-
Beyond the Mean: Testing Consumer Rationality through Higher Moments of Demand
Authors:
Sebastiaan Maes,
Raghav Malhotra
Abstract:
We study a setting where an analyst has access to purely aggregate information about the consumption choices of a heterogenous population of individuals. We show that observing the statistical moments of market demand allows the analyst to test aggregate data for rationality. Interestingly, just the mean and variance of demand carry observable restrictions. This is in stark contrast to impossibili…
▽ More
We study a setting where an analyst has access to purely aggregate information about the consumption choices of a heterogenous population of individuals. We show that observing the statistical moments of market demand allows the analyst to test aggregate data for rationality. Interestingly, just the mean and variance of demand carry observable restrictions. This is in stark contrast to impossibility result of the Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu theorem, which shows that aggregate demand carries no observable restrictions at all. We leverage our approach to deliver a characterization of rationality in terms of moments for the common two-good case. We illustrate the usefulness of moment-based restrictions through two applications: (i) improving the precision of demand and welfare estimates; and (ii) testing for the existence of a welfare-relevant representative consumer.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Robust Hicksian Welfare Analysis under Individual Heterogeneity
Authors:
Sebastiaan Maes,
Raghav Malhotra
Abstract:
Welfare effects of price changes are often estimated with cross-sections; these do not identify demand with heterogeneous consumers. We develop a theoretical method addressing this, utilizing uncompensated demand moments to construct local approximations for compensated demand moments, robust to unobserved preference heterogeneity. Our methodological contribution offers robust approximations for a…
▽ More
Welfare effects of price changes are often estimated with cross-sections; these do not identify demand with heterogeneous consumers. We develop a theoretical method addressing this, utilizing uncompensated demand moments to construct local approximations for compensated demand moments, robust to unobserved preference heterogeneity. Our methodological contribution offers robust approximations for average and distributional welfare estimates, extending to price indices, taxable income elasticities, and general equilibrium welfare. Our methods apply to any cross-section; we demonstrate them via UK household budget survey data. We uncover an insight: simple non-parametric representative agent models might be less biased than complex parametric models accounting for heterogeneity.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Finite Tests from Functional Characterizations
Authors:
Charles Gauthier,
Raghav Malhotra,
Agustin Troccoli Moretti
Abstract:
Classically, testing whether decision makers belong to specific preference classes involves two main approaches. The first, known as the functional approach, assumes access to an entire demand function. The second, the revealed preference approach, constructs inequalities to test finite demand data. This paper bridges these methods by using the functional approach to test finite data through prefe…
▽ More
Classically, testing whether decision makers belong to specific preference classes involves two main approaches. The first, known as the functional approach, assumes access to an entire demand function. The second, the revealed preference approach, constructs inequalities to test finite demand data. This paper bridges these methods by using the functional approach to test finite data through preference learnability results. We develop a computationally efficient algorithm that generates tests for choice data based on functional characterizations of preference families. We provide these restrictions for various applications, including homothetic and weakly separable preferences, where the latter's revealed preference characterization is provably NP-Hard. We also address choice under uncertainty, offering tests for betweenness preferences. Lastly, we perform a simulation exercise demonstrating that our tests are effective in finite samples and accurately reject demands not belonging to a specified class.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024; v1 submitted 7 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Exact inference from finite market data
Authors:
Felix Kübler,
Raghav Malhotra,
Herakles Polemarchakis
Abstract:
We develop conditions under which individual choices and Walrasian equilibrium prices and allocations can be exactly inferred from finite market data. First, we consider market data that consist of individual demands as prices and incomes change. Second, we show that finitely many observations of individual endowments and associated Walrasian equilibrium prices, and only prices, suffice to identif…
▽ More
We develop conditions under which individual choices and Walrasian equilibrium prices and allocations can be exactly inferred from finite market data. First, we consider market data that consist of individual demands as prices and incomes change. Second, we show that finitely many observations of individual endowments and associated Walrasian equilibrium prices, and only prices, suffice to identify individual demands and, as a consequence, equilibrium comparative statics.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
