-
On the Evaluation of Speech Foundation Models for Spoken Language Understanding
Authors:
Siddhant Arora,
Ankita Pasad,
Chung-Ming Chien,
Jionghao Han,
Roshan Sharma,
Jee-weon Jung,
Hira Dhamyal,
William Chen,
Suwon Shon,
Hung-yi Lee,
Karen Livescu,
Shinji Watanabe
Abstract:
The Spoken Language Understanding Evaluation (SLUE) suite of benchmark tasks was recently introduced to address the need for open resources and benchmarking of complex spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks, including both classification and sequence generation tasks, on natural speech. The benchmark has demonstrated preliminary success in using pre-trained speech foundation models (SFM) for th…
▽ More
The Spoken Language Understanding Evaluation (SLUE) suite of benchmark tasks was recently introduced to address the need for open resources and benchmarking of complex spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks, including both classification and sequence generation tasks, on natural speech. The benchmark has demonstrated preliminary success in using pre-trained speech foundation models (SFM) for these SLU tasks. However, the community still lacks a fine-grained understanding of the comparative utility of different SFMs. Inspired by this, we ask: which SFMs offer the most benefits for these complex SLU tasks, and what is the most effective approach for incorporating these SFMs? To answer this, we perform an extensive evaluation of multiple supervised and self-supervised SFMs using several evaluation protocols: (i) frozen SFMs with a lightweight prediction head, (ii) frozen SFMs with a complex prediction head, and (iii) fine-tuned SFMs with a lightweight prediction head. Although the supervised SFMs are pre-trained on much more speech recognition data (with labels), they do not always outperform self-supervised SFMs; the latter tend to perform at least as well as, and sometimes better than, supervised SFMs, especially on the sequence generation tasks in SLUE. While there is no universally optimal way of incorporating SFMs, the complex prediction head gives the best performance for most tasks, although it increases the inference time. We also introduce an open-source toolkit and performance leaderboard, SLUE-PERB, for these tasks and modeling strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Prompting Audios Using Acoustic Properties For Emotion Representation
Authors:
Hira Dhamyal,
Benjamin Elizalde,
Soham Deshmukh,
Huaming Wang,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Emotions lie on a continuum, but current models treat emotions as a finite valued discrete variable. This representation does not capture the diversity in the expression of emotion. To better represent emotions we propose the use of natural language descriptions (or prompts). In this work, we address the challenge of automatically generating these prompts and training a model to better learn emoti…
▽ More
Emotions lie on a continuum, but current models treat emotions as a finite valued discrete variable. This representation does not capture the diversity in the expression of emotion. To better represent emotions we propose the use of natural language descriptions (or prompts). In this work, we address the challenge of automatically generating these prompts and training a model to better learn emotion representations from audio and prompt pairs. We use acoustic properties that are correlated to emotion like pitch, intensity, speech rate, and articulation rate to automatically generate prompts i.e. 'acoustic prompts'. We use a contrastive learning objective to map speech to their respective acoustic prompts. We evaluate our model on Emotion Audio Retrieval and Speech Emotion Recognition. Our results show that the acoustic prompts significantly improve the model's performance in EAR, in various Precision@K metrics. In SER, we observe a 3.8% relative accuracy improvement on the Ravdess dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Evaluating Speech Synthesis by Training Recognizers on Synthetic Speech
Authors:
Dareen Alharthi,
Roshan Sharma,
Hira Dhamyal,
Soumi Maiti,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Modern speech synthesis systems have improved significantly, with synthetic speech being indistinguishable from real speech. However, efficient and holistic evaluation of synthetic speech still remains a significant challenge. Human evaluation using Mean Opinion Score (MOS) is ideal, but inefficient due to high costs. Therefore, researchers have developed auxiliary automatic metrics like Word Erro…
▽ More
Modern speech synthesis systems have improved significantly, with synthetic speech being indistinguishable from real speech. However, efficient and holistic evaluation of synthetic speech still remains a significant challenge. Human evaluation using Mean Opinion Score (MOS) is ideal, but inefficient due to high costs. Therefore, researchers have developed auxiliary automatic metrics like Word Error Rate (WER) to measure intelligibility. Prior works focus on evaluating synthetic speech based on pre-trained speech recognition models, however, this can be limiting since this approach primarily measures speech intelligibility. In this paper, we propose an evaluation technique involving the training of an ASR model on synthetic speech and assessing its performance on real speech. Our main assumption is that by training the ASR model on the synthetic speech, the WER on real speech reflects the similarity between distributions, a broader assessment of synthetic speech quality beyond intelligibility. Our proposed metric demonstrates a strong correlation with both MOS naturalness and MOS intelligibility when compared to SpeechLMScore and MOSNet on three recent Text-to-Speech (TTS) systems: MQTTS, StyleTTS, and YourTTS.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Describing emotions with acoustic property prompts for speech emotion recognition
Authors:
Hira Dhamyal,
Benjamin Elizalde,
Soham Deshmukh,
Huaming Wang,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Emotions lie on a broad continuum and treating emotions as a discrete number of classes limits the ability of a model to capture the nuances in the continuum. The challenge is how to describe the nuances of emotions and how to enable a model to learn the descriptions. In this work, we devise a method to automatically create a description (or prompt) for a given audio by computing acoustic properti…
▽ More
Emotions lie on a broad continuum and treating emotions as a discrete number of classes limits the ability of a model to capture the nuances in the continuum. The challenge is how to describe the nuances of emotions and how to enable a model to learn the descriptions. In this work, we devise a method to automatically create a description (or prompt) for a given audio by computing acoustic properties, such as pitch, loudness, speech rate, and articulation rate. We pair a prompt with its corresponding audio using 5 different emotion datasets. We trained a neural network model using these audio-text pairs. Then, we evaluate the model using one more dataset. We investigate how the model can learn to associate the audio with the descriptions, resulting in performance improvement of Speech Emotion Recognition and Speech Audio Retrieval. We expect our findings to motivate research describing the broad continuum of emotion
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Unifying the Discrete and Continuous Emotion labels for Speech Emotion Recognition
Authors:
Roshan Sharma,
Hira Dhamyal,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Traditionally, in paralinguistic analysis for emotion detection from speech, emotions have been identified with discrete or dimensional (continuous-valued) labels. Accordingly, models that have been proposed for emotion detection use one or the other of these label types. However, psychologists like Russell and Plutchik have proposed theories and models that unite these views, maintaining that the…
▽ More
Traditionally, in paralinguistic analysis for emotion detection from speech, emotions have been identified with discrete or dimensional (continuous-valued) labels. Accordingly, models that have been proposed for emotion detection use one or the other of these label types. However, psychologists like Russell and Plutchik have proposed theories and models that unite these views, maintaining that these representations have shared and complementary information. This paper is an attempt to validate these viewpoints computationally. To this end, we propose a model to jointly predict continuous and discrete emotional attributes and show how the relationship between these can be utilized to improve the robustness and performance of emotion recognition tasks. Our approach comprises multi-task and hierarchical multi-task learning frameworks that jointly model the relationships between continuous-valued and discrete emotion labels. Experimental results on two widely used datasets (IEMOCAP and MSPPodcast) for speech-based emotion recognition show that our model results in statistically significant improvements in performance over strong baselines with non-unified approaches. We also demonstrate that using one type of label (discrete or continuous-valued) for training improves recognition performance in tasks that use the other type of label. Experimental results and reasoning for this approach (called the mismatched training approach) are also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Self-supervision and Learnable STRFs for Age, Emotion, and Country Prediction
Authors:
Roshan Sharma,
Tyler Vuong,
Mark Lindsey,
Hira Dhamyal,
Rita Singh,
Bhiksha Raj
Abstract:
This work presents a multitask approach to the simultaneous estimation of age, country of origin, and emotion given vocal burst audio for the 2022 ICML Expressive Vocalizations Challenge ExVo-MultiTask track. The method of choice utilized a combination of spectro-temporal modulation and self-supervised features, followed by an encoder-decoder network organized in a multitask paradigm. We evaluate…
▽ More
This work presents a multitask approach to the simultaneous estimation of age, country of origin, and emotion given vocal burst audio for the 2022 ICML Expressive Vocalizations Challenge ExVo-MultiTask track. The method of choice utilized a combination of spectro-temporal modulation and self-supervised features, followed by an encoder-decoder network organized in a multitask paradigm. We evaluate the complementarity between the tasks posed by examining independent task-specific and joint models, and explore the relative strengths of different feature sets. We also introduce a simple score fusion mechanism to leverage the complementarity of different feature sets for this task.
We find that robust data preprocessing in conjunction with score fusion over spectro-temporal receptive field and HuBERT models achieved our best ExVo-MultiTask test score of 0.412.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
On the pragmatism of using binary classifiers over data intensive neural network classifiers for detection of COVID-19 from voice
Authors:
Ankit Shah,
Hira Dhamyal,
Yang Gao,
Daniel Arancibia,
Mario Arancibia,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Lately, there has been a global effort by multiple research groups to detect COVID-19 from voice. Different researchers use different kinds of information from the voice signal to achieve this. Various types of phonated sounds and the sound of cough and breath have all been used with varying degree of success in automated voice-based COVID-19 detection apps. In this paper, we show that detecting C…
▽ More
Lately, there has been a global effort by multiple research groups to detect COVID-19 from voice. Different researchers use different kinds of information from the voice signal to achieve this. Various types of phonated sounds and the sound of cough and breath have all been used with varying degree of success in automated voice-based COVID-19 detection apps. In this paper, we show that detecting COVID-19 from voice does not require custom-made non-standard features or complicated neural network classifiers rather it can be successfully done with just standard features and simple binary classifiers. In fact, we show that the latter is not only more accurate and interpretable but also more computationally efficient in that they can be run locally on small devices. We demonstrate this on a human-curated dataset of over 1000 subjects, collected and calibrated in clinical settings.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2022; v1 submitted 10 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
An Overview of Techniques for Biomarker Discovery in Voice Signal
Authors:
Rita Singh,
Ankit Shah,
Hira Dhamyal
Abstract:
This paper reflects on the effect of several categories of medical conditions on human voice, focusing on those that may be hypothesized to have effects on voice, but for which the changes themselves may be subtle enough to have eluded observation in standard analytical examinations of the voice signal. It presents three categories of techniques that can potentially uncover such elusive biomarkers…
▽ More
This paper reflects on the effect of several categories of medical conditions on human voice, focusing on those that may be hypothesized to have effects on voice, but for which the changes themselves may be subtle enough to have eluded observation in standard analytical examinations of the voice signal. It presents three categories of techniques that can potentially uncover such elusive biomarkers and allow them to be measured and used for predictive and diagnostic purposes. These approaches include proxy techniques, model-based analytical techniques and data-driven AI techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Masked Proxy Loss For Text-Independent Speaker Verification
Authors:
Jiachen Lian,
Aiswarya Vinod Kumar,
Hira Dhamyal,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Open-set speaker recognition can be regarded as a metric learning problem, which is to maximize inter-class variance and minimize intra-class variance. Supervised metric learning can be categorized into entity-based learning and proxy-based learning. Most of the existing metric learning objectives like Contrastive, Triplet, Prototypical, GE2E, etc all belong to the former division, the performance…
▽ More
Open-set speaker recognition can be regarded as a metric learning problem, which is to maximize inter-class variance and minimize intra-class variance. Supervised metric learning can be categorized into entity-based learning and proxy-based learning. Most of the existing metric learning objectives like Contrastive, Triplet, Prototypical, GE2E, etc all belong to the former division, the performance of which is either highly dependent on sample mining strategy or restricted by insufficient label information in the mini-batch. Proxy-based losses mitigate both shortcomings, however, fine-grained connections among entities are either not or indirectly leveraged. This paper proposes a Masked Proxy (MP) loss which directly incorporates both proxy-based relationships and pair-based relationships. We further propose Multinomial Masked Proxy (MMP) loss to leverage the hardness of speaker pairs. These methods have been applied to evaluate on VoxCeleb test set and reach state-of-the-art Equal Error Rate(EER).
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021; v1 submitted 9 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
The phonetic bases of vocal expressed emotion: natural versus acted
Authors:
Hira Dhamyal,
Shahan Ali Memon,
Bhiksha Raj,
Rita Singh
Abstract:
Can vocal emotions be emulated? This question has been a recurrent concern of the speech community, and has also been vigorously investigated. It has been fueled further by its link to the issue of validity of acted emotion databases. Much of the speech and vocal emotion research has relied on acted emotion databases as valid proxies for studying natural emotions. To create models that generalize…
▽ More
Can vocal emotions be emulated? This question has been a recurrent concern of the speech community, and has also been vigorously investigated. It has been fueled further by its link to the issue of validity of acted emotion databases. Much of the speech and vocal emotion research has relied on acted emotion databases as valid proxies for studying natural emotions. To create models that generalize to natural settings, it is crucial to work with valid prototypes -- ones that can be assumed to reliably represent natural emotions. More concretely, it is important to study emulated emotions against natural emotions in terms of their physiological, and psychological concomitants. In this paper, we present an on-scale systematic study of the differences between natural and acted vocal emotions. We use a self-attention based emotion classification model to understand the phonetic bases of emotions by discovering the most 'attended' phonemes for each class of emotions. We then compare these attended-phonemes in their importance and distribution across acted and natural classes. Our tests show significant differences in the manner and choice of phonemes in acted and natural speech, concluding moderate to low validity and value in using acted speech databases for emotion classification tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
