-
OpenAirLink: Reproducible Wireless Channel Emulation using Software Defined Radios
Authors:
Yash Deshpande,
Xianglong Wang,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
This paper presents OpenAirLink(OAL), an open-source channel emulator for reproducible testing of wireless scenarios. OAL is implemented on off-the-shelf software-defined radios (SDR) and presents a smaller-scale alternative to expensive commercially available channel emulators. Path loss and propagation delay are the fundamental aspects of emulating a wireless channel. OAL provides a simple metho…
▽ More
This paper presents OpenAirLink(OAL), an open-source channel emulator for reproducible testing of wireless scenarios. OAL is implemented on off-the-shelf software-defined radios (SDR) and presents a smaller-scale alternative to expensive commercially available channel emulators. Path loss and propagation delay are the fundamental aspects of emulating a wireless channel. OAL provides a simple method to change these aspects in real-time. The emulator is implemented using a finite impulse response (FIR) filter. The FIR filter is written in Verilog and flashed on the SDRs Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA). Most processing transpires on the FPGA, so OAL does not require high-performance computing hardware and SDRs. We validate the performance of OAL and demonstrate the utility of such a channel emulation tool using two examples. We believe that open-source channel emulators such as OAL can make reproducible wireless experiments accessible to many researchers in the scientific community.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Evaluation and Optimization of Positional Accuracy for Maritime Positioning Systems
Authors:
Atilla Alpay Nalcaci,
Fidan Mehmeti,
Wolfgang Kellerer,
Florian Schiegg
Abstract:
Navigation and trajectorial estimation of maritime vessels are contingent upon the context of positional accuracy. Even the smallest deviations in the estimation of a given vessel may result in detrimental consequences in terms of economic and ecologic quotients. To ensure an agile and precise environment for maritime vessel positional estimation, preexisting marine radar technologies can be utili…
▽ More
Navigation and trajectorial estimation of maritime vessels are contingent upon the context of positional accuracy. Even the smallest deviations in the estimation of a given vessel may result in detrimental consequences in terms of economic and ecologic quotients. To ensure an agile and precise environment for maritime vessel positional estimation, preexisting marine radar technologies can be utilized in a way that ensures a higher level of precision compared to GNSS-based identification and positioning. In this paper, we present a positional optimization for radarbased vessel navigation systems that utilize the installment of vessel detection sensors. The main objective of this research is to employ as fewer sensors as possible while preserving the attainable error threshold for positioning that is defined by International Maritime Organization (IMO). Our approach leads most of the time to a positioning error of up to 5 m along shorelines and rivers and up to 50 m along open coastal regions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Enabling Communication and Control Co-Design in 6G Networks
Authors:
Onur Ayan,
Nikolaos Pappas,
Miguel Angel Gutierrez Estevez,
Xueli An,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Networked control systems (NCSs), which are feedback control loops closed over a communication network, have been a popular research topic over the past decades. Numerous works in the literature propose novel algorithms and protocols with joint consideration of communication and control. However, the vast majority of the recent research results, which have shown remarkable performance improvements…
▽ More
Networked control systems (NCSs), which are feedback control loops closed over a communication network, have been a popular research topic over the past decades. Numerous works in the literature propose novel algorithms and protocols with joint consideration of communication and control. However, the vast majority of the recent research results, which have shown remarkable performance improvements if a cross-layer methodology is followed, have not been widely adopted by the industry. In this work, we review the shortcomings of today's mobile networks that render cross-layer solutions, such as semantic and goal-oriented communications, very challenging in practice. To tackle this, we propose a new framework for 6G user plane design that simplifies the adoption of recent research results in networked control, thereby facilitating the joint communication and control design in next-generation mobile networks.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Experimental Study of Transport Layer Protocols for Wireless Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Polina Kutsevol,
Onur Ayan,
Nikolaos Pappas,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
In Wireless Networked Control Systems (WNCSs), the feedback control loops are closed over a wireless communication network. The proliferation of WNCSs requires efficient network resource management mechanisms since the control performance is significantly affected by the impairments caused by network limitations. In conventional communication networks, the amount of transmitted data is one of the…
▽ More
In Wireless Networked Control Systems (WNCSs), the feedback control loops are closed over a wireless communication network. The proliferation of WNCSs requires efficient network resource management mechanisms since the control performance is significantly affected by the impairments caused by network limitations. In conventional communication networks, the amount of transmitted data is one of the key performance indicators. In contrast, in WNCSs, the efficiency of the network is measured by its ability to facilitate control applications, and the data transmission rate should be limited to avoid network congestion. In this work, we consider an experimental setup where multiple control loops share a wireless communication network. Our testbed comprises up to five control loops that include Zolertia Re-Mote devices implementing IEEE 802.15.4 standard. We propose a novel relevance- and network-aware transport layer (TL) scheme for WNCSs. The proposed scheme admits the most important measurements for the control process into the network while taking current network conditions into account. Moreover, we propose a mechanism for the scheme parameters adaptation in dynamic scenarios with unknown network statistics. Unlike the conventional TL mechanisms failing to provide adequate control performance due to either congestion in the network or inefficient utilization of available resources, our method prevents network congestion while kee** the control performance high. We argue that relevance- and network-awareness are critical components of network protocol design to avoid control performance degradation in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2023; v1 submitted 18 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Towards Semantic-Aware Transport Layer Protocols: A Control Performance Perspective
Authors:
Polina Kutsevol,
Onur Ayan,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Networked control systems (NCSs) are an example of task-oriented communication systems, where the purpose of communication is real-time control of processes over a network. In the context of NCSs, with the processes sending their state measurements to the remote controllers, the deterioration of control performance due to the network congestion can be partly mitigated by sha** the traffic inject…
▽ More
Networked control systems (NCSs) are an example of task-oriented communication systems, where the purpose of communication is real-time control of processes over a network. In the context of NCSs, with the processes sending their state measurements to the remote controllers, the deterioration of control performance due to the network congestion can be partly mitigated by sha** the traffic injected into the network at the transport layer (TL). In this work, we conduct an extensive performance evaluation of selected TL protocols and show that existing approaches from communication and control theories fail to deliver sufficient control performance in realistic network scenarios. Moreover, we propose a new semantic-aware TL policy, which uses the process state information to filter the most relevant updates and the network state information to prevent delays due to network congestion. The proposed mechanism is shown to outperform all the considered TL protocols with respect to control performance.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Task-oriented Scheduling for Networked Control Systems: An Age of Information-Aware Implementation on Software-defined Radios
Authors:
Onur Ayan,
Polina Kutsevol,
Hasan Yağız Özkan,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Networked control systems (NCSs) are feedback control loops that are closed over a communication network. Emerging applications, such as telerobotics, drones and autonomous driving are the most prominent examples of such systems. Regular and timely information sharing between the components of NCSs is essential to fulfill the desired control tasks, as stale information can lead to performance degr…
▽ More
Networked control systems (NCSs) are feedback control loops that are closed over a communication network. Emerging applications, such as telerobotics, drones and autonomous driving are the most prominent examples of such systems. Regular and timely information sharing between the components of NCSs is essential to fulfill the desired control tasks, as stale information can lead to performance degradation or even physical damage. In this work, we consider multiple heterogeneous NCSs that transmit their system state over a shared physical wireless channel towards a gateway node. We conduct a comprehensive experimental study on selected MAC protocols using software-defined radios with state-of-the-art (SotA) solutions that have been designed to increase information freshness and control performance. As a significant improvement over the SotA, we propose a novel contention-free algorithm that is able to outperform the existing solutions by combining their strengths in one protocol. In addition, we propose a new metric called normalized mean squared error that maps the age of information to a dimensionless quantity that captures the expected value of a control system's next transmission. We demonstrate its adoption and effectiveness for wireless resource scheduling in a case study involving multiple inverted pendulums. From our experimental study and results, we observe that value-aware prioritization of the sub-systems contributes to minimizing the negative effects of information staleness on control performance. In particular, as the number of devices increases, the benefit of control-awareness to the quality of control stands out when compared to protocols that focus solely on maximizing information freshness.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2022; v1 submitted 18 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
AoI-based Finite Horizon Scheduling for Heterogeneous Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Onur Ayan,
H. Murat Gürsu,
Sandra Hirche,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Age of information (AoI) measures information freshness at the receiver. AoI may provide insights into quality of service in communication systems. For this reason, it has been used as a cross-layer metric for wireless communication protocols. In this work, we employ AoI to calculate penalty functions for a centralized resource scheduling problem. We consider a single wireless link shared by multi…
▽ More
Age of information (AoI) measures information freshness at the receiver. AoI may provide insights into quality of service in communication systems. For this reason, it has been used as a cross-layer metric for wireless communication protocols. In this work, we employ AoI to calculate penalty functions for a centralized resource scheduling problem. We consider a single wireless link shared by multiple, heterogeneous control systems where each sub-system has a time-varying packet loss probability. Sub-systems are competing for network resources to improve the accuracy of their remote estimation process. In order to cope with the dynamically changing conditions of the wireless link, we define a finite horizon age-penalty minimization problem and propose a scheduler that takes optimal decisions by looking $H$ slots into the future. The proposed algorithm has a worst-case complexity that grows exponentially with $H$. However, by narrowing down our search space within the constrained set of actions, we are able to decrease the complexity significantly without losing optimality. On the contrary, we show by simulations that the benefit of increasing $H$ w.r.t. remote state estimation performance diminishes after a certain $H$ value.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Probability Analysis of Age of Information in Multi-hop Networks
Authors:
Onur Ayan,
H. Murat Gürsu,
Arled Papa,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Age-of-information (AoI) is a metric quantifying information freshness at the receiver. It captures the delay together with packet loss and packet generation rate. However, the existing literature focuses on average or peak AoI and neglects the complete distribution. In this work, we consider a N-hop network with time-invariant packet loss probabilities on each link. We derive closed form equation…
▽ More
Age-of-information (AoI) is a metric quantifying information freshness at the receiver. It captures the delay together with packet loss and packet generation rate. However, the existing literature focuses on average or peak AoI and neglects the complete distribution. In this work, we consider a N-hop network with time-invariant packet loss probabilities on each link. We derive closed form equations for the probability mass function of AoI. We verify our findings with simulations. Our results show that the performance indicators considered in the literature such as average or peak AoI may give misleading insights into the real AoI performance.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2020; v1 submitted 22 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Boost Your CotS IEEE 802.15.4 Network with Inter-Slot Interference Cancellation for Industrial IoT
Authors:
H. Murat Gürsu,
Hansini Vijayaraghavan,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
The current cellular standardization for 5G is working towards wireless advances to enable further productivity for industrial automation. However, this development will take several years. Meanwhile, the capabilities of the currently available standards should be pushed to their limits. To this end, in this work, we present results from the first inter-slot successive interference cancellation te…
▽ More
The current cellular standardization for 5G is working towards wireless advances to enable further productivity for industrial automation. However, this development will take several years. Meanwhile, the capabilities of the currently available standards should be pushed to their limits. To this end, in this work, we present results from the first inter-slot successive interference cancellation testbed using commercial off the shelf IEEE 802.15.4 sensors. Through our implementation, we have measured a throughput of $0.72$ packets per slot which doubles the currently used contention-based access, Slotted ALOHA, with a limit of $0.36$ packets per slot. The hardware effects of the boards, which degrade the successive interference cancellation performance from the theoretical limit of $1$ packet per slot, are modeled and validated through measurements. We also propose a model that can be used to calculate the expected successive interference cancellation throughput with the specific hardware available in a factory. Furthermore, our proposed model should replace the perfect physical layer assumptions for researchers to design new MAC algorithms taking practical limitations into account.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Joint Cross-layer Optimization in Real-Time Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Markus Klügel,
Mohammad H. Mamduhi,
Onur Ayan,
Mikhail Vilgelm,
Karl H. Johansson,
Sandra Hirche,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Networked control system (NCS) refer to a set of control loops that are closed over a communication network. In this article, the joint operation of control and networking for NCS is investigated wherein the network serves the sensor-to-controller communication links for multiple stochastic linear time-invariant (LTI) sub-systems. The sensors sample packets based on the observed plant state, which…
▽ More
Networked control system (NCS) refer to a set of control loops that are closed over a communication network. In this article, the joint operation of control and networking for NCS is investigated wherein the network serves the sensor-to-controller communication links for multiple stochastic linear time-invariant (LTI) sub-systems. The sensors sample packets based on the observed plant state, which they send over a shared multi-hop network. The network has limited communication resources, which need to be assigned to competing links to support proper control loop operation. In this set-up, we formulate an optimization problem to minimize the weighted-sum linear-quadratic-Gaussian (LQG) cost of all loops, taking into account the admissible sampling, control, congestion control and scheduling policies. Under some mild assumptions on the sampling frequencies of the control loops and the communication network, we find the joint optimal solution to be given by a certainty equivalence control with threshold-based sampling policy, as well as a back-pressure type scheduler with a simple pass-through congestion control. The interface between network and control loops is identified to be the buffer state of the sensor node, which can be interpreted as network price for sampling a packet from control perspective. We validate our theoretical claims by simulating NCSs comprising of multiple LTI stochastic control loops communicating over a two-hop cellular network.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Transmission Power Control for Remote State Estimation in Industrial Wireless Sensor Networks
Authors:
Samuele Zoppi,
Touraj Soleymani,
Markus Klügel,
Mikhail Vilgelm,
Sandra Hirche,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Novel low-power wireless technologies and IoT applications open the door to the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT). In this new paradigm, Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) must fulfil, despite energy and transmission power limitations, the challenging communication requirements of advanced manufacturing processes and technologies. In industrial networks, this is possible thanks to the availability…
▽ More
Novel low-power wireless technologies and IoT applications open the door to the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT). In this new paradigm, Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) must fulfil, despite energy and transmission power limitations, the challenging communication requirements of advanced manufacturing processes and technologies. In industrial networks, this is possible thanks to the availability of network infrastructure and the presence of a network coordinator that efficiently allocates the available radio resources. In this work, we consider a WSN that simultaneously transmits measurements of Networked Control Systems' (NCSs) dynamics to remote state estimators over a shared packet-erasure channel. We develop a minimum transmission power control (TPC) policy for the coordination of the wireless medium by formulating an infinite horizon Markov decision process (MDP) optimization problem. We compute the policy using an approximate value iteration algorithm and provide an extensive evaluation of its parameters in different interference scenarios and NCSs dynamics. The evaluation results present a comprehensive characterization of the algorithm's performance, proving that it can flexibly adapt to arbitrary use cases.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Age-of-Information vs. Value-of-Information Scheduling for Cellular Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Onur Ayan,
Mikhail Vilgelm,
Markus Klügel,
Sandra Hirche,
Wolfgang Kellerer
Abstract:
Age-of-Information (AoI) is a recently introduced metric for network operation with sensor applications which quantifies the freshness of data. In the context of networked control systems (NCSs), we compare the worth of the AoI metric with the value-of-information (VoI) metric, which is related to the uncertainty reduction in stochastic processes. First, we show that the uncertainty propagates non…
▽ More
Age-of-Information (AoI) is a recently introduced metric for network operation with sensor applications which quantifies the freshness of data. In the context of networked control systems (NCSs), we compare the worth of the AoI metric with the value-of-information (VoI) metric, which is related to the uncertainty reduction in stochastic processes. First, we show that the uncertainty propagates non-linearly over time depending on system dynamics. Next, we define the value of a new update of the process of interest as a function of AoI and system parameters of the NCSs. We use the aggregated update value as a utility for the centralized scheduling problem in a cellular NCS composed of multiple heterogeneous control loops. By conducting a simulative analysis, we show that prioritizing transmissions with higher VoI improves performance of the NCSs compared with providing fair data freshness to all sub-systems equally.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Design of a Networked Controller for a Two-Wheeled Inverted Pendulum Robot
Authors:
Zenit Music,
Fabio Molinari,
Sebastian Gallenmüller,
Onur Ayan,
Samuele Zoppi,
Wolfgang Kellerer,
Georg Carle,
Thomas Seel,
Jörg Raisch
Abstract:
The topic of this paper is to use an intuitive model-based approach to design a networked controller for a recent benchmark scenario. The benchmark problem is to remotely control a two-wheeled inverted pendulum robot via W-LAN communication. The robot has to keep a vertical upright position. Incorporating wireless communication in the control loop introduces multiple uncertainties and affects syst…
▽ More
The topic of this paper is to use an intuitive model-based approach to design a networked controller for a recent benchmark scenario. The benchmark problem is to remotely control a two-wheeled inverted pendulum robot via W-LAN communication. The robot has to keep a vertical upright position. Incorporating wireless communication in the control loop introduces multiple uncertainties and affects system performance and stability. The proposed networked control scheme employs model predictive techniques and deliberately extends delays in order to make them constant and deterministic. The performance of the resulting networked control system is evaluated experimentally with a predefined benchmarking experiment and is compared to local control involving no delays.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2019; v1 submitted 7 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
