-
Performance Analysis of Empirical Open-Circuit Voltage Modeling in Lithium Ion Batteries, Part-3: Experimental Results
Authors:
Prarthana Pillai,
James Nguyen,
Balakumar Balasingam
Abstract:
This paper is the third part of a series of papers about empirical approaches to open circuit voltage (OCV) modeling of lithium-ion batteries. The first part of the series proposed models to quantify various sources of uncertainties in the OCV models; and, the second part of the series presented systematic data collection approaches to compute the uncertainties in the OCV-SOC models. This paper us…
▽ More
This paper is the third part of a series of papers about empirical approaches to open circuit voltage (OCV) modeling of lithium-ion batteries. The first part of the series proposed models to quantify various sources of uncertainties in the OCV models; and, the second part of the series presented systematic data collection approaches to compute the uncertainties in the OCV-SOC models. This paper uses data collected from 28 OCV characterization experiments, performed according to the data collection plan presented, to compute and analyze the following three different OCV uncertainty metrics: cell-to-cell variations, cycle-rate error, and curve fitting error. From the computed metrics, it was observed that a lower C-Rate showed smaller errors in the OCV-SOC model and vice versa. The results reported in this paper establish a relationship between the C-Rate and the uncertainty of the OCV-SOC model. This research can be thus useful to battery researchers for quantifying the tradeoff between the time taken to complete the OCV characterization test and the corresponding uncertainty in the OCV-SOC modeling. Further, quantified uncertainty model parameters can be used to accurately characterize the uncertainty in various battery management functionalities, such as state of charge and state of health estimation.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Performance Analysis of Empirical Open-Circuit Voltage Modeling in Lithium Ion Batteries, Part-2: Data Collection Procedure
Authors:
Prarthana Pillai,
James Nguyen,
Balakumar Balasingam
Abstract:
This paper is the second part of a series of papers about empirical approaches to open circuit voltage (OCV) modeling and its performance comparison in lithium-ion batteries. The first part of the series introduced various sources of uncertainties in the OCV models and established a theoretical relationship between uncertainties and the performance of a battery management system. In this paper, cl…
▽ More
This paper is the second part of a series of papers about empirical approaches to open circuit voltage (OCV) modeling and its performance comparison in lithium-ion batteries. The first part of the series introduced various sources of uncertainties in the OCV models and established a theoretical relationship between uncertainties and the performance of a battery management system. In this paper, clearly defined approaches for low-rate OCV data collection are defined and described in detail. The data collection is designed with consideration to several parameters that affect the experimental time. Firstly, a more suitable method to fully charge the battery at different C-Rates is defined. Secondly, the OCV characterization following the full charge is described for various performance comparisons. Finally, optimal and efficient resistance estimation profiles are discussed. From the voltage, current and time data recorded using the procedure described in this paper, the OCV-SOC relationship is characterized and its uncertainties are modeled in the third part of this series of papers.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Performance Analysis of Empirical Open-Circuit Voltage Modeling in Lithium Ion Batteries, Part-1: Performance Measures
Authors:
Prarthana Pillai,
James Nguyen,
Balakumar Balasingam
Abstract:
The open circuit voltage to the state of charge (OCVSOC) characteristic is crucial for battery management systems. Using the OCV-SOC curve, the SOC and the battery capacity can be estimated in real-time. Accurate SOC and capacity information are important to carry out the majority of battery management functionalities that ensure a safe, efficient, and reliable battery pack power system. Numerous…
▽ More
The open circuit voltage to the state of charge (OCVSOC) characteristic is crucial for battery management systems. Using the OCV-SOC curve, the SOC and the battery capacity can be estimated in real-time. Accurate SOC and capacity information are important to carry out the majority of battery management functionalities that ensure a safe, efficient, and reliable battery pack power system. Numerous approaches have been reported in the literature for improved SOC estimation and battery capacity estimation. These approaches focus on various estimation and filtering techniques to reduce the effect of measurement noise and uncertainties due to hysteresis and relaxation effects. Even though all the existing approaches to SOC estimation rely on the OCV-SOC characterization, little attention was paid to investigating the possibility of errors in the OCV-SOC characterization and the effect of uncertainty in the OCV-SOC curve on SOC and capacity estimates. In this paper, which is the first part of a series of three papers, the effect of OCV-SOC modeling error in the overall battery management system is discussed. The different sources of uncertainties in the OCV-SOC curve include cell-to-cell variation, temperature variation, aging drift, cycle rate effect, curve-fitting error, and measurement/estimation error. The proposed uncertainty models can be incorporated into battery management systems to improve their safety, performance, and reliability.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
A Critical Look at Coulomb Counting Towards Improving the Kalman Filter Based State of Charge Tracking Algorithms in Rechargeable Batteries
Authors:
Kiarash Movassagh,
Sheikh Arif Raihan,
Balakumar Balasingam,
Krishna Pattipati
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider the problem of state of charge estimation for rechargeable batteries. Coulomb counting is one of the traditional approaches to state of charge estimation and it is considered reliable as long as the battery capacity and initial state of charge are known. However, the Coulomb counting method is susceptible to errors from several sources and the extent of these errors are…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider the problem of state of charge estimation for rechargeable batteries. Coulomb counting is one of the traditional approaches to state of charge estimation and it is considered reliable as long as the battery capacity and initial state of charge are known. However, the Coulomb counting method is susceptible to errors from several sources and the extent of these errors are not studied in the literature. In this paper, we formally derive and quantify the state of charge estimation error during Coulomb counting due to the following four types of error sources: (i) current measurement error; (ii) current integration approximation error; (iii) battery capacity uncertainty; and (iv) the timing oscillator error/drift. It is shown that the resulting state of charge error can either be of the time-cumulative or of state-of-charge-proportional type. Time-cumulative errors increase with time and has the potential to completely invalidate the state of charge estimation in the long run. State-of-charge-proportional errors increase with the accumulated state of charge and reach its worst value within one charge/discharge cycle. Simulation analyses are presented to demonstrate the extent of these errors under several realistic scenarios and the paper discusses approaches to reduce the time-cumulative and state of charge-proportional errors.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
On the Identification of Electrical Equivalent Circuit Models Based on Noisy Measurements
Authors:
Balakumar Balasingam,
Krishna Pattipati
Abstract:
Real-time identification of electrical equivalent circuit models is a critical requirement in many practical systems, such as batteries and electric motors. Significant work has been done in the past develo** different types of algorithms for system identification using reduced equivalent circuit models. However, little work was done in analyzing the theoretical performance bounds of these appro…
▽ More
Real-time identification of electrical equivalent circuit models is a critical requirement in many practical systems, such as batteries and electric motors. Significant work has been done in the past develo** different types of algorithms for system identification using reduced equivalent circuit models. However, little work was done in analyzing the theoretical performance bounds of these approaches. Proper understanding of theoretical bounds will help in designing a system that is economical in cost and robust in performance. In this paper, we analyze the performance of a linear recursive least squares approach to equivalent circuit model identification and show that the least squares approach is both unbiased and efficient when the signal-to-noise ratio is high enough. However, we show that, when the signal-to-noise ratio is low - resembling the case in many practical applications - the least squares estimator becomes significantly biased. Consequently, we develop a parameter estimation approach based on total least squares method and show it to be asymptotically unbiased and efficient at practically low signal-to-noise ratio regions. Further, we develop a recursive implementation of the total least square algorithm and find it to be slow to converge; for this, we employ a Kalman filter to improve the convergence speed of the total least squares method. The resulting total Kalman filter is shown to be both unbiased and efficient in equivalent circuit model parameter identification. The performance of this filter is analyzed using real-world current profile under fluctuating signal-to-noise ratios. Finally, the applicability of the algorithms and analysis in this paper in identifying higher order electrical equivalent circuit models is explained.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A Novel Slip-Kalman Filter to Track the Progression of Reading Through Eye-Gaze Measurements
Authors:
Stephen Bottos,
Balakumar Balasingam
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose an approach to track the progression of eye-gaze while reading a block of text on computer screen. The proposed approach will help to accurately quantify reading, e.g., identifying the lines of text that were read/skipped and estimating the time spent on each line, based on commercially available inexpensive eye-tracking devices. The proposed approach is based on a novel…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose an approach to track the progression of eye-gaze while reading a block of text on computer screen. The proposed approach will help to accurately quantify reading, e.g., identifying the lines of text that were read/skipped and estimating the time spent on each line, based on commercially available inexpensive eye-tracking devices. The proposed approach is based on a novel Slip Kalman filter that is custom designed to track the progression of reading. The performance of the proposed method is demonstrated using 25 pages eye-tracking data collected using a commercial desk-mounted eye-tracking device.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Tracking the Progression of Reading Through Eye-gaze Measurements
Authors:
Stephen Bottos,
Balakumar Balasingam
Abstract:
In this paper we consider the problem of tracking the progression of reading through eye-gaze measurements. Such an algorithm is novel and will ultimately help to develop a method of analyzing eye-gaze data which had been collected during reading activity in order to uncover crucial information regarding the individual's interest level and quality of experience while reading a passage of text or b…
▽ More
In this paper we consider the problem of tracking the progression of reading through eye-gaze measurements. Such an algorithm is novel and will ultimately help to develop a method of analyzing eye-gaze data which had been collected during reading activity in order to uncover crucial information regarding the individual's interest level and quality of experience while reading a passage of text or book. Additionally, such an approach will serve as a "visual signature" - a method of verifying if an individual has indeed given adequate attention to critical text-based information. Further, an accurate "reading-progression-tracker" has potential applications in educational institutions, e-readers and parenting solutions. Tracking the progression of reading remains a challenging problem due to the fact that eye-gaze movements are highly noisy and the eye-gaze is easily distracted in a limited space, like an e-book. In a prior work, we proposed an approach to analyze eye-gaze fixation points collected while reading a page of text in order to classify each measurement to a line of text; this approach did not consider tracking the progression of reading along the line of text. In this paper, we extend the capabilities of the previous algorithm in order to accurately track the progression of reading along each line. the proposed approach employs least squares batch estimation in order to estimate three states of the horizontal saccade: position, velocity and acceleration. First, the proposed approach is objectively evaluated on a simulated eye-gaze dataset. Then, the proposed algorithm is demonstrated on real data collected by a Gazepoint eye-tracker while the subject is reading several pages from an electronic book.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.