-
Demystifying the Hypercomplex: Inductive Biases in Hypercomplex Deep Learning
Authors:
Danilo Comminiello,
Eleonora Grassucci,
Danilo P. Mandic,
Aurelio Uncini
Abstract:
Hypercomplex algebras have recently been gaining prominence in the field of deep learning owing to the advantages of their division algebras over real vector spaces and their superior results when dealing with multidimensional signals in real-world 3D and 4D paradigms. This paper provides a foundational framework that serves as a roadmap for understanding why hypercomplex deep learning methods are…
▽ More
Hypercomplex algebras have recently been gaining prominence in the field of deep learning owing to the advantages of their division algebras over real vector spaces and their superior results when dealing with multidimensional signals in real-world 3D and 4D paradigms. This paper provides a foundational framework that serves as a roadmap for understanding why hypercomplex deep learning methods are so successful and how their potential can be exploited. Such a theoretical framework is described in terms of inductive bias, i.e., a collection of assumptions, properties, and constraints that are built into training algorithms to guide their learning process toward more efficient and accurate solutions. We show that it is possible to derive specific inductive biases in the hypercomplex domains, which extend complex numbers to encompass diverse numbers and data structures. These biases prove effective in managing the distinctive properties of these domains, as well as the complex structures of multidimensional and multimodal signals. This novel perspective for hypercomplex deep learning promises to both demystify this class of methods and clarify their potential, under a unifying framework, and in this way promotes hypercomplex models as viable alternatives to traditional real-valued deep learning for multidimensional signal processing.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The HR-Calculus: Enabling Information Processing with Quaternion Algebra
Authors:
Danilo P. Mandic,
Sayed Pouria Talebi,
Clive Cheong Took,
Yili Xia,
Dongpo Xu,
Min Xiang,
Pauline Bourigault
Abstract:
From their inception, quaternions and their division algebra have proven to be advantageous in modelling rotation/orientation in three-dimensional spaces and have seen use from the initial formulation of electromagnetic filed theory through to forming the basis of quantum filed theory. Despite their impressive versatility in modelling real-world phenomena, adaptive information processing technique…
▽ More
From their inception, quaternions and their division algebra have proven to be advantageous in modelling rotation/orientation in three-dimensional spaces and have seen use from the initial formulation of electromagnetic filed theory through to forming the basis of quantum filed theory. Despite their impressive versatility in modelling real-world phenomena, adaptive information processing techniques specifically designed for quaternion-valued signals have only recently come to the attention of the machine learning, signal processing, and control communities. The most important development in this direction is introduction of the HR-calculus, which provides the required mathematical foundation for deriving adaptive information processing techniques directly in the quaternion domain. In this article, the foundations of the HR-calculus are revised and the required tools for deriving adaptive learning techniques suitable for dealing with quaternion-valued signals, such as the gradient operator, chain and product derivative rules, and Taylor series expansion are presented. This serves to establish the most important applications of adaptive information processing in the quaternion domain for both single-node and multi-node formulations. The article is supported by Supplementary Material, which will be referred to as SM.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A Deep Matched Filter For R-Peak Detection in Ear-ECG
Authors:
Harry J. Davies,
Ghena Hammour,
Marek Zylinski,
Amir Nassibi,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
The Ear-ECG provides a continuous Lead I electrocardiogram (ECG) by measuring the potential difference related to heart activity using electrodes that can be embedded within earphones. The significant increase in wearability and comfort afforded by Ear-ECG is often accompanied by a corresponding degradation in signal quality - a common obstacle that is shared by most wearable technologies. We aim…
▽ More
The Ear-ECG provides a continuous Lead I electrocardiogram (ECG) by measuring the potential difference related to heart activity using electrodes that can be embedded within earphones. The significant increase in wearability and comfort afforded by Ear-ECG is often accompanied by a corresponding degradation in signal quality - a common obstacle that is shared by most wearable technologies. We aim to resolve this issue by introducing a Deep Matched Filter (Deep-MF) for the highly accurate detection of R-peaks in wearable ECG, thus enhancing the utility of Ear-ECG in real-world scenarios. The Deep-MF consists of an encoder stage (trained as part of an encoder-decoder module to reproduce ground truth ECG), and an R-peak classifier stage. Through its operation as a Matched Filter, the encoder searches for matches with an ECG template pattern in the input signal, prior to filtering the matches with the subsequent convolutional layers and selecting peaks corresponding to true ECG matches. The so condensed latent representation of R-peak information is then fed into a simple R-peak classifier, of which the output provides precise R-peak locations. The proposed Deep Matched Filter is evaluated using leave-one-subject-out cross validation over 36 subjects with an age range of 18-75, with the Deep-MF outperforming existing algorithms for R-peak detection in noisy ECG. The Deep-MF achieves a median R-peak recall of 94.9\%, a median precision of 91.2\% and an (AUC) value of 0.97. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the Deep Matched Filter algorithm not only retains the initialised ECG kernel structure during the training process, but also amplifies portions of the ECG which it deems most valuable. Overall, the Deep Matched Filter serves as a valuable step forward for the real-world functionality of Ear-ECG and, through its explainable operation, the acceptance of deep learning models in e-health.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Amplitude-Independent Machine Learning for PPG through Visibility Graphs and Transfer Learning
Authors:
Yuyang Miao,
Harry J. Davies,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Photoplethysmography (PPG) refers to the measurement of variations in blood volume using light and is a feature of most wearable devices. The PPG signals provide insight into the body's circulatory system and can be employed to extract various bio-features, such as heart rate and vascular ageing. Although several algorithms have been proposed for this purpose, many exhibit limitations, including h…
▽ More
Photoplethysmography (PPG) refers to the measurement of variations in blood volume using light and is a feature of most wearable devices. The PPG signals provide insight into the body's circulatory system and can be employed to extract various bio-features, such as heart rate and vascular ageing. Although several algorithms have been proposed for this purpose, many exhibit limitations, including heavy reliance on human calibration, high signal quality requirements, and a lack of generalisation. In this paper, we introduce a PPG signal processing framework that integrates graph theory and computer vision algorithms, to provide an analysis framework which is amplitude-independent and invariant to affine transformations. It also requires minimal preprocessing, fuses information through RGB channels and exhibits robust generalisation across tasks and datasets. The proposed VGTL-net achieves state-of-the-art performance in the prediction of vascular ageing and demonstrates robust estimation of continuous blood pressure waveforms.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024; v1 submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Convex Quaternion Optimization for Signal Processing: Theory and Applications
Authors:
Shuning Sun,
Qiankun Diao,
Dongpo Xu,
Pauline Bourigault,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Convex optimization methods have been extensively used in the fields of communications and signal processing. However, the theory of quaternion optimization is currently not as fully developed and systematic as that of complex and real optimization. To this end, we establish an essential theory of convex quaternion optimization for signal processing based on the generalized Hamilton-real (GHR) cal…
▽ More
Convex optimization methods have been extensively used in the fields of communications and signal processing. However, the theory of quaternion optimization is currently not as fully developed and systematic as that of complex and real optimization. To this end, we establish an essential theory of convex quaternion optimization for signal processing based on the generalized Hamilton-real (GHR) calculus. This is achieved in a way which conforms with traditional complex and real optimization theory. For rigorous, We present five discriminant theorems for convex quaternion functions, and four discriminant criteria for strongly convex quaternion functions. Furthermore, we provide a fundamental theorem for the optimality of convex quaternion optimization problems, and demonstrate its utility through three applications in quaternion signal processing. These results provide a solid theoretical foundation for convex quaternion optimization and open avenues for further developments in signal processing applications.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Hearables: Ear EEG Based Driver Fatigue Detection
Authors:
Metin C. Yarici,
Pierluigi Amadori,
Harry Davies,
Takashi Nakamura,
Nico Lingg,
Yiannis Demiris,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Ear EEG based driver fatigue monitoring systems have the potential to provide a seamless, efficient, and feasibly deployable alternative to existing scalp EEG based systems, which are often cumbersome and impractical. However, the feasibility of detecting the relevant delta, theta, alpha, and beta band EEG activity through the ear EEG is yet to be investigated. Through measurements of scalp and ea…
▽ More
Ear EEG based driver fatigue monitoring systems have the potential to provide a seamless, efficient, and feasibly deployable alternative to existing scalp EEG based systems, which are often cumbersome and impractical. However, the feasibility of detecting the relevant delta, theta, alpha, and beta band EEG activity through the ear EEG is yet to be investigated. Through measurements of scalp and ear EEG on ten subjects during a simulated, monotonous driving experiment, this study provides statistical analysis of characteristic ear EEG changes that are associated with the transition from alert to mentally fatigued states, and subsequent testing of a machine learning based automatic fatigue detection model. Novel numerical evidence is provided to support the feasibility of detection of mental fatigue with ear EEG that is in agreement with widely reported scalp EEG findings. This study paves the way for the development of ultra-wearable and readily deployable hearables based driver fatigue monitoring systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Rapid Extraction of Respiratory Waveforms from Photoplethysmography: A Deep Encoder Approach
Authors:
Harry J. Davies,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Much of the information of breathing is contained within the photoplethysmography (PPG) signal, through changes in venous blood flow, heart rate and stroke volume. We aim to leverage this fact, by employing a novel deep learning framework which is a based on a repurposed convolutional autoencoder. Our model aims to encode all of the relevant respiratory information contained within photoplethysmog…
▽ More
Much of the information of breathing is contained within the photoplethysmography (PPG) signal, through changes in venous blood flow, heart rate and stroke volume. We aim to leverage this fact, by employing a novel deep learning framework which is a based on a repurposed convolutional autoencoder. Our model aims to encode all of the relevant respiratory information contained within photoplethysmography waveform, and decode it into a waveform that is similar to a gold standard respiratory reference. The model is employed on two photoplethysmography data sets, namely Capnobase and BIDMC. We show that the model is capable of producing respiratory waveforms that approach the gold standard, while in turn producing state of the art respiratory rate estimates. We also show that when it comes to capturing more advanced respiratory waveform characteristics such as duty cycle, our model is for the most part unsuccessful. A suggested reason for this, in light of a previous study on in-ear PPG, is that the respiratory variations in finger-PPG are far weaker compared with other recording locations. Importantly, our model can perform these waveform estimates in a fraction of a millisecond, giving it the capacity to produce over 6 hours of respiratory waveforms in a single second. Moreover, we attempt to interpret the behaviour of the kernel weights within the model, showing that in part our model intuitively selects different breathing frequencies. The model proposed in this work could help to improve the usefulness of consumer PPG-based wearables for medical applications, where detailed respiratory information is required.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Complexity-based Financial Stress Evaluation
Authors:
Hongjian Xiao,
Yao Lei Xu,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Financial markets typically exhibit dynamically complex properties as they undergo continuous interactions with economic and environmental factors. The Efficient Market Hypothesis indicates a rich difference in the structural complexity of security prices between normal (stable markets) and abnormal (financial crises) situations. Considering the analogy between market undulation of price time seri…
▽ More
Financial markets typically exhibit dynamically complex properties as they undergo continuous interactions with economic and environmental factors. The Efficient Market Hypothesis indicates a rich difference in the structural complexity of security prices between normal (stable markets) and abnormal (financial crises) situations. Considering the analogy between market undulation of price time series and physical stress of bio-signals, we investigate whether stress indices in bio-systems can be adopted and modified so as to measure 'standard stress' in financial markets. This is achieved by employing structural complexity analysis, based on variants of univariate and multivariate sample entropy, to estimate the stress level of both financial markets on the whole and the performance of the individual financial indices. Further, we propose a novel graphical framework to establish the sensitivity of individual assets and stock markets to financial crises. This is achieved through Catastrophe Theory and entropy-based stress evaluations indicating the unique performance of each index/individual stock in response to different crises. Four major indices and four individual equities with gold prices are considered over the past 32 years from 1991-2021. Our findings based on nonlinear analyses and the proposed framework support the Efficient Market Hypothesis and reveal the relations among economic indices and within each price time series.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
HOTTBOX: Higher Order Tensor ToolBOX
Authors:
Ilya Kisil,
Giuseppe G. Calvi,
Bruno S. Dees,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
HOTTBOX is a Python library for exploratory analysis and visualisation of multi-dimensional arrays of data, also known as tensors. The library includes methods ranging from standard multi-way operations and data manipulation through to multi-linear algebra based tensor decompositions. HOTTBOX also comprises sophisticated algorithms for generalised multi-linear classification and data fusion, such…
▽ More
HOTTBOX is a Python library for exploratory analysis and visualisation of multi-dimensional arrays of data, also known as tensors. The library includes methods ranging from standard multi-way operations and data manipulation through to multi-linear algebra based tensor decompositions. HOTTBOX also comprises sophisticated algorithms for generalised multi-linear classification and data fusion, such as Support Tensor Machine (STM) and Tensor Ensemble Learning (TEL). For user convenience, HOTTBOX offers a unifying API which establishes a self-sufficient ecosystem for various forms of efficient representation of multi-way data and the corresponding decomposition and association algorithms. Particular emphasis is placed on scalability and interactive visualisation, to support multidisciplinary data analysis communities working on big data and tensors. HOTTBOX also provides means for integration with other popular data science libraries for visualisation and data manipulation. The source code, examples and documentation ca be found at https://github.com/hottbox/hottbox.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Variational Embedding Multiscale Sample Entropy:complexity-based analysis for multichannel systems
Authors:
Hongjian Xiao,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
To quantify the complexity of a system, entropy-based methods have received considerable critical attentions in real-world data analysis. Among numerous entropy algorithms, amplitude-based formulas, represented by Sample Entropy, suffer from a limitation of data length especially when it comes to practical scenarios. And this shortcoming is further highlighted by involving coarse graining procedur…
▽ More
To quantify the complexity of a system, entropy-based methods have received considerable critical attentions in real-world data analysis. Among numerous entropy algorithms, amplitude-based formulas, represented by Sample Entropy, suffer from a limitation of data length especially when it comes to practical scenarios. And this shortcoming is further highlighted by involving coarse graining procedure in multi-scale process. The unbalance between embedding dimension and data size will undoubtedly result in inaccurate and undefined estimation. To that cause, Variational Embedding Multiscale Sample Entropy is proposed in this paper, which assigns signals from various channels with distinct embedding dimensions. And this algorithm is tested by both stimulated and real signals. Furthermore, the performance of the new entropy is investigated and compared with Multivariate Multiscale Sample Entropy and Variational Embedding Multiscale Diversity Entropy. Two real-world database, wind data sets with varying regimes and physiological database recorded from young and elderly people, were utilized. As a result, the proposed algorithm gives an improved separation for both situations.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
An Apparatus for the Simulation of Breathing Disorders: Physically Meaningful Generation of Surrogate Data
Authors:
Harry J. Davies,
Ghena Hammour,
Hongjian Xiao,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
The rapidly increasing prevalence of debilitating breathing disorders, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), calls for a meaningful integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into healthcare. While this promises improved detection and monitoring of breathing disorders, AI techniques are almost invariably "data hungry" which highlights the importance of generating physically meanin…
▽ More
The rapidly increasing prevalence of debilitating breathing disorders, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), calls for a meaningful integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into healthcare. While this promises improved detection and monitoring of breathing disorders, AI techniques are almost invariably "data hungry" which highlights the importance of generating physically meaningful surrogate data. Indeed, domain aware surrogates would enable both an improved understanding of respiratory waveform changes with different breathing disorders, and enhance the training of machine learning algorithms. To this end, we introduce an apparatus comprising of PVC tubes and 3D printed parts as a simple yet effective method of simulating both obstructive and restrictive respiratory waveforms in healthy subjects. Independent control over both inspiratory and expiratory resistances allows for the simulation of obstructive breathing disorders through the whole spectrum of FEV1/FVC spirometry ratios (used to classify COPD), ranging from healthy values to values seen in severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Moreover, waveform characteristics of breathing disorders, such as a change in inspiratory duty cycle or peak flow are also observed in the waveforms resulting from use of the artificial breathing disorder simulation apparatus. Overall, the proposed apparatus provides us with a simple, effective and physically meaningful way to generate faithful surrogate breathing disorder waveforms, a prerequisite for the use of artificial intelligence in respiratory health.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2022; v1 submitted 14 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Dynamic Portfolio Cuts: A Spectral Approach to Graph-Theoretic Diversification
Authors:
Alvaro Arroyo,
Bruno Scalzo,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Stock market returns are typically analyzed using standard regression, yet they reside on irregular domains which is a natural scenario for graph signal processing. To this end, we consider a market graph as an intuitive way to represent the relationships between financial assets. Traditional methods for estimating asset-return covariance operate under the assumption of statistical time-invariance…
▽ More
Stock market returns are typically analyzed using standard regression, yet they reside on irregular domains which is a natural scenario for graph signal processing. To this end, we consider a market graph as an intuitive way to represent the relationships between financial assets. Traditional methods for estimating asset-return covariance operate under the assumption of statistical time-invariance, and are thus unable to appropriately infer the underlying true structure of the market graph. This work introduces a class of graph spectral estimators which cater for the nonstationarity inherent to asset price movements, and serve as a basis to represent the time-varying interactions between assets through a dynamic spectral market graph. Such an account of the time-varying nature of the asset-return covariance allows us to introduce the notion of dynamic spectral portfolio cuts, whereby the graph is partitioned into time-evolving clusters, allowing for online and robust asset allocation. The advantages of the proposed framework over traditional methods are demonstrated through numerical case studies using real-world price data.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Nonstationary Portfolios: Diversification in the Spectral Domain
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo,
Alvaro Arroyo,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Classical portfolio optimization methods typically determine an optimal capital allocation through the implicit, yet critical, assumption of statistical time-invariance. Such models are inadequate for real-world markets as they employ standard time-averaging based estimators which suffer significant information loss if the market observables are non-stationary. To this end, we reformulate the port…
▽ More
Classical portfolio optimization methods typically determine an optimal capital allocation through the implicit, yet critical, assumption of statistical time-invariance. Such models are inadequate for real-world markets as they employ standard time-averaging based estimators which suffer significant information loss if the market observables are non-stationary. To this end, we reformulate the portfolio optimization problem in the spectral domain to cater for the nonstationarity inherent to asset price movements and, in this way, allow for optimal capital allocations to be time-varying. Unlike existing spectral portfolio techniques, the proposed framework employs augmented complex statistics in order to exploit the interactions between the real and imaginary parts of the complex spectral variables, which in turn allows for the modelling of both harmonics and cyclostationarity in the time domain. The advantages of the proposed framework over traditional methods are demonstrated through numerical simulations using real-world price data.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
In-Ear SpO2 for Classification of Cognitive Workload
Authors:
Harry J. Davies,
Ian Williams,
Ghena Hammour,
Metin Yarici,
Barry M. Seemungal,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Classification of cognitive workload promises immense benefit in diverse areas ranging from driver safety to augmenting human capability through closed loop brain computer interface. The brain is the most metabolically active organ in the body and increases its metabolic activity and thus oxygen consumption with increasing cognitive demand. In this study, we explore the feasibility of in-ear SpO2…
▽ More
Classification of cognitive workload promises immense benefit in diverse areas ranging from driver safety to augmenting human capability through closed loop brain computer interface. The brain is the most metabolically active organ in the body and increases its metabolic activity and thus oxygen consumption with increasing cognitive demand. In this study, we explore the feasibility of in-ear SpO2 cognitive workload tracking. To this end, we preform cognitive workload assessment in 8 subjects, based on an N-back task, whereby the subjects are asked to count and remember the number of odd numbers displayed on a screen in 5 second windows. The 2 and 3-back tasks lead to either the lowest median absolute SpO2 or largest median decrease in SpO2 in all of the subjects, indicating a robust and measurable decrease in blood oxygen in response to increased cognitive workload. Using features derived from in-ear pulse oximetry, including SpO2, pulse rate and respiration rate, we were able to classify the 4 N-back task categories, over 5 second epochs, with a mean accuracy of 94.2%. Moreover, out of 21 total features, the 9 most important features for classification accuracy were all SpO2 related features. The findings suggest that in-ear SpO2 measurements provide valuable information for classification of cognitive workload over short time windows, which together with the small form factor promises a new avenue for real time cognitive workload tracking.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A Full Second-Order Analysis of the Widely Linear MVDR Beamformer for Noncircular Signals
Authors:
Zhe Li,
Rui Pu,
Yili Xia,
Wenjiang Pei,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A full performance analysis of the widely linear (WL) minimum variance distortionless response (MVDR) beamformer is introduced. While the WL MVDR is known to outperform its strictly linear counterpart, the Capon beamformer, for noncircular complex signals, the existing approaches provide limited physical insights, since they explicitly or implicitly omit the complementary second-order (SO) statist…
▽ More
A full performance analysis of the widely linear (WL) minimum variance distortionless response (MVDR) beamformer is introduced. While the WL MVDR is known to outperform its strictly linear counterpart, the Capon beamformer, for noncircular complex signals, the existing approaches provide limited physical insights, since they explicitly or implicitly omit the complementary second-order (SO) statistics of the output interferences and noise (IN). To this end, we exploit the full SO statistics of the output IN to introduce a full SO performance analysis framework for the WL MVDR beamformer. This makes it possible to separate the overall signal-to-interference plus noise ratio (SINR) gain of the WL MVDR beamformer w.r.t. the Capon one into the individual contributions along the in-phase (I) and quadrature (Q) channels. Next, by considering the reception of the unknown signal of interest (SOI) corrupted by an arbitrary number of orthogonal noncircular interferences, we further unveil the distribution of SINR gains in both the I and Q channels, and show that in almost all the spatial cases, these performance advantages are more pronounced when the SO noncircularity rate of the interferences increases. Illustrative numerical simulations are provided to support the theoretical results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2021; v1 submitted 10 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
A Probabilistic Spectral Analysis of Multivariate Real-Valued Nonstationary Signals
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A class of multivariate spectral representations for real-valued nonstationary random variables is introduced, which is characterised by a general complex Gaussian distribution. In this way, the temporal signal properties -- harmonicity, wide-sense stationarity and cyclostationarity -- are designated respectively by the mean, Hermitian variance and pseudo-variance of the associated time-frequency…
▽ More
A class of multivariate spectral representations for real-valued nonstationary random variables is introduced, which is characterised by a general complex Gaussian distribution. In this way, the temporal signal properties -- harmonicity, wide-sense stationarity and cyclostationarity -- are designated respectively by the mean, Hermitian variance and pseudo-variance of the associated time-frequency representation (TFR). For rigour, the estimators of the TFR distribution parameters are derived within a maximum likelihood framework and are shown to be statistically consistent, owing to the statistical identifiability of the proposed distribution parametrization. By virtue of the assumed probabilistic model, a generalised likelihood ratio test (GLRT) for nonstationarity detection is also proposed. Intuitive examples demonstrate the utility of the derived probabilistic framework for spectral analysis in low-SNR environments.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
In-Ear Measurement of Blood Oxygen Saturation: An Ambulatory Tool Needed To Detect The Delayed Life-Threatening Hypoxaemia in COVID-19
Authors:
Harry J. Davies,
Ian Williams,
Nicholas S. Peters,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Non-invasive ambulatory estimation of blood oxygen saturation has emerged as an important clinical requirement to detect hypoxemia in the delayed post-infective phase of COVID-19, where dangerous hypoxia may occur in the absence of subjective breathlessness. This immediate clinical driver, combined with the general quest for more personalised health data, means that pulse oximetry measurement of c…
▽ More
Non-invasive ambulatory estimation of blood oxygen saturation has emerged as an important clinical requirement to detect hypoxemia in the delayed post-infective phase of COVID-19, where dangerous hypoxia may occur in the absence of subjective breathlessness. This immediate clinical driver, combined with the general quest for more personalised health data, means that pulse oximetry measurement of capillary oxygen saturation (SpO2) will likely expand into both the clinical and consumer market of wearable health technology in the near future. In this study, we set out to establish the feasibility of SpO2 measurement from the ear canal as a convenient site for long term monitoring, and perform a comprehensive comparison with the right index finger - the conventional clinical measurement site. During resting SpO2 estimation, we found a root mean square difference of 1.47% between the two measurement sites, with a mean difference of 0.23% higher SpO2 in the right ear canal. Through the simultaneous recording of pulse oximetry from both the right ear canal and index finger during breath holds, we observe a substantial improvement in response time between the ear and finger that has a mean of 12.4 seconds and a range of 4.2 - 24.2 seconds across all subjects. Factors which influence this response time, termed SpO2 delay, such as the sex of a subject are also explored. Furthermore, we examine the potential downsides of ear canal blood oxygen saturation measurement, namely the lower photoplethysmogram amplitude, and suggest ways to mitigate this disadvantage. These results are presented in conjunction with previously discovered benefits such as robustness to temperature, making the case for measurement of SpO2 from the ear canal being both convenient and superior to conventional finger measurement sites for continuous non-intrusive long term monitoring in both clinical and everyday-life settings.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Graph Theory and Metro Traffic Modelling
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Anthony G. Constantinides,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
In this article we demonstrate how graph theory can be used to identify those stations in the London underground network which have the greatest influence on the functionality of the traffic, and proceed, in an innovative way, to assess the impact of a station closure on service levels across the city. Such underground network vulnerability analysis offers the opportunity to analyse, optimize and…
▽ More
In this article we demonstrate how graph theory can be used to identify those stations in the London underground network which have the greatest influence on the functionality of the traffic, and proceed, in an innovative way, to assess the impact of a station closure on service levels across the city. Such underground network vulnerability analysis offers the opportunity to analyse, optimize and enhance the connectivity of the London underground network in a mathematically tractable and physically meaningful manner.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
A Statistically Identifiable Model for Tensor-Valued Gaussian Random Variables
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Anh-Huy Phan,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Real-world signals typically span across multiple dimensions, that is, they naturally reside on multi-way data structures referred to as tensors. In contrast to standard ``flat-view'' multivariate matrix models which are agnostic to data structure and only describe linear pairwise relationships, we introduce the tensor-valued Gaussian distribution which caters for multilinear interactions -- the l…
▽ More
Real-world signals typically span across multiple dimensions, that is, they naturally reside on multi-way data structures referred to as tensors. In contrast to standard ``flat-view'' multivariate matrix models which are agnostic to data structure and only describe linear pairwise relationships, we introduce the tensor-valued Gaussian distribution which caters for multilinear interactions -- the linear relationship between fibers -- which is reflected by the Kronecker separable structure of the mean and covariance. By virtue of the statistical identifiability of the proposed distribution formulation, whereby different parameter values strictly generate different probability distributions, it is shown that the corresponding likelihood function can be maximised analytically to yield the maximum likelihood estimator. For rigour, the statistical consistency of the estimator is also demonstrated through numerical simulations. The probabilistic framework is then generalised to describe the joint distribution of multiple tensor-valued random variables, whereby the associated mean and covariance exhibit a Khatri-Rao separable structure. The proposed models are shown to serve as a natural basis for gridded atmospheric climate modelling.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019; v1 submitted 7 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Robust Principal Component Analysis Based On Maximum Correntropy Power Iterations
Authors:
Jean P. Chereau,
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Principal component analysis (PCA) is recognised as a quintessential data analysis technique when it comes to describing linear relationships between the features of a dataset. However, the well-known sensitivity of PCA to non-Gaussian samples and/or outliers often makes it unreliable in practice. To this end, a robust formulation of PCA is derived based on the maximum correntropy criterion (MCC)…
▽ More
Principal component analysis (PCA) is recognised as a quintessential data analysis technique when it comes to describing linear relationships between the features of a dataset. However, the well-known sensitivity of PCA to non-Gaussian samples and/or outliers often makes it unreliable in practice. To this end, a robust formulation of PCA is derived based on the maximum correntropy criterion (MCC) so as to maximise the expected likelihood of Gaussian distributed reconstruction errors. In this way, the proposed solution reduces to a generalised power iteration, whereby: (i) robust estimates of the principal components are obtained even in the presence of outliers; (ii) the number of principal components need not be specified in advance; and (iii) the entire set of principal components can be obtained, unlike existing approaches. The advantages of the proposed maximum correntropy power iteration (MCPI) are demonstrated through an intuitive numerical example.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Portfolio Cuts: A Graph-Theoretic Framework to Diversification
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Anthony G. Constantinides,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Investment returns naturally reside on irregular domains, however, standard multivariate portfolio optimization methods are agnostic to data structure. To this end, we investigate ways for domain knowledge to be conveniently incorporated into the analysis, by means of graphs. Next, to relax the assumption of the completeness of graph topology and to equip the graph model with practically relevant…
▽ More
Investment returns naturally reside on irregular domains, however, standard multivariate portfolio optimization methods are agnostic to data structure. To this end, we investigate ways for domain knowledge to be conveniently incorporated into the analysis, by means of graphs. Next, to relax the assumption of the completeness of graph topology and to equip the graph model with practically relevant physical intuition, we introduce the portfolio cut paradigm. Such a graph-theoretic portfolio partitioning technique is shown to allow the investor to devise robust and tractable asset allocation schemes, by virtue of a rigorous graph framework for considering smaller, computationally feasible, and economically meaningful clusters of assets, based on graph cuts. In turn, this makes it possible to fully utilize the asset returns covariance matrix for constructing the portfolio, even without the requirement for its inversion. The advantages of the proposed framework over traditional methods are demonstrated through numerical simulations based on real-world price data.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2019; v1 submitted 12 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Tight Lower Bound on the Tensor Rank based on the Maximally Square Unfolding
Authors:
Giuseppe G. Calvi,
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Tensors decompositions are a class of tools for analysing datasets of high dimensionality and variety in a natural manner, with the Canonical Polyadic Decomposition (CPD) being a main pillar. While the notion of CPD is closely intertwined with that of the tensor rank, $R$, unlike the matrix rank, the computation of the tensor rank is an NP-hard problem, owing to the associated computational burden…
▽ More
Tensors decompositions are a class of tools for analysing datasets of high dimensionality and variety in a natural manner, with the Canonical Polyadic Decomposition (CPD) being a main pillar. While the notion of CPD is closely intertwined with that of the tensor rank, $R$, unlike the matrix rank, the computation of the tensor rank is an NP-hard problem, owing to the associated computational burden of evaluating the CPD. To address this issue, we investigate tight lower bounds on $R$ with the aim to provide a reduced search space, and hence to lessen the computational costs of the CPD evaluation. This is achieved by establishing a link between the maximum attainable lower bound on $R$ and the dimensions of the matrix unfolding of the tensor with aspect ratio closest to unity (maximally square). Moreover, we demonstrate that, for a generic tensor, such lower bound can be attained under very mild conditions, whereby the tensor rank becomes detectable. Numerical examples demonstrate the benefits of this result.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2019; v1 submitted 12 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Unitary Shift Operators on a Graph
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Milos Dakovic,
Anthony G. Constantinides,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A unitary shift operator (GSO) for signals on a graph is introduced, which exhibits the desired property of energy preservation over both backward and forward graph shifts. For rigour, the graph differential operator is also derived in an analytical form. The commutativity relation of the shift operator with the Fourier transform is next explored in conjunction with the proposed GSO to introduce a…
▽ More
A unitary shift operator (GSO) for signals on a graph is introduced, which exhibits the desired property of energy preservation over both backward and forward graph shifts. For rigour, the graph differential operator is also derived in an analytical form. The commutativity relation of the shift operator with the Fourier transform is next explored in conjunction with the proposed GSO to introduce a graph discrete Fourier transform (GDFT) which, unlike existing approaches, ensures the orthogonality of GDFT bases and admits a natural frequency-domain interpretation. The proposed GDFT is shown to allow for a coherent definition of the graph discrete Hilbert transform (GDHT) and the graph analytic signal. The advantages of the proposed GSO are demonstrated through illustrative examples.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019; v1 submitted 12 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
A Class of Doubly Stochastic Shift Operators for Random Graph Signals and their Boundedness
Authors:
Bruno Scalzo Dees,
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Milos Dakovic,
Anthony G. Constantinides,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A class of doubly stochastic graph shift operators (GSO) is proposed, which is shown to exhibit: (i) lower and upper $L_{2}$-boundedness for locally stationary random graph signals; (ii) $L_{2}$-isometry for \textit{i.i.d.} random graph signals with the asymptotic increase in the incoming neighbourhood size of vertices; and (iii) preservation of the mean of any graph signal. These properties are o…
▽ More
A class of doubly stochastic graph shift operators (GSO) is proposed, which is shown to exhibit: (i) lower and upper $L_{2}$-boundedness for locally stationary random graph signals; (ii) $L_{2}$-isometry for \textit{i.i.d.} random graph signals with the asymptotic increase in the incoming neighbourhood size of vertices; and (iii) preservation of the mean of any graph signal. These properties are obtained through a statistical consistency analysis of the graph shift, and by exploiting the dual role of the doubly stochastic GSO as a Markov (diffusion) matrix and as an unbiased expectation operator. Practical utility of the class of doubly stochastic GSOs is demonstrated in a real-world multi-sensor signal filtering setting.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2020; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Vertex-Frequency Graph Signal Processing: A review
Authors:
Ljubisa Stankovic,
Danilo P. Mandic,
Milos Dakovic,
Bruno Scalzo,
Milos Brajovic,
Ervin Sejdic,
Anthony G. Constantinides
Abstract:
Graph signal processing deals with signals which are observed on an irregular graph domain. While many approaches have been developed in classical graph theory to cluster vertices and segment large graphs in a signal independent way, signal localization based approaches to the analysis of data on graph represent a new research direction which is also a key to big data analytics on graphs. To this…
▽ More
Graph signal processing deals with signals which are observed on an irregular graph domain. While many approaches have been developed in classical graph theory to cluster vertices and segment large graphs in a signal independent way, signal localization based approaches to the analysis of data on graph represent a new research direction which is also a key to big data analytics on graphs. To this end, after an overview of the basic definitions in graphs and graph signals, we present and discuss a localized form of the graph Fourier transform. To establish an analogy with classical signal processing, spectral- and vertex-domain definitions of the localization window are given next. The spectral and vertex localization kernels are then related to the wavelet transform, followed by a study of filtering and inversion of the localized graph Fourier transform. For rigour, the analysis of energy representation and frames in the localized graph Fourier transform is extended to the energy forms of vertex-frequency distributions, which operate even without the need to apply localization windows. Another link with classical signal processing is established through the concept of local smoothness, which is subsequently related to the particular paradigm of signal smoothness on graphs. This all represents a comprehensive account of the relation of general vertex-frequency analysis with classical time-frequency analysis, and important but missing link for more advanced applications of graphs signal processing. The theory is supported by illustrative and practically relevant examples.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2019; v1 submitted 8 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Compression and Interpretability of Deep Neural Networks via Tucker Tensor Layer: From First Principles to Tensor Valued Back-Propagation
Authors:
Giuseppe G. Calvi,
Ahmad Moniri,
Mahmoud Mahfouz,
Qibin Zhao,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
This work aims to help resolve the two main stumbling blocks in the application of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), that is, the exceedingly large number of trainable parameters and their physical interpretability. This is achieved through a tensor valued approach, based on the proposed Tucker Tensor Layer (TTL), as an alternative to the dense weight-matrices of DNNs. This allows us to treat the weigh…
▽ More
This work aims to help resolve the two main stumbling blocks in the application of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), that is, the exceedingly large number of trainable parameters and their physical interpretability. This is achieved through a tensor valued approach, based on the proposed Tucker Tensor Layer (TTL), as an alternative to the dense weight-matrices of DNNs. This allows us to treat the weight-matrices of general DNNs as a matrix unfolding of a higher order weight-tensor. By virtue of the compression properties of tensor decompositions, this enables us to introduce a novel and efficient framework for exploiting the multi-way nature of the weight-tensor in order to dramatically reduce the number of DNN parameters. We also derive the tensor valued back-propagation algorithm within the TTL framework, by extending the notion of matrix derivatives to tensors. In this way, the physical interpretability of the Tucker decomposition is exploited to gain physical insights into the NN training, through the process of computing gradients with respect to each factor matrix. The proposed framework is validated on both synthetic data, and the benchmark datasets MNIST, Fashion-MNIST, and CIFAR-10. Overall, through the ability to provide the relative importance of each data feature in training, the TTL back-propagation is shown to help mitigate the "black-box" nature inherent to NNs. Experiments also illustrate that the TTL achieves a 66.63-fold compression on MNIST and Fashion-MNIST, while, by simplifying the VGG-16 network, it achieves a 10\% speed up in training time, at a comparable performance.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2020; v1 submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Tensor Ensemble Learning for Multidimensional Data
Authors:
Ilia Kisil,
Ahmad Moniri,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
In big data applications, classical ensemble learning is typically infeasible on the raw input data and dimensionality reduction techniques are necessary. To this end, novel framework that generalises classic flat-view ensemble learning to multidimensional tensor-valued data is introduced. This is achieved by virtue of tensor decompositions, whereby the proposed method, referred to as tensor ensem…
▽ More
In big data applications, classical ensemble learning is typically infeasible on the raw input data and dimensionality reduction techniques are necessary. To this end, novel framework that generalises classic flat-view ensemble learning to multidimensional tensor-valued data is introduced. This is achieved by virtue of tensor decompositions, whereby the proposed method, referred to as tensor ensemble learning (TEL), decomposes every input data sample into multiple factors which allows for a flexibility in the choice of multiple learning algorithms in order to improve test performance. The TEL framework is shown to naturally compress multidimensional data in order to take advantage of the inherent multi-way data structure and exploit the benefit of ensemble learning. The proposed framework is verified through the application of Higher Order Singular Value Decomposition (HOSVD) to the ETH-80 dataset and is shown to outperform the classical ensemble learning approach of bootstrap aggregating.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
A Data Analytics Perspective of the Clarke and Related Transforms in Power Grid Analysis
Authors:
Danilo P. Mandic,
Sithan Kanna,
Yili Xia,
Ahmad Moniri,
Anthony G. Constantinides
Abstract:
Affordable and reliable electric power is fundamental to modern society and economy, with the Smart Grid becoming an increasingly important factor in power generation and distribution. In order to fully exploit it advantages, the analysis of modern Smart Grid requires close collaboration and convergence between power engineers and signal processing and machine learning experts. Current analysis te…
▽ More
Affordable and reliable electric power is fundamental to modern society and economy, with the Smart Grid becoming an increasingly important factor in power generation and distribution. In order to fully exploit it advantages, the analysis of modern Smart Grid requires close collaboration and convergence between power engineers and signal processing and machine learning experts. Current analysis techniques are typically derived from a Circuit Theory perspective; such an approach is adequate for only fully balanced systems operating at nominal conditions and non-obvious for data scientists - this is prohibitive for the analysis of dynamically unbalanced smart grids, where Data Analytics is not only well suited but also necessary. A common language that bridges the gap between Circuit Theory and Data Analytics, and the respective community of experts, would be a natural step forward. To this end, we revisit the Clarke and related transforms from a subspace, latent component, and spatial frequency analysis frameworks, to establish fundamental relationships between the standard three-phase transforms and modern Data Analytics. We show that the Clarke transform admits a physical interpretation as a "spatial dimensionality" reduction technique which is equivalent to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for balanced systems, but is sub-optimal for dynamically unbalanced systems, such as the Smart Grid, while the related Park transform performs further "temporal" dimensionality reduction. Such a perspective opens numerous new avenues for the use Signal Processing and Machine Learning in power grid research, and paves the way for innovative optimisation, transformation, and analysis techniques that are not accessible to arrive at from the standard Circuit Theory principles, as demonstrated in this work through the possibility of simultaneous frequency estimation and fault detection.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
The sum of tensor networks
Authors:
Giuseppe G. Calvi,
Ilia Kisil,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
Tensor networks (TNs) have been gaining interest as multiway data analysis tools owing to their ability to tackle the curse of dimensionality and to represent tensors as smaller-scale interconnections of their intrinsic features. However, despite the obvious advantages, the current treatment of TNs as stand-alone entities does not take full benefit of their underlying structure and the associated…
▽ More
Tensor networks (TNs) have been gaining interest as multiway data analysis tools owing to their ability to tackle the curse of dimensionality and to represent tensors as smaller-scale interconnections of their intrinsic features. However, despite the obvious advantages, the current treatment of TNs as stand-alone entities does not take full benefit of their underlying structure and the associated feature localization. To this end, embarking upon the analogy with a feature fusion, we propose a rigorous framework for the combination of TNs, focusing on their summation as the natural way for their combination. This allows for feature combination for any number of tensors, as long as their TN representation topologies are isomorphic. The benefits of the proposed framework are demonstrated on the classification of several groups of partially related images, where it outperforms standard machine learning algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Tensor Valued Common and Individual Feature Extraction: Multi-dimensional Perspective
Authors:
Ilia Kisil,
Giuseppe G. Calvi,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A novel method for common and individual feature analysis from exceedingly large-scale data is proposed, in order to ensure the tractability of both the computation and storage and thus mitigate the curse of dimensionality, a major bottleneck in modern data science. This is achieved by making use of the inherent redundancy in so-called multi-block data structures, which represent multiple observat…
▽ More
A novel method for common and individual feature analysis from exceedingly large-scale data is proposed, in order to ensure the tractability of both the computation and storage and thus mitigate the curse of dimensionality, a major bottleneck in modern data science. This is achieved by making use of the inherent redundancy in so-called multi-block data structures, which represent multiple observations of the same phenomenon taken at different times, angles or recording conditions. Upon providing an intrinsic link between the properties of the outer vector product and extracted features in tensor decompositions (TDs), the proposed common and individual information extraction from multi-block data is performed through imposing physical meaning to otherwise unconstrained factorisation approaches. This is shown to dramatically reduce the dimensionality of search spaces for subsequent classification procedures and to yield greatly enhanced accuracy. Simulations on a multi-class classification task of large-scale extraction of individual features from a collection of partially related real-world images demonstrate the advantages of the "blessing of dimensionality" associated with TDs.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
A Quaternion Frequency and Phasor Estimator for Three-Phase Power Distribution Networks
Authors:
Sayed Pouria Talebi,
Professor Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
For the first time quaternions have been used for real-time frequency estimation, where the multi-dimensional nature of quaternions allows for the full characterization of three-phase power systems. This is achieved through the use of quaternions to provide a unified framework for incorporating voltage measurements from all the phases of a three-phase system and then employing the recently introdu…
▽ More
For the first time quaternions have been used for real-time frequency estimation, where the multi-dimensional nature of quaternions allows for the full characterization of three-phase power systems. This is achieved through the use of quaternions to provide a unified framework for incorporating voltage measurements from all the phases of a three-phase system and then employing the recently introduced HR-calculus to derive a state space estimator based on the quaternion extended Kalman filter (QEKF). The components of the state space vector are designed such that they can be deployed for adaptive estimation of the system phasors. Finally, the proposed algorithm is validated through simulations using both synthetic and real-world data, which indicate that the developed quaternion frequency estimator can outperform its complex-valued counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Distributed Widely Linear Frequency Estimation in Unbalanced Three Phase Power Systems
Authors:
Sithan Kanna,
Dahir H. Dini,
Yili Xia,
Ron Hui,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
A novel method for distributed estimation of the frequency of power systems is introduced based on the cooperation between multiple measurement nodes. The proposed distributed widely linear complex Kalman filter (D-ACKF) and the distributed widely linear extended complex Kalman filter (D-AECKF) employ a widely linear state space and augmented complex statistics to deal with unbalanced system condi…
▽ More
A novel method for distributed estimation of the frequency of power systems is introduced based on the cooperation between multiple measurement nodes. The proposed distributed widely linear complex Kalman filter (D-ACKF) and the distributed widely linear extended complex Kalman filter (D-AECKF) employ a widely linear state space and augmented complex statistics to deal with unbalanced system conditions and the generality complex signals, both second order circular (proper) and second order noncircular (improper). It is shown that the current, strictly linear, estimators are inadequate for unbalanced systems, a typical case in smart grids, as they do not account for either the noncircularity of Clarke's αβ-voltage in unbalanced conditions or the correlated nature of nodal disturbances. We illuminate the relationship between the degree of circularity of Clarke's voltage and system imbalance, and prove that the proposed widely linear estimators are optimal for such conditions, while also accounting for the correlated and noncircular nature of real-world nodal disturbances. {Synthetic and real world} case studies over a range of power system conditions illustrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the proposed methodology.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Distributed Widely Linear Complex Kalman Filtering
Authors:
Dahir H. Dini,
Sithan Kanna,
Danilo P. Mandic
Abstract:
We introduce cooperative sequential state space estimation in the domain of augmented complex statistics, whereby nodes in a network collaborate locally to estimate noncircular complex signals. For rigour, a distributed augmented (widely linear) complex Kalman filter (D-ACKF) suited to the generality of complex signals is introduced, allowing for unified treatment of both proper (rotation invarian…
▽ More
We introduce cooperative sequential state space estimation in the domain of augmented complex statistics, whereby nodes in a network collaborate locally to estimate noncircular complex signals. For rigour, a distributed augmented (widely linear) complex Kalman filter (D-ACKF) suited to the generality of complex signals is introduced, allowing for unified treatment of both proper (rotation invariant) and improper (rotation dependent) signal distributions. Its duality with the bivariate real-valued distributed Kalman filter, along with several issues of implementation are also illuminated. The analysis and simulations show that unlike existing distributed Kalman filter solutions, the D-ACKF caters for both the improper data and the correlations between nodal observation noises, thus providing enhanced performance in real-world scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.