Showing 1–2 of 2 results for author: Pilgrim, C
-
Communication Reliably Improves Individual But Not Group Accuracy
Authors:
Charlie Pilgrim,
Joshua Becker
Abstract:
Prior research offers mixed evidence on whether and when communication improves belief accuracy for numeric estimates. Experiments on one-to-one advice suggest that communication between peers usually benefits accuracy, while group experiments indicate that communication networks produce highly variable outcomes. Notably, it is possible for a group's average estimate to become less accurate even a…
▽ More
Prior research offers mixed evidence on whether and when communication improves belief accuracy for numeric estimates. Experiments on one-to-one advice suggest that communication between peers usually benefits accuracy, while group experiments indicate that communication networks produce highly variable outcomes. Notably, it is possible for a group's average estimate to become less accurate even as its individual group members -- on average -- become more accurate. However, the conditions under which communication improves group and/or individual outcomes remain poorly characterised. We analyse an empirically supported model of opinion formation to derive these conditions, formally explicating the relationship between group-level effects and individual outcomes. We reanalyze previously published experimental data, finding that empirical dynamics are consistent with theoretical expectations. We show that 3 measures completely describe asymptotic opinion dynamics: the initial crowd bias; the degree of influence centralisation; and the correlation between influence and initial biases. We find analytic expressions for the change in crowd and individual accuracy as a function of the product of these three measures, which we describe as the truth alignment. We show how truth alignment can be decomposed into calibration (influence/accuracy correlation), and herding (influence/averageness correlation), and how these measures relate to changes in accuracy. Overall, we find that individuals can and usually do improve even when groups get worse.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
The Rising Entropy of English in the Attention Economy
Authors:
Charlie Pilgrim,
Weisi Guo,
Thomas T. Hills
Abstract:
We present evidence that the word entropy of American English has been rising steadily since around 1900, contrary to predictions from existing sociolinguistic theories. We also find differences in word entropy between media categories, with short-form media such as news and magazines having higher entropy than long-form media, and social media feeds having higher entropy still. To explain these r…
▽ More
We present evidence that the word entropy of American English has been rising steadily since around 1900, contrary to predictions from existing sociolinguistic theories. We also find differences in word entropy between media categories, with short-form media such as news and magazines having higher entropy than long-form media, and social media feeds having higher entropy still. To explain these results we develop an ecological model of the attention economy that combines ideas from Zipf's law and information foraging. In this model, media consumers maximize information utility rate taking into account the costs of information search, while media producers adapt to technologies that reduce search costs, driving them to generate higher entropy content in increasingly shorter formats.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023; v1 submitted 27 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
