-
Dichotomy between Deterministic and Probabilistic Models in Countably Additive Effectus Theory
Authors:
Kenta Cho,
Bas Westerbaan,
John van de Wetering
Abstract:
Effectus theory is a relatively new approach to categorical logic that can be seen as an abstract form of generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs). While the scalars of a GPT are always the real unit interval [0,1], in an effectus they can form any effect monoid. Hence, there are quite exotic effectuses resulting from more pathological effect monoids.
In this paper we introduce sigma-effectus…
▽ More
Effectus theory is a relatively new approach to categorical logic that can be seen as an abstract form of generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs). While the scalars of a GPT are always the real unit interval [0,1], in an effectus they can form any effect monoid. Hence, there are quite exotic effectuses resulting from more pathological effect monoids.
In this paper we introduce sigma-effectuses, where certain countable sums of morphisms are defined. We study in particular sigma-effectuses where unnormalized states can be normalized. We show that a non-trivial sigma-effectus with normalization has as scalars either the two-element effect monoid 0,1 or the real unit interval [0,1]. When states and/or predicates separate the morphisms we find that in the 0,1 case the category must embed into the category of sets and partial functions (and hence the category of Boolean algebras), showing that it implements a deterministic model, while in the [0,1] case we find it embeds into the category of Banach order-unit spaces and of Banach pre-base-norm spaces (satisfying additional properties), recovering the structure present in GPTs.
Hence, from abstract categorical and operational considerations we find a dichotomy between deterministic and convex probabilistic models of physical theories.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2021; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Preservation of Equations by Monoidal Monads
Authors:
Louis Parlant,
Jurriaan Rot,
Alexandra Silva,
Bas Westerbaan
Abstract:
If a monad $T$ is monoidal, then operations on a set $X$ can be lifted canonically to operations on $TX$. In this paper we study structural properties under which $T$ preserves equations between those operations. It has already been shown that any monoidal monad preserves linear equations; affine monads preserve drop equations (where some variable appears only on one side, such as $x\cdot y = y$)…
▽ More
If a monad $T$ is monoidal, then operations on a set $X$ can be lifted canonically to operations on $TX$. In this paper we study structural properties under which $T$ preserves equations between those operations. It has already been shown that any monoidal monad preserves linear equations; affine monads preserve drop equations (where some variable appears only on one side, such as $x\cdot y = y$) and relevant monads preserve dup equations (where some variable is duplicated, such as $x \cdot x = x$). We start the paper by showing a converse: if the monad at hand preserves a drop equation, then it must be affine. From this, we show that the problem whether a given (drop) equation is preserved is undecidable. A converse for relevance turns out to be more subtle: preservation of certain dup equations implies a weaker notion which we call $n$-relevance. Finally, we identify the subclass of equations such that their preservation is equivalent to relevance.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2020; v1 submitted 17 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
A characterisation of ordered abstract probabilities
Authors:
Abraham Westerbaan,
Bas Westerbaan,
John van de Wetering
Abstract:
In computer science, especially when dealing with quantum computing or other non-standard models of computation, basic notions in probability theory like "a predicate" vary wildly. There seems to be one constant: the only useful example of an algebra of probabilities is the real unit interval. In this paper we try to explain this phenomenon. We will show that the structure of the real unit interva…
▽ More
In computer science, especially when dealing with quantum computing or other non-standard models of computation, basic notions in probability theory like "a predicate" vary wildly. There seems to be one constant: the only useful example of an algebra of probabilities is the real unit interval. In this paper we try to explain this phenomenon. We will show that the structure of the real unit interval naturally arises from a few reasonable assumptions. We do this by studying effect monoids, an abstraction of the algebraic structure of the real unit interval: it has an addition $x+y$ which is only defined when $x+y\leq 1$ and an involution $x\mapsto 1-x$ which make it an effect algebra, in combination with an associative (possibly non-commutative) multiplication. Examples include the unit intervals of ordered rings and Boolean algebras.
We present a structure theory for effect monoids that are $ω$-complete, i.e. where every increasing sequence has a supremum. We show that any $ω$-complete effect monoid embeds into the direct sum of a Boolean algebra and the unit interval of a commutative unital C$^*$-algebra. This gives us from first principles a dichotomy between sharp logic, represented by the Boolean algebra part of the effect monoid, and probabilistic logic, represented by the commutative C$^*$-algebra. Some consequences of this characterisation are that the multiplication must always be commutative, and that the unique $ω$-complete effect monoid without zero divisors and more than 2 elements must be the real unit interval. Our results give an algebraic characterisation and motivation for why any physical or logical theory would represent probabilities by real numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2020; v1 submitted 20 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Dagger and Dilation in the Category of Von Neumann algebras
Authors:
Bas Westerbaan
Abstract:
This doctoral thesis is a mathematical study of quantum computing, concentrating on two related, but independent topics. First up are dilations, covered in chapter 2. In chapter 3 "diamond, andthen, dagger" we turn to the second topic: effectus theory. Both chapters, or rather parts, can be read separately and feature a comprehensive introduction of their own.
This doctoral thesis is a mathematical study of quantum computing, concentrating on two related, but independent topics. First up are dilations, covered in chapter 2. In chapter 3 "diamond, andthen, dagger" we turn to the second topic: effectus theory. Both chapters, or rather parts, can be read separately and feature a comprehensive introduction of their own.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2019; v1 submitted 5 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Statman's Hierarchy Theorem
Authors:
Bram Westerbaan,
Bas Westerbaan,
Rutger Kuyper,
Carst Tankink,
Remy Viehoff,
Henk Barendregt
Abstract:
In the Simply Typed $λ$-calculus Statman investigates the reducibility relation $\leq_{βη}$ between types: for $A,B \in \mathbb{T}^0$, types freely generated using $\rightarrow$ and a single ground type $0$, define $A \leq_{βη} B$ if there exists a $λ$-definable injection from the closed terms of type $A$ into those of type $B$. Unexpectedly, the induced partial order is the (linear) well-ordering…
▽ More
In the Simply Typed $λ$-calculus Statman investigates the reducibility relation $\leq_{βη}$ between types: for $A,B \in \mathbb{T}^0$, types freely generated using $\rightarrow$ and a single ground type $0$, define $A \leq_{βη} B$ if there exists a $λ$-definable injection from the closed terms of type $A$ into those of type $B$. Unexpectedly, the induced partial order is the (linear) well-ordering (of order type) $ω+ 4$.
In the proof a finer relation $\leq_{h}$ is used, where the above injection is required to be a Böhm transformation, and an (a posteriori) coarser relation $\leq_{h^+}$, requiring a finite family of Böhm transformations that is jointly injective.
We present this result in a self-contained, syntactic, constructive and simplified manner. En route similar results for $\leq_h$ (order type $ω+ 5$) and $\leq_{h^+}$ (order type $8$) are obtained. Five of the equivalence classes of $\leq_{h^+}$ correspond to canonical term models of Statman, one to the trivial term model collapsing all elements of the same type, and one does not even form a model by the lack of closed terms of many types.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017; v1 submitted 15 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
An Introduction to Effectus Theory
Authors:
Kenta Cho,
Bart Jacobs,
Bas Westerbaan,
Abraham Westerbaan
Abstract:
Effectus theory is a new branch of categorical logic that aims to capture the essentials of quantum logic, with probabilistic and Boolean logic as special cases. Predicates in effectus theory are not subobjects having a Heyting algebra structure, like in topos theory, but `characteristic' functions, forming effect algebras. Such effect algebras are algebraic models of quantitative logic, in which…
▽ More
Effectus theory is a new branch of categorical logic that aims to capture the essentials of quantum logic, with probabilistic and Boolean logic as special cases. Predicates in effectus theory are not subobjects having a Heyting algebra structure, like in topos theory, but `characteristic' functions, forming effect algebras. Such effect algebras are algebraic models of quantitative logic, in which double negation holds. Effects in quantum theory and fuzzy predicates in probability theory form examples of effect algebras.
This text is an account of the basics of effectus theory. It includes the fundamental duality between states and effects, with the associated Born rule for validity of an effect (predicate) in a particular state. A basic result says that effectuses can be described equivalently in both `total' and `partial' form. So-called `commutative' and `Boolean' effectuses are distinguished, for probabilistic and classical models. It is shown how these Boolean effectuses are essentially extensive categories. A large part of the theory is devoted to the logical notions of comprehension and quotient, which are described abstractly as right adjoint to truth, and as left adjoint to falisity, respectively. It is illustrated how comprehension and quotients are closely related to measurement. The paper closes with a section on `non-commutative' effectus theory, where the appropriate formalisation is not entirely clear yet.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Quotient-Comprehension Chains
Authors:
Kenta Cho,
Bart Jacobs,
Bas Westerbaan,
Bram Westerbaan
Abstract:
Quotients and comprehension are fundamental mathematical constructions that can be described via adjunctions in categorical logic. This paper reveals that quotients and comprehension are related to measurement, not only in quantum logic, but also in probabilistic and classical logic. This relation is presented by a long series of examples, some of them easy, and some also highly non-trivial (esp.…
▽ More
Quotients and comprehension are fundamental mathematical constructions that can be described via adjunctions in categorical logic. This paper reveals that quotients and comprehension are related to measurement, not only in quantum logic, but also in probabilistic and classical logic. This relation is presented by a long series of examples, some of them easy, and some also highly non-trivial (esp. for von Neumann algebras). We have not yet identified a unifying theory. Nevertheless, the paper contributes towards such a theory by introducing the new quotient-and-comprehension perspective on measurement instruments, and by describing the examples on which such a theory should be built.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
A Kochen-Specker system has at least 22 vectors (extended abstract)
Authors:
Sander Uijlen,
Bas Westerbaan
Abstract:
At the heart of the Conway-Kochen Free Will theorem and Kochen and Specker's argument against non-contextual hidden variable theories is the existence of a Kochen-Specker (KS) system: a set of points on the sphere that has no 0,1-coloring such that at most one of two orthogonal points are colored 1 and of three pairwise orthogonal points exactly one is colored 1. In public lectures, Conway encoura…
▽ More
At the heart of the Conway-Kochen Free Will theorem and Kochen and Specker's argument against non-contextual hidden variable theories is the existence of a Kochen-Specker (KS) system: a set of points on the sphere that has no 0,1-coloring such that at most one of two orthogonal points are colored 1 and of three pairwise orthogonal points exactly one is colored 1. In public lectures, Conway encouraged the search for small KS systems. At the time of writing, the smallest known KS system has 31 vectors. Arends, Ouaknine and Wampler have shown that a KS system has at least 18 vectors, by reducing the problem to the existence of graphs with a topological embeddability and non-colorability property. The bottleneck in their search proved to be the sheer number of graphs on more than 17 vertices and deciding embeddability.
Continuing their effort, we prove a restriction on the class of graphs we need to consider and develop a more practical decision procedure for embeddability to improve the lower bound to 22.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
