Showing 1–21 of 21 results for author: Van Hentenryck, P

Strong Mixed-Integer Formulations for Transmission Expansion Planning with FACTS Devices

Authors: Kevin Wu, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Transmission Network Expansion Planning (TNEP) problems find the most economical way of expanding a given grid given long-term growth in generation capacity and demand patterns. The recent development of Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS) devices, which can dynamically re-route power flows by adjusting individual branches' impedance, call for their integration into TNEP problems. However, the… ▽ More Transmission Network Expansion Planning (TNEP) problems find the most economical way of expanding a given grid given long-term growth in generation capacity and demand patterns. The recent development of Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS) devices, which can dynamically re-route power flows by adjusting individual branches' impedance, call for their integration into TNEP problems. However, the resulting TNEP+FACTS formulations are significantly harder to solve than traditional TNEP instances, due to the nonlinearity of FACTS behavior. This paper proposes a new mixed-integer formulation for TNEP+FACTS, which directly represents the change in power flow induced by individual FACTS devices. The proposed formulation uses an extended formulation and facet-defining constraints, which are stronger than big-M constraints typically used in the literature. The paper conducts numerical experiments on a synthetic model of the Texas system with high renewable penetration. The results demonstrate the computational superiority of the proposed approach, which achieves a 4x speedup over state-of-the-art formulations, and highlight the potential of FACTS devices to mitigate congestion. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 3 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Optimization-based Learning for Dynamic Load Planning in Trucking Service Networks

Authors: Ritesh Ojha, Wenbo Chen, Hanyu Zhang, Reem Khir, Alan Erera, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The load planning problem is a critical challenge in service network design for parcel carriers: it decides how many trailers to assign for dispatch over time between pairs of terminals. Another key challenge is to determine a flow plan, which specifies how parcel volumes are assigned to planned loads. This paper considers the Outbound Load Planning Problem (OLPP) that considers flow and load plan… ▽ More The load planning problem is a critical challenge in service network design for parcel carriers: it decides how many trailers to assign for dispatch over time between pairs of terminals. Another key challenge is to determine a flow plan, which specifies how parcel volumes are assigned to planned loads. This paper considers the Outbound Load Planning Problem (OLPP) that considers flow and load planning challenges jointly in order to adjust loads and flows as the demand forecast changes over time before the day of operations in a terminal. The paper aims at develo** a decision-support tool to inform planners making these decisions at terminals across the network. The paper formulates the OLPP as a mixed-integer programming model and shows that it admits a large number of symmetries in a network where each commodity can be routed through primary and alternate terminals. As a result, an optimization solver may return fundamentally different solutions to closely related problems, confusing planners and reducing trust in optimization. To remedy this limitation, this paper proposes a lexicographical optimization approach that eliminates those symmetries by generating optimal solutions staying close to a reference plan. Moreover, this paper designs an optimization proxy that addresses the computational challenges of the optimization model. The optimization proxy combines a machine-learning model and a repair procedure to find near-optimal solutions that satisfy real-time constraints imposed by planners in the loop. An extensive computational study on industrial instances shows that the optimization proxy is orders of magnitude faster for generating solutions that are consistent with each other. The proposed approach also demonstrates the benefits of the OLPP for load consolidation and the significant savings obtained from combining machine learning and optimization. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2024; v1 submitted 8 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Just-In-Time Learning for Operational Risk Assessment in Power Grids

Authors: Oliver Stover, Pranav Karve, Sankaran Mahadevan, Wenbo Chen, Haoruo Zhao, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: In a grid with a significant share of renewable generation, operators will need additional tools to evaluate the operational risk due to the increased volatility in load and generation. The computational requirements of the forward uncertainty propagation problem, which must solve numerous security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED) optimizations, is a major barrier for such real-time risk asses… ▽ More In a grid with a significant share of renewable generation, operators will need additional tools to evaluate the operational risk due to the increased volatility in load and generation. The computational requirements of the forward uncertainty propagation problem, which must solve numerous security-constrained economic dispatch (SCED) optimizations, is a major barrier for such real-time risk assessment. This paper proposes a Just-In-Time Risk Assessment Learning Framework (JITRALF) as an alternative. JITRALF trains risk surrogates, one for each hour in the day, using Machine Learning (ML) to predict the quantities needed to estimate risk, without explicitly solving the SCED problem. This significantly reduces the computational burden of the forward uncertainty propagation and allows for fast, real-time risk estimation. The paper also proposes a novel, asymmetric loss function and shows that models trained using the asymmetric loss perform better than those using symmetric loss functions. JITRALF is evaluated on the French transmission system for assessing the risk of insufficient operating reserves, the risk of load shedding, and the expected operating cost. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Bucketized Active Sampling for Learning ACOPF

Authors: Michael Klamkin, Mathieu Tanneau, Terrence W. K. Mak, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper considers optimization proxies for Optimal Power Flow (OPF), i.e., machine-learning models that approximate the input/output relationship of OPF. Recent work has focused on showing that such proxies can be of high fidelity. However, their training requires significant data, each instance necessitating the (offline) solving of an OPF for a sample of the input distribution. To meet the re… ▽ More This paper considers optimization proxies for Optimal Power Flow (OPF), i.e., machine-learning models that approximate the input/output relationship of OPF. Recent work has focused on showing that such proxies can be of high fidelity. However, their training requires significant data, each instance necessitating the (offline) solving of an OPF for a sample of the input distribution. To meet the requirements of market-clearing applications, this paper proposes Bucketized Active Sampling (BAS), a novel active learning framework that aims at training the best possible OPF proxy within a time limit. BAS partitions the input distribution into buckets and uses an acquisition function to determine where to sample next. By applying the same partitioning to the validation set, BAS leverages labeled validation samples in the selection of unlabeled samples. BAS also relies on an adaptive learning rate that increases and decreases over time. Experimental results demonstrate the benefits of BAS. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2023; v1 submitted 15 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Learning Regionally Decentralized AC Optimal Power Flows with ADMM

Authors: Terrence W. K. Mak, Minas Chatzos, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: One potential future for the next generation of smart grids is the use of decentralized optimization algorithms and secured communications for coordinating renewable generation (e.g., wind/solar), dispatchable devices (e.g., coal/gas/nuclear generations), demand response, battery & storage facilities, and topology optimization. The Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM) has been widely… ▽ More One potential future for the next generation of smart grids is the use of decentralized optimization algorithms and secured communications for coordinating renewable generation (e.g., wind/solar), dispatchable devices (e.g., coal/gas/nuclear generations), demand response, battery & storage facilities, and topology optimization. The Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM) has been widely used in the community to address such decentralized optimization problems and, in particular, the AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF). This paper studies how machine learning may help in speeding up the convergence of ADMM for solving AC-OPF. It proposes a novel decentralized machine-learning approach, namely ML-ADMM, where each agent uses deep learning to learn the consensus parameters on the coupling branches. The paper also explores the idea of learning only from ADMM runs that exhibit high-quality convergence properties, and proposes filtering mechanisms to select these runs. Experimental results on test cases based on the French system demonstrate the potential of the approach in speeding up the convergence of ADMM significantly. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2023; v1 submitted 8 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 14 pages

Learning Optimization Proxies for Large-Scale Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch

Authors: Wenbo Chen, Seonho Park, Mathieu Tanneau, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch (SCED) is a fundamental optimization model for Transmission System Operators (TSO) to clear real-time energy markets while ensuring reliable operations of power grids. In a context of growing operational uncertainty, due to increased penetration of renewable generators and distributed energy resources, operators must continuously monitor risk in real-time… ▽ More The Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch (SCED) is a fundamental optimization model for Transmission System Operators (TSO) to clear real-time energy markets while ensuring reliable operations of power grids. In a context of growing operational uncertainty, due to increased penetration of renewable generators and distributed energy resources, operators must continuously monitor risk in real-time, i.e., they must quickly assess the system's behavior under various changes in load and renewable production. Unfortunately, systematically solving an optimization problem for each such scenario is not practical given the tight constraints of real-time operations. To overcome this limitation, this paper proposes to learn an optimization proxy for SCED, i.e., a Machine Learning (ML) model that can predict an optimal solution for SCED in milliseconds. Motivated by a principled analysis of the market-clearing optimizations of MISO, the paper proposes a novel ML pipeline that addresses the main challenges of learning SCED solutions, i.e., the variability in load, renewable output and production costs, as well as the combinatorial structure of commitment decisions. A novel Classification-Then-Regression architecture is also proposed, to further capture the behavior of SCED solutions. Numerical experiments are reported on the French transmission system, and demonstrate the approach's ability to produce, within a time frame that is compatible with real-time operations, accurate optimization proxies that produce relative errors below $0.6\%$. △ Less

Submitted 26 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: The paper is the extension version of the paper submitted to PSCC2022

Spatial Network Decomposition for Fast and Scalable AC-OPF Learning

Authors: Minas Chatzos, Terrence W. K. Mak, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper proposes a novel machine-learning approach for predicting AC-OPF solutions that features a fast and scalable training. It is motivated by the two critical considerations: (1) the fact that topology optimization and the stochasticity induced by renewable energy sources may lead to fundamentally different AC-OPF instances; and (2) the significant training time needed by existing machine-l… ▽ More This paper proposes a novel machine-learning approach for predicting AC-OPF solutions that features a fast and scalable training. It is motivated by the two critical considerations: (1) the fact that topology optimization and the stochasticity induced by renewable energy sources may lead to fundamentally different AC-OPF instances; and (2) the significant training time needed by existing machine-learning approaches for predicting AC-OPF. The proposed approach is a 2-stage methodology that exploits a spatial decomposition of the power network that is viewed as a set of regions. The first stage learns to predict the flows and voltages on the buses and lines coupling the regions, and the second stage trains, in parallel, the machine-learning models for each region. Experimental results on the French transmission system (up to 6,700 buses and 9,000 lines) demonstrate the potential of the approach. Within a short training time, the approach predicts AC-OPF solutions with very high fidelity and minor constraint violations, producing significant improvements over the state-of-the-art. The results also show that the predictions can seed a load flow optimization to return a feasible solution within 0.03% of the AC-OPF objective, while reducing running times significantly. △ Less

Submitted 17 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

High-Fidelity Machine Learning Approximations of Large-Scale Optimal Power Flow

Authors: Minas Chatzos, Ferdinando Fioretto, Terrence W. K. Mak, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF) is a key building block in many power system applications. It determines generator setpoints at minimal cost that meet the power demands while satisfying the underlying physical and operational constraints. It is non-convex and NP-hard, and computationally challenging for large-scale power systems. Motivated by the increased stochasticity in generation schedules… ▽ More The AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF) is a key building block in many power system applications. It determines generator setpoints at minimal cost that meet the power demands while satisfying the underlying physical and operational constraints. It is non-convex and NP-hard, and computationally challenging for large-scale power systems. Motivated by the increased stochasticity in generation schedules and increasing penetration of renewable sources, this paper explores a deep learning approach to deliver highly efficient and accurate approximations to the AC-OPF. In particular, the paper proposes an integration of deep neural networks and Lagrangian duality to capture the physical and operational constraints. The resulting model, called OPF-DNN, is evaluated on real case studies from the French transmission system, with up to 3,400 buses and 4,500 lines. Computational results show that OPF-DNN produces highly accurate AC-OPF approximations whose costs are within 0.01% of optimality. OPF-DNN generates, in milliseconds, solutions that capture the problem constraints with high fidelity. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Electricity-Aware Bid Format for Heat Commitment and Dispatch

Authors: Lesia Mitridati, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Jalal Kazempour

Abstract: Coordination between heat and electricity markets is essential to achieve a cost-effective and efficient operation of the overall energy system. In the current sequential market practice, the heat market is cleared before the electricity market, and has no insight into the impacts of heat dispatch on the electricity market. While preserving this sequential practice, this paper introduces an ``elec… ▽ More Coordination between heat and electricity markets is essential to achieve a cost-effective and efficient operation of the overall energy system. In the current sequential market practice, the heat market is cleared before the electricity market, and has no insight into the impacts of heat dispatch on the electricity market. While preserving this sequential practice, this paper introduces an ``electricity-aware'' bid format for the coordination of heat and electricity systems. This novel market mechanism defines heat bids conditionally on day-ahead electricity prices. Prior to clearing heat and electricity markets, the proposed bid selection mechanism selects the ``valid'' bids which minimize the operating cost of the heat system, while anticipating heat and electricity market clearing.} This mechanism is modeled as a trilevel optimization problem, which we recast as a mixed-integer linear program using a lexicographic function. We use a realistic case study based on the Danish electricity and heat system, and show that the proposed bid selection mechanism yields a 4.5\% reduction in total operating cost of heat and electricity systems compared to the existing market-clearing procedure, while reducing the financial losses of combined heat and power plants and heat pumps due to invalid bids by up to 20.3 million euros. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 6 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1910.08617

Differentially Private Optimal Power Flow for Distribution Grids

Authors: Vladimir Dvorkin, Ferdinando Fioretto, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Pierre Pinson, Jalal Kazempour

Abstract: Although distribution grid customers are obliged to share their consumption data with distribution system operators (DSOs), a possible leakage of this data is often disregarded in operational routines of DSOs. This paper introduces a privacy-preserving optimal power flow (OPF) mechanism for distribution grids that secures customer privacy from unauthorised access to OPF solutions, e.g., current an… ▽ More Although distribution grid customers are obliged to share their consumption data with distribution system operators (DSOs), a possible leakage of this data is often disregarded in operational routines of DSOs. This paper introduces a privacy-preserving optimal power flow (OPF) mechanism for distribution grids that secures customer privacy from unauthorised access to OPF solutions, e.g., current and voltage measurements. The mechanism is based on the framework of differential privacy that allows to control the participation risks of individuals in a dataset by applying a carefully calibrated noise to the output of a computation. Unlike existing private mechanisms, this mechanism does not apply the noise to the optimization parameters or its result. Instead, it optimizes OPF variables as affine functions of the random noise, which weakens the correlation between the grid loads and OPF variables. To ensure feasibility of the randomized OPF solution, the mechanism makes use of chance constraints enforced on the grid limits. The mechanism is further extended to control the optimality loss induced by the random noise, as well as the variance of OPF variables. The paper shows that the differentially private OPF solution does not leak customer loads up to specified parameters. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2020; v1 submitted 8 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

PPSM: A Privacy-Preserving Stackelberg Mechanism: Privacy Guarantees for the Coordination of Sequential Electricity and Gas Markets

Authors: Ferdinando Fioretto, Lesia Mitridati, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper introduces a differentially private mechanism to protect the information exchanged during the coordination of the sequential market-clearing of electricity and natural gas systems. The coordination between these sequential and interdependent markets represents a classic Stackelberg game and relies on the exchange of sensitive information between the system agents, including the supply a… ▽ More This paper introduces a differentially private mechanism to protect the information exchanged during the coordination of the sequential market-clearing of electricity and natural gas systems. The coordination between these sequential and interdependent markets represents a classic Stackelberg game and relies on the exchange of sensitive information between the system agents, including the supply and demand bids in each market or the characteristics of the systems. The paper is motivated by the observation that traditional differential privacy mechanisms are unsuitable for the problem of interest: The perturbation introduced by these mechanisms fundamentally changes the underlying optimization problem and even leads to unsatisfiable instances. To remedy such limitation, the paper introduces the Privacy-Preserving Stackelberg Mechanism (PPSM), a framework that enforces the notions of consistency and fidelity of the privacy-preserving information to the original problem objective. The PPSM has strong properties: It complies with the notion of differential privacy and ensures that the outcomes of the privacy-preserving coordination mechanisms are close-to-optimality for each agent. The fidelity property is analyzed by providing theoretical guarantees on the cost of privacy of PPSM and experimental results on several gas and electricity market benchmarks based on a real case study demonstrate the effectiveness of the approach. △ Less

Submitted 22 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Optimization Models for Estimating Transit Network Origin-Destination Flows with AVL/APC Data

Authors: Xinyu Liu, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Xilei Zhao

Abstract: With the increasing adoption of Automatic Vehicle Location (AVL) and Automatic Passenger Count (APC) technologies by transit agencies, a massive amount of time-stamped and location-based passenger boarding and alighting count data can be collected on a continuous basis. The availability of such large-scale transit data offers new opportunities to produce estimates for Origin-Destination (O-D) flow… ▽ More With the increasing adoption of Automatic Vehicle Location (AVL) and Automatic Passenger Count (APC) technologies by transit agencies, a massive amount of time-stamped and location-based passenger boarding and alighting count data can be collected on a continuous basis. The availability of such large-scale transit data offers new opportunities to produce estimates for Origin-Destination (O-D) flows, hel** inform transportation planning and transit management. However, the state-of-the-art methodologies for AVL/APC data analysis mostly tackle the O-D flow estimation problem within routes and barely infer the transfer activities across the entire transit network. This paper proposes three optimization models to identify transfers and approximate network-level O-D flows by minimizing the deviations between estimated and observed proportions or counts of transferring passengers: A Quadratic Integer Program (QIP), a feasible rounding procedure for the Quadratic Convex Programming (QCP) relaxation of the QIP, and an Integer Program (IP). The inputs of the models are readily available by applying the various route-level flow estimation algorithms to the automatically collected AVL/APC data and the output of the models is a network O-D estimation at varying geographical resolutions. The optimization models were evaluated on a case study for Ann Arbor-Ypsilanti area in Michigan. The IP model outperforms the QCP approach in terms of accuracy and remains tractable from an efficiency standpoint, contrary to the QIP. Its estimated O-D matrix achieves an R-Squared metric of 95.57% at the Traffic Analysis Zone level and 92.39% at the stop level, compared to the ground-truth estimates inferred from the state-of-practice trip-chaining methods. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 5 figures

A Bid-Validity Mechanism for Sequential Heat and Electricity Market Clearing

Authors: Lesia Mitridati, Pascal Van Hentenryck, jalal Kazempour

Abstract: Coordinating the operation of units at the interface between heat and electricity systems, such as combined heat and power plants and heat pumps, is essential to reduce inefficiencies in each system and help achieve a cost-effective and efficient operation of the overall energy system. These energy systems are currently operated by sequential markets, which interface the technical and economic asp… ▽ More Coordinating the operation of units at the interface between heat and electricity systems, such as combined heat and power plants and heat pumps, is essential to reduce inefficiencies in each system and help achieve a cost-effective and efficient operation of the overall energy system. These energy systems are currently operated by sequential markets, which interface the technical and economic aspects of the systems. In that context, this study introduces an electricity-aware heat unit commitment model, which seeks to optimize the operation of the heat system while accounting for the techno-economic interdependencies between heat and electricity markets. These interdependencies are represented by bid-validity constraints, which model the linkage between the heat and electricity outputs and costs of combined heat and power plants and heat pumps. This approach also constitutes a novel market mechanism for the coordination of heat and electricity systems, which defines heat bids conditionally on electricity prices. Additionally, a tractable reformulation of the resulting trilevel optimization problem as a mixed integer linear program is proposed. Finally, it is shown on a case study that the proposed model yields a 23% reduction in total operating cost and a 6% reduction in wind curtailment compared to a traditional decoupled unit commitment model. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Privacy-Preserving Obfuscation for Distributed Power Systems

Authors: Terrence W. K. Mak, Ferdinando Fioretto, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: This paper considers the problem of releasing privacy-preserving load data of a decentralized operated power system. The paper focuses on data used to solve Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problems and proposes a distributed algorithm that complies with the notion of Differential Privacy, a strong privacy framework used to bound the risk of re-identification. The problem is challenging since the applicat… ▽ More This paper considers the problem of releasing privacy-preserving load data of a decentralized operated power system. The paper focuses on data used to solve Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problems and proposes a distributed algorithm that complies with the notion of Differential Privacy, a strong privacy framework used to bound the risk of re-identification. The problem is challenging since the application of traditional differential privacy mechanisms to the load data fundamentally changes the nature of the underlying optimization problem and often leads to severe feasibility issues. The proposed differentially private distributed algorithm is based on the Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM) and guarantees that the released privacy-preserving data retains high fidelity and satisfies the AC power flow constraints. Experimental results on a variety of OPF benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of the approach. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: Total 10 pages: main body 8 pages, reference 1 page, appendix 2 pages

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Power Systems ( Volume: 35 , Issue: 2 , March 2020 )

Predicting AC Optimal Power Flows: Combining Deep Learning and Lagrangian Dual Methods

Authors: Ferdinando Fioretto, Terrence W. K. Mak, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: The Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problem is a fundamental building block for the optimization of electrical power systems. It is nonlinear and nonconvex and computes the generator setpoints for power and voltage, given a set of load demands. It is often needed to be solved repeatedly under various conditions, either in real-time or in large-scale studies. This need is further exacerbated by the increa… ▽ More The Optimal Power Flow (OPF) problem is a fundamental building block for the optimization of electrical power systems. It is nonlinear and nonconvex and computes the generator setpoints for power and voltage, given a set of load demands. It is often needed to be solved repeatedly under various conditions, either in real-time or in large-scale studies. This need is further exacerbated by the increasing stochasticity of power systems due to renewable energy sources in front and behind the meter. To address these challenges, this paper presents a deep learning approach to the OPF. The learning model exploits the information available in the prior states of the system (which is commonly available in practical applications), as well as a dual Lagrangian method to satisfy the physical and engineering constraints present in the OPF. The proposed model is evaluated on a large collection of realistic power systems. The experimental results show that its predictions are highly accurate with average errors as low as 0.2%. Additionally, the proposed approach is shown to improve the accuracy of widely adopted OPF linear DC approximation by at least two orders of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2019; v1 submitted 18 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: A version of this paper appears in AAAI 2020

Resilient Transmission Grid Design: AC Relaxation vs. DC approximation

Authors: Harsha Nagarajan, Russell Bent, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Scott Backhaus, Emre Yamangil

Abstract: As illustrated in recent years (Superstorm Sandy, the Northeast Ice Storm of 1998, etc.), extreme weather events pose an enormous threat to the electric power transmission systems and the associated socio-economic systems that depend on reliable delivery of electric power. Besides inevitable malfunction of power grid components, deliberate malicious attacks can cause high risks to the service. The… ▽ More As illustrated in recent years (Superstorm Sandy, the Northeast Ice Storm of 1998, etc.), extreme weather events pose an enormous threat to the electric power transmission systems and the associated socio-economic systems that depend on reliable delivery of electric power. Besides inevitable malfunction of power grid components, deliberate malicious attacks can cause high risks to the service. These threats motivate the need for approaches and methods that improve the resilience of power systems. In this paper, we develop a model and tractable methods for optimizing the upgrade of transmission systems through a combination of hardening existing components, adding redundant lines, switches, generators, and FACTS and phase-shifting devices. While many of these controllable components are included in traditional design (expansion planning) problems, we uniquely assess their benefits from a resiliency point of view. More importantly, perhaps, we evaluate the suitability of using state-of-the-art AC power flow relaxations versus the common DC approximation in resilience improvement studies. The resiliency model and algorithms are tested on a modified version of the RTS-96 (single area) system. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Graphical Models and Belief Propagation-hierarchy for Optimal Physics-Constrained Network Flows

Authors: Michael Chertkov, Sidhant Misra, Marc Vuffray, Dvijotham Krishnamurty, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: In this manuscript we review new ideas and first results on application of the Graphical Models approach, originated from Statistical Physics, Information Theory, Computer Science and Machine Learning, to optimization problems of network flow type with additional constraints related to the physics of the flow. We illustrate the general concepts on a number of enabling examples from power system an… ▽ More In this manuscript we review new ideas and first results on application of the Graphical Models approach, originated from Statistical Physics, Information Theory, Computer Science and Machine Learning, to optimization problems of network flow type with additional constraints related to the physics of the flow. We illustrate the general concepts on a number of enabling examples from power system and natural gas transmission (continental scale) and distribution (district scale) systems. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 28 pages, 1 figure

Graphical Models for Optimal Power Flow

Authors: Krishnamurthy Dvijotham, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Michael Chertkov, Sidhant Misra, Marc Vuffray

Abstract: Optimal power flow (OPF) is the central optimization problem in electric power grids. Although solved routinely in the course of power grid operations, it is known to be strongly NP-hard in general, and weakly NP-hard over tree networks. In this paper, we formulate the optimal power flow problem over tree networks as an inference problem over a tree-structured graphical model where the nodal varia… ▽ More Optimal power flow (OPF) is the central optimization problem in electric power grids. Although solved routinely in the course of power grid operations, it is known to be strongly NP-hard in general, and weakly NP-hard over tree networks. In this paper, we formulate the optimal power flow problem over tree networks as an inference problem over a tree-structured graphical model where the nodal variables are low-dimensional vectors. We adapt the standard dynamic programming algorithm for inference over a tree-structured graphical model to the OPF problem. Combining this with an interval discretization of the nodal variables, we develop an approximation algorithm for the OPF problem. Further, we use techniques from constraint programming (CP) to perform interval computations and adaptive bound propagation to obtain practically efficient algorithms. Compared to previous algorithms that solve OPF with optimality guarantees using convex relaxations, our approach is able to work for arbitrary distribution networks and handle mixed-integer optimization problems. Further, it can be implemented in a distributed message-passing fashion that is scalable and is suitable for "smart grid" applications like control of distributed energy resources. We evaluate our technique numerically on several benchmark networks and show that practical OPF problems can be solved effectively using this approach. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: To appear in Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on Principles and Practice of Constraint Programming (CP 2016(

Interdependent Scheduling Games

Authors: Andres Abeliuk, Haris Aziz, Gerardo Berbeglia, Serge Gaspers, Petr Kalina, Nicholas Mattei, Dominik Peters, Paul Stursberg, Pascal Van Hentenryck, Toby Walsh

Abstract: We propose a model of interdependent scheduling games in which each player controls a set of services that they schedule independently. A player is free to schedule his own services at any time; however, each of these services only begins to accrue reward for the player when all predecessor services, which may or may not be controlled by the same player, have been activated. This model, where play… ▽ More We propose a model of interdependent scheduling games in which each player controls a set of services that they schedule independently. A player is free to schedule his own services at any time; however, each of these services only begins to accrue reward for the player when all predecessor services, which may or may not be controlled by the same player, have been activated. This model, where players have interdependent services, is motivated by the problems faced in planning and coordinating large-scale infrastructures, e.g., restoring electricity and gas to residents after a natural disaster or providing medical care in a crisis when different agencies are responsible for the delivery of staff, equipment, and medicine. We undertake a game-theoretic analysis of this setting and in particular consider the issues of welfare maximization, computing best responses, Nash dynamics, and existence and computation of Nash equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Accepted to IJCAI 2016

MSC Class: 91A80; 90B35; 91B74 ACM Class: J.4; I.2; F.2.2

Network Flow and Copper Plate Relaxations for AC Transmission Systems

Authors: Carleton Coffrin, Hassan L. Hijazi, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Nonlinear convex relaxations of the power flow equations and, in particular, the Semi-Definite Programming (SDP), Convex Quadratic (QC), and Second-Order Cone (SOC) relaxations, have attracted significant interest in recent years. Thus far, little attention has been given to simpler linear relaxations of the power flow equations, which may bring significant performance gains at the cost of model a… ▽ More Nonlinear convex relaxations of the power flow equations and, in particular, the Semi-Definite Programming (SDP), Convex Quadratic (QC), and Second-Order Cone (SOC) relaxations, have attracted significant interest in recent years. Thus far, little attention has been given to simpler linear relaxations of the power flow equations, which may bring significant performance gains at the cost of model accuracy. To fill the gap, this paper develops two intuitive linear relaxations of the power flow equations, one based on classic network flow models (NF) and another inspired by copper plate approximations (CP). Theoretical results show that the proposed NF model is a relaxation of the established nonlinear SOC model and the CP model is a relaxation of the NF model. Consequently, considering the linear NF and CP relaxations alongside the established nonlinear relaxations (SDP, QC, SOC) provides a rich variety of tradeoffs between the relaxation accuracy and performance. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2015; v1 submitted 17 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: This article includes power flow background information similar to that in arXiv:1506.04773 and builds on the three bus example from arXiv:1502.07847

DistFlow Extensions for AC Transmission Systems

Authors: Carleton Coffrin, Hassan L. Hijazi, Pascal Van Hentenryck

Abstract: Convex relaxations of the power flow equations and, in particular, the Semi-Definite Programming (SDP), Second-Order Cone (SOC), and Convex DistFlow (CDF) relaxations, have attracted significant interest in recent years. Thus far, studies of the CDF model and its connection to the other relaxations have been limited to power distribution systems, which omit several parameters necessary for modelin… ▽ More Convex relaxations of the power flow equations and, in particular, the Semi-Definite Programming (SDP), Second-Order Cone (SOC), and Convex DistFlow (CDF) relaxations, have attracted significant interest in recent years. Thus far, studies of the CDF model and its connection to the other relaxations have been limited to power distribution systems, which omit several parameters necessary for modeling transmission systems. To increase the applicability of the CDF relaxation, this paper develops an extended CDF model that is suitable for transmission systems by incorporating bus shunts, line charging, and transformers. Additionally, a theoretical result shows that the established equivalence of the SOC and CDF models for distribution systems also holds in this transmission system extension. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2018; v1 submitted 27 May, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Report number: LA-UR-17-25214