-
Recent advancements on MPC for tracking: periodic and harmonic formulations
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
The main benefit of model predictive control (MPC) is its ability to steer the system to a given reference without violating the constraints while minimizing some objective. Furthermore, a suitably designed MPC controller guarantees asymptotic stability of the closed-loop system to the given reference as long as its optimization problem is feasible at the initial state of the system. Therefore, on…
▽ More
The main benefit of model predictive control (MPC) is its ability to steer the system to a given reference without violating the constraints while minimizing some objective. Furthermore, a suitably designed MPC controller guarantees asymptotic stability of the closed-loop system to the given reference as long as its optimization problem is feasible at the initial state of the system. Therefore, one of the limitations of classical MPC is that changing the reference may lead to an unfeasible MPC problem. Furthermore, due to a lack of deep knowledge of the system, it is possible for the user to provide a desired reference that is unfeasible or non-attainable for the MPC controller, leading to the same problem. This chapter summarizes MPC formulations recently proposed that have been designed to address these issues. In particular, thanks to the addition of an artificial reference as decision variable, the formulations achieve asymptotic stability and recursive feasibility guarantees regardless of the reference provided by the user, even if it is changed online or if it violates the system constraints. We show a recent formulation which extends this idea, achieving better performance and larger domains of attraction when working with small prediction horizons. Additional benefits of these formulations, when compared to classical MPC, are also discussed and highlighted with illustrative examples.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Model predictive control for tracking using artificial references: Fundamentals, recent results and practical implementation
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Johannes Köhler,
Antonio Ferramosca,
Ignacio Alvarado,
Melanie N. Zeilinger,
Teodoro Alamo,
Daniel Limon
Abstract:
This paper provides a comprehensive tutorial on a family of Model Predictive Control (MPC) formulations, known as MPC for tracking, which are characterized by including an artificial reference as part of the decision variables in the optimization problem. These formulations have several benefits with respect to the classical MPC formulations, including guaranteed recursive feasibility under online…
▽ More
This paper provides a comprehensive tutorial on a family of Model Predictive Control (MPC) formulations, known as MPC for tracking, which are characterized by including an artificial reference as part of the decision variables in the optimization problem. These formulations have several benefits with respect to the classical MPC formulations, including guaranteed recursive feasibility under online reference changes, as well as asymptotic stability and an increased domain of attraction. This tutorial paper introduces the concept of using an artificial reference in MPC, presenting the benefits and theoretical guarantees obtained by its use. We then provide a survey of the main advances and extensions of the original linear MPC for tracking, including its non-linear extension. Additionally, we discuss its application to learning-based MPC, and discuss optimization aspects related to its implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Implementation of soft-constrained MPC for Tracking using its semi-banded problem structure
Authors:
Victor Gracia,
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
Model Predictive Control (MPC) is a popular control approach due to its ability to consider constraints, including input and state restrictions, while minimizing a cost function. However, in practice, said constraints can result in feasibility issues, either because the system model is not accurate or due to the existence of external disturbances. To mitigate this problem, a solution adopted by th…
▽ More
Model Predictive Control (MPC) is a popular control approach due to its ability to consider constraints, including input and state restrictions, while minimizing a cost function. However, in practice, said constraints can result in feasibility issues, either because the system model is not accurate or due to the existence of external disturbances. To mitigate this problem, a solution adopted by the MPC community is the use of soft constraints. In this article, we consider a not-so-typical methodology to encode soft constraints in a particular MPC formulation known as MPC for Tracking (MPCT), which has several advantages when compared to standard MPC formulations. The motivation behind the proposed encoding is to maintain the semi-banded structure of the ingredients of a recently proposed solver for the considered MPCT formulation, thus providing an efficient and fast solver when compared to alternative approaches from the literature. We show numerical results highlighting the benefits of the formulation and the computational efficiency of the solver.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Efficient implementation of MPC for tracking using ADMM by decoupling its semi-banded structure
Authors:
Victor Gracia,
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
Model Predictive Control (MPC) for tracking formulation presents numerous advantages compared to standard MPC, such as a larger domain of attraction and recursive feasibility even when abrupt changes in the reference are produced. As a drawback, it includes some extra decision variables in its related optimization problem, leading to a semi-banded structure that differs from the banded structure e…
▽ More
Model Predictive Control (MPC) for tracking formulation presents numerous advantages compared to standard MPC, such as a larger domain of attraction and recursive feasibility even when abrupt changes in the reference are produced. As a drawback, it includes some extra decision variables in its related optimization problem, leading to a semi-banded structure that differs from the banded structure encountered in standard MPC. This semi-banded structure prevents the direct use of the efficient algorithms available for banded problems. To address this issue, we present an algorithm based on the alternating direction method of multipliers that explicitly takes advantage of the underlying semi-banded structure of the MPC for tracking.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Learning disturbance models for offset-free reference tracking
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Mario Zanon,
Alberto Bemporad
Abstract:
This work presents a nonlinear MPC framework that guarantees asymptotic offset-free tracking of generic reference trajectories by learning a nonlinear disturbance model, which compensates for input disturbances and model-plant mismatch. Our approach generalizes the well-established method of using an observer to estimate a constant disturbance to allow tracking constant setpoints with zero steady-…
▽ More
This work presents a nonlinear MPC framework that guarantees asymptotic offset-free tracking of generic reference trajectories by learning a nonlinear disturbance model, which compensates for input disturbances and model-plant mismatch. Our approach generalizes the well-established method of using an observer to estimate a constant disturbance to allow tracking constant setpoints with zero steady-state error. In this paper, the disturbance model is generalized to a nonlinear static function of the plant's state and command input, learned online, so as to perfectly track time-varying reference trajectories under certain assumptions on the model and provided that future reference samples are available. We compare our approach with the classical constant disturbance model in numerical simulations, showing its superiority.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Harmonic model predictive control for tracking periodic references
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Alberto Bemporad,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
Harmonic model predictive control (HMPC) is a recent model predictive control (MPC) formulation for tracking piece-wise constant references that includes a parameterized artificial harmonic reference as a decision variable, resulting in an increased performance and domain of attraction with respect to other MPC formulations. This article presents an extension of the HMPC formulation to track perio…
▽ More
Harmonic model predictive control (HMPC) is a recent model predictive control (MPC) formulation for tracking piece-wise constant references that includes a parameterized artificial harmonic reference as a decision variable, resulting in an increased performance and domain of attraction with respect to other MPC formulations. This article presents an extension of the HMPC formulation to track periodic harmonic references and discusses its use to track arbitrary references. The proposed formulation inherits the benefits of its predecessor, namely its good performance and large domain of attraction when using small prediction horizons, and that the complexity of its optimization problem does not depend on the period of the periodic reference. We show closed-loop results discussing its performance and comparing it to other MPC formulations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Efficient online update of model predictive control in embedded systems using first-order methods
Authors:
Victor Gracia,
Pablo Krupa,
Teodoro Alamo,
Daniel Limon
Abstract:
Model Predictive Control (MPC) is typically characterized for being computationally demanding, as it requires solving optimization problems online; a particularly relevant point when considering its implementation in embedded systems. To reduce the computational burden of the optimization algorithm, most solvers perform as many offline operations as possible, typically performing the computation a…
▽ More
Model Predictive Control (MPC) is typically characterized for being computationally demanding, as it requires solving optimization problems online; a particularly relevant point when considering its implementation in embedded systems. To reduce the computational burden of the optimization algorithm, most solvers perform as many offline operations as possible, typically performing the computation and factorization of its expensive matrices offline and then storing them in the embedded system. This improves the efficiency of the solver, with the disadvantage that online changes on some of the ingredients of the MPC formulation require performing these expensive computations online. This article presents an efficient algorithm for the factorization of the key matrix used in several first-order optimization methods applied to linear MPC formulations, allowing its prediction model and cost function matrices to be updated online at the expense of a small computational cost. We show results comparing the proposed approach with other solvers from the literature applied to a linear time-varying system.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2023; v1 submitted 14 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Certification of the proximal gradient method under fixed-point arithmetic for box-constrained QP problems
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Omar Inverso,
Mirco Tribastone,
Alberto Bemporad
Abstract:
In safety-critical applications that rely on the solution of an optimization problem, the certification of the optimization algorithm is of vital importance. Certification and suboptimality results are available for a wide range of optimization algorithms. However, a typical underlying assumption is that the operations performed by the algorithm are exact, i.e., that there is no numerical error du…
▽ More
In safety-critical applications that rely on the solution of an optimization problem, the certification of the optimization algorithm is of vital importance. Certification and suboptimality results are available for a wide range of optimization algorithms. However, a typical underlying assumption is that the operations performed by the algorithm are exact, i.e., that there is no numerical error during the mathematical operations, which is hardly a valid assumption in a real hardware implementation. This is particularly true in the case of fixed-point hardware, where computational inaccuracies are not uncommon. This article presents a certification procedure for the proximal gradient method for box-constrained QP problems implemented in fixed-point arithmetic. The procedure provides a method to select the minimal fractional precision required to obtain a certain suboptimality bound, indicating the maximum number of iterations of the optimization method required to obtain it. The procedure makes use of formal verification methods to provide arbitrarily tight bounds on the suboptimality guarantee. We apply the proposed certification procedure on the implementation of a non-trivial model predictive controller on 32-bit fixed-point hardware.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023; v1 submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Implementation of MPC in embedded systems using first order methods
Authors:
Pablo Krupa
Abstract:
This Ph.D. dissertation contains results in two different but related fields: the implementation of model predictive control (MPC) in embedded systems using first order methods, and restart schemes for accelerated first order methods (AFOM). We start by presenting three novel restart schemes for AFOM. These schemes can improve the convergence of the AFOM by suppressing the undesirable oscillations…
▽ More
This Ph.D. dissertation contains results in two different but related fields: the implementation of model predictive control (MPC) in embedded systems using first order methods, and restart schemes for accelerated first order methods (AFOM). We start by presenting three novel restart schemes for AFOM. These schemes can improve the convergence of the AFOM by suppressing the undesirable oscillations that they are prone to present. The schemes we develop have theoretical guarantees and do not require knowledge of difficult-to-obtain parameters of the optimization problem. Next, we present sparse solvers for various MPC formulations which take advantage of the structures of the optimization problems. The solvers have been made available in an open-source toolbox for Matlab called SPCIES (https://github.com/GepocUS/Spcies). Finally, we present a novel MPC formulation that displays a larger domain of attraction and better performance than other MPC formulations, especially when using small prediction horizons. This, along with its recursive feasibility and asymptotic stability, makes it especially suitable for its implementation in embedded systems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A sparse ADMM-based solver for linear MPC subject to terminal quadratic constraint
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Rim Jaouani,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
Model Predictive Control (MPC) typically includes a terminal constraint to guarantee stability of the closed-loop system under nominal conditions. In linear MPC this constraint is generally taken on a polyhedral set, leading to a quadratic optimization problem. However, the use of an ellipsoidal terminal constraint may be desirable, leading to an optimization problem with a quadratic constraint. I…
▽ More
Model Predictive Control (MPC) typically includes a terminal constraint to guarantee stability of the closed-loop system under nominal conditions. In linear MPC this constraint is generally taken on a polyhedral set, leading to a quadratic optimization problem. However, the use of an ellipsoidal terminal constraint may be desirable, leading to an optimization problem with a quadratic constraint. In this case, the optimization problem can be solved using Second Order Cone (SOC) programming solvers, since the quadratic constraint can be posed as a SOC constraint, at the expense of adding additional slack variables and possibly compromising the simple structure of the solver ingredients. In this paper we present a sparse solver for linear MPC subject to a terminal ellipsoidal constraint based on the alternating direction method of multipliers algorithm in which we directly deal with the quadratic constraints without having to resort to the use of a SOC constraint nor the inclusion of additional decision variables. The solver is suitable for its use in embedded systems, since it is sparse, has a small memory footprint and requires no external libraries. We compare its performance against other approaches from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024; v1 submitted 18 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Tractable robust MPC design based on nominal predictions
Authors:
Ignacio Alvarado,
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
Many popular approaches in the field of robust model predictive control (MPC) are based on nominal predictions. This paper presents a novel formulation of this class of controller with proven input-to-state stability and robust constraint satisfaction. Its advantages are: (i) the design of its main ingredients are tractable for medium to large-sized systems, (ii) the terminal set does not need to…
▽ More
Many popular approaches in the field of robust model predictive control (MPC) are based on nominal predictions. This paper presents a novel formulation of this class of controller with proven input-to-state stability and robust constraint satisfaction. Its advantages are: (i) the design of its main ingredients are tractable for medium to large-sized systems, (ii) the terminal set does not need to be robust with respect to all the possible system uncertainties, but only for a reduced set that can be made arbitrarily small, thus facilitating its design and implementation, (iii) under certain conditions the terminal set can be taken as a positive invariant set of the nominal system, allowing us to use a terminal equality constraint, which facilitates its application to large-scale systems, and (iv) the complexity of its optimization problem is comparable to the non-robust MPC variant. We show numerical closed-loop results of its application to a multivariable chemical plant and compare it against other robust MPC formulations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2022; v1 submitted 13 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Real-time implementation of MPC for tracking in embedded systems: Application to a two-wheeled inverted pendulum
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Jose Camara,
Ignacio Alvarado,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
This article presents the real-time implementation of the model predictive control for tracking formulation to control a two-wheeled inverted pendulum robot. This formulation offers several advantages over standard MPC formulations at the expense of the addition of a small number of decision variables, which complicates the inner structure of the matrices of the optimization problem. We implement…
▽ More
This article presents the real-time implementation of the model predictive control for tracking formulation to control a two-wheeled inverted pendulum robot. This formulation offers several advantages over standard MPC formulations at the expense of the addition of a small number of decision variables, which complicates the inner structure of the matrices of the optimization problem. We implement a sparse solver, based on an extension of the alternating direction method of multipliers, in the system's embedded hardware. The results indicate that the solver is suitable for controlling a real system with sample times in the range of milliseconds using current, readily-available hardware.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Implementation of model predictive control for tracking in embedded systems using a sparse extended ADMM algorithm
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Ignacio Alvarado,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
This article presents a sparse, low-memory footprint optimization algorithm for the implementation of the model predictive control (MPC) for tracking formulation in embedded systems. This MPC formulation has several advantages over standard MPC formulations, such as an increased domain of attraction and guaranteed recursive feasibility even in the event of a sudden reference change. However, this…
▽ More
This article presents a sparse, low-memory footprint optimization algorithm for the implementation of the model predictive control (MPC) for tracking formulation in embedded systems. This MPC formulation has several advantages over standard MPC formulations, such as an increased domain of attraction and guaranteed recursive feasibility even in the event of a sudden reference change. However, this comes at the expense of the addition of a small amount of decision variables to the MPC's optimization problem that complicates the structure of its matrices. We propose a sparse optimization algorithm, based on an extension of the alternating direction method of multipliers, that exploits the structure of this particular MPC formulation. We describe the controller formulation and detail how its structure is exploited by means of the aforementioned optimization algorithm. We show closed-loop simulations comparing the proposed solver against other solvers and approaches from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2021; v1 submitted 20 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Harmonic based model predictive control for set-point tracking
Authors:
Pablo Krupa,
Daniel Limon,
Teodoro Alamo
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel model predictive control (MPC) formulation for set-point tracking. Stabilizing predictive controllers based on terminal ingredients may exhibit stability and feasibility issues in the event of a reference change for small to moderate prediction horizons. In the MPC for tracking formulation, these issues are solved by the addition of an artificial equilibrium point as a…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel model predictive control (MPC) formulation for set-point tracking. Stabilizing predictive controllers based on terminal ingredients may exhibit stability and feasibility issues in the event of a reference change for small to moderate prediction horizons. In the MPC for tracking formulation, these issues are solved by the addition of an artificial equilibrium point as a new decision variable, providing a significantly enlarged domain of attraction and guaranteeing recursive feasibility for any reference change. However, it may suffer from performance issues if the prediction horizon is not large enough. This paper presents an extension of this formulation where a harmonic artificial reference is used in place of the equilibrium point. The proposed formulation achieves even greater domains of attraction and can significantly outperform other MPC formulations when the prediction horizon is small. We prove the asymptotic stability and recursive feasibility of the proposed controller, as well as provide guidelines for the design of its main ingredients. Finally, we highlight its advantages with a case study of a ball and plate system.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2021; v1 submitted 16 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
