Finding Stable Matchings in PhD Markets with Consistent Preferences and Cooperative Partners
Authors:
Maximilian Mordig,
Riccardo Della Vecchia,
Nicolò Cesa-Bianchi,
Bernhard Schölkopf
Abstract:
We introduce a new algorithm for finding stable matchings in multi-sided matching markets. Our setting is motivated by a PhD market of students, advisors, and co-advisors, and can be generalized to supply chain networks viewed as $n$-sided markets. In the three-sided PhD market, students primarily care about advisors and then about co-advisors (consistent preferences), while advisors and co-adviso…
▽ More
We introduce a new algorithm for finding stable matchings in multi-sided matching markets. Our setting is motivated by a PhD market of students, advisors, and co-advisors, and can be generalized to supply chain networks viewed as $n$-sided markets. In the three-sided PhD market, students primarily care about advisors and then about co-advisors (consistent preferences), while advisors and co-advisors have preferences over students only (hence they are cooperative). A student must be matched to one advisor and one co-advisor, or not at all. In contrast to previous work, advisor-student and student-co-advisor pairs may not be mutually acceptable (e.g., a student may not want to work with an advisor or co-advisor and vice versa). We show that three-sided stable matchings always exist, and present an algorithm that, in time quadratic in the market size (up to log factors), finds a three-sided stable matching using any two-sided stable matching algorithm as matching engine. We illustrate the challenges that arise when not all advisor-co-advisor pairs are compatible. We then generalize our algorithm to $n$-sided markets with quotas and show how they can model supply chain networks. Finally, we show how our algorithm outperforms the baseline given by [Danilov, 2003] in terms of both producing a stable matching and a larger number of matches on a synthetic dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2021; v1 submitted 23 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
Two-Sided Matching Markets in the ELLIS 2020 PhD Program
Authors:
Maximilian Mordig,
Riccardo Della Vecchia,
Nicolò Cesa-Bianchi,
Bernhard Schölkopf
Abstract:
The ELLIS PhD program is a European initiative that supports excellent young researchers by connecting them to leading researchers in AI. In particular, PhD students are supervised by two advisors from different countries: an advisor and a co-advisor. In this work we summarize the procedure that, in its final step, matches students to advisors in the ELLIS 2020 PhD program. The steps of the proced…
▽ More
The ELLIS PhD program is a European initiative that supports excellent young researchers by connecting them to leading researchers in AI. In particular, PhD students are supervised by two advisors from different countries: an advisor and a co-advisor. In this work we summarize the procedure that, in its final step, matches students to advisors in the ELLIS 2020 PhD program. The steps of the procedure are based on the extensive literature of two-sided matching markets and the college admissions problem [Knuth and De Bruijn, 1997, Gale and Shapley, 1962, Rothand Sotomayor, 1992]. We introduce PolyGS, an algorithm for the case of two-sided markets with quotas on both sides (also known as many-to-many markets) which we use throughout the selection procedure of pre-screening, interview matching and final matching with advisors. The algorithm returns a stable matching in the sense that no unmatched persons prefer to be matched together rather than with their current partners (given their indicated preferences). Roth [1984] gives evidence that only stable matchings are likely to be adhered to over time. Additionally, the matching is student-optimal. Preferences are constructed based on the rankings each side gives to the other side and the overlaps of research fields. We present and discuss the matchings that the algorithm produces in the ELLIS 2020 PhD program.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2021; v1 submitted 28 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.