-
Battery Operations in Electricity Markets: Strategic Behavior and Distortions
Authors:
Jerry Anunrojwong,
Santiago R. Balseiro,
Omar Besbes,
Bolun Xu
Abstract:
Electric power systems are undergoing a major transformation as they integrate intermittent renewable energy sources, and batteries to smooth out variations in renewable energy production. As privately-owned batteries grow from their role as marginal "price-takers" to significant players in the market, a natural question arises: How do batteries operate in electricity markets, and how does the str…
▽ More
Electric power systems are undergoing a major transformation as they integrate intermittent renewable energy sources, and batteries to smooth out variations in renewable energy production. As privately-owned batteries grow from their role as marginal "price-takers" to significant players in the market, a natural question arises: How do batteries operate in electricity markets, and how does the strategic behavior of decentralized batteries distort decisions compared to centralized batteries?
We propose an analytically tractable model that captures salient features of the highly complex electricity market. We derive in closed form the resulting battery behavior and generation cost in three operating regimes: (i) no battery, (ii) centralized battery, and (ii) decentralized profit-maximizing battery. We establish that a decentralized battery distorts its discharge decisions in three ways. First, there is quantity withholding, i.e., discharging less than centrally optimal. Second, there is a shift in participation from day-ahead to real-time, i.e., postponing some of its discharge from day-ahead to real-time. Third, there is reduction in real-time responsiveness, or discharging less in response to smoothing real-time demand than centrally optimal. We quantify each of the three forms of distortions in terms of market fundamentals. To illustrate our results, we calibrate our model to Los Angeles and Houston and show that the loss from incentive misalignment could be consequential.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Falsifiable Test Design in Coordination Games
Authors:
Yingkai Li,
Boli Xu
Abstract:
A principal can propose a project to an agent, who then decides whether to accept. Their payoffs from launching the project depend on an unknown binary state. The principal can obtain more precise information about the state through a test at no cost, but crucially, it is common knowledge that she can falsify the test result. In the most interesting case where players have conflicted interests, th…
▽ More
A principal can propose a project to an agent, who then decides whether to accept. Their payoffs from launching the project depend on an unknown binary state. The principal can obtain more precise information about the state through a test at no cost, but crucially, it is common knowledge that she can falsify the test result. In the most interesting case where players have conflicted interests, the optimal test is a binary lemon-detecting test. We also find that coordination is possible when the principal is pessimistic but not when the agent is pessimistic. Moreover, when the agent has private information about the state, a single binary lemon-detecting test remains optimal even though the principal has the option to screen the agent by providing a menu of tests. Our finding is consistent with observed tests in real practice.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Prudent Price-Responsive Demands
Authors:
Liudong Chen,
Bolun Xu
Abstract:
We investigate a flexible demand with a risk-neutral cost-saving objective in response to volatile electricity prices. We introduce the concept of prudent demand, which states that future price uncertainties will affect immediate consumption patterns, despite the price expectations remaining unchanged. We develop a theoretical framework and prove that demand exhibits prudence when the third-order…
▽ More
We investigate a flexible demand with a risk-neutral cost-saving objective in response to volatile electricity prices. We introduce the concept of prudent demand, which states that future price uncertainties will affect immediate consumption patterns, despite the price expectations remaining unchanged. We develop a theoretical framework and prove that demand exhibits prudence when the third-order derivative of its utility cost function is positive, and show a prudent demand demonstrates risk-averse behaviors despite the objective being risk-neutral. . Prudent demands exhibit skewness aversion, with increased price skewness elevating the cost associated with prudence. We validate our theoretical findings through numerical simulations and conclude their implications for demand response modeling and the future design of incentive-based demand response mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Matching Markets
Authors:
Andrew Yang,
Bruce Changlong Xu,
Ivan Villa-Renteria
Abstract:
Matching markets are of particular interest in computer science and economics literature as they are often used to model real-world phenomena where we aim to equitably distribute a limited amount of resources to multiple agents and determine these distributions efficiently. Although it has been shown that finding market clearing prices for Fisher markets with indivisible goods is NP-hard, there ex…
▽ More
Matching markets are of particular interest in computer science and economics literature as they are often used to model real-world phenomena where we aim to equitably distribute a limited amount of resources to multiple agents and determine these distributions efficiently. Although it has been shown that finding market clearing prices for Fisher markets with indivisible goods is NP-hard, there exist polynomial-time algorithms able to compute these prices and allocations when the goods are divisible and the utility functions are linear. We provide a promising research direction toward the development of a market that simulates buyers' preferences that vary according to the bundles of goods allocated to other buyers. Our research aims to elucidate unique ways in which the theory of matching markets can be extended to account for more complex and often counterintuitive microeconomic phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.