-
Game-theoretic Energy Management Strategies With Interacting Agents in Formula 1
Authors:
Giona Fieni,
Marc-Philippe Neumann,
Alessandro Zanardi,
Alberto Cerofolini,
Christopher H. Onder
Abstract:
This paper presents an interaction-aware energy management optimization framework for Formula 1 racing. The considered scenario involves two agents and a drag reduction model. Strategic interactions between the agents are captured by a Stackelberg game formulated as a bilevel program. To address the computational challenges associated with bilevel optimization, the problem is reformulated as a sin…
▽ More
This paper presents an interaction-aware energy management optimization framework for Formula 1 racing. The considered scenario involves two agents and a drag reduction model. Strategic interactions between the agents are captured by a Stackelberg game formulated as a bilevel program. To address the computational challenges associated with bilevel optimization, the problem is reformulated as a single-level nonlinear program employing the Karush-Kuhn-Tucker conditions. The proposed framework contributes towards the development of new energy management and allocation strategies, caused by the presence of another agent. For instance, it provides valuable insights on how to redistribute the energy in order to optimally exploit the wake effect, showcasing a notable difference with the behavior studied in previous works. Robust energy allocations can be identified to reduce the lap time loss associated with unexpected choices of the other agent. It allows to recognize the boundary conditions for the interaction to become relevant, impacting the system's behavior, and to assess if overtaking is possible and beneficial. Overall, the framework provides a comprehensive approach for a two-agent Formula 1 racing problem with strategic interactions, offering physically intuitive and practical results.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Optimization of the Energy-Comfort Trade-Off of HVAC Systems in Electric City Buses Based on a Steady-State Model
Authors:
Fabio Widmer,
Stijn van Dooren,
Christopher H. Onder
Abstract:
The electrification of public transport vehicles offers the potential to relieve city centers of pollutant and noise emissions. Furthermore, electric buses have lower life-cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than diesel buses, particularly when operated with sustainably produced electricity. However, the heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) system can consume a significant amount of…
▽ More
The electrification of public transport vehicles offers the potential to relieve city centers of pollutant and noise emissions. Furthermore, electric buses have lower life-cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than diesel buses, particularly when operated with sustainably produced electricity. However, the heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) system can consume a significant amount of energy, thus limiting the achievable driving range. In this paper, we address the HVAC system in an electric city bus by analyzing the trade-off between the energy consumption and the thermal comfort of the passengers. We do this by develo** a dynamic thermal model for the bus cabin, which we simplify by considering it to be in steady state. We introduce a method that is able to quickly optimize the steady-state HVAC system inputs for a large number of samples representative of a year-round operation. A comparison between the results from the steady-state optimization approach and a dynamic simulation reveal small deviations in both the HVAC system power demand and achieved thermal comfort. Thus, the approximation of the system performance with a steady-state model is justified. We present two case studies to demonstrate the practical relevance of the approach. First, we show how the method can be used to compare different system designs based on a year-round performance evaluation. Second, we show how the method can be used to generate accurate setpoints for online controllers. In conclusion, this study shows that a steady-state analysis of the HVAC systems of an electric city bus is a valuable approach to evaluate and optimize its performance.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Energy Management of Hydrogen Hybrid Electric Vehicles -- A Potential Study
Authors:
David Theodor Machacek,
Nazim Ozan Yazar,
Thomas Huber,
Christopher Harald Onder
Abstract:
The hydrogen combustion engine (H$_2$ICE) is known to be able to burn H$_2$ under ultra-lean conditions, while producing no CO$_2$ emissions and extremely low engine-out NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions. Immediate goals, as for instance the upcoming EURO 7 NO$_x$ limitations, can be reached more easily as extremely low engine-out NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions facilitate the reduction of the overall…
▽ More
The hydrogen combustion engine (H$_2$ICE) is known to be able to burn H$_2$ under ultra-lean conditions, while producing no CO$_2$ emissions and extremely low engine-out NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions. Immediate goals, as for instance the upcoming EURO 7 NO$_x$ limitations, can be reached more easily as extremely low engine-out NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions facilitate the reduction of the overall tailpipe NO$_x^{\mathrm{tp}}$ emissions. In this work, the feasibility of achieving consistent reductions in NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions through the implementation of electric hybridization of an H$_2$ICE-equipped passenger car (H$_2$-HEV), combined with a dedicated energy management strategy (EMS) is discussed. In particular, the mixed H$_2$-HEV architecture is investigated and compared to a series H$_2$-HEV, a parallel H$_2$-HEV, and a base H$_2$-vehicle, which is only equipped with an H$_2$ICE. For hybrid vehicles, a low H$_2$ consumption and low NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions are conflicting objectives, the trade-off of which depends on the EMS and can be represented as a Pareto front. Overall, through the utilization of a dedicated energy management calibration, the mixed H$_2$-HEV demonstrates the capability to consistently achieve extremely low engine-out NO$_x^{\mathrm{eo}}$ emissions. For a broad range of driving missions, the mixed H$_2$-HEV is able to decrease the engine-out NO$_\mathrm{x}^\mathrm{eo}$ emissions by more than 90%, while, at the same time, the H$_2$ consumption is decreased by over 16%, compared to a comparable non-hybridized H$_2$-vehicle. These significant emission reductions are possible without having to modify the exhaust-gas aftertreatment system, or the optimization of any of the individual drivetrain components, but solely by setting the EMS calibration accordingly.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
ZTBus: A Large Dataset of Time-Resolved City Bus Driving Missions
Authors:
Fabio Widmer,
Andreas Ritter,
Christopher H. Onder
Abstract:
This paper presents the Zurich Transit Bus (ZTBus) dataset, which consists of data recorded during driving missions of electric city buses in Zurich, Switzerland. The data was collected over several years on two trolley buses as part of multiple research projects. It involves more than a thousand missions across all seasons, each mission usually covering a full day of operation. The ZTBus dataset…
▽ More
This paper presents the Zurich Transit Bus (ZTBus) dataset, which consists of data recorded during driving missions of electric city buses in Zurich, Switzerland. The data was collected over several years on two trolley buses as part of multiple research projects. It involves more than a thousand missions across all seasons, each mission usually covering a full day of operation. The ZTBus dataset contains detailed information on the vehicle's power demand, propulsion system, odometry, global position, ambient temperature, door openings, number of passengers, dispatch patterns within the public transportation network, etc. All signals are synchronized in time and include an absolute timestamp in tabular form. The dataset can be used as a foundation for a variety of studies and analyses. For example, the data can serve as a basis for simulations to estimate the performance of different public transit vehicle types, or to evaluate and optimize control strategies of hybrid electric vehicles. Furthermore, numerous influencing factors on vehicle operation, such as traffic, passenger volume, etc., can be analyzed in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2023; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Highly Efficient Year-Round Energy and Comfort Optimization of HVAC Systems in Electric City Buses
Authors:
Fabio Widmer,
Andreas Ritter,
Mathias Achermann,
Fabian Büeler,
Joshua Bagajo,
Christopher H. Onder
Abstract:
In this paper, we present a novel approach to perform highly efficient numerical simulations of the heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) system of an electric city bus. The models for this simulation are based on the assumption of a steady-state operation. We show two approaches to obtain the minimum energy requirement for a certain thermal comfort criterion under specific ambient con…
▽ More
In this paper, we present a novel approach to perform highly efficient numerical simulations of the heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) system of an electric city bus. The models for this simulation are based on the assumption of a steady-state operation. We show two approaches to obtain the minimum energy requirement for a certain thermal comfort criterion under specific ambient conditions. Due to the computationally efficient approach developed, we can evaluate the model on a large dataset of 7500 scenarios in various ambient conditions to estimate the year-round performance of the system subject to different comfort requirements. Compared to a heating strategy based on positive temperature coefficient (PTC) elements, we can thus show that a heat pump (HP) can reduce the annual mean power consumption by up to 60%. Ceiling-mounted radiant heating elements complementing a PTC heating system can reduce the annual mean power consumption by up to 10%, while they cannot improve the energy efficiency when used in conjunction with a HP. Finally, a broad sensitivity study reveals the fact that improving the HP's heating-mode coefficient of performance (COP) manifests the largest leverage in terms of mean annual power consumption. Moreover, the annual energy expenditure for cooling are around eight times smaller than those for heating. The case study considered thus reveals that the advantages of improving the COP of the cooling mode are significantly lower.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Low-level Online Control of the Formula 1 Power Unit with Feedforward Cylinder Deactivation
Authors:
Marc-Philippe Neumann,
Giona Fieni,
Camillo Balerna,
Pol Duhr,
Alberto Cerofolini,
Christopher H. Onder
Abstract:
Since 2014, the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile has prescribed a parallel hybrid powertrain for the Formula 1 race cars. The complex low-level interactions between the thermal and the electrical part represent a non-trivial and challenging system to be controlled online. We present a novel controller architecture composed of a supervisory controller for the energy management, a feedforwa…
▽ More
Since 2014, the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile has prescribed a parallel hybrid powertrain for the Formula 1 race cars. The complex low-level interactions between the thermal and the electrical part represent a non-trivial and challenging system to be controlled online. We present a novel controller architecture composed of a supervisory controller for the energy management, a feedforward cylinder deactivation controller, and a track region-dependent low-level nonlinear model predictive controller to optimize the engine actuators. Except for the nonlinear model predictive controller, the proposed controller subsystems are computationally inexpensive and are real time capable. The framework is tested and validated in a simulation environment for several realistic scenarios disturbed by driver actions or grip conditions on the track. In particular, we analyze how the control architecture deals with an unexpected gearshift trajectory during an acceleration phase. Further, we demonstrate how an increased maximum velocity trajectory impacts the online low-level controller. Our results show a suboptimality over an entire lap with respect to the benchmark solution of 49 ms and 64 ms, respectively, which we deem acceptable. Compared to the same control architecture with full knowledge of the disturbances, the suboptimality amounted to only 2 ms and 17 ms. For all case studies we show that the cylinder deactivation capability decreases the suboptimality by 7 to 8 ms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
On the Interaction between Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand and Public Transportation Systems
Authors:
Mauro Salazar,
Federico Rossi,
Maximilian Schiffer,
Christopher H. Onder,
Marco Pavone
Abstract:
In this paper we study models and coordination policies for intermodal Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand (AMoD), wherein a fleet of self-driving vehicles provides on-demand mobility jointly with public transit. Specifically, we first present a network flow model for intermodal AMoD, where we capture the coupling between AMoD and public transit and the goal is to maximize social welfare. Second, levera…
▽ More
In this paper we study models and coordination policies for intermodal Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand (AMoD), wherein a fleet of self-driving vehicles provides on-demand mobility jointly with public transit. Specifically, we first present a network flow model for intermodal AMoD, where we capture the coupling between AMoD and public transit and the goal is to maximize social welfare. Second, leveraging such a model, we design a pricing and tolling scheme that allows to achieve the social optimum under the assumption of a perfect market with selfish agents. Finally, we present a real-world case study for New York City. Our results show that the coordination between AMoD fleets and public transit can yield significant benefits compared to an AMoD system operating in isolation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2018; v1 submitted 30 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
