-
Local Nonlinear Elastic Response of Extracellular Matrices
Authors:
Haiqian Yang,
Estelle Berthier,
Chenghai Li,
Pierre Ronceray,
Yu Long Han,
Chase P. Broedersz,
Shengqiang Cai,
Ming Guo
Abstract:
Nonlinear stiffening is a ubiquitous property of major types of biopolymers that make up the extracellular matrices (ECM) including collagen, fibrin and basement membrane. Within the ECM, many types of cells such as fibroblasts and cancer cells are known to mechanically stretch their surroundings that locally stiffens the matrix. Although the bulk nonlinear elastic behaviors of these biopolymer ne…
▽ More
Nonlinear stiffening is a ubiquitous property of major types of biopolymers that make up the extracellular matrices (ECM) including collagen, fibrin and basement membrane. Within the ECM, many types of cells such as fibroblasts and cancer cells are known to mechanically stretch their surroundings that locally stiffens the matrix. Although the bulk nonlinear elastic behaviors of these biopolymer networks are well studied, their local mechanical responses remain poorly characterized. Here, to understand how a living cell feels the nonlinear mechanical resistance from the ECM, we mimic the cell-applied local force using optical tweezers; we report that the local stiffening responses in highly nonlinear ECM are significantly weaker than responses found in bulk rheology, across two orders of magnitude of the locally applied force since the onset of stiffening. With a minimal model, we show that a local point force application can induce a stiffened region in the matrix, which expands with increasing magnitude of the point force. Furthermore, we show that this stiffened region behaves as an effective probe upon local loading. The local nonlinear elastic response can be attributed to the nonlinear growth of this effective probe that linearly deforms an increasing portion of the matrix.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Nonlinear mechanosensation in fiber networks
Authors:
Estelle Berthier,
Haiqian Yang,
Ming Guo,
Pierre Ronceray,
Chase P. Broedersz
Abstract:
In a diversity of physiological contexts, eukaryotic cells adhere to an extracellular matrix (ECM), a disordered network with complex nonlinear mechanics. Such cells can perform mechanosensation: using local force probing they can measure and respond to their substrate's mechanical properties. It remains unclear, however, how the mechanical complexity of the ECM at the cellular scale impacts mecha…
▽ More
In a diversity of physiological contexts, eukaryotic cells adhere to an extracellular matrix (ECM), a disordered network with complex nonlinear mechanics. Such cells can perform mechanosensation: using local force probing they can measure and respond to their substrate's mechanical properties. It remains unclear, however, how the mechanical complexity of the ECM at the cellular scale impacts mechanosensation. Here, we investigate the physical limits of mechanosensation imposed by the inherent structural disorder and nonlinear elastic response of the ECM. Using a theoretical framework for disordered fiber networks, we find that the extreme mechanical heterogeneity that cells can locally sense with small probing forces is strongly reduced with increasing force. Specifically, we predict that the accuracy of mechanosensation dramatically improves with force, following a universal power law insensitive to constitutive details, which we quantitatively confirm using microrheology experiments in collagen and fibrin gels. We provide conceptual insights into this behavior by introducing a general model for nonlinear mechanosensation, based on the idea of an emergent nonlinear length-scale associated with fiber buckling. This force-dependent length-scale enhances the range over which local mechanical measurements are performed, thereby averaging the response of a disordered network over an enlarged region. We show with an example how a cell can use this nonlinear mechanosensation to infer the macroscopic mechanical properties of a disordered ECM using local measurements. Together, our results demonstrate that cells can take advantage of the inherent nonlinearity of fibrous networks to robustly sense, control, and respond to their mechanical environment.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
How criticality meets bifurcation in compressive failure of disordered solids
Authors:
Ashwij Mayya,
Estelle Berthier,
Laurent Ponson
Abstract:
Continuum mechanics describes compressive failure as a standard bifurcation in the response of a material to an increasing load: damage, which initially grows uniformly in the material, localizes within a thin band at failure. Yet, experiments recording the acoustic activity preceding localization evidence power-law distributed failure precursors of increasing size, suggesting that compressive fai…
▽ More
Continuum mechanics describes compressive failure as a standard bifurcation in the response of a material to an increasing load: damage, which initially grows uniformly in the material, localizes within a thin band at failure. Yet, experiments recording the acoustic activity preceding localization evidence power-law distributed failure precursors of increasing size, suggesting that compressive failure is a critical phenomenon. We examine here this apparent contradiction by probing the spatial organization of the damage activity and its evolution until localization during compression experiments of 2D cellular solids. The intermittent damage evolution measured in our experiments is adequately described by a non-stationary depinning equation derived from damage mechanics and reminiscent of critical phenomena. In this description, precursors are damage cascades emerging from the interplay between the material's disorder and the long-range stress redistributions following individual damage events. Yet, the divergence of their characteristic size close to failure, which we observe in our experiments, is not the signature of a transition towards criticality. Instead, the system remains at a fixed distance to the critical point at all stages of the damage evolution. The divergence results from the progressive loss of stability of the material as it is driven towards localization. Thus, our study shows that compressive failure is a standard bifurcation for which the material disorder plays a marginal role. It also shows that precursory activity constitute by-products of the evolution towards localization and can serve to build a predictive method to assess the residual lifetime of structures.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2023; v1 submitted 25 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Damage spreading in quasi-brittle disordered solids: II. What the statistics of precursors teach us about compressive failure
Authors:
Estelle Berthier,
Ashwij Mayya,
Laurent Ponson
Abstract:
We investigate numerically and theoretically the precursory intermittent activity characterizing the preliminary phase of damage accumulation prior to failure of quasi-brittle solids. We use a minimal but thermodynamically consistent model of damage growth and localization developed by Berthier et al. (2017). The approach accounts for both microstructural disorder and non-local interactions and pe…
▽ More
We investigate numerically and theoretically the precursory intermittent activity characterizing the preliminary phase of damage accumulation prior to failure of quasi-brittle solids. We use a minimal but thermodynamically consistent model of damage growth and localization developed by Berthier et al. (2017). The approach accounts for both microstructural disorder and non-local interactions and permits inferring a complete scaling description of the spatio-temporal structure of failure precursors. By develo** a theoretical model of damage growth in disordered elasto-damageable specimen, we demonstrate that these scaling relations emerge from the physics of elastic manifolds driven in disordered media, while the divergence of these quantities close to failure is reminiscent of the loss of stability of the specimen at the localization threshold. Our study sorts out a long-standing debate on the nature of the compressive failure point and the origin of the universal statistics of the precursors preceding it. Our analysis rules out a critical-point scenario in which the divergence of the precursor size close to failure is signature of a second-order phase transition governed by the microstructural disorder. Instead, we show that while the jerky evolution of damage prior to failure results from the presence of material disorder, the latter does not significantly change the nature of the localization process, which is an instability well described by standard bifurcation theory of homogeneous systems. Finally, we harness our detailed understanding of the precursory statistics to design a methodology to estimate the residual lifetime of a structure from the statistical analysis of precursors. This method relevant for structural health monitoring is shown to perform rather accurately on our data.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2022; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Fault orientation in damage failure under compression
Authors:
Véronique Dansereau,
Vincent Démery,
Estelle Berthier,
Jérôme Weiss,
Laurent Ponson
Abstract:
The Mohr-Coulomb criterion is widely used in geosciences to relate the state of stress at failure to the observed orientation of the resulting faults. This relation is based on the assumption that the fault occurs along a plane that maximizes the Coulomb stress. Here, we test this hypothesis using an elastic, progressive damage model that implements the Mohr-Coulomb criterion at the local scale. W…
▽ More
The Mohr-Coulomb criterion is widely used in geosciences to relate the state of stress at failure to the observed orientation of the resulting faults. This relation is based on the assumption that the fault occurs along a plane that maximizes the Coulomb stress. Here, we test this hypothesis using an elastic, progressive damage model that implements the Mohr-Coulomb criterion at the local scale. We find that the orientation of the fault is not given by the Mohr-Coulomb criterion. Instead, for minimal disorder, it corresponds to the most unstable mode of damage in the model, which we determine through a linear stability analysis of the homogeneously damaged state. Our simulations show that microstructural disorder significantly affects the orientation of the fault, which, however, remains always far from the Mohr-Coulomb prediction.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
