-
A Stress Test of Global PDF Fits: Closure Testing the MSHT PDFs and a First Direct Comparison to the Neural Net Approach
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
T. Cridge,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present a first global closure test of the fixed parameterisation (MSHT) approach to PDF fitting. We find that the default MSHT20 parameterisation can reproduce the features of the input set in such a closure test to well within the textbook uncertainties. This provides strong evidence that parameterisation inflexibility in the MSHT20 fit is not a significant issue in the data region. We also p…
▽ More
We present a first global closure test of the fixed parameterisation (MSHT) approach to PDF fitting. We find that the default MSHT20 parameterisation can reproduce the features of the input set in such a closure test to well within the textbook uncertainties. This provides strong evidence that parameterisation inflexibility in the MSHT20 fit is not a significant issue in the data region. We also present the first completely like-for-like comparison between two global PDF fits, namely MSHT and NNPDF, where the only difference is guaranteed to be due to the fitting methodology. To achieve this, we present a fit to the NNPDF4.0 data and theory inputs, but with the MSHT fixed parameterisation. We find that this gives a moderately, but noticeably, better fit quality than the central NNPDF4.0 fits, both with perturbative and fitted charm, and that this difference persists at the level of the PDFs and benchmark cross sections. The NNPDF4.0 uncertainties are found to be broadly in line with the MSHT results if a textbook $T^2=1$ tolerance is applied, but to be significantly smaller if a tolerance typical of the MSHT20 fit is applied. This points to an inherent inconsistency between these approaches. We discuss the need for an enlarged tolerance criterion in global PDF fits in detail, and demonstrate the impact of data/theory inconsistencies in the closure test setting; namely, these do not lead to any increase in the $T^2=1$ PDF uncertainty. We also investigate the impact of restricting the PDF parameterisation to have fewer free parameters than the default MSHT20 case, and find this can be significant at the level of both closure tests and the full fit.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
The Impact of LHC Jet and $Z$ $p_T$ Data at up to Approximate N${}^3$LO Order in the MSHT Global PDF Fit
Authors:
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present an analysis of two key sets of data constraining the high $x$ gluon at up to approximate N${}^3$LO in QCD within the MSHT global PDF fitting framework. We begin with LHC 7 and 8 TeV inclusive jet and dijet production at both NNLO and aN${}^3$LO. This makes use of the formalism established in the previous global MSHT20aN${}^3$LO PDF fit, but now considers the role of dijet production for…
▽ More
We present an analysis of two key sets of data constraining the high $x$ gluon at up to approximate N${}^3$LO in QCD within the MSHT global PDF fitting framework. We begin with LHC 7 and 8 TeV inclusive jet and dijet production at both NNLO and aN${}^3$LO. This makes use of the formalism established in the previous global MSHT20aN${}^3$LO PDF fit, but now considers the role of dijet production for the first time at this order. We present a detailed comparison of the fit quality and PDF impact for both cases, and consider the role that electroweak corrections, and the scale choice for inclusive jet production has. Some mild tension between these data sets in the impact on the high $x$ gluon is seen at NNLO, but this is largely eliminated at aN${}^3$LO. While a good fit quality to the dijet data is achieved at both orders, the fit quality to the inclusive jet data is relatively poor. We examine the impact of including full colour corrections in a global PDF fit for the first time, finding this to be relatively mild. We also revisit the fit to the ATLAS 8 TeV $Z$ $p_T$ data, considering the role that the $p_T$ cuts, data selection and different aspects of the aN${}^3$LO treatment have on the fit quality and PDF impact. We observe that in all cases the aN${}^3$LO fit quality is consistently improved relative to the NNLO, indicating a clear preference for higher order theory for these data.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Combining QED and Approximate N${}^3$LO QCD Corrections in a Global PDF Fit: MSHT20qed_an3lo PDFs
Authors:
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present the MSHT20qed_an3lo parton distribution functions (PDFs). These result from the first global PDF analysis to combine QED and approximate N${}^3$LO (aN${}^3$LO) QCD corrections in the theoretical calculation of the PDF evolution and cross sections entering the fit. We examine the PDF impact, and find that the effect of QED is relatively mild in comparison to the aN${}^3$LO corrections, a…
▽ More
We present the MSHT20qed_an3lo parton distribution functions (PDFs). These result from the first global PDF analysis to combine QED and approximate N${}^3$LO (aN${}^3$LO) QCD corrections in the theoretical calculation of the PDF evolution and cross sections entering the fit. We examine the PDF impact, and find that the effect of QED is relatively mild in comparison to the aN${}^3$LO corrections, although it should still be accounted for at the level of precision now required. These QED corrections are in addition found to roughly factorise from the QCD corrections; that is, their relative impact on the PDFs is roughly the same at NNLO and aN${}^3$LO. The fit quality exhibits a very small deterioration at aN${}^3$LO upon the inclusion of QED corrections, which is rather smaller than the deterioration observed at NNLO in QCD. The impact on several cross sections at N${}^3$LO is also examined, including the Higgs cross section via gluon fusion at N${}^3$LO. Finally, a LO in QCD fit that includes QED corrections is also presented: the MSHT20qed_lo set.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Exciting Ions: a Systematic Treatment of Ultraperipheral Heavy Ion Collisions with Nuclear Breakup
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang
Abstract:
We present an updated theoretical treatment of ultraperipheral collisions (UPCs) of heavy ions, within the SuperChic Monte Carlo generator. This in particular accounts for mutual ion excitation through additional photon exchanges between the colliding ions. This effect occurs frequently in UPCs, and indeed can be (and has been) measured in data through the use of zero degree calorimeter (ZDC) dete…
▽ More
We present an updated theoretical treatment of ultraperipheral collisions (UPCs) of heavy ions, within the SuperChic Monte Carlo generator. This in particular accounts for mutual ion excitation through additional photon exchanges between the colliding ions. This effect occurs frequently in UPCs, and indeed can be (and has been) measured in data through the use of zero degree calorimeter (ZDC) detectors installed in the far forward region. The theoretical approach presented here accounts for the non-trivial and non-negligible impact such ion dissociation has on the measured cross sections and distributions of the produced particles in the central detectors. This builds on previous work, whereby the survival factor probability of no additional inelastic ion-ion scattering due to the strong interaction, and its kinematic impact, are also accounted for within the same overall framework. We compare to data from ATLAS and CMS at the LHC, and STAR at RHIC, and find in general encouraging agreement for a range of observables and ZDC neutron tags, with some room for further improvement, suggesting the inclusion of higher order QED effects and/or tuning of the the $γA \to A^*$ cross section may be desirable. Overall, this gives confidence in the approach considered here and for applications to new phenomena within and beyond the Standard Model.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Two-photon decay of fully-charmed tetraquarks from light-by-light scattering at the LHC
Authors:
Volodymyr Biloshytskyi,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Bogdan Malaescu,
Vladimir Pascalutsa,
Kristof Schmieden,
Matthias Schott
Abstract:
The LHC newly-discovered resonant structures around 7 GeV, such as the $X(6900)$, could be responsible for the observed excess in light-by-light scattering between 5 and 10 GeV. We show that the ATLAS data for light-by-light scattering may indeed be explained by such a state with the $γγ$ branching ratio of order of $10^{-4}$. This is much larger than the value inferred by the vector-meson dominan…
▽ More
The LHC newly-discovered resonant structures around 7 GeV, such as the $X(6900)$, could be responsible for the observed excess in light-by-light scattering between 5 and 10 GeV. We show that the ATLAS data for light-by-light scattering may indeed be explained by such a state with the $γγ$ branching ratio of order of $10^{-4}$. This is much larger than the value inferred by the vector-meson dominance, but agrees quite well with the tetraquark expectation for the nature of this state. Further light-by-light scattering data in this region, obtained during the ongoing Run-3 and future Run-4 of the LHC, are required to pin down these states in $γγ$ channel.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
A new calculation of semi-exclusive axion-like particle production at the LHC
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
M. Tasevsky
Abstract:
We present a new calculation of axion-like particle (ALP) production in the semi-exclusive photon-initiated (PI) channel, that is either with intact outgoing protons or rapidity gaps present in the final state, and with no colour flow between the colliding LHC protons. This is the first full treatment of this process, accounting for both the possibility of proton dissociation and the survival fact…
▽ More
We present a new calculation of axion-like particle (ALP) production in the semi-exclusive photon-initiated (PI) channel, that is either with intact outgoing protons or rapidity gaps present in the final state, and with no colour flow between the colliding LHC protons. This is the first full treatment of this process, accounting for both the possibility of proton dissociation and the survival factor probability of no additional proton-proton interactions, including its kinematic and process dependence. We present the expected event yields in the case that either one or both protons are required to be registered in the forward proton detectors installed in association with ATLAS and CMS. We find that this process can be sensitive to currently unprobed regions of ALP mass and ALP-photon coupling, in particular in the intermediate mass region. Our calculation is provided in the publicly available SuperChic 4 Monte Carlo (MC) generator, and can be passed to a general purpose MC for showering and hadronization of the final state.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
The two-photon decay of X(6900) from light-by-light scattering at the LHC
Authors:
Volodymyr Biloshytskyi,
Vladimir Pascalutsa,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Bogdan Malaescu,
Kristof Schmieden,
Matthias Schott
Abstract:
The LHCb Collaboration has recently discovered a structure around 6.9 GeV in the double-$J/ψ$ mass distribution, possibly a first fully-charmed tetraquark state $X(6900)$. Based on vector-meson dominance (VMD) such a state should have a significant branching ratio for decaying into two photons. We show that the recorded LHC data for the light-by-light scattering may indeed accommodate for such a s…
▽ More
The LHCb Collaboration has recently discovered a structure around 6.9 GeV in the double-$J/ψ$ mass distribution, possibly a first fully-charmed tetraquark state $X(6900)$. Based on vector-meson dominance (VMD) such a state should have a significant branching ratio for decaying into two photons. We show that the recorded LHC data for the light-by-light scattering may indeed accommodate for such a state, with a $γγ$ branching ratio of order of $10^{-4}$, which is larger even than the value inferred by the VMD. The spin-parity assignment $0^{-+}$ is in better agreement with the VMD prediction than $0^{++}$, albeit not significantly at the current precision. Further light-by-light scattering data in this region, clarifying the nature of this state, should be obtained in the Run 3 and probably in the high-luminosity phase of the LHC (Run 4 etc.).
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Approximate N$^{3}$LO Parton Distribution Functions with Theoretical Uncertainties: MSHT20aN$^3$LO PDFs
Authors:
J. McGowan,
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present the first global analysis of parton distribution functions (PDFs) at approximate N$^{3}$LO in the strong coupling constant $α_{s}$, extending beyond the current highest NNLO achieved in PDF fits. To achieve this, we present a general formalism for the inclusion of theoretical uncertainties associated with the perturbative expansion in the strong coupling. We demonstrate how using the cu…
▽ More
We present the first global analysis of parton distribution functions (PDFs) at approximate N$^{3}$LO in the strong coupling constant $α_{s}$, extending beyond the current highest NNLO achieved in PDF fits. To achieve this, we present a general formalism for the inclusion of theoretical uncertainties associated with the perturbative expansion in the strong coupling. We demonstrate how using the currently available knowledge surrounding the next highest order (N$^{3}$LO) in $α_{s}$ can provide consistent, justifiable and explainable approximate N$^{3}$LO (aN$^{3}$LO) PDFs. This includes estimates for uncertainties due the the currently unknown N$^{3}$LO ingredients, but also implicitly some missing higher order uncertainties (MHOUs) beyond these. Specifically, we approximate the splitting functions, transition matrix elements, coefficient functions and $K$-factors for multiple processes to N$^{3}$LO. Crucially, these are constrained to be consistent with the wide range of already available information about N$^{3}$LO to match the complete result at this order as accurately as possible. Using this approach we perform a fully consistent approximate N$^{3}$LO global fit within the MSHT framework. This relies on an expansion of the Hessian procedure used in previous MSHT fits to allow for sources of theoretical uncertainties. These are included as nuisance parameters in a global fit, controlled by knowledge and intuition based prior distributions. We analyse the differences between our aN$^{3}$LO PDFs and the standard NNLO PDF set, and study the impact of using aN$^{3}$LO PDFs on the LHC production of a Higgs boson at this order. Finally, we provide guidelines on how these PDFs should be be used in phenomenological investigations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2023; v1 submitted 11 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Snowmass 2021 whitepaper: Proton structure at the precision frontier
Authors:
S. Amoroso,
A. Apyan,
N. Armesto,
R. D. Ball,
V. Bertone,
C. Bissolotti,
J. Bluemlein,
R. Boughezal,
G. Bozzi,
D. Britzger,
A. Buckley,
A. Candido,
S. Carrazza,
F. G. Celiberto,
S. Cerci,
G. Chachamis,
A. M. Cooper-Sarkar,
A. Courtoy,
T. Cridge,
J. M. Cruz-Martinez,
F. Giuli,
M. Guzzi,
C. Gwenlan,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
F. Hekhorn
, et al. (32 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
An overwhelming number of theoretical predictions for hadron colliders require parton distribution functions (PDFs), which are an important ingredient of theory infrastructure for the next generation of high-energy experiments. This whitepaper summarizes the status and future prospects for determination of high-precision PDFs applicable in a wide range of energies and experiments, in particular in…
▽ More
An overwhelming number of theoretical predictions for hadron colliders require parton distribution functions (PDFs), which are an important ingredient of theory infrastructure for the next generation of high-energy experiments. This whitepaper summarizes the status and future prospects for determination of high-precision PDFs applicable in a wide range of energies and experiments, in particular in precision tests of the Standard Model and in new physics searches at the high-luminosity Large Hadron Collider and Electron-Ion Collider. We discuss the envisioned advancements in experimental measurements, QCD theory, global analysis methodology, and computing that are necessary to bring unpolarized PDFs in the nucleon to the N2LO and N3LO accuracy in the QCD coupling strength. Special attention is given to the new tasks that emerge in the era of the precision PDF analysis, such as those focusing on the robust control of systematic factors both in experimental measurements and theoretical computations. Various synergies between experimental and theoretical studies of the hadron structure are explored, including opportunities for studying PDFs for nuclear and meson targets, PDFs with electroweak contributions or dependence on the transverse momentum, for incisive comparisons between phenomenological models for the PDFs and computations on discrete lattice, and for cross-fertilization with machine learning/AI approaches. [Submitted to the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021).]
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Snowmass 2021 White Paper: Electron Ion Collider for High Energy Physics
Authors:
R. Abdul Khalek,
U. D'Alesio,
M. Arratia,
A. Bacchetta,
M. Battaglieri,
M. Begel,
M. Boglione,
R. Boughezal,
R. Boussarie,
G. Bozzi,
S. V. Chekanov,
F. G. Celiberto,
G. Chirilli,
T. Cridge,
R. Cruz-Torres,
R. Corliss,
C. Cotton,
H. Davoudiasl,
A. Deshpande,
X. Dong,
A. Emmert,
S. Fazio,
S. Forte,
Y. Furletova,
C. Gal
, et al. (83 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Electron Ion Collider (EIC) is a particle accelerator facility planned for construction at Brookhaven National Laboratory on Long Island, New York by the United States Department of Energy. EIC will provide capabilities of colliding beams of polarized electrons with polarized beams of proton and light ions. EIC will be one of the largest and most sophisticated new accelerator facilities worldwide,…
▽ More
Electron Ion Collider (EIC) is a particle accelerator facility planned for construction at Brookhaven National Laboratory on Long Island, New York by the United States Department of Energy. EIC will provide capabilities of colliding beams of polarized electrons with polarized beams of proton and light ions. EIC will be one of the largest and most sophisticated new accelerator facilities worldwide, and the only new large-scale accelerator facility planned for construction in the United States in the next few decades. The versatility, resolving power and intensity of EIC will present many new opportunities to address some of the crucial and fundamental open scientific questions in particle physics. This document provides an overview of the science case of EIC from the perspective of the high energy physics community.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2022; v1 submitted 24 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The PDF4LHC21 combination of global PDF fits for the LHC Run III
Authors:
Richard D. Ball,
Jon Butterworth,
Amanda M. Cooper-Sarkar,
Aurore Courtoy,
Thomas Cridge,
Albert De Roeck,
Joel Feltesse,
Stefano Forte,
Francesco Giuli,
Claire Gwenlan,
Lucian A. Harland-Lang,
T. J. Hobbs,
Tie-Jiun Hou,
Joey Huston,
Ronan McNulty,
Pavel M. Nadolsky,
Emanuele R. Nocera,
Tanjona R. Rabemananjara,
Juan Rojo,
Robert S. Thorne,
C. -P. Yuan
Abstract:
A precise knowledge of the quark and gluon structure of the proton, encoded by the parton distribution functions (PDFs), is of paramount importance for the interpretation of high-energy processes at present and future lepton-hadron and hadron-hadron colliders. Motivated by recent progress in the PDF determinations carried out by the CT, MSHT, and NNPDF groups, we present an updated combination of…
▽ More
A precise knowledge of the quark and gluon structure of the proton, encoded by the parton distribution functions (PDFs), is of paramount importance for the interpretation of high-energy processes at present and future lepton-hadron and hadron-hadron colliders. Motivated by recent progress in the PDF determinations carried out by the CT, MSHT, and NNPDF groups, we present an updated combination of global PDF fits: PDF4LHC21. It is based on the Monte Carlo combination of the CT18, MSHT20, and NNPDF3.1 sets followed by either its Hessian reduction or its replica compression. Extensive benchmark studies are carried out in order to disentangle the origin of the differences between the three global PDF sets. In particular, dedicated fits based on almost identical theory settings and input datasets are performed by the three groups, highlighting the role played by the respective fitting methodologies. We compare the new PDF4LHC21 combination with its predecessor, PDF4LHC15, demonstrating their good overall consistency and a modest reduction of PDF uncertainties for key LHC processes such as electroweak gauge boson production and Higgs boson production in gluon fusion. We study the phenomenological implications of PDF4LHC21 for a representative selection of inclusive, fiducial, and differential cross sections at the LHC. The PDF4LHC21 combination is made available via the LHAPDF library and provides a robust, user-friendly, and efficient method to estimate the PDF uncertainties associated to theoretical calculations for the upcoming Run III of the LHC and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2022; v1 submitted 10 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The Forward Physics Facility at the High-Luminosity LHC
Authors:
Jonathan L. Feng,
Felix Kling,
Mary Hall Reno,
Juan Rojo,
Dennis Soldin,
Luis A. Anchordoqui,
Jamie Boyd,
Ahmed Ismail,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Kevin J. Kelly,
Vishvas Pandey,
Sebastian Trojanowski,
Yu-Dai Tsai,
Jean-Marco Alameddine,
Takeshi Araki,
Akitaka Ariga,
Tomoko Ariga,
Kento Asai,
Alessandro Bacchetta,
Kincso Balazs,
Alan J. Barr,
Michele Battistin,
Jianming Bian,
Caterina Bertone,
Weidong Bai
, et al. (211 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
High energy collisions at the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (LHC) produce a large number of particles along the beam collision axis, outside of the acceptance of existing LHC experiments. The proposed Forward Physics Facility (FPF), to be located several hundred meters from the ATLAS interaction point and shielded by concrete and rock, will host a suite of experiments to probe Standard Mod…
▽ More
High energy collisions at the High-Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (LHC) produce a large number of particles along the beam collision axis, outside of the acceptance of existing LHC experiments. The proposed Forward Physics Facility (FPF), to be located several hundred meters from the ATLAS interaction point and shielded by concrete and rock, will host a suite of experiments to probe Standard Model (SM) processes and search for physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM). In this report, we review the status of the civil engineering plans and the experiments to explore the diverse physics signals that can be uniquely probed in the forward region. FPF experiments will be sensitive to a broad range of BSM physics through searches for new particle scattering or decay signatures and deviations from SM expectations in high statistics analyses with TeV neutrinos in this low-background environment. High statistics neutrino detection will also provide valuable data for fundamental topics in perturbative and non-perturbative QCD and in weak interactions. Experiments at the FPF will enable synergies between forward particle production at the LHC and astroparticle physics to be exploited. We report here on these physics topics, on infrastructure, detector, and simulation studies, and on future directions to realize the FPF's physics potential.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Modelling $W^+ W^-$ production with rapidity gaps at the LHC
Authors:
S. Bailey,
L. A. Harland-Lang
Abstract:
We present a new calculation of $W^+ W^-$ production in the semi-exclusive channel, that is either with intact outgoing protons or rapidity gaps present in the final state, and with no colour flow between the colliding protons. This study provides the first complete prediction of the $W^+ W^-$ semi-exclusive cross section, as well as the breakdown between elastic and proton dissociative channels.…
▽ More
We present a new calculation of $W^+ W^-$ production in the semi-exclusive channel, that is either with intact outgoing protons or rapidity gaps present in the final state, and with no colour flow between the colliding protons. This study provides the first complete prediction of the $W^+ W^-$ semi-exclusive cross section, as well as the breakdown between elastic and proton dissociative channels. It combines the structure function calculation for a precise modelling of the region of low momentum transfers with a parton-level calculation in the region of high momentum transfers. The survival factor probability of no additional proton-proton interactions is fully accounted for, including its kinematic and process dependence. We analyse in detail the role that the pure photon-initiated ($γγ\to W^+ W^-$) subprocess plays, a comparison that is only viable by working in the electroweak axial gauge. In this way, we find that the dominance of this is not complete in the proton dissociative cases, although once $Z$-initiated production is included a significantly better matching to the complete calculation is achieved. A direct consequence of this is that the relative elastic, single and double dissociative fractions are in general different in comparison to the case of lepton pair production. We present a direct comparison to the recent ATLAS data on semi-exclusive $W^+ W^-$ production, finding excellent agreement within uncertainties. Our calculation is provided in the publicly available SuperChic 4.1 Monte Carlo (MC) generator, and can be passed to a general purpose MC for showering and hadronization of the final state.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
QED Parton Distribution Functions in the MSHT20 Fit
Authors:
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present the MSHT20qed set of parton distribution functions (PDFs). These are obtained from the MSHT20 global analysis via a refit including QED corrections to the DGLAP evolution at ${\cal O}(α),{\cal O}(αα_S)$ and ${\cal O}(α^2)$, and containing the photon PDF of the proton. As in the previous MMHT15qed study we use an input distribution for the photon that is derived from the LUXqed formulati…
▽ More
We present the MSHT20qed set of parton distribution functions (PDFs). These are obtained from the MSHT20 global analysis via a refit including QED corrections to the DGLAP evolution at ${\cal O}(α),{\cal O}(αα_S)$ and ${\cal O}(α^2)$, and containing the photon PDF of the proton. As in the previous MMHT15qed study we use an input distribution for the photon that is derived from the LUXqed formulation, and find good consistency for the photon PDF with that of MMHT15qed, as well as with other recent sets. We also present a set of QED corrected neutron PDFs and accompanying photon distribution, and provide the photon PDF of the nucleons separated into elastic and inelastic contributions. We assess the general expectations for the impact of photon-initiated (PI) corrections to processes entering PDF fits, and review the effect of QED corrections on the other partons and on the fit quality, where electroweak corrections (including PI production) are appropriately added to the cross sections wherever possible. We explore the phenomenological implications of this set by comparing to a variety of benchmark cross sections, finding small but significant corrections due to the inclusion of QED effects in the PDFs.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Elastic photon-initiated production at the LHC: the role of hadron-hadron interactions
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
We analyse in detail the role of additional hadron-hadron interactions in elastic photon-initiated (PI) production at the LHC, both in $pp$ and heavy ion collisions. We first demonstrate that the source of difference between our predictions and other results in the literature for PI muon pair production is dominantly due to an unphysical cut that is imposed in these latter results on the dimuon-ha…
▽ More
We analyse in detail the role of additional hadron-hadron interactions in elastic photon-initiated (PI) production at the LHC, both in $pp$ and heavy ion collisions. We first demonstrate that the source of difference between our predictions and other results in the literature for PI muon pair production is dominantly due to an unphysical cut that is imposed in these latter results on the dimuon-hadron impact parameter. We in addition show that this is experimentally disfavoured by the shape of the muon kinematic distributions measured by ATLAS in ultraperipheral PbPb collisions. We then consider the theoretical uncertainty due to the survival probability for no additional hadron-hadron interactions, and in particular the role this may play in the tendency for the predicted cross sections to lie somewhat above ATLAS data on PI muon pair production, in both $pp$ and PbPb collisions. This difference is relatively mild, at the $\sim 10\%$ level, and hence a very good control over the theory is clearly required. We show that this uncertainty is very small, and it is only by taking very extreme and rather unphysical variations in the modelling of the survival factor that this tension can be removed. This underlines the basic, rather model independent, point that a significant fraction of elastic PI scattering occurs for hadron-hadron impact parameters that are simply outside the range of QCD interactions, and hence this sets a lower bound on the survival factor in any physically reasonable approach. Finally, other possible origins for this discrepancy are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2021; v1 submitted 27 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Physics with Leptons and Photons at the LHC
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang
Abstract:
We present a phenomenological study of photon-initiated (PI) lepton production at the LHC, as implemented in the structure function (SF) approach. We provide detailed predictions for multi-differential lepton pair production, and show that the impact on observables sensitive to the the weak mixing angle, $\sin^2 θ_W$, and $W$ boson mass, $M_W$, as well as PDFs can be non-negligible, in particular…
▽ More
We present a phenomenological study of photon-initiated (PI) lepton production at the LHC, as implemented in the structure function (SF) approach. We provide detailed predictions for multi-differential lepton pair production, and show that the impact on observables sensitive to the the weak mixing angle, $\sin^2 θ_W$, and $W$ boson mass, $M_W$, as well as PDFs can be non-negligible, in particular given the high precision being aimed for. The SF calculation can provide percent level precision in the corresponding production cross sections, and is therefore well positioned to account for LHC precision requirements. We consider the pure $γγ$ channel, and compare in detail to the NLO collinear calculation. We in addition include initial-state $Z$ as well as mixed $γ/Z + q$ contributions, and assess their impact. We also consider photon-initiated lepton-lepton scattering, and again find the SF approach can provide high precision predictions for this process in way that can straightforwardly account for any fiducial cuts imposed. Finally, we provide a publicly available Monte Carlo generator, SFGen, for PI lepton pair production and lepton-lepton scattering within the SF approach, for use by the community.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2022; v1 submitted 11 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Parton distributions from LHC, HERA, Tevatron and fixed target data: MSHT20 PDFs
Authors:
S. Bailey,
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present the new MSHT20 set of parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton, determined from global analyses of the available hard scattering data. The PDFs are made available at NNLO, NLO, and LO, and supersede the MMHT14 sets. They are obtained using the same basic framework, but the parameterisation is now adapted and extended, and there are 32 pairs of eigenvector PDFs. We also include…
▽ More
We present the new MSHT20 set of parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton, determined from global analyses of the available hard scattering data. The PDFs are made available at NNLO, NLO, and LO, and supersede the MMHT14 sets. They are obtained using the same basic framework, but the parameterisation is now adapted and extended, and there are 32 pairs of eigenvector PDFs. We also include a large number of new data sets: from the final HERA combined data on total and heavy flavour structure functions, to final Tevatron data, and in particular a significant number of new LHC 7 and 8 TeV data sets on vector boson production, inclusive jets and top quark distributions. We include up to NNLO QCD corrections for all data sets that play a major role in the fit, and NLO EW corrections where relevant. We find that these updates have an important impact on the PDFs, and for the first time the NNLO fit is strongly favoured over the NLO, reflecting the wider range and in particular increased precision of data included in the fit. There are some changes to central values and a significant reduction in the uncertainties of the PDFs in many, though not all, cases. Nonetheless, the PDFs and the resulting predictions are generally within one standard deviation of the MMHT14 results. The major changes are the $u-d$ valence quark difference at small $x$, due to the improved parameterisation and new precise data, the $\bar d, \bar u$ difference at small $x$, due to a much improved parameterisation, and the strange quark PDF due to the effect of LHC $W,Z$ data and inclusion of new NNLO corrections for dimuon production in neutrino DIS. We discuss the phenomenological impact of our results, and in general find reduced uncertainties in predictions for processes such as Higgs, top quark pair and $W,Z$ production at post LHC Run-II energies.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2022; v1 submitted 8 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
New opportunities at the photon energy frontier
Authors:
Jaroslav Adam,
Christine Aidala,
Aaron Angerami,
Benjamin Audurier,
Carlos Bertulani,
Christian Bierlich,
Boris Blok,
James Daniel Brandenburg,
Stanley Brodsky,
Aleksandr Bylinkin,
Veronica Canoa Roman,
Francesco Giovanni Celiberto,
Jan Cepila,
Grigorios Chachamis,
Brian Cole,
Guillermo Contreras,
David d'Enterria,
Adrian Dumitru,
Arturo Fernández Téllez,
Leonid Frankfurt,
Maria Beatriz Gay Ducati,
Frank Geurts,
Gustavo Gil da Silveira,
Francesco Giuli,
Victor P. Goncalves
, et al. (50 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Ultra-peripheral collisions (UPCs) involving heavy ions and protons are the energy frontier for photon-mediated interactions. UPC photons can be used for many purposes, including probing low-$x$ gluons via photoproduction of dijets and vector mesons, probes of beyond-standard-model processes, such as those enabled by light-by-light scattering, and studies of two-photon production of the Higgs.
Ultra-peripheral collisions (UPCs) involving heavy ions and protons are the energy frontier for photon-mediated interactions. UPC photons can be used for many purposes, including probing low-$x$ gluons via photoproduction of dijets and vector mesons, probes of beyond-standard-model processes, such as those enabled by light-by-light scattering, and studies of two-photon production of the Higgs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The Large Hadron-Electron Collider at the HL-LHC
Authors:
P. Agostini,
H. Aksakal,
S. Alekhin,
P. P. Allport,
N. Andari,
K. D. J. Andre,
D. Angal-Kalinin,
S. Antusch,
L. Aperio Bella,
L. Apolinario,
R. Apsimon,
A. Apyan,
G. Arduini,
V. Ari,
A. Armbruster,
N. Armesto,
B. Auchmann,
K. Aulenbacher,
G. Azuelos,
S. Backovic,
I. Bailey,
S. Bailey,
F. Balli,
S. Behera,
O. Behnke
, et al. (312 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Large Hadron electron Collider (LHeC) is designed to move the field of deep inelastic scattering (DIS) to the energy and intensity frontier of particle physics. Exploiting energy recovery technology, it collides a novel, intense electron beam with a proton or ion beam from the High Luminosity--Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC). The accelerator and interaction region are designed for concurrent el…
▽ More
The Large Hadron electron Collider (LHeC) is designed to move the field of deep inelastic scattering (DIS) to the energy and intensity frontier of particle physics. Exploiting energy recovery technology, it collides a novel, intense electron beam with a proton or ion beam from the High Luminosity--Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC). The accelerator and interaction region are designed for concurrent electron-proton and proton-proton operation. This report represents an update of the Conceptual Design Report (CDR) of the LHeC, published in 2012. It comprises new results on parton structure of the proton and heavier nuclei, QCD dynamics, electroweak and top-quark physics. It is shown how the LHeC will open a new chapter of nuclear particle physics in extending the accessible kinematic range in lepton-nucleus scattering by several orders of magnitude. Due to enhanced luminosity, large energy and the cleanliness of the hadronic final states, the LHeC has a strong Higgs physics programme and its own discovery potential for new physics. Building on the 2012 CDR, the report represents a detailed updated design of the energy recovery electron linac (ERL) including new lattice, magnet, superconducting radio frequency technology and further components. Challenges of energy recovery are described and the lower energy, high current, 3-turn ERL facility, PERLE at Orsay, is presented which uses the LHeC characteristics serving as a development facility for the design and operation of the LHeC. An updated detector design is presented corresponding to the acceptance, resolution and calibration goals which arise from the Higgs and parton density function physics programmes. The paper also presents novel results on the Future Circular Collider in electron-hadron mode, FCC-eh, which utilises the same ERL technology to further extend the reach of DIS to even higher centre-of-mass energies.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021; v1 submitted 28 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
A new approach to modelling elastic and inelastic photon-initiated production at the LHC: SuperChic 4
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
M. Tasevsky,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
We present the results of the new SuperChic 4 Monte Carlo implementation of photon-initiated production in proton-proton collisions, considering as a first example the case of lepton pair production. This is based on the structure function calculation of the underlying process, and focusses on a complete account of the various contributing channels, including the case where a rapidity gap veto is…
▽ More
We present the results of the new SuperChic 4 Monte Carlo implementation of photon-initiated production in proton-proton collisions, considering as a first example the case of lepton pair production. This is based on the structure function calculation of the underlying process, and focusses on a complete account of the various contributing channels, including the case where a rapidity gap veto is imposed. We provide a careful treatment of the contributions where either (single dissociation), both (double dissociation) or neither (elastic) proton interacts inelastically and dissociates, and interface our results to Pythia for showering and hadronization. The particle decay distribution from dissociation system, as well the survival probability for no additional proton-proton interactions, are both fully accounted for; these are essential for comparing to data where a rapidity gap veto is applied. We present detailed results for the impact of the veto requirement on the differential cross section, compare to and find good agreement with ATLAS 7 TeV data on semi-exclusive production, and provide a new precise evaluation of the background from semi-exclusive lepton pair production to SUSY particle production in compressed mass scenarios, which is found to be low.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2021; v1 submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
The Proton in High Definition: Revisiting Photon-Initiated Production in High Energy Collisions
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang
Abstract:
We re-examine the current state of the art for the calculation of photon-initiated processes at the LHC, as formulated in terms of a photon PDF in the proton that may be determined rather precisely from the known proton structure functions. We in particular demonstrate that a by construction more precise calculation is provided by a direct application of the structure function approach, best known…
▽ More
We re-examine the current state of the art for the calculation of photon-initiated processes at the LHC, as formulated in terms of a photon PDF in the proton that may be determined rather precisely from the known proton structure functions. We in particular demonstrate that a by construction more precise calculation is provided by a direct application of the structure function approach, best known from the case of Higgs Boson production via vector boson fusion. This avoids any artificial scale variation uncertainties, which can otherwise be rather significant for processes calculated within the standard approach thus far. To understand the source of these, we present a detailed comparison of the structure function approach and its relation to the photon PDF. We then provide precise predictions for the photon-initiated contribution to lepton pair production at the LHC, including the lepton pair transverse momentum distribution. Thus, by a direct application of the structure function formalism we show how the contribution from initial-state photons at the LHC may for the first time be included with high precision in a universal and straightforward way, providing a high definition picture of the photon content of the proton.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2021; v1 submitted 22 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Updates of PDFs in the MMHT framework
Authors:
R. S. Thorne,
S. Bailey,
T. Cridge,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
R. Nathvani
Abstract:
We summarise recent developments in the path towards the "MMHT19" parton distribution functions. We concentrate on the extraction of the strange quark upon the improvement of theoretical calculations for NNLO charged current cross sections; the effect of an extension of our parameterisation; and the role of correlated uncertainties in some data sets which prove difficult to fit.
We summarise recent developments in the path towards the "MMHT19" parton distribution functions. We concentrate on the extraction of the strange quark upon the improvement of theoretical calculations for NNLO charged current cross sections; the effect of an extension of our parameterisation; and the role of correlated uncertainties in some data sets which prove difficult to fit.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Ad Lucem: QED Parton Distribution Functions in the MMHT Framework
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
R. Nathvani,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present the MMHT2015qed PDF set, resulting from the inclusion of QED corrections to the existing set of MMHT Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs), and which contain the photon PDF of the proton. Adopting an input distribution from the LUXqed formulation, we discuss our methods of including QED effects for the full, coupled DGLAP evolution of all partons with QED at $\mathcal{O}(α)$,…
▽ More
We present the MMHT2015qed PDF set, resulting from the inclusion of QED corrections to the existing set of MMHT Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs), and which contain the photon PDF of the proton. Adopting an input distribution from the LUXqed formulation, we discuss our methods of including QED effects for the full, coupled DGLAP evolution of all partons with QED at $\mathcal{O}(α)$, $\mathcal{O}(αα_{S})$, $\mathcal{O}(α^2)$. While we find consistency for the photon PDF of the proton with other recent sets, building on this we also present a set of QED corrected neutron PDFs and provide the photon PDF separated into its elastic and inelastic contributions. The effect of QED corrections on the other partons and the fit quality is investigated, and the sources of uncertainty for the photon are outlined. Finally we explore the phenomenological implications of this set, giving the partonic luminosities for both the elastic and inelastic contributions to the photon and the effect of our photon PDF on fits to high mass Drell-Yan production, including the photon--initiated channel.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Probing Proton Structure at the Large Hadron electron Collider
Authors:
Rabah Abdul Khalek,
Shaun Bailey,
Jun Gao,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Juan Rojo
Abstract:
For the foreseeable future, the exploration of the high-energy frontier will be the domain of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Of particular significance will be its high-luminosity upgrade (HL-LHC), which will operate until the mid-2030s. In this endeavour, for the full exploitation of the HL-LHC physics potential an improved understanding of the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton…
▽ More
For the foreseeable future, the exploration of the high-energy frontier will be the domain of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Of particular significance will be its high-luminosity upgrade (HL-LHC), which will operate until the mid-2030s. In this endeavour, for the full exploitation of the HL-LHC physics potential an improved understanding of the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton is critical. The HL-LHC program would be uniquely complemented by the proposed Large Hadron electron Collider (LHeC), a high-energy lepton-proton and lepton-nucleus collider based at CERN. In this work, we build on our recent PDF projections for the HL-LHC to assess the constraining power of the LHeC measurements of inclusive and heavy quark structure functions. We find that the impact of the LHeC would be significant, reducing PDF uncertainties by up to an order of magnitude in comparison to state-of-the-art global fits. In comparison to the HL-LHC projections, the PDF constraints from the LHeC are in general more significant for small and intermediate values of the momentum fraction x. At higher values of x, the impact of the LHeC and HL-LHC data is expected to be of a comparable size, with the HL-LHC constraints being more competitive in some cases, and the LHeC ones in others. Our results illustrate the encouraging complementarity of the HL-LHC and the LHeC in terms of charting the quark and gluon structure of the proton.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2019; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
A fresh look at ALP searches in fixed target experiments
Authors:
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Joerg Jaeckel,
Michael Spannowsky
Abstract:
A significant number of high power proton beams are available or will go online in the near future. This provides exciting opportunities for new fixed target experiments and the search for new physics in particular. In this note we will survey these beams and consider their potential to discover new physics in the form of axion-like particles, identifying promising locations and set ups. To achiev…
▽ More
A significant number of high power proton beams are available or will go online in the near future. This provides exciting opportunities for new fixed target experiments and the search for new physics in particular. In this note we will survey these beams and consider their potential to discover new physics in the form of axion-like particles, identifying promising locations and set ups. To achieve this, we present a significantly improved calculation of the production of axion-like particles in the coherent scattering of protons on nuclei, valid for lower ALP masses and/or beam energies. We also provide a new publicly available tool for this process: the Alpaca Monte Carlo generator. This will impact ongoing and planned searches based on this process.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019; v1 submitted 13 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Higgs Physics at the HL-LHC and HE-LHC
Authors:
M. Cepeda,
S. Gori,
P. Ilten,
M. Kado,
F. Riva,
R. Abdul Khalek,
A. Aboubrahim,
J. Alimena,
S. Alioli,
A. Alves,
C. Asawatangtrakuldee,
A. Azatov,
P. Azzi,
S. Bailey,
S. Banerjee,
E. L. Barberio,
D. Barducci,
G. Barone,
M. Bauer,
C. Bautista,
P. Bechtle,
K. Becker,
A. Benaglia,
M. Bengala,
N. Berger
, et al. (352 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The discovery of the Higgs boson in 2012, by the ATLAS and CMS experiments, was a success achieved with only a percent of the entire dataset foreseen for the LHC. It opened a landscape of possibilities in the study of Higgs boson properties, Electroweak Symmetry breaking and the Standard Model in general, as well as new avenues in probing new physics beyond the Standard Model. Six years after the…
▽ More
The discovery of the Higgs boson in 2012, by the ATLAS and CMS experiments, was a success achieved with only a percent of the entire dataset foreseen for the LHC. It opened a landscape of possibilities in the study of Higgs boson properties, Electroweak Symmetry breaking and the Standard Model in general, as well as new avenues in probing new physics beyond the Standard Model. Six years after the discovery, with a conspicuously larger dataset collected during LHC Run 2 at a 13 TeV centre-of-mass energy, the theory and experimental particle physics communities have started a meticulous exploration of the potential for precision measurements of its properties. This includes studies of Higgs boson production and decays processes, the search for rare decays and production modes, high energy observables, and searches for an extended electroweak symmetry breaking sector. This report summarises the potential reach and opportunities in Higgs physics during the High Luminosity phase of the LHC, with an expected dataset of pp collisions at 14 TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 3 ab$^{-1}$. These studies are performed in light of the most recent analyses from LHC collaborations and the latest theoretical developments. The potential of an LHC upgrade, colliding protons at a centre-of-mass energy of 27 TeV and producing a dataset corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 15 ab$^{-1}$, is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2019; v1 submitted 31 January, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
PHOTON-2017 conference proceedings
Authors:
David d'Enterria,
Albert de Roeck,
Michelangelo Mangano,
Jaroslav Adam,
Massimiliano Alvioli,
Christopher D. Anson,
Hamed Bakhshiansohi,
Cristian Baldenegro,
Valerio Bertone,
Stanley J. Brodsky,
Peter J. Bussey,
Chav Chhiv Chau,
Weiren Chou,
Ruchi Chudasama,
Fernando Cornet,
David d'Enterria,
Stefan Dittmaier,
Babette Dobrich,
Dipanwita Dutta,
John Ellis,
Sylvain Fichet,
Leonid Frankfurt,
Carlos Garcia-Canal,
Rohini M. Godbole,
Agnes Grau
, et al. (56 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This document collects the proceedings of the PHOTON 2017 conference ("International Conference on the Structure and the Interactions of the Photon", including the 22th "International Workshop on Photon-Photon Collisions", and the "International Workshop on High Energy Photon Colliders") held at CERN (Geneva) in May 2017. The latest experimental and theoretical developments on the topics of the PH…
▽ More
This document collects the proceedings of the PHOTON 2017 conference ("International Conference on the Structure and the Interactions of the Photon", including the 22th "International Workshop on Photon-Photon Collisions", and the "International Workshop on High Energy Photon Colliders") held at CERN (Geneva) in May 2017. The latest experimental and theoretical developments on the topics of the PHOTON conference series are covered: (i) $γ\,γ$ processes in e$^+$e$^-$, proton-proton (pp) and nucleus-nucleus (AA) collisions at current and future colliders, (ii) $γ$-hadron interactions in e$^\pm$p, pp, and AA collisions, (iii) final-state photon production (including Standard Model studies and searches beyond it) in pp and AA collisions, and (iv) high-energy $γ$-ray astrophysics. These proceedings are dedicated to the memory of Maria Krawczyk.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
New physics searches with heavy-ion collisions at the LHC
Authors:
Roderik Bruce,
David d'Enterria,
Albert de Roeck,
Marco Drewes,
Glennys R. Farrar,
Andrea Giammanco,
Oliver Gould,
Jan Hajer,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Jan Heisig,
John M. Jowett,
Sonia Kabana,
Georgios K. Krintiras,
Michael Korsmeier,
Michele Lucente,
Guilherme Milhano,
Swagata Mukherjee,
Jeremi Niedziela,
Vitalii A. Okorokov,
Arttu Rajantie,
Michaela Schaumann
Abstract:
This document summarises proposed searches for new physics accessible in the heavy-ion mode at the CERN Large Hadron Collider (LHC), both through hadronic and ultraperipheral $γγ$ interactions, and that have a competitive or, even, unique discovery potential compared to standard proton-proton collision studies. Illustrative examples include searches for new particles -- such as axion-like pseudosc…
▽ More
This document summarises proposed searches for new physics accessible in the heavy-ion mode at the CERN Large Hadron Collider (LHC), both through hadronic and ultraperipheral $γγ$ interactions, and that have a competitive or, even, unique discovery potential compared to standard proton-proton collision studies. Illustrative examples include searches for new particles -- such as axion-like pseudoscalars, radions, magnetic monopoles, new long-lived particles, dark photons, and sexaquarks as dark matter candidates -- as well as new interactions, such as non-linear or non-commutative QED extensions. We argue that such interesting possibilities constitute a well-justified scientific motivation, complementing standard quark-gluon-plasma physics studies, to continue running with ions at the LHC after the Run-4, i.e. beyond 2030, including light and intermediate-mass ion species, accumulating nucleon-nucleon integrated luminosities in the accessible fb$^{-1}$ range per month.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
On the Consistent Use of Scale Variations in PDF Fits and Predictions
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present an investigation of the theoretical uncertainties in parton distribution functions (PDFs) due to missing higher-order corrections in the perturbative predictions used in the fit, and their relationship to the uncertainties in subsequent predictions made using the PDFs. We consider in particular the standard approach of factorization and renormalization scale variation, and derive genera…
▽ More
We present an investigation of the theoretical uncertainties in parton distribution functions (PDFs) due to missing higher-order corrections in the perturbative predictions used in the fit, and their relationship to the uncertainties in subsequent predictions made using the PDFs. We consider in particular the standard approach of factorization and renormalization scale variation, and derive general results for the consistent application of these at the PDF fit stage. To do this, we use the fact that a PDF fit may be recast in a physical basis, where the PDFs themselves are bypassed entirely, and one instead relates measured observables to predicted ones. In the case of factorization scale variation we find that in various situations there is a high degree of effective correlation between the variation in the fit and in predicted observables. In particular, including such a variation in both cases can lead to an exaggerated theoretical uncertainty. More generally, a careful treatment of this correlation appears mandatory, at least within the standard scale variation paradigm. For the renormalization scale, the situation is less straightforward, but again we highlight the potential for correlations between related processes in the fit and predictions to enter at the same level as between processes in the fit or prediction alone.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2019; v1 submitted 20 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Exclusive LHC physics with heavy ions: SuperChic 3
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
We present results of the updated SuperChic 3 Monte Carlo event generator for central exclusive production. This extends the previous treatment of proton-proton collisions to include heavy ion (pA and AA) beams, for both photon and QCD-initiated production, the first time such a unified treatment of exclusive processes has been presented in a single generator. To achieve this we have developed a t…
▽ More
We present results of the updated SuperChic 3 Monte Carlo event generator for central exclusive production. This extends the previous treatment of proton-proton collisions to include heavy ion (pA and AA) beams, for both photon and QCD-initiated production, the first time such a unified treatment of exclusive processes has been presented in a single generator. To achieve this we have developed a theory of the gap survival factor in heavy ion collisions, which allows us to derive some straightforward results about the $A$ scaling of the corresponding cross sections. We compare against the recent ATLAS and CMS measurements of light-by-light scattering at the LHC, in lead-lead collisions. We find that the background from QCD-initiated production is expected to be very small, in contrast to some earlier estimates. We also present results from new photon-initiated processes that can now be generated, namely the production of axion-like particles, monopole pairs and monopolium, top quark pair production, and the inclusion of $W$ loops in light-by-light scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019; v1 submitted 15 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Towards Ultimate Parton Distributions at the High-Luminosity LHC
Authors:
Rabah Abdul Khalek,
Shaun Bailey,
Jun Gao,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Juan Rojo
Abstract:
Since its start of data taking, the LHC has provided an impressive wealth of information on the quark and gluon structure of the proton. Indeed, modern global analyses of parton distribution functions (PDFs) include a wide range of LHC measurements of processes such as the production of jets, electroweak gauge bosons, and top quark pairs. In this work, we assess the ultimate constraining power of…
▽ More
Since its start of data taking, the LHC has provided an impressive wealth of information on the quark and gluon structure of the proton. Indeed, modern global analyses of parton distribution functions (PDFs) include a wide range of LHC measurements of processes such as the production of jets, electroweak gauge bosons, and top quark pairs. In this work, we assess the ultimate constraining power of LHC data on the PDFs that can be expected from the complete dataset, in particular after the High-Luminosity (HL) phase, starting in around 2025. The huge statistics of the HL-LHC, delivering $\mathcal{L}=3$ ab$^{-1}$ to ATLAS and CMS and $\mathcal{L}=0.3$ ab$^{-1}$ to LHCb, will lead to an extension of the kinematic coverage of PDF-sensitive measurements as well as to an improvement in their statistical and systematic uncertainties. Here we generate HL-LHC pseudo-data for different projections of the experimental uncertainties, and then quantify the resulting constraints on the PDF4LHC15 set by means of the Hessian profiling method. We find that HL-LHC measurements can reduce PDF uncertainties by up to a factor of 2 to 4 in comparison to state-of-the-art fits, leading to few-percent uncertainties for important observables such as the Higgs boson transverse momentum distribution via gluon-fusion. Our results illustrate the significant improvement in the precision of PDF fits achievable from hadron collider data alone, and motivate the continuation of the ongoing successful program of PDF-sensitive measurements by the LHC collaborations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
WG1: Structure Functions and Parton Densities
Authors:
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Philip Ilten,
Jan Kretzschmar
Abstract:
This paper gives a summary of selected highlights discussed in the working group on "Structure Functions and Parton Densities" (WG1) at the DIS 2017 conference. From the many talks presented we extract some general themes discussed with respect to global PDF fits, new PDF-sensitive measurements from the LHC experiments and elsewhere, exploitation of new ideas, tools to perform PDF fits, PDFs of he…
▽ More
This paper gives a summary of selected highlights discussed in the working group on "Structure Functions and Parton Densities" (WG1) at the DIS 2017 conference. From the many talks presented we extract some general themes discussed with respect to global PDF fits, new PDF-sensitive measurements from the LHC experiments and elsewhere, exploitation of new ideas, tools to perform PDF fits, PDFs of heavy nuclei, and finally progress in basic theory calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2018; v1 submitted 14 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
The Impact of LHC Jet Data on the MMHT PDF Fit at NNLO
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We investigate the impact of the high precision ATLAS and CMS 7 TeV measurements of inclusive jet production on the MMHT global PDF analysis at next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). This is made possible by the recent completion of the long-term project to calculate the NNLO corrections to the hard cross section. We find that a good description of the ATLAS data is not possible with the default tr…
▽ More
We investigate the impact of the high precision ATLAS and CMS 7 TeV measurements of inclusive jet production on the MMHT global PDF analysis at next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). This is made possible by the recent completion of the long-term project to calculate the NNLO corrections to the hard cross section. We find that a good description of the ATLAS data is not possible with the default treatment of experimental systematic errors, and develop a simplified solution that retains the dominant physical information of the data. We then investigate the fit quality and the impact on the gluon PDF central value and uncertainty when the ATLAS and CMS data are included in a MMHT fit. We consider both common choices for the factorization and renormalization scale, namely the inclusive jet transverse momentum, $p_\perp$, and the leading jet $p_\perp$, as well as the different jet radii for which the ATLAS and CMS data are made available. We find that the impact of these data on the gluon is relatively insensitive to these inputs, in particular the scale choice, while the inclusion of NNLO corrections tends to improve the data description somewhat, and gives a qualitatively similar though not identical impact on the gluon in comparison to NLO.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2018; v1 submitted 15 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
The Structure of the Proton in the LHC Precision Era
Authors:
Jun Gao,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Juan Rojo
Abstract:
We review recent progress in the determination of the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton, with emphasis on the applications for precision phenomenology at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). First of all, we introduce the general theoretical framework underlying the global QCD analysis of the quark and gluon internal structure of protons. We then present a detailed overview of the har…
▽ More
We review recent progress in the determination of the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton, with emphasis on the applications for precision phenomenology at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). First of all, we introduce the general theoretical framework underlying the global QCD analysis of the quark and gluon internal structure of protons. We then present a detailed overview of the hard-scattering measurements, and the corresponding theory predictions, that are used in state-of-the-art PDF fits. We emphasize here the role that higher-order QCD and electroweak corrections play in the description of recent high-precision collider data. We present the methodology used to extract PDFs in global analyses, including the PDF parametrization strategy and the definition and propagation of PDF uncertainties. Then we review and compare the most recent releases from the various PDF fitting collaborations, highlighting their differences and similarities. We discuss the role that QED corrections and photon-initiated contributions play in modern PDF analysis. We provide representative examples of the implications of PDF fits for high-precision LHC phenomenological applications, such as Higgs coupling measurements and searches for high-mass New Physics resonances. We conclude this report by discussing some selected topics relevant for the future of PDF determinations, including the treatment of theoretical uncertainties, the connection with lattice QCD calculations, and the role of PDFs at future high-energy colliders beyond the LHC.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2018; v1 submitted 14 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Photon-Photon Collisions with SuperChic
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
The SuperChic Monte Carlo generator provides a common platform for QCD-mediated, photoproduction and photon-induced Central Exclusive Production (CEP), with a fully differential treatment of soft survival effects. In these proceedings we summarise the processes generated, before discussing in more detail those due to photon-photon collisions, paying special attention to the correct treatment of th…
▽ More
The SuperChic Monte Carlo generator provides a common platform for QCD-mediated, photoproduction and photon-induced Central Exclusive Production (CEP), with a fully differential treatment of soft survival effects. In these proceedings we summarise the processes generated, before discussing in more detail those due to photon-photon collisions, paying special attention to the correct treatment of the survival factor. We briefly consider the light-by-light scattering process as an example, before discussing planned extensions and refinements for the generator.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
$χ_c$ decays and the gluon content of the $η'$, $η$ mesons
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin,
A. G. Shuvaev
Abstract:
The large mass of the $η'$ meson indicates that a sizeable gluon component is present in the meson wave function. However, the $χ_{c0}$ and $χ_{c2}$ decays to $η'$ mesons, which proceed via a purely gluonic intermediate state and we would therefore naïvely expect to be enhanced by such a component, are in fact relatively suppressed. We argue that this apparent contradiction may be resolved by a pr…
▽ More
The large mass of the $η'$ meson indicates that a sizeable gluon component is present in the meson wave function. However, the $χ_{c0}$ and $χ_{c2}$ decays to $η'$ mesons, which proceed via a purely gluonic intermediate state and we would therefore naïvely expect to be enhanced by such a component, are in fact relatively suppressed. We argue that this apparent contradiction may be resolved by a proper treatment of interference effects in the decay. In particular, by accounting for the destructive interference between the quark and gluon components of the $η'$ distribution function, in combination with a model for strange quark mass effects, we demonstrate that the observed $χ_{c(0,2)}\toη(')η(')$ branching ratios can be reproduced for a reasonable gluon component of the $η'$, $η$ mesons.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2017; v1 submitted 14 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
LHC Forward Physics
Authors:
K. Akiba,
M. Akbiyik,
M. Albrow,
M. Arneodo,
V. Avati,
J. Baechler,
O. Villalobos Baillie,
P. Bartalini,
J. Bartels,
S. Baur,
C. Baus,
W. Beaumont,
U. Behrens,
D. Berge,
M. Berretti,
E. Bossini,
R. Boussarie,
S. Brodsky,
M. Broz,
M. Bruschi,
P. Bussey,
W. Byczynski,
J. C. Cabanillas Noris,
E. Calvo Villar,
A. Campbell
, et al. (162 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The goal of this report is to give a comprehensive overview of the rich field of forward physics, with a special attention to the topics that can be studied at the LHC. The report starts presenting a selection of the Monte Carlo simulation tools currently available, chapter 2, then enters the rich phenomenology of QCD at low, chapter 3, and high, chapter 4, momentum transfer, while the unique scat…
▽ More
The goal of this report is to give a comprehensive overview of the rich field of forward physics, with a special attention to the topics that can be studied at the LHC. The report starts presenting a selection of the Monte Carlo simulation tools currently available, chapter 2, then enters the rich phenomenology of QCD at low, chapter 3, and high, chapter 4, momentum transfer, while the unique scattering conditions of central exclusive production are analyzed in chapter 5. The last two experimental topics, Cosmic Ray and Heavy Ion physics are presented in the chapter 6 and 7 respectively. Chapter 8 is dedicated to the BFKL dynamics, multiparton interactions, and saturation. The report ends with an overview of the forward detectors at LHC. Each chapter is correlated with a comprehensive bibliography, attempting to provide to the interested reader with a wide opportunity for further studies.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2017; v1 submitted 15 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Photon-initiated processes at high mass
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
We consider the influence of photon-initiated processes on high-mass particle production. We discuss in detail the photon PDF at relatively high parton $x$, relevant to such processes, and evaluate its uncertainties. In particular we show that, as the dominant contribution to the input photon distribution is due to coherent photon emission, at phenomenologically relevant scales the photon PDF is a…
▽ More
We consider the influence of photon-initiated processes on high-mass particle production. We discuss in detail the photon PDF at relatively high parton $x$, relevant to such processes, and evaluate its uncertainties. In particular we show that, as the dominant contribution to the input photon distribution is due to coherent photon emission, at phenomenologically relevant scales the photon PDF is already well determined in this region, with the corresponding uncertainties under good control. We then demonstrate the implications of this result for the example processes of high-mass lepton and $W$ boson pair production at the LHC and FCC. While for the former process the photon-initiated contribution is expected to be small, in the latter case we find that it is potentially significant, in particular at larger masses.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2016; v1 submitted 15 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Jet activity as a probe of high-mass resonance production
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin,
M. Spannowsky
Abstract:
We explore the method of using the measured jet activity associated with a high mass resonance state to determine the corresponding production modes. To demonstrate the potential of the approach, we consider the case of a resonance of mass $M_R$ decaying to a diphoton final state. We perform a Monte Carlo study, considering three mass points $M_R=0.75,\,1.5\,,2.5$ TeV, and show that the $γγ$,…
▽ More
We explore the method of using the measured jet activity associated with a high mass resonance state to determine the corresponding production modes. To demonstrate the potential of the approach, we consider the case of a resonance of mass $M_R$ decaying to a diphoton final state. We perform a Monte Carlo study, considering three mass points $M_R=0.75,\,1.5\,,2.5$ TeV, and show that the $γγ$, $WW$, $gg$ and light and heavy $q\overline{q}$ initiated cases lead to distinct predictions for the jet multiplicity distributions. As an example, we apply this result to the ATLAS search for resonances in diphoton events, using the 2015 data set of $3.2\,{\rm fb}^{-1}$ at $\sqrt{s}=13$ TeV. Taking the spin-0 selection, we demonstrate that a dominantly $gg$-initiated signal hypothesis is mildly disfavoured, while the $γγ$ and light quark cases give good descriptions within the limited statistics, and a dominantly $WW$-initiated hypothesis is found to be in strong tension with the data. We also comment on the $b\overline{b}$ initial state, which can already be constrained by the measured $b$-jet multiplicity. Finally, we present expected exclusion limits with integrated luminosity, and demonstrate that with just a few 10's of ${\rm fb}^{-1}$ we can expect to constrain the production modes of such a resonance.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2016; v1 submitted 15 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
The Effect of Final HERA inclusive Cross Section Data on MMHT2014 PDFs
Authors:
R. S. Thorne,
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
P. Motylinski
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of including the HERA run I + II combined cross section data on the MMHT2014 PDFs. We present the fit quality within the context of the global fit and when only the HERA data are included. We examine the changes in both the central values and uncertainties in the PDFs. We find that the prediction for the data is good, and only relatively small improvements in $χ^2$ and ch…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of including the HERA run I + II combined cross section data on the MMHT2014 PDFs. We present the fit quality within the context of the global fit and when only the HERA data are included. We examine the changes in both the central values and uncertainties in the PDFs. We find that the prediction for the data is good, and only relatively small improvements in $χ^2$ and changes in the PDFs are obtained with a refit at both NLO and NNLO. PDF uncertainties are slightly reduced. There is a small dependence of the fit quality on the value of $Q^2_{\min}$.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
The PDF4LHC report on PDFs and LHC data: Results from Run I and preparation for Run II
Authors:
Juan Rojo,
Alberto Accardi,
Richard D. Ball,
Amanda Cooper-Sarkar,
Albert de Roeck,
Stephen Farry,
James Ferrando,
Stefano Forte,
Jun Gao,
Lucian Harland-Lang,
Joey Huston,
Alexander Glazov,
Maxime Gouzevitch,
Claire Gwenlan,
Katerina Lipka,
Mykhailo Lisovyi,
Michelangelo Mangano,
Pavel Nadolsky,
Luca Perrozzi,
Ringaile Placakyte,
Voica Radescu,
Gavin P. Salam,
Robert Thorne
Abstract:
The accurate determination of the Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) of the proton is an essential ingredient of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) program. PDF uncertainties impact a wide range of processes, from Higgs boson characterisation and precision Standard Model measurements to New Physics searches. A major recent development in modern PDF analyses has been to exploit the wealth of new inf…
▽ More
The accurate determination of the Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) of the proton is an essential ingredient of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) program. PDF uncertainties impact a wide range of processes, from Higgs boson characterisation and precision Standard Model measurements to New Physics searches. A major recent development in modern PDF analyses has been to exploit the wealth of new information contained in precision measurements from the LHC Run I, as well as progress in tools and methods to include these data in PDF fits. In this report we summarise the information that PDF-sensitive measurements at the LHC have provided so far, and review the prospects for further constraining PDFs with data from the recently started Run II. This document aims to provide useful input to the LHC collaborations to prioritise their PDF-sensitive measurements at Run II, as well as a comprehensive reference for the PDF-fitting collaborations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Uncertainties on $α_S$ in the MMHT2014 global PDF analysis and implications for SM predictions
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
P. Motylinski,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We investigate the uncertainty in the value of the strong coupling $α_S(M_Z^2)$ when allowing it to be a free parameter in the recent MMHT global analyses of deep-inelastic and related hard scattering data that was undertaken to determine the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton. The analysis uses the standard framework of leading twist fixed--order collinear factorisation in the…
▽ More
We investigate the uncertainty in the value of the strong coupling $α_S(M_Z^2)$ when allowing it to be a free parameter in the recent MMHT global analyses of deep-inelastic and related hard scattering data that was undertaken to determine the parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton. The analysis uses the standard framework of leading twist fixed--order collinear factorisation in the ${\overline {\rm MS}}$ scheme. We study the constraints on the value of $α_S(M_Z^2)$ coming from the individual data sets by repeating the NNLO and NLO global analyses at various fixed values of $α_S(M_Z^2)$ about its optimum values, spanning the range $α_S(M_Z^2)=0.108$ to $0.128$ in units of $0.001$, and making all PDFs sets available. The inclusion of the measurements of the cross section for inclusive $t\bar{t}$ production in the global fit allows us to explore the correlation between the values taken for the mass $m_t$ of the top quark and $α_S(M_Z^2)$. We find that the best fit values are $α_S(M_Z^2)=0.1201\pm0.0015$ and $0.1172\pm 0.0013$ at NLO and NNLO respectively, with the central values changing to $α_S(M_Z^2)=0.1195$ and $0.1178$ when the world average of $α_S(M_Z^2)$ is used as a data point. We investigate the interplay between the uncertainties on $α_S(M_Z^2)$ and the uncertainties on the PDFs. In particular we calculate the cross sections for key processes at the LHC and show how the uncertainties coming from the standard MMHT2014 PDFs and from $α_S(M_Z^2)$ can be provided independently and can be combined.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2015; v1 submitted 18 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Parton distributions in the LHC era: MMHT 2014 PDFs
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
A. D. Martin,
P. Motylinski,
R. S. Thorne
Abstract:
We present LO, NLO and NNLO sets of parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton determined from global analyses of the available hard scattering data. These MMHT2014 PDFs supersede the `MSTW2008' parton sets, but are obtained within the same basic framework. We include a variety of new data sets, from the LHC, updated Tevatron data and the HERA combined H1 and ZEUS data on the total and cha…
▽ More
We present LO, NLO and NNLO sets of parton distribution functions (PDFs) of the proton determined from global analyses of the available hard scattering data. These MMHT2014 PDFs supersede the `MSTW2008' parton sets, but are obtained within the same basic framework. We include a variety of new data sets, from the LHC, updated Tevatron data and the HERA combined H1 and ZEUS data on the total and charm structure functions. We also improve the theoretical framework of the previous analysis. These new PDFs are compared to the `MSTW2008' parton sets. In most cases the PDFs, and the predictions, are within one standard deviation of those of MSTW2008. The major changes are the $u-d$ valence quark difference at small $x$ due to an improved parameterisation and, to a lesser extent, the strange quark PDF due to the effect of certain LHC data and a better treatment of the $D \to μ$ branching ratio. We compare our MMHT PDF sets with those of other collaborations; in particular with the NNPDF3.0 sets, which are contemporary with the present analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2015; v1 submitted 12 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Sharpening $m_{T2}$ cusps: the mass determination of semi-invisibly decaying particles from a resonance
Authors:
Lucian A. Harland-Lang,
Chun-Hay Kom,
Kazuki Sakurai,
Marco Tonini
Abstract:
We revisit mass determination techniques for the minimum symmetric event topology, namely $X$ pair production followed by $X \to \ell N$, where $X$ and $N$ are unknown particles with the masses to be measured, and $N$ is an invisible particle, concentrating on the case where $X$ is pair produced from a resonance. We consider separate scenarios, with different initial constraints on the invisible p…
▽ More
We revisit mass determination techniques for the minimum symmetric event topology, namely $X$ pair production followed by $X \to \ell N$, where $X$ and $N$ are unknown particles with the masses to be measured, and $N$ is an invisible particle, concentrating on the case where $X$ is pair produced from a resonance. We consider separate scenarios, with different initial constraints on the invisible particle momenta, and present a systematic method to identify the kinematically allowed mass regions in the $(m_N, m_X)$ plane. These allowed regions exhibit a cusp structure at the true mass point, which is equivalent to the one observed in the $m_{T2}$ endpoints in certain cases. By considering the boundary of the allowed mass region we systematically define kinematical variables which can be used in measuring the unknown masses, and find a new expression for the $m_{T2}$ variable as well as its inverse. We explicitly apply our method to the case that $X$ is pair produced from a resonance, and as a case study, we consider the process $pp \to A \to \tilde χ_1^+ \tilde χ_1^-$, followed by $\tilde χ_1^\pm \to \ell^{\pm} \, \tilde ν_{\ell}$, in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model and show that our method provides a precise measurement of the chargino and sneutrino masses, $m_X$ and $m_N$, at $14 \, \mathrm{TeV}$ LHC with $300 \, \mathrm{fb}^{-1}$ luminosity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2014; v1 submitted 19 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Exclusive meson pair production and the gluonic component of the eta, eta' mesons
Authors:
L. A. Harland-Lang,
V. A. Khoze,
M. G. Ryskin
Abstract:
We present the results of recent work on the central exclusive production of meson pairs. We concentrate on the case of flavour-singlet pseudoscalar mesons eta, eta' and show that the central exclusive process, as modelled using a recent novel application of the 'hard exclusive' perturbative formalism, is potentially highly sensitive to the size of the gluon content of these states. We also discus…
▽ More
We present the results of recent work on the central exclusive production of meson pairs. We concentrate on the case of flavour-singlet pseudoscalar mesons eta, eta' and show that the central exclusive process, as modelled using a recent novel application of the 'hard exclusive' perturbative formalism, is potentially highly sensitive to the size of the gluon content of these states. We also discuss the exclusive production of meson pairs in the lower mass region, and present the first results of the new Dime Monte Carlo.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
