Showing 1–50 of 160 results for author: Braaten, E

Born-Oppenheimer Potentials for $SU(3)$ Gauge Theory

Authors: Fareed Alasiri, Eric Braaten, Abhishek Mohapatra

Abstract: We develop parameterizations of 8 of the lowest Born-Oppenheimer potentials for quarkonium hybrid mesons as functions of the separation $r$ of the static quark and antiquark sources. The parameters are determined by fitting results calculated using pure $SU(3)$ lattice gauge theory. The parameterizations have the correct limiting behavior at small $r$, where the potentials form multiplets associat… ▽ More We develop parameterizations of 8 of the lowest Born-Oppenheimer potentials for quarkonium hybrid mesons as functions of the separation $r$ of the static quark and antiquark sources. The parameters are determined by fitting results calculated using pure $SU(3)$ lattice gauge theory. The parameterizations have the correct limiting behavior at small $r$, where the potentials form multiplets associated with gluelumps. They have the correct limiting behavior at large $r$, where the potentials form multiplets associated with excitations of a relativistic string. There is a narrow avoided crossing in the small-$r$ region between two potentials with the same Born-Oppenheimer quantum numbers. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 37 pages, 10 figures, 4 tables

Report number: TUM-EFT 188/24

Model-independent predictions for decays of hidden-heavy hadrons into pairs of heavy hadrons

Authors: E. Braaten, R. Bruschini

Abstract: Hidden-heavy hadrons can decay into pairs of heavy hadrons through transitions from confining Born-Oppenheimer potentials to hadron-pair potentials with the same Born-Oppenheimer quantum numbers. The transitions are also constrained by conservation of angular momentum and parity. From these constraints, we derive model-independent selection rules for decays of hidden-heavy hadrons into pairs of he… ▽ More Hidden-heavy hadrons can decay into pairs of heavy hadrons through transitions from confining Born-Oppenheimer potentials to hadron-pair potentials with the same Born-Oppenheimer quantum numbers. The transitions are also constrained by conservation of angular momentum and parity. From these constraints, we derive model-independent selection rules for decays of hidden-heavy hadrons into pairs of heavy hadrons. The coupling potentials are expressed as sums of products of Born-Oppenheimer transition amplitudes and angular-momentum coefficients. If there is a single dominant Born-Oppenheimer transition amplitude, it factors out of the coupling potentials between hidden-heavy hadrons in the same Born-Oppenheimer multiplet and pairs of heavy hadrons in specific heavy-quark-spin-symmetry doublets. If furthermore the kinetic energies of the heavy hadrons are much larger than their spin splittings, we obtain analytic expressions for the relative partial decay rates in terms of Wigner 6-j and 9-j symbols. We consider in detail the decays of quarkonia and quarkonium hybrids into the lightest heavy-meson pairs. For quarkonia, our model-independent selection rules and relative partial decay rates agree with previous results from quark-pair-creation models in simple cases and give stronger results in other cases. For quarkonium hybrids, we find disagreement even in simple cases. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 39 pages, 5 tables; v2: introduced additional references; v3: new title, focused on hidden-heavy hadrons, removed treatment of double-heavy hadrons, version accepted in PRD

Charm-Meson $t$-channel Singularities in an Expanding Hadron Gas

Authors: Eric Braaten, Roberto Bruschini, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: We study the time evolution of the numbers of charm mesons after the kinetic freezeout of the expanding hadron gas produced by the hadronization of the quark-gluon plasma from a central heavy-ion collision. The $πD$ reaction rates have contributions from a $D^\ast$ resonance in the $s$ channel. The $πD^\ast$ reaction rates are enhanced by $t$-channel singularities from an intermediate $D$. The con… ▽ More We study the time evolution of the numbers of charm mesons after the kinetic freezeout of the expanding hadron gas produced by the hadronization of the quark-gluon plasma from a central heavy-ion collision. The $πD$ reaction rates have contributions from a $D^\ast$ resonance in the $s$ channel. The $πD^\ast$ reaction rates are enhanced by $t$-channel singularities from an intermediate $D$. The contributions to reaction rates from $D^\ast$ resonances and $D$-meson $t$-channel singularities are sensitive to thermal mass shifts and thermal widths. In the expanding hadron gas, the $t$-channel singularities are regularized by the thermal $D$ widths. After kinetic freezeout, the thermal $D$ widths are dominated by coherent pion forward scattering. The contributions to $πD^\ast$ reaction rates from $t$-channel singularities are inversely proportional to the pion number density, which decreases to 0 as the hadron gas expands. The $t$-channel singularities produce small but significant changes in charm-meson ratios from those predicted using the known $D^\ast$-decay branching fractions. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 41 pages, 12 figures

The case for an EIC Theory Alliance: Theoretical Challenges of the EIC

Authors: Raktim Abir, Igor Akushevich, Tolga Altinoluk, Daniele Paolo Anderle, Fatma P. Aslan, Alessandro Bacchetta, Baha Balantekin, Joao Barata, Marco Battaglieri, Carlos A. Bertulani, Guillaume Beuf, Chiara Bissolotti, Daniël Boer, M. Boglione, Radja Boughezal, Eric Braaten, Nora Brambilla, Vladimir Braun, Duane Byer, Francesco Giovanni Celiberto, Yang-Ting Chien, Ian C. Cloët, Martha Constantinou, Wim Cosyn, Aurore Courtoy , et al. (146 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We outline the physics opportunities provided by the Electron Ion Collider (EIC). These include the study of the parton structure of the nucleon and nuclei, the onset of gluon saturation, the production of jets and heavy flavor, hadron spectroscopy and tests of fundamental symmetries. We review the present status and future challenges in EIC theory that have to be addressed in order to realize thi… ▽ More We outline the physics opportunities provided by the Electron Ion Collider (EIC). These include the study of the parton structure of the nucleon and nuclei, the onset of gluon saturation, the production of jets and heavy flavor, hadron spectroscopy and tests of fundamental symmetries. We review the present status and future challenges in EIC theory that have to be addressed in order to realize this ambitious and impactful physics program, including how to engage a diverse and inclusive workforce. In order to address these many-fold challenges, we propose a coordinated effort involving theory groups with differing expertise is needed. We discuss the scientific goals and scope of such an EIC Theory Alliance. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 44 pages, ReVTeX, White Paper on EIC Theory Alliance

Thermal Energy of a Charm-meson Molecule in a Pion Gas

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: The thermal corrections to the propagator of a loosely bound charm-meson molecule in a pion gas are calculated to next-to-leading order in the heavy-meson expansion using a zero-range effective field theory. Ultraviolet divergences in the charm-meson-pair self energy are canceled by corrections to the charm-meson-pair contact vertex. Terms that are singular at the charm-meson-pair threshold can be… ▽ More The thermal corrections to the propagator of a loosely bound charm-meson molecule in a pion gas are calculated to next-to-leading order in the heavy-meson expansion using a zero-range effective field theory. Ultraviolet divergences in the charm-meson-pair self energy are canceled by corrections to the charm-meson-pair contact vertex. Terms that are singular at the charm-meson-pair threshold can be absorbed into thermal corrections to the rest energies and kinetic masses of the charm-meson constituents. The remaining terms reduce to a thermal correction to the binding momentum that is proportional to the pion number density and suppressed by the pion/charm-meson mass ratio. The correction gives a tiny decrease in the binding energy of the charm-meson molecule relative to the charm-meson-pair threshold in the pion gas and a change in its thermal width that is small compared to the thermal widths of the charm-meson constituents. These results are encouraging for the prospects of observing $X(3872)$ and $T_{cc}^+(3875)$ in the expanding hadron gas produced by heavy-ion collisions. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2023; v1 submitted 14 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 39 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables

Point Production of a Nonrelativistic Unparticle Recoiling Against a Particle

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hans-Werner Hammer

Abstract: A nonrelativistic unparticle can be defined as an excitation created by an operator with a definite scaling dimension in a nonrelativistic field theory with an approximate conformal symmetry. The point production rate of an unparticle has power-law dependence on its total energy with an exponent determined by its scaling dimension. We use the exact result for the 3-point function of primary operat… ▽ More A nonrelativistic unparticle can be defined as an excitation created by an operator with a definite scaling dimension in a nonrelativistic field theory with an approximate conformal symmetry. The point production rate of an unparticle has power-law dependence on its total energy with an exponent determined by its scaling dimension. We use the exact result for the 3-point function of primary operators in a nonrelativistic conformal field theory to derive the contribution to the point production rate of the unparticle from its decay into another unparticle recoiling against a particle. In the case where the conformal symmetry is broken by a large positive scattering length, we deduce the exponent of the energy in the point production rate of the loosely bound two-particle state recoiling against a particle with large relative momentum. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 17 pages, 7 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2107.02831

Evolution of charm-meson ratios in an expanding hadron gas

Authors: Eric Braaten, Roberto Bruschini, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: We study the time evolution of the numbers of charm mesons after the kinetic freeze-out of the hadron gas produced by a central heavy-ion collision. The $πD^\ast \to πD^\ast$ reaction rates have $t$-channel singularities that give contributions inversely proportional to the thermal width of the $D$. The ratio of the $D^0$ and $D^+$ production rates can differ significantly from those predicted usi… ▽ More We study the time evolution of the numbers of charm mesons after the kinetic freeze-out of the hadron gas produced by a central heavy-ion collision. The $πD^\ast \to πD^\ast$ reaction rates have $t$-channel singularities that give contributions inversely proportional to the thermal width of the $D$. The ratio of the $D^0$ and $D^+$ production rates can differ significantly from those predicted using the measured $D^\ast$ branching fractions. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 1 figure

Triangle Singularity in the Production of $T_{cc}^+$(3875) and a Soft Pion

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: The double-charm tetraquark meson $T_{cc}^+(3875)$ can be produced in high-energy proton-proton collisions by the creation of the charm mesons $D^{*+} D^0$ at short distances followed by their binding into $T_{cc}^+$. The $T_{cc}^+$ can also be produced by the creation of $D^{*+} D^{*+}$ at short distances followed by their rescattering into $T_{cc}^+ π^+$. A charm-meson triangle singularity produ… ▽ More The double-charm tetraquark meson $T_{cc}^+(3875)$ can be produced in high-energy proton-proton collisions by the creation of the charm mesons $D^{*+} D^0$ at short distances followed by their binding into $T_{cc}^+$. The $T_{cc}^+$ can also be produced by the creation of $D^{*+} D^{*+}$ at short distances followed by their rescattering into $T_{cc}^+ π^+$. A charm-meson triangle singularity produces a narrow peak in the $T_{cc}^+ π^+$ invariant mass distribution 6.1 MeV above the threshold with a width of about 1 MeV. Well beyond the peak, the differential cross section decreases with the invariant kinetic energy $E$ of $T_{cc}^+ π^+$ as $E^{-1/2}$. The fraction of $T_{cc}^+$ that are accompanied by $π^+$ with $E< m_π$ is estimated to be roughly 3%. The fraction of $T_{cc}^+$ events with $T_{cc}^+ π^+$ in the narrow peak from the triangle singularity could be comparable. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2022; v1 submitted 8 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 44 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D 106 (2022) 3, 034033

Interpretation of neutral charm mesons near threshold as unparticles

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hans-Werner Hammer

Abstract: The existence of the $X(3872)$ resonance extremely close to the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ threshold implies that neutral charm mesons have an approximate nonrelativistic conformal symmetry. Systems consisting of these mesons with small kinetic energies produced in a short-distance reaction are unparticles in the sense that they can be created by operators with definite scaling dimensions in a nonrelativi… ▽ More The existence of the $X(3872)$ resonance extremely close to the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ threshold implies that neutral charm mesons have an approximate nonrelativistic conformal symmetry. Systems consisting of these mesons with small kinetic energies produced in a short-distance reaction are unparticles in the sense that they can be created by operators with definite scaling dimensions in a nonrelativistic conformal field theory. There is a scaling region in which their energy distribution has power-law behavior with an exponent determined by the scaling dimension of the operator. The unparticle associated with two neutral charm mesons produces a peak in the recoil momentum spectrum of $K^\pm$ in inclusive decays of $B^\pm$ that has been observed. The scaling dimensions of the unparticles associated with three neutral charm mesons are calculated. They can be determined experimentally by measuring the invariant mass distributions for $XD^0$ or $X D^{*0}$ in inclusive prompt production at the Large Hadron Collider. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2022; v1 submitted 6 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, title changed, final version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 032002 (2022)

Production of $X(3872)$ at High Multiplicity

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: The dependence of the production of the $X(3872)$ meson on the hadron multiplicity in $pp$ collisions has been used as evidence against $X$ being a charm-meson molecule. The argument is based in part on the incorrect assumption that the cross section for the breakup of $X$ by scattering with comovers can be approximated by a geometric cross section inversely proportional to the binding energy of… ▽ More The dependence of the production of the $X(3872)$ meson on the hadron multiplicity in $pp$ collisions has been used as evidence against $X$ being a charm-meson molecule. The argument is based in part on the incorrect assumption that the cross section for the breakup of $X$ by scattering with comovers can be approximated by a geometric cross section inversely proportional to the binding energy of $X$. The breakup cross section should instead be approximated by the probability-weighted sum of the cross sections for the scattering of comoving pions from the charm-meson constituents of $X$, which is insensitive to the binding energy. A simple modification of the comover interaction model gives excellent fits to the data from the LHCb collaboration on the multiplicity dependence of the production of $X$ and $ψ(2S)$ using parameters compatible with $X$ being a loosely bound charm-meson molecule. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 071901 (2021)

Galilean-Invariant XEFT at Next-to-Leading Order

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Jun Jiang

Abstract: XEFT is a low-energy effective field theory for charm mesons and pions that provides a systematically improvable description of the $X(3872)$ resonance. To simplify calculations beyond leading order, we introduce a new formulation of XEFT with a dynamical field for a pair of charm mesons in the resonant channel. We simplify the renormalization of XEFT by introducing a new renormalization scheme th… ▽ More XEFT is a low-energy effective field theory for charm mesons and pions that provides a systematically improvable description of the $X(3872)$ resonance. To simplify calculations beyond leading order, we introduce a new formulation of XEFT with a dynamical field for a pair of charm mesons in the resonant channel. We simplify the renormalization of XEFT by introducing a new renormalization scheme that involves the subtraction of amplitudes at the complex $D^{*0} \bar D^0$ threshold. The new formulation and the new renormalization scheme are illustrated by calculating the complex pole energy of $X$ and the $D^{*0} \bar D^0$ scattering amplitude to next-to-leading order using Galilean-invariant XEFT. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: 47 pages, 18 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 036014 (2021)

Masses of Doubly Heavy Tetraquarks with Error Bars

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Abhishek Mohapatra

Abstract: In the heavy-quark limit, the two heavy quarks in a doubly heavy baryon or a doubly heavy tetraquark are bound by their color-Coulomb potential into a compact diquark. The doubly heavy hadrons are related by the approximate heavy-quark--diquark symmetry of QCD to the heavy hadrons obtained by replacing the heavy diquark by a heavy antiquark. Effective field theories can be used to expand the masse… ▽ More In the heavy-quark limit, the two heavy quarks in a doubly heavy baryon or a doubly heavy tetraquark are bound by their color-Coulomb potential into a compact diquark. The doubly heavy hadrons are related by the approximate heavy-quark--diquark symmetry of QCD to the heavy hadrons obtained by replacing the heavy diquark by a heavy antiquark. Effective field theories can be used to expand the masses of singly heavy hadrons and doubly heavy hadrons in inverse powers of the heavy quark masses. The coefficients in the expansions for doubly heavy tetraquarks can be determined from those for heavy mesons, heavy baryons, and doubly heavy baryons using heavy-quark--diquark symmetry. We predict the masses of the ground-state doubly heavy tetraquarks with error bars using as inputs the masses of heavy mesons and heavy baryons measured in experiments and the masses of doubly heavy baryons calculated using lattice QCD. The only doubly heavy tetraquarks predicted to be stable with respect to strong decays are $bb$ tetraquarks with light flavor $\bar u \bar d$, $\bar s \bar u$ and $\bar s \bar d$. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2021; v1 submitted 15 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 28 pages, 7 tables, Minor revisions, published in Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 016001 (2021)

Charm-meson Triangle Singularity in ${e^+e^-}$ Annihilation into ${ D^{*0} \bar{D}^0 + γ}$

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles, Jun Jiang

Abstract: We calculate the cross section for $e^+ e^-$ annihilation into $D^{*0} \bar D^0 +γ$ at center-of-mass energies near the $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ threshold under the assumption that $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm meson molecule. The Dalitz plot has a $\bar D^{*0}$ resonance band in the squared invariant mass $t$ of $\bar D^0 γ$. In the limit as the decay width of the $D^{*0}$ goes to 0, the Dalitz p… ▽ More We calculate the cross section for $e^+ e^-$ annihilation into $D^{*0} \bar D^0 +γ$ at center-of-mass energies near the $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ threshold under the assumption that $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm meson molecule. The Dalitz plot has a $\bar D^{*0}$ resonance band in the squared invariant mass $t$ of $\bar D^0 γ$. In the limit as the decay width of the $D^{*0}$ goes to 0, the Dalitz plot also has a narrow band in the squared invariant mass $u$ of $D^{*0} \bar D^0$ from a charm-meson triangle singularity. At the physical value of the $D^{*0}$ width, the narrow band reduces to a shoulder. Thus the triangle singularity cannot be observed directly as a peak in a differential cross section as a function of $u$. It may however be observed indirectly as a local minimum in the $t$ distribution for events with $u$ below the triangle singularity. The minimum is produced by the Schmid cancellation between triangle loop diagrams and a tree diagram. The observation of this minimum would support the identification of $X(3872)$ as a weakly bound charm meson molecule. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 29 pages and 15 figures

Production of $X(3872)$ and a Photon in $e^+e^-$ Annihilation

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced in $e^+ e^-$ annihilation by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ from a virtual photon followed by the rescattering of the P-wave charm-meson pair into the $X$ and a photon. A triangle singularity produces a narrow peak in the cross section for $e^+ e^- \to X γ$ 2.2 MeV above the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold. We predic… ▽ More If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced in $e^+ e^-$ annihilation by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ from a virtual photon followed by the rescattering of the P-wave charm-meson pair into the $X$ and a photon. A triangle singularity produces a narrow peak in the cross section for $e^+ e^- \to X γ$ 2.2 MeV above the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold. We predict the normalized cross section in the region of the peak. We show that the absorptive contribution to the cross section for $e^+ e^- \to D^{*0} \bar D^{*0} \to X γ$, which was calculated previously by Dubynskiy and Voloshin, does not give a good approximation to the peak from the triangle singularity. △ Less

Submitted 22 November, 2019; v1 submitted 5 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 26 pages, 11 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1904.12915

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 014021 (2020)

Branching Fractions of the $X(3872)$

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: The recoil momentum spectrum from the decay $B^+ \to K^+ +\mathrm{anything}$ has recently been measured by the BaBar collaboration. The spectrum has a peak with invariant mass near the mass of the $X(3872)$ meson. The preliminary measurement by the BaBar collaboration implies that its branching fraction into $J/ψ\, π^+π^-$ is about 4\%. We emphasize that this is the branching fraction for the enti… ▽ More The recoil momentum spectrum from the decay $B^+ \to K^+ +\mathrm{anything}$ has recently been measured by the BaBar collaboration. The spectrum has a peak with invariant mass near the mass of the $X(3872)$ meson. The preliminary measurement by the BaBar collaboration implies that its branching fraction into $J/ψ\, π^+π^-$ is about 4\%. We emphasize that this is the branching fraction for the entire resonance feature from $B^+$-to-$K^+$ transitions, which includes a $D^{*0} \bar D^0$ and $D^0 \bar D^{*0}$ threshold enhancement as well as a possible bound state below the threshold or a virtual state. If the $X$ is a bound state of charm mesons, its branching fraction into $J/ψ\, π^+π^-$ should be considerably larger than that of the $X$ resonance feature. We use measurements of branching ratios of the $X$ to put an upper bound on this branching fraction of 33\%. We also constrain the parameters of the simplest plausible model for the line shapes of the $X$ using the precise measurement of the resonance energy of the $X$ and an estimate of the branching fraction into $D^0 \bar D^0 π^0$ and $D^0 \bar D^0γ$ from the $X$ resonance feature from $B^+$-to-$K^+$ transitions. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Dark Matter Bound States from Three-Body Recombination

Authors: Eric Braaten, Daekyoung Kang, Ranjan Laha

Abstract: The small-scale structure problems of the universe can be solved by self-interacting dark matter that becomes strongly interacting at low energies. A particularly predictive model is resonant short-range self-interactions, with a dark-matter mass of about 19 GeV and a large S-wave scattering length of about 17 fm. Such a model makes definite predictions for the few-body physics of weakly bound clu… ▽ More The small-scale structure problems of the universe can be solved by self-interacting dark matter that becomes strongly interacting at low energies. A particularly predictive model is resonant short-range self-interactions, with a dark-matter mass of about 19 GeV and a large S-wave scattering length of about 17 fm. Such a model makes definite predictions for the few-body physics of weakly bound clusters of the dark-matter particles. We calculate the production of two-body bound clusters by three-body recombination in the early universe under the assumption that the dark matter particles are identical bosons, which is the most favorable case for forming larger clusters. The fraction of dark matter in the form of two-body bound clusters can increase by as much as 4 orders of magnitude when the dark-matter temperature falls below the binding energy, but its present value remains less than 10^(-6). △ Less

Submitted 11 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, presented at 22nd International Conference on Few-Body Problems in Physics in July 2018 in Caen, France

Triangle Singularity in the Production of $X(3872)$ and a Photon in $e^+e^-$ Annihilation

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced in $e^+ e^-$ annihilation by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ from a virtual photon followed by the rescattering of the charm-meson pair into $X$ and a photon. A triangle singularity produces a narrow peak in the cross section for $e^+ e^- \to X γ$ about 2.2 MeV above the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold. We predict the… ▽ More If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced in $e^+ e^-$ annihilation by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar D^{*0}$ from a virtual photon followed by the rescattering of the charm-meson pair into $X$ and a photon. A triangle singularity produces a narrow peak in the cross section for $e^+ e^- \to X γ$ about 2.2 MeV above the $D^{*0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold. We predict the normalized cross section in the region near the peak. The peak from the triangle singularity may be observable by the BESIII detector. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2019; v1 submitted 29 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, published in Phys. Rev. D as Rapid Communication

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 031501 (2019)

Production of $X(3872)$ Accompanied by a Soft Pion at Hadron Colliders

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ or $D^{0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ at short distances followed by the formation of the bound state from the charm-meson pair. The $X$ can also be produced by the creation of $D^* \bar{D}^*$ at short distances followed by the rescattering of the charm-meson pair into $X π$. At a high-energy hadron… ▽ More If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ or $D^{0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ at short distances followed by the formation of the bound state from the charm-meson pair. The $X$ can also be produced by the creation of $D^* \bar{D}^*$ at short distances followed by the rescattering of the charm-meson pair into $X π$. At a high-energy hadron collider, the prompt cross section from this mechanism has a narrow peak in the $X π$ invariant mass distribution near the $D^* \bar D^*$ threshold from a charm-meson triangle singularity. An order-of-magnitude estimate of the ratio of the cross section for producing the peak in the $X π^\pm$ distribution to the cross section for producing $X$ without an accompanying pion suggests that the peak may be observable at the LHC. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2019; v1 submitted 7 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures. Extensively revised to focus mainly on the production of $X(3872)$ plus a pion. Some material on cross sections for producing $X(3872)$ without a pion was removed. An error in identifying the region of validity in the $X π$ invariant mass was corrected. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1902.03259, arXiv:1811.08876

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 094006 (2019)

Production of $X(3872)$ Accompanied by a Pion in $B$ Meson Decay

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ or $D^{0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ at short distances followed by the formation of the bound state from the charm-meson pairs. It can also be produced by the creation of $D^{*} \bar{D}^*$ at short distances followed by the rescattering of the charm mesons into $X π$. We use results of a previous… ▽ More If the $X(3872)$ is a weakly bound charm-meson molecule, it can be produced by the creation of $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ or $D^{0} \bar{D}^{*0}$ at short distances followed by the formation of the bound state from the charm-meson pairs. It can also be produced by the creation of $D^{*} \bar{D}^*$ at short distances followed by the rescattering of the charm mesons into $X π$. We use results of a previous isospin analysis of $B$ meson decays into $K D^{(*)} \bar D^{(*)}$ to estimate the short-distance amplitudes for creating $D^* \bar D^*$. We use an effective field theory for charm mesons and pions called XEFT to calculate the amplitudes for rescattering of $D^{*} \bar{D}^*$ into $X π$ with small relative momentum. The $Xπ$ invariant mass distribution is predicted to have a narrow peak near the $D^{*} \bar{D}^*$ threshold from a charm-meson triangle singularity. We estimate the branching fractions into the peak from the triangle singularity for the decays $B^0 \to K^+ X π^-$ and $B^+ \to K^0 X π^+$. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2019; v1 submitted 8 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 4 figures, 1 table. An error in identifying the region of validity in the $X(3872)π$ invariant mass was corrected

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 074028 (2019)

Estimates of the $X(3872)$ Cross Section at a Hadron Collider

Authors: Eric Braaten, Li-** He, Kevin Ingles

Abstract: The claim that the $X(3872)$ meson cannot be a charm-meson molecule because its prompt production cross section at hadron colliders is too large is based on an upper bound in terms of a cross section for producing charm-meson pairs. Assuming $X$ is sufficiently weakly bound, we derive an equality between the $X$ cross section and a charm-meson pair cross section that takes into account the thresho… ▽ More The claim that the $X(3872)$ meson cannot be a charm-meson molecule because its prompt production cross section at hadron colliders is too large is based on an upper bound in terms of a cross section for producing charm-meson pairs. Assuming $X$ is sufficiently weakly bound, we derive an equality between the $X$ cross section and a charm-meson pair cross section that takes into account the threshold enhancement from the $X$ resonance. The cross section for producing $X$ is equal to that for producing $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ integrated up to a relative momentum $k_\mathrm{max} = 7.7\,γ_X$, where $γ_X$ is the binding momentum of $X$. We also derive an order-of-magnitude estimate of the $X$ cross section in terms of a naive charm-meson pair cross section that does not take into account the threshold enhancement, such as that produced by a Monte Carlo event generator. The cross section for producing $X$ can be approximated by the naive cross section for producing $D^{*0} \bar{D}^0$ integrated up to a relative momentum $k_\mathrm{max}$ of order $(m_π^2 γ_X)^{1/3}$. The estimates of the prompt $X$ cross section at hadron colliders are consistent with the cross sections observed at the Tevatron and the LHC. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2019; v1 submitted 21 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 14 pages, 1 figure. Extensively revised to focus mainly on the production of $X(3872)$ at hadron colliders. Material on production of $X(3872)$ plus a pion was removed. Text overlap with arXiv:1903:04355

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 094024 (2019)

Axion Stars

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hong Zhang

Abstract: The particle that makes up the dark matter of the universe could be an axion or axion-like particle. A collection of axions can condense into a bound Bose-Einstein condensate called an axion star. It is possible that a significant fraction of the axion dark matter is in the form of axion stars. This would make some efforts to identify the axion as the dark matter particle more challenging, but it… ▽ More The particle that makes up the dark matter of the universe could be an axion or axion-like particle. A collection of axions can condense into a bound Bose-Einstein condensate called an axion star. It is possible that a significant fraction of the axion dark matter is in the form of axion stars. This would make some efforts to identify the axion as the dark matter particle more challenging, but it would also open up new possibilities. We summarize the basic properties of isolated axion stars, which can be gravitationally bound or bound by self-interactions. Axions are naturally described by a relativistic field theory with a real scalar field, but low-energy axions can be described more simply by a classical nonrelativistic effective field theory with a complex scalar field. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 20 pages, 10 figures

Gluon fragmentation into quarkonium at next-to-leading order using FKS subtraction

Authors: Pierre Artoisenet, Eric Braaten

Abstract: We present the calculation at next-to-leading order (NLO) in alpha_s of the fragmentation function of a gluon into heavy quarkonium in the color-octet spin-singlet S-wave channel. To calculate the real NLO corrections, we adapt a subtraction scheme introduced by Frixione, Kunszt, and Signer. Ultraviolet and infrared divergences in the real NLO corrections are calculated analytically by evaluating… ▽ More We present the calculation at next-to-leading order (NLO) in alpha_s of the fragmentation function of a gluon into heavy quarkonium in the color-octet spin-singlet S-wave channel. To calculate the real NLO corrections, we adapt a subtraction scheme introduced by Frixione, Kunszt, and Signer. Ultraviolet and infrared divergences in the real NLO corrections are calculated analytically by evaluating the phase-space integrals of the subtraction terms using dimensional regularization. The subtracted phase-space integrals are then evaluated in 4 space-time dimensions. The divergences in the virtual NLO corrections are also calculated analytically. After renormalization, all the divergences cancel. The NLO corrections significantly increase the fragmentation probability for a gluon into the spin-singlet quarkonium states eta_c and eta_b. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 52 pages, 6 figures

Classical Nonrelativistic Effective Field Theories for a Real Scalar Field

Authors: Eric Braaten, Abhishek Mohapatra, Hong Zhang

Abstract: A classical nonrelativistic effective field theory for a real Lorentz-scalar field $φ$ is most conveniently formulated in terms of a complex scalar field $ψ$. There have been two derivations of effective Lagrangians for the complex field $ψ$ in which terms in the effective potential were determined to order $(ψ^* ψ)^4$. We point out an error in each of the effective Lagrangians. After correcting t… ▽ More A classical nonrelativistic effective field theory for a real Lorentz-scalar field $φ$ is most conveniently formulated in terms of a complex scalar field $ψ$. There have been two derivations of effective Lagrangians for the complex field $ψ$ in which terms in the effective potential were determined to order $(ψ^* ψ)^4$. We point out an error in each of the effective Lagrangians. After correcting the errors, we demonstrate the equivalence of the two effective Lagrangians by verifying that they both reproduce $T$-matrix elements of the relativistic real scalar field theory and by also constructing a redefinition of the complex field $ψ$ that transforms terms in one effective Lagrangian into the corresponding terms of the other. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 25 pages, 2 figures

Report number: TUM-HEP-1143/18

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 096012 (2018)

Production of dark-matter bound states in the early universe by three-body recombination

Authors: Eric Braaten, Daekyoung Kang, Ranjan Laha

Abstract: The small-scale structure problems of the universe can be solved by self-interacting dark matter that becomes strongly interacting at low energy. A particularly predictive model for the self-interactions is resonant short-range interactions with an S-wave scattering length that is much larger than the range. The velocity dependence of the cross section in such a model provides an excellent fit to… ▽ More The small-scale structure problems of the universe can be solved by self-interacting dark matter that becomes strongly interacting at low energy. A particularly predictive model for the self-interactions is resonant short-range interactions with an S-wave scattering length that is much larger than the range. The velocity dependence of the cross section in such a model provides an excellent fit to self-interaction cross sections inferred from dark-matter halos of galaxies and clusters of galaxies if the dark-matter mass is about 19 GeV and the scattering length is about 17 fm. Such a model makes definite predictions for the few-body physics of weakly bound clusters of the dark-matter particles. The formation of the two-body bound cluster is a bottleneck for the formation of larger bound clusters. We calculate the production of two-body bound clusters by three-body recombination in the early universe under the assumption that the dark matter particles are identical bosons, which is the most favorable case. If the dark-matter mass is 19 GeV and the scattering length is 17 fm, the fraction of dark matter in the form of two-body bound clusters can increase by as much as 4 orders of magnitude when the dark-matter temperature falls below the binding energy, but its present value remains less than 10^(-6). The present fraction can be increased to as large as 10^(-3) by relaxing the constraints from small-scale structure and decreasing the mass of the dark matter particle. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2018; v1 submitted 2 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 35 pages, 8 figure, v2: published version, a comment on spin-1/2 dark matter case added

Report number: INT-PUB-18-027, MITP/18-036

Journal ref: JHEP 11 (2018) 084

Zero-Range Effective Field Theory for Resonant Wino Dark Matter III. Annihilation Effects

Authors: Eric Braaten, Evan Johnson, Hong Zhang

Abstract: Near a critical value of the wino mass where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory (ZREFT) in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction and through Coulomb interactions. The effects of wino-pair annihilation into electroweak gauge bosons are taken into accou… ▽ More Near a critical value of the wino mass where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory (ZREFT) in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction and through Coulomb interactions. The effects of wino-pair annihilation into electroweak gauge bosons are taken into account through the analytic continuation of the real parameters for the contact interaction to complex values. The parameters of ZREFT can be determined by matching wino-wino scattering amplitudes calculated by solving the Schrödinger equation for winos interacting through a real potential due to the exchange of electroweak gauge bosons and an imaginary potential due to wino-pair annihilation into electroweak gauge bosons. ZREFT at leading order gives an accurate analytic description of low-energy wino-wino scattering, inclusive wino-pair annihilation, and a wino-pair bound state. ZREFT can also be applied to partial annihilation rates, such as the Sommerfeld enhancement of the annihilation rate of wino pairs into monochromatic photons. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2018; v1 submitted 19 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 57 pages, 25 figures. Published version in JHEP. Final part of a 3 part series. Part 1: arXiv:1706.02253 and 10.1007/JHEP11(2017)108. Part 2: arXiv:1708.07155 and 10.1007/JHEP02(2018)150

Conformality Lost in Efimov Physics

Authors: Abhishek Mohapatra, Eric Braaten

Abstract: A general mechanism for the loss of conformal invariance is the merger and disappearance of an infrared fixed point and an ultraviolet fixed point of a renormalization group flow. We show explicitly how this mechanism works in the case of identical bosons at unitarity as the spatial dimension $d$ is varied. For $d$ between the critical dimensions $d_{\rm 1}=2.30$ and $d_{\rm 2}=3.76$, there is los… ▽ More A general mechanism for the loss of conformal invariance is the merger and disappearance of an infrared fixed point and an ultraviolet fixed point of a renormalization group flow. We show explicitly how this mechanism works in the case of identical bosons at unitarity as the spatial dimension $d$ is varied. For $d$ between the critical dimensions $d_{\rm 1}=2.30$ and $d_{\rm 2}=3.76$, there is loss of conformality as evidenced by the Efimov effect in the three-body sector. The beta function for an appropriate three-body coupling is a quadratic polynomial in that coupling. For $d<d_{\rm 1}$ and for $d>d_{\rm 2}$, the beta function has two real roots that correspond to infrared and ultraviolet fixed points. As $d$ approaches $d_{\rm 1}$ from below and as $d$ approaches $d_{\rm 2}$ from above, the fixed points merge and disappear into the complex plane. For $d_{\rm 1}<d<d_{\rm 2}$, the beta function has complex roots and the renormalization group flow for the three-body coupling is a limit cycle. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 98, 013633 (2018)

Effective field theory for resonant wino dark matter

Authors: Evan Johnson, Hong Zhang, Eric Braaten

Abstract: Enhancements in WIMP annihilation rates have been identified with a nonperturbative "Sommerfeld enhancement" arising from the exchange of light mediators. At certain critical values of the WIMP mass, the enhancement is increased dramatically due to a zero-energy resonance at the WIMP-pair threshold. For masses near these critical values, WIMP scattering processes are accurately described by an eff… ▽ More Enhancements in WIMP annihilation rates have been identified with a nonperturbative "Sommerfeld enhancement" arising from the exchange of light mediators. At certain critical values of the WIMP mass, the enhancement is increased dramatically due to a zero-energy resonance at the WIMP-pair threshold. For masses near these critical values, WIMP scattering processes are accurately described by an effective field theory where WIMPs have nonperturbative zero-range contact interactions. The effective field theory is controlled by a renormalization-group fixed point at which the WIMPs are degenerate in mass and their scattering length is infinite. If the WIMPs can exchange massless mediators, the resulting long-range interaction must also be treated nonperturbatively. We develop an effective field theory for SU(2)-triplet dark matter, which have short-range weak and long-range electromagnetic interactions. We refer to these dark matter particles as winos. The long-range Coulomb interaction between charged winos is resummed to all orders. The parameters of the effective field theory can be determined by matching wino-wino scattering amplitudes calculated by solving the Schrödinger equation with a potential describing exchange of electroweak gauge bosons. With Coulomb resummation, the effective field theory at leading order gives a good description of the low-energy two-body observables for winos. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures. Presented at the APS Division of Particles and Fields Meeting (DPF 2017), July 31-August 4, 2017, Fermilab. C170731

Zero-Range Effective Field Theory for Resonant Wino Dark Matter II. Coulomb Resummation

Authors: Eric Braaten, Evan Johnson, Hong Zhang

Abstract: Near a critical value of the wino mass where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory (ZREFT) in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction and charged winos also have electromagnetic interactions. At energies near the wino-pair thresholds, the Coulomb interacti… ▽ More Near a critical value of the wino mass where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory (ZREFT) in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction and charged winos also have electromagnetic interactions. At energies near the wino-pair thresholds, the Coulomb interaction from photon exchange between charged winos must also be treated nonperturbatively. The parameters of ZREFT can be determined by matching wino-wino scattering amplitudes calculated by solving the Schrödinger equation for winos interacting through a potential due to the exchange of electroweak gauge bosons. With Coulomb resummation, ZREFT at leading order gives a good description of the low-energy two-body observables for winos. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2018; v1 submitted 23 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 46 pages, 21 figures. Corrected typos in version 1. Published version in JHEP

Mass Dependence of Higgs Production at Large Transverse Momentum through a Bottom Quark Loop

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hong Zhang, Jia-Wei Zhang

Abstract: In the production of the Higgs through a bottom-quark loop, the transverse momentum distribution of the Higgs at large $P_T$ is complicated by its dependence on two other important scales: the bottom quark mass $m_b$ and the Higgs mass $m_H$. A strategy for simplifying the calculation of the cross section at large $P_T$ is to calculate only the leading terms in its expansion in $m_b^2/P_T^2$. In t… ▽ More In the production of the Higgs through a bottom-quark loop, the transverse momentum distribution of the Higgs at large $P_T$ is complicated by its dependence on two other important scales: the bottom quark mass $m_b$ and the Higgs mass $m_H$. A strategy for simplifying the calculation of the cross section at large $P_T$ is to calculate only the leading terms in its expansion in $m_b^2/P_T^2$. In this paper, we consider the bottom-quark-loop contribution to the parton process $q\bar{q}\to H+g$ at leading order in $α_s$. We show that the leading power of $1/P_T^2$ can be expressed in the form of a factorization formula that separates the large scale $P_T$ from the scale of the masses. All the dependence on $m_b$ and $m_H$ can be factorized into a distribution amplitude for $b \bar b$ in the Higgs, a distribution amplitude for $b \bar b$ in a real gluon, and an endpoint contribution. The factorization formula can be used to organize the calculation of the leading terms in the expansion in $m_b^2/P_T^2$ so that every calculation involves at most two scales. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 29 pages, 7 figures. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1704.06620

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 096014 (2018)

Zero-Range Effective Field Theory for Resonant Wino Dark Matter I. Framework

Authors: Eric Braaten, Evan Johnson, Hong Zhang

Abstract: The most dramatic "Sommerfeld enhancements" of neutral-wino-pair annihilation occur when the wino mass is near a critical value where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold. Near such a critical mass, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction. The effective… ▽ More The most dramatic "Sommerfeld enhancements" of neutral-wino-pair annihilation occur when the wino mass is near a critical value where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold. Near such a critical mass, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction. The effective field theory is controlled by a renormalization-group fixed point at which the neutral and charged winos are degenerate in mass and their scattering length is infinite. The parameters of the zero-range effective field theory can be determined by matching wino-wino scattering amplitudes calculated by solving the Schrödinger equation for winos interacting through a potential due to the exchange of weak gauge bosons. If the wino mass is larger than the critical value, the resonance is a wino-pair bound state. The power of the zero-range effective field theory is illustrated by calculating the rate for formation of the bound state in the collision of two neutral winos through the emission of two soft photons. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2017; v1 submitted 7 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 63 pages, 22 figures, Corrected typos in version 1

Mass Dependence of Higgs Production at Large Transverse Momentum

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hong Zhang, Jia-Wei Zhang

Abstract: The transverse momentum distribution of the Higgs at large $P_T$ is complicated by its dependence on three important energy scales: $P_T$, the top quark mass $m_t$, and the Higgs mass $m_H$. A strategy for simplifying the calculation of the cross section at large $P_T$ is to calculate only the leading terms in its expansion in $m_t^2/P_T^2$ and/or $m_H^2/P_T^2$. The expansion of the cross section… ▽ More The transverse momentum distribution of the Higgs at large $P_T$ is complicated by its dependence on three important energy scales: $P_T$, the top quark mass $m_t$, and the Higgs mass $m_H$. A strategy for simplifying the calculation of the cross section at large $P_T$ is to calculate only the leading terms in its expansion in $m_t^2/P_T^2$ and/or $m_H^2/P_T^2$. The expansion of the cross section in inverse powers of $P_T$ is complicated by logarithms of $P_T$ and by mass singularities. In this paper, we consider the top-quark loop contribution to the subprocess $q\bar{q}\to H+g$ at leading order in $α_s$. We show that the leading power of $1/P_T^2$ can be expressed in the form of a factorization formula that separates the large scale $P_T$ from the scale of the masses. All the dependence on $m_t$ and $m_H$ can be factorized into a distribution amplitude for $t \bar t$ in the Higgs, a distribution amplitude for $t \bar t$ in a real gluon, and an endpoint contribution. The factorization formula can be used to simplify calculations of the $P_T$ distribution at large $P_T$ to next-to-leading order in $α_s$. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 49 pages, 8 figures

Comment on "Single-inclusive jet production in electron-nucleon collisions through next-to-next-to-leading order in perturbative QCD" [Phys. Lett. B 763, 52--59 (2016)]

Authors: Geoffrey T. Bodwin, Eric Braaten

Abstract: In the cross section for single-inclusive jet production in electron-nucleon collisions, the distribution of a quark in an electron appears at next-to-next-to-leading order. The numerical calculations in Ref. [1] were carried out using a perturbative approximation for the distribution of a quark in an electron. We point out that that distribution receives nonperturbative QCD contributions that inv… ▽ More In the cross section for single-inclusive jet production in electron-nucleon collisions, the distribution of a quark in an electron appears at next-to-next-to-leading order. The numerical calculations in Ref. [1] were carried out using a perturbative approximation for the distribution of a quark in an electron. We point out that that distribution receives nonperturbative QCD contributions that invalidate the perturbative approximation. Those nonperturbative effects enter into cross sections for hard-scattering processes through resolved-electron contributions and can be taken into account by determining the distribution of a quark in an electron phenomenologically. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2017; v1 submitted 27 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, minor corrections, version published in Physics Letters B

Journal ref: Phys. Lett. B 769 (2017) 82

Open Effective Field Theories from Highly Inelastic Reactions

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hans-Werner Hammer, G. Peter Lepage

Abstract: The loss of particles due to highly inelastic reactions has previously been taken into account in effective field theories for low-energy particles by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. An additional modification is required in the time evolution equation for the density matrix of a multi-particle system. An effective density matrix can be defined by tracing over state… ▽ More The loss of particles due to highly inelastic reactions has previously been taken into account in effective field theories for low-energy particles by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. An additional modification is required in the time evolution equation for the density matrix of a multi-particle system. An effective density matrix can be defined by tracing over states containing high-momentum particles produced by the highly inelastic reactions and by a time average that eliminates short-time correlations. The effective density matrix satisfies the Lindblad equation, with local Lindblad operators that are determined by the anti-Hermitian terms in the effective Hamiltonian. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, presented at 38th International Conference on High Energy Physics

Wino dark matter annihilation through the radiative formation of bound states

Authors: Evan Johnson, Eric Braaten, Hong Zhang

Abstract: The most dramatic "Sommerfeld enhancements" of neutral-wino-pair annihilation occur when the wino mass is tuned to near critical values where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold. If the wino mass is larger than the critical value, the resonance is a wino-pair bound state. If the wino mass is near a critical value, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-r… ▽ More The most dramatic "Sommerfeld enhancements" of neutral-wino-pair annihilation occur when the wino mass is tuned to near critical values where there is a zero-energy S-wave resonance at the neutral-wino-pair threshold. If the wino mass is larger than the critical value, the resonance is a wino-pair bound state. If the wino mass is near a critical value, low-energy winos can be described by a zero-range effective field theory in which the winos interact nonperturbatively through a contact interaction. The parameters of the zero-range effective field theory can be determined by matching wino scattering amplitudes calculated by solving the Schrödinger equation for a nonrelativistic effective field theory in which the winos interact through a potential due to the exchange of electroweak gauge bosons. The utility of the zero-range effective field theory is illustrated by calculating the rate for formation of an S-wave bound state in the collision of two neutral winos through the emission of two soft photons. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures. Contribution to proceedings of ICHEP 2016

Emission of Photons and Relativistic Axions from Axion Stars

Authors: Eric Braaten, Abhishek Mohapatra, Hong Zhang

Abstract: The number of nonrelativistic axions can be changed by inelastic reactions that produce photons or relativistic axions. Any odd number of axions can annihilate into two photons. Any even number of nonrelativistic axions can scatter into two relativistic axions. We calculate the rate at which axions are lost from axion stars from these inelastic reactions. In dilute systems of axions, the dominant… ▽ More The number of nonrelativistic axions can be changed by inelastic reactions that produce photons or relativistic axions. Any odd number of axions can annihilate into two photons. Any even number of nonrelativistic axions can scatter into two relativistic axions. We calculate the rate at which axions are lost from axion stars from these inelastic reactions. In dilute systems of axions, the dominant inelastic reaction is axion decay into two photons. In sufficiently dense systems of axions, the dominant inelastic reaction is the scattering of four nonrelativistic axions into two relativistic axions. The scattering of odd numbers of axions into two photons produces monochromatic radio-frequency signals at odd-integer harmonics of the fundamental frequency set by the axion mass. This provides a unique signature for dense systems of axions, such as a dense axion star or a collapsing dilute axion star. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Lindblad Equation for the Inelastic Loss of Ultracold Atoms

Authors: Eric Braaten, H. -W. Hammer, G. Peter Lepage

Abstract: The loss of ultracold trapped atoms due to deeply inelastic reactions has previously been taken into account in effective field theories for low-energy atoms by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. Here we show that when multi-atom systems are considered, an additional modification is required in the equation governing the density matrix. We define an effective density m… ▽ More The loss of ultracold trapped atoms due to deeply inelastic reactions has previously been taken into account in effective field theories for low-energy atoms by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. Here we show that when multi-atom systems are considered, an additional modification is required in the equation governing the density matrix. We define an effective density matrix by tracing over the states containing high-momentum atoms produced by deeply inelastic reactions. We show that it satisfies a Lindblad equation, with local Lindblad operators determined by the local anti-Hermitian terms in the effective Hamiltonian. We use the Lindblad equation to derive the universal relation for the two-atom inelastic loss rate for fermions with two spin states and the universal relation for the three-atom inelastic loss rate for identical bosons. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 24 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 95, 012708 (2017)

Open Effective Field Theories from Deeply Inelastic Reactions

Authors: Eric Braaten, H. -W. Hammer, G. Peter Lepage

Abstract: Effective field theories have often been applied to systems with deeply inelastic reactions that produce particles with large momenta outside the domain of validity of the effective theory. The effects of the deeply inelastic reactions have been taken into account in previous work by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. Here we show that when multi-particle systems are c… ▽ More Effective field theories have often been applied to systems with deeply inelastic reactions that produce particles with large momenta outside the domain of validity of the effective theory. The effects of the deeply inelastic reactions have been taken into account in previous work by adding local anti-Hermitian terms to the effective Hamiltonian. Here we show that when multi-particle systems are considered, an additional modification is required in equations governing the density matrix. We define an effective density matrix by tracing over the states containing high-momentum particles, and show that it satisfies a Lindblad equation, with local Lindblad operators determined by the anti-Hermitian terms in the effective Hamiltonian density. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 056006 (2016)

Nonrelativistic Effective Field Theory for Axions

Authors: Eric Braaten, Abhishek Mohapatra, Hong Zhang

Abstract: Axions can be described by a relativistic field theory with a real scalar field $φ$ whose self-interaction potential is a periodic function of $φ$. Low-energy axions, such as those produced in the early universe by the vacuum misalignment mechanism, can be described more simply by a nonrelativistic effective field theory with a complex scalar field $ψ$ whose effective potential is a function of… ▽ More Axions can be described by a relativistic field theory with a real scalar field $φ$ whose self-interaction potential is a periodic function of $φ$. Low-energy axions, such as those produced in the early universe by the vacuum misalignment mechanism, can be described more simply by a nonrelativistic effective field theory with a complex scalar field $ψ$ whose effective potential is a function of $ψ^*ψ$. We determine the coefficients in the expansion of the effective potential to fifth order in $ψ^*ψ$ by matching low-energy axion scattering amplitudes. In order to describe a Bose-Einstein condensate of axions that is too dense to expand the effective potential in powers of $ψ^*ψ$, we develop a sequence of systematically improvable approximations to the effective potential that include terms of all orders in $ψ^*ψ$. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2016; v1 submitted 3 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 21 pages, 8 figures, Published Version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 076004 (2016)

Towards a Theoretical Understanding of the XYZ Mesons from QCD

Authors: Eric Braaten

Abstract: The XYZ mesons are mesons that contain a heavy quark and antiquark but have properties that seem to require additional constituents. Some of them are electrically charged, so they must be tetraquark mesons whose additional constituents are a light quark and antiquark. The list of XYZ mesons has grown to about two dozen over the last decade. A promising approach to understanding these mesons within… ▽ More The XYZ mesons are mesons that contain a heavy quark and antiquark but have properties that seem to require additional constituents. Some of them are electrically charged, so they must be tetraquark mesons whose additional constituents are a light quark and antiquark. The list of XYZ mesons has grown to about two dozen over the last decade. A promising approach to understanding these mesons within QCD is the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, which reduces the problem to the solution of the Schrodinger equation in potentials that can be calculated using lattice QCD. The Born-Oppenheimer approximation has not yet revealed the pattern of the XYZ mesons, but it provides a compelling framework for understanding them from the fundamental theory. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 8 pages, 1 figure, presented at 21st International Conference on Few-body Problems in Physics, Chicago, May 18-22 2015

Dense Axion Stars

Authors: Eric Braaten, Abhishek Mohapatra, Hong Zhang

Abstract: If the dark matter particles are axions, gravity can cause them to coalesce into axion stars, which are stable gravitationally bound systems of axions. In the previously known solutions for axion stars, gravity and the attractive force between pairs of axions are balanced by the kinetic pressure. The mass of these dilute axion stars cannot exceed a critical mass, which is about $10^{-14} M_\odot$… ▽ More If the dark matter particles are axions, gravity can cause them to coalesce into axion stars, which are stable gravitationally bound systems of axions. In the previously known solutions for axion stars, gravity and the attractive force between pairs of axions are balanced by the kinetic pressure. The mass of these dilute axion stars cannot exceed a critical mass, which is about $10^{-14} M_\odot$ if the axion mass is $10^{-4}$~eV. We study axion stars using a simple approximation to the effective potential of the nonrelativistic effective field theory for axions. We find a new branch of dense axion stars in which gravity is balanced by the mean-field pressure of the axion Bose-Einstein condensate. The mass on this branch ranges from about $10^{-20} M_\odot$ to about $M_\odot$. If a dilute axion star with the critical mass accretes additional axions and collapses, it could produce a bosenova, leaving a dense axion star as the remnant. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2016; v1 submitted 30 November, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, Added calculations of unstable branch of axion stars. Added discussion of possible ways to detect dense axion stars. Removed EFT calculations that were not essential for this paper

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 121801 (2016)

Inclusive Higgs Production at Large Transverse Momentum

Authors: Hong Zhang, Eric Braaten

Abstract: We present a factorization formula for the inclusive production of the Higgs boson at large transverse momentum $P_T$ that includes all terms with the leading power of $1/P_T^2$. The cross section is factorized into convolutions of parton distributions, infrared-safe hard-scattering cross sections for producing a parton, and fragmentation functions that give the distribution of the longitudinal mo… ▽ More We present a factorization formula for the inclusive production of the Higgs boson at large transverse momentum $P_T$ that includes all terms with the leading power of $1/P_T^2$. The cross section is factorized into convolutions of parton distributions, infrared-safe hard-scattering cross sections for producing a parton, and fragmentation functions that give the distribution of the longitudinal momentum fraction of the Higgs relative to the fragmenting parton. The infrared-safe cross sections and the fragmentation functions are perturbatively calculable. The factorization formula enables the resummation of large logarithms of $P_T/M_H$ due to final-state radiation by integrating evolution equations for the fragmentation functions. By comparing the cross section for the process $q\bar{q}\to H t\bar t$ from the leading-power factorization formula at leading order in the coupling constants with the complete leading-order cross section, we infer that the error in the factorization formula decreases to less than 5% for $P_T>600$ GeV at a future $100$ TeV collider. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: Presentation at the DPF 2015 Meeting of the American Physical Society Division of Particles and Fields, Ann Arbor, Michigan, August 4-8, 2015

Inclusive Higgs Production at Large Transverse Momentum

Authors: Eric Braaten, Hong Zhang

Abstract: We present a factorization formula for the inclusive production of the Higgs boson at large transverse momentum $P_T$ that includes all terms with the leading power of $1/P_T^2$. The cross section is factorized into convolutions of parton distributions, infrared-safe hard-scattering cross sections for producing a parton, and fragmentation functions that give the distribution of the longitudinal mo… ▽ More We present a factorization formula for the inclusive production of the Higgs boson at large transverse momentum $P_T$ that includes all terms with the leading power of $1/P_T^2$. The cross section is factorized into convolutions of parton distributions, infrared-safe hard-scattering cross sections for producing a parton, and fragmentation functions that give the distribution of the longitudinal momentum fraction of the Higgs relative to the fragmenting parton. The infrared-safe cross sections and the fragmentation functions are perturbatively calculable. The most important fragmentation functions are those for which the fragmenting parton is the top quark, gluon, $W$, $Z$, and the Higgs itself. We calculate the fragmentation functions at leading order in the Standard Model coupling constants. The factorization formula enables the resummation of large logarithms of $P_T/M_H$ due to final-state radiation by integrating evolution equations for the fragmentation functions. By comparing the cross section for the process $q\bar{q}\to H t\bar t$ from the leading-power factorization formula at leading order in the coupling constants with the complete leading-order cross section, we infer that the error in the factorization formula decreases to less than 5\% for $P_T>600$ GeV at a future $100$ TeV collider. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: 39 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 053014 (2016)

Galilean-Invariant XEFT

Authors: Eric Braaten

Abstract: XEFT is a low-energy effective field theory for charm mesons and pions that provides a systematically improvable description of the X(3872) resonance. A Galilean-invariant formulation of XEFT is introduced to exploit the fact that mass is very nearly conserved in the transition D*0 --> D0 pi0. The transitions D*0 --> D0 pi0 and X --> D0 D0-bar pi0 are described explicitly in XEFT. The effects of t… ▽ More XEFT is a low-energy effective field theory for charm mesons and pions that provides a systematically improvable description of the X(3872) resonance. A Galilean-invariant formulation of XEFT is introduced to exploit the fact that mass is very nearly conserved in the transition D*0 --> D0 pi0. The transitions D*0 --> D0 pi0 and X --> D0 D0-bar pi0 are described explicitly in XEFT. The effects of the decay D*0 --> D0 gamma and of short-distance decay modes of the X(3872), such as J/psi --> pi+ pi-, can be taken into account by using complex on-shell renormalization schemes for the D*0 propagator and for the D*0 D0-bar propagator in which the positions of their complex poles are specified. Galilean-invariant XEFT is used to calculate the D*0 D0-bar scattering length to next-to-leading order. Galilean invariance ensures the cancellation of ultraviolet divergences without the need for truncating an expansion in powers of the ratio of the pion and charm meson masses. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 31 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 114007 (2015)

Gluon fragmentation into quarkonium at next-to-leading order

Authors: Pierre Artoisenet, Eric Braaten

Abstract: We present the first calculation at next-to-leading order (NLO) in $α_s$ of a fragmentation function into quarkonium whose form at leading order is a nontrivial function of $z$, namely the fragmentation function for a gluon into a spin-singlet S-wave state at leading order in the relative velocity. To calculate the real NLO corrections, we introduce a new subtraction scheme that allows the phase-s… ▽ More We present the first calculation at next-to-leading order (NLO) in $α_s$ of a fragmentation function into quarkonium whose form at leading order is a nontrivial function of $z$, namely the fragmentation function for a gluon into a spin-singlet S-wave state at leading order in the relative velocity. To calculate the real NLO corrections, we introduce a new subtraction scheme that allows the phase-space integrals to be evaluated in 4 dimensions. We extract all ultraviolet and infrared divergences in the real NLO corrections analytically by calculating the phase-space integrals of the subtraction terms in $4-2ε$ dimensions. We also extract the divergences in the virtual NLO corrections analytically, and detail the cancellation of all divergences after renormalization. The NLO corrections have a dramatic effect on the shape of the fragmentation function, and they significantly increase the fragmentation probability. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 33 pages, 4 figures

Report number: CP3-14-81

Born-Oppenheimer Approximation for the XYZ Mesons

Authors: Eric Braaten, Christian Langmack, D. Hudson Smith

Abstract: Many of the XYZ mesons discovered in the last decade can be identified as bound states in Born-Oppenheimer (B-O) potentials for a heavy quark and antiquark. They include quarkonium hybrids, which are bound states in excited flavor-singlet B-O potentials, and quarkonium tetraquarks, which are bound states in flavor-nonsinglet B-O potentials. We present simple parameterizations of the deepest flavor… ▽ More Many of the XYZ mesons discovered in the last decade can be identified as bound states in Born-Oppenheimer (B-O) potentials for a heavy quark and antiquark. They include quarkonium hybrids, which are bound states in excited flavor-singlet B-O potentials, and quarkonium tetraquarks, which are bound states in flavor-nonsinglet B-O potentials. We present simple parameterizations of the deepest flavor-singlet B-O potentials. We infer the deepest flavor-nonsinglet B-O potentials from lattice QCD calculations of static adjoint mesons. Selection rules for hadronic transitions are used to identify XYZ mesons that are candidates for ground-state energy levels in the B-O potentials for charmonium hybrids and tetraquarks. The energies of the lowest-energy charmonium hybrids are predicted by using the results of lattice QCD calculations to calculate the energy splittings between the ground states of different B-O potentials and using the Schroedinger equation to determine the splittings between energy levels within a B-O potential. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 40 pages, 11 tables, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 90, 014044 (2014)

J/psi and Upsilon Polarization in Hadronic Production Processes

Authors: Eric Braaten, James Russ

Abstract: Both charm and bottom quarks form nonrelativistic bound states analogous to positronium. The J/psi and psi(2S) charmonium states and the first three Upsilon(nS) bottomonium states, all spin-triplet S-wave quarkonium states below open-heavy-flavor thresholds, have relatively large branching ratios to e- e+ or mu- mu+ pairs. In hadron collisions, experiments measuring lepton pairs can determine pola… ▽ More Both charm and bottom quarks form nonrelativistic bound states analogous to positronium. The J/psi and psi(2S) charmonium states and the first three Upsilon(nS) bottomonium states, all spin-triplet S-wave quarkonium states below open-heavy-flavor thresholds, have relatively large branching ratios to e- e+ or mu- mu+ pairs. In hadron collisions, experiments measuring lepton pairs can determine polarization by using angular correlation techniques. The polarization, in turn, can be related theoretically to the production mechanism for the bound state. This review summarizes experimental studies with proton beams at fixed target and colliding beam accelerators, covering a center-of-mass energy range from 39 to 7000 GeV for nucleon and antiproton targets. Analyses using various polarization frames and spin-quantization axes are described and results compared. A pattern emerges that connects experimental results over the whole energy span. The theoretical implications of the pattern are presented and a set of new measurements is proposed. △ Less

Submitted 28 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 28 pages, 5 figures; prepared for Volume 64 of the Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science

Selection Rules for Hadronic Transitions of XYZ Mesons

Authors: Eric Braaten, Christian Langmack, D. Hudson Smith

Abstract: Many of the XYZ mesons discovered in the last decade can be identified as bound states of a heavy quark and antiquark in Born-Oppenheimer (B-O) potentials defined by the energy of gluon and light-quark fields in the presence of static color sources. The mesons include quarkonium hybrids, which are bound states in excited flavor-singlet B-O potentials, and quarkonium tetraquarks, which are bound st… ▽ More Many of the XYZ mesons discovered in the last decade can be identified as bound states of a heavy quark and antiquark in Born-Oppenheimer (B-O) potentials defined by the energy of gluon and light-quark fields in the presence of static color sources. The mesons include quarkonium hybrids, which are bound states in excited flavor-singlet B-O potentials, and quarkonium tetraquarks, which are bound states in flavor-nonsinglet B-O potentials. The deepest hybrid potentials are known from lattice QCD calculations. The deepest tetraquark potentials can be inferred from lattice QCD calculations of static adjoint mesons. Selection rules for hadronic transitions are derived and used to identify XYZ mesons that are candidates for ground-state energy levels in the B-O potentials for charmonium hybrids and tetraquarks. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2014; v1 submitted 28 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 5 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 222001 (2014)

Direct detection of dark matter in universal bound states

Authors: Ranjan Laha, Eric Braaten

Abstract: We study the signatures for internal structure of dark matter in direct detection experiments in the context of asymmetric self-interacting dark matter. The self-interaction cross section of two dark matter particles at low energies is assumed to come close to saturating the S-wave unitarity bound, which requires the presence of a resonance near their scattering threshold. The universality of S-wa… ▽ More We study the signatures for internal structure of dark matter in direct detection experiments in the context of asymmetric self-interacting dark matter. The self-interaction cross section of two dark matter particles at low energies is assumed to come close to saturating the S-wave unitarity bound, which requires the presence of a resonance near their scattering threshold. The universality of S-wave near-threshold resonances then implies that the low-energy scattering properties of a two-body bound state of dark matter particles are completely determined by its binding energy, irrespective of the underlying microphysics. The form factor for elastic scattering of the bound state from a nucleus and the possibility of breakup of the bound state produce new signatures in the nuclear recoil energy spectrum. If these features are observed in experiments, it will give a smoking-gun signature for the internal structure of dark matter. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2014; v1 submitted 25 November, 2013; originally announced November 2013.

Comments: v2: 14 pages, 5 figures. Added discussion on survival of bound state dark matter and bound state dark matter self-scattering. Conclusions unchanged. Journal version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 89, 103510 (2014)

Theoretical Interpretations of the XYZ Mesons

Authors: Eric Braaten

Abstract: The XYZ mesons are unexpected mesons containing a heavy quark-antiquark pair that have been discovered during the last decade. The models for the XYZ mesons that have been proposed include conventional quarkonium, quarkonium hybrids, and quarkonium tetraquarks, whose four constituents can be clustered in several possible ways. None of the models have provided a compelling pattern for the XYZ meson… ▽ More The XYZ mesons are unexpected mesons containing a heavy quark-antiquark pair that have been discovered during the last decade. The models for the XYZ mesons that have been proposed include conventional quarkonium, quarkonium hybrids, and quarkonium tetraquarks, whose four constituents can be clustered in several possible ways. None of the models have provided a compelling pattern for the XYZ mesons. The most promising theoretical approaches within QCD are lattice QCD for the c c-bar mesons, lattice NRQCD for the b b-bar mesons, and the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The additional hints that will be provided by future experiments guarantee the eventual solution of the XYZ puzzle. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 11 pages, to appear in the proceedings of The 6th International Workshop on Charm Physics (CHARM 2013)

Two-body and Three-body Contacts for Identical Bosons near Unitarity

Authors: D. Hudson Smith, Eric Braaten, Daekyoung Kang, Lucas Platter

Abstract: In a recent experiment with ultracold trapped Rb-85 atoms, Makotyn et al. have studied a quantum-degenerate Bose gas in the unitary limit where its scattering length is infinitely large. We show that the observed momentum distributions are compatible with a universal relation that expresses the high-momentum tail in terms of the 2-body and the 3-body contacts. We determine the 2- and 3-body contac… ▽ More In a recent experiment with ultracold trapped Rb-85 atoms, Makotyn et al. have studied a quantum-degenerate Bose gas in the unitary limit where its scattering length is infinitely large. We show that the observed momentum distributions are compatible with a universal relation that expresses the high-momentum tail in terms of the 2-body and the 3-body contacts. We determine the 2- and 3-body contact densities for the unitary Bose gas with number density n to be approximately 20n^{4/3} and 2n^{5/3}, respectively. We also show that the observed atom loss rate is compatible with that from 3-atom inelastic collisions, which gives a contribution proportional to the 3-body contact, but the loss rate is not compatible with that from 2-atom inelastic collisions, which gives a contribution proportional to the 2-body contact. We point out that the contacts could be measured independently by using the virial theorem near and at unitarity. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2014; v1 submitted 26 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure

Report number: MIT-CTP 4498

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 110402 (2014)