-
Sha** Nonlinearity in Reset Controllers for Precision Motion Systems
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
The precision motion industry has an ever-increasing demand for faster, more precise and more robust controllers. From the perspective of frequency domain and loopsha** technique, this demand has pushed the linear controllers to their inherent limits, namely, the waterbed effect and Bode's phase-gain relationship. Mathematically, complex-order transfer functions are not bound by Bode's phase-gai…
▽ More
The precision motion industry has an ever-increasing demand for faster, more precise and more robust controllers. From the perspective of frequency domain and loopsha** technique, this demand has pushed the linear controllers to their inherent limits, namely, the waterbed effect and Bode's phase-gain relationship. Mathematically, complex-order transfer functions are not bound by Bode's phase-gain relationship. However, implementing them in practice is a challenge to be solved. This extended abstract will show review the previous work of the authors in sha** nonlinearities in reset controllers and contribute and propose an overall architecture for reset control systems to approximate complex order controllers.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Complex-order Reset Control System
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
According to the well-known loop sha** method for the design of controllers, the performance of the controllers in terms of step response, steady-state disturbance rejection and noise attenuation and robustness can be improved by increasing the gain at lower frequencies and decreasing it at higher frequencies and increasing the phase margin as much as possible. However, the inherent properties o…
▽ More
According to the well-known loop sha** method for the design of controllers, the performance of the controllers in terms of step response, steady-state disturbance rejection and noise attenuation and robustness can be improved by increasing the gain at lower frequencies and decreasing it at higher frequencies and increasing the phase margin as much as possible. However, the inherent properties of linear controllers, the Bode's phase-gain relation, create a limitation. In theory, a complex-order transfer function can break the Bode's gain-phase relation; however, such transfer function cannot be directly implemented and should be approximated. This paper proposes a reset element and a tuning method to approximate a Complex-Order Controller (CLOC) and, through a simulation example, shows the benefits of using such a controller.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Continuous reset element: Transient and steady-state analysis for precision motion systems
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper addresses the main goal of using reset control in precision motion control systems, breaking of the well-known "Waterbed effect". A new architecture for reset elements will be introduced which has a continuous output signal as opposed to conventional reset elements. A steady-state precision study is presented, showing the steady-state precision is preserved while the peak of sensitivity…
▽ More
This paper addresses the main goal of using reset control in precision motion control systems, breaking of the well-known "Waterbed effect". A new architecture for reset elements will be introduced which has a continuous output signal as opposed to conventional reset elements. A steady-state precision study is presented, showing the steady-state precision is preserved while the peak of sensitivity is reduced. The architecture is then used for a "Constant in Gain Lead in Phase" (CgLp) element and a numerical analysis on transient response shows a significant improvement in transient response. It is shown that by following the presented guideline for tuning, settling time can be reduced and at the same time a non-overshoot step response can be achieved. A practical example is presented to verify the results and also to show that the proposed element can achieve a complex-order behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022; v1 submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Stacking Integrators Without Sacrificing the Overshoot in Reset Control Systems
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
According to the well-known loop-sha** control design approach, the steady-state precision of control systems can be improved by stacking integrators. However, due to the waterbed effect in linear control systems, such an action will worsen the transient response by increasing overshoot and creating wind-up problems. This paper presents a new architecture for rest control systems that can signif…
▽ More
According to the well-known loop-sha** control design approach, the steady-state precision of control systems can be improved by stacking integrators. However, due to the waterbed effect in linear control systems, such an action will worsen the transient response by increasing overshoot and creating wind-up problems. This paper presents a new architecture for rest control systems that can significantly decrease the overshoot and create a no-overshoot performance even in presence of stacked integrators. The steady-state analysis of the proposed system will also show that improved precision expected due to stacked integrators can be achieved as well. A numerical simulation study is presented to verify the results and the tuning guide presented.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Fractional-Order Single State Reset Element
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
Niranjan Saikumar,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper proposes a fractional-order reset element whose architecture allows for the suppression of nonlinear effects for a range of frequencies. Suppressing the nonlinear effects of a reset element for the desired frequency range while maintaining it for the rest is beneficial, especially when it is used in the framework of a "Constant in gain, Lead in phase" (CgLp) filter. CgLp is a newly intr…
▽ More
This paper proposes a fractional-order reset element whose architecture allows for the suppression of nonlinear effects for a range of frequencies. Suppressing the nonlinear effects of a reset element for the desired frequency range while maintaining it for the rest is beneficial, especially when it is used in the framework of a "Constant in gain, Lead in phase" (CgLp) filter. CgLp is a newly introduced nonlinear filter, bound to circumvent the well-known linear control limitation -- the waterbed effect. The ideal behaviour of such a filter in the frequency domain is unity gain while providing a phase lead for a broad range of frequencies. However, CgLp's ideal behaviour is based on the describing function, which is a first-order approximation that neglects the effects of the higher-order harmonics in the output of the filter. Although CgLp is fundamentally a nonlinear filter, its nonlinearity is not required for all frequencies. Thus, it is shown in this paper that using the proposed reset element architecture, CgLp gets closer to its ideal behaviour for a range of frequencies, and its performance will be improved accordingly.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Band-Passing Nonlinearity in Reset Elements
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
Ali Ahmadi Dastjerdi,
Niranjan Saikumar,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper addresses nonlinearity in reset elements and their effects. Reset elements are known for having less phase lag compared to their linear counterparts; however, they are nonlinear elements and produce higher-order harmonics. This paper investigates the higher-order harmonics for reset elements with one resetting state and proposes an architecture and a method of design which allows for ba…
▽ More
This paper addresses nonlinearity in reset elements and their effects. Reset elements are known for having less phase lag compared to their linear counterparts; however, they are nonlinear elements and produce higher-order harmonics. This paper investigates the higher-order harmonics for reset elements with one resetting state and proposes an architecture and a method of design which allows for band-passing the nonlinearity and its effects, namely, higher-order harmonics and phase advantage. The nonlinearity of reset elements is not entirely useful for all frequencies, e.g., they are useful for reducing phase lag at cross-over frequency region; however, higher-order harmonics can compromise tracking and disturbance rejection performance at lower frequencies. Using proposed "phase sha**" method, one can selectively suppress nonlinearity of a single-state reset element in a desired range of frequencies and allow the nonlinearity to provide its phase benefit in a different desired range of frequencies. This can be especially useful for the reset elements in the framework of "Constant in gain, Lead in phase" (CgLp) filter, which is a newly introduced nonlinear filter, bound to circumvent the well-known linear control limitation -- the waterbed effect.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Tuning of CgLp based reset controllers: Application in precision positioning systems
Authors:
Mahmoud Shirdast Bahnamiri,
Nima Karbasizadeh,
Ali Ahmadi Dastjerdi,
Niranjan Saikumar,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper presents the tuning of a reset-based element called "Constant in gain and Lead in phase" (CgLp) in order to achieve desired precision performance in tracking and steady state. CgLp has been recently introduced to overcome the inherent linear control limitation - the waterbed effect. The analysis of reset controllers including ones based on CgLp is mainly carried out in the frequency dom…
▽ More
This paper presents the tuning of a reset-based element called "Constant in gain and Lead in phase" (CgLp) in order to achieve desired precision performance in tracking and steady state. CgLp has been recently introduced to overcome the inherent linear control limitation - the waterbed effect. The analysis of reset controllers including ones based on CgLp is mainly carried out in the frequency domain using describing function with the assumption that the relatively large magnitude of the first harmonic provides a good approximation. While this is true for several cases, the existence of higher-order harmonics in the output of these elements complicates their analysis and tuning in the control design process for high precision motion applications, where they cannot be neglected. While some numerical observation-based approaches have been considered in literature for the tuning of CgLp elements, a systematic approach based on the analysis of higher-order harmonics is found to be lacking. This paper analyzes the CgLp behaviour from the perspective of first as well as higher-order harmonics and presents simple relations between the tuning parameters and the gain-phase behaviour of all the harmonics, which can be used for better tuning of these elements. The presented relations are used for tuning a controller for a high-precision positioning stage and results used for validation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Benefiting from Linear Behaviour of a Nonlinear Reset-based Element at Certain Frequencies
Authors:
Nima Karbasizadeh,
Ali Ahmadi Dastjerdi,
Niranjan Saikumar,
Duarte Valerio,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper addresses a phenomenon caused by resetting only one of the two states of a so-called second order "Constant in gain Lead in phase" (CgLp) element. CgLp is a recently introduced reset-based nonlinear element, bound to circumvent the well-known linear control limitation -- the waterbed effect. The ideal behaviour of such a filter in the frequency domain is unity gain while providing a pha…
▽ More
This paper addresses a phenomenon caused by resetting only one of the two states of a so-called second order "Constant in gain Lead in phase" (CgLp) element. CgLp is a recently introduced reset-based nonlinear element, bound to circumvent the well-known linear control limitation -- the waterbed effect. The ideal behaviour of such a filter in the frequency domain is unity gain while providing a phase lead for a broad range of frequencies, which clearly violates the linear Bode's gain phase relationship. However, CgLp's ideal behaviour is based on a describing function, which is a first order approximation that neglects the effects of higher order harmonics in the output of the filter. Consequently, achieving the ideal behaviour is challenging when higher order harmonics are relatively large. It is shown in this paper that by resetting only one of the two states of a second order CgLp, the nonlinear filter will act as a linear one at a certain frequency, provided that some conditions are met. This phenomenon can be used to the benefit of reducing higher order harmonics of CgLp's output and achieving the ideal behaviour and thus better performance in terms of precision.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Closed-Loop Frequency Analysis of Reset Control Systems
Authors:
Ali Ahmadi Dastjerdi,
A. Astolfi,
Niranjan Saikumar,
N. Karbasizadeh,
Duarte Valerio,
S. Hassan HosseinNia
Abstract:
This paper introduces a closed-loop frequency analysis tool for reset control systems. To begin with sufficient conditions for the existence of the steady-state response for a closed-loop system with a reset element and driven by periodic references are provided. It is then shown that, under specific conditions, such a steady-state response for periodic inputs is periodic with the same period as t…
▽ More
This paper introduces a closed-loop frequency analysis tool for reset control systems. To begin with sufficient conditions for the existence of the steady-state response for a closed-loop system with a reset element and driven by periodic references are provided. It is then shown that, under specific conditions, such a steady-state response for periodic inputs is periodic with the same period as the input. Furthermore, a framework to obtain the steady-state response and to define a notion of closed-loop frequency response, including high order harmonics, is presented. Finally, pseudo-sensitivities for reset control systems are defined. These simplify the analysis of this class of systems and allow a direct software implementation of the analysis tool. To show the effectiveness of the proposed analysis method the position control problem for a precision positioning stage is studied. In particular, comparison with the results achieved using methods based on the Describing Function shows that the proposed method achieves superior closed-loop performance.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020; v1 submitted 28 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.