-
Marginal treatment effects in the absence of instrumental variables
Authors:
Zhewen Pan,
Zhengxin Wang,
Junsen Zhang,
Yahong Zhou
Abstract:
We propose a method for defining, identifying, and estimating the marginal treatment effect (MTE) without imposing the instrumental variable (IV) assumptions of independence, exclusion, and separability (or monotonicity). Under a new definition of the MTE based on reduced-form treatment error that is statistically independent of the covariates, we find that the relationship between the MTE and sta…
▽ More
We propose a method for defining, identifying, and estimating the marginal treatment effect (MTE) without imposing the instrumental variable (IV) assumptions of independence, exclusion, and separability (or monotonicity). Under a new definition of the MTE based on reduced-form treatment error that is statistically independent of the covariates, we find that the relationship between the MTE and standard treatment parameters holds in the absence of IVs. We provide a set of sufficient conditions ensuring the identification of the defined MTE in an environment of essential heterogeneity. The key conditions include a linear restriction on potential outcome regression functions, a nonlinear restriction on the propensity score, and a conditional mean independence restriction that will lead to additive separability. We prove this identification using the notion of semiparametric identification based on functional form. We suggest consistent semiparametric estimation procedures, and provide an empirical application for the Head Start program to illustrate the usefulness of the proposed method in analyzing heterogenous causal effects when IVs are elusive.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Collective Sampling: An Ex Ante Perspective
Authors:
Yangfan Zhou
Abstract:
I study collective dynamic information acquisition. Players determine when to end sequential sampling via a collective stop** rule. With two players, collective stop** is determined either unilaterally or unanimously. I develop a methodology to characterize equilibria using an ex ante perspective on posterior distributions. Under unilateral stop**, each player chooses a mean-preserving contr…
▽ More
I study collective dynamic information acquisition. Players determine when to end sequential sampling via a collective stop** rule. With two players, collective stop** is determined either unilaterally or unanimously. I develop a methodology to characterize equilibria using an ex ante perspective on posterior distributions. Under unilateral stop**, each player chooses a mean-preserving contraction of the other's posterior distribution; under unanimous stop**, they choose mean-preserving spreads. Equilibrium sampling regions are determined via concavification. Preference misalignment generates Pareto inefficiency: there is too little learning under unilateral stop** and possibly too much under unanimous stop**. Learning inefficiencies are amplified when players' preferences become less aligned. I demonstrate the value of my methodology in three applications: committee search, dynamic persuasion, and competition in persuasion.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024; v1 submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Fast Instrument Learning with Faster Rates
Authors:
Ziyu Wang,
Yuhao Zhou,
Jun Zhu
Abstract:
We investigate nonlinear instrumental variable (IV) regression given high-dimensional instruments. We propose a simple algorithm which combines kernelized IV methods and an arbitrary, adaptive regression algorithm, accessed as a black box. Our algorithm enjoys faster-rate convergence and adapts to the dimensionality of informative latent features, while avoiding an expensive minimax optimization p…
▽ More
We investigate nonlinear instrumental variable (IV) regression given high-dimensional instruments. We propose a simple algorithm which combines kernelized IV methods and an arbitrary, adaptive regression algorithm, accessed as a black box. Our algorithm enjoys faster-rate convergence and adapts to the dimensionality of informative latent features, while avoiding an expensive minimax optimization procedure, which has been necessary to establish similar guarantees. It further brings the benefit of flexible machine learning models to quasi-Bayesian uncertainty quantification, likelihood-based model selection, and model averaging. Simulation studies demonstrate the competitive performance of our method.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2022; v1 submitted 22 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Competitive ride-sourcing market with a third-party integrator
Authors:
Yaqian Zhou,
Hai Yang,
**tao Ke,
Hai Wang,
Xinwei Li
Abstract:
Recently, some transportation service providers attempt to integrate the ride services offered by multiple independent ride-sourcing platforms, and passengers are able to request ride through such third-party integrators or connectors and receive service from any one of the platforms. This novel business model, termed as third-party platform-integration in this paper, has potentials to alleviate t…
▽ More
Recently, some transportation service providers attempt to integrate the ride services offered by multiple independent ride-sourcing platforms, and passengers are able to request ride through such third-party integrators or connectors and receive service from any one of the platforms. This novel business model, termed as third-party platform-integration in this paper, has potentials to alleviate the cost of market fragmentation due to the demand splitting among multiple platforms. While most existing studies focus on the operation strategies for one single monopolist platform, much less is known about the competition and platform-integration as well as the implications on operation strategy and system efficiency. In this paper, we propose mathematical models to describe the ride-sourcing market with multiple competing platforms and compare system performance metrics between two market scenarios, i.e., with and without platform-integration, at Nash equilibrium as well as social optimum. We find that platform-integration can increase total realized demand and social welfare at both Nash equilibrium and social optimum, but may not necessarily generate a greater profit when vehicle supply is sufficiently large or/and market is too fragmented. We show that the market with platform-integration generally achieves greater social welfare. On one hand, the integrator in platform-integration is able to generate a thicker market and reduce matching frictions; on the other hand, multiple platforms are still competing by independently setting their prices, which help to mitigate monopoly mark-up as in the monopoly market.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Dynamic Assortment Optimization with Changing Contextual Information
Authors:
Xi Chen,
Yining Wang,
Yuan Zhou
Abstract:
In this paper, we study the dynamic assortment optimization problem under a finite selling season of length $T$. At each time period, the seller offers an arriving customer an assortment of substitutable products under a cardinality constraint, and the customer makes the purchase among offered products according to a discrete choice model. Most existing work associates each product with a real-val…
▽ More
In this paper, we study the dynamic assortment optimization problem under a finite selling season of length $T$. At each time period, the seller offers an arriving customer an assortment of substitutable products under a cardinality constraint, and the customer makes the purchase among offered products according to a discrete choice model. Most existing work associates each product with a real-valued fixed mean utility and assumes a multinomial logit choice (MNL) model. In many practical applications, feature/contexutal information of products is readily available. In this paper, we incorporate the feature information by assuming a linear relationship between the mean utility and the feature. In addition, we allow the feature information of products to change over time so that the underlying choice model can also be non-stationary. To solve the dynamic assortment optimization under this changing contextual MNL model, we need to simultaneously learn the underlying unknown coefficient and makes the decision on the assortment. To this end, we develop an upper confidence bound (UCB) based policy and establish the regret bound on the order of $\widetilde O(d\sqrt{T})$, where $d$ is the dimension of the feature and $\widetilde O$ suppresses logarithmic dependence. We further established the lower bound $Ω(d\sqrt{T}/K)$ where $K$ is the cardinality constraint of an offered assortment, which is usually small. When $K$ is a constant, our policy is optimal up to logarithmic factors. In the exploitation phase of the UCB algorithm, we need to solve a combinatorial optimization for assortment optimization based on the learned information. We further develop an approximation algorithm and an efficient greedy heuristic. The effectiveness of the proposed policy is further demonstrated by our numerical studies.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2019; v1 submitted 30 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Failure of Smooth Pasting Principle and Nonexistence of Equilibrium Stop** Rules under Time-Inconsistency
Authors:
Ken Seng Tan,
Wei Wei,
Xun Yu Zhou
Abstract:
This paper considers a time-inconsistent stop** problem in which the inconsistency arises from non-constant time preference rates. We show that the smooth pasting principle, the main approach that has been used to construct explicit solutions for conventional time-consistent optimal stop** problems, may fail under time-inconsistency. Specifically, we prove that the smooth pasting principle sol…
▽ More
This paper considers a time-inconsistent stop** problem in which the inconsistency arises from non-constant time preference rates. We show that the smooth pasting principle, the main approach that has been used to construct explicit solutions for conventional time-consistent optimal stop** problems, may fail under time-inconsistency. Specifically, we prove that the smooth pasting principle solves a time-inconsistent problem within the intra-personal game theoretic framework if and only if a certain inequality on the model primitives is satisfied. We show that the violation of this inequality can happen even for very simple non-exponential discount functions. Moreover, we demonstrate that the stop** problem does not admit any intra-personal equilibrium whenever the smooth pasting principle fails. The "negative" results in this paper caution blindly extending the classical approaches for time-consistent stop** problems to their time-inconsistent counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2019; v1 submitted 4 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
General Stop** Behaviors of Naive and Non-Committed Sophisticated Agents, with Application to Probability Distortion
Authors:
Yu-Jui Huang,
Adrien Nguyen-Huu,
Xun Yu Zhou
Abstract:
We consider the problem of stop** a diffusion process with a payoff functional that renders the problem time-inconsistent. We study stop** decisions of naive agents who reoptimize continuously in time, as well as equilibrium strategies of sophisticated agents who anticipate but lack control over their future selves' behaviors. When the state process is one dimensional and the payoff functional…
▽ More
We consider the problem of stop** a diffusion process with a payoff functional that renders the problem time-inconsistent. We study stop** decisions of naive agents who reoptimize continuously in time, as well as equilibrium strategies of sophisticated agents who anticipate but lack control over their future selves' behaviors. When the state process is one dimensional and the payoff functional satisfies some regularity conditions, we prove that any equilibrium can be obtained as a fixed point of an operator. This operator represents strategic reasoning that takes the future selves' behaviors into account. We then apply the general results to the case when the agents distort probability and the diffusion process is a geometric Brownian motion. The problem is inherently time-inconsistent as the level of distortion of a same event changes over time. We show how the strategic reasoning may turn a naive agent into a sophisticated one. Moreover, we derive stop** strategies of the two types of agent for various parameter specifications of the problem, illustrating rich behaviors beyond the extreme ones such as "never-stop**" or "never-starting".
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2019; v1 submitted 11 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
