-
SLOctolyzer: Fully automatic analysis toolkit for segmentation and feature extracting in scanning laser ophthalmoscopy images
Authors:
Jamie Burke,
Samuel Gibbon,
Justin Engelmann,
Adam Threlfall,
Ylenia Giarratano,
Charlene Hamid,
Stuart King,
Ian J. C. MacCormick,
Tom MacGillivray
Abstract:
Purpose: To describe SLOctolyzer: an open-source analysis toolkit for en face retinal vessels appearing in infrared reflectance scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (SLO) images.
Methods: SLOctolyzer includes two main modules: segmentation and measurement. The segmentation module use deep learning methods to delineate retinal anatomy, while the measurement module quantifies key retinal vascular feature…
▽ More
Purpose: To describe SLOctolyzer: an open-source analysis toolkit for en face retinal vessels appearing in infrared reflectance scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (SLO) images.
Methods: SLOctolyzer includes two main modules: segmentation and measurement. The segmentation module use deep learning methods to delineate retinal anatomy, while the measurement module quantifies key retinal vascular features such as vessel complexity, density, tortuosity, and calibre. We evaluate the segmentation module using unseen data and measure its reproducibility.
Results: SLOctolyzer's segmentation module performed well against unseen internal test data (Dice for all-vessels, 0.9097; arteries, 0.8376; veins, 0.8525; optic disc, 0.9430; fovea, 0.8837). External validation against severe retinal pathology showed decreased performance (Dice for arteries, 0.7180; veins, 0.7470; optic disc, 0.9032). SLOctolyzer had good reproducibility (mean difference for fractal dimension, -0.0007; vessel density, -0.0003; vessel calibre, -0.3154 $μ$m; tortuosity density, 0.0013). SLOctolyzer can process a macula-centred SLO image in under 20 seconds and a disc-centred SLO image in under 30 seconds using a standard laptop CPU.
Conclusions: To our knowledge, SLOctolyzer is the first open-source tool to convert raw SLO images into reproducible and clinically meaningful retinal vascular parameters. SLO images are captured simultaneous to optical coherence tomography (OCT), and we believe our software will be useful for extracting retinal vascular measurements from large OCT image sets and linking them to ocular or systemic diseases. It requires no specialist knowledge or proprietary software, and allows manual correction of segmentations and re-computing of vascular metrics. SLOctolyzer is freely available at https://github.com/jaburke166/SLOctolyzer.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Domain-specific augmentations with resolution agnostic self-attention mechanism improves choroid segmentation in optical coherence tomography images
Authors:
Jamie Burke,
Justin Engelmann,
Charlene Hamid,
Diana Moukaddem,
Dan Pugh,
Neeraj Dhaun,
Amos Storkey,
Niall Strang,
Stuart King,
Tom MacGillivray,
Miguel O. Bernabeu,
Ian J. C. MacCormick
Abstract:
The choroid is a key vascular layer of the eye, supplying oxygen to the retinal photoreceptors. Non-invasive enhanced depth imaging optical coherence tomography (EDI-OCT) has recently improved access and visualisation of the choroid, making it an exciting frontier for discovering novel vascular biomarkers in ophthalmology and wider systemic health. However, current methods to measure the choroid o…
▽ More
The choroid is a key vascular layer of the eye, supplying oxygen to the retinal photoreceptors. Non-invasive enhanced depth imaging optical coherence tomography (EDI-OCT) has recently improved access and visualisation of the choroid, making it an exciting frontier for discovering novel vascular biomarkers in ophthalmology and wider systemic health. However, current methods to measure the choroid often require use of multiple, independent semi-automatic and deep learning-based algorithms which are not made open-source. Previously, Choroidalyzer -- an open-source, fully automatic deep learning method trained on 5,600 OCT B-scans from 385 eyes -- was developed to fully segment and quantify the choroid in EDI-OCT images, thus addressing these issues. Using the same dataset, we propose a Robust, Resolution-agnostic and Efficient Attention-based network for CHoroid segmentation (REACH). REACHNet leverages multi-resolution training with domain-specific data augmentation to promote generalisation, and uses a lightweight architecture with resolution-agnostic self-attention which is not only faster than Choroidalyzer's previous network (4 images/s vs. 2.75 images/s on a standard laptop CPU), but has greater performance for segmenting the choroid region, vessels and fovea (Dice coefficient for region 0.9769 vs. 0.9749, vessels 0.8612 vs. 0.8192 and fovea 0.8243 vs. 0.3783) due to its improved hyperparameter configuration and model training pipeline. REACHNet can be used with Choroidalyzer as a drop-in replacement for the original model and will be made available upon publication.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Choroidalyzer: An open-source, end-to-end pipeline for choroidal analysis in optical coherence tomography
Authors:
Justin Engelmann,
Jamie Burke,
Charlene Hamid,
Megan Reid-Schachter,
Dan Pugh,
Neeraj Dhaun,
Diana Moukaddem,
Lyle Gray,
Niall Strang,
Paul McGraw,
Amos Storkey,
Paul J. Steptoe,
Stuart King,
Tom MacGillivray,
Miguel O. Bernabeu,
Ian J. C. MacCormick
Abstract:
Purpose: To develop Choroidalyzer, an open-source, end-to-end pipeline for segmenting the choroid region, vessels, and fovea, and deriving choroidal thickness, area, and vascular index.
Methods: We used 5,600 OCT B-scans (233 subjects, 6 systemic disease cohorts, 3 device types, 2 manufacturers). To generate region and vessel ground-truths, we used state-of-the-art automatic methods following ma…
▽ More
Purpose: To develop Choroidalyzer, an open-source, end-to-end pipeline for segmenting the choroid region, vessels, and fovea, and deriving choroidal thickness, area, and vascular index.
Methods: We used 5,600 OCT B-scans (233 subjects, 6 systemic disease cohorts, 3 device types, 2 manufacturers). To generate region and vessel ground-truths, we used state-of-the-art automatic methods following manual correction of inaccurate segmentations, with foveal positions manually annotated. We trained a U-Net deep-learning model to detect the region, vessels, and fovea to calculate choroid thickness, area, and vascular index in a fovea-centred region of interest. We analysed segmentation agreement (AUC, Dice) and choroid metrics agreement (Pearson, Spearman, mean absolute error (MAE)) in internal and external test sets. We compared Choroidalyzer to two manual graders on a small subset of external test images and examined cases of high error.
Results: Choroidalyzer took 0.299 seconds per image on a standard laptop and achieved excellent region (Dice: internal 0.9789, external 0.9749), very good vessel segmentation performance (Dice: internal 0.8817, external 0.8703) and excellent fovea location prediction (MAE: internal 3.9 pixels, external 3.4 pixels). For thickness, area, and vascular index, Pearson correlations were 0.9754, 0.9815, and 0.8285 (internal) / 0.9831, 0.9779, 0.7948 (external), respectively (all p<0.0001). Choroidalyzer's agreement with graders was comparable to the inter-grader agreement across all metrics.
Conclusions: Choroidalyzer is an open-source, end-to-end pipeline that accurately segments the choroid and reliably extracts thickness, area, and vascular index. Especially choroidal vessel segmentation is a difficult and subjective task, and fully-automatic methods like Choroidalyzer could provide objectivity and standardisation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
A publicly available vessel segmentation algorithm for SLO images
Authors:
Adam Threlfall,
Samuel Gibbon,
James Cameron,
Tom MacGillivray
Abstract:
Background and Objective: Infra-red scanning laser ophthalmoscope (IRSLO) images are akin to colour fundus photographs in displaying the posterior pole and retinal vasculature fine detail. While there are many trained networks readily available for retinal vessel segmentation in colour fundus photographs, none cater to IRSLO images. Accordingly, we aimed to develop (and release as open source) a v…
▽ More
Background and Objective: Infra-red scanning laser ophthalmoscope (IRSLO) images are akin to colour fundus photographs in displaying the posterior pole and retinal vasculature fine detail. While there are many trained networks readily available for retinal vessel segmentation in colour fundus photographs, none cater to IRSLO images. Accordingly, we aimed to develop (and release as open source) a vessel segmentation algorithm tailored specifically to IRSLO images. Materials and Methods: We used 23 expertly annotated IRSLO images from the RAVIR dataset, combined with 7 additional images annotated in-house. We trained a U-Net (convolutional neural network) to label pixels as 'vessel' or 'background'. Results: On an unseen test set (4 images), our model achieved an AUC of 0.981, and an AUPRC of 0.815. Upon thresholding, it achieved a sensitivity of 0.844, a specificity of 0.983, and an F1 score of 0.857. Conclusion: We have made our automatic segmentation algorithm publicly available and easy to use. Researchers can use the generated vessel maps to compute metrics such as fractal dimension and vessel density.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A method for quantifying sectoral optic disc pallor in fundus photographs and its association with peripapillary RNFL thickness
Authors:
Samuel Gibbon,
Graciela Muniz-Terrera,
Fabian SL Yii,
Charlene Hamid,
Simon Cox,
Ian JC Maccormick,
Andrew J Tatham,
Craig Ritchie,
Emanuele Trucco,
Baljean Dhillon,
Thomas J MacGillivray
Abstract:
Purpose: To develop an automatic method of quantifying optic disc pallor in fundus photographs and determine associations with peripapillary retinal nerve fibre layer (pRNFL) thickness.
Methods: We used deep learning to segment the optic disc, fovea, and vessels in fundus photographs, and measured pallor. We assessed the relationship between pallor and pRNFL thickness derived from optical cohere…
▽ More
Purpose: To develop an automatic method of quantifying optic disc pallor in fundus photographs and determine associations with peripapillary retinal nerve fibre layer (pRNFL) thickness.
Methods: We used deep learning to segment the optic disc, fovea, and vessels in fundus photographs, and measured pallor. We assessed the relationship between pallor and pRNFL thickness derived from optical coherence tomography scans in 118 participants. Separately, we used images diagnosed by clinical inspection as pale (N=45) and assessed how measurements compared to healthy controls (N=46). We also developed automatic rejection thresholds, and tested the software for robustness to camera type, image format, and resolution.
Results: We developed software that automatically quantified disc pallor across several zones in fundus photographs. Pallor was associated with pRNFL thickness globally (\b{eta} = -9.81 (SE = 3.16), p < 0.05), in the temporal inferior zone (\b{eta} = -29.78 (SE = 8.32), p < 0.01), with the nasal/temporal ratio (\b{eta} = 0.88 (SE = 0.34), p < 0.05), and in the whole disc (\b{eta} = -8.22 (SE = 2.92), p < 0.05). Furthermore, pallor was significantly higher in the patient group. Lastly, we demonstrate the analysis to be robust to camera type, image format, and resolution.
Conclusions: We developed software that automatically locates and quantifies disc pallor in fundus photographs and found associations between pallor measurements and pRNFL thickness.
Translational relevance: We think our method will be useful for the identification, monitoring and progression of diseases characterized by disc pallor/optic atrophy, including glaucoma, compression, and potentially in neurodegenerative disorders.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
An open-source deep learning algorithm for efficient and fully-automatic analysis of the choroid in optical coherence tomography
Authors:
Jamie Burke,
Justin Engelmann,
Charlene Hamid,
Megan Reid-Schachter,
Tom Pearson,
Dan Pugh,
Neeraj Dhaun,
Stuart King,
Tom MacGillivray,
Miguel O. Bernabeu,
Amos Storkey,
Ian J. C. MacCormick
Abstract:
Purpose: To develop an open-source, fully-automatic deep learning algorithm, DeepGPET, for choroid region segmentation in optical coherence tomography (OCT) data. Methods: We used a dataset of 715 OCT B-scans (82 subjects, 115 eyes) from 3 clinical studies related to systemic disease. Ground truth segmentations were generated using a clinically validated, semi-automatic choroid segmentation method…
▽ More
Purpose: To develop an open-source, fully-automatic deep learning algorithm, DeepGPET, for choroid region segmentation in optical coherence tomography (OCT) data. Methods: We used a dataset of 715 OCT B-scans (82 subjects, 115 eyes) from 3 clinical studies related to systemic disease. Ground truth segmentations were generated using a clinically validated, semi-automatic choroid segmentation method, Gaussian Process Edge Tracing (GPET). We finetuned a UNet with MobileNetV3 backbone pre-trained on ImageNet. Standard segmentation agreement metrics, as well as derived measures of choroidal thickness and area, were used to evaluate DeepGPET, alongside qualitative evaluation from a clinical ophthalmologist. Results: DeepGPET achieves excellent agreement with GPET on data from 3 clinical studies (AUC=0.9994, Dice=0.9664; Pearson correlation of 0.8908 for choroidal thickness and 0.9082 for choroidal area), while reducing the mean processing time per image on a standard laptop CPU from 34.49s ($\pm$15.09) using GPET to 1.25s ($\pm$0.10) using DeepGPET. Both methods performed similarly according to a clinical ophthalmologist, who qualitatively judged a subset of segmentations by GPET and DeepGPET, based on smoothness and accuracy of segmentations. Conclusions: DeepGPET, a fully-automatic, open-source algorithm for choroidal segmentation, will enable researchers to efficiently extract choroidal measurements, even for large datasets. As no manual interventions are required, DeepGPET is less subjective than semi-automatic methods and could be deployed in clinical practice without necessitating a trained operator.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Evaluation of an automated choroid segmentation algorithm in a longitudinal kidney donor and recipient cohort
Authors:
Jamie Burke,
Dan Pugh,
Tariq Farrah,
Charlene Hamid,
Emily Godden,
Tom MacGillivray,
Neeraj Dhaun,
J. Kenneth Baillie,
Stuart King,
Ian J. C. MacCormick
Abstract:
Purpose: To evaluate the performance of an automated choroid segmentation algorithm in optical coherence tomography (OCT) data using a longitudinal kidney donor and recipient cohort. Methods: We assessed 22 donors and 23 patients requiring renal transplantation over up to 1 year post-transplant. We measured choroidal thickness (CT) and area and compared our automated CT measurements to manual ones…
▽ More
Purpose: To evaluate the performance of an automated choroid segmentation algorithm in optical coherence tomography (OCT) data using a longitudinal kidney donor and recipient cohort. Methods: We assessed 22 donors and 23 patients requiring renal transplantation over up to 1 year post-transplant. We measured choroidal thickness (CT) and area and compared our automated CT measurements to manual ones at the same locations. We estimated associations between choroidal measurements and markers of renal function (estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), serum creatinine and urea) using correlation and linear mixed-effects (LME) modelling. Results: There was good agreement between manual and automated CT. Automated measures were more precise because of smaller measurement error over time. External adjudication of major discrepancies were in favour of automated measures. Significant differences were observed in the choroid pre- and post-transplant in both cohorts, and LME modelling revealed significant linear associations observed between choroidal measures and renal function in recipients. Significant associations were mostly stronger with automated CT (eGFR P<0.001, creatinine P=0.004, urea P=0.04) compared to manual CT (eGFR P=0.002, creatinine P=0.01, urea P=0.03). Conclusions: Our automated approach has greater precision than human-performed manual measurements, which may explain stronger associations with renal function compared to manual measurements. To improve detection of meaningful associations with clinical endpoints in longitudinal studies of OCT, reducing measurement error should be a priority, and automated measurements help achieve this. Translational relevance: We introduce a novel choroid segmentation algorithm which can replace manual grading for studying the choroid in renal disease, and other clinical conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2023; v1 submitted 19 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Automated Segmentation of Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography Images: Benchmark Data and Clinically Relevant Metrics
Authors:
Ylenia Giarratano,
Eleonora Bianchi,
Calum Gray,
Andrew Morris,
Tom MacGillivray,
Baljean Dhillon,
Miguel O. Bernabeu
Abstract:
Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is a novel non-invasive imaging modality for the visualisation of microvasculature in vivo that has encountered broad adoption in retinal research. OCTA potential in the assessment of pathological conditions and the reproducibility of studies relies on the quality of the image analysis. However, automated segmentation of parafoveal OCTA images is sti…
▽ More
Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) is a novel non-invasive imaging modality for the visualisation of microvasculature in vivo that has encountered broad adoption in retinal research. OCTA potential in the assessment of pathological conditions and the reproducibility of studies relies on the quality of the image analysis. However, automated segmentation of parafoveal OCTA images is still an open problem. In this study, we generate the first open dataset of retinal parafoveal OCTA images with associated ground truth manual segmentations. Furthermore, we establish a standard for OCTA image segmentation by surveying a broad range of state-of-the-art vessel enhancement and binarisation procedures. We provide the most comprehensive comparison of these methods under a unified framework to date. Our results show that, for the set of images considered, deep learning architectures (U-Net and CS-Net) achieve the best performance. For applications where manually segmented data is not available to retrain these approaches, our findings suggest that optimal oriented flux is the best handcrafted filter from those considered. Furthermore, we report on the importance of preserving network structure in the segmentation to enable deep vascular phenoty**. We introduce new metrics for network structure evaluation in segmented angiograms. Our results demonstrate that segmentation methods with equal Dice score perform very differently in terms of network structure preservation. Moreover, we compare the error in the computation of clinically relevant vascular network metrics (e.g. foveal avascular zone area and vessel density) across segmentation methods. Our results show up to 25% differences in vessel density accuracy depending on the segmentation method employed. These findings should be taken into account when comparing the results of clinical studies and performing meta-analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2020; v1 submitted 20 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Unsupervised learning for cross-domain medical image synthesis using deformation invariant cycle consistency networks
Authors:
Chengjia Wang,
Gillian Macnaught,
Giorgos Papanastasiou,
Tom MacGillivray,
David Newby
Abstract:
Recently, the cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks (CycleGAN) has been widely used for synthesis of multi-domain medical images. The domain-specific nonlinear deformations captured by CycleGAN make the synthesized images difficult to be used for some applications, for example, generating pseudo-CT for PET-MR attenuation correction. This paper presents a deformation-invariant CycleGAN (…
▽ More
Recently, the cycle-consistent generative adversarial networks (CycleGAN) has been widely used for synthesis of multi-domain medical images. The domain-specific nonlinear deformations captured by CycleGAN make the synthesized images difficult to be used for some applications, for example, generating pseudo-CT for PET-MR attenuation correction. This paper presents a deformation-invariant CycleGAN (DicycleGAN) method using deformable convolutional layers and new cycle-consistency losses. Its robustness dealing with data that suffer from domain-specific nonlinear deformations has been evaluated through comparison experiments performed on a multi-sequence brain MR dataset and a multi-modality abdominal dataset. Our method has displayed its ability to generate synthesized data that is aligned with the source while maintaining a proper quality of signal compared to CycleGAN-generated data. The proposed model also obtained comparable performance with CycleGAN when data from the source and target domains are alignable through simple affine transformations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.