Policy Changes and Growth Slowdown: Assessing the Lost Decade of the Latin American Miracle
Authors:
Emiliano Toni,
Pablo Paniagua,
Patricio Órdenes
Abstract:
The Latin American region has suffered an economic slowdown since the end of the commodities boom. Within this context, Chile was the poster child of economic growth and development up until 2014. Since then, Chile has also been trapped in a decade of slow economic growth. Chile's sudden slowdown and recent growth path divergence have posed a puzzle for economic growth and development economics. T…
▽ More
The Latin American region has suffered an economic slowdown since the end of the commodities boom. Within this context, Chile was the poster child of economic growth and development up until 2014. Since then, Chile has also been trapped in a decade of slow economic growth. Chile's sudden slowdown and recent growth path divergence have posed a puzzle for economic growth and development economics. This paper examines this slowdown from an empirical perspective and determines how much can be attributed to internal and external causes. Using a synthetic control approach and a structural time series Bayesian estimation, our findings suggest that at least two-thirds of the Chilean slowdown is attributable to internal causes driven by a policy regime change in 2014, with external factors playing a secondary role. The net effect of this set of internal reforms resulted in a nearly 10% reduction in real GDP per capita over five years and led to a 1.8% decline in average GDP growth rates from 2015 to 2019. Our results are consistent with the literature that establishes that external shocks can explain only a small fraction of the poor economic performance of develo** countries, suggesting that internal factors are the primary source of subpar performance. This research sheds light on the potential effects of policy regime shifts in economic growth, thus providing valuable insights for development economics and, more specifically, emerging economies.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
Earthquakes and the wealth of nations: The cases of Chile and New Zealand
Authors:
Diego Díaz,
Pablo Paniagua,
Cristián Larroulet
Abstract:
The consequences of natural disasters, such as earthquakes, are evident: death, coordination problems, destruction of infrastructure, and displacement of population. However, according to empirical research, the impact of a natural disaster on economic activity is mixed. Natural disasters could have significant economic effects, especially in develo** economies. This is particularly important fo…
▽ More
The consequences of natural disasters, such as earthquakes, are evident: death, coordination problems, destruction of infrastructure, and displacement of population. However, according to empirical research, the impact of a natural disaster on economic activity is mixed. Natural disasters could have significant economic effects, especially in develo** economies. This is particularly important for highly seismic countries such as Chile and New Zealand. This paper contributes to the literature on natural disasters and economic development by analyzing the cases of two affected regions within these countries in the wake of major earthquakes experienced during 2010-2011: Maule (Chile) and Canterbury (New Zealand). We examine the impact of natural disasters on GDP per capita by applying the synthetic control method. Using the synthetic approach, we assess the effects of these two earthquakes by building counterfactuals to compare their recovery trajectories. We find that Chile and New Zealand experienced opposite economic effects. The Canterbury region grew 10% more in three years than its synthetic counterfactual without the earthquake, while the Maule region declined by 5%. We build synthetic controls at a regional and economic-sector level, looking at aggregated and sectoral effects. The difference in institutions, such as property rights and the large amount of government spending given for reconstruction after the New Zealand earthquake relative to Chile's, help to explain the difference in outcomes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
