Showing 1–18 of 18 results for author: Tanneau, M

Compact Optimality Verification for Optimization Proxies

Authors: Wenbo Chen, Haoruo Zhao, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Recent years have witnessed increasing interest in optimization proxies, i.e., machine learning models that approximate the input-output map** of parametric optimization problems and return near-optimal feasible solutions. Following recent work by (Nellikkath & Chatzivasileiadis, 2021), this paper reconsiders the optimality verification problem for optimization proxies, i.e., the determination o… ▽ More Recent years have witnessed increasing interest in optimization proxies, i.e., machine learning models that approximate the input-output map** of parametric optimization problems and return near-optimal feasible solutions. Following recent work by (Nellikkath & Chatzivasileiadis, 2021), this paper reconsiders the optimality verification problem for optimization proxies, i.e., the determination of the worst-case optimality gap over the instance distribution. The paper proposes a compact formulation for optimality verification and a gradient-based primal heuristic that brings substantial computational benefits to the original formulation. The compact formulation is also more general and applies to non-convex optimization problems. The benefits of the compact formulation are demonstrated on large-scale DC Optimal Power Flow and knapsack problems. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: International Conference on Machine Learning 2024

Dual Lagrangian Learning for Conic Optimization

Authors: Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper presents Dual Lagrangian Learning (DLL), a principled learning methodology for dual conic optimization proxies. DLL leverages conic duality and the representation power of ML models to provide high-duality, dual-feasible solutions, and therefore valid Lagrangian dual bounds, for linear and nonlinear conic optimization problems. The paper introduces a systematic dual completion procedure… ▽ More This paper presents Dual Lagrangian Learning (DLL), a principled learning methodology for dual conic optimization proxies. DLL leverages conic duality and the representation power of ML models to provide high-duality, dual-feasible solutions, and therefore valid Lagrangian dual bounds, for linear and nonlinear conic optimization problems. The paper introduces a systematic dual completion procedure, differentiable conic projection layers, and a self-supervised learning framework based on Lagrangian duality. It also provides closed-form dual completion formulae for broad classes of conic problems, which eliminate the need for costly implicit layers. The effectiveness of DLL is demonstrated on linear and nonlinear conic optimization problems. The proposed methodology significantly outperforms a state-of-the-art learning-based method, and achieves 1000x speedups over commercial interior-point solvers with optimality gaps under 0.5\% on average. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2024; v1 submitted 5 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Dual Interior-Point Optimization Learning

Authors: Michael Klamkin, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper introduces Dual Interior Point Learning (DIPL) and Dual Supergradient Learning (DSL) to learn dual feasible solutions to parametric linear programs with bounded variables, which are pervasive across many industries. DIPL mimics a novel dual interior point algorithm while DSL mimics classical dual supergradient ascent. DIPL and DSL ensure dual feasibility by predicting dual variables ass… ▽ More This paper introduces Dual Interior Point Learning (DIPL) and Dual Supergradient Learning (DSL) to learn dual feasible solutions to parametric linear programs with bounded variables, which are pervasive across many industries. DIPL mimics a novel dual interior point algorithm while DSL mimics classical dual supergradient ascent. DIPL and DSL ensure dual feasibility by predicting dual variables associated with the constraints then exploiting the flexibility of the duals of the bound constraints. DIPL and DSL complement existing primal learning methods by providing a certificate of quality. They are shown to produce high-fidelity dual-feasible solutions to large-scale optimal power flow problems providing valid dual bounds under 0.5% optimality gap. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Bound Tightening using Rolling-Horizon Decomposition for Neural Network Verification

Authors: Haoruo Zhao, Hassan Hijazi, Haydn Jones, Juston Moore, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Neural network verification aims at providing formal guarantees on the output of trained neural networks, to ensure their robustness against adversarial examples and enable their deployment in safety-critical applications. This paper introduces a new approach to neural network verification using a novel mixed-integer programming rolling-horizon decomposition method. The algorithm leverages the lay… ▽ More Neural network verification aims at providing formal guarantees on the output of trained neural networks, to ensure their robustness against adversarial examples and enable their deployment in safety-critical applications. This paper introduces a new approach to neural network verification using a novel mixed-integer programming rolling-horizon decomposition method. The algorithm leverages the layered structure of neural networks, by employing optimization-based bound-tightening on smaller sub-graphs of the original network in a rolling-horizon fashion. This strategy strikes a balance between achieving tighter bounds and ensuring the tractability of the underlying mixed-integer programs. Extensive numerical experiments, conducted on instances from the VNN-COMP benchmark library, demonstrate that the proposed approach yields significantly improved bounds compared to existing effective bound propagation methods. Notably, the parallelizable nature of the proposed method proves effective in solving open verification problems. Our code is built and released as part of the open-source mathematical modeling tool Gravity (https://github.com/coin-or/Gravity), which is extended to support generic neural network models. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2024; v1 submitted 10 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Learning Optimal Power Flow Value Functions with Input-Convex Neural Networks

Authors: Andrew Rosemberg, Mathieu Tanneau, Bruno Fanzeres, Joaquim Garcia, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problem is integral to the functioning of power systems, aiming to optimize generation dispatch while adhering to technical and operational constraints. These constraints are far from straightforward; they involve intricate, non-convex considerations related to Alternating Current (AC) power flow, which are essential for the safety and practicality of electrical grids.… ▽ More The Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problem is integral to the functioning of power systems, aiming to optimize generation dispatch while adhering to technical and operational constraints. These constraints are far from straightforward; they involve intricate, non-convex considerations related to Alternating Current (AC) power flow, which are essential for the safety and practicality of electrical grids. However, solving the OPF problem for varying conditions within stringent time frames poses practical challenges. To address this, operators resort to model simplifications of varying accuracy. Unfortunately, better approximations (tight convex relaxations) are often computationally intractable. This research explores machine learning (ML) to learn convex approximate solutions for faster analysis in the online setting while still allowing for coupling into other convex dependent decision problems. By trading off a small amount of accuracy for substantial gains in speed, they enable the efficient exploration of vast solution spaces in these complex problems. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 7 pages

MSC Class: 49M20

Dual Conic Proxies for AC Optimal Power Flow

Authors: Guancheng Qiu, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: In recent years, there has been significant interest in the development of machine learning-based optimization proxies for AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF). Although significant progress has been achieved in predicting high-quality primal solutions, no existing learning-based approach can provide valid dual bounds for AC-OPF. This paper addresses this gap by training optimization proxies for a conve… ▽ More In recent years, there has been significant interest in the development of machine learning-based optimization proxies for AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF). Although significant progress has been achieved in predicting high-quality primal solutions, no existing learning-based approach can provide valid dual bounds for AC-OPF. This paper addresses this gap by training optimization proxies for a convex relaxation of AC-OPF. Namely, the paper considers a second-order cone (SOC) relaxation of AC-OPF, and proposes \revision{a novel architecture} that embeds a fast, differentiable (dual) feasibility recovery, thus providing valid dual bounds. The paper combines this new architecture with a self-supervised learning scheme, which alleviates the need for costly training data generation. Extensive numerical experiments on medium- and large-scale power grids demonstrate the efficiency and scalability of the proposed methodology. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2024; v1 submitted 4 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: accepted to PSCC 2024

Real-Time Risk Analysis with Optimization Proxies

Authors: Wenbo Chen, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The increasing penetration of renewable generation and distributed energy resources requires new operating practices for power systems, wherein risk is explicitly quantified and managed. However, traditional risk-assessment frameworks are not fast enough for real-time operations, because they require numerous simulations, each of which requires solving multiple economic dispatch problems sequentia… ▽ More The increasing penetration of renewable generation and distributed energy resources requires new operating practices for power systems, wherein risk is explicitly quantified and managed. However, traditional risk-assessment frameworks are not fast enough for real-time operations, because they require numerous simulations, each of which requires solving multiple economic dispatch problems sequentially. The paper addresses this computational challenge by proposing proxy-based risk assessment, wherein optimization proxies are trained to learn the input-to-output map** of an economic dispatch optimization solver. Once trained, the proxies make predictions in milliseconds, thereby enabling real-time risk assessment. The paper leverages self-supervised learning and end-to-end-feasible architecture to achieve high-quality sequential predictions. Numerical experiments on large systems demonstrate the scalability and accuracy of the proposed approach. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2023; v1 submitted 1 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 7 pages

On the Benefits of Stochastic Economic Dispatch in Real-Time Electricity Markets

Authors: Haoruo Zhao, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Independent system operators (ISOs) in the US clear their real-time electricity market every five minutes, optimizing energy and reserve dispatches to minimize operating costs while meeting technical and regulatory constraints. Currently, many real-time markets are cleared by solving a single-period, deterministic, security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED). Nevertheless, given the growing pene… ▽ More Independent system operators (ISOs) in the US clear their real-time electricity market every five minutes, optimizing energy and reserve dispatches to minimize operating costs while meeting technical and regulatory constraints. Currently, many real-time markets are cleared by solving a single-period, deterministic, security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED). Nevertheless, given the growing penetration of renewable generation and the forthcoming retirement of conventional generation units, it becomes increasingly challenging to manage operational uncertainty at the real-time stage via the current SCED formulations. This limitation is best illustrated by the recent introduction into the real-time market of multiple short-term ram** products, which aim at bridging the gap between deterministic and stochastic formulations. In contrast, this paper explores the scalability and potential benefits of explicitly considering uncertainty in real-time market formulations by combining multi-period look-ahead dispatch (LAD) and stochastic look-ahead (SLAD) formulations. An accelerated Benders' decomposition is presented to solve the resulting problems efficiently. The paper conducts extensive numerical experiments on a real, industry-size transmission grid that benchmarks the proposed approaches and evaluates their benefits. The results demonstrate that stochastic optimization is now tractable enough to be used in real-time markets. Furthermore, the combination of multi-period and stochastic look-ahead offers significant benefits in both reliability and cost, as SLAD can better position online generators to accommodate future ram** needs, thereby reducing future operational costs and violations. Overall, SLAD reduces import costs and the risk of transmission violation and saves an average of more than 2% of costs compared to SCED. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

End-to-End Feasible Optimization Proxies for Large-Scale Economic Dispatch

Authors: Wenbo Chen, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The paper proposes a novel End-to-End Learning and Repair (E2ELR) architecture for training optimization proxies for economic dispatch problems. E2ELR combines deep neural networks with closed-form, differentiable repair layers, thereby integrating learning and feasibility in an end-to-end fashion. E2ELR is also trained with self-supervised learning, removing the need for labeled data and the solv… ▽ More The paper proposes a novel End-to-End Learning and Repair (E2ELR) architecture for training optimization proxies for economic dispatch problems. E2ELR combines deep neural networks with closed-form, differentiable repair layers, thereby integrating learning and feasibility in an end-to-end fashion. E2ELR is also trained with self-supervised learning, removing the need for labeled data and the solving of numerous optimization problems offline. E2ELR is evaluated on industry-size power grids with tens of thousands of buses using an economic dispatch that co-optimizes energy and reserves. The results demonstrate that the self-supervised E2ELR achieves state-of-the-art performance, with optimality gaps that outperform other baselines by at least an order of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2023; v1 submitted 23 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Confidence-Aware Graph Neural Networks for Learning Reliability Assessment Commitments

Authors: Seonho Park, Wenbo Chen, Dahye Han, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Reliability Assessment Commitment (RAC) Optimization is increasingly important in grid operations due to larger shares of renewable generations in the generation mix and increased prediction errors. Independent System Operators (ISOs) also aim at using finer time granularities, longer time horizons, and possibly stochastic formulations for additional economic and reliability benefits. The goal of… ▽ More Reliability Assessment Commitment (RAC) Optimization is increasingly important in grid operations due to larger shares of renewable generations in the generation mix and increased prediction errors. Independent System Operators (ISOs) also aim at using finer time granularities, longer time horizons, and possibly stochastic formulations for additional economic and reliability benefits. The goal of this paper is to address the computational challenges arising in extending the scope of RAC formulations. It presents RACLearn that (1) uses a Graph Neural Network (GNN) based architecture to predict generator commitments and active line constraints, (2) associates a confidence value to each commitment prediction, (3) selects a subset of the high-confidence predictions, which are (4) repaired for feasibility, and (5) seeds a state-of-the-art optimization algorithm with feasible predictions and active constraints. Experimental results on exact RAC formulations used by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO) and an actual transmission network (8965 transmission lines, 6708 buses, 1890 generators, and 6262 load units) show that the RACLearn framework can speed up RAC optimization by factors ranging from 2 to 4 with negligible loss in solution quality. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2023; v1 submitted 28 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

Bucketized Active Sampling for Learning ACOPF

Authors: Michael Klamkin, Mathieu Tanneau, Terrence W. K. Mak, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper considers optimization proxies for Optimal Power Flow (OPF), i.e., machine-learning models that approximate the input/output relationship of OPF. Recent work has focused on showing that such proxies can be of high fidelity. However, their training requires significant data, each instance necessitating the (offline) solving of an OPF for a sample of the input distribution. To meet the re… ▽ More This paper considers optimization proxies for Optimal Power Flow (OPF), i.e., machine-learning models that approximate the input/output relationship of OPF. Recent work has focused on showing that such proxies can be of high fidelity. However, their training requires significant data, each instance necessitating the (offline) solving of an OPF for a sample of the input distribution. To meet the requirements of market-clearing applications, this paper proposes Bucketized Active Sampling (BAS), a novel active learning framework that aims at training the best possible OPF proxy within a time limit. BAS partitions the input distribution into buckets and uses an acquisition function to determine where to sample next. By applying the same partitioning to the validation set, BAS leverages labeled validation samples in the selection of unlabeled samples. BAS also relies on an adaptive learning rate that increases and decreases over time. Experimental results demonstrate the benefits of BAS. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2023; v1 submitted 15 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Risk-Aware Control and Optimization for High-Renewable Power Grids

Authors: Neil Barry, Minas Chatzos, Wenbo Chen, Dahye Han, Chaofan Huang, Roshan Joseph, Michael Klamkin, Seonho Park, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Shangkun Wang, Hanyu Zhang, Haoruo Zhao

Abstract: The transition of the electrical power grid from fossil fuels to renewable sources of energy raises fundamental challenges to the market-clearing algorithms that drive its operations. Indeed, the increased stochasticity in load and the volatility of renewable energy sources have led to significant increases in prediction errors, affecting the reliability and efficiency of existing deterministic op… ▽ More The transition of the electrical power grid from fossil fuels to renewable sources of energy raises fundamental challenges to the market-clearing algorithms that drive its operations. Indeed, the increased stochasticity in load and the volatility of renewable energy sources have led to significant increases in prediction errors, affecting the reliability and efficiency of existing deterministic optimization models. The RAMC project was initiated to investigate how to move from this deterministic setting into a risk-aware framework where uncertainty is quantified explicitly and incorporated in the market-clearing optimizations. Risk-aware market-clearing raises challenges on its own, primarily from a computational standpoint. This paper reviews how RAMC approaches risk-aware market clearing and presents some of its innovations in uncertainty quantification, optimization, and machine learning. Experimental results on real networks are presented. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Learning Optimization Proxies for Large-Scale Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch

Authors: Wenbo Chen, Seonho Park, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch (SCED) is a fundamental optimization model for Transmission System Operators (TSO) to clear real-time energy markets while ensuring reliable operations of power grids. In a context of growing operational uncertainty, due to increased penetration of renewable generators and distributed energy resources, operators must continuously monitor risk in real-time… ▽ More The Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch (SCED) is a fundamental optimization model for Transmission System Operators (TSO) to clear real-time energy markets while ensuring reliable operations of power grids. In a context of growing operational uncertainty, due to increased penetration of renewable generators and distributed energy resources, operators must continuously monitor risk in real-time, i.e., they must quickly assess the system's behavior under various changes in load and renewable production. Unfortunately, systematically solving an optimization problem for each such scenario is not practical given the tight constraints of real-time operations. To overcome this limitation, this paper proposes to learn an optimization proxy for SCED, i.e., a Machine Learning (ML) model that can predict an optimal solution for SCED in milliseconds. Motivated by a principled analysis of the market-clearing optimizations of MISO, the paper proposes a novel ML pipeline that addresses the main challenges of learning SCED solutions, i.e., the variability in load, renewable output and production costs, as well as the combinatorial structure of commitment decisions. A novel Classification-Then-Regression architecture is also proposed, to further capture the behavior of SCED solutions. Numerical experiments are reported on the French transmission system, and demonstrate the approach's ability to produce, within a time frame that is compatible with real-time operations, accurate optimization proxies that produce relative errors below $0.6\%$. △ Less

Submitted 26 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: The paper is the extension version of the paper submitted to PSCC2022

A Linear Outer Approximation of Line Losses for DC-based Optimal Power Flow Problems

Authors: Haoruo Zhao, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper proposes a novel and simple linear model to capture line losses for use in linearized DC models, such as optimal power flow (DC-OPF) and security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED). The \textit{Line Loss Outer Approximation} (LLOA) model implements an outer approximation of the line losses lazily and typically terminates in a small number of iterations. Experiments on large-scale powe… ▽ More This paper proposes a novel and simple linear model to capture line losses for use in linearized DC models, such as optimal power flow (DC-OPF) and security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED). The \textit{Line Loss Outer Approximation} (LLOA) model implements an outer approximation of the line losses lazily and typically terminates in a small number of iterations. Experiments on large-scale power systems demonstrate the accuracy and computational efficiency of LLOA and contrast it with classical line loss approaches. The results seem to indicate that LLOA is a practical and useful model for real-world applications, providing a good tradeoff between accuracy, computational efficiency, and implementation simplicity. In particular, the LLOA method may have significant advantages compared to the traditional loss factor formulation for multi-period, stochastic optimization problems where good reference points may not be available. The paper also provides a comprehensive overview and evaluation of approximation methods for line losses. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2021; v1 submitted 20 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Data-Driven Time Series Reconstruction for Modern Power Systems Research

Authors: Minas Chatzos, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: A critical aspect of power systems research is the availability of suitable data, access to which is limited by privacy concerns and the sensitive nature of energy infrastructure. This lack of data, in turn, hinders the development of modern research avenues such as machine learning approaches or stochastic formulations. To overcome this challenge, this paper proposes a systematic, data-driven fra… ▽ More A critical aspect of power systems research is the availability of suitable data, access to which is limited by privacy concerns and the sensitive nature of energy infrastructure. This lack of data, in turn, hinders the development of modern research avenues such as machine learning approaches or stochastic formulations. To overcome this challenge, this paper proposes a systematic, data-driven framework for reconstructing high-fidelity time series, using publicly-available grid snapshots and historical data published by transmission system operators. The proposed approach, from geo-spatial data and generation capacity reconstruction, to time series disaggregation, is applied to the French transmission grid. Thereby, synthetic but highly realistic time series data, spanning multiple years with a 5-minute granularity, is generated at the individual component level. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Design and implementation of a modular interior-point solver for linear optimization

Authors: Miguel F. Anjos, Andrea Lodi, Mathieu Tanneau

Abstract: This paper introduces the algorithmic design and implementation of Tulip, an open-source interior-point solver for linear optimization. It implements a regularized homogeneous interior-point algorithm with multiple centrality corrections, and therefore handles unbounded and infeasible problems. The solver is written in Julia, thus allowing for a flexible and efficient implementation: Tulip's algor… ▽ More This paper introduces the algorithmic design and implementation of Tulip, an open-source interior-point solver for linear optimization. It implements a regularized homogeneous interior-point algorithm with multiple centrality corrections, and therefore handles unbounded and infeasible problems. The solver is written in Julia, thus allowing for a flexible and efficient implementation: Tulip's algorithmic framework is fully disentangled from linear algebra implementations and from a model's arithmetic. In particular, this allows to seamlessly integrate specialized routines for structured problems. Extensive computational results are reported. We find that Tulip is competitive with open-source interior-point solvers on the H. Mittelmann's benchmark of barrier linear programming solvers. Furthermore, we design specialized linear algebra routines for structured master problems in the context of Dantzig-Wolfe decomposition. These routines yield a tenfold speedup on large and dense instances that arise in power systems operation and two-stage stochastic programming, thereby outperforming state-of-the-art commercial interior point method solvers. Finally, we illustrate Tulip's ability to use different levels of arithmetic precision by solving problems in extended precision. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2020; v1 submitted 15 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Disjunctive cuts in Mixed-Integer Conic Optimization

Authors: Andrea Lodi, Mathieu Tanneau, Juan Pablo Vielma

Abstract: This paper studies disjunctive cutting planes in Mixed-Integer Conic Programming. Building on conic duality, we formulate a cut-generating conic program for separating disjunctive cuts, and investigate the impact of the normalization condition on its resolution. In particular, we show that a careful selection of normalization guarantees its solvability and conic strong duality. Then, we highlight… ▽ More This paper studies disjunctive cutting planes in Mixed-Integer Conic Programming. Building on conic duality, we formulate a cut-generating conic program for separating disjunctive cuts, and investigate the impact of the normalization condition on its resolution. In particular, we show that a careful selection of normalization guarantees its solvability and conic strong duality. Then, we highlight the shortcomings of separating conic-infeasible points in an outer-approximation context, and propose conic extensions to the classical lifting and monoidal strengthening procedures. Finally, we assess the computational behavior of various normalization conditions in terms of gap closed, computing time and cut sparsity. In the process, we show that our approach is competitive with the internal lift-and-project cuts of a state-of-the-art solver. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2020; v1 submitted 6 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Learning chordal extensions

Authors: Defeng Liu, Andrea Lodi, Mathieu Tanneau

Abstract: A highly influential ingredient of many techniques designed to exploit sparsity in numerical optimization is the so-called chordal extension of a graph representation of the optimization problem. The definitive relation between chordal extension and the performance of the optimization algorithm that uses the extension is not a mathematically understood task. For this reason, we follow the current… ▽ More A highly influential ingredient of many techniques designed to exploit sparsity in numerical optimization is the so-called chordal extension of a graph representation of the optimization problem. The definitive relation between chordal extension and the performance of the optimization algorithm that uses the extension is not a mathematically understood task. For this reason, we follow the current research trend of looking at Combinatorial Optimization tasks by using a Machine Learning lens, and we devise a framework for learning elimination rules yielding high-quality chordal extensions. As a first building block of the learning framework, we propose an on-policy imitation learning scheme that mimics the elimination ordering provided by the (classical) minimum degree rule. The results show that our on-policy imitation learning approach is effective in learning the minimum degree policy and, consequently, produces graphs with desirable fill-in characteristics. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: Submitted to Journal of Global Optimization