Showing 1–18 of 18 results for author: Traub, V

Cost Allocation for Set Covering: the Happy Nucleolus

Authors: Jannis Blauth, Antonia Ellerbrock, Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We consider cost allocation for set covering problems. We allocate as much cost to the elements (players) as possible without violating the group rationality condition (no subset of players pays more than covering this subset would cost), and so that the excess vector is lexicographically maximized. This is identical to the well-known nucleolus if the core of the corresponding cooperative game is… ▽ More We consider cost allocation for set covering problems. We allocate as much cost to the elements (players) as possible without violating the group rationality condition (no subset of players pays more than covering this subset would cost), and so that the excess vector is lexicographically maximized. This is identical to the well-known nucleolus if the core of the corresponding cooperative game is nonempty, i.e., if some optimum fractional cover is integral. In general, we call this the 'happy nucleolus'. Like for the nucleolus, the excess vector contains an entry for every subset of players, not only for the sets in the given set covering instance. Moreover, it is NP-hard to compute a single entry because this requires solving a set covering problem. Nevertheless, we give an explicit family of at most $mn$ subsets, each with a trivial cover (by a single set), such that the happy nucleolus is always completely determined by this proxy excess vector; here $m$ and $n$ denote the number of sets and the number of players in our set covering instance. We show that this is the unique minimal such family in a natural sense. While computing the nucleolus for set covering is NP-hard, our results imply that the happy nucleolus can be computed in polynomial time. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 7 figures

Single-Source Unsplittable Flows in Planar Graphs

Authors: Vera Traub, Laura Vargas Koch, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: The single-source unsplittable flow (SSUF) problem asks to send flow from a common source to different terminals with unrelated demands, each terminal being served through a single path. One of the most heavily studied SSUF objectives is to minimize the violation of some given arc capacities. A seminal result of Dinitz, Garg, and Goemans showed that, whenever a fractional flow exists respecting th… ▽ More The single-source unsplittable flow (SSUF) problem asks to send flow from a common source to different terminals with unrelated demands, each terminal being served through a single path. One of the most heavily studied SSUF objectives is to minimize the violation of some given arc capacities. A seminal result of Dinitz, Garg, and Goemans showed that, whenever a fractional flow exists respecting the capacities, then there is an unsplittable one violating the capacities by at most the maximum demand. Goemans conjectured a very natural cost version of the same result, where the unsplittable flow is required to be no more expensive than the fractional one. This intriguing conjecture remains open. More so, there are arguably no non-trivial graph classes for which it is known to hold. We show that a slight weakening of it (with at most twice as large violations) holds for planar graphs. Our result is based on a connection to a highly structured discrepancy problem, whose repeated resolution allows us to successively reduce the number of paths used for each terminal, until we obtain an unsplittable flow. Moreover, our techniques also extend to simultaneous upper and lower bounds on the flow values. This also affirmatively answers a conjecture of Morell and Skutella for planar SSUF. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

A $(1.5+ε)$-Approximation Algorithm for Weighted Connectivity Augmentation

Authors: Vera Traub, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: Connectivity augmentation problems are among the most elementary questions in Network Design. Many of these problems admit natural $2$-approximation algorithms, often through various classic techniques, whereas it remains open whether approximation factors below $2$ can be achieved. One of the most basic examples thereof is the Weighted Connectivity Augmentation Problem (WCAP). In WCAP, one is giv… ▽ More Connectivity augmentation problems are among the most elementary questions in Network Design. Many of these problems admit natural $2$-approximation algorithms, often through various classic techniques, whereas it remains open whether approximation factors below $2$ can be achieved. One of the most basic examples thereof is the Weighted Connectivity Augmentation Problem (WCAP). In WCAP, one is given an undirected graph together with a set of additional weighted candidate edges, and the task is to find a cheapest set of candidate edges whose addition to the graph increases its edge-connectivity. We present a $(1.5+\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for WCAP, showing for the first time that factors below $2$ are achievable. On a high level, we design a well-chosen local search algorithm, inspired by recent advances for Weighted Tree Augmentation. To measure progress, we consider a directed weakening of WCAP and show that it has highly structured planar solutions. Interpreting a solution of the original problem as one of this directed weakening allows us to describe local exchange steps in a clean and algorithmically amenable way. Leveraging these insights, we show that we can efficiently search for good exchange steps within a component class for link sets that is closely related to bounded treewidth subgraphs of circle graphs. Moreover, we prove that an optimum solution can be decomposed into smaller components, at least one of which leads to a good local search step as long as we did not yet achieve the claimed approximation guarantee. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Vehicle Routing with Time-Dependent Travel Times: Theory, Practice, and Benchmarks

Authors: Jannis Blauth, Stephan Held, Dirk Müller, Niklas Schlomberg, Vera Traub, Thorben Tröbst, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We develop theoretical foundations and practical algorithms for vehicle routing with time-dependent travel times. We also provide new benchmark instances and experimental results. First, we study basic operations on piecewise linear arrival time functions. In particular, we devise a faster algorithm to compute the pointwise minimum of a set of piecewise linear functions and a monotonicity-preservi… ▽ More We develop theoretical foundations and practical algorithms for vehicle routing with time-dependent travel times. We also provide new benchmark instances and experimental results. First, we study basic operations on piecewise linear arrival time functions. In particular, we devise a faster algorithm to compute the pointwise minimum of a set of piecewise linear functions and a monotonicity-preserving variant of the Imai-Iri algorithm to approximate an arrival time function with fewer breakpoints. Next, we show how to evaluate insertion and deletion operations in tours efficiently and update the underlying data structure faster than previously known when a tour changes. Evaluating a tour also requires a scheduling step which is non-trivial in the presence of time windows and time-dependent travel times. We show how to perform this in linear time. Based on these results, we develop a local search heuristic to solve real-world vehicle routing problems with various constraints efficiently and report experimental results on classical benchmarks. Since most of these do not have time-dependent travel times, we generate and publish new benchmark instances that are based on real-world data. This data also demonstrates the importance of considering time-dependent travel times in instances with tight time windows. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2024; v1 submitted 2 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Better-Than-$\frac{4}{3}$-Approximations for Leaf-to-Leaf Tree and Connectivity Augmentation

Authors: Federica Cecchetto, Vera Traub, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: The Connectivity Augmentation Problem (CAP) together with a well-known special case thereof known as the Tree Augmentation Problem (TAP) are among the most basic Network Design problems. There has been a surge of interest recently to find approximation algorithms with guarantees below $2$ for both TAP and CAP, culminating in the currently best approximation factor for both problems of $1.393$ thro… ▽ More The Connectivity Augmentation Problem (CAP) together with a well-known special case thereof known as the Tree Augmentation Problem (TAP) are among the most basic Network Design problems. There has been a surge of interest recently to find approximation algorithms with guarantees below $2$ for both TAP and CAP, culminating in the currently best approximation factor for both problems of $1.393$ through quite sophisticated techniques. We present a new and arguably simple matching-based method for the well-known special case of leaf-to-leaf instances. Combining our work with prior techniques, we readily obtain a $(\frac{4}{3}+ε)$-approximation for Leaf-to-Leaf CAP by returning the better of our solution and one of an existing method. Prior to our work, a $\frac{4}{3}$-guarantee was only known for Leaf-to-Leaf TAP instances on trees of height $2$. Moreover, when combining our technique with a recently introduced stack analysis approach, which is part of the above-mentioned $1.393$-approximation, we can further improve the approximation factor to $1.29$, obtaining for the first time a factor below $\frac{4}{3}$ for a nontrivial class of TAP/CAP instances. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Breaching the 2-Approximation Barrier for the Forest Augmentation Problem

Authors: Fabrizio Grandoni, Afrouz Jabal Ameli, Vera Traub

Abstract: The basic goal of survivable network design is to build cheap networks that guarantee the connectivity of certain pairs of nodes despite the failure of a few edges or nodes. A celebrated result by Jain [Combinatorica'01] provides a 2-approximation for a wide class of these problems. However nothing better is known even for very basic special cases, raising the natural question whether any improved… ▽ More The basic goal of survivable network design is to build cheap networks that guarantee the connectivity of certain pairs of nodes despite the failure of a few edges or nodes. A celebrated result by Jain [Combinatorica'01] provides a 2-approximation for a wide class of these problems. However nothing better is known even for very basic special cases, raising the natural question whether any improved approximation factor is possible at all. In this paper we address one of the most basic problems in this family for which 2 is still the best-known approximation factor, the Forest Augmentation Problem (FAP): given an undirected unweighted graph (that w.l.o.g. is a forest) and a collection of extra edges (links), compute a minimum cardinality subset of links whose addition to the graph makes it 2-edge-connected. Several better-than-2 approximation algorithms are known for the special case where the input graph is a tree, a.k.a. the Tree Augmentation Problem (TAP). Recently this was achieved also for the weighted version of TAP, and for the k-edge-connectivity generalization of TAP. These results heavily exploit the fact that the input graph is connected, a condition that does not hold in FAP. In this paper we breach the 2-approximation barrier for FAP. Our result is based on two main ingredients. First, we describe a reduction to the Path Augmentation Problem (PAP), the special case of FAP where the input graph is a collection of disjoint paths. Our reduction is not approximation preserving, however it is sufficiently accurate to improve on a factor 2 approximation. Second, we present a better-than-2 approximation algorithm for PAP, an open problem on its own. Here we exploit a novel notion of implicit credits which might turn out to be helpful in future related work. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2022; v1 submitted 22 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Local Search for Weighted Tree Augmentation and Steiner Tree

Authors: Vera Traub, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: We present a technique that allows for improving on some relative greedy procedures by well-chosen (non-oblivious) local search algorithms. Relative greedy procedures are a particular type of greedy algorithm that start with a simple, though weak, solution, and iteratively replace parts of this starting solution by stronger components. Some well-known applications of relative greedy algorithms inc… ▽ More We present a technique that allows for improving on some relative greedy procedures by well-chosen (non-oblivious) local search algorithms. Relative greedy procedures are a particular type of greedy algorithm that start with a simple, though weak, solution, and iteratively replace parts of this starting solution by stronger components. Some well-known applications of relative greedy algorithms include approximation algorithms for Steiner Tree and, more recently, for connectivity augmentation problems. The main application of our technique leads to a $(1.5+ε)$-approximation for Weighted Tree Augmentation, improving on a recent relative greedy based method with approximation factor $1+\ln 2 + ε\approx 1.69$. Furthermore, we show how our local search technique can be applied to Steiner Tree, leading to an alternative way to obtain the currently best known approximation factor of $\ln 4 + ε$. Contrary to prior methods, our approach is purely combinatorial without the need to solve an LP. Nevertheless, the solution value can still be bounded in terms of the well-known hypergraphic LP, leading to an alternative, and arguably simpler, technique to bound its integrality gap by $\ln 4$. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

A Better-Than-2 Approximation for Weighted Tree Augmentation

Authors: Vera Traub, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: We present an approximation algorithm for Weighted Tree Augmentation with approximation factor $1+\ln 2 + \varepsilon < 1.7$. This is the first algorithm beating the longstanding factor of $2$, which can be achieved through many standard techniques. We present an approximation algorithm for Weighted Tree Augmentation with approximation factor $1+\ln 2 + \varepsilon < 1.7$. This is the first algorithm beating the longstanding factor of $2$, which can be achieved through many standard techniques. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Bridging the Gap Between Tree and Connectivity Augmentation: Unified and Stronger Approaches

Authors: Federica Cecchetto, Vera Traub, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: We consider the Connectivity Augmentation Problem (CAP), a classical problem in the area of Survivable Network Design. It is about increasing the edge-connectivity of a graph by one unit in the cheapest possible way. More precisely, given a $k$-edge-connected graph $G=(V,E)$ and a set of extra edges, the task is to find a minimum cardinality subset of extra edges whose addition to $G$ makes the gr… ▽ More We consider the Connectivity Augmentation Problem (CAP), a classical problem in the area of Survivable Network Design. It is about increasing the edge-connectivity of a graph by one unit in the cheapest possible way. More precisely, given a $k$-edge-connected graph $G=(V,E)$ and a set of extra edges, the task is to find a minimum cardinality subset of extra edges whose addition to $G$ makes the graph $(k+1)$-edge-connected. If $k$ is odd, the problem is known to reduce to the Tree Augmentation Problem (TAP) -- i.e., $G$ is a spanning tree -- for which significant progress has been achieved recently, leading to approximation factors below $1.5$ (the currently best factor is $1.458$). However, advances on TAP did not carry over to CAP so far. Indeed, only very recently, Byrka, Grandoni, and Ameli (STOC 2020) managed to obtain the first approximation factor below $2$ for CAP by presenting a $1.91$-approximation algorithm based on a method that is disjoint from recent advances for TAP. We first bridge the gap between TAP and CAP, by presenting techniques that allow for leveraging insights and methods from TAP to approach CAP. We then introduce a new way to get approximation factors below $1.5$, based on a new analysis technique. Through these ingredients, we obtain a $1.393$-approximation algorithm for CAP, and therefore also TAP. This leads to the currently best approximation result for both problems in a unified way, by significantly improving on the above-mentioned $1.91$-approximation for CAP and also the previously best approximation factor of $1.458$ for TAP by Grandoni, Kalaitzis, and Zenklusen (STOC 2018). Additionally, a feature we inherit from recent TAP advances is that our approach can deal with the weighted setting when the ratio between the largest to smallest cost on extra links is bounded, in which case we obtain approximation factors below $1.5$. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 30 November, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Improving the Approximation Ratio for Capacitated Vehicle Routing

Authors: Jannis Blauth, Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We devise a new approximation algorithm for capacitated vehicle routing. Our algorithm yields a better approximation ratio for general capacitated vehicle routing as well as for the unit-demand case and the splittable variant. Our results hold in arbitrary metric spaces. This is the first improvement upon the classical tour partitioning algorithm by Haimovich and Rinnooy Kan and Altinkemer and Gav… ▽ More We devise a new approximation algorithm for capacitated vehicle routing. Our algorithm yields a better approximation ratio for general capacitated vehicle routing as well as for the unit-demand case and the splittable variant. Our results hold in arbitrary metric spaces. This is the first improvement upon the classical tour partitioning algorithm by Haimovich and Rinnooy Kan and Altinkemer and Gavish. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Improving on Best-of-Many-Christofides for $T$-tours

Authors: Vera Traub

Abstract: The $T$-tour problem is a natural generalization of TSP and Path TSP. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, edge cost $c: E \to \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}$, and an even cardinality set $T\subseteq V$, we want to compute a minimum-cost $T$-join connecting all vertices of $G$ (and possibly containing parallel edges). In this paper we give an $\frac{11}{7}$-approximation for the $T$-tour problem and show that the integ… ▽ More The $T$-tour problem is a natural generalization of TSP and Path TSP. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, edge cost $c: E \to \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}$, and an even cardinality set $T\subseteq V$, we want to compute a minimum-cost $T$-join connecting all vertices of $G$ (and possibly containing parallel edges). In this paper we give an $\frac{11}{7}$-approximation for the $T$-tour problem and show that the integrality ratio of the standard LP relaxation is at most $\frac{11}{7}$. Despite much progress for the special case Path TSP, for general $T$-tours this is the first improvement on Sebő's analysis of the Best-of-Many-Christofides algorithm (Sebő [2013]). △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

An improved approximation algorithm for ATSP

Authors: Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We revisit the constant-factor approximation algorithm for the asymmetric traveling salesman problem by Svensson, Tarnawski, and Végh. We improve on each part of this algorithm. We avoid the reduction to irreducible instances and thus obtain a simpler and much better reduction to vertebrate pairs. We also show that a slight variant of their algorithm for vertebrate pairs has a much smaller approxi… ▽ More We revisit the constant-factor approximation algorithm for the asymmetric traveling salesman problem by Svensson, Tarnawski, and Végh. We improve on each part of this algorithm. We avoid the reduction to irreducible instances and thus obtain a simpler and much better reduction to vertebrate pairs. We also show that a slight variant of their algorithm for vertebrate pairs has a much smaller approximation ratio. Overall we improve the approximation ratio from $506$ to $22+ε$ for any $ε> 0$. This also improves the upper bound on the integrality ratio from $319$ to $22$. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2021; v1 submitted 2 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Reducing Path TSP to TSP

Authors: Vera Traub, Jens Vygen, Rico Zenklusen

Abstract: We present a black-box reduction from the path version of the Traveling Salesman Problem (Path TSP) to the classical tour version (TSP). More precisely, we show that given an $α$-approximation algorithm for TSP, then, for any $ε>0$, there is an $(α+ε)$-approximation algorithm for the more general Path TSP. This reduction implies that the approximability of Path TSP is the same as for TSP, up to an… ▽ More We present a black-box reduction from the path version of the Traveling Salesman Problem (Path TSP) to the classical tour version (TSP). More precisely, we show that given an $α$-approximation algorithm for TSP, then, for any $ε>0$, there is an $(α+ε)$-approximation algorithm for the more general Path TSP. This reduction implies that the approximability of Path TSP is the same as for TSP, up to an arbitrarily small error. This avoids future discrepancies between the best known approximation factors achievable for these two problems, as they have existed until very recently. A well-studied special case of TSP, Graph TSP, asks for tours in unit-weight graphs. Our reduction shows that any $α$-approximation algorithm for Graph TSP implies an $(α+ε)$-approximation algorithm for its path version. By applying our reduction to the $1.4$-approximation algorithm for Graph TSP by Sebő and Vygen, we obtain a polynomial-time $(1.4+ε)$-approximation algorithm for Graph Path TSP, improving on a recent $1.497$-approximation algorithm of Traub and Vygen. We obtain our results through a variety of new techniques, including a novel way to set up a recursive dynamic program to guess significant parts of an optimal solution. At the core of our dynamic program we deal with instances of a new generalization of (Path) TSP which combines parity constraints with certain connectivity requirements. This problem, which we call $Φ$-TSP, has a constant-factor approximation algorithm and can be reduced to TSP in certain cases when the dynamic program would not make sufficient progress. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

An improved upper bound on the integrality ratio for the $s$-$t$-path TSP

Authors: Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We give an improved analysis of the best-of-many Christofides algorithm with lonely edge deletion, which was proposed by Sebő and van Zuylen [2016]. This implies an improved upper bound on the integrality ratio of the standard LP relaxation for the $s$-$t$-path TSP. We give an improved analysis of the best-of-many Christofides algorithm with lonely edge deletion, which was proposed by Sebő and van Zuylen [2016]. This implies an improved upper bound on the integrality ratio of the standard LP relaxation for the $s$-$t$-path TSP. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 31 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Journal ref: Operations Research Letters 47 (2019), 225--228

The asymmetric traveling salesman path LP has constant integrality ratio

Authors: Anna Köhne, Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We show that the classical LP relaxation of the asymmetric traveling salesman path problem (ATSPP) has constant integrality ratio. If $ρ_{\text{ATSP}}$ and $ρ_{\text{ATSPP}}$ denote the integrality ratios for the asymmetric TSP and its path version, then $ρ_{\text{ATSPP}}\le 4ρ_{\text{ATSP}}-3$. We prove an even better bound for node-weighted instances: if the integrality ratio for ATSP on node-… ▽ More We show that the classical LP relaxation of the asymmetric traveling salesman path problem (ATSPP) has constant integrality ratio. If $ρ_{\text{ATSP}}$ and $ρ_{\text{ATSPP}}$ denote the integrality ratios for the asymmetric TSP and its path version, then $ρ_{\text{ATSPP}}\le 4ρ_{\text{ATSP}}-3$. We prove an even better bound for node-weighted instances: if the integrality ratio for ATSP on node-weighted instances is $ρ_{\text{ATSP}}^{\text{NW}}$, then the integrality ratio for ATSPP on node-weighted instances is at most $2ρ_{\text{ATSP}}^{\text NW}-1$. Moreover, we show that for ATSP node-weighted instances and unweighted digraph instances are almost equivalent. From this we deduce a lower bound of 2 on the integrality ratio of unweighted digraph instances. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2018; v1 submitted 20 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Beating the integrality ratio for s-t-tours in graphs

Authors: Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: Among various variants of the traveling salesman problem, the s-t-path graph TSP has the special feature that we know the exact integrality ratio, 3/2, and an approximation algorithm matching this ratio. In this paper, we go below this threshold: we devise a polynomial-time algorithm for the s-t-path graph TSP with approximation ratio 1.497. Our algorithm can be viewed as a refinement of the 3/2-a… ▽ More Among various variants of the traveling salesman problem, the s-t-path graph TSP has the special feature that we know the exact integrality ratio, 3/2, and an approximation algorithm matching this ratio. In this paper, we go below this threshold: we devise a polynomial-time algorithm for the s-t-path graph TSP with approximation ratio 1.497. Our algorithm can be viewed as a refinement of the 3/2-approximation algorithm by Sebő and Vygen [2014], but we introduce several completely new techniques. These include a new type of ear-decomposition, an enhanced ear induction that reveals a novel connection to matroid union, a stronger lower bound, and a reduction of general instances to instances in which s and t have small distance (which works for general metrics). △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2018; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Approaching $\frac{3}{2}$ for the $s$-$t$-path TSP

Authors: Vera Traub, Jens Vygen

Abstract: We show that there is a polynomial-time algorithm with approximation guarantee $\frac{3}{2}+ε$ for the $s$-$t$-path TSP, for any fixed $ε>0$. It is well known that Wolsey's analysis of Christofides' algorithm also works for the $s$-$t$-path TSP with its natural LP relaxation except for the narrow cuts (in which the LP solution has value less than two). A fixed optimum tour has either a single edge… ▽ More We show that there is a polynomial-time algorithm with approximation guarantee $\frac{3}{2}+ε$ for the $s$-$t$-path TSP, for any fixed $ε>0$. It is well known that Wolsey's analysis of Christofides' algorithm also works for the $s$-$t$-path TSP with its natural LP relaxation except for the narrow cuts (in which the LP solution has value less than two). A fixed optimum tour has either a single edge in a narrow cut (then call the edge and the cut lonely) or at least three (then call the cut busy). Our algorithm "guesses" (by dynamic programming) lonely cuts and edges. Then we partition the instance into smaller instances and strengthen the LP, requiring value at least three for busy cuts. By setting up a $k$-stage recursive dynamic program, we can compute a spanning tree $(V,S)$ and an LP solution $y$ such that $(\frac{1}{2}+O(2^{-k}))y$ is in the $T$-join polyhedron, where $T$ is the set of vertices whose degree in $S$ has the wrong parity. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 13 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: Final version for Journal of the ACM

Journal ref: Journal of the ACM 66 (2019), Article 14

Layers and Matroids for the Traveling Salesman's Paths

Authors: Frans Schalekamp, András Sebő, Vera Traub, Anke van Zuylen

Abstract: Gottschalk and Vygen proved that every solution of the subtour elimination linear program for traveling salesman paths is a convex combination of more and more restrictive "generalized Gao-trees". We give a short proof of this fact, as a layered convex combination of bases of a sequence of increasingly restrictive matroids. A strongly polynomial, combinatorial algorithm follows for finding this co… ▽ More Gottschalk and Vygen proved that every solution of the subtour elimination linear program for traveling salesman paths is a convex combination of more and more restrictive "generalized Gao-trees". We give a short proof of this fact, as a layered convex combination of bases of a sequence of increasingly restrictive matroids. A strongly polynomial, combinatorial algorithm follows for finding this convex combination, which is a new tool offering polyhedral insight, already instrumental in recent results for the $s-t$ path TSP. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.