-
Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data
Authors:
Gil Keren,
Wei Zhou,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with token-specific weights…
▽ More
ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Effective internal language model training and fusion for factorized transducer model
Authors:
**xi Guo,
Niko Moritz,
Yingyi Ma,
Frank Seide,
Chunyang Wu,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Christian Fuegen,
Mike Seltzer
Abstract:
The internal language model (ILM) of the neural transducer has been widely studied. In most prior work, it is mainly used for estimating the ILM score and is subsequently subtracted during inference to facilitate improved integration with external language models. Recently, various of factorized transducer models have been proposed, which explicitly embrace a standalone internal language model for…
▽ More
The internal language model (ILM) of the neural transducer has been widely studied. In most prior work, it is mainly used for estimating the ILM score and is subsequently subtracted during inference to facilitate improved integration with external language models. Recently, various of factorized transducer models have been proposed, which explicitly embrace a standalone internal language model for non-blank token prediction. However, even with the adoption of factorized transducer models, limited improvement has been observed compared to shallow fusion. In this paper, we propose a novel ILM training and decoding strategy for factorized transducer models, which effectively combines the blank, acoustic and ILM scores. Our experiments show a 17% relative improvement over the standard decoding method when utilizing a well-trained ILM and the proposed decoding strategy on LibriSpeech datasets. Furthermore, when compared to a strong RNN-T baseline enhanced with external LM fusion, the proposed model yields a 5.5% relative improvement on general-sets and an 8.9% WER reduction for rare words. The proposed model can achieve superior performance without relying on external language models, rendering it highly efficient for production use-cases. To further improve the performance, we propose a novel and memory-efficient ILM-fusion-aware minimum word error rate (MWER) training method which improves ILM integration significantly.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Correction Focused Language Model Training for Speech Recognition
Authors:
Yingyi Ma,
Zhe Liu,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
Language models (LMs) have been commonly adopted to boost the performance of automatic speech recognition (ASR) particularly in domain adaptation tasks. Conventional way of LM training treats all the words in corpora equally, resulting in suboptimal improvements in ASR performance. In this work, we introduce a novel correction focused LM training approach which aims to prioritize ASR fallible word…
▽ More
Language models (LMs) have been commonly adopted to boost the performance of automatic speech recognition (ASR) particularly in domain adaptation tasks. Conventional way of LM training treats all the words in corpora equally, resulting in suboptimal improvements in ASR performance. In this work, we introduce a novel correction focused LM training approach which aims to prioritize ASR fallible words. The word-level ASR fallibility score, representing the likelihood of ASR mis-recognition, is defined and shaped as a prior word distribution to guide the LM training. To enable correction focused training with text-only corpora, large language models (LLMs) are employed as fallibility score predictors and text generators through multi-task fine-tuning. Experimental results for domain adaptation tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method. Compared with conventional LMs, correction focused training achieves up to relatively 5.5% word error rate (WER) reduction in sufficient text scenarios. In insufficient text scenarios, LM training with LLM-generated text achieves up to relatively 13% WER reduction, while correction focused training further obtains up to relatively 6% WER reduction.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Dynamic ASR Pathways: An Adaptive Masking Approach Towards Efficient Pruning of A Multilingual ASR Model
Authors:
Jiamin Xie,
Ke Li,
**xi Guo,
Andros Tjandra,
Yuan Shangguan,
Leda Sari,
Chunyang Wu,
Junteng Jia,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
Neural network pruning offers an effective method for compressing a multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) model with minimal performance loss. However, it entails several rounds of pruning and re-training needed to be run for each language. In this work, we propose the use of an adaptive masking approach in two scenarios for pruning a multilingual ASR model efficiently, each resulting in…
▽ More
Neural network pruning offers an effective method for compressing a multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) model with minimal performance loss. However, it entails several rounds of pruning and re-training needed to be run for each language. In this work, we propose the use of an adaptive masking approach in two scenarios for pruning a multilingual ASR model efficiently, each resulting in sparse monolingual models or a sparse multilingual model (named as Dynamic ASR Pathways). Our approach dynamically adapts the sub-network, avoiding premature decisions about a fixed sub-network structure. We show that our approach outperforms existing pruning methods when targeting sparse monolingual models. Further, we illustrate that Dynamic ASR Pathways jointly discovers and trains better sub-networks (pathways) of a single multilingual model by adapting from different sub-network initializations, thereby reducing the need for language-specific pruning.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2024; v1 submitted 22 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
End-to-End Speech Recognition Contextualization with Large Language Models
Authors:
Egor Lakomkin,
Chunyang Wu,
Yassir Fathullah,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer,
Christian Fuegen
Abstract:
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention from the research community due to their exceptional performance and generalization capabilities. In this paper, we introduce a novel method for contextualizing speech recognition models incorporating LLMs. Our approach casts speech recognition as a mixed-modal language modeling task based on a pretrained LLM. We pro…
▽ More
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention from the research community due to their exceptional performance and generalization capabilities. In this paper, we introduce a novel method for contextualizing speech recognition models incorporating LLMs. Our approach casts speech recognition as a mixed-modal language modeling task based on a pretrained LLM. We provide audio features, along with optional text tokens for context, to train the system to complete transcriptions in a decoder-only fashion. As a result, the system is implicitly incentivized to learn how to leverage unstructured contextual information during training. Our empirical results demonstrate a significant improvement in performance, with a 6% WER reduction when additional textual context is provided. Moreover, we find that our method performs competitively and improve by 7.5% WER overall and 17% WER on rare words against a baseline contextualized RNN-T system that has been trained on more than twenty five times larger speech dataset. Overall, we demonstrate that by only adding a handful number of trainable parameters via adapters, we can unlock contextualized speech recognition capability for the pretrained LLM while kee** the same text-only input functionality.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Augmenting text for spoken language understanding with Large Language Models
Authors:
Roshan Sharma,
Suyoun Kim,
Daniel Lazar,
Trang Le,
Akshat Shrivastava,
Kwanghoon Ahn,
Piyush Kansal,
Leda Sari,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael Seltzer
Abstract:
Spoken semantic parsing (SSP) involves generating machine-comprehensible parses from input speech. Training robust models for existing application domains represented in training data or extending to new domains requires corresponding triplets of speech-transcript-semantic parse data, which is expensive to obtain. In this paper, we address this challenge by examining methods that can use transcrip…
▽ More
Spoken semantic parsing (SSP) involves generating machine-comprehensible parses from input speech. Training robust models for existing application domains represented in training data or extending to new domains requires corresponding triplets of speech-transcript-semantic parse data, which is expensive to obtain. In this paper, we address this challenge by examining methods that can use transcript-semantic parse data (unpaired text) without corresponding speech. First, when unpaired text is drawn from existing textual corpora, Joint Audio Text (JAT) and Text-to-Speech (TTS) are compared as ways to generate speech representations for unpaired text. Experiments on the STOP dataset show that unpaired text from existing and new domains improves performance by 2% and 30% in absolute Exact Match (EM) respectively. Second, we consider the setting when unpaired text is not available in existing textual corpora. We propose to prompt Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate unpaired text for existing and new domains. Experiments show that examples and words that co-occur with intents can be used to generate unpaired text with Llama 2.0. Using the generated text with JAT and TTS for spoken semantic parsing improves EM on STOP by 1.4% and 2.6% absolute for existing and new domains respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
TODM: Train Once Deploy Many Efficient Supernet-Based RNN-T Compression For On-device ASR Models
Authors:
Yuan Shangguan,
Haichuan Yang,
Danni Li,
Chunyang Wu,
Yassir Fathullah,
Dilin Wang,
Ayushi Dalmia,
Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Junteng Jia,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Xin Lei,
Mike Seltzer,
Vikas Chandra
Abstract:
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models need to be optimized for specific hardware before they can be deployed on devices. This can be done by tuning the model's hyperparameters or exploring variations in its architecture. Re-training and re-validating models after making these changes can be a resource-intensive task. This paper presents TODM (Train Once Deploy Many), a new approach to efficien…
▽ More
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models need to be optimized for specific hardware before they can be deployed on devices. This can be done by tuning the model's hyperparameters or exploring variations in its architecture. Re-training and re-validating models after making these changes can be a resource-intensive task. This paper presents TODM (Train Once Deploy Many), a new approach to efficiently train many sizes of hardware-friendly on-device ASR models with comparable GPU-hours to that of a single training job. TODM leverages insights from prior work on Supernet, where Recurrent Neural Network Transducer (RNN-T) models share weights within a Supernet. It reduces layer sizes and widths of the Supernet to obtain subnetworks, making them smaller models suitable for all hardware types. We introduce a novel combination of three techniques to improve the outcomes of the TODM Supernet: adaptive dropouts, an in-place Alpha-divergence knowledge distillation, and the use of ScaledAdam optimizer. We validate our approach by comparing Supernet-trained versus individually tuned Multi-Head State Space Model (MH-SSM) RNN-T using LibriSpeech. Results demonstrate that our TODM Supernet either matches or surpasses the performance of manually tuned models by up to a relative of 3% better in word error rate (WER), while efficiently kee** the cost of training many models at a small constant.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 5 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Contextual Biasing of Named-Entities with Large Language Models
Authors:
Chuanneng Sun,
Zeeshan Ahmed,
Yingyi Ma,
Zhe Liu,
Lucas Kabela,
Yutong Pang,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
This paper studies contextual biasing with Large Language Models (LLMs), where during second-pass rescoring additional contextual information is provided to a LLM to boost Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) performance. We propose to leverage prompts for a LLM without fine tuning during rescoring which incorporate a biasing list and few-shot examples to serve as additional information when calcula…
▽ More
This paper studies contextual biasing with Large Language Models (LLMs), where during second-pass rescoring additional contextual information is provided to a LLM to boost Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) performance. We propose to leverage prompts for a LLM without fine tuning during rescoring which incorporate a biasing list and few-shot examples to serve as additional information when calculating the score for the hypothesis. In addition to few-shot prompt learning, we propose multi-task training of the LLM to predict both the entity class and the next token. To improve the efficiency for contextual biasing and to avoid exceeding LLMs' maximum sequence lengths, we propose dynamic prompting, where we select the most likely class using the class tag prediction, and only use entities in this class as contexts for next token prediction. Word Error Rate (WER) evaluation is performed on i) an internal calling, messaging, and dictation dataset, and ii) the SLUE-Voxpopuli dataset. Results indicate that biasing lists and few-shot examples can achieve 17.8% and 9.6% relative improvement compared to first pass ASR, and that multi-task training and dynamic prompting can achieve 20.0% and 11.3% relative WER improvement, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2023; v1 submitted 1 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Modality Confidence Aware Training for Robust End-to-End Spoken Language Understanding
Authors:
Suyoun Kim,
Akshat Shrivastava,
Duc Le,
Ju Lin,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
End-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU) systems that generate a semantic parse from speech have become more promising recently. This approach uses a single model that utilizes audio and text representations from pre-trained speech recognition models (ASR), and outperforms traditional pipeline SLU systems in on-device streaming scenarios. However, E2E SLU systems still show weakness wh…
▽ More
End-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU) systems that generate a semantic parse from speech have become more promising recently. This approach uses a single model that utilizes audio and text representations from pre-trained speech recognition models (ASR), and outperforms traditional pipeline SLU systems in on-device streaming scenarios. However, E2E SLU systems still show weakness when text representation quality is low due to ASR transcription errors. To overcome this issue, we propose a novel E2E SLU system that enhances robustness to ASR errors by fusing audio and text representations based on the estimated modality confidence of ASR hypotheses. We introduce two novel techniques: 1) an effective method to encode the quality of ASR hypotheses and 2) an effective approach to integrate them into E2E SLU models. We show accuracy improvements on STOP dataset and share the analysis to demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Prompting Large Language Models with Speech Recognition Abilities
Authors:
Yassir Fathullah,
Chunyang Wu,
Egor Lakomkin,
Junteng Jia,
Yuan Shangguan,
Ke Li,
**xi Guo,
Wenhan Xiong,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Christian Fuegen,
Mike Seltzer
Abstract:
Large language models have proven themselves highly flexible, able to solve a wide range of generative tasks, such as abstractive summarization and open-ended question answering. In this paper we extend the capabilities of LLMs by directly attaching a small audio encoder allowing it to perform speech recognition. By directly prepending a sequence of audial embeddings to the text token embeddings,…
▽ More
Large language models have proven themselves highly flexible, able to solve a wide range of generative tasks, such as abstractive summarization and open-ended question answering. In this paper we extend the capabilities of LLMs by directly attaching a small audio encoder allowing it to perform speech recognition. By directly prepending a sequence of audial embeddings to the text token embeddings, the LLM can be converted to an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system, and be used in the exact same manner as its textual counterpart. Experiments on Multilingual LibriSpeech (MLS) show that incorporating a conformer encoder into the open sourced LLaMA-7B allows it to outperform monolingual baselines by 18% and perform multilingual speech recognition despite LLaMA being trained overwhelmingly on English text. Furthermore, we perform ablation studies to investigate whether the LLM can be completely frozen during training to maintain its original capabilities, scaling up the audio encoder, and increasing the audio encoder striding to generate fewer embeddings. The results from these studies show that multilingual ASR is possible even when the LLM is frozen or when strides of almost 1 second are used in the audio encoder opening up the possibility for LLMs to operate on long-form audio.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Towards Selection of Text-to-speech Data to Augment ASR Training
Authors:
Shuo Liu,
Leda Sarı,
Chunyang Wu,
Gil Keren,
Yuan Shangguan,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
This paper presents a method for selecting appropriate synthetic speech samples from a given large text-to-speech (TTS) dataset as supplementary training data for an automatic speech recognition (ASR) model. We trained a neural network, which can be optimised using cross-entropy loss or Arcface loss, to measure the similarity of a synthetic data to real speech. We found that incorporating syntheti…
▽ More
This paper presents a method for selecting appropriate synthetic speech samples from a given large text-to-speech (TTS) dataset as supplementary training data for an automatic speech recognition (ASR) model. We trained a neural network, which can be optimised using cross-entropy loss or Arcface loss, to measure the similarity of a synthetic data to real speech. We found that incorporating synthetic samples with considerable dissimilarity to real speech, owing in part to lexical differences, into ASR training is crucial for boosting recognition performance. Experimental results on Librispeech test sets indicate that, in order to maintain the same speech recognition accuracy as when using all TTS data, our proposed solution can reduce the size of the TTS data down below its $30\,\%$, which is superior to several baseline methods.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Multi-Head State Space Model for Speech Recognition
Authors:
Yassir Fathullah,
Chunyang Wu,
Yuan Shangguan,
Junteng Jia,
Wenhan Xiong,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Chunxi Liu,
Yangyang Shi,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Mike Seltzer,
Mark J. F. Gales
Abstract:
State space models (SSMs) have recently shown promising results on small-scale sequence and language modelling tasks, rivalling and outperforming many attention-based approaches. In this paper, we propose a multi-head state space (MH-SSM) architecture equipped with special gating mechanisms, where parallel heads are taught to learn local and global temporal dynamics on sequence data. As a drop-in…
▽ More
State space models (SSMs) have recently shown promising results on small-scale sequence and language modelling tasks, rivalling and outperforming many attention-based approaches. In this paper, we propose a multi-head state space (MH-SSM) architecture equipped with special gating mechanisms, where parallel heads are taught to learn local and global temporal dynamics on sequence data. As a drop-in replacement for multi-head attention in transformer encoders, this new model significantly outperforms the transformer transducer on the LibriSpeech speech recognition corpus. Furthermore, we augment the transformer block with MH-SSMs layers, referred to as the Stateformer, achieving state-of-the-art performance on the LibriSpeech task, with word error rates of 1.76\%/4.37\% on the development and 1.91\%/4.36\% on the test sets without using an external language model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023; v1 submitted 21 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Improving Fast-slow Encoder based Transducer with Streaming Deliberation
Authors:
Ke Li,
Jay Mahadeokar,
**xi Guo,
Yangyang Shi,
Gil Keren,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer,
Duc Le
Abstract:
This paper introduces a fast-slow encoder based transducer with streaming deliberation for end-to-end automatic speech recognition. We aim to improve the recognition accuracy of the fast-slow encoder based transducer while kee** its latency low by integrating a streaming deliberation model. Specifically, the deliberation model leverages partial hypotheses from the streaming fast encoder and impl…
▽ More
This paper introduces a fast-slow encoder based transducer with streaming deliberation for end-to-end automatic speech recognition. We aim to improve the recognition accuracy of the fast-slow encoder based transducer while kee** its latency low by integrating a streaming deliberation model. Specifically, the deliberation model leverages partial hypotheses from the streaming fast encoder and implicitly learns to correct recognition errors. We modify the parallel beam search algorithm for fast-slow encoder based transducer to be efficient and compatible with the deliberation model. In addition, the deliberation model is designed to process streaming data. To further improve the deliberation performance, a simple text augmentation approach is explored. We also compare LSTM and Conformer models for encoding partial hypotheses. Experiments on Librispeech and in-house data show relative WER reductions (WERRs) from 3% to 5% with a slight increase in model size and negligible extra token emission latency compared with fast-slow encoder based transducer. Compared with vanilla neural transducers, the proposed deliberation model together with fast-slow encoder based transducer obtains relative 10-11% WERRs on Librispeech and around relative 6% WERR on in-house data with smaller emission delays.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Massively Multilingual ASR on 70 Languages: Tokenization, Architecture, and Generalization Capabilities
Authors:
Andros Tjandra,
Nayan Singhal,
David Zhang,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Abdelrahman Mohamed,
Duc Le,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
End-to-end multilingual ASR has become more appealing because of several reasons such as simplifying the training and deployment process and positive performance transfer from high-resource to low-resource languages. However, scaling up the number of languages, total hours, and number of unique tokens is not a trivial task. This paper explores large-scale multilingual ASR models on 70 languages. W…
▽ More
End-to-end multilingual ASR has become more appealing because of several reasons such as simplifying the training and deployment process and positive performance transfer from high-resource to low-resource languages. However, scaling up the number of languages, total hours, and number of unique tokens is not a trivial task. This paper explores large-scale multilingual ASR models on 70 languages. We inspect two architectures: (1) Shared embedding and output and (2) Multiple embedding and output model. In the shared model experiments, we show the importance of tokenization strategy across different languages. Later, we use our optimal tokenization strategy to train multiple embedding and output model to further improve our result. Our multilingual ASR achieves 13.9%-15.6% average WER relative improvement compared to monolingual models. We show that our multilingual ASR generalizes well on an unseen dataset and domain, achieving 9.5% and 7.5% WER on Multilingual Librispeech (MLS) with zero-shot and finetuning, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Factorized Blank Thresholding for Improved Runtime Efficiency of Neural Transducers
Authors:
Duc Le,
Frank Seide,
Yuhao Wang,
Yang Li,
Kjell Schubert,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
We show how factoring the RNN-T's output distribution can significantly reduce the computation cost and power consumption for on-device ASR inference with no loss in accuracy. With the rise in popularity of neural-transducer type models like the RNN-T for on-device ASR, optimizing RNN-T's runtime efficiency is of great interest. While previous work has primarily focused on the optimization of RNN-…
▽ More
We show how factoring the RNN-T's output distribution can significantly reduce the computation cost and power consumption for on-device ASR inference with no loss in accuracy. With the rise in popularity of neural-transducer type models like the RNN-T for on-device ASR, optimizing RNN-T's runtime efficiency is of great interest. While previous work has primarily focused on the optimization of RNN-T's acoustic encoder and predictor, this paper focuses the attention on the joiner. We show that despite being only a small part of RNN-T, the joiner has a large impact on the overall model's runtime efficiency. We propose to utilize HAT-style joiner factorization for the purpose of skip** the more expensive non-blank computation when the blank probability exceeds a certain threshold. Since the blank probability can be computed very efficiently and the RNN-T output is dominated by blanks, our proposed method leads to a 26-30% decoding speed-up and 43-53% reduction in on-device power consumption, all the while incurring no accuracy degradation and being relatively simple to implement.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2023; v1 submitted 2 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Joint Audio/Text Training for Transformer Rescorer of Streaming Speech Recognition
Authors:
Suyoun Kim,
Ke Li,
Lucas Kabela,
Rongqing Huang,
Jiedan Zhu,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Duc Le
Abstract:
Recently, there has been an increasing interest in two-pass streaming end-to-end speech recognition (ASR) that incorporates a 2nd-pass rescoring model on top of the conventional 1st-pass streaming ASR model to improve recognition accuracy while kee** latency low. One of the latest 2nd-pass rescoring model, Transformer Rescorer, takes the n-best initial outputs and audio embeddings from the 1st-p…
▽ More
Recently, there has been an increasing interest in two-pass streaming end-to-end speech recognition (ASR) that incorporates a 2nd-pass rescoring model on top of the conventional 1st-pass streaming ASR model to improve recognition accuracy while kee** latency low. One of the latest 2nd-pass rescoring model, Transformer Rescorer, takes the n-best initial outputs and audio embeddings from the 1st-pass model, and then choose the best output by re-scoring the n-best initial outputs. However, training this Transformer Rescorer requires expensive paired audio-text training data because the model uses audio embeddings as input. In this work, we present our Joint Audio/Text training method for Transformer Rescorer, to leverage unpaired text-only data which is relatively cheaper than paired audio-text data. We evaluate Transformer Rescorer with our Joint Audio/Text training on Librispeech dataset as well as our large-scale in-house dataset and show that our training method can improve word error rate (WER) significantly compared to standard Transformer Rescorer without requiring any extra model parameters or latency.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Anchored Speech Recognition with Neural Transducers
Authors:
Desh Raj,
Junteng Jia,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Chunyang Wu,
Niko Moritz,
Xiaohui Zhang,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
Neural transducers have achieved human level performance on standard speech recognition benchmarks. However, their performance significantly degrades in the presence of cross-talk, especially when the primary speaker has a low signal-to-noise ratio. Anchored speech recognition refers to a class of methods that use information from an anchor segment (e.g., wake-words) to recognize device-directed s…
▽ More
Neural transducers have achieved human level performance on standard speech recognition benchmarks. However, their performance significantly degrades in the presence of cross-talk, especially when the primary speaker has a low signal-to-noise ratio. Anchored speech recognition refers to a class of methods that use information from an anchor segment (e.g., wake-words) to recognize device-directed speech while ignoring interfering background speech. In this paper, we investigate anchored speech recognition to make neural transducers robust to background speech. We extract context information from the anchor segment with a tiny auxiliary network, and use encoder biasing and joiner gating to guide the transducer towards the target speech. Moreover, to improve the robustness of context embedding extraction, we propose auxiliary training objectives to disentangle lexical content from speaking style. We evaluate our methods on synthetic LibriSpeech-based mixtures comprising several SNR and overlap conditions; they improve relative word error rates by 19.6% over a strong baseline, when averaged over all conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2023; v1 submitted 20 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Learning ASR pathways: A sparse multilingual ASR model
Authors:
Mu Yang,
Andros Tjandra,
Chunxi Liu,
David Zhang,
Duc Le,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
Neural network pruning compresses automatic speech recognition (ASR) models effectively. However, in multilingual ASR, language-agnostic pruning may lead to severe performance drops on some languages because language-agnostic pruning masks may not fit all languages and discard important language-specific parameters. In this work, we present ASR pathways, a sparse multilingual ASR model that activa…
▽ More
Neural network pruning compresses automatic speech recognition (ASR) models effectively. However, in multilingual ASR, language-agnostic pruning may lead to severe performance drops on some languages because language-agnostic pruning masks may not fit all languages and discard important language-specific parameters. In this work, we present ASR pathways, a sparse multilingual ASR model that activates language-specific sub-networks ("pathways"), such that the parameters for each language are learned explicitly. With the overlap** sub-networks, the shared parameters can also enable knowledge transfer for lower-resource languages via joint multilingual training. We propose a novel algorithm to learn ASR pathways, and evaluate the proposed method on 4 languages with a streaming RNN-T model. Our proposed ASR pathways outperform both dense models and a language-agnostically pruned model, and provide better performance on low-resource languages compared to the monolingual sparse models.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023; v1 submitted 13 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Learning a Dual-Mode Speech Recognition Model via Self-Pruning
Authors:
Chunxi Liu,
Yuan Shangguan,
Haichuan Yang,
Yangyang Shi,
Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi,
Ozlem Kalinli
Abstract:
There is growing interest in unifying the streaming and full-context automatic speech recognition (ASR) networks into a single end-to-end ASR model to simplify the model training and deployment for both use cases. While in real-world ASR applications, the streaming ASR models typically operate under more storage and computational constraints - e.g., on embedded devices - than any server-side full-…
▽ More
There is growing interest in unifying the streaming and full-context automatic speech recognition (ASR) networks into a single end-to-end ASR model to simplify the model training and deployment for both use cases. While in real-world ASR applications, the streaming ASR models typically operate under more storage and computational constraints - e.g., on embedded devices - than any server-side full-context models. Motivated by the recent progress in Omni-sparsity supernet training, where multiple subnetworks are jointly optimized in one single model, this work aims to jointly learn a compact sparse on-device streaming ASR model, and a large dense server non-streaming model, in a single supernet. Next, we present that, performing supernet training on both wav2vec 2.0 self-supervised learning and supervised ASR fine-tuning can not only substantially improve the large non-streaming model as shown in prior works, and also be able to improve the compact sparse streaming model.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2022; v1 submitted 25 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Deliberation Model for On-Device Spoken Language Understanding
Authors:
Duc Le,
Akshat Shrivastava,
Paden Tomasello,
Suyoun Kim,
Aleksandr Livshits,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
We propose a novel deliberation-based approach to end-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU), where a streaming automatic speech recognition (ASR) model produces the first-pass hypothesis and a second-pass natural language understanding (NLU) component generates the semantic parse by conditioning on both ASR's text and audio embeddings. By formulating E2E SLU as a generalized decoder, ou…
▽ More
We propose a novel deliberation-based approach to end-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU), where a streaming automatic speech recognition (ASR) model produces the first-pass hypothesis and a second-pass natural language understanding (NLU) component generates the semantic parse by conditioning on both ASR's text and audio embeddings. By formulating E2E SLU as a generalized decoder, our system is able to support complex compositional semantic structures. Furthermore, the sharing of parameters between ASR and NLU makes the system especially suitable for resource-constrained (on-device) environments; our proposed approach consistently outperforms strong pipeline NLU baselines by 0.60% to 0.65% on the spoken version of the TOPv2 dataset (STOP). We demonstrate that the fusion of text and audio features, coupled with the system's ability to rewrite the first-pass hypothesis, makes our approach more robust to ASR errors. Finally, we show that our approach can significantly reduce the degradation when moving from natural speech to synthetic speech training, but more work is required to make text-to-speech (TTS) a viable solution for scaling up E2E SLU.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2022; v1 submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Federated Domain Adaptation for ASR with Full Self-Supervision
Authors:
Junteng Jia,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Weiyi Zheng,
Yuan Shangguan,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Frank Seide
Abstract:
Cross-device federated learning (FL) protects user privacy by collaboratively training a model on user devices, therefore eliminating the need for collecting, storing, and manually labeling user data. While important topics such as the FL training algorithm, non-IID-ness, and Differential Privacy have been well studied in the literature, this paper focuses on two challenges of practical importance…
▽ More
Cross-device federated learning (FL) protects user privacy by collaboratively training a model on user devices, therefore eliminating the need for collecting, storing, and manually labeling user data. While important topics such as the FL training algorithm, non-IID-ness, and Differential Privacy have been well studied in the literature, this paper focuses on two challenges of practical importance for improving on-device ASR: the lack of ground-truth transcriptions and the scarcity of compute resource and network bandwidth on edge devices. First, we propose a FL system for on-device ASR domain adaptation with full self-supervision, which uses self-labeling together with data augmentation and filtering techniques. The system can improve a strong Emformer-Transducer based ASR model pretrained on out-of-domain data, using in-domain audio without any ground-truth transcriptions. Second, to reduce the training cost, we propose a self-restricted RNN Transducer (SR-RNN-T) loss, a variant of alignment-restricted RNN-T that uses Viterbi alignments from self-supervision. To further reduce the compute and network cost, we systematically explore adapting only a subset of weights in the Emformer-Transducer. Our best training recipe achieves a $12.9\%$ relative WER reduction over the strong out-of-domain baseline, which equals $70\%$ of the reduction achievable with full human supervision and centralized training.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2022; v1 submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Streaming parallel transducer beam search with fast-slow cascaded encoders
Authors:
Jay Mahadeokar,
Yangyang Shi,
Ke Li,
Duc Le,
Jiedan Zhu,
Vikas Chandra,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L Seltzer
Abstract:
Streaming ASR with strict latency constraints is required in many speech recognition applications. In order to achieve the required latency, streaming ASR models sacrifice accuracy compared to non-streaming ASR models due to lack of future input context. Previous research has shown that streaming and non-streaming ASR for RNN Transducers can be unified by cascading causal and non-causal encoders.…
▽ More
Streaming ASR with strict latency constraints is required in many speech recognition applications. In order to achieve the required latency, streaming ASR models sacrifice accuracy compared to non-streaming ASR models due to lack of future input context. Previous research has shown that streaming and non-streaming ASR for RNN Transducers can be unified by cascading causal and non-causal encoders. This work improves upon this cascaded encoders framework by leveraging two streaming non-causal encoders with variable input context sizes that can produce outputs at different audio intervals (e.g. fast and slow). We propose a novel parallel time-synchronous beam search algorithm for transducers that decodes from fast-slow encoders, where the slow encoder corrects the mistakes generated from the fast encoder. The proposed algorithm, achieves up to 20% WER reduction with a slight increase in token emission delays on the public Librispeech dataset and in-house datasets. We also explore techniques to reduce the computation by distributing processing between the fast and slow encoders. Lastly, we explore sharing the parameters in the fast encoder to reduce the memory footprint. This enables low latency processing on edge devices with low computation cost and a low memory footprint.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Neural-FST Class Language Model for End-to-End Speech Recognition
Authors:
Antoine Bruguier,
Duc Le,
Rohit Prabhavalkar,
Dangna Li,
Zhe Liu,
Bo Wang,
Eun Chang,
Fuchun Peng,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
We propose Neural-FST Class Language Model (NFCLM) for end-to-end speech recognition, a novel method that combines neural network language models (NNLMs) and finite state transducers (FSTs) in a mathematically consistent framework. Our method utilizes a background NNLM which models generic background text together with a collection of domain-specific entities modeled as individual FSTs. Each outpu…
▽ More
We propose Neural-FST Class Language Model (NFCLM) for end-to-end speech recognition, a novel method that combines neural network language models (NNLMs) and finite state transducers (FSTs) in a mathematically consistent framework. Our method utilizes a background NNLM which models generic background text together with a collection of domain-specific entities modeled as individual FSTs. Each output token is generated by a mixture of these components; the mixture weights are estimated with a separately trained neural decider. We show that NFCLM significantly outperforms NNLM by 15.8% relative in terms of Word Error Rate. NFCLM achieves similar performance as traditional NNLM and FST shallow fusion while being less prone to overbiasing and 12 times more compact, making it more suitable for on-device usage.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022; v1 submitted 27 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Scaling ASR Improves Zero and Few Shot Learning
Authors:
Alex Xiao,
Weiyi Zheng,
Gil Keren,
Duc Le,
Frank Zhang,
Christian Fuegen,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Yatharth Saraf,
Abdelrahman Mohamed
Abstract:
With 4.5 million hours of English speech from 10 different sources across 120 countries and models of up to 10 billion parameters, we explore the frontiers of scale for automatic speech recognition. We propose data selection techniques to efficiently scale training data to find the most valuable samples in massive datasets. To efficiently scale model sizes, we leverage various optimizations such a…
▽ More
With 4.5 million hours of English speech from 10 different sources across 120 countries and models of up to 10 billion parameters, we explore the frontiers of scale for automatic speech recognition. We propose data selection techniques to efficiently scale training data to find the most valuable samples in massive datasets. To efficiently scale model sizes, we leverage various optimizations such as sparse transducer loss and model sharding. By training 1-10B parameter universal English ASR models, we push the limits of speech recognition performance across many domains. Furthermore, our models learn powerful speech representations with zero and few-shot capabilities on novel domains and styles of speech, exceeding previous results across multiple in-house and public benchmarks. For speakers with disorders due to brain damage, our best zero-shot and few-shot models achieve 22% and 60% relative improvement on the AphasiaBank test set, respectively, while realizing the best performance on public social media videos. Furthermore, the same universal model reaches equivalent performance with 500x less in-domain data on the SPGISpeech financial-domain dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2021; v1 submitted 10 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Omni-sparsity DNN: Fast Sparsity Optimization for On-Device Streaming E2E ASR via Supernet
Authors:
Haichuan Yang,
Yuan Shangguan,
Dilin Wang,
Meng Li,
Pierce Chuang,
Xiaohui Zhang,
Ganesh Venkatesh,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Vikas Chandra
Abstract:
From wearables to powerful smart devices, modern automatic speech recognition (ASR) models run on a variety of edge devices with different computational budgets. To navigate the Pareto front of model accuracy vs model size, researchers are trapped in a dilemma of optimizing model accuracy by training and fine-tuning models for each individual edge device while kee** the training GPU-hours tracta…
▽ More
From wearables to powerful smart devices, modern automatic speech recognition (ASR) models run on a variety of edge devices with different computational budgets. To navigate the Pareto front of model accuracy vs model size, researchers are trapped in a dilemma of optimizing model accuracy by training and fine-tuning models for each individual edge device while kee** the training GPU-hours tractable. In this paper, we propose Omni-sparsity DNN, where a single neural network can be pruned to generate optimized model for a large range of model sizes. We develop training strategies for Omni-sparsity DNN that allows it to find models along the Pareto front of word-error-rate (WER) vs model size while kee** the training GPU-hours to no more than that of training one singular model. We demonstrate the Omni-sparsity DNN with streaming E2E ASR models. Our results show great saving on training time and resources with similar or better accuracy on LibriSpeech compared to individually pruned sparse models: 2%-6.6% better WER on Test-other.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2022; v1 submitted 15 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Streaming Transformer Transducer Based Speech Recognition Using Non-Causal Convolution
Authors:
Yangyang Shi,
Chunyang Wu,
Dilin Wang,
Alex Xiao,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Xiaohui Zhang,
Chunxi Liu,
Ke Li,
Yuan Shangguan,
Varun Nagaraja,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Mike Seltzer
Abstract:
This paper improves the streaming transformer transducer for speech recognition by using non-causal convolution. Many works apply the causal convolution to improve streaming transformer ignoring the lookahead context. We propose to use non-causal convolution to process the center block and lookahead context separately. This method leverages the lookahead context in convolution and maintains simila…
▽ More
This paper improves the streaming transformer transducer for speech recognition by using non-causal convolution. Many works apply the causal convolution to improve streaming transformer ignoring the lookahead context. We propose to use non-causal convolution to process the center block and lookahead context separately. This method leverages the lookahead context in convolution and maintains similar training and decoding efficiency. Given the similar latency, using the non-causal convolution with lookahead context gives better accuracy than causal convolution, especially for open-domain dictation scenarios. Besides, this paper applies talking-head attention and a novel history context compression scheme to further improve the performance. The talking-head attention improves the multi-head self-attention by transferring information among different heads. The history context compression method introduces more extended history context compactly. On our in-house data, the proposed methods improve a small Emformer baseline with lookahead context by relative WERR 5.1\%, 14.5\%, 8.4\% on open-domain dictation, assistant general scenarios, and assistant calling scenarios, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Transferring Voice Knowledge for Acoustic Event Detection: An Empirical Study
Authors:
Dawei Liang,
Yangyang Shi,
Yun Wang,
Nayan Singhal,
Alex Xiao,
Jonathan Shaw,
Edison Thomaz,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Mike Seltzer
Abstract:
Detection of common events and scenes from audio is useful for extracting and understanding human contexts in daily life. Prior studies have shown that leveraging knowledge from a relevant domain is beneficial for a target acoustic event detection (AED) process. Inspired by the observation that many human-centered acoustic events in daily life involve voice elements, this paper investigates the po…
▽ More
Detection of common events and scenes from audio is useful for extracting and understanding human contexts in daily life. Prior studies have shown that leveraging knowledge from a relevant domain is beneficial for a target acoustic event detection (AED) process. Inspired by the observation that many human-centered acoustic events in daily life involve voice elements, this paper investigates the potential of transferring high-level voice representations extracted from a public speaker dataset to enrich an AED pipeline. Towards this end, we develop a dual-branch neural network architecture for the joint learning of voice and acoustic features during an AED process and conduct thorough empirical studies to examine the performance on the public AudioSet [1] with different types of inputs. Our main observations are that: 1) Joint learning of audio and voice inputs improves the AED performance (mean average precision) for both a CNN baseline (0.292 vs 0.134 mAP) and a TALNet [2] baseline (0.361 vs 0.351 mAP); 2) Augmenting the extra voice features is critical to maximize the model performance with dual inputs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Collaborative Training of Acoustic Encoders for Speech Recognition
Authors:
Varun Nagaraja,
Yangyang Shi,
Ganesh Venkatesh,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Michael L. Seltzer,
Vikas Chandra
Abstract:
On-device speech recognition requires training models of different sizes for deploying on devices with various computational budgets. When building such different models, we can benefit from training them jointly to take advantage of the knowledge shared between them. Joint training is also efficient since it reduces the redundancy in the training procedure's data handling operations. We propose a…
▽ More
On-device speech recognition requires training models of different sizes for deploying on devices with various computational budgets. When building such different models, we can benefit from training them jointly to take advantage of the knowledge shared between them. Joint training is also efficient since it reduces the redundancy in the training procedure's data handling operations. We propose a method for collaboratively training acoustic encoders of different sizes for speech recognition. We use a sequence transducer setup where different acoustic encoders share a common predictor and joiner modules. The acoustic encoders are also trained using co-distillation through an auxiliary task for frame level chenone prediction, along with the transducer loss. We perform experiments using the LibriSpeech corpus and demonstrate that the collaboratively trained acoustic encoders can provide up to a 11% relative improvement in the word error rate on both the test partitions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2021; v1 submitted 16 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Flexi-Transducer: Optimizing Latency, Accuracy and Compute forMulti-Domain On-Device Scenarios
Authors:
Jay Mahadeokar,
Yangyang Shi,
Yuan Shangguan,
Chunyang Wu,
Alex Xiao,
Hang Su,
Duc Le,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Christian Fuegen,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
Often, the storage and computational constraints of embeddeddevices demand that a single on-device ASR model serve multiple use-cases / domains. In this paper, we propose aFlexibleTransducer(FlexiT) for on-device automatic speech recognition to flexibly deal with multiple use-cases / domains with different accuracy and latency requirements. Specifically, using a single compact model, FlexiT provid…
▽ More
Often, the storage and computational constraints of embeddeddevices demand that a single on-device ASR model serve multiple use-cases / domains. In this paper, we propose aFlexibleTransducer(FlexiT) for on-device automatic speech recognition to flexibly deal with multiple use-cases / domains with different accuracy and latency requirements. Specifically, using a single compact model, FlexiT provides a fast response for voice commands, and accurate transcription but with more latency for dictation. In order to achieve flexible and better accuracy and latency trade-offs, the following techniques are used. Firstly, we propose using domain-specific altering of segment size for Emformer encoder that enables FlexiT to achieve flexible de-coding. Secondly, we use Alignment Restricted RNNT loss to achieve flexible fine-grained control on token emission latency for different domains. Finally, we add a domain indicator vector as an additional input to the FlexiT model. Using the combination of techniques, we show that a single model can be used to improve WERs and real time factor for dictation scenarios while maintaining optimal latency for voice commands use-cases
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Dissecting User-Perceived Latency of On-Device E2E Speech Recognition
Authors:
Yuan Shangguan,
Rohit Prabhavalkar,
Hang Su,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Yangyang Shi,
Jiatong Zhou,
Chunyang Wu,
Duc Le,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Christian Fuegen,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
As speech-enabled devices such as smartphones and smart speakers become increasingly ubiquitous, there is growing interest in building automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems that can run directly on-device; end-to-end (E2E) speech recognition models such as recurrent neural network transducers and their variants have recently emerged as prime candidates for this task. Apart from being accurate…
▽ More
As speech-enabled devices such as smartphones and smart speakers become increasingly ubiquitous, there is growing interest in building automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems that can run directly on-device; end-to-end (E2E) speech recognition models such as recurrent neural network transducers and their variants have recently emerged as prime candidates for this task. Apart from being accurate and compact, such systems need to decode speech with low user-perceived latency (UPL), producing words as soon as they are spoken. This work examines the impact of various techniques - model architectures, training criteria, decoding hyperparameters, and endpointer parameters - on UPL. Our analyses suggest that measures of model size (parameters, input chunk sizes), or measures of computation (e.g., FLOPS, RTF) that reflect the model's ability to process input frames are not always strongly correlated with observed UPL. Thus, conventional algorithmic latency measurements might be inadequate in accurately capturing latency observed when models are deployed on embedded devices. Instead, we find that factors affecting token emission latency, and endpointing behavior have a larger impact on UPL. We achieve the best trade-off between latency and word error rate when performing ASR jointly with endpointing, while utilizing the recently proposed alignment regularization mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2021; v1 submitted 5 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Contextualized Streaming End-to-End Speech Recognition with Trie-Based Deep Biasing and Shallow Fusion
Authors:
Duc Le,
Mahaveer Jain,
Gil Keren,
Suyoun Kim,
Yangyang Shi,
Jay Mahadeokar,
Julian Chan,
Yuan Shangguan,
Christian Fuegen,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Yatharth Saraf,
Michael L. Seltzer
Abstract:
How to leverage dynamic contextual information in end-to-end speech recognition has remained an active research area. Previous solutions to this problem were either designed for specialized use cases that did not generalize well to open-domain scenarios, did not scale to large biasing lists, or underperformed on rare long-tail words. We address these limitations by proposing a novel solution that…
▽ More
How to leverage dynamic contextual information in end-to-end speech recognition has remained an active research area. Previous solutions to this problem were either designed for specialized use cases that did not generalize well to open-domain scenarios, did not scale to large biasing lists, or underperformed on rare long-tail words. We address these limitations by proposing a novel solution that combines shallow fusion, trie-based deep biasing, and neural network language model contextualization. These techniques result in significant 19.5% relative Word Error Rate improvement over existing contextual biasing approaches and 5.4%-9.3% improvement compared to a strong hybrid baseline on both open-domain and constrained contextualization tasks, where the targets consist of mostly rare long-tail words. Our final system remains lightweight and modular, allowing for quick modification without model re-training.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2021; v1 submitted 5 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Bandwidth Embeddings for Mixed-bandwidth Speech Recognition
Authors:
Gautam Mantena,
Ozlem Kalinli,
Ossama Abdel-Hamid,
Don McAllaster
Abstract:
In this paper, we tackle the problem of handling narrowband and wideband speech by building a single acoustic model (AM), also called mixed bandwidth AM. In the proposed approach, an auxiliary input feature is used to provide the bandwidth information to the model, and bandwidth embeddings are jointly learned as part of acoustic model training. Experimental evaluations show that using bandwidth em…
▽ More
In this paper, we tackle the problem of handling narrowband and wideband speech by building a single acoustic model (AM), also called mixed bandwidth AM. In the proposed approach, an auxiliary input feature is used to provide the bandwidth information to the model, and bandwidth embeddings are jointly learned as part of acoustic model training. Experimental evaluations show that using bandwidth embeddings helps the model to handle the variability of the narrow and wideband speech, and makes it possible to train a mixed-bandwidth AM. Furthermore, we propose to use parallel convolutional layers to handle the mismatch between the narrow and wideband speech better, where separate convolution layers are used for each type of input speech signal. Our best system achieves 13% relative improvement on narrowband speech, while not degrading on wideband speech.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.