-
Muchisim: A Simulation Framework for Design Exploration of Multi-Chip Manycore Systems
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Esin Tureci,
Margaret Martonosi,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
The design space exploration of scaled-out manycores for communication-intensive applications (e.g., graph analytics and sparse linear algebra) is hampered due to either lack of scalability or accuracy of existing frameworks at simulating data-dependent execution patterns. This paper presents MuchiSim, a novel parallel simulator designed to address these challenges when exploring the design space…
▽ More
The design space exploration of scaled-out manycores for communication-intensive applications (e.g., graph analytics and sparse linear algebra) is hampered due to either lack of scalability or accuracy of existing frameworks at simulating data-dependent execution patterns. This paper presents MuchiSim, a novel parallel simulator designed to address these challenges when exploring the design space of distributed multi-chiplet manycore architectures. We evaluate MuchiSim at simulating systems with up to a million interconnected processing units (PUs) while modeling data movement and communication cycle by cycle. In addition to performance, MuchiSim reports the energy, area, and cost of the simulated system. It also comes with a benchmark application suite and two data visualization tools. MuchiSim supports various parallelization strategies and communication primitives such as task-based parallelization and message passing, making it highly relevant for architectures with software-managed coherence and distributed memory. Via a case study, we show that MuchiSim helps users explore the balance between memory and computation units and the constraints related to chiplet integration and inter-chip communication. MuchiSim enables evaluating new techniques or design parameters for systems at scales that are more realistic for modern parallel systems, opening the gate for further research in this area.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
A Hardware Evaluation Framework for Large Language Model Inference
Authors:
Hengrui Zhang,
August Ning,
Rohan Prabhakar,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
The past year has witnessed the increasing popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs). Their unprecedented scale and associated high hardware cost have impeded their broader adoption, calling for efficient hardware designs. With the large hardware needed to simply run LLM inference, evaluating different hardware designs becomes a new bottleneck.
This work introduces LLMCompass, a hardware evalua…
▽ More
The past year has witnessed the increasing popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs). Their unprecedented scale and associated high hardware cost have impeded their broader adoption, calling for efficient hardware designs. With the large hardware needed to simply run LLM inference, evaluating different hardware designs becomes a new bottleneck.
This work introduces LLMCompass, a hardware evaluation framework for LLM inference workloads. LLMCompass is fast, accurate, versatile, and able to describe and evaluate different hardware designs. LLMCompass includes a mapper to automatically find performance-optimal map** and scheduling. It also incorporates an area-based cost model to help architects reason about their design choices. Compared to real-world hardware, LLMCompass' estimated latency achieves an average 10.4% error rate across various operators with various input sizes and an average 4.1% error rate for LLM inference. With LLMCompass, simulating a 4-NVIDIA A100 GPU node running GPT-3 175B inference can be done within 16 minutes on commodity hardware, including 26,400 rounds of the mapper's parameter search.
With the aid of LLMCompass, this work draws architectural implications and explores new cost-effective hardware designs. By reducing the compute capability or replacing High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) with traditional DRAM, these new designs can achieve as much as 3.41x improvement in performance/cost compared to an NVIDIA A100, making them promising choices for democratizing LLMs.
LLMCompass is planned to be fully open-source.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Tascade: Hardware Support for Atomic-free, Asynchronous and Efficient Reduction Trees
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Esin Tureci,
David Wentzlaff,
Margaret Martonosi
Abstract:
Graph search and sparse data-structure traversal workloads contain challenging irregular memory patterns on global data structures that need to be modified atomically. Distributed processing of these workloads has relied on server threads operating on their own data copies that are merged upon global synchronization. As parallelism increases within each server, the communication challenges that ar…
▽ More
Graph search and sparse data-structure traversal workloads contain challenging irregular memory patterns on global data structures that need to be modified atomically. Distributed processing of these workloads has relied on server threads operating on their own data copies that are merged upon global synchronization. As parallelism increases within each server, the communication challenges that arose in distributed systems a decade ago are now being encountered within large manycore servers. Prior work has achieved scalability for sparse applications up to thousands of PUs on-chip, but does not scale further due to increasing communication distances and load-imbalance across PUs. To address these challenges we propose Tascade, a hardware-software co-design that offers support for storage-efficient data-private reductions as well as asynchronous and opportunistic reduction trees. Tascade introduces an execution model along with supporting hardware design that allows coalescing of data updates regionally and merges the data from these regions through cascaded updates. Together, Tascade innovations minimize communication and increase work balance in task-based parallelization schemes and scales up to a million PUs. We evaluate six applications and four datasets to provide a detailed analysis of Tascade's performance, power, and traffic-reduction gains over prior work. Our parallelization of Breadth-First-Search with RMAT-26 across a million PUs -- the largest of the literature -- reaches over 7600 GTEPS.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
DCRA: A Distributed Chiplet-based Reconfigurable Architecture for Irregular Applications
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Esin Tureci,
Margaret Martonosi,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
In recent years, the growing demand to process large graphs and sparse datasets has led to increased research efforts to develop hardware- and software-based architectural solutions to accelerate them. While some of these approaches achieve scalable parallelization with up to thousands of cores, adaptation of these proposals by the industry remained slow. To help solve this dissonance, we identifi…
▽ More
In recent years, the growing demand to process large graphs and sparse datasets has led to increased research efforts to develop hardware- and software-based architectural solutions to accelerate them. While some of these approaches achieve scalable parallelization with up to thousands of cores, adaptation of these proposals by the industry remained slow. To help solve this dissonance, we identified a set of questions and considerations that current research has not considered deeply.
Starting from a tile-based architecture, we put forward a Distributed Chiplet-based Reconfigurable Architecture (DCRA) for irregular applications that carefully consider fabrication constraints that made prior work either hard or costly to implement or too rigid to be applied. We identify and study pre-silicon, package-time and compile-time configurations that help optimize DCRA for different deployments and target metrics. To enable that, we propose a practical path for manufacturing chip packages by composing variable numbers of DCRA and memory dies, with a software-configurable Torus network to connect them. We evaluate six applications and four datasets, with several configurations and memory technologies, to provide a detailed analysis of the performance, power, and cost of DCRA as a compute node for scale-out sparse data processing. Finally, we present our findings and discuss how DCRA's framework for design exploration can help guide architects to build scalable and cost-efficient systems for irregular applications.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2024; v1 submitted 26 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Using LLMs to Facilitate Formal Verification of RTL
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Margaret Martonosi,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
Formal property verification (FPV) has existed for decades and has been shown to be effective at finding intricate RTL bugs. However, formal properties, such as those written as SystemVerilog Assertions (SVA), are time-consuming and error-prone to write, even for experienced users. Prior work has attempted to lighten this burden by raising the abstraction level so that SVA is generated from high-l…
▽ More
Formal property verification (FPV) has existed for decades and has been shown to be effective at finding intricate RTL bugs. However, formal properties, such as those written as SystemVerilog Assertions (SVA), are time-consuming and error-prone to write, even for experienced users. Prior work has attempted to lighten this burden by raising the abstraction level so that SVA is generated from high-level specifications. However, this does not eliminate the manual effort of reasoning and writing about the detailed hardware behavior. Motivated by the increased need for FPV in the era of heterogeneous hardware and the advances in large language models (LLMs), we set out to explore whether LLMs can capture RTL behavior and generate correct SVA properties.
First, we design an FPV-based evaluation framework that measures the correctness and completeness of SVA. Then, we evaluate GPT4 iteratively to craft the set of syntax and semantic rules needed to prompt it toward creating better SVA. We extend the open-source AutoSVA framework by integrating our improved GPT4-based flow to generate safety properties, in addition to facilitating their existing flow for liveness properties. Lastly, our use cases evaluate (1) the FPV coverage of GPT4-generated SVA on complex open-source RTL and (2) using generated SVA to prompt GPT4 to create RTL from scratch.
Through these experiments, we find that GPT4 can generate correct SVA even for flawed RTL, without mirroring design errors. Particularly, it generated SVA that exposed a bug in the RISC-V CVA6 core that eluded the prior work's evaluation.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023; v1 submitted 17 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Massive Data-Centric Parallelism in the Chiplet Era
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Esin Tureci,
David Wentzlaff,
Margaret Martonosi
Abstract:
Recent works have introduced task-based parallelization schemes to accelerate graph search and sparse data-structure traversal, where some solutions scale up to thousands of processing units (PUs) on a single chip. However parallelizing these memory-intensive workloads across millions of cores requires a scalable communication scheme as well as designing a cost-efficient computing node that makes…
▽ More
Recent works have introduced task-based parallelization schemes to accelerate graph search and sparse data-structure traversal, where some solutions scale up to thousands of processing units (PUs) on a single chip. However parallelizing these memory-intensive workloads across millions of cores requires a scalable communication scheme as well as designing a cost-efficient computing node that makes multi-node systems practical, which have not been addressed in previous research. To address these challenges, we propose a task-oriented scalable chiplet architecture for distributed execution (Tascade), a multi-node system design that we evaluate with up to 256 distributed chips -- over a million PUs. We introduce an execution model that scales to this level via proxy regions and selective cascading, which reduce overall communication and improve load balancing. In addition, package-time reconfiguration of our chiplet-based design enables creating chip products that optimized post-silicon for different target metrics, such as time-to-solution, energy, or cost. We evaluate six applications and four datasets, with several configurations and memory technologies to provide a detailed analysis of the performance, power, and cost of data-centric execution at a massive scale. Our parallelization of Breadth-First-Search with RMAT-26 across a million PUs -- the largest of the literature -- reaches 3021 GTEPS.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2023; v1 submitted 18 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Duet: Creating Harmony between Processors and Embedded FPGAs
Authors:
Ang Li,
August Ning,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
The demise of Moore's Law has led to the rise of hardware acceleration. However, the focus on accelerating stable algorithms in their entirety neglects the abundant fine-grained acceleration opportunities available in broader domains and squanders host processors' compute power. This paper presents Duet, a scalable, manycore-FPGA architecture that promotes embedded FPGAs (eFPGA) to be equal peers…
▽ More
The demise of Moore's Law has led to the rise of hardware acceleration. However, the focus on accelerating stable algorithms in their entirety neglects the abundant fine-grained acceleration opportunities available in broader domains and squanders host processors' compute power. This paper presents Duet, a scalable, manycore-FPGA architecture that promotes embedded FPGAs (eFPGA) to be equal peers with processors through non-intrusive, bi-directionally cache-coherent integration. In contrast to existing CPU-FPGA hybrid systems in which the processors play a supportive role, Duet unleashes the full potential of both the processors and the eFPGAs with two classes of post-fabrication enhancements: fine-grained acceleration, which partitions an application into small tasks and offloads the frequently-invoked, compute-intensive ones onto various small accelerators, leveraging the processors to handle dynamic control flow and less accelerable tasks; hardware augmentation, which employs eFPGA-emulated hardware widgets to improve processor efficiency or mitigate software overheads in certain execution models. An RTL-level implementation of Duet is developed to evaluate the architecture with high fidelity. Experiments using synthetic benchmarks show that Duet can reduce the processor-accelerator communication latency by up to 82% and increase the bandwidth by up to 9.5x. The RTL implementation is further evaluated with seven application benchmarks, achieving 1.5-24.9x speedup.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Dalorex: A Data-Local Program Execution and Architecture for Memory-bound Applications
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Esin Tureci,
David Wentzlaff,
Margaret Martonosi
Abstract:
Applications with low data reuse and frequent irregular memory accesses, such as graph or sparse linear algebra workloads, fail to scale well due to memory bottlenecks and poor core utilization. While prior work with prefetching, decoupling, or pipelining can mitigate memory latency and improve core utilization, memory bottlenecks persist due to limited off-chip bandwidth. Approaches doing process…
▽ More
Applications with low data reuse and frequent irregular memory accesses, such as graph or sparse linear algebra workloads, fail to scale well due to memory bottlenecks and poor core utilization. While prior work with prefetching, decoupling, or pipelining can mitigate memory latency and improve core utilization, memory bottlenecks persist due to limited off-chip bandwidth. Approaches doing processing in-memory (PIM) with Hybrid Memory Cube (HMC) overcome bandwidth limitations but fail to achieve high core utilization due to poor task scheduling and synchronization overheads. Moreover, the high memory-per-core ratio available with HMC limits strong scaling.
We introduce Dalorex, a hardware-software co-design that achieves high parallelism and energy efficiency, demonstrating strong scaling with >16,000 cores when processing graph and sparse linear algebra workloads. Over the prior work in PIM, both using 256 cores, Dalorex improves performance and energy consumption by two orders of magnitude through (1) a tile-based distributed-memory architecture where each processing tile holds an equal amount of data, and all memory operations are local; (2) a task-based parallel programming model where tasks are executed by the processing unit that is co-located with the target data; (3) a network design optimized for irregular traffic, where all communication is one-way, and messages do not contain routing metadata; (4) novel traffic-aware task scheduling hardware that maintains high core utilization; and (5) a data placement strategy that improves work balance.
This work proposes architectural and software innovations to provide the greatest scalability to date for running graph algorithms while still being programmable for other domains.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023; v1 submitted 26 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Evolving Transferable Neural Pruning Functions
Authors:
Yuchen Liu,
S. Y. Kung,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
Structural design of neural networks is crucial for the success of deep learning. While most prior works in evolutionary learning aim at directly searching the structure of a network, few attempts have been made on another promising track, channel pruning, which recently has made major headway in designing efficient deep learning models. In fact, prior pruning methods adopt human-made pruning func…
▽ More
Structural design of neural networks is crucial for the success of deep learning. While most prior works in evolutionary learning aim at directly searching the structure of a network, few attempts have been made on another promising track, channel pruning, which recently has made major headway in designing efficient deep learning models. In fact, prior pruning methods adopt human-made pruning functions to score a channel's importance for channel pruning, which requires domain knowledge and could be sub-optimal. To this end, we pioneer the use of genetic programming (GP) to discover strong pruning metrics automatically. Specifically, we craft a novel design space to express high-quality and transferable pruning functions, which ensures an end-to-end evolution process where no manual modification is needed on the evolved functions for their transferability after evolution. Unlike prior methods, our approach can provide both compact pruned networks for efficient inference and novel closed-form pruning metrics which are mathematically explainable and thus generalizable to different pruning tasks. While the evolution is conducted on small datasets, our functions shows promising results when applied to more challenging datasets, different from those used in the evolution process. For example, on ILSVRC-2012, an evolved function achieves state-of-the-art pruning results.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2022; v1 submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Class-Discriminative CNN Compression
Authors:
Yuchen Liu,
David Wentzlaff,
S. Y. Kung
Abstract:
Compressing convolutional neural networks (CNNs) by pruning and distillation has received ever-increasing focus in the community. In particular, designing a class-discrimination based approach would be desired as it fits seamlessly with the CNNs training objective. In this paper, we propose class-discriminative compression (CDC), which injects class discrimination in both pruning and distillation…
▽ More
Compressing convolutional neural networks (CNNs) by pruning and distillation has received ever-increasing focus in the community. In particular, designing a class-discrimination based approach would be desired as it fits seamlessly with the CNNs training objective. In this paper, we propose class-discriminative compression (CDC), which injects class discrimination in both pruning and distillation to facilitate the CNNs training goal. We first study the effectiveness of a group of discriminant functions for channel pruning, where we include well-known single-variate binary-class statistics like Student's T-Test in our study via an intuitive generalization. We then propose a novel layer-adaptive hierarchical pruning approach, where we use a coarse class discrimination scheme for early layers and a fine one for later layers. This method naturally accords with the fact that CNNs process coarse semantics in the early layers and extract fine concepts at the later. Moreover, we leverage discriminant component analysis (DCA) to distill knowledge of intermediate representations in a subspace with rich discriminative information, which enhances hidden layers' linear separability and classification accuracy of the student. Combining pruning and distillation, CDC is evaluated on CIFAR and ILSVRC 2012, where we consistently outperform the state-of-the-art results.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
AutoSVA: Democratizing Formal Verification of RTL Module Interactions
Authors:
Marcelo Orenes-Vera,
Aninda Manocha,
David Wentzlaff,
Margaret Martonosi
Abstract:
Modern SoC design relies on the ability to separately verify IP blocks relative to their own specifications. Formal verification (FV) using SystemVerilog Assertions (SVA) is an effective method to exhaustively verify blocks at unit-level. Unfortunately, FV has a steep learning curve and requires engineering effort that discourages hardware designers from using it during RTL module development. We…
▽ More
Modern SoC design relies on the ability to separately verify IP blocks relative to their own specifications. Formal verification (FV) using SystemVerilog Assertions (SVA) is an effective method to exhaustively verify blocks at unit-level. Unfortunately, FV has a steep learning curve and requires engineering effort that discourages hardware designers from using it during RTL module development. We propose AutoSVA, a framework to automatically generate FV testbenches that verify liveness and safety of control logic involved in module interactions. We demonstrate AutoSVA's effectiveness and efficiency on deadlock-critical modules of widely-used open-source hardware projects.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Rethinking Class-Discrimination Based CNN Channel Pruning
Authors:
Yuchen Liu,
David Wentzlaff,
S. Y. Kung
Abstract:
Channel pruning has received ever-increasing focus on network compression. In particular, class-discrimination based channel pruning has made major headway, as it fits seamlessly with the classification objective of CNNs and provides good explainability. Prior works singly propose and evaluate their discriminant functions, while further study on the effectiveness of the adopted metrics is absent.…
▽ More
Channel pruning has received ever-increasing focus on network compression. In particular, class-discrimination based channel pruning has made major headway, as it fits seamlessly with the classification objective of CNNs and provides good explainability. Prior works singly propose and evaluate their discriminant functions, while further study on the effectiveness of the adopted metrics is absent. To this end, we initiate the first study on the effectiveness of a broad range of discriminant functions on channel pruning. Conventional single-variate binary-class statistics like Student's T-Test are also included in our study via an intuitive generalization. The winning metric of our study has a greater ability to select informative channels over other state-of-the-art methods, which is substantiated by our qualitative and quantitative analysis. Moreover, we develop a FLOP-normalized sensitivity analysis scheme to automate the structural pruning procedure. On CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and ILSVRC-2012 datasets, our pruned models achieve higher accuracy with less inference cost compared to state-of-the-art results. For example, on ILSVRC-2012, our 44.3% FLOPs-pruned ResNet-50 has only a 0.3% top-1 accuracy drop, which significantly outperforms the state of the art.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
JuxtaPiton: Enabling Heterogeneous-ISA Research with RISC-V and SPARC FPGA Soft-cores
Authors:
Katie Lim,
Jonathan Balkind,
David Wentzlaff
Abstract:
Energy efficiency has become an increasingly important concern in computer architecture due to the end of Dennard scaling. Heterogeneity has been explored as a way to achieve better energy efficiency and heterogeneous microarchitecture chips have become common in the mobile setting.
Recent research has explored using heterogeneous-ISA, heterogeneous microarchitecture, general-purpose cores to ac…
▽ More
Energy efficiency has become an increasingly important concern in computer architecture due to the end of Dennard scaling. Heterogeneity has been explored as a way to achieve better energy efficiency and heterogeneous microarchitecture chips have become common in the mobile setting.
Recent research has explored using heterogeneous-ISA, heterogeneous microarchitecture, general-purpose cores to achieve further energy efficiency gains. However, there is no open-source hardware implementation of a heterogeneous-ISA processor available for research, and effective research on heterogeneous-ISA processors necessitates the emulation speed provided by FPGA prototy**. This work describes our experiences creating JuxtaPiton by integrating a small RISC-V core into the OpenPiton framework, which uses a modified OpenSPARC T1 core. This is the first time a new core has been integrated with the OpenPiton framework, and JuxtaPiton is the first open-source, general-purpose, heterogeneous-ISA processor. JuxtaPiton inherits all the capabilities of OpenPiton, including vital FPGA emulation infrastructure which can boot full-stack Debian Linux. Using this infrastructure, we investigate area and timing effects of using the new RISC-V core on FPGA and the performance of the new core running microbenchmarks.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Acoustic Denial of Service Attacks on HDDs
Authors:
Mohammad Shahrad,
Arsalan Mosenia,
Liwei Song,
Mung Chiang,
David Wentzlaff,
Prateek Mittal
Abstract:
Among storage components, hard disk drives (HDDs) have become the most commonly-used type of non-volatile storage due to their recent technological advances, including, enhanced energy efficacy and significantly-improved areal density. Such advances in HDDs have made them an inevitable part of numerous computing systems, including, personal computers, closed-circuit television (CCTV) systems, medi…
▽ More
Among storage components, hard disk drives (HDDs) have become the most commonly-used type of non-volatile storage due to their recent technological advances, including, enhanced energy efficacy and significantly-improved areal density. Such advances in HDDs have made them an inevitable part of numerous computing systems, including, personal computers, closed-circuit television (CCTV) systems, medical bedside monitors, and automated teller machines (ATMs). Despite the widespread use of HDDs and their critical role in real-world systems, there exist only a few research studies on the security of HDDs. In particular, prior research studies have discussed how HDDs can potentially leak critical private information through acoustic or electromagnetic emanations. Borrowing theoretical principles from acoustics and mechanics, we propose a novel denial-of-service (DoS) attack against HDDs that exploits a physical phenomenon, known as acoustic resonance. We perform a comprehensive examination of physical characteristics of several HDDs and create acoustic signals that cause significant vibrations in HDD's internal components. We demonstrate that such vibrations can negatively influence the performance of HDDs embedded in real-world systems. We show the feasibility of the proposed attack in two real-world case studies, namely, personal computers and CCTVs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
