Equity Implications of Net-Zero Emissions: A Multi-Model Analysis of Energy Expenditures Across Income Classes Under Economy-Wide Deep Decarbonization Policies
Authors:
John Bistlinea,
Chikara Onda,
Morgan Browning,
Johannes Emmerling,
Gokul Iyer,
Megan Mahajan,
Jim McFarland,
Haewon McJeon,
Robbie Orvis,
Francisco Ralston Fonseca,
Christopher Roney,
Noah Sandoval,
Luis Sarmiento,
John Weyant,
Jared Woollacott,
Mei Yuan
Abstract:
With companies, states, and countries targeting net-zero emissions around midcentury, there are questions about how these targets alter household welfare and finances, including distributional effects across income groups. This paper examines the distributional dimensions of technology transitions and net-zero policies with a focus on welfare impacts across household incomes. The analysis uses a m…
▽ More
With companies, states, and countries targeting net-zero emissions around midcentury, there are questions about how these targets alter household welfare and finances, including distributional effects across income groups. This paper examines the distributional dimensions of technology transitions and net-zero policies with a focus on welfare impacts across household incomes. The analysis uses a model intercomparison with a range of energy-economy models using harmonized policy scenarios reaching economy-wide, net-zero CO2 emissions across the United States in 2050. We employ a novel linking approach that connects output from detailed energy system models with survey microdata on energy expenditures across income classes to provide distributional analysis of net-zero policies. Although there are differences in model structure and input assumptions, we find broad agreement in qualitative trends in policy incidence and energy burdens across income groups. Models generally agree that direct energy expenditures for many households will likely decline over time with reference and net-zero policies. However, there is variation in the extent of changes relative to current levels, energy burdens relative to reference levels, and electricity expenditures. Policy design, primarily how climate policy revenues are used, has first-order impacts on distributional outcomes. Net-zero policy costs, in both absolute and relative terms, are unevenly distributed across households, and relative increases in energy expenditures are higher for lowest-income households. However, we also find that recycled revenues from climate policies have countervailing effects when rebated on a per-capita basis, offsetting higher energy burdens and potentially even leading to net progressive outcomes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
Emissions and Energy Impacts of the Inflation Reduction Act
Authors:
John Bistline,
Geoffrey Blanford,
Maxwell Brown,
Dallas Burtraw,
Maya Domeshek,
Jamil Farbes,
Allen Fawcett,
Anne Hamilton,
Jesse Jenkins,
Ryan Jones,
Ben King,
Hannah Kolus,
John Larsen,
Amanda Levin,
Megan Mahajan,
Cara Marcy,
Erin Mayfield,
James McFarland,
Haewon McJeon,
Robbie Orvis,
Neha Patankar,
Kevin Rennert,
Christopher Roney,
Nicholas Roy,
Greg Schivley
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
If goals set under the Paris Agreement are met, the world may hold warming well below 2 C; however, parties are not on track to deliver these commitments, increasing focus on policy implementation to close the gap between ambition and action. Recently, the US government passed its most prominent piece of climate legislation to date, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA), designed to invest in…
▽ More
If goals set under the Paris Agreement are met, the world may hold warming well below 2 C; however, parties are not on track to deliver these commitments, increasing focus on policy implementation to close the gap between ambition and action. Recently, the US government passed its most prominent piece of climate legislation to date, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA), designed to invest in a wide range of programs that, among other provisions, incentivize clean energy and carbon management, encourage electrification and efficiency measures, reduce methane emissions, promote domestic supply chains, and address environmental justice concerns. IRA's scope and complexity make modeling important to understand impacts on emissions and energy systems. We leverage results from nine independent, state-of-the-art models to examine potential implications of key IRA provisions, showing economy wide emissions reductions between 43-48% below 2005 by 2035.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
