-
A framework for experimental-data-driven assessment of Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion stagnation image metrics
Authors:
William E. Lewis,
Eric C. Harding,
David A. Yager-Elorriaga,
Jeffrey R. Fein,
Patrick F. Knapp,
Kristian Beckwith,
David J. Ampleford
Abstract:
A variety of spherical crystal x-ray imager (SCXI) diagnostics have been developed and fielded on Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) experiments at the Sandia National Laboratories Z-facility. These different imaging modalities provide detailed insight into different physical phenomena such as mix of liner material into the hot fuel, cold liner emission, or reduce impact of liner opacity. H…
▽ More
A variety of spherical crystal x-ray imager (SCXI) diagnostics have been developed and fielded on Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) experiments at the Sandia National Laboratories Z-facility. These different imaging modalities provide detailed insight into different physical phenomena such as mix of liner material into the hot fuel, cold liner emission, or reduce impact of liner opacity. However, several practical considerations ranging from the lack of a consistent spatial fiducial for registration to different point-spread-functions and tuning crystals or using filters to highlight specific spectral regions make it difficult to develop broadly applicable metrics to compare experiments across our stagnation image database without making significant unverified assumptions. We leverage experimental data for a model-free assessment of sensitivities to instrumentation-based features for any specified image metric. In particular, we utilize a database of historical and recent MagLIF data including $N_{\text{scans}} = 139$ image plate scans gathered across $N_{\text{exp}} = 67$ different experiments to assess the impact of a variety of features in the experimental observations arising from uncertainties in registration as well as discrepancies in signal-to-noise ratio and instrument resolution. We choose a wavelet-based image metric known as the Mallat Scattering Transform for the study and highlight how alternate metric choices could also be studied. In particular, we demonstrate a capability to understand and mitigate the impact of signal-to-noise, image registration, and resolution difference between images. This is achieved by utilizing multiple scans of the same image plate, sampling random translations and rotations, and applying instrument specific point-spread-functions found by ray tracing to high-resolution datasets, augmenting our data in an effectively model-free fashion.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
As a matter of dynamical range -- scale dependent energy dynamics in MHD turbulence
Authors:
Philipp Grete,
Brian W. O'Shea,
Kris Beckwith
Abstract:
Magnetized turbulence is ubiquitous in many astrophysical and terrestrial plasmas but no universal theory exists. Even the detailed energy dynamics in magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence are still not well understood. We present a suite of subsonic, super-Alfvénic, high plasma-beta MHD turbulence simulations that only vary in their dynamical range, i.e., in their separation between the large-scal…
▽ More
Magnetized turbulence is ubiquitous in many astrophysical and terrestrial plasmas but no universal theory exists. Even the detailed energy dynamics in magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence are still not well understood. We present a suite of subsonic, super-Alfvénic, high plasma-beta MHD turbulence simulations that only vary in their dynamical range, i.e., in their separation between the large-scale forcing and dissipation scales, and their dissipation mechanism (implicit large eddy simulation, ILES, versus and direct numerical simulation, DNS). Using an energy transfer analysis framework we calculate the effective, numerical viscosities and resistivities and demonstrate and that all ILES calculations of MHD turbulence are resolved and correspond to an equivalent visco-resistive MHD turbulence calculation. Increasing the number of grid points used in an ILES corresponds to lowering the dissipation coefficients, i.e., larger (kinetic and magnetic) Reynolds numbers for a constant forcing scale. Independently, we use this same framework to demonstrate that -- contrary to hydrodynamic turbulence -- the cross-scale energy fluxes are not constant in MHD turbulence. This applies both to different mediators (such as cascade processes or magnetic tension) for a given dynamical range as well as to a dependence on the dynamical range itself, which determines the physical properties of the flow. We do not observe any indication of convergence even at the highest resolution (largest Reynolds numbers) simulation at $2{,}048^3$ cells, calling into question whether an asymptotic regime in MHD turbulence exists, and, if so, what it looks like.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Exploring the parameter space of MagLIF implosions using similarity scaling. II. Current scaling
Authors:
D. E. Ruiz,
P. F. Schmit,
D. A. Yager-Elorriaga,
M. R. Gomez,
M. R. Weis,
C. A. Jennings,
A. J. Harvey-Thompson,
P. F. Knapp,
S. A. Slutz,
D. J. Ampleford,
K. Beckwith,
M. K. Matzen
Abstract:
Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) is a magneto-inertial-fusion (MIF) concept, which is presently being studied on the Z Pulsed Power Facility. The MagLIF platform has achieved interesting plasma conditions at stagnation and produced significant fusion yields in the laboratory. Given the relative success of MagLIF, there is a strong interest to scale the platform to higher peak currents. Ho…
▽ More
Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) is a magneto-inertial-fusion (MIF) concept, which is presently being studied on the Z Pulsed Power Facility. The MagLIF platform has achieved interesting plasma conditions at stagnation and produced significant fusion yields in the laboratory. Given the relative success of MagLIF, there is a strong interest to scale the platform to higher peak currents. However, scaling MagLIF is not entirely straightforward due to the large dimensionality of the experimental input parameter space and the large number of distinct physical processes involved in MIF implosions. In this work, we propose a novel method to scale MagLIF loads to higher currents. Our method is based on similarity (or similitude) scaling and attempts to preserve much of the physics regimes already known or being studied on today's Z pulsed-power driver. By avoiding significant deviations into unexplored and/or less well-understood regimes, the risk of unexpected outcomes on future scaled-up experiments is reduced. Using arguments based on similarity scaling, we derive the scaling rules for the experimental input parameters characterizing a MagLIF load (as functions of the characteristic current driving the implosion). We then test the estimated scaling laws for various metrics measuring performance against results of 2D radiation--magneto-hydrodynamic HYDRA simulations. Agreement is found between the scaling theory and the simulation results.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2023; v1 submitted 29 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Exploring the parameter space of MagLIF implosions using similarity scaling. I. Theoretical framework
Authors:
D. E. Ruiz,
P. F. Schmit,
D. A. Yager-Elorriaga,
C. A. Jennings,
K. Beckwith
Abstract:
Magneto-inertial fusion (MIF) concepts, such as the Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) platform [M. R. Gomez et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 155003 (2014)], constitute a promising path for achieving ignition and significant fusion yields in the laboratory. The space of experimental input parameters defining a MagLIF load is highly multi-dimensional, and the implosion itself is a complex event…
▽ More
Magneto-inertial fusion (MIF) concepts, such as the Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion (MagLIF) platform [M. R. Gomez et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 155003 (2014)], constitute a promising path for achieving ignition and significant fusion yields in the laboratory. The space of experimental input parameters defining a MagLIF load is highly multi-dimensional, and the implosion itself is a complex event involving many physical processes. In the first paper of this series, we develop a simplified analytical model that identifies the main physical processes at play during a MagLIF implosion. Using non-dimensional analysis, we determine the most important dimensionless parameters characterizing MagLIF implosions and provide estimates of such parameters using typical fielded or experimentally observed quantities for MagLIF. We then show that MagLIF loads can be "incompletely" similarity scaled, meaning that the experimental input parameters of MagLIF can be varied such that many (but not all) of the dimensionless quantities are conserved. Based on similarity-scaling arguments, we can explore the parameter space of MagLIF loads and estimate the performance of the scaled loads. In the follow-up papers of this series, we test the similar scaling theory for MagLIF loads against simulations for two different scaling "vectors", which include current scaling and rise-time scaling.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2023; v1 submitted 29 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Efficacy of the Radial Pair Potential Approximation for Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Dense Plasmas
Authors:
Lucas J. Stanek,
Raymond C. Clay III,
M. W. C. Dharma-wardana,
Mitchell A. Wood,
Kristian R. C. Beckwith,
Michael S. Murillo
Abstract:
Macroscopic simulations of dense plasmas rely on detailed microscopic information that can be computationally expensive and is difficult to verify experimentally. In this work, we delineate the accuracy boundary between microscale simulation methods by comparing Kohn-Sham density functional theory molecular dynamics (KS-MD) and radial pair potential molecular dynamics (RPP- MD) for a range of elem…
▽ More
Macroscopic simulations of dense plasmas rely on detailed microscopic information that can be computationally expensive and is difficult to verify experimentally. In this work, we delineate the accuracy boundary between microscale simulation methods by comparing Kohn-Sham density functional theory molecular dynamics (KS-MD) and radial pair potential molecular dynamics (RPP- MD) for a range of elements, temperature, and density. By extracting the optimal RPP from KS-MD data using force-matching, we constrain its functional form and dismiss classes of potentials that assume a constant power law for small interparticle distances. Our results show excellent agreement between RPP-MD and KS-MD for multiple metrics of accuracy at temperatures of only a few electron volts. The use of RPPs offers orders of magnitude decrease in computational cost and indicates that three-body potentials are not required beyond temperatures of a few eV. Due to its efficiency, the validated RPP-MD provides an avenue for reducing errors due to finite-size effects that can be on the order of $\sim20\%$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
As a matter of tension -- kinetic energy spectra in MHD turbulence
Authors:
Philipp Grete,
Brian W. O'Shea,
Kris Beckwith
Abstract:
Magnetized turbulence is ubiquitous in many astrophysical and terrestrial systems but no complete, uncontested theory even in the simplest form, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), exists. Many theories and phenomenologies focus on the joint (kinetic and magnetic) energy fluxes and spectra. We highlight the importance of treating kinetic and magnetic energies separately to shed light on MHD turbulence dyn…
▽ More
Magnetized turbulence is ubiquitous in many astrophysical and terrestrial systems but no complete, uncontested theory even in the simplest form, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), exists. Many theories and phenomenologies focus on the joint (kinetic and magnetic) energy fluxes and spectra. We highlight the importance of treating kinetic and magnetic energies separately to shed light on MHD turbulence dynamics. We conduct an implicit large eddy simulation of subsonic, super-Alfvénic MHD turbulence and analyze the scale-wise energy transfer over time. Our key finding is that the kinetic energy spectrum develops a scaling of approximately $k^{-4/3}$ in the stationary regime as the kinetic energy cascade is suppressed by magnetic tension. This motivates a reevaluation of existing MHD turbulence theories with respect to a more differentiated modeling of the energy fluxes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Multidimensional tests of a finite-volume solver for MHD with a real-gas equation of state
Authors:
J. R. King,
R. Masti,
B. Srinivasan,
K. Beckwith
Abstract:
This work considers two algorithms of a finite-volume solver for the MHD equations with a real-gas equation of state (EOS). Both algorithms use a multistate form of Harten-Lax-Van Leer approximate Riemann solver as formulated for MHD discontinuities. This solver is modified to use the generalized sound speed from the real-gas EOS. Two methods are tested: EOS evaluation at cell centers and at flux…
▽ More
This work considers two algorithms of a finite-volume solver for the MHD equations with a real-gas equation of state (EOS). Both algorithms use a multistate form of Harten-Lax-Van Leer approximate Riemann solver as formulated for MHD discontinuities. This solver is modified to use the generalized sound speed from the real-gas EOS. Two methods are tested: EOS evaluation at cell centers and at flux interfaces where the former is more computationally efficient. A battery of 1D and 2D tests are employed: convergence of 1D and 2D linearized waves, shock tube Riemann problems, a 2D nonlinear circularly polarized Alfvén wave, and a 2D magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instability test. The cell-centered EOS evaluation algorithm produces unresolvable thermodynamic inconsistencies in the intermediate states leading to spurious solutions while the flux-interface EOS evaluation algorithm robustly produces the correct solution. The linearized wave tests show this inconsistency is associated with the magnetosonic waves and the magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instability test demonstrates simulation results where the spurious solution leads to an unphysical simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
As A Matter of State: The role of thermodynamics in magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Philipp Grete,
Brian W. O'Shea,
Kris Beckwith
Abstract:
Turbulence simulations play a key role in advancing the general understanding of the physical properties turbulence and in interpreting astrophysical observations of turbulent plasmas. For the sake of simplicity, however, turbulence simulations are often conducted in the isothermal limit. Given that the majority of astrophysical systems are not governed by isothermal dynamics, we aim to quantify t…
▽ More
Turbulence simulations play a key role in advancing the general understanding of the physical properties turbulence and in interpreting astrophysical observations of turbulent plasmas. For the sake of simplicity, however, turbulence simulations are often conducted in the isothermal limit. Given that the majority of astrophysical systems are not governed by isothermal dynamics, we aim to quantify the impact of thermodynamics on the physics of turbulence, through varying adiabatic index, $γ$, combined with a range of optically thin cooling functions. In this paper, we present a suite of ideal magnetohydrodynamics simulations of thermally balanced stationary turbulence in the subsonic, super-Alfvénic, high beta (ratio of thermal to magnetic pressure) regime, where turbulent dissipation is balanced by two idealized cooling functions (approximating linear cooling and free-free emission) and examine the impact of the equation of state by considering cases that correspond to isothermal, monatomic and diatomic gases. We find a strong anticorrelation between thermal and magnetic pressure independent of thermodynamics, whereas the strong anticorrelation between density and magnetic field found in the isothermal case weakens with increasing $γ$. Similarly, with the linear relation between variations in density and thermal pressure with sonic Mach number becomes steeper with increasing $γ$. This suggests that there exists a degeneracy in these relations with respect to thermodynamics and Mach number in this regime, which is dominated by slow magnetosonic modes. These results have implications for attempts to infer (e.g.) Mach numbers from (e.g.) Faraday rotation measurements, without additional information regarding the thermodynamics of the plasma. However, our results suggest that this degeneracy can be broken by utilizing higher-order moments of observable distribution functions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019; v1 submitted 11 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
As a matter of force - Systematic biases in idealized turbulence simulations
Authors:
Philipp Grete,
Brian W. O'Shea,
Kris Beckwith
Abstract:
Many astrophysical systems encompass very large dynamical ranges in space and time, which are not accessible by direct numerical simulations. Thus, idealized subvolumes are often used to study small-scale effects including the dynamics of turbulence. These turbulent boxes require an artificial driving in order to mimic energy injection from large-scale processes. In this Letter, we show and quanti…
▽ More
Many astrophysical systems encompass very large dynamical ranges in space and time, which are not accessible by direct numerical simulations. Thus, idealized subvolumes are often used to study small-scale effects including the dynamics of turbulence. These turbulent boxes require an artificial driving in order to mimic energy injection from large-scale processes. In this Letter, we show and quantify how the autocorrelation time of the driving and its normalization systematically change properties of an isothermal compressible magnetohydrodynamic flow in the sub- and supersonic regime and affect astrophysical observations such as Faraday rotation. For example, we find that $δ$-in-time forcing with a constant energy injection leads to a steeper slope in kinetic energy spectrum and less efficient small-scale dynamo action. In general, we show that shorter autocorrelation times require more power in the acceleration field, which results in more power in compressive modes that weaken the anticorrelation between density and magnetic field strength. Thus, derived observables, such as the line-of-sight magnetic field from rotation measures, are systematically biased by the driving mechanism. We argue that $δ$-in-time forcing is unrealistic and numerically unresolved, and conclude that special care needs to be taken in interpreting observational results based on the use of idealized simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2018; v1 submitted 14 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Experiment to Form and Characterize a Section of a Spherically Imploding Plasma Liner
Authors:
S. C. Hsu,
S. J. Langendorf,
K. C. Yates,
J. P. Dunn,
S. Brockington,
A. Case,
E. Cruz,
F. D. Witherspoon,
M. A. Gilmore,
J. T. Cassibry,
R. Samulyak,
P. Stoltz,
K. Schillo,
W. Shih,
K. Beckwith,
Y. C. F. Thio
Abstract:
We describe an experiment to form and characterize a section of a spherically imploding plasma liner by merging six supersonic plasma jets that are launched by newly designed contoured-gap coaxial plasma guns. This experiment is a prelude to forming a fully spherical imploding plasma liner using many dozens of plasma guns, as a standoff driver for plasma-jet-driven magneto-inertial fusion. The obj…
▽ More
We describe an experiment to form and characterize a section of a spherically imploding plasma liner by merging six supersonic plasma jets that are launched by newly designed contoured-gap coaxial plasma guns. This experiment is a prelude to forming a fully spherical imploding plasma liner using many dozens of plasma guns, as a standoff driver for plasma-jet-driven magneto-inertial fusion. The objectives of the six-jet experiments are to assess the evolution and scalings of liner Mach number and uniformity, which are important metrics for spherically imploding plasma liners to compress magnetized target plasmas to fusion conditions. This paper describes the design of the coaxial plasma guns, experimental characterization of the plasma jets, six-jet experimental setup and diagnostics, initial diagnostic data from three- and six-jet experiments, and the high-level objectives of associated numerical modeling.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2017; v1 submitted 30 September, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Energy transfer in compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Philipp Grete,
Brian W. O'Shea,
Kris Beckwith,
Wolfram Schmidt,
Andrew Christlieb
Abstract:
Magnetic fields, compressibility and turbulence are important factors in many terrestrial and astrophysical processes. While energy dynamics, i.e. how energy is transferred within and between kinetic and magnetic reservoirs, has been previously studied in the context of incompressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence, we extend shell-to-shell energy transfer analysis to the compressible regime…
▽ More
Magnetic fields, compressibility and turbulence are important factors in many terrestrial and astrophysical processes. While energy dynamics, i.e. how energy is transferred within and between kinetic and magnetic reservoirs, has been previously studied in the context of incompressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence, we extend shell-to-shell energy transfer analysis to the compressible regime. We derive four new transfer functions specifically capturing compressibility effects in the kinetic and magnetic cascade, and capturing energy exchange via magnetic pressure. To illustrate their viability, we perform and analyze four simulations of driven isothermal MHD turbulence in the sub- and supersonic regime with two different codes. On the one hand, our analysis reveals robust characteristics across regime and numerical method. For example, energy transfer between individual scales is local and forward for both cascades with the magnetic cascade being stronger than the kinetic one. Magnetic tension and magnetic pressure related transfers are less local and weaker than the cascades. We find no evidence for significant nonlocal transfer. On the other hand, we show that certain functions, e.g., the compressive component of the magnetic energy cascade, exhibit a more complex behavior that varies both with regime and numerical method. Having established a basis for the analysis in the compressible regime, the method can now be applied to study a broader parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2017; v1 submitted 20 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Modeling radio communication blackout and blackout mitigation in hypersonic vehicles
Authors:
Madhusudhan Kundrapu,
John Loverich,
Kristian Beckwith,
Peter Stoltz,
Alexey Shashurin,
Michael Keidar
Abstract:
A procedure for the modeling and analysis of radio communication blackout of hypersonic vehicles is presented. The weakly ionized plasma generated around the surface of a hypersonic reentry vehicle is simulated using full Navier-Stokes equations in multi-species single fluid form. A seven species air chemistry model is used to compute the individual species densities in air including ionization -…
▽ More
A procedure for the modeling and analysis of radio communication blackout of hypersonic vehicles is presented. The weakly ionized plasma generated around the surface of a hypersonic reentry vehicle is simulated using full Navier-Stokes equations in multi-species single fluid form. A seven species air chemistry model is used to compute the individual species densities in air including ionization - plasma densities are compared with experiment. The electromagnetic wave's interaction with the plasma layer is modeled using multi-fluid equations for fluid transport and full Maxwell's equations for the electromagnetic fields. The multi-fluid solver is verified for a whistler wave propagating through a slab. First principles radio communication blackout over a hypersonic vehicle is demonstrated along with a simple blackout mitigation scheme using a magnetic window.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2014; v1 submitted 24 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Electromagnetic Wave Propagation In The Plasma Layer of A Reentry Vehicle
Authors:
Madhusudhan Kundrapu,
John Loverich,
Kris Beckwith,
Peter Stoltz,
Alexey Shashurin,
Michael Keidar
Abstract:
The ability to simulate a reentry vehicle plasma layer and the radio wave interaction with that layer, is crucial to the design of aerospace vehicles when the analysis of radio communication blackout is required. Results of aerothermal heating, plasma generation and electromagnetic wave propagation over a reentry vehicle are presented in this paper. Simulation of a magnetic window radio communicat…
▽ More
The ability to simulate a reentry vehicle plasma layer and the radio wave interaction with that layer, is crucial to the design of aerospace vehicles when the analysis of radio communication blackout is required. Results of aerothermal heating, plasma generation and electromagnetic wave propagation over a reentry vehicle are presented in this paper. Simulation of a magnetic window radio communication blackout mitigation method is successfully demonstrated.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
A Second Order Godunov Method for Multidimensional Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics
Authors:
Kris Beckwith,
James M. Stone
Abstract:
We describe a new Godunov algorithm for relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (RMHD) that combines a simple, unsplit second order accurate integrator with the constrained transport (CT) method for enforcing the solenoidal constraint on the magnetic field. A variety of approximate Riemann solvers are implemented to compute the fluxes of the conserved variables. The methods are tested with a comprehensi…
▽ More
We describe a new Godunov algorithm for relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (RMHD) that combines a simple, unsplit second order accurate integrator with the constrained transport (CT) method for enforcing the solenoidal constraint on the magnetic field. A variety of approximate Riemann solvers are implemented to compute the fluxes of the conserved variables. The methods are tested with a comprehensive suite of multidimensional problems. These tests have helped us develop a hierarchy of correction steps that are applied when the integration algorithm predicts unphysical states due to errors in the fluxes, or errors in the inversion between conserved and primitive variables. Although used exceedingly rarely, these corrections dramatically improve the stability of the algorithm. We present preliminary results from the application of these algorithms to two problems in RMHD: the propagation of supersonic magnetized jets, and the amplification of magnetic field by turbulence driven by the relativistic Kelvin-Helmholtz instability (KHI). Both of these applications reveal important differences between the results computed with Riemann solvers that adopt different approximations for the fluxes. For example, we show that use of Riemann solvers which include both contact and rotational discontinuities can increase the strength of the magnetic field within the cocoon by a factor of ten in simulations of RMHD jets, and can increase the spectral resolution of three-dimensional RMHD turbulence driven by the KHI by a factor of 2. This increase in accuracy far outweighs the associated increase in computational cost. Our RMHD scheme is publicly available as part of the Athena code.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
