-
Advances in Shannon-Based Communications and Computations Approaches to Understanding Information Processing in the Brain
Authors:
James Tee,
Giorgio M. Vitetta,
Desmond P. Taylor
Abstract:
This article serves as a supplement to the recently published call for participation in a Research Topic [1] that is timed to commemorate the 75th anniversary of Shannon's pioneering 1948 paper [2]. Here, we include some citations of key and relevant literature, which reflect our opinions/perspectives on the proposed topic, and serve as guidance to potential submissions.
This article serves as a supplement to the recently published call for participation in a Research Topic [1] that is timed to commemorate the 75th anniversary of Shannon's pioneering 1948 paper [2]. Here, we include some citations of key and relevant literature, which reflect our opinions/perspectives on the proposed topic, and serve as guidance to potential submissions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Where is Memory Information Stored in the Brain?
Authors:
James Tee,
Desmond P. Taylor
Abstract:
Within the scientific research community, memory information in the brain is commonly believed to be stored in the synapse - a hypothesis famously attributed to psychologist Donald Hebb. However, there is a growing minority who postulate that memory is stored inside the neuron at the molecular (RNA or DNA) level - an alternative postulation known as the cell-intrinsic hypothesis, coined by psychol…
▽ More
Within the scientific research community, memory information in the brain is commonly believed to be stored in the synapse - a hypothesis famously attributed to psychologist Donald Hebb. However, there is a growing minority who postulate that memory is stored inside the neuron at the molecular (RNA or DNA) level - an alternative postulation known as the cell-intrinsic hypothesis, coined by psychologist Randy Gallistel. In this paper, we review a selection of key experimental evidence from both sides of the argument. We begin with Eric Kandel's studies on sea slugs, which provided the first evidence in support of the synaptic hypothesis. Next, we touch on experiments in mice by John O'Keefe (declarative memory and the hippocampus) and Joseph LeDoux (procedural fear memory and the amygdala). Then, we introduce the synapse as the basic building block of today's artificial intelligence neural networks. After that, we describe David Glanzman's study on dissociating memory storage and synaptic change in sea slugs, and Susumu Tonegawa's experiment on reactivating retrograde amnesia in mice using laser. From there, we highlight Germund Hesslow's experiment on conditioned pauses in ferrets, and Beatrice Gelber's experiment on conditioning in single-celled organisms without synapses (Paramecium aurelia). This is followed by a description of David Glanzman's experiment on transplanting memory between sea slugs using RNA. Finally, we provide an overview of Brian Dias and Kerry Ressler's experiment on DNA transfer of fear in mice from parents to offspring. We conclude with some potential implications for the wider field of psychology.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
What If Memory Information is Stored Inside the Neuron, Instead of in the Synapse?
Authors:
James Tee,
Desmond P. Taylor
Abstract:
Memory information in the brain is commonly believed to be stored in the synapse. However, a recent groundbreaking electrophysiology research has raised the possibility that memory information may actually be stored inside the neuron itself. Drawing on information theory and communications system engineering perspectives, we examine the problem of how memory information might be transmitted reliab…
▽ More
Memory information in the brain is commonly believed to be stored in the synapse. However, a recent groundbreaking electrophysiology research has raised the possibility that memory information may actually be stored inside the neuron itself. Drawing on information theory and communications system engineering perspectives, we examine the problem of how memory information might be transmitted reliably between neurons. We identify 2 types of errors that affect neuronal communications (i.e., channel error and source error), along with plausible error mitigation solutions. We confirm the feasibility of these solutions using simulations. Four alternative hypotheses of the synapse's function are also proposed. We conclude by highlighting some research directions, along with potential areas of application.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A Quantized Representation of Probability in the Brain
Authors:
James Tee,
Desmond P. Taylor
Abstract:
Conventional and current wisdom assumes that the brain represents probability as a continuous number to many decimal places. This assumption seems implausible given finite and scarce resources in the brain. Quantization is an information encoding process whereby a continuous quantity is systematically divided into a finite number of possible categories. Rounding is a simple example of quantization…
▽ More
Conventional and current wisdom assumes that the brain represents probability as a continuous number to many decimal places. This assumption seems implausible given finite and scarce resources in the brain. Quantization is an information encoding process whereby a continuous quantity is systematically divided into a finite number of possible categories. Rounding is a simple example of quantization. We apply this information theoretic concept to develop a novel quantized (i.e., discrete) probability distortion function. We develop three conjunction probability gambling tasks to look for evidence of quantized probability representations in the brain. We hypothesize that certain ranges of probability will be lumped together in the same indifferent category if a quantized representation exists. For example, two distinct probabilities such as 0.57 and 0.585 may be treated indifferently. Our extensive data analysis has found strong evidence to support such a quantized representation: 59/76 participants (i.e., 78%) demonstrated a best fit to 4-bit quantized models instead of continuous models. This observation is the major development and novelty of the present work. The brain is very likely to be employing a quantized representation of probability. This discovery demonstrates a major precision limitation of the brain's representational and decision-making ability.
△ Less
Submitted 1 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Is Information in the Brain Represented in Continuous or Discrete Form?
Authors:
James Tee,
Desmond P. Taylor
Abstract:
The question of continuous-versus-discrete information representation in the brain is a fundamental yet unresolved question. Historically, most analyses assume a continuous representation without considering the discrete alternative. Our work explores the plausibility of both, answering the question from a communications systems engineering perspective. Using Shannon's communications theory, we po…
▽ More
The question of continuous-versus-discrete information representation in the brain is a fundamental yet unresolved question. Historically, most analyses assume a continuous representation without considering the discrete alternative. Our work explores the plausibility of both, answering the question from a communications systems engineering perspective. Using Shannon's communications theory, we posit that information in the brain is represented in discrete form. We address this hypothesis using 2 approaches. First, we identify the fundamental communication requirements of the brain. Second, we estimate the symbol error probability and channel capacity for a continuous information representation. Our work concludes that information cannot be communicated and represented reliably in the brain using a continuous representation - it has to be in a discrete form. This is a major demarcation from conventional and current wisdom. We apply this discrete result to the 4 major neural coding hypotheses, and illustrate the use of discrete ISI neural coding in analyzing electrophysiology experimental data. We further posit and illustrate a plausible direct link between Weber's Law and discrete neural coding. We end by outlining a number of key research questions on discrete neural coding.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
