions and assumed in MHD, may not apply in collisionless shocks. This is especially true within a magnetized plasma, where the field can stabilize an anisotropy.
In a previous article \citep{BretJPP2022b}, a m…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks are frequently analyzed using the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) formalism, even though MHD assumes a small mean free path. Yet, isotropy of pressure, fruit of binary collisions and assumed in MHD, may not apply in collisionless shocks. This is especially true within a magnetized plasma, where the field can stabilize an anisotropy.
In a previous article \citep{BretJPP2022b}, a model was presented capable of dealing with the anisotropies that may arise at the front crossing. It was solved for any orientation of the field with respect to the shock front. Yet, for some values of the upstream parameters, several downstream solutions were found.
Here, we complete the work started in \cite{BretJPP2022b} by showing how to pick the physical solution out of the ones offered by the algebra. This is achieved by 2 means: 1) selecting the solution that has the downstream field obliquity closest to the upstream one. This criterion is exemplified on the parallel case and backed up by Particle-in-Cell simulations. 2) Filtering out solutions which do not satisfy a criteria already invoked to trim multiple solutions in MHD: the evolutionarity criterion, that we assume valid in the collisionless case.
The end result is a model in which a given upstream configuration results in a unique, or none (like in MHD), downstream configuration. The largest departure from MHD is found for the case of a parallel shock.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
PIC simulations of stable surface waves on a subcritical fast magnetosonic shock front
Authors:
M E Dieckmann,
C Huete,
F Cobos,
A Bret,
D Folini,
B Eliasson,
R Walder
Abstract:
We study with particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations the stability of fast magnetosonic shocks. They expand across a collisionless plasma and an orthogonal magnetic field that is aligned with one of the directions resolved by the 2D simulations. The shock speed is 1.6 times the fast magnetosonic speed when it enters a layer with a reduced density of mobile ions, which decreases the shock speed by up t…
▽ More
We study with particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations the stability of fast magnetosonic shocks. They expand across a collisionless plasma and an orthogonal magnetic field that is aligned with one of the directions resolved by the 2D simulations. The shock speed is 1.6 times the fast magnetosonic speed when it enters a layer with a reduced density of mobile ions, which decreases the shock speed by up to 15\% in 1D simulations. In the 2D simulations, the density of mobile ions in the layer varies sinusoidally perpendicularly to the shock normal. We resolve one sine period. This variation only leads to small changes in the shock speed evidencing a restoring force that opposes a shock deformation. As the shock propagates through the layer, the ion density becomes increasingly spatially modulated along the shock front and the magnetic field bulges out where the mobile ion density is lowest. The perturbed shock eventually reaches a steady state. Once it leaves the layer, the perturbations of the ion density and magnetic field oscillate along its front at a frequency close to the lower-hybrid frequency; the shock is mediated by a standing wave composed of obliquely propagating lower-hybrid waves. We perform three 2D simulations with different box lengths along the shock front. The shock front oscillations are aperiodically damped in the smallest box with the fastest variation of the ion density, strongly damped in the intermediate one, and weakly damped in the largest box. The shock front oscillations perturb the magnetic field in a spatial interval that extends by several electron skin depths upstream and downstream of the shock front and could give rise to Whistler waves that propagate along the shock's magnetic field overshoot. Similar waves were observed in hybrid and PIC simulations and by the MMS satellite mission.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Density jump as a function of magnetic field strength for perpendicular collisionless shocks with anisotropic upstream pressure
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
Shock waves are common in astrophysical environments. On many occasions, they are collisionless, which means they occur in settings where the mean free path is much larger than the dimensions of the system. For this very reason, magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) is not equipped to deal with such shocks, be it because it assumes binary collisions, hence temperature isotropy, when such isotropy is not guara…
▽ More
Shock waves are common in astrophysical environments. On many occasions, they are collisionless, which means they occur in settings where the mean free path is much larger than the dimensions of the system. For this very reason, magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) is not equipped to deal with such shocks, be it because it assumes binary collisions, hence temperature isotropy, when such isotropy is not guaranteed in the absence of collisions. Here we solve a model capable of dealing with perpendicular shocks with anisotropic upstream pressure. The system of MHD conservation equations is closed assuming the temperature normal to the flow is conserved at the crossing of the shock front. In the strong shock sonic limit, the behavior of a perpendicular shock with isotropic upstream is retrieved, regardless of the upstream anisotropy. Generally speaking, a rich variety of behaviors is found, inaccessible to MHD, depending on the upstream parameters. The present work can be viewed as the companion paper of MNRAS 520, 6083-6090 (2023), where the case of a parallel shock was treated. Differences and similarities with the present case are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Density jump as a function of magnetic field strength for parallel collisionless shocks with anisotropic upstream pressure
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
The properties of collisionless shocks are frequently assessed in the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model. Yet, in a collisionless plasma, an ambient magnetic field can sustain a stable anisotropy in the upstream or the downstream, resulting in a departure from the MHD predicted behavior. We present a model allowing to derive the downstream anisotropy, hence the shock density jump, in terms of the up…
▽ More
The properties of collisionless shocks are frequently assessed in the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model. Yet, in a collisionless plasma, an ambient magnetic field can sustain a stable anisotropy in the upstream or the downstream, resulting in a departure from the MHD predicted behavior. We present a model allowing to derive the downstream anisotropy, hence the shock density jump, in terms of the upstream quantities. For simplicity, the case of a parallel shock in pair plasma is considered. Contrary to previous works where the upstream was assumed isotropic, here the upstream anisotropy $A=T_\perp/T_\parallel$ is a free parameter. The strong sonic shock regime is formally identical to the isotropic upstream case. Yet, for intermediate sonic Mach numbers, a variety of behaviors appear as a result of the anisotropy of the upstream.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Density jump for oblique collisionless shocks in pair plasmas: allowed solutions
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
Shockwaves in plasma are usually dealt with using Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). Yet, MHD entails the assumption of a short mean free path, which is not fulfilled in a collisionless plasma. Recently, for pair plasmas, we devised a model allowing to account for kinetic effects within an MHD-like formalism. Its relies on an estimate of the anisotropy generated when crossing the front, with a subsequent…
▽ More
Shockwaves in plasma are usually dealt with using Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD). Yet, MHD entails the assumption of a short mean free path, which is not fulfilled in a collisionless plasma. Recently, for pair plasmas, we devised a model allowing to account for kinetic effects within an MHD-like formalism. Its relies on an estimate of the anisotropy generated when crossing the front, with a subsequent assessment of the stability of this anisotropy in the downstream. We solved our model for parallel, perpendicular and switch-on shocks. Here we bridge between all these cases by treating the problem of an arbitrarily, but coplanar, oriented magnetic field. Even though the formalism presented is valid for anisotropic upstream temperatures, only the case of a cold upstream is solved. We find extra solutions which are not part of the MHD catalog, and a density jump that is notably less in the quasi parallel, highly magnetized, regime. Given the complexity of the calculations, this work is mainly devoted to the presentation of the mathematical aspect of our model. A forthcoming article will be devoted to the physics of the shocks here defined.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Density jump as a function of magnetic field for switch-on collisionless shocks in pair plasmas
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
The properties of collisionless shocks, like the density jump, are usually derived from magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), where isotropic pressures are assumed. Yet, in a collisionless plasma, an external magnetic field can sustain a stable anisotropy. In \cite{BretJPP2018}, we devised a model for the kinetic history of the plasma through the shock front, allowing to self-consistently compute the downst…
▽ More
The properties of collisionless shocks, like the density jump, are usually derived from magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), where isotropic pressures are assumed. Yet, in a collisionless plasma, an external magnetic field can sustain a stable anisotropy. In \cite{BretJPP2018}, we devised a model for the kinetic history of the plasma through the shock front, allowing to self-consistently compute the downstream anisotropy, hence the density jump, in terms of the upstream parameters. This model dealt with the case of a parallel shock, where the magnetic field is normal to the front both in the upstream and the downstream. Yet, MHD also allows for shock solutions, the so-called switch-on solutions, where the field is normal to the front only in the upstream. This article consists in applying our model to these switch-on shocks. While MHD offers only 1 switch-on solution within a limited range of Alfvén Mach numbers, our model offers 2 kinds of solutions within a slightly different range of Alfvén Mach numbers. These 2 solutions are most likely the outcome of the intermediate and fast MHD shocks under our model. While the intermediate and fast shocks merge in MHD for the parallel case, they do not within our model. For simplicity, the formalism is restricted to non-relativistic shocks in pair plasmas where the upstream is cold.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Quantum electrodynamic effects on counter-streaming instabilities in the whole \textbf{k} space
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
In a recent work [Bret, EPL \textbf{135} (2021) 35001], quantum electrodynamic (QED) effects were evaluated for the two-stream instability. It pertains to the growth of perturbations with a wave vector oriented along the flow in a collisionless counter-streaming system. Here, the analysis is extended to every possible orientation of the wave vector. The previous result for the two-stream instabili…
▽ More
In a recent work [Bret, EPL \textbf{135} (2021) 35001], quantum electrodynamic (QED) effects were evaluated for the two-stream instability. It pertains to the growth of perturbations with a wave vector oriented along the flow in a collisionless counter-streaming system. Here, the analysis is extended to every possible orientation of the wave vector. The previous result for the two-stream instability is recovered, and it is proved that even within the framework of a 3D analysis, this instability remains fundamentally 1D even when accounting for QED effects. The filamentation instability, found for wave vectors normal to the flow, is weakly affected by QED corrections. As in the classical case, its growth rate saturates at large $k_\perp$. The saturation value is found independent of QED corrections. Also, the smallest unstable $k_\perp$ is independent of QED corrections. Surprisingly, unstable modes found for oblique wave vectors do \emph{not} follow the same pattern. For some, QED corrections do reduce the growth rate. But for others, the same corrections increase the growth rate instead. The possibility for QED effects to play a role in un-magnetized systems is evaluated. Pair production resulting from gamma emission by particles oscillating in the exponentially growing fields, is not accounting for.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Building a weak shockwave from linear modes
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
In shockwave theory, the density, velocity and pressure jumps are derived from the conservation equations. Here, we address the physics of a weak shock the other way around. We first show that the density profile of a weak shockwave in a fluid can be expressed as a sum of linear acoustic modes. The shock so built propagates at the speed of sound and matter is exactly conserved at the front crossin…
▽ More
In shockwave theory, the density, velocity and pressure jumps are derived from the conservation equations. Here, we address the physics of a weak shock the other way around. We first show that the density profile of a weak shockwave in a fluid can be expressed as a sum of linear acoustic modes. The shock so built propagates at the speed of sound and matter is exactly conserved at the front crossing. Yet, momentum and energy are only conserved up to order 0 in powers of the shock amplitude. The density, velocity and pressure jumps are similar to those of a fluid shock, and an equivalent Mach number can be defined. A similar process is possible in magnetohydrodynamic. Yet, such a decomposition is found impossible for collisionless shocks due to the dispersive nature of ion acoustic waves. Weakly nonlinear corrections to their frequency do not solve the problem. Weak collisionless shocks could be inherently nonlinear, non-amenable to any linear superposition. Or they could be nonexistent, as hinted by recent works.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2021; v1 submitted 19 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Kinetic Simulations of Strongly-Magnetized Parallel Shocks: Deviations from MHD Jump Conditions
Authors:
Colby C. Haggerty,
Antoine Bret,
Damiano Caprioli
Abstract:
Shocks waves are a ubiquitous feature of many astrophysical plasma systems, and an important process for energy dissipation and transfer. The physics of these shock waves are frequently treated/modeled as a collisional, fluid MHD discontinuity, despite the fact that many shocks occur in the collisionless regime. In light of this, using fully kinetic, 3D simulations of non-relativistic, parallel pr…
▽ More
Shocks waves are a ubiquitous feature of many astrophysical plasma systems, and an important process for energy dissipation and transfer. The physics of these shock waves are frequently treated/modeled as a collisional, fluid MHD discontinuity, despite the fact that many shocks occur in the collisionless regime. In light of this, using fully kinetic, 3D simulations of non-relativistic, parallel propagating collisionless shocks comprised of electron-positron plasma, we detail the deviation of collisionless shocks form MHD predictions for varying magnetization/Alfvénic Mach numbers, with particular focus on systems with Alfénic Mach numbers much smaller than sonic Mach numbers. We show that the shock compression ratio decreases for sufficiently large upstream magnetic fields, in agreement with the predictions of Bret & Narayan (2018). Additionally, we examine the role of magnetic field strength on the shock front width. This work reinforces a growing body of work that suggest that modeling many astrophysical systems with only a fluid plasma description omits potentially important physics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Quantum electrodynamic effects on the two-stream instability
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
We consider the quantum electrodynamic corrections to the two-stream instability. We find these corrections vanish at first order unless a guiding magnetic field $\mathbf{B}_0$ is considered. With respect to the classical version of the instability, quantum electrodynamic effects reduce the most unstable wave vector and its growth rate by a factor $\sqrt{1+ξ}$, with $ξ= \fracα{9π} (B_0/B_{cr})^2$,…
▽ More
We consider the quantum electrodynamic corrections to the two-stream instability. We find these corrections vanish at first order unless a guiding magnetic field $\mathbf{B}_0$ is considered. With respect to the classical version of the instability, quantum electrodynamic effects reduce the most unstable wave vector and its growth rate by a factor $\sqrt{1+ξ}$, with $ξ= \fracα{9π} (B_0/B_{cr})^2$, where $α$ is the fine-structure constant and $B_{cr}$ the Schwinger critical magnetic field. Although derived for a cold system, these results are valid for the kinetic case. The results are valid in the range $ξ\ll 1$ and, actually, up to linear corrections in $ξ$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Modified jump conditions for parallel collisionless shocks
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
Within the context of Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), the properties of a parallel shock do not depend on the field strength, as the field and the fluid are disconnected for such a geometry. However, in the collisionless case, the field can sustain a stable anisotropy in the downstream, triggering a departure from the expected MHD behavior. In a recent work [A. Bret and R. Narayan, J. Plasma Phys. \te…
▽ More
Within the context of Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), the properties of a parallel shock do not depend on the field strength, as the field and the fluid are disconnected for such a geometry. However, in the collisionless case, the field can sustain a stable anisotropy in the downstream, triggering a departure from the expected MHD behavior. In a recent work [A. Bret and R. Narayan, J. Plasma Phys. \textbf{84}, 905840604 (2018)], a theoretical model was presented allowing to derive the density ratio of a non-relativistic parallel collisionless shock in an electron/positron plasma, as a function of the field. Here we derive the entropy, pressure and temperature jumps stemming from this model. It is found to offer a transition between a 3D and a 1D downstream for the jumps in density, entropy, parallel temperature and parallel pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Bridging the gap between collisional and collisionless shock waves
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Asaf Pe'er
Abstract:
While the front of a fluid shock is a few mean-free-paths thick, the front of a collisionless shock can be orders of magnitude thinner. By bridging between a collisional and a collisionless formalism, we assess the transition between these two regimes. We consider non-relativistic, un-magnetized, planar shocks in electron/ion plasmas. In addition, our treatment of the collisionless regime is restr…
▽ More
While the front of a fluid shock is a few mean-free-paths thick, the front of a collisionless shock can be orders of magnitude thinner. By bridging between a collisional and a collisionless formalism, we assess the transition between these two regimes. We consider non-relativistic, un-magnetized, planar shocks in electron/ion plasmas. In addition, our treatment of the collisionless regime is restricted to high Mach number electrostatic shocks. We find that the transition can be parameterized by the upstream plasma parameter $Λ$ which measures the coupling of the upstream medium. For $Λ\lesssim 1.12$, the upstream is collisional, i.e. strongly coupled, and the strong shock front is about $\mathcal{M}_1 λ_{\mathrm{mfp},1}$ thick, where $λ_{\mathrm{mfp},1}$ and $\mathcal{M}_1 $ are the upstream mean-free-path and Mach number respectively. A transition occurs for $Λ\sim 1.12$ beyond which the front is $\sim \mathcal{M}_1λ_{\mathrm{mfp},1}\ln Λ/Λ$ thick for $Λ\gtrsim 1.12$. Considering $Λ$ can reach billions in astrophysical settings, this allows to understand how the front of a collisionless shock can be orders of magnitude smaller than the mean-free-path, and how physics transitions continuously between these 2 extremes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Can we trust MHD jump conditions for collisionless shocks?
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
When applied to compute the density jump of a shock, the standard magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) formalism assumes, 1) that all the upstream material passes downstream, together with the momentum and energy it carries, and 2) that pressures are isotropic. In a collisionless shock, shock accelerated particles going back and forth around the front can invalid the first assumption. In addition, an externa…
▽ More
When applied to compute the density jump of a shock, the standard magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) formalism assumes, 1) that all the upstream material passes downstream, together with the momentum and energy it carries, and 2) that pressures are isotropic. In a collisionless shock, shock accelerated particles going back and forth around the front can invalid the first assumption. In addition, an external magnetic field can sustain stable pressure anisotropies, invaliding the second assumption. It is therefore unclear whether the density jump of a collisionless shock fulfils the MHD jump or not.
Here we try to clarify this issue. A literature review is conducted on 68 articles dealing with Particle-In-Cell simulations of collisionless shocks. We analyze the factors triggering departure from the MHD density jump and quantify their influence on $Δ_{RH}$, the relative departure from the Rankine-Hugoniot jump. For small departures we propose $Δ_{RH} = + \mathcal{O}(10^{-1-3.7κ})t^κ- σ\mathcal{O}(1)$ where $t$ is the timescale of the simulation, $σ$ the magnetization parameter and $κ$ a constant of order unity. The first term stems from the energy leakage into accelerated particle. The second term stems from the downstream anisotropy triggered by the field (assuming an isotropic upstream). This relation allows to assess to which extent a collisionless shock fulfils the RH density jump.
In the strong field limit and for parallel shocks, the departure caused by the field saturates at a finite, negative, value. For perpendicular shocks, the departure goes to zero at small and high $σ$'s so that we find here a departure window. The results obtained have to be checked against full 3D simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Particle trajectories in Weibel filaments: influence of external field obliquity and chaos
Authors:
A Bret,
M E Dieckmann
Abstract:
When two collisionless plasma shells collide, they interpenetrate and the overlap** region may turn Weibel unstable for some values of the collision parameters. This instability grows magnetic filaments which, at saturation, have to block the incoming flow if a Weibel shock is to form. In a recent paper [J. Plasma Phys. (2016), vol. 82, 905820403], it was found implementing a toy model for the i…
▽ More
When two collisionless plasma shells collide, they interpenetrate and the overlap** region may turn Weibel unstable for some values of the collision parameters. This instability grows magnetic filaments which, at saturation, have to block the incoming flow if a Weibel shock is to form. In a recent paper [J. Plasma Phys. (2016), vol. 82, 905820403], it was found implementing a toy model for the incoming particles trajectories in the filaments, that a strong enough external magnetic field $\mathbf{B}_0$ can prevent the filaments to block the flow if it is aligned with. Denoting $B_f$ the peak value of the field in the magnetic filaments, all test particles stream through them if $α=B_0/B_f > 1/2$. Here, this result is extended to the case of an oblique external field $B_0$ making an angle $θ$ with the flow. The result, numerically found, is simply $α> κ(θ)/\cosθ$, where $κ(θ)$ is of order unity. Noteworthily, test particles exhibit chaotic trajectories.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Density jump as a function of magnetic field for collisionless shocks in pair plasmas: the perpendicular case
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
In the absence of frequent binary collisions to isotropize the plasma, the fulfillment of the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions by collisionless shocks is not trivial. In particular, the presence of an external magnetic field can allow for stable anisotropies, implying some departures from the isotropic MHD jumps. The functional dependence of such anisotropies in terms of…
▽ More
In the absence of frequent binary collisions to isotropize the plasma, the fulfillment of the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions by collisionless shocks is not trivial. In particular, the presence of an external magnetic field can allow for stable anisotropies, implying some departures from the isotropic MHD jumps. The functional dependence of such anisotropies in terms of the field is yet to be determined. By hypothesizing a kinetic history of the plasma through the shock front, we recently devised a theory of the downstream anisotropy, hence of the density jump, in terms of the field strength for a parallel shock [J. Plasma Phys. (2018), vol. 84, 905840604]. Here, we extend the analysis to the case of a perpendicular shock. We still find that the field reduces the density jump, but the effect is less pronounced than in the parallel case.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Density jump as a function of magnetic field strength for parallel collisionless shocks in pair plasmas
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks follow the Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions to a good approximation. However, for a shock propagating parallel to a magnetic field, magnetohydrodynamics states that the shock properties are independent of the field strength, whereas recent Particle-in-Cell simulations reveal a significant departure from magnetohydrodynamics behavior for such shocks in the collisionless regime.…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks follow the Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions to a good approximation. However, for a shock propagating parallel to a magnetic field, magnetohydrodynamics states that the shock properties are independent of the field strength, whereas recent Particle-in-Cell simulations reveal a significant departure from magnetohydrodynamics behavior for such shocks in the collisionless regime. This departure is found to be caused by a field-driven anisotropy in the downstream pressure, but the functional dependence of this anisotropy on the field strength is yet to be determined. Here, we present a non-relativistic model of the plasma evolution through the shock front, allowing for a derivation of the downstream anisotropy in terms of the field strength. Our scenario assumes double adiabatic evolution of a pair plasma through the shock front. As a result, the perpendicular temperature is conserved. If the resulting downstream is firehose stable, then the plasma remains in this state. If unstable, it migrates towards the firehose stability threshold. In both cases, the conservation equations, together with the relevant hypothesis made on the temperature, allows a full determination of the downstream anisotropy in terms of the field strength.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Expansion of a radially symmetric blast shell into a uniformly magnetized plasma
Authors:
M E Dieckmann,
Q Moreno,
D Doria,
L Romagnani,
G Sarri,
D Folini,
R Walder,
A Bret,
E d'Humieres,
M Borghesi
Abstract:
The expansion of a thermal pressure-driven radial blast shell into a dilute ambient plasma is examined with two-dimensional PIC simulations. The purpose is to determine if laminar shocks form in a collisionless plasma that resemble their magnetohydrodynamic counterparts. The ambient plasma is composed of electrons with the temperature 2 keV and cool fully ionized nitrogen ions. It is permeated by…
▽ More
The expansion of a thermal pressure-driven radial blast shell into a dilute ambient plasma is examined with two-dimensional PIC simulations. The purpose is to determine if laminar shocks form in a collisionless plasma that resemble their magnetohydrodynamic counterparts. The ambient plasma is composed of electrons with the temperature 2 keV and cool fully ionized nitrogen ions. It is permeated by a spatially uniform magnetic field. A forward shock forms between the shocked ambient medium and the pristine ambient medium, which changes from an ion acoustic one through a slow magnetosonic one to a fast magnetosonic shock with increasing shock propagation angles relative to the magnetic field. The slow magnetosonic shock that propagates obliquely to the magnetic field changes into a tangential discontinuity for a perpendicular propagation direction, which is in line with the magnetohydrodynamic model. The expulsion of the magnetic field by the expanding blast shell triggers an electron-cyclotron drift instability.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
On the Formation and Properties of Fluid Shocks and Collisionless Shock Waves in Astrophysical Plasmas
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Asaf Pe'er
Abstract:
When two plasmas collide, their interaction can be mediated by collisionless plasma instabilities or binary collisions between particles of each shell. By comparing the maximum growth rate of the collisionless instabilities with the collision frequency between particles of the shells, we determine the critical density separating the collisionless formation from the collisional formation of the res…
▽ More
When two plasmas collide, their interaction can be mediated by collisionless plasma instabilities or binary collisions between particles of each shell. By comparing the maximum growth rate of the collisionless instabilities with the collision frequency between particles of the shells, we determine the critical density separating the collisionless formation from the collisional formation of the resulting shock waves. This critical density is also the density beyond which the shock downstream is field free, as plasma instabilities do not have time to develop electromagnetic patterns. We further determine the conditions on the shells initial density and velocity for the downstream to be collisional. If these quantities fulfill the determined conditions, the collisionality of the downstream also prevents the shock from accelerating particles or generating strong magnetic fields. We compare the speed of sound with the relative speed of collision between the two shells, thus determining the portion of the parameters space where strong shock formation is possible for both classical and degenerate plasmas. Finally, we discuss the observational consequences in several astrophysical settings.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2018; v1 submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Electrostatic and magnetic instabilities in the transition layer of a collisionless weakly relativistic pair shock
Authors:
M E Dieckmann,
A Bret
Abstract:
Energetic electromagnetic emissions by astrophysical jets like those that are launched during the collapse of a massive star and trigger gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are partially attributed to relativistic internal shocks. The shocks are mediated in the collisionless plasma of such jets by the filamentation instability of counterstreaming particle beams. The filamentation instability grows fastest onl…
▽ More
Energetic electromagnetic emissions by astrophysical jets like those that are launched during the collapse of a massive star and trigger gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are partially attributed to relativistic internal shocks. The shocks are mediated in the collisionless plasma of such jets by the filamentation instability of counterstreaming particle beams. The filamentation instability grows fastest only if the beams move at a relativistic relative speed. We model here with a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation the collision of two cold pair clouds at the speed c/2 (c: speed of light). We demonstrate that the two-stream instability outgrows the filamentation instability for this speed and is thus responsible for the shock formation. The incomplete thermalization of the upstream plasma by its quasi-electrostatic waves allows other instabilities to grow. A shock transition layer forms, in which a filamentation instability modulates the plasma far upstream of the shock. The inflowing upstream plasma is progressively heated by a two-stream instability closer to the shock and compressed to the expected downstream density by the Weibel instability. The strong magnetic field due to the latter is confined to a layer 10 electron skin depths wide.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Emergence of MHD structures in a collisionless PIC simulation plasma
Authors:
M E Dieckmann,
D Folini,
R Walder,
L Romagnani,
E d'Humieres,
A Bret,
T Karlsson,
A Ynnerman
Abstract:
The expansion of a dense plasma into a dilute plasma across an initially uniform perpendicular magnetic field is followed with a one-dimensional particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation over MHD time scales. The dense plasma expands in the form of a fast rarefaction wave. The accelerated dilute plasma becomes separated from the dense plasma by a tangential discontinuity at its back. A fast magnetosonic s…
▽ More
The expansion of a dense plasma into a dilute plasma across an initially uniform perpendicular magnetic field is followed with a one-dimensional particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation over MHD time scales. The dense plasma expands in the form of a fast rarefaction wave. The accelerated dilute plasma becomes separated from the dense plasma by a tangential discontinuity at its back. A fast magnetosonic shock with the Mach number 1.5 forms at its front. Our simulation demonstrates how wave dispersion widens the shock transition layer into a train of nonlinear fast magnetosonic waves.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Expansion of a radial plasma blast shell into an ambient plasma
Authors:
M E Dieckmann,
D Doria,
H Ahmed,
L Romagnani,
G Sarri,
D Folini,
R Walder,
A Bret,
M Borghesi
Abstract:
The expansion of a radial blast shell into an ambient plasma is modeled with a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation. The unmagnetized plasma consists of electrons and protons. The formation and evolution of an electrostatic shock is observed, which is trailed by ion-acoustic solitary waves that grow on the beam of the blast shell ions in the post-shock plasma. In spite of the initially radially symme…
▽ More
The expansion of a radial blast shell into an ambient plasma is modeled with a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation. The unmagnetized plasma consists of electrons and protons. The formation and evolution of an electrostatic shock is observed, which is trailed by ion-acoustic solitary waves that grow on the beam of the blast shell ions in the post-shock plasma. In spite of the initially radially symmetric outflow, the solitary waves become twisted and entangled and, hence, they break the radial symmetry of the flow. The waves and their interaction with the shocked ambient ions slows down the blast shell protons and brings the post-shock plasma closer to an equilibrium.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Hierarchy of instabilities for two counter-streaming magnetized pair beams: influence of field obliquity
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Mark Eric Dieckmann
Abstract:
The hierarchy of unstable modes when two counter-streaming pair plasmas interact over a flow-aligned magnetic field has been recently investigated [PoP \textbf{23}, 062122 (2016)]. The analysis is here extended to the case of an arbitrarily tilted magnetic field. The two plasma shells are initially cold and identical. For any angle $θ\in [0,π/2]$ between the field and the initial flow, the hierarc…
▽ More
The hierarchy of unstable modes when two counter-streaming pair plasmas interact over a flow-aligned magnetic field has been recently investigated [PoP \textbf{23}, 062122 (2016)]. The analysis is here extended to the case of an arbitrarily tilted magnetic field. The two plasma shells are initially cold and identical. For any angle $θ\in [0,π/2]$ between the field and the initial flow, the hierarchy of unstable modes is numerically determined in terms of the initial Lorentz factor of the shells $γ_0$, and the field strength as measured by a parameter denoted $σ$. For $θ=0$, four different kinds of mode are likely to lead the linear phase. The hierarchy simplifies for larger $θ$'s, partly because the Weibel instability can no longer be cancelled in this regime. For $θ>0.78$ (44$^\circ$) and in the relativistic regime, the Weibel instability always govern the interaction. In the non-relativistic regime, the hierarchy becomes $θ$-independent because the interaction turns to be field-independent. As a result, the two-stream instability becomes the dominant one, regardless of the field obliquity.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Kinetic inhibition of MHD-shocks in the vicinity of a parallel magnetic field
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Asaf Pe'er,
Lorenzo Sironi,
Aleksander Sadowski,
Ramesh Narayan
Abstract:
According to magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), the encounter of two collisional magnetized plasmas at high velocity gives rise to shock waves. Investigations conducted so far have found that the same conclusion still holds in the case of collisionless plasmas. For the case of a flow-aligned field, MHD stipulates that the field and the fluid are disconnected, so that the shock produced is independent of…
▽ More
According to magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), the encounter of two collisional magnetized plasmas at high velocity gives rise to shock waves. Investigations conducted so far have found that the same conclusion still holds in the case of collisionless plasmas. For the case of a flow-aligned field, MHD stipulates that the field and the fluid are disconnected, so that the shock produced is independent of the field. We present a violation of this MHD prediction when considering the encounter of two cold pair plasmas along a flow-aligned magnetic field. As the guiding magnetic field grows, isotropization is progressively suppressed, resulting in a strong influence of the field on the resulting structure. A micro-physics analysis allows to understand the mechanisms at work. Particle-in-cell simulations also support our conclusions and show that the results are not restricted to a strictly parallel field.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Simulation study of the formation of a non-relativistic pair shock
Authors:
Mark Eric Dieckmann,
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
We examine with a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation the collision of two equally dense clouds of cold pair plasma. The clouds interpenetrate until instabilities set in, which heat up the plasma and trigger the formation of a pair of shocks. The fastest-growing waves at the collision speed c/5 and low temperature are the electrostatic two-stream mode and the quasi-electrostatic oblique mode. Both w…
▽ More
We examine with a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation the collision of two equally dense clouds of cold pair plasma. The clouds interpenetrate until instabilities set in, which heat up the plasma and trigger the formation of a pair of shocks. The fastest-growing waves at the collision speed c/5 and low temperature are the electrostatic two-stream mode and the quasi-electrostatic oblique mode. Both waves grow and saturate via the formation of phase space vortices. The strong electric fields of these nonlinear plasma structures provide an efficient means of heating up and compressing the inflowing upstream leptons. The interaction of the hot leptons, which leak back into the upstream region, with the inflowing cool upstream leptons continuously drives electrostatic waves that mediate the shock. These waves heat up the inflowing upstream leptons primarily along the shock normal, which results in an anisotropic velocity distribution in the post-shock region. This distribution gives rise to the Weibel instability. Our simulation shows that even if the shock is mediated by quasi-electrostatic waves, strong magnetowaves will still develop in its downstream region.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Simple model on collisionless thin-shell instability growth
Authors:
Domenico Doria,
Antoine Bret,
Mark E. Dieckmann
Abstract:
The manuscript discusses a simple model on the Thin Shell Instability (TSI) growth phenomenon at early stage, by only imposing the fulfillment of conservation laws; and in particular just applying the laws of mass and linear momentum conservation, without taking into account the energy partitioning inside the thin shell.
The manuscript discusses a simple model on the Thin Shell Instability (TSI) growth phenomenon at early stage, by only imposing the fulfillment of conservation laws; and in particular just applying the laws of mass and linear momentum conservation, without taking into account the energy partitioning inside the thin shell.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Particles trajectories in Weibel magnetic filaments with a flow-aligned magnetic field
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
For a Weibel shock to form, two plasma shells have to collide and trigger the Weibel instability. At saturation, this instability generates in the overlap** region magnetic filaments with peak field $B_f$. In the absence of an external guiding magnetic field, these filaments can block the incoming flow, initiating the shock formation, if their size is larger than the Larmor radius of the incomin…
▽ More
For a Weibel shock to form, two plasma shells have to collide and trigger the Weibel instability. At saturation, this instability generates in the overlap** region magnetic filaments with peak field $B_f$. In the absence of an external guiding magnetic field, these filaments can block the incoming flow, initiating the shock formation, if their size is larger than the Larmor radius of the incoming particles in the peak field. Here we show that this results still holds in the presence of an external magnetic field $B_0$, provided it is not too high. Yet, for $B_0 \gtrsim B_f/2$, the filaments become unable to stop any particle, regardless of its initially velocity.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Hierarchy of instabilities for two counter-streaming magnetized pair beams
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
The instabilities triggered when two counter-streaming pair beams collide are analyzed. A guiding magnetic field is accounting for, while both beams are considered identical and cold. The instability analysis is conducted over the full \textbf{k}-spectrum, allowing to derive the hierarchy map of the dominant unstable modes, in terms of the initial beams energy $γ_0$ and a magnetic field strength p…
▽ More
The instabilities triggered when two counter-streaming pair beams collide are analyzed. A guiding magnetic field is accounting for, while both beams are considered identical and cold. The instability analysis is conducted over the full \textbf{k}-spectrum, allowing to derive the hierarchy map of the dominant unstable modes, in terms of the initial beams energy $γ_0$ and a magnetic field strength parameter $Ω_B$. Four different regions of the $(Ω_B,γ_0)$ phase space are identified, each one governed by a different kind of mode. The analysis also unravels the existence of a "triple point", where 3 different modes grow exactly the same rate. A number of analytical expressions can be derived, either for the modes growth-rates, or for the frontiers between the 4 regions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Physics of collisionless shocks - theory and simulation
Authors:
A. Stockem Novo,
A. Bret,
R. A. Fonseca,
L. O. Silva
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks occur in various fields of physics. In the context of space and astrophysics they have been investigated for many decades. However, a thorough understanding of shock formation and particle acceleration is still missing. Collisionless shocks can be distinguished into electromagnetic and electrostatic shocks. Electromagnetic shocks are of importance mainly in astrophysical envir…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks occur in various fields of physics. In the context of space and astrophysics they have been investigated for many decades. However, a thorough understanding of shock formation and particle acceleration is still missing. Collisionless shocks can be distinguished into electromagnetic and electrostatic shocks. Electromagnetic shocks are of importance mainly in astrophysical environments and they are mediated by the Weibel or filamentation instability. In such shocks, charged particles gain energy by diffusive shock acceleration. Electrostatic shocks are characterized by a strong electrostatic field, which leads to electron trap**. Ions are accelerated by reflection from the electrostatic potential. Shock formation and particle acceleration will be discussed in theory and simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
A thin-shell instability in collisionless plasma
Authors:
M. E. Dieckmann,
H. Ahmed,
D. Doria,
G. Sarri,
R. Walder,
D. Folini,
A. Bret,
A. Ynnerman,
M. Borghesi
Abstract:
The thin-shell instability has been named as one process, which can generate entangled structures in astrophysical plasma on collisional (fluid) scales. It is driven by a spatially varying imbalance between the ram pressure of the inflowing upstream plasma and the downstream's thermal pressure at a non-planar shock. Here we show by means of a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation that an analogue proc…
▽ More
The thin-shell instability has been named as one process, which can generate entangled structures in astrophysical plasma on collisional (fluid) scales. It is driven by a spatially varying imbalance between the ram pressure of the inflowing upstream plasma and the downstream's thermal pressure at a non-planar shock. Here we show by means of a particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation that an analogue process can destabilize a thin shell formed by two interpenetrating, unmagnetized and collisionless plasma clouds. The amplitude of the shell's spatial modulation grows and saturates after about ten inverse proton plasma frequencies, when the shell consists of connected piecewise linear patches.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Particles trajectories in magnetic filaments
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
The motion of a particle in a spatially harmonic magnetic field is a basic problem involved, for example, in the mechanism of formation of a collisionless shock. In such settings, it is generally reasoned that particles entering a Weibel generated turbulence are trapped inside it, provided their Larmor radius in the peak field is smaller than the field coherence length. The goal of this work is to…
▽ More
The motion of a particle in a spatially harmonic magnetic field is a basic problem involved, for example, in the mechanism of formation of a collisionless shock. In such settings, it is generally reasoned that particles entering a Weibel generated turbulence are trapped inside it, provided their Larmor radius in the peak field is smaller than the field coherence length. The goal of this work is to put this heuristic conclusion on firm ground by studying, both analytically and numerically, such motion. A toy model is analyzed, consisting of a relativistic particle entering a region of space occupied by a spatially harmonic field. The particle penetrates the magnetic structure in a direction aligned with the magnetic filaments. Although the conclusions are not trivial, the main result is confirmed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Shock formation in electron-ion plasmas: mechanism and timing
Authors:
Anne Stockem Novo,
Antoine Bret,
Ricardo A. Fonseca,
Luis O. Silva
Abstract:
We analyse the full shock formation process in electron-ion plasmas in theory and simulations. It is accepted that electromagnetic shocks in initially unmagnetised relativistic plasmas are triggered by the filamentation instability. However, the transition from the first unstable phase to the quasi-steady shock is still missing. We derive a theoretical model for the shock formation time, taking in…
▽ More
We analyse the full shock formation process in electron-ion plasmas in theory and simulations. It is accepted that electromagnetic shocks in initially unmagnetised relativistic plasmas are triggered by the filamentation instability. However, the transition from the first unstable phase to the quasi-steady shock is still missing. We derive a theoretical model for the shock formation time, taking into account the filament merging in the non-linear phase of the filamentation instability. This process is much slower than in electron-positron pair shocks, so that the shock formation is longer by a factor proportional to sqrt(m_i/m_e) ln(m_i/m_e).
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Collisional behaviors of astrophysical collisionless plasmas
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
In collisional fluids, a number of key processes rely on the frequency of binary collisions. Collisions seem necessary to generate a shock wave when two fluids collide fast enough, to fulfill the Rankine-Hugoniot relations, to establish an equation of state or a Maxwellian distribution. Yet, these seemingly collisional features are routinely either observed or assumed, in relation with collision\e…
▽ More
In collisional fluids, a number of key processes rely on the frequency of binary collisions. Collisions seem necessary to generate a shock wave when two fluids collide fast enough, to fulfill the Rankine-Hugoniot relations, to establish an equation of state or a Maxwellian distribution. Yet, these seemingly collisional features are routinely either observed or assumed, in relation with collision\emph{less} astrophysical plasmas. This article will review our current answers to the following questions: How do colliding collisionless plasmas end-up generating a shock as if they were fluids? To which extent are the Rankine-Hugoniot relations fulfilled in this case? Do collisionless shocks propagate like fluid ones? Can we use an equation of state to describe collisionless plasmas, like MHD codes for astrophysics do? Why are Maxwellian distributions ubiquitous in Particle-In-Cell simulations of collisionless shocks? Time and length scales defining the border between the collisional and the collisionless behavior will be given when relevant. In general, when the time and length scales involved in the collisionless processes responsible for the fluid-like behavior may be neglected, the system may be treated like a fluid.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Collisionless Weibel shocks: full formation mechanism and timing
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Anne Stockem,
Ramesh Narayan,
Luis O. Silva
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks in plasmas play an important role in space physics (Earth's bow shock) and astrophysics (supernova remnants, relativistic jets, gamma-ray bursts, high energy cosmic rays). While the formation of a fluid shock through the steepening of a large amplitude sound wave has been understood for long, there is currently no detailed picture of the mechanism responsible for the formation…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks in plasmas play an important role in space physics (Earth's bow shock) and astrophysics (supernova remnants, relativistic jets, gamma-ray bursts, high energy cosmic rays). While the formation of a fluid shock through the steepening of a large amplitude sound wave has been understood for long, there is currently no detailed picture of the mechanism responsible for the formation of a collisionless shock. We unravel the physical mechanism at work and show that an electromagnetic Weibel shock always forms when two relativistic collisionless, initially unmagnetized, plasma shells encounter. The predicted shock formation time is in good agreement with 2D and 3D particle-in-cell simulations of counterstreaming pair plasmas. By predicting the shock formation time, experimental setups aiming at producing such shocks can be optimised to favourable conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Influence of flavor oscillations on neutrino beam instabilities
Authors:
José Tito Mendonça,
Fernando Haas,
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
We consider the collective neutrino plasma interactions, and study the electron plasma instabilities produced by a nearly mono-energetic neutrino beam in a plasma. We describe the mutual influence of neutrino flavor oscillations and electron plasma waves. We show that the neutrino flavor oscillations are not only perturbed by electron plasmas waves, but also contribute to the dispersion relation a…
▽ More
We consider the collective neutrino plasma interactions, and study the electron plasma instabilities produced by a nearly mono-energetic neutrino beam in a plasma. We describe the mutual influence of neutrino flavor oscillations and electron plasma waves. We show that the neutrino flavor oscillations are not only perturbed by electron plasmas waves, but also contribute to the dispersion relation and the growth rates of neutrino beam instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Robustness of the filamentation instability in arbitrarily oriented magnetic field: Full 3D calculation
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
The filamentation (Weibel) instability plays a key role in the formation of collisionless shocks which are thought to produce Gamma-Ray-Bursts and High-Energy-Cosmic-Rays in astrophysical environments. While it has been known for long that a flow-aligned magnetic field can completely quench the instability, it was recently proved in 2D that in the cold regime, such cancelation is possible if and o…
▽ More
The filamentation (Weibel) instability plays a key role in the formation of collisionless shocks which are thought to produce Gamma-Ray-Bursts and High-Energy-Cosmic-Rays in astrophysical environments. While it has been known for long that a flow-aligned magnetic field can completely quench the instability, it was recently proved in 2D that in the cold regime, such cancelation is possible if and only if the field is perfectly aligned. Here, this result is finally extended to a 3D geometry. Calculations are conducted for symmetric and asymmetric counter-streaming relativistic plasma shells. 2D results are retrieved in 3D: the instability can never be completely canceled for an oblique magnetic field. In addition, the maximum growth-rate is always larger for wave vectors lying in the plan defined by the flow and the oblique field. On the one hand, this bears consequences on the orientation of the generated filaments. On the other hand, it certifies 2D simulations of the problem can be performed without missing the most unstable filamentation modes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Exploring the nature of collisionless shocks under laboratory conditions
Authors:
A. Stockem,
F. Fiuza,
A. Bret,
R. A. Fonseca,
L. O. Silva
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks are pervasive in astrophysics and they are critical to understand cosmic ray acceleration. Laboratory experiments with intense lasers are now opening the way to explore and characterise the underlying microphysics, which determine the acceleration process of collisionless shocks. We determine the shock character - electrostatic or electromagnetic - based on the stability of el…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks are pervasive in astrophysics and they are critical to understand cosmic ray acceleration. Laboratory experiments with intense lasers are now opening the way to explore and characterise the underlying microphysics, which determine the acceleration process of collisionless shocks. We determine the shock character - electrostatic or electromagnetic - based on the stability of electrostatic shocks to transverse electromagnetic fluctuations as a function of the electron temperature and flow velocity of the plasma components, and we compare the analytical model with particle-in-cell simulations. By making the connection with the laser parameters driving the plasma flows, we demonstrate that shocks with different and distinct underlying microphysics can be explored in the laboratory with state-of-the-art laser systems.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Robustness of the filamentation instability for asymmetric plasma shells collision in arbitrarily oriented magnetic field
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
The filamentation instability triggered when two counter streaming plasma shells overlap appears to be the main mechanism by which collisionless shocks are generated. It has been known for long that a flow aligned magnetic field can completely suppress this instability. In a recent paper [PHYSICS OF PLASMAS 18, 080706 (2011)], it was demonstrated in two dimensions that for the case of two cold, sy…
▽ More
The filamentation instability triggered when two counter streaming plasma shells overlap appears to be the main mechanism by which collisionless shocks are generated. It has been known for long that a flow aligned magnetic field can completely suppress this instability. In a recent paper [PHYSICS OF PLASMAS 18, 080706 (2011)], it was demonstrated in two dimensions that for the case of two cold, symmetric, relativistically colliding shells, such cancellation cannot occur if the field is not perfectly aligned. Here, this result is extended to the case of two asymmetric shells. The filamentation instability appears therefore as an increasingly robust mechanism to generate shocks.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Collisionless shock formation, spontaneous electromagnetic fluctuations and streaming instabilities
Authors:
A. Bret,
A. Stockem,
F. Fiuza,
C. Ruyer,
L. Gremillet,
R. Narayan,
L. O. Silva
Abstract:
Collisionless shocks are ubiquitous in astrophysics and in the lab. Recent numerical simulations and experiments have shown how they can arise from the encounter of two collisionless plasma shells. When the shells interpenetrate, the overlap** region turns unstable, triggering the shock formation. As a first step towards a microscopic understanding of the process, we analyze here in detail the i…
▽ More
Collisionless shocks are ubiquitous in astrophysics and in the lab. Recent numerical simulations and experiments have shown how they can arise from the encounter of two collisionless plasma shells. When the shells interpenetrate, the overlap** region turns unstable, triggering the shock formation. As a first step towards a microscopic understanding of the process, we analyze here in detail the initial instability phase. On the one hand, 2D relativistic PIC simulations are performed where two symmetric initially cold pair plasmas collide. On the other hand, the instabilities at work are analyzed, as well as the field at saturation and the seed field which gets amplified. For mildly relativistic motions and onward, Weibel modes govern the linear phase. We derive an expression for the duration of the linear phase in good agreement with the simulations. This saturation time constitutes indeed a lower-bound for the shock formation time.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2013; v1 submitted 17 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Nonrelativistic parallel shocks in unmagnetized and weakly magnetized plasmas
Authors:
Jacek Niemiec,
Martin Pohl,
Antoine Bret,
Volkmar Wieland
Abstract:
We present results of 2D3V particle-in-cell simulations of non-relativistic plasma collisions with absent or parallel large-scale magnetic field for parameters applicable to the conditions at young supernova remnants. We study the collision of plasma slabs of different density, leading to two different shocks and a contact discontinuity. Electron dynamics play an important role in the development…
▽ More
We present results of 2D3V particle-in-cell simulations of non-relativistic plasma collisions with absent or parallel large-scale magnetic field for parameters applicable to the conditions at young supernova remnants. We study the collision of plasma slabs of different density, leading to two different shocks and a contact discontinuity. Electron dynamics play an important role in the development of the system. While non-relativistic shocks in both unmagnetized and magnetized plasmas can be mediated by Weibel-type instabilities, the efficiency of shock-formation processes is higher when a large-scale magnetic field is present. The electron distributions downstream of the forward and reverse shocks are generally isotropic, whereas that is not always the case for the ions. We do not see any significant evidence of pre-acceleration, neither in the electron population nor in the ion distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Quantum effects in beam-plasma instabilities
Authors:
A. Bret,
F. Haas
Abstract:
Among the numerous works on quantum effects that have been published in recent years, streaming instabilities in plasma have also been revisited. Both the fluid quantum and the kinetic Wigner-Maxwell models have been used to explore quantum effects on the Weibel, Filamentation and Two-Stream instabilities. While quantum effects usually tend to reduce the instabilities, they can also spur new unsta…
▽ More
Among the numerous works on quantum effects that have been published in recent years, streaming instabilities in plasma have also been revisited. Both the fluid quantum and the kinetic Wigner-Maxwell models have been used to explore quantum effects on the Weibel, Filamentation and Two-Stream instabilities. While quantum effects usually tend to reduce the instabilities, they can also spur new unstable branches. A number of theoretical results will be reviewed together with the implications to one physical setting, namely the electron driven fast ignition scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Nonlinear low-frequency collisional quantum Buneman instability
Authors:
F. Haas,
A. Bret
Abstract:
The Buneman instability occurring when an electron population is drifting with respect to the ions is analyzed in the quantum linear and nonlinear regimes. The one-dimensional low-frequency and collisional model of Shokri and Niknam [Phys. Plasmas, v. 12, p. 062110 (2005)] is revisited introducing the Bohm potential term in the momentum equation. The linear regime is investigated analytically, and…
▽ More
The Buneman instability occurring when an electron population is drifting with respect to the ions is analyzed in the quantum linear and nonlinear regimes. The one-dimensional low-frequency and collisional model of Shokri and Niknam [Phys. Plasmas, v. 12, p. 062110 (2005)] is revisited introducing the Bohm potential term in the momentum equation. The linear regime is investigated analytically, and quantum effects result in a reduction of the instability. The nonlinear regime is then assessed both numerically and analytically, and pure quantum density oscillations are found to appear during the late evolution of the instability.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
CfA Plasma Talks
Authors:
Antoine Bret
Abstract:
Notes from a series of 13 one hour (or more) lectures on Plasma Physics given to Ramesh Narayan' research group at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, between January and July 2012.
Lectures 1 to 5 cover various key Plasma Physics themes. Lectures 6 to 12 mainly go over the Review Paper on "Multidimensional electron beam-plasma instabilities in the relativistic regime" [\emph{Physic…
▽ More
Notes from a series of 13 one hour (or more) lectures on Plasma Physics given to Ramesh Narayan' research group at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, between January and July 2012.
Lectures 1 to 5 cover various key Plasma Physics themes. Lectures 6 to 12 mainly go over the Review Paper on "Multidimensional electron beam-plasma instabilities in the relativistic regime" [\emph{Physics of Plasmas} \textbf{17}, 120501 (2010)]. Lectures 13 talks about the so-called Biermann battery and its ability to generate magnetic fields from scratch.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2012; v1 submitted 29 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Harmonic analysis of irradiation asymmetry for cylindrical implosions driven by high-frequency rotating ion beams
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Roberto Piriz,
Naeem Tahir
Abstract:
Cylindrical implosions driven by intense heavy ions beams should be instrumental in a near future to study High Energy Density Matter. By rotating the beam by means of a high frequency wobbler, it should be possible to deposit energy in the outer layers of a cylinder, compressing the material deposited in its core. The beam temporal profile should however generate an inevitable irradiation asymmet…
▽ More
Cylindrical implosions driven by intense heavy ions beams should be instrumental in a near future to study High Energy Density Matter. By rotating the beam by means of a high frequency wobbler, it should be possible to deposit energy in the outer layers of a cylinder, compressing the material deposited in its core. The beam temporal profile should however generate an inevitable irradiation asymmetry likely to feed the Rayleigh-Taylor instability (RTI) during the implosion phase. In this paper, we compute the Fourier components of the target irradiation in order to make the junction with previous works on RTI performed in this setting. Implementing a 1D and 2D beam models, we find these components can be expressed exactly in terms of the Fourier transform of the temporal beam profile. If $T$ is the beam duration and $Ω$ its rotation frequency, "magic products" $ΩT$ can be identified which cancel the first harmonic of the deposited density, resulting in an improved irradiation symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Robustness of the filamentation instability as shock mediator in arbitrarily oriented magnetic field
Authors:
Antoine Bret,
Erica Perez Alvaro
Abstract:
The filamentation instability (sometimes also referred to as "Weibel") is a key process in many astrophysical scenario. In the Fireball model for Gamma Ray Bursts, this instability is believed to mediate collisionless shock formation from the collision of two plasma shells. It has been known for long that a flow aligned magnetic field can completely cancel this instability. We show here that in th…
▽ More
The filamentation instability (sometimes also referred to as "Weibel") is a key process in many astrophysical scenario. In the Fireball model for Gamma Ray Bursts, this instability is believed to mediate collisionless shock formation from the collision of two plasma shells. It has been known for long that a flow aligned magnetic field can completely cancel this instability. We show here that in the general case where there is an angle between the field and the flow, the filamentation instability can never be stabilized, regardless of the field strength. The presented model analyzes the stability of two symmetric counter-streaming cold electron/proton plasma shells. Relativistic effects are accounted for, and various exact analytical results are derived. This result guarantees the occurrence of the instability in realistic settings fulfilling the cold approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Two-stream-like instability in dilute hot relativistic beams and astrophysical relativistic shocks
Authors:
Ehud Nakar,
Antoine Bret,
Milos Milosavljevic
Abstract:
Relativistic collisionless shocks are believed to be efficient particle accelerators. Nonlinear outcome of the interaction of accelerated particles that run ahead of the shock, the so-called "precursor", with the unperturbed plasma of the shock upstream, is thought to facilitate additional acceleration of these particles and to possibly modify the hydrodynamic structure of the shock. We explore he…
▽ More
Relativistic collisionless shocks are believed to be efficient particle accelerators. Nonlinear outcome of the interaction of accelerated particles that run ahead of the shock, the so-called "precursor", with the unperturbed plasma of the shock upstream, is thought to facilitate additional acceleration of these particles and to possibly modify the hydrodynamic structure of the shock. We explore here the linear growth of kinetic modes appearing in the precursor-upstream interaction in relativistic shocks propagating in non and weakly magnetized plasmas: electrostatic two-stream parallel mode and electrostatic oblique modes. These modes are of particular interest because they are the fastest growing modes known in this type of system. Using a simplified distribution function for a dilute ultra-relativistic beam that is relativistically hot in its own rest frame, yet has momenta that are narrowly collimated in the frame of the cold upstream plasma into which it propagates, we identify the fastest growing mode in the full $k$-space and calculate its growth rate. We consider all types of plasma (pairs and ions-electrons) and beam (charged and charge-neutral). We find that unstable electrostatic modes are present in any type of plasma and for any shock parameters. We further find that two modes, one parallel ($k_\perp=0$) and the other one oblique ($k_\perp \sim k_\|$), are competing for dominance and that either one may dominate the growth rate in different regions of the phase space. The dominant mode is determined mostly by the perpendicular spread of the accelerated particle momenta in the upstream frame, which reflects the shock Lorentz factor. The parallel mode becomes more dominant in shocks with lower Lorentz factors (i.e., with larger momentum spreads). We briefly discuss possible implications of our results for external shocks in gamma-ray burst sources.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2011; v1 submitted 27 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Intuitive calculation of the relativistic Rayleigh-Taylor instability linear growth rate
Authors:
A Bret
Abstract:
The Rayleigh-Taylor instability is a key process in many fields of Physics ranging from astrophysics to inertial confinement fusion. It is usually analyzed deriving the linearized fluid equations, but the physics behind the instability is not always clear. Recent works on this instability allow for an very intuitive understanding of the phenomenon and for a straightforward calculation of the linea…
▽ More
The Rayleigh-Taylor instability is a key process in many fields of Physics ranging from astrophysics to inertial confinement fusion. It is usually analyzed deriving the linearized fluid equations, but the physics behind the instability is not always clear. Recent works on this instability allow for an very intuitive understanding of the phenomenon and for a straightforward calculation of the linear growth rate. In this Letter, it is shown that the same reasoning allows for a direct derivation of the relativistic expression of the linear growth rate for an incompressible fluid.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Quantum kinetic theory of the filamentation instability
Authors:
A. Bret,
F. Haas
Abstract:
The quantum electromagnetic dielectric tensor for a multi species plasma is re-derived from the gauge invariant Wigner-Maxwell system and presented under a form very similar to the classical one. The resulting expression is then applied to a quantum kinetic theory of the electromagnetic filamentation instability. Comparison is made with the quantum fluid theory including a Bohm pressure term, and…
▽ More
The quantum electromagnetic dielectric tensor for a multi species plasma is re-derived from the gauge invariant Wigner-Maxwell system and presented under a form very similar to the classical one. The resulting expression is then applied to a quantum kinetic theory of the electromagnetic filamentation instability. Comparison is made with the quantum fluid theory including a Bohm pressure term, and with the cold classical plasma result. A number of analytical expressions are derived for the cutoff wave vector, the largest growth rate and the most unstable wave vector.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2011; v1 submitted 24 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Why is the earth not burning ? The earth radiative energy balance
Authors:
A Bret
Abstract:
The concept of energy balance is a key one in climate science. Yet, students may find it counterintuitive: while it is obvious that some energy comes in from the sun, the part coming out is more elusive. Asking them why the earth is not burning after billions of years of exposure to the sun, takes them to the question "where does the energy goes?" A series of Fermi like calculations then convinces…
▽ More
The concept of energy balance is a key one in climate science. Yet, students may find it counterintuitive: while it is obvious that some energy comes in from the sun, the part coming out is more elusive. Asking them why the earth is not burning after billions of years of exposure to the sun, takes them to the question "where does the energy goes?" A series of Fermi like calculations then convinces them that storage capabilities are negligible compared to the amount of energy coming in: the earth necessarily re-emits what it receives.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
How large can the electron to proton mass ratio be in Particle-In-Cell simulations of unstable systems?
Authors:
A. Bret,
M. E. Dieckmann
Abstract:
Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations are widely used as a tool to investigate instabilities that develop between a collisionless plasma and beams of charged particles. However, even on contemporary supercomputers, it is not always possible to resolve the ion dynamics in more than one spatial dimension with such simulations. The ion mass is thus reduced below 1836 electron masses, which can affect…
▽ More
Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations are widely used as a tool to investigate instabilities that develop between a collisionless plasma and beams of charged particles. However, even on contemporary supercomputers, it is not always possible to resolve the ion dynamics in more than one spatial dimension with such simulations. The ion mass is thus reduced below 1836 electron masses, which can affect the plasma dynamics during the initial exponential growth phase of the instability and during the subsequent nonlinear saturation. The goal of this article is to assess how far the electron to ion mass ratio can be increased, without changing qualitatively the physics. It is first demonstrated that there can be no exact similarity law, which balances a change of the mass ratio with that of another plasma parameter, leaving the physics unchanged. Restricting then the analysis to the linear phase, a criterion allowing to define a maximum ratio is explicated in terms of the hierarchy of the linear unstable modes. The criterion is applied to the case of a relativistic electron beam crossing an unmagnetized electron-ion plasma.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
