-
Dynamics of Hot QCD Matter -- Current Status and Developments
Authors:
Santosh K. Das,
Prabhakar Palni,
Jhuma Sannigrahi,
Jan-e Alam,
Cho Win Aung,
Yoshini Bailung,
Debjani Banerjee,
Gergely Gábor Barnaföldi,
Subash Chandra Behera,
Partha Pratim Bhaduri,
Samapan Bhadury,
Rajesh Biswas,
Pritam Chakraborty,
Vinod Chandra,
Prottoy Das,
Sadhana Dash,
Saumen Datta,
Sudipan De,
Vaishnavi Desai,
Suman Deb,
Debarshi Dey,
Jayanta Dey,
Sabyasachi Ghosh,
Najmul Haque,
Mujeeb Hasan
, et al. (42 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The discovery and characterization of hot and dense QCD matter, known as Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP), remains the most international collaborative effort and synergy between theorists and experimentalists in modern nuclear physics to date. The experimentalists around the world not only collect an unprecedented amount of data in heavy-ion collisions, at Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), at Brook…
▽ More
The discovery and characterization of hot and dense QCD matter, known as Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP), remains the most international collaborative effort and synergy between theorists and experimentalists in modern nuclear physics to date. The experimentalists around the world not only collect an unprecedented amount of data in heavy-ion collisions, at Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) in New York, USA, and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), at CERN in Geneva, Switzerland but also analyze these data to unravel the mystery of this new phase of matter that filled a few microseconds old universe, just after the Big Bang. In the meantime, advancements in theoretical works and computing capability extend our wisdom about the hot-dense QCD matter and its dynamics through mathematical equations. The exchange of ideas between experimentalists and theoreticians is crucial for the progress of our knowledge. The motivation of this first conference named "HOT QCD Matter 2022" is to bring the community together to have a discourse on this topic. In this article, there are 36 sections discussing various topics in the field of relativistic heavy-ion collisions and related phenomena that cover a snapshot of the current experimental observations and theoretical progress. This article begins with the theoretical overview of relativistic spin-hydrodynamics in the presence of the external magnetic field, followed by the Lattice QCD results on heavy quarks in QGP, and finally, it ends with an overview of experiment results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Effect of magnetic field on the charge and thermal transport properties of hot and dense QCD matter
Authors:
Shubhalaxmi Rath,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
We have studied the effect of strong magnetic field on the charge and thermal transport properties of hot QCD matter at finite chemical potential. For this purpose, we have calculated the electrical ($σ_{\rm el}$) and thermal ($κ$) conductivities using kinetic theory in the relaxation time approximation, where the interactions are subsumed through the distribution functions within the quasiparticl…
▽ More
We have studied the effect of strong magnetic field on the charge and thermal transport properties of hot QCD matter at finite chemical potential. For this purpose, we have calculated the electrical ($σ_{\rm el}$) and thermal ($κ$) conductivities using kinetic theory in the relaxation time approximation, where the interactions are subsumed through the distribution functions within the quasiparticle model at finite temperature, strong magnetic field and finite chemical potential. This study helps to understand the impacts of strong magnetic field and chemical potential on the local equilibrium by the Knudsen number ($Ω$) through $κ$ and on the relative behavior between thermal conductivity and electrical conductivity through the Lorenz number ($L$) in the Wiedemann-Franz law. We have observed that, both $σ_{\rm el}$ and $κ$ get increased in the presence of strong magnetic field, and the additional presence of chemical potential further increases their magnitudes, where $σ_{\rm el}$ shows decreasing trend with the temperature, opposite to its increasing behavior in the isotropic medium, whereas $κ$ increases slowly with the temperature, contrary to its fast increase in the isotropic medium. The variation in $κ$ explains the decrease of the Knudsen number with the increase of the temperature. However, in the presence of strong magnetic field and finite chemical potential, $Ω$ gets enhanced and approaches unity, thus, the system may move slightly away from the equilibrium state. The Lorenz number ($κ/(σ_{\rm el} T))$ in the abovementioned regime of strong magnetic field and finite chemical potential shows linear enhancement with the temperature and has smaller magnitude than the isotropic one, thus, it describes the violation of the Wiedemann-Franz law for the hot and dense QCD matter in the presence of a strong magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2020; v1 submitted 3 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Momentum and its affiliated transport coefficients for a hot QCD matter in a strong magnetic field
Authors:
Shubhalaxmi Rath,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
We have studied the effects of anisotropies on the momentum transport in a QCD matter by shear ($η$) and bulk ($ζ$) viscosities. The anisotropies arise either by the strong magnetic field or by the preferential expansion. This study helps to understand the fluidity and location of transition point of matter through $η/s$ and $ζ/s$ ($s$ is entropy density), respectively, the sound attenuation throu…
▽ More
We have studied the effects of anisotropies on the momentum transport in a QCD matter by shear ($η$) and bulk ($ζ$) viscosities. The anisotropies arise either by the strong magnetic field or by the preferential expansion. This study helps to understand the fluidity and location of transition point of matter through $η/s$ and $ζ/s$ ($s$ is entropy density), respectively, the sound attenuation through the Prandtl number (Pl), the nature of flow by the Reynolds number (Rl), and the competition between momentum and charge diffusions. The viscosities are calculated in the relaxation time approximation of kinetic theory within the quasiparticle model. Compared to isotropic medium, both $η$ and $ζ$ get increased in magnetic field-driven (B-driven) anisotropy, contrary to the decrease in expansion-driven anisotropy. $η$ increases with temperature faster in former case than in latter case whereas $ζ$ in former case decreases with temperature and in latter case, it is meagre and diminishes at a specific temperature. So the viscosities can distinguish aforesaid anisotropies. Thus, $η/s$ gets enhanced in former case and in latter case, it becomes smaller than isotropic one. Similarly $ζ/s$ gets amplified but decreases faster with the temperature in a strong magnetic field. The Prandtl number gets increased in B-induced anisotropy and gets decreased in expansion-induced anisotropy, compared to isotropic one. Since, Pl is found larger than 1, the sound attenuation is governed by momentum diffusion. The B-driven anisotropy makes the Reynolds number smaller than one, whereas the expansion-driven anisotropy makes it larger. The ratio ($\fracη{s}/\frac{σ_{\rm el}}{T}$) gets amplified in B-driven anisotropy whereas it gets reduced in expansion-driven anisotropy. Since, the ratio is always more than one, the momentum diffusion prevails over the charge diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2020; v1 submitted 31 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Revisit to electrical and thermal conductivities, Lorenz number and Knudsen number in thermal QCD in a strong magnetic field
Authors:
Shubhalaxmi Rath,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
We have explored how the electrical ($σ_{\rm el}$) and thermal ($κ$) conductivities in a thermal QCD medium get affected in weak-momentum anisotropies arising either due to a strong magnetic field or due to asymptotic expansion. This study facilitates to understand the longevity of strong magnetic field through $σ_{el}$, Lorenz number in Wiedemann-Franz law, and the validity of equilibrium by the…
▽ More
We have explored how the electrical ($σ_{\rm el}$) and thermal ($κ$) conductivities in a thermal QCD medium get affected in weak-momentum anisotropies arising either due to a strong magnetic field or due to asymptotic expansion. This study facilitates to understand the longevity of strong magnetic field through $σ_{el}$, Lorenz number in Wiedemann-Franz law, and the validity of equilibrium by the Knudsen number. We calculate the conductivities by solving relativistic Boltzmann transport equation in relaxation-time approximation within quasiparticle model at finite T and strong B. We have found that $σ_{el}$ and $κ$ get enhanced in a magnetic field-driven anisotropy, but $σ_{el}$ decreases with temperature, opposite to its faster increase in expansion-driven anisotropy. Whereas $κ$ increases slowly with temperature, contrary to its rapid increase in expansion-driven anisotropy. The above findings are broadly attributed to three factors: the stretching and squeezing of distribution function in anisotropies generated by the magnetic field and asymptotic expansion, respectively, the dispersion relation and resulting phase-space factor, the relaxation-time in absence and presence of strong magnetic field. So $σ_{\rm el}$ extracts the time-dependence of magnetic field, which decays slower than in vacuum but expansion-driven anisotropy makes the decay faster. The variation in $κ$ transpires that Knudsen number decreases with T but expansion-driven anisotropy reduces its value and magnetic field-driven anisotropy raises its value but to less than one, thus the system can still be in equilibrium. The ratio, $κ/σ_{el}$ in magnetic field-driven anisotropy increases linearly with temperature but with a value smaller than in expansion-driven anisotropy. Thus the Lorenz number can make the distinction between different anisotropies.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2019; v1 submitted 12 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
S-Matrix approach to Compton scattering at the tree level in a strong magnetic field
Authors:
Jitendra Pal,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
We have studied the Compton scattering ($γe^- \longrightarrow γe^-$) at the tree level in a homogeneous background of strong magnetic field ($|eB| \gg { m }^{ 2 },~\text{m is the mass of electron}$) through the S-matrix approach. For that purpose, using the Schwinger propagator for the electron, we have first calculated the square of the S-matrix element in the Landau gauge by summing over the fin…
▽ More
We have studied the Compton scattering ($γe^- \longrightarrow γe^-$) at the tree level in a homogeneous background of strong magnetic field ($|eB| \gg { m }^{ 2 },~\text{m is the mass of electron}$) through the S-matrix approach. For that purpose, using the Schwinger propagator for the electron, we have first calculated the square of the S-matrix element in the Landau gauge by summing over the final states of electron and photon and averaging over the initial states of the same. In the strong magnetic field, only the lowest Landau level for electron is considered. Finally we have computed the crosssection for Compton scattering as a function of initial photon energy for the different strengths of strong magnetic fields, where we have found that the crosssection in vacuum gets decreased due to the presence of strong magnetic field. However, for a fixed initial photon energy, the crosssection increases linearly with the magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Thermomagnetic properties and Bjorken expansion of hot QCD matter in a strong magnetic field
Authors:
Shubhalaxmi Rath,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
In this work we have studied the effects of an external strong magnetic field on the thermodynamic and magnetic properties of a hot QCD matter and then explored these effects on the subsequent hydrodynamic expansion of the said matter once produced in the ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions. For that purpose, we have computed the quark and gluon self-energies up to one loop in the strong magnet…
▽ More
In this work we have studied the effects of an external strong magnetic field on the thermodynamic and magnetic properties of a hot QCD matter and then explored these effects on the subsequent hydrodynamic expansion of the said matter once produced in the ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions. For that purpose, we have computed the quark and gluon self-energies up to one loop in the strong magnetic field, using the HTL approximation with two hard scales - temperature and magnetic field, which in turn compute the effective propagators for quarks and gluons, respectively. Hence the quark and gluon contributions to the free energy are obtained from the respective propagators and finally derive the equation of state (EOS) by calculating the pressure and energy density. We have found that the speed of sound is enhanced due to the presence of strong magnetic field and this effect will be later exploited in the hydrodynamics. Thereafter the magnetic properties are studied from the free energy of the matter, where the magnetization is found to increase linearly with the magnetic field, thus hints the paramagnetic behavior. The temperature dependence of the magnetization is also studied, where the magnetization is found to increase slowly with the temperature. Finally, to see how a strong magnetic field could affect the hydrodynamic evolution, we have revisited the Bjorken boost-invariant picture with our paramagnetic EOS as an input in the equation of motion for the energy-momentum conservation. We have noticed that the energy density evolves faster than in the absence of strong magnetic field, i.e. cooling becomes faster, which could have implications on the heavy-ion phenomenology. As mentioned earlier, this observation can be understood by the enhancement of the speed of sound.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2019; v1 submitted 8 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Landau Dam** in a strong magnetic field: Dissociation of Quarkonia
Authors:
Mujeeb Hasan,
Binoy Krishna Patra,
Bhaswar Chatterjee,
Partha Bagchi
Abstract:
We have investigated the effects of strong magnetic field on the properties of quarkonia immersed in a thermal medium of quarks and gluons and studied its quasi-free dissociation due to the Landau-dam**. Thermalizing the Schwinger propagator in the lowest Landau levels for quarks and the Feynman propagator for gluons in real-time formalism, we have calculated the resummed retarded and symmetric…
▽ More
We have investigated the effects of strong magnetic field on the properties of quarkonia immersed in a thermal medium of quarks and gluons and studied its quasi-free dissociation due to the Landau-dam**. Thermalizing the Schwinger propagator in the lowest Landau levels for quarks and the Feynman propagator for gluons in real-time formalism, we have calculated the resummed retarded and symmetric propagators, which in turn give the real and imaginary components of dielectric permittivity, respectively. The magnetic field affects the large-distance interaction more than the short-distance interaction, as a result, the real part of potential becomes more attractive and the magnitude of imaginary part too becomes larger, compared to the thermal medium in absence of strong magnetic field. As a consequence the average size of $J/ψ$'s and $ψ^\prime$'s are increased but $χ_c$'s get shrunk. Similarly the magnetic field affects the binding of $J/ψ$'s and $χ_c$'s discriminately, i.e. it decreases the binding of $J/ψ$ and increases for $χ_c$. However, the further increase in magnetic field results in the decrease of binding energies. On contrary the magnetic field increases the width of the resonances, unless the temperature is sufficiently high. We have finally studied how the presence of magnetic field affects the dissolution of quarkonia in a thermal medium due to the Landau dam**, where the dissociation temperatures are found to increase compared to the thermal medium in absence of magnetic field. However, further increase of magnetic field decreases the dissociation temperatures. For example, $J/ψ$'s and $χ_c$'s are dissociated at higher temperatures at 2 $T_c$ and 1.1 $T_c$ at a magnetic field $eB \approx 6~{\rm{and}}~4~m_π^2$, respectively, compared to the values 1.60 $T_c$ and 0.8 $T_c$ in the absence of magnetic field, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
One-loop QCD thermodynamics in a strong homogeneous and static magnetic field
Authors:
Shubhalaxmi Rath,
Binoy Krishna Patra
Abstract:
We have studied how the equation of state of thermal QCD with two light flavours is modified in strong magnetic field by calculating the thermodynamic observables of hot QCD matter up to one-loop, where the magnetic field affects mainly the quark contribution and the gluonic part is largely unaffected except for the softening of the screening mass due to the strong magnetic field. To begin with th…
▽ More
We have studied how the equation of state of thermal QCD with two light flavours is modified in strong magnetic field by calculating the thermodynamic observables of hot QCD matter up to one-loop, where the magnetic field affects mainly the quark contribution and the gluonic part is largely unaffected except for the softening of the screening mass due to the strong magnetic field. To begin with the effect of magnetic field on the thermodynamics, we have first calculated the pressure of a thermal QCD medium in strong magnetic field limit (SML), where the pressure at fixed temperature increases with the magnetic field faster than the increase with the temperature at constant magnetic field. This can be envisaged from the dominant scale of thermal medium in SML, which is the magnetic field, like the temperature in thermal medium in absence of strong magnetic field. Thus although the presence of strong magnetic field makes the pressure of hot QCD medium harder but the increase of pressure with respect to the temperature becomes less steeper. Corroborated to the above observations, the entropy density is found to decrease with the temperature in the ambience of strong magnetic field which resonates with the fact that the strong magnetic field restricts the dynamics of quarks in two dimensions, hence the phase space gets squeezed resulting the reduction of number of microstates. Moreover the energy density is seen to decrease and the speed of sound of thermal QCD medium is increased in the presence of strong magnetic field. These crucial findings in strong magnetic field could have phenomenological implications in heavy ion collisions because the expansion dynamics of the medium produced in noncentral ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions is effectively controlled by both the energy density and the speed of sound.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Quenching parameter in a holographic thermal QCD
Authors:
Binoy Krishna Patra,
Bhaskar Arya
Abstract:
We have calculated the quenching parameter, $\hat{q}$ in a model-independent way using the gauge-gravity duality. In earlier calculations, the geometry in the gravity side at finite temperature was usually taken as the pure AdS blackhole metric for which the dual gauge theory becomes conformally invariant unlike QCD. Therefore we use a metric which incorporates the fundamental quarks by embedding…
▽ More
We have calculated the quenching parameter, $\hat{q}$ in a model-independent way using the gauge-gravity duality. In earlier calculations, the geometry in the gravity side at finite temperature was usually taken as the pure AdS blackhole metric for which the dual gauge theory becomes conformally invariant unlike QCD. Therefore we use a metric which incorporates the fundamental quarks by embedding the coincident D7 branes in the Klebanov-Tseytlin background and a finite temperature is switched on by inserting a black hole into the background, known as OKS-BH metric. Further inclusion of an additional UV cap to the metric prepares the dual gauge theory to run similar to thermal QCD. Moreover $\hat{q}$ is usually defined in the literature from the Glauber-model perturbative QCD evaluation of the Wilson loop, which has no reasons to hold if the coupling is large and is thus against the main idea of gauge-gravity duality. Thus we use an appropriate definition of $\hat{q}$: $\hat{q} L^- = 1/L^2$, where $L$ is the separation for which the Wilson loop is equal to some specific value. The above two refinements cause $\hat{q}$ to vary with the temperature as $T^4$ always and to depend linearly on the light-cone time $L^-$ with an additional ($1/L^-$) correction term in the short-distance limit whereas in the long-distance limit, it depends only linearly on $L^-$ with no correction term. These observations agree with other holographic calculations directly or indirectly.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Velocity-induced Heavy Quarkonium Dissociation using the gauge-gravity correspondence
Authors:
Binoy Krishna Patra,
Himanshu Khanchandani,
Lata Thakur
Abstract:
Using the gauge-gravity duality we have obtained the potential between a heavy quark and an antiquark pair, which is moving perpendicular to the direction of orientation, in a strongly-coupled supersymmetric hot plasma. For the purpose we work on a metric in the gravity side, {\em viz.} OKS-BH geometry, whose dual in the gauge theory side runs with the energy and hence proves to be a better backgr…
▽ More
Using the gauge-gravity duality we have obtained the potential between a heavy quark and an antiquark pair, which is moving perpendicular to the direction of orientation, in a strongly-coupled supersymmetric hot plasma. For the purpose we work on a metric in the gravity side, {\em viz.} OKS-BH geometry, whose dual in the gauge theory side runs with the energy and hence proves to be a better background for thermal QCD. The potential obtained has confining term both in vacuum and in medium, in addition to the Coulomb term alone, usually reported in the literature. As the velocity of the pair is increased the screening of the potential gets weakened, which may be understood by the decrease of effective temperature with the increase of velocity. The crucial observation of our work is that beyond a critical separation of the heavy quark pair, the potential develops an imaginary part which is nowadays understood to be the main source of dissociation. The imaginary part is found to vanish at small $r$, thus agrees with the perturbative result. Finally we have estimated the thermal width for the ground and first excited states and found that non-zero rapidities lead to an increase of thermal width. This implies that the moving quarkonia dissociate easier than the static ones, which agrees with other calculations. However, the width in our case is larger than other calculations due to the presence of confining terms.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2015; v1 submitted 21 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Heavy Quark Potential at Finite Temperature in a Dual Gravity Closer to Large N QCD
Authors:
Binoy Krishna Patra,
Himanshu Khanchandani
Abstract:
In gauge-gravity duality, the heavy quark potential at finite temperature is usually calculated with the pure AdS background, which does not capture the renormalization group (RG) running in the gauge theory part. In addition, the potential does not contain any confining term in the deconfined phase. Following the Klebanov-Strassler geometry, we employ a geometry, which captures the RG flow simila…
▽ More
In gauge-gravity duality, the heavy quark potential at finite temperature is usually calculated with the pure AdS background, which does not capture the renormalization group (RG) running in the gauge theory part. In addition, the potential does not contain any confining term in the deconfined phase. Following the Klebanov-Strassler geometry, we employ a geometry, which captures the RG flow similar to QCD, to obtain the heavy quark potential by analytically continuing the string configurations into the complex plane. In addition to the attractive terms, the obtained potential has confining terms both at $T = 0$ and $T \neq 0 $, compared to the calculations usually done in the literature, where only the Coulomb-like term is present in the deconfined phase. The potential also develops an (negative) imaginary part above a critical separation, $r_c (= 0.53 z_h )$. Moreover, our potential exhibits a behavior different from the usual Debye screening obtained from perturbation theory.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2015; v1 submitted 16 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Spectral Representation at Finite Temperature
Authors:
Sourav Sarkar,
B. K. Patra,
V. J. Menon,
S. Mallik
Abstract:
This is a short review on the thermal, spectral representation in the real-time version of the finite temperature quantum field theory. After presenting a clear derivation of the spectral representation, we discuss the properties of its spectral function. Two applications of this representation are then considered. One is the solution of the Dyson equation for the thermal propagator. The other i…
▽ More
This is a short review on the thermal, spectral representation in the real-time version of the finite temperature quantum field theory. After presenting a clear derivation of the spectral representation, we discuss the properties of its spectral function. Two applications of this representation are then considered. One is the solution of the Dyson equation for the thermal propagator. The other is the formulation of the QCD sum rules at finite temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2002; v1 submitted 10 October, 2000;
originally announced October 2000.
