Evaluation of Mean Shift, ComBat, and CycleGAN for Harmonizing Brain Connectivity Matrices Across Sites
Authors:
Hanliang Xu,
Nancy R. Newlin,
Michael E. Kim,
Chenyu Gao,
Praitayini Kanakaraj,
Aravind R. Krishnan,
Lucas W. Remedios,
Nazirah Mohd Khairi,
Kimberly Pechman,
Derek Archer,
Timothy J. Hohman,
Angela L. Jefferson,
The BIOCARD Study Team,
Ivana Isgum,
Yuankai Huo,
Daniel Moyer,
Kurt G. Schilling,
Bennett A. Landman
Abstract:
Connectivity matrices derived from diffusion MRI (dMRI) provide an interpretable and generalizable way of understanding the human brain connectome. However, dMRI suffers from inter-site and between-scanner variation, which impedes analysis across datasets to improve robustness and reproducibility of results. To evaluate different harmonization approaches on connectivity matrices, we compared graph…
▽ More
Connectivity matrices derived from diffusion MRI (dMRI) provide an interpretable and generalizable way of understanding the human brain connectome. However, dMRI suffers from inter-site and between-scanner variation, which impedes analysis across datasets to improve robustness and reproducibility of results. To evaluate different harmonization approaches on connectivity matrices, we compared graph measures derived from these matrices before and after applying three harmonization techniques: mean shift, ComBat, and CycleGAN. The sample comprises 168 age-matched, sex-matched normal subjects from two studies: the Vanderbilt Memory and Aging Project (VMAP) and the Biomarkers of Cognitive Decline Among Normal Individuals (BIOCARD). First, we plotted the graph measures and used coefficient of variation (CoV) and the Mann-Whitney U test to evaluate different methods' effectiveness in removing site effects on the matrices and the derived graph measures. ComBat effectively eliminated site effects for global efficiency and modularity and outperformed the other two methods. However, all methods exhibited poor performance when harmonizing average betweenness centrality. Second, we tested whether our harmonization methods preserved correlations between age and graph measures. All methods except for CycleGAN in one direction improved correlations between age and global efficiency and between age and modularity from insignificant to significant with p-values less than 0.05.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
Predicting Age from White Matter Diffusivity with Residual Learning
Authors:
Chenyu Gao,
Michael E. Kim,
Ho Hin Lee,
Qi Yang,
Nazirah Mohd Khairi,
Praitayini Kanakaraj,
Nancy R. Newlin,
Derek B. Archer,
Angela L. Jefferson,
Warren D. Taylor,
Brian D. Boyd,
Lori L. Beason-Held,
Susan M. Resnick,
The BIOCARD Study Team,
Yuankai Huo,
Katherine D. Van Schaik,
Kurt G. Schilling,
Daniel Moyer,
Ivana Išgum,
Bennett A. Landman
Abstract:
Imaging findings inconsistent with those expected at specific chronological age ranges may serve as early indicators of neurological disorders and increased mortality risk. Estimation of chronological age, and deviations from expected results, from structural MRI data has become an important task for develo** biomarkers that are sensitive to such deviations. Complementary to structural analysis,…
▽ More
Imaging findings inconsistent with those expected at specific chronological age ranges may serve as early indicators of neurological disorders and increased mortality risk. Estimation of chronological age, and deviations from expected results, from structural MRI data has become an important task for develo** biomarkers that are sensitive to such deviations. Complementary to structural analysis, diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) has proven effective in identifying age-related microstructural changes within the brain white matter, thereby presenting itself as a promising additional modality for brain age prediction. Although early studies have sought to harness DTI's advantages for age estimation, there is no evidence that the success of this prediction is owed to the unique microstructural and diffusivity features that DTI provides, rather than the macrostructural features that are also available in DTI data. Therefore, we seek to develop white-matter-specific age estimation to capture deviations from normal white matter aging. Specifically, we deliberately disregard the macrostructural information when predicting age from DTI scalar images, using two distinct methods. The first method relies on extracting only microstructural features from regions of interest. The second applies 3D residual neural networks (ResNets) to learn features directly from the images, which are non-linearly registered and warped to a template to minimize macrostructural variations. When tested on unseen data, the first method yields mean absolute error (MAE) of 6.11 years for cognitively normal participants and MAE of 6.62 years for cognitively impaired participants, while the second method achieves MAE of 4.69 years for cognitively normal participants and MAE of 4.96 years for cognitively impaired participants. We find that the ResNet model captures subtler, non-macrostructural features for brain age prediction.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2024; v1 submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
