-
A Lower Bound for the Max Entropy Algorithm for TSP
Authors:
Billy **,
Nathan Klein,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
One of the most famous conjectures in combinatorial optimization is the four-thirds conjecture, which states that the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation of the TSP is equal to $\frac43$. For 40 years, the best known upper bound was 1.5, due to Wolsey (1980). Recently, Karlin, Klein, and Oveis Gharan (2022) showed that the max entropy algorithm for the TSP gives an improved bound of…
▽ More
One of the most famous conjectures in combinatorial optimization is the four-thirds conjecture, which states that the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation of the TSP is equal to $\frac43$. For 40 years, the best known upper bound was 1.5, due to Wolsey (1980). Recently, Karlin, Klein, and Oveis Gharan (2022) showed that the max entropy algorithm for the TSP gives an improved bound of $1.5 - 10^{-36}$. In this paper, we show that the approximation ratio of the max entropy algorithm is at least 1.375, even for graphic TSP. Thus the max entropy algorithm does not appear to be the algorithm that will ultimately resolve the four-thirds conjecture in the affirmative, should that be possible.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Revisiting Garg's 2-Approximation Algorithm for the k-MST Problem in Graphs
Authors:
Emmett Breen,
Renee Mirka,
Zichen Wang,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
This paper revisits the 2-approximation algorithm for $k$-MST presented by Garg in light of a recent paper of Paul et al.. In the $k$-MST problem, the goal is to return a tree spanning $k$ vertices of minimum total edge cost. Paul et al. extend Garg's primal-dual subroutine to improve the approximation ratios for the budgeted prize-collecting traveling salesman and minimum spanning tree problems.…
▽ More
This paper revisits the 2-approximation algorithm for $k$-MST presented by Garg in light of a recent paper of Paul et al.. In the $k$-MST problem, the goal is to return a tree spanning $k$ vertices of minimum total edge cost. Paul et al. extend Garg's primal-dual subroutine to improve the approximation ratios for the budgeted prize-collecting traveling salesman and minimum spanning tree problems. We follow their algorithm and analysis to provide a cleaner version of Garg's result. Additionally, we introduce the novel concept of a kernel which allows an easier visualization of the stages of the algorithm and a clearer understanding of the pruning phase. Other notable updates include presenting a linear programming formulation of the $k$-MST problem, including pseudocode, replacing the coloring scheme used by Garg with the simpler concept of neutral sets, and providing an explicit potential function.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2023; v1 submitted 2 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
A 4/3-Approximation Algorithm for Half-Integral Cycle Cut Instances of the TSP
Authors:
Billy **,
Nathan Klein,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
A long-standing conjecture for the traveling salesman problem (TSP) states that the integrality gap of the standard linear programming relaxation of the TSP is at most 4/3. Despite significant efforts, the conjecture remains open.
We consider the half-integral case, in which the LP has solution values in $\{0, 1/2, 1\}$. Such instances have been conjectured to be the most difficult instances for…
▽ More
A long-standing conjecture for the traveling salesman problem (TSP) states that the integrality gap of the standard linear programming relaxation of the TSP is at most 4/3. Despite significant efforts, the conjecture remains open.
We consider the half-integral case, in which the LP has solution values in $\{0, 1/2, 1\}$. Such instances have been conjectured to be the most difficult instances for the overall four-thirds conjecture. Karlin, Klein, and Oveis Gharan, in a breakthrough result, were able to show that in the half-integral case, the integrality gap is at most 1.49993. This result led to the first significant progress on the overall conjecture in decades; the same authors showed the integrality gap is at most $1.5- 10^{-36}$ in the non-half-integral case. For the half-integral case, the current best-known ratio is 1.4983, a result by Gupta et al.
With the improvements on the 3/2 bound remaining very incremental even in the half-integral case, we turn the question around and look for a large class of half-integral instances for which we can prove that the 4/3 conjecture is correct.
The previous works on the half-integral case perform induction on a hierarchy of critical tight sets in the support graph of the LP solution, in which some of the sets correspond to "cycle cuts" and the others to "degree cuts". We show that if all the sets in the hierarchy correspond to cycle cuts, then we can find a distribution of tours whose expected cost is at most 4/3 times the value of the half-integral LP solution; sampling from the distribution gives us a randomized 4/3-approximation algorithm. We note that the known bad cases for the integrality gap have a gap of 4/3 and have a half-integral LP solution in which all the critical tight sets in the hierarchy are cycle cuts; thus our result is tight.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2023; v1 submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
GILP: An Interactive Tool for Visualizing the Simplex Algorithm
Authors:
Henry W. Robbins,
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David B. Shmoys,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
The Simplex algorithm for solving linear programs-one of Computing in Science & Engineering's top 10 most influential algorithms of the 20th century-is an important topic in many algorithms courses. While the Simplex algorithm relies on intuitive geometric ideas, the computationally-involved mechanics of the algorithm can obfuscate a geometric understanding. In this paper, we present gilp, an easy…
▽ More
The Simplex algorithm for solving linear programs-one of Computing in Science & Engineering's top 10 most influential algorithms of the 20th century-is an important topic in many algorithms courses. While the Simplex algorithm relies on intuitive geometric ideas, the computationally-involved mechanics of the algorithm can obfuscate a geometric understanding. In this paper, we present gilp, an easy-to-use Simplex algorithm visualization tool designed to explicitly connect the mechanical steps of the algorithm with their geometric interpretation. We provide an extensive library with example visualizations, and our tool allows an instructor to quickly produce custom interactive HTML files for students to experiment with the algorithm (without requiring students to install anything!). The tool can also be used for interactive assignments in Jupyter notebooks, and has been incorporated into a forthcoming Data Science and Decision Making interactive textbook. In this paper, we first describe how the tool fits into the existing literature on algorithm visualizations: how it was designed to facilitate student engagement and instructor adoption, and how it substantially extends existing algorithm visualization tools for Simplex. We then describe the development and usage of the tool, and report feedback from its use in a course with roughly 100 students. Student feedback was overwhelmingly positive, with students finding the tool easy to use: it effectively helped them link the algebraic and geometrical views of the Simplex algorithm and understand its nuances. Finally, gilp is open-source, includes an extension to visualizing linear programming-based branch and bound, and is readily amenable to further extensions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2022; v1 submitted 18 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Two-Stripe Symmetric Circulant TSP is in P
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
Billy **,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
The symmetric circulant TSP is a special case of the traveling salesman problem in which edge costs are symmetric and obey circulant symmetry. Despite the substantial symmetry of the input, remarkably little is known about the symmetric circulant TSP, and the complexity of the problem has been an often-cited open question. Considerable effort has been made to understand the case in which only edge…
▽ More
The symmetric circulant TSP is a special case of the traveling salesman problem in which edge costs are symmetric and obey circulant symmetry. Despite the substantial symmetry of the input, remarkably little is known about the symmetric circulant TSP, and the complexity of the problem has been an often-cited open question. Considerable effort has been made to understand the case in which only edges of two lengths are allowed to have finite cost: the two-stripe symmetric circulant TSP. In this paper, we resolve the complexity of the two-stripe symmetric circulant TSP. To do so, we reduce two-stripe symmetric circulant TSP to the problem of finding certain minimum-cost Hamiltonian paths on cylindrical graphs. We then solve this Hamiltonian path problem. Our results show that the two-stripe symmetric circulant TSP is in P. Note that a two-stripe symmetric circulant TSP instance consists of a constant number of inputs (including $n$, the number of cities), so that a polynomial-time algorithm for the decision problem must run in time polylogarithmic in $n$, and a polynomial-time algorithm for the optimization problem cannot output the tour. We address this latter difficulty by showing that the optimal tour must fall into one of two parameterized classes of tours, and that we can output the class and the parameters in polynomial time. Thus we make a substantial contribution to the set of polynomial-time solvable special cases of the TSP, and take an important step towards resolving the complexity of the general symmetric circulant TSP.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Graph Coloring and Semidefinite Rank
Authors:
Renee Mirka,
Devin Smedira,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
This paper considers the interplay between semidefinite programming, matrix rank, and graph coloring. Karger, Motwani, and Sudan \cite{KMS98} give a vector program for which a coloring of the graph can be encoded as a semidefinite matrix of low rank. By complementary slackness conditions of semidefinite programming, if an optimal dual solution has sufficiently high rank, any optimal primal solutio…
▽ More
This paper considers the interplay between semidefinite programming, matrix rank, and graph coloring. Karger, Motwani, and Sudan \cite{KMS98} give a vector program for which a coloring of the graph can be encoded as a semidefinite matrix of low rank. By complementary slackness conditions of semidefinite programming, if an optimal dual solution has sufficiently high rank, any optimal primal solution must have low rank. We attempt to characterize graphs for which we can show that the corresponding dual optimal solution must have sufficiently high rank. In the case of the original Karger, Motwani, and Sudan vector program, we show that any graph which is a $k$-tree has sufficiently high dual rank, and we can extract the coloring from the corresponding low-rank primal solution. We can also show that if the graph is not uniquely colorable, then no sufficiently high rank dual optimal solution can exist. This allows us to completely characterize the planar graphs for which dual optimal solutions have sufficiently high dual rank. We then modify the semidefinite program to have an objective function with costs, and explore when we can create a cost function whose optimal dual solution has sufficiently high rank. We show that it is always possible to construct such a cost function given the graph coloring. The construction of the cost function gives rise to a heuristic for graph coloring which we show works well in the case of planar graphs. Our research was motivated by the Colin de Verdière graph invariant \cite{CDV90}(and a corresponding conjecture of Colin de Verdière), in which matrices that have some similarities to the dual feasible matrices must have high rank in the case that graphs are of a certain type. We explore the connection between the conjecture and the rank of the dual solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Cut-Toggling and Cycle-Toggling for Electrical Flow and Other p-Norm Flows
Authors:
Monika Henzinger,
Billy **,
Richard Peng,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
We study the problem of finding flows in undirected graphs so as to minimize the weighted $p$-norm of the flow for any $p > 1$. When $p=2$, the problem is that of finding an electrical flow, and its dual is equivalent to solving a Laplacian linear system. The case $p = \infty$ corresponds to finding a min-congestion flow, which is equivalent to max-flows. A typical algorithmic construction for suc…
▽ More
We study the problem of finding flows in undirected graphs so as to minimize the weighted $p$-norm of the flow for any $p > 1$. When $p=2$, the problem is that of finding an electrical flow, and its dual is equivalent to solving a Laplacian linear system. The case $p = \infty$ corresponds to finding a min-congestion flow, which is equivalent to max-flows. A typical algorithmic construction for such problems considers vertex potentials corresponding to the flow conservation constraints, and has two simple types of update steps: cycle toggling, which modifies the flow along a cycle, and cut toggling, which modifies all potentials on one side of a cut. Both types of steps are typically performed relative to a spanning tree $T$; then the cycle is a fundamental cycle of $T$, and the cut is a fundamental cut of $T$. In this paper, we show that these simple steps can be used to give a novel efficient implementation for the $p = 2$ case and to find near-optimal $p$-norm flows in a low number of iterations for all values of $p > 1$. Compared to known faster algorithms for these problems, our algorithms are simpler, more combinatorial, and also expose several underlying connections between these algorithms and dynamic graph data structures that have not been formalized previously.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The Circlet Inequalities: A New, Circulant-Based Facet-Defining Inequality for the TSP
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
Facet-defining inequalities of the symmetric Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) polytope play a prominent role in both polyhedral TSP research and state-of-the-art TSP solvers. In this paper, we introduce a new class of facet-defining inequalities, the \emph{circlet inequalities}. These inequalities were first conjectured in Gutekunst and Williamson \cite{Gut19b} when studying Circulant TSP, and the…
▽ More
Facet-defining inequalities of the symmetric Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) polytope play a prominent role in both polyhedral TSP research and state-of-the-art TSP solvers. In this paper, we introduce a new class of facet-defining inequalities, the \emph{circlet inequalities}. These inequalities were first conjectured in Gutekunst and Williamson \cite{Gut19b} when studying Circulant TSP, and they provide a bridge between polyhedral TSP research and number-theoretic investigations of Hamiltonian cycles stemming from a conjecture due to Marco Buratti in 2017. The circlet inequalities exhibit circulant symmetry by placing the same weight on all edges of a given length; our main proof exploits this symmetry to prove the validity of the circlet inequalities. We then show that the circlet inequalities are facet-defining and compute their strength following Goemans \cite{Goe95b}; they achieve the same worst-case strength as the similarly circulant crown inequalities of Naddef and Rinaldi \cite{Nad92}, but are generally stronger.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
A Combinatorial Cut-Toggling Algorithm for Solving Laplacian Linear Systems
Authors:
Monika Henzinger,
Billy **,
Richard Peng,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
Over the last two decades, a significant line of work in theoretical algorithms has made progress in solving linear systems whose coefficient matrix is the Laplacian matrix of a weighted graph. The solution of the linear system can be interpreted as the potentials of an electrical flow. Kelner, Orrechia, Sidford, and Zhu (STOC 2013) give a combinatorial, near-linear time algorithm that maintains t…
▽ More
Over the last two decades, a significant line of work in theoretical algorithms has made progress in solving linear systems whose coefficient matrix is the Laplacian matrix of a weighted graph. The solution of the linear system can be interpreted as the potentials of an electrical flow. Kelner, Orrechia, Sidford, and Zhu (STOC 2013) give a combinatorial, near-linear time algorithm that maintains the Kirchoff Current Law, and gradually enforces the Kirchoff Potential Law by updating flows around cycles (cycle toggling). In this paper, we consider a dual version of the algorithm that maintains the Kirchoff Potential Law, and gradually enforces the Kirchoff Current Law by cut toggling: each iteration updates all potentials on one side of a fundamental cut of a spanning tree by the same amount. We prove that this dual algorithm also runs in a near-linear number of iterations.
We show, however, that if we abstract cut toggling as a natural data structure problem, this problem can be reduced to the online vector-matrix-vector problem, which has been conjectured to be difficult for dynamic algorithms by Henzinger, Krinninger, Nanongkai, and Saranurak (STOC 2015). The conjecture implies that a straightforward implementation of the cut-toggling algorithm requires essentially linear time per iteration. To circumvent the lower bound, we batch update steps, and perform them simultaneously instead of sequentially. An appropriate choice of batching leads to an $\tilde{O}(m^{1.5})$ time cut-toggling algorithm for solving Laplacian systems. Furthermore, if we sparsify the graph and call our algorithm recursively on the Laplacian system implied by batching and sparsifying, the running time can be reduced to $O(m^{1+ε})$ for any $ε> 0$. Thus, the dual cut-toggling algorithm can achieve (almost) the same running time as its primal cycle-toggling counterpart.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 30 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Recursive Random Contraction Revisited
Authors:
David R. Karger,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
In this note, we revisit the recursive random contraction algorithm of Karger and Stein for finding a minimum cut in a graph. Our revisit is occasioned by a paper of Fox, Panigrahi, and Zhang which gives an extension of the Karger-Stein algorithm to minimum cuts and minimum $k$-cuts in hypergraphs. When specialized to the case of graphs, the algorithm is somewhat different than the original Karger…
▽ More
In this note, we revisit the recursive random contraction algorithm of Karger and Stein for finding a minimum cut in a graph. Our revisit is occasioned by a paper of Fox, Panigrahi, and Zhang which gives an extension of the Karger-Stein algorithm to minimum cuts and minimum $k$-cuts in hypergraphs. When specialized to the case of graphs, the algorithm is somewhat different than the original Karger-Stein algorithm. We show that the analysis becomes particularly clean in this case: we can prove that the probability that a fixed minimum cut in an $n$ node graph is returned by the algorithm is bounded below by $1/(2H_n-2)$, where $H_n$ is the $n$th harmonic number. We also consider other similar variants of the algorithm, and show that no such algorithm can achieve an asymptotically better probability of finding a fixed minimum cut.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Improved Analysis of RANKING for Online Vertex-Weighted Bipartite Matching in the Random Order Model
Authors:
Billy **,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider the online vertex-weighted bipartite matching problem in the random arrival model. We consider the generalization of the RANKING algorithm for this problem introduced by Huang, Tang, Wu, and Zhang (TALG 2019), who show that their algorithm has a competitive ratio of 0.6534. We show that assumptions in their analysis can be weakened, allowing us to replace their derivatio…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider the online vertex-weighted bipartite matching problem in the random arrival model. We consider the generalization of the RANKING algorithm for this problem introduced by Huang, Tang, Wu, and Zhang (TALG 2019), who show that their algorithm has a competitive ratio of 0.6534. We show that assumptions in their analysis can be weakened, allowing us to replace their derivation of a crucial function $g$ on the unit square with a linear program that computes the values of a best possible $g$ under these assumptions on a discretized unit square. We show that the discretization does not incur much error, and show computationally that we can obtain a competitive ratio of 0.6629. To compute the bound over our discretized unit square we use parallelization, and still needed two days of computing on a 64-core machine. Furthermore, by modifying our linear program somewhat, we can show computationally an upper bound on our approach of 0.6688; any further progress beyond this bound will require either further weakening in the assumptions of $g$ or a stronger analysis than that of Huang et al.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2022; v1 submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Learning to Solve Combinatorial Optimization Problems on Real-World Graphs in Linear Time
Authors:
Iddo Drori,
Anant Kharkar,
William R. Sickinger,
Brandon Kates,
Qiang Ma,
Suwen Ge,
Eden Dolev,
Brenda Dietrich,
David P. Williamson,
Madeleine Udell
Abstract:
Combinatorial optimization algorithms for graph problems are usually designed afresh for each new problem with careful attention by an expert to the problem structure. In this work, we develop a new framework to solve any combinatorial optimization problem over graphs that can be formulated as a single player game defined by states, actions, and rewards, including minimum spanning tree, shortest p…
▽ More
Combinatorial optimization algorithms for graph problems are usually designed afresh for each new problem with careful attention by an expert to the problem structure. In this work, we develop a new framework to solve any combinatorial optimization problem over graphs that can be formulated as a single player game defined by states, actions, and rewards, including minimum spanning tree, shortest paths, traveling salesman problem, and vehicle routing problem, without expert knowledge. Our method trains a graph neural network using reinforcement learning on an unlabeled training set of graphs. The trained network then outputs approximate solutions to new graph instances in linear running time. In contrast, previous approximation algorithms or heuristics tailored to NP-hard problems on graphs generally have at least quadratic running time. We demonstrate the applicability of our approach on both polynomial and NP-hard problems with optimality gaps close to 1, and show that our method is able to generalize well: (i) from training on small graphs to testing on large graphs; (ii) from training on random graphs of one type to testing on random graphs of another type; and (iii) from training on random graphs to running on real world graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020; v1 submitted 5 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Easy Capacitated Facility Location Problems, with Connections to Lot-Sizing
Authors:
Alice Paul,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
In this note, we consider the capacitated facility location problem when the transportation costs of the instance satisfy the Monge property. We show that a straightforward dynamic program finds the optimal solution when the demands are polynomially bounded. When demands are not polynomially bounded, we give a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme by adapting an algorithm and analysis of Van…
▽ More
In this note, we consider the capacitated facility location problem when the transportation costs of the instance satisfy the Monge property. We show that a straightforward dynamic program finds the optimal solution when the demands are polynomially bounded. When demands are not polynomially bounded, we give a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme by adapting an algorithm and analysis of Van Hoesel and Wagelmans.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Subtour Elimination Constraints Imply a Matrix-Tree Theorem SDP Constraint for the TSP
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
De Klerk, Pasechnik, and Sotirov give a semidefinite programming constraint for the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) based on the matrix-tree Theorem. This constraint says that the aggregate weight of all spanning trees in a solution to a TSP relaxation is at least that of a cycle graph. In this note, we show that the semidefinite constraint holds for any weighted 2-edge-connected graph and, in pa…
▽ More
De Klerk, Pasechnik, and Sotirov give a semidefinite programming constraint for the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) based on the matrix-tree Theorem. This constraint says that the aggregate weight of all spanning trees in a solution to a TSP relaxation is at least that of a cycle graph. In this note, we show that the semidefinite constraint holds for any weighted 2-edge-connected graph and, in particular, is implied by the subtour elimination constraints of the subtour elimination linear program. Hence, this semidefinite constraint is implied by a finite set of linear inequality constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Semidefinite Programming Relaxations of the Traveling Salesman Problem and Their Integrality Gaps
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
The traveling salesman problem (TSP) is a fundamental problem in combinatorial optimization. Several semidefinite programming relaxations have been proposed recently that exploit a variety of mathematical structures including, e.g., algebraic connectivity, permutation matrices, and association schemes. The main results of this paper are twofold. First, de Klerk and Sotirov [9] present an SDP based…
▽ More
The traveling salesman problem (TSP) is a fundamental problem in combinatorial optimization. Several semidefinite programming relaxations have been proposed recently that exploit a variety of mathematical structures including, e.g., algebraic connectivity, permutation matrices, and association schemes. The main results of this paper are twofold. First, de Klerk and Sotirov [9] present an SDP based on permutation matrices and symmetry reduction; they show that it is incomparable to the subtour elimination linear program, but generally dominates it on small instances. We provide a family of \emph{simplicial TSP instances} that shows that the integrality gap of this SDP is unbounded. Second, we show that these simplicial TSP instances imply the unbounded integrality gap of every SDP relaxation of the TSP mentioned in the survey on SDP relaxations of the TSP in Section 2 of Sotirov [24]. In contrast, the subtour LP performs perfectly on simplicial instances. The simplicial instances thus form a natural litmus test for future SDP relaxations of the TSP.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Tight Bounds for Online Weighted Tree Augmentation
Authors:
Joseph,
Naor,
Seeun William Umboh,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
The Weighted Tree Augmentation problem (WTAP) is a fundamental problem in network design. In this paper, we consider this problem in the online setting. We are given an $n$-vertex spanning tree $T$ and an additional set $L$ of edges (called links) with costs. Then, terminal pairs arrive one-by-one and our task is to maintain a low-cost subset of links $F$ such that every terminal pair that has arr…
▽ More
The Weighted Tree Augmentation problem (WTAP) is a fundamental problem in network design. In this paper, we consider this problem in the online setting. We are given an $n$-vertex spanning tree $T$ and an additional set $L$ of edges (called links) with costs. Then, terminal pairs arrive one-by-one and our task is to maintain a low-cost subset of links $F$ such that every terminal pair that has arrived so far is $2$-edge-connected in $T \cup F$. This online problem was first studied by Gupta, Krishnaswamy and Ravi (SICOMP 2012) who used it as a subroutine for the online survivable network design problem. They gave a deterministic $O(\log^2 n)$-competitive algorithm and showed an $Ω(\log n)$ lower bound on the competitive ratio of randomized algorithms. The case when $T$ is a path is also interesting: it is exactly the online interval set cover problem, which also captures as a special case the parking permit problem studied by Meyerson (FOCS 2005). The contribution of this paper is to give tight results for online weighted tree and path augmentation problems. The main result of this work is a deterministic $O(\log n)$-competitive algorithm for online WTAP, which is tight up to constant factors.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Characterizing the Integrality Gap of the Subtour LP for the Circulant Traveling Salesman Problem
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
We consider the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation of the Traveling Salesman Problem restricted to circulant instances. De Klerk and Dobre conjectured that the value of the optimal solution to the subtour LP on these instances is equal to an entirely combinatorial lower bound from Van der Veen, Van Dal, and Sierksma. We prove this conjecture by giving an explicit optimal solution to the…
▽ More
We consider the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation of the Traveling Salesman Problem restricted to circulant instances. De Klerk and Dobre conjectured that the value of the optimal solution to the subtour LP on these instances is equal to an entirely combinatorial lower bound from Van der Veen, Van Dal, and Sierksma. We prove this conjecture by giving an explicit optimal solution to the subtour LP. We then use it to show that the integrality gap of the subtour LP is 2 on circulant instances, making such instances one of the few non-trivial classes of TSP instances for which the integrality gap of the subtour LP is exactly known. We also show that the degree constraints do not strengthen the subtour LP on circulant instances, mimicking the parsimonious property of metric, symmetric TSP instances shown in Goemans and Bertsimas in a distinctly non-metric set of instances.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
The Unbounded Integrality Gap of a Semidefinite Relaxation of the Traveling Salesman Problem
Authors:
Samuel C. Gutekunst,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
We study a semidefinite programming relaxation of the traveling salesman problem introduced by de Klerk, Pasechnik, and Sotirov [8] and show that their relaxation has an unbounded integrality gap. In particular, we give a family of instances such that the gap increases linearly with $n$. To obtain this result, we search for feasible solutions within a highly structured class of matrices; the probl…
▽ More
We study a semidefinite programming relaxation of the traveling salesman problem introduced by de Klerk, Pasechnik, and Sotirov [8] and show that their relaxation has an unbounded integrality gap. In particular, we give a family of instances such that the gap increases linearly with $n$. To obtain this result, we search for feasible solutions within a highly structured class of matrices; the problem of finding such solutions reduces to finding feasible solutions for a related linear program, which we do analytically. The solutions we find imply the unbounded integrality gap. Further, they imply several corollaries that help us better understand the semidefinite program and its relationship to other TSP relaxations. Using the same technique, we show that a more general semidefinite program introduced by de Klerk, de Oliveira Filho, and Pasechnik [7] for the $k$-cycle cover problem also has an unbounded integrality gap.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Online Constrained Forest and Prize-Collecting Network Design
Authors:
Jiawei Qian,
Seeun William Umboh,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
In this paper, we study a very general type of online network design problem, and generalize two different previous algorithms, one for an online network design problem due to Berman and Coulston [4] and one for (offline) general network design problems due to Goemans and Williamson [9]; we give an O(log k)-competitive algorithm, where k is the number of nodes that must be connected. We also consi…
▽ More
In this paper, we study a very general type of online network design problem, and generalize two different previous algorithms, one for an online network design problem due to Berman and Coulston [4] and one for (offline) general network design problems due to Goemans and Williamson [9]; we give an O(log k)-competitive algorithm, where k is the number of nodes that must be connected. We also consider a further generalization of the problem that allows us to pay penalties in exchange for violating connectivity constraints; we give an online O(log k)-competitive algorithm for this case as well.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Maximizing a Submodular Function with Viability Constraints
Authors:
Wolfgang Dvořák,
Monika Henzinger,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
We study the problem of maximizing a monotone submodular function with viability constraints. This problem originates from computational biology, where we are given a phylogenetic tree over a set of species and a directed graph, the so-called food web, encoding viability constraints between these species. These food webs usually have constant {depth}. The goal is to select a subset of $k$ species…
▽ More
We study the problem of maximizing a monotone submodular function with viability constraints. This problem originates from computational biology, where we are given a phylogenetic tree over a set of species and a directed graph, the so-called food web, encoding viability constraints between these species. These food webs usually have constant {depth}. The goal is to select a subset of $k$ species that satisfies the viability constraints and has maximal phylogenetic diversity. As this problem is known to be NP-hard, we investigate approximation algorithms. We present the first constant factor approximation algorithm if the depth is constant. Its approximation ratio is $(1-\frac{1}{\sqrt{e}})$. This algorithm not only applies to phylogenetic trees with viability constraints but for arbitrary monotone submodular set functions with viability constraints. Second, we show that there is no $(1-1/e+ε)$-approximation algorithm for our problem setting (even for additive functions) and that there is no approximation algorithm for a slight extension of this setting.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Rank Aggregation: New Bounds for MCx
Authors:
Daniel Freund,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
The rank aggregation problem has received significant recent attention within the computer science community. Its applications today range far beyond the original aim of building metasearch engines to problems in machine learning, recommendation systems and more. Several algorithms have been proposed for these problems, and in many cases approximation guarantees have been proven for them. However,…
▽ More
The rank aggregation problem has received significant recent attention within the computer science community. Its applications today range far beyond the original aim of building metasearch engines to problems in machine learning, recommendation systems and more. Several algorithms have been proposed for these problems, and in many cases approximation guarantees have been proven for them. However, it is also known that some Markov chain based algorithms (MC1, MC2, MC3, MC4) perform extremely well in practice, yet had no known performance guarantees. We prove supra-constant lower bounds on approximation guarantees for all of them. We also raise the lower bound for sorting by Copeland score from 3/2 to 2 and prove an upper bound of 11, before showing that in particular ways, MC4 can nevertheless be seen as a generalization of Copeland score.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
An Experimental Evaluation of the Best-of-Many Christofides' Algorithm for the Traveling Salesman Problem
Authors:
Kyle Genova,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
Recent papers on approximation algorithms for the traveling salesman problem (TSP) have given a new variant on the well-known Christofides' algorithm for the TSP, called the Best-of-Many Christofides' algorithm. The algorithm involves sampling a spanning tree from the solution the standard LP relaxation of the TSP, subject to the condition that each edge is sampled with probability at most its val…
▽ More
Recent papers on approximation algorithms for the traveling salesman problem (TSP) have given a new variant on the well-known Christofides' algorithm for the TSP, called the Best-of-Many Christofides' algorithm. The algorithm involves sampling a spanning tree from the solution the standard LP relaxation of the TSP, subject to the condition that each edge is sampled with probability at most its value in the LP relaxation. One then runs Christofides' algorithm on the tree by computing a minimum-cost matching on the odd-degree vertices in the tree, and shortcutting the resulting Eulerian graph to a tour. In this paper we perform an experimental evaluation of the Best-of-Many Christofides' algorithm to see if there are empirical reasons to believe its performance is better than that of Christofides' algorithm. Furthermore, several different sampling schemes have been proposed; we implement several different schemes to determine which ones might be the most promising for obtaining improved performance guarantees over that of Christofides' algorithm. In our experiments, all of the implemented methods perform significantly better than the Christofides' algorithm; an algorithm that samples from a maximum entropy distribution over spanning trees seems to be particularly good, though there are others that perform almost as well.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
On Some Recent MAX SAT Approximation Algorithms
Authors:
Matthias Poloczek,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
Recently a number of randomized 3/4-approximation algorithms for MAX SAT have been proposed that all work in the same way: given a fixed ordering of the variables, the algorithm makes a random assignment to each variable in sequence, in which the probability of assigning each variable true or false depends on the current set of satisfied (or unsatisfied) clauses. To our knowledge, the first such a…
▽ More
Recently a number of randomized 3/4-approximation algorithms for MAX SAT have been proposed that all work in the same way: given a fixed ordering of the variables, the algorithm makes a random assignment to each variable in sequence, in which the probability of assigning each variable true or false depends on the current set of satisfied (or unsatisfied) clauses. To our knowledge, the first such algorithm was proposed by Poloczek and Schnitger; Van Zuylen subsequently gave an algorithm that set the probabilities differently and had a simpler analysis. She also set up a framework for deriving such algorithms. Buchbinder, Feldman, Naor, and Schwartz, as a special case of their work on maximizing submodular functions, also give a randomized 3/4-approximation algorithm for MAX SAT with the same structure as these previous algorithms. In this note we give a gloss on the Buchbinder et al. algorithm that makes it even simpler, and show that in fact it is equivalent to the previous algorithm of Van Zuylen. We also show how it extends to a deterministic LP rounding algorithm; such an algorithm was also given by Van Zuylen.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
A note on the generalized min-sum set cover problem
Authors:
Martin Skutella,
David P. Williamson
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider the generalized min-sum set cover problem, introduced by Azar, Gamzu, and Yin. Bansal, Gupta, and Krishnaswamy give a 485-approximation algorithm for the problem. We are able to alter their algorithm and analysis to obtain a 28-approximation algorithm, improving the performance guarantee by an order of magnitude. We use concepts from $α$-point scheduling to obtain our im…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider the generalized min-sum set cover problem, introduced by Azar, Gamzu, and Yin. Bansal, Gupta, and Krishnaswamy give a 485-approximation algorithm for the problem. We are able to alter their algorithm and analysis to obtain a 28-approximation algorithm, improving the performance guarantee by an order of magnitude. We use concepts from $α$-point scheduling to obtain our improvements.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
On the Integrality Gap of the Subtour LP for the 1,2-TSP
Authors:
Jiawei Qian,
Frans Schalekamp,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
In this paper, we study the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation for the traveling salesman problem in the special case when all edge costs are either 1 or 2. For the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality, a famous conjecture is that the integrality gap is 4/3. Little progress towards resolving this conjecture has been made in thirty years. We conjecture that when a…
▽ More
In this paper, we study the integrality gap of the subtour LP relaxation for the traveling salesman problem in the special case when all edge costs are either 1 or 2. For the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality, a famous conjecture is that the integrality gap is 4/3. Little progress towards resolving this conjecture has been made in thirty years. We conjecture that when all edge costs $c_{ij}\in \{1,2\}$, the integrality gap is $10/9$. We show that this conjecture is true when the optimal subtour LP solution has a certain structure. Under a weaker assumption, which is an analog of a recent conjecture by Schalekamp, Williamson and van Zuylen, we show that the integrality gap is at most $7/6$. When we do not make any assumptions on the structure of the optimal subtour LP solution, we can show that integrality gap is at most $5/4$; this is the first bound on the integrality gap of the subtour LP strictly less than $4/3$ known for an interesting special case of the TSP. We show computationally that the integrality gap is at most $10/9$ for all instances with at most 12 cities.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2014; v1 submitted 8 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
A Proof of the Boyd-Carr Conjecture
Authors:
Frans Schalekamp,
David P. Williamson,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
Determining the precise integrality gap for the subtour LP relaxation of the traveling salesman problem is a significant open question, with little progress made in thirty years in the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality. Boyd and Carr [3] observe that we do not even know the worst-case upper bound on the ratio of the optimal 2-matching to the subtour LP; they conjecture…
▽ More
Determining the precise integrality gap for the subtour LP relaxation of the traveling salesman problem is a significant open question, with little progress made in thirty years in the general case of symmetric costs that obey triangle inequality. Boyd and Carr [3] observe that we do not even know the worst-case upper bound on the ratio of the optimal 2-matching to the subtour LP; they conjecture the ratio is at most 10/9. In this paper, we prove the Boyd-Carr conjecture. In the case that a fractional 2-matching has no cut edge, we can further prove that an optimal 2-matching is at most 10/9 times the cost of the fractional 2-matching.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
