-
Franck-Condon spectra of unbound and imaginary-frequency vibrations via correlation functions: a branch-cut free, numerically stable derivation
Authors:
P. Bryan Changala,
Nadav Genossar,
Joshua H. Baraban
Abstract:
Molecular electronic spectra can be represented in the time domain as auto-correlation functions of the initial vibrational wavepacket. We present a derivation of the harmonic vibrational auto-correlation function that is valid for both real and imaginary harmonic frequencies. The derivation rests on Lie algebra techniques that map otherwise complicated exponential operator arithmetic to simpler m…
▽ More
Molecular electronic spectra can be represented in the time domain as auto-correlation functions of the initial vibrational wavepacket. We present a derivation of the harmonic vibrational auto-correlation function that is valid for both real and imaginary harmonic frequencies. The derivation rests on Lie algebra techniques that map otherwise complicated exponential operator arithmetic to simpler matrix formulae. The expressions for the zero- and finite-temperature harmonic auto-correlation functions have been carefully structured both to be free of branch-cut discontinuities and to remain numerically stable with finite-precision arithmetic. Simple extensions correct the harmonic Franck-Condon approximation for the lowest-order anharmonic and Herzberg-Teller effects. Quantitative simulations are shown for several examples, including the electronic absorption spectra of F$_2$, HOCl, CH$_2$NH, and NO$_2$.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Matters Arising in -- "Plasmon-driven carbon-fluorine (C(sp^$3$)-F) bond activation with mechanistic insights into hot-carrier-mediated pathways"
Authors:
Yonatan Dubi,
Ieng Wai Un,
Joshua H. Baraban,
Yonatan Sivan
Abstract:
In a recent paper~[Nature Catalysis 3, 573 (2020)], Robatjazi {\em et al.} demonstrate hydrodefluorination on Al nanocrystals decorated by Pd islands under illumination and under external heating. They conclude that photocatalysis accomplishes the desired transformation \ce{CH3F + D2 -> CH3D + DF} efficiently and selectively due to "hot" electrons, as evidenced by an illumination-induced reduction…
▽ More
In a recent paper~[Nature Catalysis 3, 573 (2020)], Robatjazi {\em et al.} demonstrate hydrodefluorination on Al nanocrystals decorated by Pd islands under illumination and under external heating. They conclude that photocatalysis accomplishes the desired transformation \ce{CH3F + D2 -> CH3D + DF} efficiently and selectively due to "hot" electrons, as evidenced by an illumination-induced reduction of the activation energy.
Although some of the problems identified in prior work by the same group have been addressed, scrutiny of the data in~[Nature Catalysis 3, 573 (2020)] raises doubts about both the methodology and the central conclusions. First, we show that the thermal control experiments in~[Nature Catalysis 3, 573 (2020)] do not separate thermal from "hot electron" contributions, and therefore any conclusions drawn from these experiments are invalid. We then show that an improved thermal control implies that the activation energy of the reaction does not change, and that an independent purely thermal calculation (based solely on the sample parameters provided in the original manuscript) explains the measured data perfectly. For the sake of completeness, we also address technical problems in the calibration of the thermal camera, an unjustifiable disqualification of some of the measured data, as well as concerning aspects of the rest of the main results, including the mass spectrometry approach used to investigate the selectivity of the reaction, and claims about the stoichiometry and reaction order. All this shows that the burden of proof for involvement of hot electrons has not been met.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Ab initio effective rotational and rovibrational Hamiltonians for non-rigid systems via curvilinear second order vibrational Møller-Plesset perturbation theory
Authors:
P. Bryan Changala,
Joshua H. Baraban
Abstract:
We present a perturbative method for ab initio calculations of rotational and rovibrational effective Hamiltonians of both rigid and non-rigid molecules. Our approach is based on a curvilinear implementation of second order vibrational Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (VMP2) extended to include rotational effects via a second order contact transformation. Though more expensive, this approach is…
▽ More
We present a perturbative method for ab initio calculations of rotational and rovibrational effective Hamiltonians of both rigid and non-rigid molecules. Our approach is based on a curvilinear implementation of second order vibrational Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (VMP2) extended to include rotational effects via a second order contact transformation. Though more expensive, this approach is significantly more accurate than standard second order vibrational perturbation theory (VPT2) for systems that are poorly described to zeroth order by rectilinear normal mode harmonic oscillators. We apply this method and demonstrate its accuracy on two molecules: Si$_2$C, a quasilinear triatomic with significant bending anharmonicity, and CH$_3$NO$_2$, which contains a completely unhindered methyl rotor. In addition to these two examples, we discuss several key technical aspects of the method, including an efficient implementation of Eckart and quasi-Eckart frame embedding that does not rely on numerical finite differences.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Reduced Dimension DVR Study of cis-trans Isomerization in the S_1 State of C_2H_2
Authors:
Joshua H. Baraban,
Annelise R. Beck,
Adam H. Steeves,
John F. Stanton,
Robert W. Field
Abstract:
Isomerization between the cis and trans conformers of the S1 state of acetylene is studied using a reduced dimension DVR calculation. Existing DVR techniques are combined with a high accuracy potential energy surface and a kinetic energy operator derived from FG theory to yield an effective but simple Hamiltonian for treating large amplitude motions. The spectroscopic signatures of the S1 isomeriz…
▽ More
Isomerization between the cis and trans conformers of the S1 state of acetylene is studied using a reduced dimension DVR calculation. Existing DVR techniques are combined with a high accuracy potential energy surface and a kinetic energy operator derived from FG theory to yield an effective but simple Hamiltonian for treating large amplitude motions. The spectroscopic signatures of the S1 isomerization are discussed, with emphasis on the vibrational aspects. The presence of a low barrier to isomerization causes distortion of the trans vibrational level structure and the appearance of nominally electronically forbidden Ã1A2 \leftarrow X 1Σ+g transitions to vibrational levels of the cis conformer. Both of these effects are modeled in agreement with experimental results, and the underlying mechanisms of tunneling and state mixing are elucidated by use of the calculated vibrational wavefunctions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
