-
Assumptions and Bounds in the Instrumental Variable Model
Authors:
Thomas S. Richardson,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
In this note we give proofs for results relating to the Instrumental Variable (IV) model with binary response $Y$ and binary treatment $X$, but with an instrument $Z$ with $K$ states. These results were originally stated in Richardson & Robins (2014), "ACE Bounds; SEMS with Equilibrium Conditions," arXiv:1410.0470.
In this note we give proofs for results relating to the Instrumental Variable (IV) model with binary response $Y$ and binary treatment $X$, but with an instrument $Z$ with $K$ states. These results were originally stated in Richardson & Robins (2014), "ACE Bounds; SEMS with Equilibrium Conditions," arXiv:1410.0470.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2024; v1 submitted 24 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Assumption-lean falsification tests of rate double-robustness of double-machine-learning estimators
Authors:
Lin Liu,
Rajarshi Mukherjee,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
The class of doubly-robust (DR) functionals studied by Rotnitzky et al. (2021) is of central importance in economics and biostatistics. It strictly includes both (i) the class of mean-square continuous functionals that can be written as an expectation of an affine functional of a conditional expectation studied by Chernozhukov et al. (2022b) and (ii) the class of functionals studied by Robins et a…
▽ More
The class of doubly-robust (DR) functionals studied by Rotnitzky et al. (2021) is of central importance in economics and biostatistics. It strictly includes both (i) the class of mean-square continuous functionals that can be written as an expectation of an affine functional of a conditional expectation studied by Chernozhukov et al. (2022b) and (ii) the class of functionals studied by Robins et al. (2008). The present state-of-the-art estimators for DR functionals $ψ$ are double-machine-learning (DML) estimators (Chernozhukov et al., 2018). A DML estimator $\widehatψ_{1}$ of $ψ$ depends on estimates $\widehat{p} (x)$ and $\widehat{b} (x)$ of a pair of nuisance functions $p(x)$ and $b(x)$, and is said to satisfy "rate double-robustness" if the Cauchy--Schwarz upper bound of its bias is $o (n^{- 1/2})$. Were it achievable, our scientific goal would have been to construct valid, assumption-lean (i.e. no complexity-reducing assumptions on $b$ or $p$) tests of the validity of a nominal $(1 - α)$ Wald confidence interval (CI) centered at $\widehatψ_{1}$. But this would require a test of the bias to be $o (n^{-1/2})$, which can be shown not to exist. We therefore adopt the less ambitious goal of falsifying, when possible, an analyst's justification for her claim that the reported $(1 - α)$ Wald CI is valid. In many instances, an analyst justifies her claim by imposing complexity-reducing assumptions on $b$ and $p$ to ensure "rate double-robustness". Here we exhibit valid, assumption-lean tests of $H_{0}$: "rate double-robustness holds", with non-trivial power against certain alternatives. If $H_{0}$ is rejected, we will have falsified her justification. However, no assumption-lean test of $H_{0}$, including ours, can be a consistent test. Thus, the failure of our test to reject is not meaningful evidence in favor of $H_{0}$.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2023; v1 submitted 18 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Potential Outcome and Decision Theoretic Foundations for Statistical Causality
Authors:
Thomas S. Richardson,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
In a recent paper published in the Journal of Causal Inference, Philip Dawid has described a graphical causal model based on decision diagrams. This article describes how single-world intervention graphs (SWIGs) relate to these diagrams. In this way, a correspondence is established between Dawid's approach and those based on potential outcomes such as Robins' Finest Fully Randomized Causally Inter…
▽ More
In a recent paper published in the Journal of Causal Inference, Philip Dawid has described a graphical causal model based on decision diagrams. This article describes how single-world intervention graphs (SWIGs) relate to these diagrams. In this way, a correspondence is established between Dawid's approach and those based on potential outcomes such as Robins' Finest Fully Randomized Causally Interpreted Structured Tree Graphs. In more detail, a reformulation of Dawid's theory is given that is essentially equivalent to his proposal and isomorphic to SWIGs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023; v1 submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Minimax rates for heterogeneous causal effect estimation
Authors:
Edward H. Kennedy,
Sivaraman Balakrishnan,
James M. Robins,
Larry Wasserman
Abstract:
Estimation of heterogeneous causal effects - i.e., how effects of policies and treatments vary across subjects - is a fundamental task in causal inference. Many methods for estimating conditional average treatment effects (CATEs) have been proposed in recent years, but questions surrounding optimality have remained largely unanswered. In particular, a minimax theory of optimality has yet to be dev…
▽ More
Estimation of heterogeneous causal effects - i.e., how effects of policies and treatments vary across subjects - is a fundamental task in causal inference. Many methods for estimating conditional average treatment effects (CATEs) have been proposed in recent years, but questions surrounding optimality have remained largely unanswered. In particular, a minimax theory of optimality has yet to be developed, with the minimax rate of convergence and construction of rate-optimal estimators remaining open problems. In this paper we derive the minimax rate for CATE estimation, in a Holder-smooth nonparametric model, and present a new local polynomial estimator, giving high-level conditions under which it is minimax optimal. Our minimax lower bound is derived via a localized version of the method of fuzzy hypotheses, combining lower bound constructions for nonparametric regression and functional estimation. Our proposed estimator can be viewed as a local polynomial R-Learner, based on a localized modification of higher-order influence function methods. The minimax rate we find exhibits several interesting features, including a non-standard elbow phenomenon and an unusual interpolation between nonparametric regression and functional estimation rates. The latter quantifies how the CATE, as an estimand, can be viewed as a regression/functional hybrid.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Conditional separable effects
Authors:
Mats J. Stensrud,
James M. Robins,
Aaron Sarvet,
Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen,
Jessica G. Young
Abstract:
Researchers are often interested in treatment effects on outcomes that are only defined conditional on a post-treatment event status. For example, in a study of the effect of different cancer treatments on quality of life at end of follow-up, the quality of life of individuals who die during the study is undefined. In these settings, a naive contrast of outcomes conditional on the post-treatment v…
▽ More
Researchers are often interested in treatment effects on outcomes that are only defined conditional on a post-treatment event status. For example, in a study of the effect of different cancer treatments on quality of life at end of follow-up, the quality of life of individuals who die during the study is undefined. In these settings, a naive contrast of outcomes conditional on the post-treatment variable is not an average causal effect, even in a randomized experiment. Therefore the effect in the principal stratum of those who would have the same value of the post-treatment variable regardless of treatment, such as the always survivors in a truncation by death setting, is often advocated for causal inference. While this principal stratum effect is a well defined causal contrast, it is often hard to justify that it is relevant to scientists, patients or policy makers, and it cannot be identified without relying on unfalsifiable assumptions. Here we formulate alternative estimands, the conditional separable effects, that have a natural causal interpretation under assumptions that can be falsified in a randomized experiment. We provide identification results and introduce different estimators, including a doubly robust estimator derived from the nonparametric influence function. As an illustration, we estimate a conditional separable effect of chemotherapies on quality of life in patients with prostate cancer, using data from a randomized clinical trial.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021; v1 submitted 28 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Generalized interpretation and identification of separable effects in competing event settings
Authors:
Mats J. Stensrud,
Miguel A. Hernán,
Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen,
James M. Robins,
Vanessa Didelez,
Jessica G. Young
Abstract:
In competing event settings, a counterfactual contrast of cause-specific cumulative incidences quantifies the total causal effect of a treatment on the event of interest. However, effects of treatment on the competing event may indirectly contribute to this total effect, complicating its interpretation. We previously proposed the separable effects (Stensrud et al, 2019) to define direct and indire…
▽ More
In competing event settings, a counterfactual contrast of cause-specific cumulative incidences quantifies the total causal effect of a treatment on the event of interest. However, effects of treatment on the competing event may indirectly contribute to this total effect, complicating its interpretation. We previously proposed the separable effects (Stensrud et al, 2019) to define direct and indirect effects of the treatment on the event of interest. This definition presupposes a treatment decomposition into two components acting along two separate causal pathways, one exclusively outside of the competing event and the other exclusively through it. Unlike previous definitions of direct and indirect effects, the separable effects can be subject to empirical scrutiny in a study where separate interventions on the treatment components are available. Here we extend and generalize the notion of the separable effects in several ways, allowing for interpretation, identification and estimation under considerably weaker assumptions. We propose and discuss a definition of separable effects that is applicable to general time-varying structures, where the separable effects can still be meaningfully interpreted, even when they cannot be regarded as direct and indirect effects. We further derive weaker conditions for identification of separable effects in observational studies where decomposed treatments are not yet available; in particular, these conditions allow for time-varying common causes of the event of interest, the competing events and loss to follow-up. For these general settings, we propose semi-parametric weighted estimators that are straightforward to implement. As an illustration, we apply the estimators to study the separable effects of intensive blood pressure therapy on acute kidney injury, using data from a randomized clinical trial.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
On nearly assumption-free tests of nominal confidence interval coverage for causal parameters estimated by machine learning
Authors:
Lin Liu,
Rajarshi Mukherjee,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
For many causal effect parameters of interest, doubly robust machine learning (DRML) estimators $\hatψ_{1}$ are the state-of-the-art, incorporating the good prediction performance of machine learning; the decreased bias of doubly robust estimators; and the analytic tractability and bias reduction of sample splitting with cross fitting. Nonetheless, even in the absence of confounding by unmeasured…
▽ More
For many causal effect parameters of interest, doubly robust machine learning (DRML) estimators $\hatψ_{1}$ are the state-of-the-art, incorporating the good prediction performance of machine learning; the decreased bias of doubly robust estimators; and the analytic tractability and bias reduction of sample splitting with cross fitting. Nonetheless, even in the absence of confounding by unmeasured factors, the nominal $(1 - α)$ Wald confidence interval $\hatψ_{1} \pm z_{α/ 2} \widehat{\mathsf{se}} [\hatψ_{1}]$ may still undercover even in large samples, because the bias of $\hatψ_{1}$ may be of the same or even larger order than its standard error of order $n^{-1/2}$.
In this paper, we introduce essentially assumption-free tests that (i) can falsify the null hypothesis that the bias of $\hatψ_{1}$ is of smaller order than its standard error, (ii) can provide an upper confidence bound on the true coverage of the Wald interval, and (iii) are valid under the null under no smoothness/sparsity assumptions on the nuisance parameters. The tests, which we refer to as \underline{A}ssumption \underline{F}ree \underline{E}mpirical \underline{C}overage \underline{T}ests (AFECTs), are based on a U-statistic that estimates part of the bias of $\hatψ_{1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2020; v1 submitted 8 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
A unifying approach for doubly-robust $\ell_1$ regularized estimation of causal contrasts
Authors:
Ezequiel Smucler,
Andrea Rotnitzky,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
We consider inference about a scalar parameter under a non-parametric model based on a one-step estimator computed as a plug in estimator plus the empirical mean of an estimator of the parameter's influence function. We focus on a class of parameters that have influence function which depends on two infinite dimensional nuisance functions and such that the bias of the one-step estimator of the par…
▽ More
We consider inference about a scalar parameter under a non-parametric model based on a one-step estimator computed as a plug in estimator plus the empirical mean of an estimator of the parameter's influence function. We focus on a class of parameters that have influence function which depends on two infinite dimensional nuisance functions and such that the bias of the one-step estimator of the parameter of interest is the expectation of the product of the estimation errors of the two nuisance functions. Our class includes many important treatment effect contrasts of interest in causal inference and econometrics, such as ATE, ATT, an integrated causal contrast with a continuous treatment, and the mean of an outcome missing not at random. We propose estimators of the target parameter that entertain approximately sparse regression models for the nuisance functions allowing for the number of potential confounders to be even larger than the sample size. By employing sample splitting, cross-fitting and $\ell_1$-regularized regression estimators of the nuisance functions based on objective functions whose directional derivatives agree with those of the parameter's influence function, we obtain estimators of the target parameter with two desirable robustness properties: (1) they are rate doubly-robust in that they are root-n consistent and asymptotically normal when both nuisance functions follow approximately sparse models, even if one function has a very non-sparse regression coefficient, so long as the other has a sufficiently sparse regression coefficient, and (2) they are model doubly-robust in that they are root-n consistent and asymptotically normal even if one of the nuisance functions does not follow an approximately sparse model so long as the other nuisance function follows an approximately sparse model with a sufficiently sparse regression coefficient.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2019; v1 submitted 7 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Characterization of parameters with a mixed bias property
Authors:
Andrea Rotnitzky,
Ezequiel Smucler,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
In this article we study a class of parameters with the so-called `mixed bias property'. For parameters with this property, the bias of the semiparametric efficient one step estimator is equal to the mean of the product of the estimation errors of two nuisance functions. In non-parametric models, parameters with the mixed bias property admit so-called rate doubly robust estimators, i.e. estimators…
▽ More
In this article we study a class of parameters with the so-called `mixed bias property'. For parameters with this property, the bias of the semiparametric efficient one step estimator is equal to the mean of the product of the estimation errors of two nuisance functions. In non-parametric models, parameters with the mixed bias property admit so-called rate doubly robust estimators, i.e. estimators that are consistent and asymptotically normal when one succeeds in estimating both nuisance functions at sufficiently fast rates, with the possibility of trading off slower rates of convergence for the estimator of one of the nuisance functions with faster rates for the estimator of the other nuisance. We show that the class of parameters with the mixed bias property strictly includes two recently studied classes of parameters which, in turn, include many parameters of interest in causal inference. We characterize the form of parameters with the mixed bias property and of their influence functions. Furthermore, we derive two functional moment equations, each being solved at one of the two nuisance functions, as well as, two functional loss functions, each being minimized at one of the two nuisance functions. These loss functions can be used to derive loss based penalized estimators of the nuisance functions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2019; v1 submitted 7 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Semiparametric Efficient Empirical Higher Order Influence Function Estimators
Authors:
Lin Liu,
Rajarshi Mukherjee,
Whitney K. Newey,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
Robins et al. (2008, 2017) applied the theory of higher order influence functions (HOIFs) to derive an estimator of the mean $ψ$ of an outcome Y in a missing data model with Y missing at random conditional on a vector X of continuous covariates; their estimator, in contrast to previous estimators, is semiparametric efficient under the minimal conditions of Robins et al. (2009b), together with an a…
▽ More
Robins et al. (2008, 2017) applied the theory of higher order influence functions (HOIFs) to derive an estimator of the mean $ψ$ of an outcome Y in a missing data model with Y missing at random conditional on a vector X of continuous covariates; their estimator, in contrast to previous estimators, is semiparametric efficient under the minimal conditions of Robins et al. (2009b), together with an additional (non-minimal) smoothness condition on the density g of X, because the Robins et al. (2008, 2017) estimator depends on a nonparametric estimate of g. In this paper, we introduce a new HOIF estimator that has the same asymptotic properties as the original one, but does not impose any smoothness requirement on g. This is important for two reasons. First, one rarely has the knowledge about the properties of g. Second, even when g is smooth, if the dimension of X is even moderate, accurate nonparametric estimation of its density is not feasible at the sample sizes often encountered in applications. In fact, to the best of our knowledge, this new HOIF estimator remains the only semiparametric efficient estimator of $ψ$ under minimal conditions, despite the rapidly growing literature on causal effect estimation. We also show that our estimator can be generalized to the entire class of functionals considered by Robins et al. (2008) which include the average effect of a treatment on a response Y when a vector X suffices to control confounding and the expected conditional variance of a response Y given a vector X. Simulation experiments are also conducted, which demonstrate that our new estimator outperforms those of Robins et al. (2008, 2017) in finite samples, when g is not very smooth.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2023; v1 submitted 22 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Locally Robust Semiparametric Estimation
Authors:
Victor Chernozhukov,
Juan Carlos Escanciano,
Hidehiko Ichimura,
Whitney K. Newey,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
Many economic and causal parameters depend on nonparametric or high dimensional first steps. We give a general construction of locally robust/orthogonal moment functions for GMM, where moment conditions have zero derivative with respect to first steps. We show that orthogonal moment functions can be constructed by adding to identifying moments the nonparametric influence function for the effect of…
▽ More
Many economic and causal parameters depend on nonparametric or high dimensional first steps. We give a general construction of locally robust/orthogonal moment functions for GMM, where moment conditions have zero derivative with respect to first steps. We show that orthogonal moment functions can be constructed by adding to identifying moments the nonparametric influence function for the effect of the first step on identifying moments. Orthogonal moments reduce model selection and regularization bias, as is very important in many applications, especially for machine learning first steps.
We give debiased machine learning estimators of functionals of high dimensional conditional quantiles and of dynamic discrete choice parameters with high dimensional state variables. We show that adding to identifying moments the nonparametric influence function provides a general construction of orthogonal moments, including regularity conditions, and show that the nonparametric influence function is robust to additional unknown functions on which it depends. We give a general approach to estimating the unknown functions in the nonparametric influence function and use it to automatically debias estimators of functionals of high dimensional conditional location learners. We give a variety of new doubly robust moment equations and characterize double robustness. We give general and simple regularity conditions and apply these for asymptotic inference on functionals of high dimensional regression quantiles and dynamic discrete choice parameters with high dimensional state variables.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Parameter and Structure Learning in Nested Markov Models
Authors:
Ilya Shpitser,
Thomas S. Richardson,
James M. Robins,
Robin Evans
Abstract:
The constraints arising from DAG models with latent variables can be naturally represented by means of acyclic directed mixed graphs (ADMGs). Such graphs contain directed and bidirected arrows, and contain no directed cycles. DAGs with latent variables imply independence constraints in the distribution resulting from a 'fixing' operation, in which a joint distribution is divided by a conditional.…
▽ More
The constraints arising from DAG models with latent variables can be naturally represented by means of acyclic directed mixed graphs (ADMGs). Such graphs contain directed and bidirected arrows, and contain no directed cycles. DAGs with latent variables imply independence constraints in the distribution resulting from a 'fixing' operation, in which a joint distribution is divided by a conditional. This operation generalizes marginalizing and conditioning. Some of these constraints correspond to identifiable 'dormant' independence constraints, with the well known 'Verma constraint' as one example. Recently, models defined by a set of the constraints arising after fixing from a DAG with latents, were characterized via a recursive factorization and a nested Markov property. In addition, a parameterization was given in the discrete case. In this paper we use this parameterization to describe a parameter fitting algorithm, and a search and score structure learning algorithm for these nested Markov models. We apply our algorithms to a variety of datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Minimal sufficient causation and directed acyclic graphs
Authors:
Tyler J. VanderWeele,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
Notions of minimal sufficient causation are incorporated within the directed acyclic graph causal framework. Doing so allows for the graphical representation of sufficient causes and minimal sufficient causes on causal directed acyclic graphs while maintaining all of the properties of causal directed acyclic graphs. This in turn provides a clear theoretical link between two major conceptualizati…
▽ More
Notions of minimal sufficient causation are incorporated within the directed acyclic graph causal framework. Doing so allows for the graphical representation of sufficient causes and minimal sufficient causes on causal directed acyclic graphs while maintaining all of the properties of causal directed acyclic graphs. This in turn provides a clear theoretical link between two major conceptualizations of causality: one counterfactual-based and the other based on a more mechanistic understanding of causation. The theory developed can be used to draw conclusions about the sign of the conditional covariances among variables.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Generation interval contraction and epidemic data analysis
Authors:
Eben Kenah,
Marc Lipsitch,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
The generation interval is the time between the infection time of an infected person and the infection time of his or her infector. Probability density functions for generation intervals have been an important input for epidemic models and epidemic data analysis. In this paper, we specify a general stochastic SIR epidemic model and prove that the mean generation interval decreases when susceptib…
▽ More
The generation interval is the time between the infection time of an infected person and the infection time of his or her infector. Probability density functions for generation intervals have been an important input for epidemic models and epidemic data analysis. In this paper, we specify a general stochastic SIR epidemic model and prove that the mean generation interval decreases when susceptible persons are at risk of infectious contact from multiple sources. The intuition behind this is that when a susceptible person has multiple potential infectors, there is a ``race'' to infect him or her in which only the first infectious contact leads to infection. In an epidemic, the mean generation interval contracts as the prevalence of infection increases. We call this global competition among potential infectors. When there is rapid transmission within clusters of contacts, generation interval contraction can be caused by a high local prevalence of infection even when the global prevalence is low. We call this local competition among potential infectors. Using simulations, we illustrate both types of competition.
Finally, we show that hazards of infectious contact can be used instead of generation intervals to estimate the time course of the effective reproductive number in an epidemic. This approach leads naturally to partial likelihoods for epidemic data that are very similar to those that arise in survival analysis, opening a promising avenue of methodological research in infectious disease epidemiology.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2008; v1 submitted 13 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
Network-based analysis of stochastic SIR epidemic models with random and proportionate mixing
Authors:
Eben Kenah,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
In this paper, we outline the theory of epidemic percolation networks and their use in the analysis of stochastic SIR epidemic models on undirected contact networks. We then show how the same theory can be used to analyze stochastic SIR models with random and proportionate mixing. The epidemic percolation networks for these models are purely directed because undirected edges disappear in the lim…
▽ More
In this paper, we outline the theory of epidemic percolation networks and their use in the analysis of stochastic SIR epidemic models on undirected contact networks. We then show how the same theory can be used to analyze stochastic SIR models with random and proportionate mixing. The epidemic percolation networks for these models are purely directed because undirected edges disappear in the limit of a large population. In a series of simulations, we show that epidemic percolation networks accurately predict the mean outbreak size and probability and final size of an epidemic for a variety of epidemic models in homogeneous and heterogeneous populations. Finally, we show that epidemic percolation networks can be used to re-derive classical results from several different areas of infectious disease epidemiology. In an appendix, we show that an epidemic percolation network can be defined for any time-homogeneous stochastic SIR model in a closed population and prove that the distribution of outbreak sizes given the infection of any given node in the SIR model is identical to the distribution of its out-component sizes in the corresponding probability space of epidemic percolation networks. We conclude that the theory of percolation on semi-directed networks provides a very general framework for the analysis of stochastic SIR models in closed populations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2008; v1 submitted 11 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Second look at the spread of epidemics on networks
Authors:
Eben Kenah,
James M. Robins
Abstract:
In an important paper, M.E.J. Newman claimed that a general network-based stochastic Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) epidemic model is isomorphic to a bond percolation model, where the bonds are the edges of the contact network and the bond occupation probability is equal to the marginal probability of transmission from an infected node to a susceptible neighbor. In this paper, we show that…
▽ More
In an important paper, M.E.J. Newman claimed that a general network-based stochastic Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) epidemic model is isomorphic to a bond percolation model, where the bonds are the edges of the contact network and the bond occupation probability is equal to the marginal probability of transmission from an infected node to a susceptible neighbor. In this paper, we show that this isomorphism is incorrect and define a semi-directed random network we call the epidemic percolation network that is exactly isomorphic to the SIR epidemic model in any finite population. In the limit of a large population, (i) the distribution of (self-limited) outbreak sizes is identical to the size distribution of (small) out-components, (ii) the epidemic threshold corresponds to the phase transition where a giant strongly-connected component appears, (iii) the probability of a large epidemic is equal to the probability that an initial infection occurs in the giant in-component, and (iv) the relative final size of an epidemic is equal to the proportion of the network contained in the giant out-component. For the SIR model considered by Newman, we show that the epidemic percolation network predicts the same mean outbreak size below the epidemic threshold, the same epidemic threshold, and the same final size of an epidemic as the bond percolation model. However, the bond percolation model fails to predict the correct outbreak size distribution and probability of an epidemic when there is a nondegenerate infectious period distribution. We confirm our findings by comparing predictions from percolation networks and bond percolation models to the results of simulations. In an appendix, we show that an isomorphism to an epidemic percolation network can be defined for any time-homogeneous stochastic SIR model.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2007; v1 submitted 30 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Causal Inference for Complex Longitudinal Data: The Continuous Time g-Computation Formula
Authors:
R. D. Gill,
J. M. Robins
Abstract:
We extend Robins' theory of causal inference for complex longitudinal data to the case of continuously varying as opposed to discrete covariates and treatments. In particular we establish versions of the key results of the discrete theory: the g-computation formula and a collection of powerful characterizations of the g-null hypothesis of no treatment effect. This is accomplished under natural con…
▽ More
We extend Robins' theory of causal inference for complex longitudinal data to the case of continuously varying as opposed to discrete covariates and treatments. In particular we establish versions of the key results of the discrete theory: the g-computation formula and a collection of powerful characterizations of the g-null hypothesis of no treatment effect. This is accomplished under natural continuity hypotheses concerning the conditional distributions of the outcome variable and of the covariates given the past. We also show that our assumptions concerning counterfactual variables place no restriction on the joint distribution of the observed variables: thus in a precise sense, these assumptions are "for free," or if you prefer, harmless.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2023; v1 submitted 22 September, 2004;
originally announced September 2004.
-
Estimating the causal effect of a time-varying treatment on time-to-event using structural nested failure time models
Authors:
J. J. Lok,
R. D. Gill,
A. W. van der Vaart,
J. M. Robins
Abstract:
In this paper we review an approach to estimating the causal effect of a time-varying treatment on time to some event of interest. This approach is designed for the situation where the treatment may have been repeatedly adapted to patient characteristics, which themselves may also be time-dependent. In this situation the effect of the treatment cannot simply be estimated by conditioning on the p…
▽ More
In this paper we review an approach to estimating the causal effect of a time-varying treatment on time to some event of interest. This approach is designed for the situation where the treatment may have been repeatedly adapted to patient characteristics, which themselves may also be time-dependent. In this situation the effect of the treatment cannot simply be estimated by conditioning on the patient characteristics, as these may themselves be indicators of the treatment effect. This so-called time-dependent confounding is typical in observational studies. We discuss a new class of failure time models, structural nested failure time models, which can be used to estimate the causal effect of a time-varying treatment, and present methods for estimating and testing the parameters of these models.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2004;
originally announced September 2004.