-
Meeting Recognition with Continuous Speech Separation and Transcription-Supported Diarization
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Tobias Cord-Landwehr,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
We propose a modular pipeline for the single-channel separation, recognition, and diarization of meeting-style recordings and evaluate it on the Libri-CSS dataset. Using a Continuous Speech Separation (CSS) system with a TF-GridNet separation architecture, followed by a speaker-agnostic speech recognizer, we achieve state-of-the-art recognition performance in terms of Optimal Reference Combination…
▽ More
We propose a modular pipeline for the single-channel separation, recognition, and diarization of meeting-style recordings and evaluate it on the Libri-CSS dataset. Using a Continuous Speech Separation (CSS) system with a TF-GridNet separation architecture, followed by a speaker-agnostic speech recognizer, we achieve state-of-the-art recognition performance in terms of Optimal Reference Combination Word Error Rate (ORC WER). Then, a d-vector-based diarization module is employed to extract speaker embeddings from the enhanced signals and to assign the CSS outputs to the correct speaker. Here, we propose a syntactically informed diarization using sentence- and word-level boundaries of the ASR module to support speaker turn detection. This results in a state-of-the-art Concatenated minimum-Permutation Word Error Rate (cpWER) for the full meeting recognition pipeline.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024; v1 submitted 28 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Mixture Encoder Supporting Continuous Speech Separation for Meeting Recognition
Authors:
Peter Vieting,
Simon Berger,
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Ralf Schlüter,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Many real-life applications of automatic speech recognition (ASR) require processing of overlapped speech. A commonmethod involves first separating the speech into overlap-free streams and then performing ASR on the resulting signals. Recently, the inclusion of a mixture encoder in the ASR model has been proposed. This mixture encoder leverages the original overlapped speech to mitigate the effect…
▽ More
Many real-life applications of automatic speech recognition (ASR) require processing of overlapped speech. A commonmethod involves first separating the speech into overlap-free streams and then performing ASR on the resulting signals. Recently, the inclusion of a mixture encoder in the ASR model has been proposed. This mixture encoder leverages the original overlapped speech to mitigate the effect of artifacts introduced by the speech separation. Previously, however, the method only addressed two-speaker scenarios. In this work, we extend this approach to more natural meeting contexts featuring an arbitrary number of speakers and dynamic overlaps. We evaluate the performance using different speech separators, including the powerful TF-GridNet model. Our experiments show state-of-the-art performance on the LibriCSS dataset and highlight the advantages of the mixture encoder. Furthermore, they demonstrate the strong separation of TF-GridNet which largely closes the gap between previous methods and oracle separation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
MeetEval: A Toolkit for Computation of Word Error Rates for Meeting Transcription Systems
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
MeetEval is an open-source toolkit to evaluate all kinds of meeting transcription systems. It provides a unified interface for the computation of commonly used Word Error Rates (WERs), specifically cpWER, ORC-WER and MIMO-WER along other WER definitions. We extend the cpWER computation by a temporal constraint to ensure that only words are identified as correct when the temporal alignment is plaus…
▽ More
MeetEval is an open-source toolkit to evaluate all kinds of meeting transcription systems. It provides a unified interface for the computation of commonly used Word Error Rates (WERs), specifically cpWER, ORC-WER and MIMO-WER along other WER definitions. We extend the cpWER computation by a temporal constraint to ensure that only words are identified as correct when the temporal alignment is plausible. This leads to a better quality of the matching of the hypothesis string to the reference string that more closely resembles the actual transcription quality, and a system is penalized if it provides poor time annotations. Since word-level timing information is often not available, we present a way to approximate exact word-level timings from segment-level timings (e.g., a sentence) and show that the approximation leads to a similar WER as a matching with exact word-level annotations. At the same time, the time constraint leads to a speedup of the matching algorithm, which outweighs the additional overhead caused by processing the time stamps.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2024; v1 submitted 21 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
On Word Error Rate Definitions and their Efficient Computation for Multi-Speaker Speech Recognition Systems
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
We propose a general framework to compute the word error rate (WER) of ASR systems that process recordings containing multiple speakers at their input and that produce multiple output word sequences (MIMO). Such ASR systems are typically required, e.g., for meeting transcription. We provide an efficient implementation based on a dynamic programming search in a multi-dimensional Levenshtein distanc…
▽ More
We propose a general framework to compute the word error rate (WER) of ASR systems that process recordings containing multiple speakers at their input and that produce multiple output word sequences (MIMO). Such ASR systems are typically required, e.g., for meeting transcription. We provide an efficient implementation based on a dynamic programming search in a multi-dimensional Levenshtein distance tensor under the constraint that a reference utterance must be matched consistently with one hypothesis output. This also results in an efficient implementation of the ORC WER which previously suffered from exponential complexity. We give an overview of commonly used WER definitions for multi-speaker scenarios and show that they are specializations of the above MIMO WER tuned to particular application scenarios. We conclude with a discussion of the pros and cons of the various WER definitions and a recommendation when to use which.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023; v1 submitted 29 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
MMS-MSG: A Multi-purpose Multi-Speaker Mixture Signal Generator
Authors:
Tobias Cord-Landwehr,
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
The scope of speech enhancement has changed from a monolithic view of single, independent tasks, to a joint processing of complex conversational speech recordings. Training and evaluation of these single tasks requires synthetic data with access to intermediate signals that is as close as possible to the evaluation scenario. As such data often is not available, many works instead use specialized d…
▽ More
The scope of speech enhancement has changed from a monolithic view of single, independent tasks, to a joint processing of complex conversational speech recordings. Training and evaluation of these single tasks requires synthetic data with access to intermediate signals that is as close as possible to the evaluation scenario. As such data often is not available, many works instead use specialized databases for the training of each system component, e.g WSJ0-mix for source separation. We present a Multi-purpose Multi-Speaker Mixture Signal Generator (MMS-MSG) for generating a variety of speech mixture signals based on any speech corpus, ranging from classical anechoic mixtures (e.g., WSJ0-mix) over reverberant mixtures (e.g., SMS-WSJ) to meeting-style data. Its highly modular and flexible structure allows for the simulation of diverse environments and dynamic mixing, while simultaneously enabling an easy extension and modification to generate new scenarios and mixture types. These meetings can be used for prototy**, evaluation, or training purposes. We provide example evaluation data and baseline results for meetings based on the WSJ corpus. Further, we demonstrate the usefulness for realistic scenarios by using MMS-MSG to provide training data for the LibriCSS database.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Utterance-by-utterance overlap-aware neural diarization with Graph-PIT
Authors:
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Thilo von Neumann,
Marc Delcroix,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Recent speaker diarization studies showed that integration of end-to-end neural diarization (EEND) and clustering-based diarization is a promising approach for achieving state-of-the-art performance on various tasks. Such an approach first divides an observed signal into fixed-length segments, then performs {\it segment-level} local diarization based on an EEND module, and merges the segment-level…
▽ More
Recent speaker diarization studies showed that integration of end-to-end neural diarization (EEND) and clustering-based diarization is a promising approach for achieving state-of-the-art performance on various tasks. Such an approach first divides an observed signal into fixed-length segments, then performs {\it segment-level} local diarization based on an EEND module, and merges the segment-level results via clustering to form a final global diarization result. The segmentation is done to limit the number of speakers in each segment since the current EEND cannot handle a large number of speakers. In this paper, we argue that such an approach involving the segmentation has several issues; for example, it inevitably faces a dilemma that larger segment sizes increase both the context available for enhancing the performance and the number of speakers for the local EEND module to handle. To resolve such a problem, this paper proposes a novel framework that performs diarization without segmentation. However, it can still handle challenging data containing many speakers and a significant amount of overlap** speech. The proposed method can take an entire meeting for inference and perform {\it utterance-by-utterance} diarization that clusters utterance activities in terms of speakers. To this end, we leverage a neural network training scheme called Graph-PIT proposed recently for neural source separation. Experiments with simulated active-meeting-like data and CALLHOME data show the superiority of the proposed approach over the conventional methods.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A Meeting Transcription System for an Ad-Hoc Acoustic Sensor Network
Authors:
Tobias Gburrek,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Thilo von Neumann,
Tobias Cord-Landwehr,
Joerg Schmalenstroeer,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
We propose a system that transcribes the conversation of a typical meeting scenario that is captured by a set of initially unsynchronized microphone arrays at unknown positions. It consists of subsystems for signal synchronization, including both sampling rate and sampling time offset estimation, diarization based on speaker and microphone array position estimation, multi-channel speech enhancemen…
▽ More
We propose a system that transcribes the conversation of a typical meeting scenario that is captured by a set of initially unsynchronized microphone arrays at unknown positions. It consists of subsystems for signal synchronization, including both sampling rate and sampling time offset estimation, diarization based on speaker and microphone array position estimation, multi-channel speech enhancement, and automatic speech recognition. With the estimated diarization information, a spatial mixture model is initialized that is used to estimate beamformer coefficients for source separation. Simulations show that the speech recognition accuracy can be improved by synchronizing and combining multiple distributed microphone arrays compared to a single compact microphone array. Furthermore, the proposed informed initialization of the spatial mixture model delivers a clear performance advantage over random initialization.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
An Initialization Scheme for Meeting Separation with Spatial Mixture Models
Authors:
Christoph Boeddeker,
Tobias Cord-Landwehr,
Thilo von Neumann,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Spatial mixture model (SMM) supported acoustic beamforming has been extensively used for the separation of simultaneously active speakers. However, it has hardly been considered for the separation of meeting data, that are characterized by long recordings and only partially overlap** speech. In this contribution, we show that the fact that often only a single speaker is active can be utilized fo…
▽ More
Spatial mixture model (SMM) supported acoustic beamforming has been extensively used for the separation of simultaneously active speakers. However, it has hardly been considered for the separation of meeting data, that are characterized by long recordings and only partially overlap** speech. In this contribution, we show that the fact that often only a single speaker is active can be utilized for a clever initialization of an SMM that employs time-varying class priors. In experiments on LibriCSS we show that the proposed initialization scheme achieves a significantly lower Word Error Rate (WER) on a downstream speech recognition task than a random initialization of the class probabilities by drawing from a Dirichlet distribution. With the only requirement that the number of speakers has to be known, we obtain a WER of 5.9 %, which is comparable to the best reported WER on this data set. Furthermore, the estimated speaker activity from the mixture model serves as a diarization based on spatial information.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Monaural source separation: From anechoic to reverberant environments
Authors:
Tobias Cord-Landwehr,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Thilo von Neumann,
Catalin Zorila,
Rama Doddipatla,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Impressive progress in neural network-based single-channel speech source separation has been made in recent years. But those improvements have been mostly reported on anechoic data, a situation that is hardly met in practice. Taking the SepFormer as a starting point, which achieves state-of-the-art performance on anechoic mixtures, we gradually modify it to optimize its performance on reverberant…
▽ More
Impressive progress in neural network-based single-channel speech source separation has been made in recent years. But those improvements have been mostly reported on anechoic data, a situation that is hardly met in practice. Taking the SepFormer as a starting point, which achieves state-of-the-art performance on anechoic mixtures, we gradually modify it to optimize its performance on reverberant mixtures. Although this leads to a word error rate improvement by 7 percentage points compared to the standard SepFormer implementation, the system ends up with only marginally better performance than a PIT-BLSTM separation system, that is optimized with rather straightforward means. This is surprising and at the same time sobering, challenging the practical usefulness of many improvements reported in recent years for monaural source separation on nonreverberant data.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2022; v1 submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
SA-SDR: A novel loss function for separation of meeting style data
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Many state-of-the-art neural network-based source separation systems use the averaged Signal-to-Distortion Ratio (SDR) as a training objective function. The basic SDR is, however, undefined if the network reconstructs the reference signal perfectly or if the reference signal contains silence, e.g., when a two-output separator processes a single-speaker recording. Many modifications to the plain SD…
▽ More
Many state-of-the-art neural network-based source separation systems use the averaged Signal-to-Distortion Ratio (SDR) as a training objective function. The basic SDR is, however, undefined if the network reconstructs the reference signal perfectly or if the reference signal contains silence, e.g., when a two-output separator processes a single-speaker recording. Many modifications to the plain SDR have been proposed that trade-off between making the loss more robust and distorting its value. We propose to switch from a mean over the SDRs of each individual output channel to a global SDR over all output channels at the same time, which we call source-aggregated SDR (SA-SDR). This makes the loss robust against silence and perfect reconstruction as long as at least one reference signal is not silent. We experimentally show that our proposed SA-SDR is more stable and preferable over other well-known modifications when processing meeting-style data that typically contains many silent or single-speaker regions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2022; v1 submitted 29 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Graph-PIT: Generalized permutation invariant training for continuous separation of arbitrary numbers of speakers
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Automatic transcription of meetings requires handling of overlapped speech, which calls for continuous speech separation (CSS) systems. The uPIT criterion was proposed for utterance-level separation with neural networks and introduces the constraint that the total number of speakers must not exceed the number of output channels. When processing meeting-like data in a segment-wise manner, i.e., by…
▽ More
Automatic transcription of meetings requires handling of overlapped speech, which calls for continuous speech separation (CSS) systems. The uPIT criterion was proposed for utterance-level separation with neural networks and introduces the constraint that the total number of speakers must not exceed the number of output channels. When processing meeting-like data in a segment-wise manner, i.e., by separating overlap** segments independently and stitching adjacent segments to continuous output streams, this constraint has to be fulfilled for any segment. In this contribution, we show that this constraint can be significantly relaxed. We propose a novel graph-based PIT criterion, which casts the assignment of utterances to output channels in a graph coloring problem. It only requires that the number of concurrently active speakers must not exceed the number of output channels. As a consequence, the system can process an arbitrary number of speakers and arbitrarily long segments and thus can handle more diverse scenarios. Further, the stitching algorithm for obtaining a consistent output order in neighboring segments is of less importance and can even be eliminated completely, not the least reducing the computational effort. Experiments on meeting-style WSJ data show improvements in recognition performance over using the uPIT criterion.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2021; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Speeding Up Permutation Invariant Training for Source Separation
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Marc Delcroix,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Permutation invariant training (PIT) is a widely used training criterion for neural network-based source separation, used for both utterance-level separation with utterance-level PIT (uPIT) and separation of long recordings with the recently proposed Graph-PIT. When implemented naively, both suffer from an exponential complexity in the number of utterances to separate, rendering them unusable for…
▽ More
Permutation invariant training (PIT) is a widely used training criterion for neural network-based source separation, used for both utterance-level separation with utterance-level PIT (uPIT) and separation of long recordings with the recently proposed Graph-PIT. When implemented naively, both suffer from an exponential complexity in the number of utterances to separate, rendering them unusable for large numbers of speakers or long realistic recordings. We present a decomposition of the PIT criterion into the computation of a matrix and a strictly monotonously increasing function so that the permutation or assignment problem can be solved efficiently with several search algorithms. The Hungarian algorithm can be used for uPIT and we introduce various algorithms for the Graph-PIT assignment problem to reduce the complexity to be polynomial in the number of utterances.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Multi-path RNN for hierarchical modeling of long sequential data and its application to speaker stream separation
Authors:
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Thilo von Neumann,
Marc Delcroix,
Tomohiro Nakatani,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Recently, the source separation performance was greatly improved by time-domain audio source separation based on dual-path recurrent neural network (DPRNN). DPRNN is a simple but effective model for a long sequential data. While DPRNN is quite efficient in modeling a sequential data of the length of an utterance, i.e., about 5 to 10 second data, it is harder to apply it to longer sequences such as…
▽ More
Recently, the source separation performance was greatly improved by time-domain audio source separation based on dual-path recurrent neural network (DPRNN). DPRNN is a simple but effective model for a long sequential data. While DPRNN is quite efficient in modeling a sequential data of the length of an utterance, i.e., about 5 to 10 second data, it is harder to apply it to longer sequences such as whole conversations consisting of multiple utterances. It is simply because, in such a case, the number of time steps consumed by its internal module called inter-chunk RNN becomes extremely large. To mitigate this problem, this paper proposes a multi-path RNN (MPRNN), a generalized version of DPRNN, that models the input data in a hierarchical manner. In the MPRNN framework, the input data is represented at several (>3) time-resolutions, each of which is modeled by a specific RNN sub-module. For example, the RNN sub-module that deals with the finest resolution may model temporal relationship only within a phoneme, while the RNN sub-module handling the most coarse resolution may capture only the relationship between utterances such as speaker information. We perform experiments using simulated dialogue-like mixtures and show that MPRNN has greater model capacity, and it outperforms the current state-of-the-art DPRNN framework especially in online processing scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Multi-talker ASR for an unknown number of sources: Joint training of source counting, separation and ASR
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Lukas Drude,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Marc Delcroix,
Tomohiro Nakatani,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Most approaches to multi-talker overlapped speech separation and recognition assume that the number of simultaneously active speakers is given, but in realistic situations, it is typically unknown. To cope with this, we extend an iterative speech extraction system with mechanisms to count the number of sources and combine it with a single-talker speech recognizer to form the first end-to-end multi…
▽ More
Most approaches to multi-talker overlapped speech separation and recognition assume that the number of simultaneously active speakers is given, but in realistic situations, it is typically unknown. To cope with this, we extend an iterative speech extraction system with mechanisms to count the number of sources and combine it with a single-talker speech recognizer to form the first end-to-end multi-talker automatic speech recognition system for an unknown number of active speakers. Our experiments show very promising performance in counting accuracy, source separation and speech recognition on simulated clean mixtures from WSJ0-2mix and WSJ0-3mix. Among others, we set a new state-of-the-art word error rate on the WSJ0-2mix database. Furthermore, our system generalizes well to a larger number of speakers than it ever saw during training, as shown in experiments with the WSJ0-4mix database.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2020; v1 submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
End-to-end training of time domain audio separation and recognition
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Lukas Drude,
Christoph Boeddeker,
Marc Delcroix,
Tomohiro Nakatani,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
The rising interest in single-channel multi-speaker speech separation sparked development of End-to-End (E2E) approaches to multi-speaker speech recognition. However, up until now, state-of-the-art neural network-based time domain source separation has not yet been combined with E2E speech recognition. We here demonstrate how to combine a separation module based on a Convolutional Time domain Audi…
▽ More
The rising interest in single-channel multi-speaker speech separation sparked development of End-to-End (E2E) approaches to multi-speaker speech recognition. However, up until now, state-of-the-art neural network-based time domain source separation has not yet been combined with E2E speech recognition. We here demonstrate how to combine a separation module based on a Convolutional Time domain Audio Separation Network (Conv-TasNet) with an E2E speech recognizer and how to train such a model jointly by distributing it over multiple GPUs or by approximating truncated back-propagation for the convolutional front-end. To put this work into perspective and illustrate the complexity of the design space, we provide a compact overview of single-channel multi-speaker recognition systems. Our experiments show a word error rate of 11.0% on WSJ0-2mix and indicate that our joint time domain model can yield substantial improvements over cascade DNN-HMM and monolithic E2E frequency domain systems proposed so far.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2020; v1 submitted 18 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
All-neural online source separation, counting, and diarization for meeting analysis
Authors:
Thilo von Neumann,
Keisuke Kinoshita,
Marc Delcroix,
Shoko Araki,
Tomohiro Nakatani,
Reinhold Haeb-Umbach
Abstract:
Automatic meeting analysis comprises the tasks of speaker counting, speaker diarization, and the separation of overlapped speech, followed by automatic speech recognition. This all has to be carried out on arbitrarily long sessions and, ideally, in an online or block-online manner. While significant progress has been made on individual tasks, this paper presents for the first time an all-neural ap…
▽ More
Automatic meeting analysis comprises the tasks of speaker counting, speaker diarization, and the separation of overlapped speech, followed by automatic speech recognition. This all has to be carried out on arbitrarily long sessions and, ideally, in an online or block-online manner. While significant progress has been made on individual tasks, this paper presents for the first time an all-neural approach to simultaneous speaker counting, diarization and source separation. The NN-based estimator operates in a block-online fashion and tracks speakers even if they remain silent for a number of time blocks, thus learning a stable output order for the separated sources. The neural network is recurrent over time as well as over the number of sources. The simulation experiments show that state of the art separation performance is achieved, while at the same time delivering good diarization and source counting results. It even generalizes well to an unseen large number of blocks.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.