-
Modeling Unknown Stochastic Dynamical System Subject to External Excitation
Authors:
Yuan Chen,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical method for learning unknown nonautonomous stochastic dynamical system, i.e., stochastic system subject to time dependent excitation or control signals. Our basic assumption is that the governing equations for the stochastic system are unavailable. However, short bursts of input/output (I/O) data consisting of certain known excitation signals and their corresponding system re…
▽ More
We present a numerical method for learning unknown nonautonomous stochastic dynamical system, i.e., stochastic system subject to time dependent excitation or control signals. Our basic assumption is that the governing equations for the stochastic system are unavailable. However, short bursts of input/output (I/O) data consisting of certain known excitation signals and their corresponding system responses are available. When a sufficient amount of such I/O data are available, our method is capable of learning the unknown dynamics and producing an accurate predictive model for the stochastic responses of the system subject to arbitrary excitation signals not in the training data. Our method has two key components: (1) a local approximation of the training I/O data to transfer the learning into a parameterized form; and (2) a generative model to approximate the underlying unknown stochastic flow map in distribution. After presenting the method in detail, we present a comprehensive set of numerical examples to demonstrate the performance of the proposed method, especially for long-term system predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Modeling Unknown Stochastic Dynamical System via Autoencoder
Authors:
Zhongshu Xu,
Yuan Chen,
Qifan Chen,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical method to learn an accurate predictive model for an unknown stochastic dynamical system from its trajectory data. The method seeks to approximate the unknown flow map of the underlying system. It employs the idea of autoencoder to identify the unobserved latent random variables. In our approach, we design an encoding function to discover the latent variables, which are model…
▽ More
We present a numerical method to learn an accurate predictive model for an unknown stochastic dynamical system from its trajectory data. The method seeks to approximate the unknown flow map of the underlying system. It employs the idea of autoencoder to identify the unobserved latent random variables. In our approach, we design an encoding function to discover the latent variables, which are modeled as unit Gaussian, and a decoding function to reconstruct the future states of the system. Both the encoder and decoder are expressed as deep neural networks (DNNs). Once the DNNs are trained by the trajectory data, the decoder serves as a predictive model for the unknown stochastic system. Through an extensive set of numerical examples, we demonstrate that the method is able to produce long-term system predictions by using short bursts of trajectory data. It is also applicable to systems driven by non-Gaussian noises.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Flow Map Learning for Unknown Dynamical Systems: Overview, Implementation, and Benchmarks
Authors:
Victor Churchill,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
Flow map learning (FML), in conjunction with deep neural networks (DNNs), has shown promises for data driven modeling of unknown dynamical systems. A remarkable feature of FML is that it is capable of producing accurate predictive models for partially observed systems, even when their exact mathematical models do not exist. In this paper, we present an overview of the FML framework, along with the…
▽ More
Flow map learning (FML), in conjunction with deep neural networks (DNNs), has shown promises for data driven modeling of unknown dynamical systems. A remarkable feature of FML is that it is capable of producing accurate predictive models for partially observed systems, even when their exact mathematical models do not exist. In this paper, we present an overview of the FML framework, along with the important computational details for its successful implementation. We also present a set of well defined benchmark problems for learning unknown dynamical systems. All the numerical details of these problems are presented, along with their FML results, to ensure that the problems are accessible for cross-examination and the results are reproducible.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The 2nd Place Solution for 2023 Waymo Open Sim Agents Challenge
Authors:
Cheng Qian,
Di Xiu,
Minghao Tian
Abstract:
In this technical report, we present the 2nd place solution of 2023 Waymo Open Sim Agents Challenge (WOSAC)[4]. We propose a simple yet effective autoregressive method for simulating multi-agent behaviors, which is built upon a well-known multimodal motion forecasting framework called Motion Transformer (MTR)[5] with postprocessing algorithms applied. Our submission named MTR+++ achieves 0.4697 on…
▽ More
In this technical report, we present the 2nd place solution of 2023 Waymo Open Sim Agents Challenge (WOSAC)[4]. We propose a simple yet effective autoregressive method for simulating multi-agent behaviors, which is built upon a well-known multimodal motion forecasting framework called Motion Transformer (MTR)[5] with postprocessing algorithms applied. Our submission named MTR+++ achieves 0.4697 on the Realism Meta metric in 2023 WOSAC. Besides, a modified model based on MTR named MTR_E is proposed after the challenge, which has a better score 0.4911 and is ranked the 3rd on the leaderboard of WOSAC as of June 25, 2023.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Learning Stochastic Dynamical System via Flow Map Operator
Authors:
Yuan Chen,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical framework for learning unknown stochastic dynamical systems using measurement data. Termed stochastic flow map learning (sFML), the new framework is an extension of flow map learning (FML) that was developed for learning deterministic dynamical systems. For learning stochastic systems, we define a stochastic flow map that is a superposition of two sub-flow maps: a determinis…
▽ More
We present a numerical framework for learning unknown stochastic dynamical systems using measurement data. Termed stochastic flow map learning (sFML), the new framework is an extension of flow map learning (FML) that was developed for learning deterministic dynamical systems. For learning stochastic systems, we define a stochastic flow map that is a superposition of two sub-flow maps: a deterministic sub-map and a stochastic sub-map. The stochastic training data are used to construct the deterministic sub-map first, followed by the stochastic sub-map. The deterministic sub-map takes the form of residual network (ResNet), similar to the work of FML for deterministic systems. For the stochastic sub-map, we employ a generative model, particularly generative adversarial networks (GANs) in this paper. The final constructed stochastic flow map then defines a stochastic evolution model that is a weak approximation, in term of distribution, of the unknown stochastic system. A comprehensive set of numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the flexibility and effectiveness of the proposed sFML method for various types of stochastic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Learning Fine Scale Dynamics from Coarse Observations via Inner Recurrence
Authors:
Victor Churchill,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
Recent work has focused on data-driven learning of the evolution of unknown systems via deep neural networks (DNNs), with the goal of conducting long term prediction of the dynamics of the unknown system. In many real-world applications, data from time-dependent systems are often collected on a time scale that is coarser than desired, due to various restrictions during the data acquisition process…
▽ More
Recent work has focused on data-driven learning of the evolution of unknown systems via deep neural networks (DNNs), with the goal of conducting long term prediction of the dynamics of the unknown system. In many real-world applications, data from time-dependent systems are often collected on a time scale that is coarser than desired, due to various restrictions during the data acquisition process. Consequently, the observed dynamics can be severely under-sampled and do not reflect the true dynamics of the underlying system. This paper presents a computational technique to learn the fine-scale dynamics from such coarsely observed data. The method employs inner recurrence of a DNN to recover the fine-scale evolution operator of the underlying system. In addition to mathematical justification, several challenging numerical examples, including unknown systems of both ordinary and partial differential equations, are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Deep Learning of Chaotic Systems from Partially-Observed Data
Authors:
Victor Churchill,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
Recently, a general data driven numerical framework has been developed for learning and modeling of unknown dynamical systems using fully- or partially-observed data. The method utilizes deep neural networks (DNNs) to construct a model for the flow map of the unknown system. Once an accurate DNN approximation of the flow map is constructed, it can be recursively executed to serve as an effective p…
▽ More
Recently, a general data driven numerical framework has been developed for learning and modeling of unknown dynamical systems using fully- or partially-observed data. The method utilizes deep neural networks (DNNs) to construct a model for the flow map of the unknown system. Once an accurate DNN approximation of the flow map is constructed, it can be recursively executed to serve as an effective predictive model of the unknown system. In this paper, we apply this framework to chaotic systems, in particular the well-known Lorenz 63 and 96 systems, and critically examine the predictive performance of the approach. A distinct feature of chaotic systems is that even the smallest perturbations will lead to large (albeit bounded) deviations in the solution trajectories. This makes long-term predictions of the method, or any data driven methods, questionable, as the local model accuracy will eventually degrade and lead to large pointwise errors. Here we employ several other qualitative and quantitative measures to determine whether the chaotic dynamics have been learned. These include phase plots, histograms, autocorrelation, correlation dimension, approximate entropy, and Lyapunov exponent. Using these measures, we demonstrate that the flow map based DNN learning method is capable of accurately modeling chaotic systems, even when only a subset of the state variables are available to the DNNs. For example, for the Lorenz 96 system with 40 state variables, when data of only 3 variables are available, the method is able to learn an effective DNN model for the 3 variables and produce accurately the chaotic behavior of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Robust Modeling of Unknown Dynamical Systems via Ensemble Averaged Learning
Authors:
Victor Churchill,
Steve Manns,
Zhen Chen,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
Recent work has focused on data-driven learning of the evolution of unknown systems via deep neural networks (DNNs), with the goal of conducting long time prediction of the evolution of the unknown system. Training a DNN with low generalization error is a particularly important task in this case as error is accumulated over time. Because of the inherent randomness in DNN training, chiefly in stoch…
▽ More
Recent work has focused on data-driven learning of the evolution of unknown systems via deep neural networks (DNNs), with the goal of conducting long time prediction of the evolution of the unknown system. Training a DNN with low generalization error is a particularly important task in this case as error is accumulated over time. Because of the inherent randomness in DNN training, chiefly in stochastic optimization, there is uncertainty in the resulting prediction, and therefore in the generalization error. Hence, the generalization error can be viewed as a random variable with some probability distribution. Well-trained DNNs, particularly those with many hyperparameters, typically result in probability distributions for generalization error with low bias but high variance. High variance causes variability and unpredictably in the results of a trained DNN. This paper presents a computational technique which decreases the variance of the generalization error, thereby improving the reliability of the DNN model to generalize consistently. In the proposed ensemble averaging method, multiple models are independently trained and model predictions are averaged at each time step. A mathematical foundation for the method is presented, including results regarding the distribution of the local truncation error. In addition, three time-dependent differential equation problems are considered as numerical examples, demonstrating the effectiveness of the method to decrease variance of DNN predictions generally.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Modeling unknown dynamical systems with hidden parameters
Authors:
Xiaohan Fu,
Weize Mao,
Lo-Bin Chang,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a data-driven numerical approach for modeling unknown dynamical systems with missing/hidden parameters. The method is based on training a deep neural network (DNN) model for the unknown system using its trajectory data. A key feature is that the unknown dynamical system contains system parameters that are completely hidden, in the sense that no information about the parameters is availa…
▽ More
We present a data-driven numerical approach for modeling unknown dynamical systems with missing/hidden parameters. The method is based on training a deep neural network (DNN) model for the unknown system using its trajectory data. A key feature is that the unknown dynamical system contains system parameters that are completely hidden, in the sense that no information about the parameters is available through either the measurement trajectory data or our prior knowledge of the system. We demonstrate that by training a DNN using the trajectory data with sufficient time history, the resulting DNN model can accurately model the unknown dynamical system. For new initial conditions associated with new, and unknown, system parameters, the DNN model can produce accurate system predictions over longer time.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Deep Neural Network Modeling of Unknown Partial Differential Equations in Nodal Space
Authors:
Zhen Chen,
Victor Churchill,
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical framework for deep neural network (DNN) modeling of unknown time-dependent partial differential equations (PDE) using their trajectory data. Unlike the recent work of [Wu and Xiu, J. Comput. Phys. 2020], where the learning takes place in modal/Fourier space, the current method conducts the learning and modeling in physical space and uses measurement data as nodal values. We…
▽ More
We present a numerical framework for deep neural network (DNN) modeling of unknown time-dependent partial differential equations (PDE) using their trajectory data. Unlike the recent work of [Wu and Xiu, J. Comput. Phys. 2020], where the learning takes place in modal/Fourier space, the current method conducts the learning and modeling in physical space and uses measurement data as nodal values. We present a DNN structure that has a direct correspondence to the evolution operator of the underlying PDE, thus establishing the existence of the DNN model. The DNN model also does not require any geometric information of the data nodes. Consequently, a trained DNN defines a predictive model for the underlying unknown PDE over structureless grids. A set of examples, including linear and nonlinear scalar PDE, system of PDEs, in both one dimension and two dimensions, over structured and unstructured grids, are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed DNN modeling. Extension to other equations such as differential-integral equations is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Data-driven learning of non-autonomous systems
Authors:
Tong Qin,
Zhen Chen,
John Jakeman,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical framework for recovering unknown non-autonomous dynamical systems with time-dependent inputs. To circumvent the difficulty presented by the non-autonomous nature of the system, our method transforms the solution state into piecewise integration of the system over a discrete set of time instances. The time-dependent inputs are then locally parameterized by using a proper mode…
▽ More
We present a numerical framework for recovering unknown non-autonomous dynamical systems with time-dependent inputs. To circumvent the difficulty presented by the non-autonomous nature of the system, our method transforms the solution state into piecewise integration of the system over a discrete set of time instances. The time-dependent inputs are then locally parameterized by using a proper model, for example, polynomial regression, in the pieces determined by the time instances. This transforms the original system into a piecewise parametric system that is locally time invariant. We then design a deep neural network structure to learn the local models. Once the network model is constructed, it can be iteratively used over time to conduct global system prediction. We provide theoretical analysis of our algorithm and present a number of numerical examples to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Learning reduced systems via deep neural networks with memory
Authors:
Xiaohan Fu,
Lo-Bin Chang,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a general numerical approach for constructing governing equations for unknown dynamical systems when only data on a subset of the state variables are available. The unknown equations for these observed variables are thus a reduced system of the complete set of state variables. Reduced systems possess memory integrals, based on the well known Mori-Zwanzig (MZ) formulism. Our numerical st…
▽ More
We present a general numerical approach for constructing governing equations for unknown dynamical systems when only data on a subset of the state variables are available. The unknown equations for these observed variables are thus a reduced system of the complete set of state variables. Reduced systems possess memory integrals, based on the well known Mori-Zwanzig (MZ) formulism. Our numerical strategy to recover the reduced system starts by formulating a discrete approximation of the memory integral in the MZ formulation. The resulting unknown approximate MZ equations are of finite dimensional, in the sense that a finite number of past history data are involved. We then present a deep neural network structure that directly incorporates the history terms to produce memory in the network. The approach is suitable for any practical systems with finite memory length. We then use a set of numerical examples to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2020; v1 submitted 20 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A Non-Intrusive Correction Algorithm for Classification Problems with Corrupted Data
Authors:
Jun Hou,
Tong Qin,
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
A novel correction algorithm is proposed for multi-class classification problems with corrupted training data. The algorithm is non-intrusive, in the sense that it post-processes a trained classification model by adding a correction procedure to the model prediction. The correction procedure can be coupled with any approximators, such as logistic regression, neural networks of various architecture…
▽ More
A novel correction algorithm is proposed for multi-class classification problems with corrupted training data. The algorithm is non-intrusive, in the sense that it post-processes a trained classification model by adding a correction procedure to the model prediction. The correction procedure can be coupled with any approximators, such as logistic regression, neural networks of various architectures, etc. When training dataset is sufficiently large, we prove that the corrected models deliver correct classification results as if there is no corruption in the training data. For datasets of finite size, the corrected models produce significantly better recovery results, compared to the models without the correction algorithm. All of the theoretical findings in the paper are verified by our numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
On generalized residue network for deep learning of unknown dynamical systems
Authors:
Zhen Chen,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a general numerical approach for learning unknown dynamical systems using deep neural networks (DNNs). Our method is built upon recent studies that identified the residue network (ResNet) as an effective neural network structure. In this paper, we present a generalized ResNet framework and broadly define residue as the discrepancy between observation data and prediction made by another…
▽ More
We present a general numerical approach for learning unknown dynamical systems using deep neural networks (DNNs). Our method is built upon recent studies that identified the residue network (ResNet) as an effective neural network structure. In this paper, we present a generalized ResNet framework and broadly define residue as the discrepancy between observation data and prediction made by another model, which can be an existing coarse model or reduced-order model. In this case, the generalized ResNet serves as a model correction to the existing model and recovers the unresolved dynamics. When an existing coarse model is not available, we present numerical strategies for fast creation of coarse models, to be used in conjunction with the generalized ResNet. These coarse models are constructed using the same data set and thus do not require additional resources. The generalized ResNet is capable of learning the underlying unknown equations and producing predictions with accuracy higher than the standard ResNet structure. This is demonstrated via several numerical examples, including long-term prediction of a chaotic system.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Data-Driven Deep Learning of Partial Differential Equations in Modal Space
Authors:
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a framework for recovering/approximating unknown time-dependent partial differential equation (PDE) using its solution data. Instead of identifying the terms in the underlying PDE, we seek to approximate the evolution operator of the underlying PDE numerically. The evolution operator of the PDE, defined in infinite-dimensional space, maps the solution from a current time to a future tim…
▽ More
We present a framework for recovering/approximating unknown time-dependent partial differential equation (PDE) using its solution data. Instead of identifying the terms in the underlying PDE, we seek to approximate the evolution operator of the underlying PDE numerically. The evolution operator of the PDE, defined in infinite-dimensional space, maps the solution from a current time to a future time and completely characterizes the solution evolution of the underlying unknown PDE. Our recovery strategy relies on approximation of the evolution operator in a properly defined modal space, i.e., generalized Fourier space, in order to reduce the problem to finite dimensions. The finite dimensional approximation is then accomplished by training a deep neural network structure, which is based on residual network (ResNet), using the given data. Error analysis is provided to illustrate the predictive accuracy of the proposed method. A set of examples of different types of PDEs, including inviscid Burgers' equation that develops discontinuity in its solution, are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2019; v1 submitted 15 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Structure-preserving Method for Reconstructing Unknown Hamiltonian Systems from Trajectory Data
Authors:
Kailiang Wu,
Tong Qin,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical approach for approximating unknown Hamiltonian systems using observation data. A distinct feature of the proposed method is that it is structure-preserving, in the sense that it enforces conservation of the reconstructed Hamiltonian. This is achieved by directly approximating the underlying unknown Hamiltonian, rather than the right-hand-side of the governing equations. We p…
▽ More
We present a numerical approach for approximating unknown Hamiltonian systems using observation data. A distinct feature of the proposed method is that it is structure-preserving, in the sense that it enforces conservation of the reconstructed Hamiltonian. This is achieved by directly approximating the underlying unknown Hamiltonian, rather than the right-hand-side of the governing equations. We present the technical details of the proposed algorithm and its error estimate in a special case, along with a practical de-noising procedure to cope with noisy data. A set of numerical examples are then presented to demonstrate the structure-preserving property and effectiveness of the algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2020; v1 submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Data Driven Governing Equations Approximation Using Deep Neural Networks
Authors:
Tong Qin,
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present a numerical framework for approximating unknown governing equations using observation data and deep neural networks (DNN). In particular, we propose to use residual network (ResNet) as the basic building block for equation approximation. We demonstrate that the ResNet block can be considered as a one-step method that is exact in temporal integration. We then present two multi-step metho…
▽ More
We present a numerical framework for approximating unknown governing equations using observation data and deep neural networks (DNN). In particular, we propose to use residual network (ResNet) as the basic building block for equation approximation. We demonstrate that the ResNet block can be considered as a one-step method that is exact in temporal integration. We then present two multi-step methods, recurrent ResNet (RT-ResNet) method and recursive ReNet (RS-ResNet) method. The RT-ResNet is a multi-step method on uniform time steps, whereas the RS-ResNet is an adaptive multi-step method using variable time steps. All three methods presented here are based on integral form of the underlying dynamical system. As a result, they do not require time derivative data for equation recovery and can cope with relatively coarsely distributed trajectory data. Several numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the performance of the methods.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Numerical Aspects for Approximating Governing Equations Using Data
Authors:
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present effective numerical algorithms for locally recovering unknown governing differential equations from measurement data. We employ a set of standard basis functions, e.g., polynomials, to approximate the governing equation with high accuracy. Upon recasting the problem into a function approximation problem, we discuss several important aspects for accurate approximation. Most notably, we d…
▽ More
We present effective numerical algorithms for locally recovering unknown governing differential equations from measurement data. We employ a set of standard basis functions, e.g., polynomials, to approximate the governing equation with high accuracy. Upon recasting the problem into a function approximation problem, we discuss several important aspects for accurate approximation. Most notably, we discuss the importance of using a large number of short bursts of trajectory data, rather than using data from a single long trajectory. Several options for the numerical algorithms to perform accurate approximation are then presented, along with an error estimate of the final equation approximation. We then present an extensive set of numerical examples of both linear and nonlinear systems to demonstrate the properties and effectiveness of our equation recovery algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
An Explicit Neural Network Construction for Piecewise Constant Function Approximation
Authors:
Kailiang Wu,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
We present an explicit construction for feedforward neural network (FNN), which provides a piecewise constant approximation for multivariate functions. The proposed FNN has two hidden layers, where the weights and thresholds are explicitly defined and do not require numerical optimization for training. Unlike most of the existing work on explicit FNN construction, the proposed FNN does not rely on…
▽ More
We present an explicit construction for feedforward neural network (FNN), which provides a piecewise constant approximation for multivariate functions. The proposed FNN has two hidden layers, where the weights and thresholds are explicitly defined and do not require numerical optimization for training. Unlike most of the existing work on explicit FNN construction, the proposed FNN does not rely on tensor structure in multiple dimensions. Instead, it automatically creates Voronoi tessellation of the domain, based on the given data of the target function, and piecewise constant approximation of the function. This makes the construction more practical for applications. We present both theoretical analysis and numerical examples to demonstrate its properties.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Reducing Parameter Space for Neural Network Training
Authors:
Tong Qin,
Ling Zhou,
Dongbin Xiu
Abstract:
For neural networks (NNs) with rectified linear unit (ReLU) or binary activation functions, we show that their training can be accomplished in a reduced parameter space. Specifically, the weights in each neuron can be trained on the unit sphere, as opposed to the entire space, and the threshold can be trained in a bounded interval, as opposed to the real line. We show that the NNs in the reduced p…
▽ More
For neural networks (NNs) with rectified linear unit (ReLU) or binary activation functions, we show that their training can be accomplished in a reduced parameter space. Specifically, the weights in each neuron can be trained on the unit sphere, as opposed to the entire space, and the threshold can be trained in a bounded interval, as opposed to the real line. We show that the NNs in the reduced parameter space are mathematically equivalent to the standard NNs with parameters in the whole space. The reduced parameter space shall facilitate the optimization procedure for the network training, as the search space becomes (much) smaller. We demonstrate the improved training performance using numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2020; v1 submitted 21 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
