Showing 1–46 of 46 results for author: Salzman, O

Towards Contact-Aided Motion Planning for Tendon-Driven Continuum Robots

Authors: Priyanka Rao, Oren Salzman, Jessica Burgner-Kahrs

Abstract: Tendon-driven continuum robots (TDCRs), with their flexible backbones, offer the advantage of being used for navigating complex, cluttered environments. However, to do so, they typically require multiple segments, often leading to complex actuation and control challenges. To this end, we propose a novel approach to navigate cluttered spaces effectively for a single-segment long TDCR which is the s… ▽ More Tendon-driven continuum robots (TDCRs), with their flexible backbones, offer the advantage of being used for navigating complex, cluttered environments. However, to do so, they typically require multiple segments, often leading to complex actuation and control challenges. To this end, we propose a novel approach to navigate cluttered spaces effectively for a single-segment long TDCR which is the simplest topology from a mechanical point of view. Our key insight is that by leveraging contact with the environment we can achieve multiple curvatures without mechanical alterations to the robot. Specifically, we propose a search-based motion planner for a single-segment TDCR. This planner, guided by a specially designed heuristic, discretizes the configuration space and employs a best-first search. The heuristic, crucial for efficient navigation, provides an effective cost-to-go estimation while respecting the kinematic constraints of the TDCR and environmental interactions. We empirically demonstrate the efficiency of our planner-testing over 525 queries in environments with both convex and non-convex obstacles, our planner is demonstrated to have a success rate of about 80% while baselines were not able to obtain a success rate higher than 30%. The difference is attributed to our novel heuristic which is shown to significantly reduce the required search space. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables

Inspection planning under execution uncertainty

Authors: Shmuel David Alpert, Kiril Solovey, Itzik Klein, Oren Salzman

Abstract: Autonomous inspection tasks necessitate path-planning algorithms to efficiently gather observations from points of interest (POI). However, localization errors commonly encountered in urban environments can introduce execution uncertainty, posing challenges to successfully completing such tasks. Unfortunately, existing algorithms for inspection planning do not explicitly account for execution unce… ▽ More Autonomous inspection tasks necessitate path-planning algorithms to efficiently gather observations from points of interest (POI). However, localization errors commonly encountered in urban environments can introduce execution uncertainty, posing challenges to successfully completing such tasks. Unfortunately, existing algorithms for inspection planning do not explicitly account for execution uncertainty, which can hinder their performance. To bridge this gap, we present IRIS-under uncertainty (IRIS-U^2), the first inspection-planning algorithm that offers statistical guarantees regarding coverage, path length, and collision probability. Our approach builds upon IRIS -- our framework for deterministic inspection planning, which is highly efficient and provably asymptotically-optimal. The extension to the much more involved uncertain setting is achieved by a refined search procedure that estimates POI coverage probabilities using Monte Carlo (MC) sampling. The efficacy of IRIS-U^2 is demonstrated through a case study focusing on structural inspections of bridges. Our approach exhibits improved expected coverage, reduced collision probability, and yields increasingly precise statistical guarantees as the number of MC samples grows. Furthermore, we demonstrate the potential advantages of computing bounded sub-optimal solutions to reduce computation time while maintaining statistical guarantees. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2024; v1 submitted 12 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 18 pages,12 figures

Introducing Delays in Multi-Agent Path Finding

Authors: Justin Kottinger, Tzvika Geft, Shaull Almagor, Oren Salzman, Morteza Lahijanian

Abstract: We consider a Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) setting where agents have been assigned a plan, but during its execution some agents are delayed. Instead of replanning from scratch when such a delay occurs, we propose delay introduction, whereby we delay some additional agents so that the remainder of the plan can be executed safely. We show that finding the minimum number of additional delays is AP… ▽ More We consider a Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) setting where agents have been assigned a plan, but during its execution some agents are delayed. Instead of replanning from scratch when such a delay occurs, we propose delay introduction, whereby we delay some additional agents so that the remainder of the plan can be executed safely. We show that finding the minimum number of additional delays is APX-Hard, i.e., it is NP-Hard to find a $(1+\varepsilon)$-approximation for some $\varepsilon>0$. However, in practice we can find optimal delay-introductions using Conflict-Based Search for very large numbers of agents, and both planning time and the resulting length of the plan are comparable, and sometimes outperform the state-of-the-art heuristics for replanning. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2024; v1 submitted 20 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, and 3 tables

Terraforming -- Environment Manipulation during Disruptions for Multi-Agent Pickup and Delivery

Authors: David Vainshtein, Yaakov Sherma, Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman

Abstract: In automated warehouses, teams of mobile robots fulfill the packaging process by transferring inventory pods to designated workstations while navigating narrow aisles formed by tightly packed pods. This problem is typically modeled as a Multi-Agent Pickup and Delivery (MAPD) problem, which is then solved by repeatedly planning collision-free paths for agents on a fixed graph, as in the Rolling-Hor… ▽ More In automated warehouses, teams of mobile robots fulfill the packaging process by transferring inventory pods to designated workstations while navigating narrow aisles formed by tightly packed pods. This problem is typically modeled as a Multi-Agent Pickup and Delivery (MAPD) problem, which is then solved by repeatedly planning collision-free paths for agents on a fixed graph, as in the Rolling-Horizon Collision Resolution (RHCR) algorithm. However, existing approaches make the limiting assumption that agents are only allowed to move pods that correspond to their current task, while considering the other pods as stationary obstacles (even though all pods are movable). This behavior can result in unnecessarily long paths which could otherwise be avoided by opening additional corridors via pod manipulation. To this end, we explore the implications of allowing agents the flexibility of dynamically relocating pods. We call this new problem Terraforming MAPD (tMAPD) and develop an RHCR-based approach to tackle it. As the extra flexibility of terraforming comes at a significant computational cost, we utilize this capability judiciously by identifying situations where it could make a significant impact on the solution quality. In particular, we invoke terraforming in response to disruptions that often occur in automated warehouses, e.g., when an item is dropped from a pod or when agents malfunction. Empirically, using our approach for tMAPD, where disruptions are modeled via a stochastic process, we improve throughput by over 10%, reduce the maximum service time (the difference between the drop-off time and the pickup time of a pod) by more than 50%, without drastically increasing the runtime, compared to the MAPD setting. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Wall Street Tree Search: Risk-Aware Planning for Offline Reinforcement Learning

Authors: Dan Elbaz, Gal Novik, Oren Salzman

Abstract: Offline reinforcement-learning (RL) algorithms learn to make decisions using a given, fixed training dataset without online data collection. This problem setting is captivating because it holds the promise of utilizing previously collected datasets without any costly or risky interaction with the environment. However, this promise also bears the drawback of this setting as the restricted dataset i… ▽ More Offline reinforcement-learning (RL) algorithms learn to make decisions using a given, fixed training dataset without online data collection. This problem setting is captivating because it holds the promise of utilizing previously collected datasets without any costly or risky interaction with the environment. However, this promise also bears the drawback of this setting as the restricted dataset induces uncertainty because the agent can encounter unfamiliar sequences of states and actions that the training data did not cover. To mitigate the destructive uncertainty effects, we need to balance the aspiration to take reward-maximizing actions with the incurred risk due to incorrect ones. In financial economics, modern portfolio theory (MPT) is a method that risk-averse investors can use to construct diversified portfolios that maximize their returns without unacceptable levels of risk. We propose integrating MPT into the agent's decision-making process, presenting a new simple-yet-highly-effective risk-aware planning algorithm for offline RL. Our algorithm allows us to systematically account for the \emph{estimated quality} of specific actions and their \emph{estimated risk} due to the uncertainty. We show that our approach can be coupled with the Transformer architecture to yield a state-of-the-art planner, which maximizes the return for offline RL tasks. Moreover, our algorithm reduces the variance of the results significantly compared to conventional Transformer decoding, which results in a much more stable algorithm -- a property that is essential for the offline RL setting, where real-world exploration and failures can be costly or dangerous. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 6 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: Accepted to Foundation Models for Decision Making (FMDM) Workshop at 36th Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS)

T*$\varepsilon$ -- Bounded-Suboptimal Efficient Motion Planning for Minimum-Time Planar Curvature-Constrained Systems

Authors: Doron Pinsky, Petr Váňa, Jan Faigl, Oren Salzman

Abstract: We consider the problem of finding collision-free paths for curvature-constrained systems in the presence of obstacles while minimizing execution time. Specifically, we focus on the setting where a planar system can travel at some range of speeds with unbounded acceleration. This setting can model many systems, such as fixed-wing drones. Unfortunately, planning for such systems might require evalu… ▽ More We consider the problem of finding collision-free paths for curvature-constrained systems in the presence of obstacles while minimizing execution time. Specifically, we focus on the setting where a planar system can travel at some range of speeds with unbounded acceleration. This setting can model many systems, such as fixed-wing drones. Unfortunately, planning for such systems might require evaluating many (local) time-optimal transitions connecting two close-by configurations, which is computationally expensive. Existing methods either pre-compute all such transitions in a preprocessing stage or use heuristics to speed up the search, thus foregoing any guarantees on solution quality. Our key insight is that computing all the time-optimal transitions is both~(i)~computationally expensive and~(ii)~unnecessary for many problem instances. We show that by finding bounded-suboptimal solutions (solutions whose cost is bounded by $1+\varepsilon$ times the cost of the optimal solution for any user-provided $\varepsilon$) and not time-optimal solutions, one can dramatically reduce the number of time-optimal transitions used. We demonstrate using empirical evaluation that our planning framework can reduce the runtime by several orders of magnitude compared to the state-of-the-art while still providing guarantees on the quality of the solution. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: IEEE ROBOTICS AND AUTOMATION LETTERS, VOL. 7, NO. 2, 4102-4109, APRIL 2022

Multi-Agent Terraforming: Efficient Multi-Agent Path Finding via Environment Manipulation

Authors: David Vainshtein, Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman

Abstract: Multi-agent pathfinding (MAPF) is concerned with planning collision-free paths for a team of agents from their start to goal locations in an environment cluttered with obstacles. Typical approaches for MAPF consider the locations of obstacles as being fixed, which limits their effectiveness in automated warehouses, where obstacles (representing pods or shelves) can be moved out of the way by agent… ▽ More Multi-agent pathfinding (MAPF) is concerned with planning collision-free paths for a team of agents from their start to goal locations in an environment cluttered with obstacles. Typical approaches for MAPF consider the locations of obstacles as being fixed, which limits their effectiveness in automated warehouses, where obstacles (representing pods or shelves) can be moved out of the way by agents (representing robots) to relieve bottlenecks and introduce shorter routes. In this work we initiate the study of MAPF with movable obstacles. In particular, we introduce a new extension of MAPF, which we call Terraforming MAPF (tMAPF), where some agents are responsible for moving obstacles to clear the way for other agents. Solving tMAPF is extremely challenging as it requires reasoning not only about collisions between agents, but also where and when obstacles should be moved. We present extensions of two state-of-the-art algorithms, CBS and PBS, in order to tackle tMAPF, and demonstrate that they can consistently outperform the best solution possible under a static-obstacle setting. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Towards Predicting Fine Finger Motions from Ultrasound Images via Kinematic Representation

Authors: Dean Zadok, Oren Salzman, Alon Wolf, Alex M. Bronstein

Abstract: A central challenge in building robotic prostheses is the creation of a sensor-based system able to read physiological signals from the lower limb and instruct a robotic hand to perform various tasks. Existing systems typically perform discrete gestures such as pointing or gras**, by employing electromyography (EMG) or ultrasound (US) technologies to analyze muscle states. While estimating finge… ▽ More A central challenge in building robotic prostheses is the creation of a sensor-based system able to read physiological signals from the lower limb and instruct a robotic hand to perform various tasks. Existing systems typically perform discrete gestures such as pointing or gras**, by employing electromyography (EMG) or ultrasound (US) technologies to analyze muscle states. While estimating finger gestures has been done in the past by detecting prominent gestures, we are interested in detection, or inference, done in the context of fine motions that evolve over time. Examples include motions occurring when performing fine and dexterous tasks such as keyboard ty** or piano playing. We consider this task as an important step towards higher adoption rates of robotic prostheses among arm amputees, as it has the potential to dramatically increase functionality in performing daily tasks. To this end, we present an end-to-end robotic system, which can successfully infer fine finger motions. This is achieved by modeling the hand as a robotic manipulator and using it as an intermediate representation to encode muscles' dynamics from a sequence of US images. We evaluated our method by collecting data from a group of subjects and demonstrating how it can be used to replay music played or text typed. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study demonstrating these downstream tasks within an end-to-end system. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2022; v1 submitted 10 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Leveraging Experience in Lifelong Multi-Agent Pathfinding

Authors: Nitzan Madar, Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman

Abstract: In Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding (L-MAPF) a team of agents performs a stream of tasks consisting of multiple locations to be visited by the agents on a shared graph while avoiding collisions with one another. L-MAPF is typically tackled by partitioning it into multiple consecutive, and hence similar, "one-shot" MAPF queries, as in the Rolling-Horizon Collision Resolution (RHCR) algorithm. Ther… ▽ More In Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding (L-MAPF) a team of agents performs a stream of tasks consisting of multiple locations to be visited by the agents on a shared graph while avoiding collisions with one another. L-MAPF is typically tackled by partitioning it into multiple consecutive, and hence similar, "one-shot" MAPF queries, as in the Rolling-Horizon Collision Resolution (RHCR) algorithm. Therefore, a solution to one query informs the next query, which leads to similarity with respect to the agents' start and goal positions, and how collisions need to be resolved from one query to the next. Thus, experience from solving one MAPF query can potentially be used to speedup solving the next one. Despite this intuition, current L-MAPF planners solve consecutive MAPF queries from scratch. In this paper, we introduce a new RHCR-inspired approach called exRHCR, which exploits experience in its constituent MAPF queries. In particular, exRHCR employs an extension of Priority-Based Search (PBS), a state-of-the-art MAPF solver. The extension, which we call exPBS, allows to warm-start the search with the priorities between agents used by PBS in the previous MAPF instances. We demonstrate empirically that exRHCR solves L-MAPF instances up to 39% faster than RHCR, and has the potential to increase system throughput for given task streams by increasing the number of agents a planner can cope with for a given time budget. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2022; v1 submitted 9 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Resolution-Optimal Motion Planning for Steerable Needles

Authors: Mengyu Fu, Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman, Ron Alterovitz

Abstract: Medical steerable needles can follow 3D curvilinear trajectories inside body tissue, enabling them to move around critical anatomical structures and precisely reach clinically significant targets in a minimally invasive way. Automating needle steering, with motion planning as a key component, has the potential to maximize the accuracy, precision, speed, and safety of steerable needle procedures. I… ▽ More Medical steerable needles can follow 3D curvilinear trajectories inside body tissue, enabling them to move around critical anatomical structures and precisely reach clinically significant targets in a minimally invasive way. Automating needle steering, with motion planning as a key component, has the potential to maximize the accuracy, precision, speed, and safety of steerable needle procedures. In this paper, we introduce the first resolution-optimal motion planner for steerable needles that offers excellent practical performance in terms of runtime while simultaneously providing strong theoretical guarantees on completeness and the global optimality of the motion plan in finite time. Compared to state-of-the-art steerable needle motion planners, simulation experiments on realistic scenarios of lung biopsy demonstrate that our proposed planner is faster in generating higher-quality plans while incorporating clinically relevant cost functions. This indicates that the theoretical guarantees of the proposed planner have a practical impact on the motion plan quality, which is valuable for computing motion plans that minimize patient trauma. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2022; v1 submitted 6 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2107.04939; to be published in ICRA 2022

Toward Certifiable Motion Planning for Medical Steerable Needles

Authors: Mengyu Fu, Oren Salzman, Ron Alterovitz

Abstract: Medical steerable needles can move along 3D curvilinear trajectories to avoid anatomical obstacles and reach clinically significant targets inside the human body. Automating steerable needle procedures can enable physicians and patients to harness the full potential of steerable needles by maximally leveraging their steerability to safely and accurately reach targets for medical procedures such as… ▽ More Medical steerable needles can move along 3D curvilinear trajectories to avoid anatomical obstacles and reach clinically significant targets inside the human body. Automating steerable needle procedures can enable physicians and patients to harness the full potential of steerable needles by maximally leveraging their steerability to safely and accurately reach targets for medical procedures such as biopsies and localized therapy delivery for cancer. For the automation of medical procedures to be clinically accepted, it is critical from a patient care, safety, and regulatory perspective to certify the correctness and effectiveness of the motion planning algorithms involved in procedure automation. In this paper, we take an important step toward creating a certifiable motion planner for steerable needles. We introduce the first motion planner for steerable needles that offers a guarantee, under clinically appropriate assumptions, that it will, in finite time, compute an exact, obstacle-avoiding motion plan to a specified target, or notify the user that no such plan exists. We present an efficient, resolution-complete motion planner for steerable needles based on a novel adaptation of multi-resolution planning. Compared to state-of-the-art steerable needle motion planners (none of which provide any completeness guarantees), we demonstrate that our new resolution-complete motion planner computes plans faster and with a higher success rate. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: To be published in Robotics: Science and Systems (RSS) 2021

Cooperative Multi-Agent Path Finding: Beyond Path Planning and Collision Avoidance

Authors: Nir Greshler, Ofir Gordon, Oren Salzman, Nahum Shimkin

Abstract: We introduce the Cooperative Multi-Agent Path Finding (Co-MAPF) problem, an extension to the classical MAPF problem, where cooperative behavior is incorporated. In this setting, a group of autonomous agents operate in a shared environment and have to complete cooperative tasks while avoiding collisions with the other agents in the group. This extension naturally models many real-world applications… ▽ More We introduce the Cooperative Multi-Agent Path Finding (Co-MAPF) problem, an extension to the classical MAPF problem, where cooperative behavior is incorporated. In this setting, a group of autonomous agents operate in a shared environment and have to complete cooperative tasks while avoiding collisions with the other agents in the group. This extension naturally models many real-world applications, where groups of agents are required to collaborate in order to complete a given task. To this end, we formalize the Co-MAPF problem and introduce Cooperative Conflict-Based Search (Co-CBS), a CBS-based algorithm for solving the problem optimally for a wide set of Co-MAPF problems. Co-CBS uses a cooperation-planning module integrated into CBS such that cooperation planning is decoupled from path planning. Finally, we present empirical results on several MAPF benchmarks demonstrating our algorithm's properties. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures

Revisiting the Complexity Analysis of Conflict-Based Search: New Computational Techniques and Improved Bounds

Authors: Ofir Gordon, Yuval Filmus, Oren Salzman

Abstract: The problem of Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) calls for finding a set of conflict-free paths for a fleet of agents operating in a given environment. Arguably, the state-of-the-art approach to computing optimal solutions is Conflict-Based Search (CBS). In this work we revisit the complexity analysis of CBS to provide tighter bounds on the algorithm's run-time in the worst-case. Our analysis paves… ▽ More The problem of Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) calls for finding a set of conflict-free paths for a fleet of agents operating in a given environment. Arguably, the state-of-the-art approach to computing optimal solutions is Conflict-Based Search (CBS). In this work we revisit the complexity analysis of CBS to provide tighter bounds on the algorithm's run-time in the worst-case. Our analysis paves the way to better pinpoint the parameters that govern (in the worst case) the algorithm's computational complexity. Our analysis is based on two complementary approaches: In the first approach we bound the run-time using the size of a Multi-valued Decision Diagram (MDD) -- a layered graph which compactly contains all possible single-agent paths between two given vertices for a specific path length. In the second approach we express the running time by a novel recurrence relation which bounds the algorithm's complexity. We use generating functions-based analysis in order to tightly bound the recurrence. Using these technique we provide several new upper-bounds on CBS's complexity. The results allow us to improve the existing bound on the running time of CBS for many cases. For example, on a set of common benchmarks we improve the upper-bound by a factor of at least $2^{10^{7}}$. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Computationally-Efficient Roadmap-based Inspection Planning via Incremental Lazy Search

Authors: Mengyu Fu, Oren Salzman, Ron Alterovitz

Abstract: The inspection-planning problem calls for computing motions for a robot that allow it to inspect a set of points of interest (POIs) while considering plan quality (e.g., plan length). This problem has applications across many domains where robots can help with inspection, including infrastructure maintenance, construction, and surgery. Incremental Random Inspection-roadmap Search (IRIS) is an asym… ▽ More The inspection-planning problem calls for computing motions for a robot that allow it to inspect a set of points of interest (POIs) while considering plan quality (e.g., plan length). This problem has applications across many domains where robots can help with inspection, including infrastructure maintenance, construction, and surgery. Incremental Random Inspection-roadmap Search (IRIS) is an asymptotically-optimal inspection planner that was shown to compute higher-quality inspection plans orders of magnitudes faster than the prior state-of-the-art method. In this paper, we significantly accelerate the performance of IRIS to broaden its applicability to more challenging real-world applications. A key computational challenge that IRIS faces is effectively searching roadmaps for inspection plans -- a procedure that dominates its running time. In this work, we show how to incorporate lazy edge-evaluation techniques into \iris's search algorithm and how to reuse search efforts when a roadmap undergoes local changes. These enhancements, which do not compromise IRIS's asymptotic optimality, enable us to compute inspection plans much faster than the original IRIS. We apply IRIS with the enhancements to simulated bridge inspection and surgical inspection tasks and show that our new algorithm for some scenarios can compute similar-quality inspection plans 570x faster than prior work. △ Less

Submitted 24 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: to be published in ICRA 2021

Provably Constant-time Planning and Replanning for Real-time Gras** Objects off a Conveyor Belt

Authors: Fahad Islam, Oren Salzman, Aditya Agarwal, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: In warehouse and manufacturing environments, manipulation platforms are frequently deployed at conveyor belts to perform pick and place tasks. Because objects on the conveyor belts are moving, robots have limited time to pick them up. This brings the requirement for fast and reliable motion planners that could provide provable real-time planning guarantees, which the existing algorithms do not pro… ▽ More In warehouse and manufacturing environments, manipulation platforms are frequently deployed at conveyor belts to perform pick and place tasks. Because objects on the conveyor belts are moving, robots have limited time to pick them up. This brings the requirement for fast and reliable motion planners that could provide provable real-time planning guarantees, which the existing algorithms do not provide. Besides the planning efficiency, the success of manipulation tasks relies heavily on the accuracy of the perception system which is often noisy, especially if the target objects are perceived from a distance. For fast moving conveyor belts, the robot cannot wait for a perfect estimate before it starts executing its motion. In order to be able to reach the object in time, it must start moving early on (relying on the initial noisy estimates) and adjust its motion on-the-fly in response to the pose updates from perception. We propose a planning framework that meets these requirements by providing provable constant-time planning and replanning guarantees. To this end, we first introduce and formalize a new class of algorithms called Constant-Time Motion Planning algorithms (CTMP) that guarantee to plan in constant time and within a user-defined time bound. We then present our planning framework for gras** objects off a conveyor belt as an instance of the CTMP class of algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2003.08517

Safer Motion Planning of Steerable Needles via a Shaft-to-Tissue Force Model

Authors: Michael Bentley, Caleb Rucker, Chakravarthy Reddy, Oren Salzman, Alan Kuntz

Abstract: Steerable needles are capable of accurately targeting difficult-to-reach clinical sites in the body. By bending around sensitive anatomical structures, steerable needles have the potential to reduce the invasiveness of many medical procedures. However, inserting these needles with curved trajectories increases the risk of tissue damage due to perpendicular forces exerted on the surrounding tissue… ▽ More Steerable needles are capable of accurately targeting difficult-to-reach clinical sites in the body. By bending around sensitive anatomical structures, steerable needles have the potential to reduce the invasiveness of many medical procedures. However, inserting these needles with curved trajectories increases the risk of tissue damage due to perpendicular forces exerted on the surrounding tissue by the needle's shaft, potentially resulting in lateral shearing through tissue. Such forces can cause significant damage to surrounding tissue, negatively affecting patient outcomes. In this work, we derive a tissue and needle force model based on a Cosserat string formulation, which describes the normal forces and frictional forces along the shaft as a function of the planned needle path, friction model and parameters, and tip piercing force. We propose this new force model and associated cost function as a safer and more clinically relevant metric than those currently used in motion planning for steerable needles. We fit and validate our model through physical needle robot experiments in a gel phantom. We use this force model to define a bottleneck cost function for motion planning and evaluate it against the commonly used path-length cost function in hundreds of randomly generated 3-D environments. Plans generated with our force-based cost show a 62% reduction in the peak modeled tissue force with only a 0.07% increase in length on average compared to using the path-length cost in planning. Additionally, we demonstrate the ability to plan motions with our force-based cost function in a lung tumor biopsy scenario from a segmented computed tomography (CT) scan. By planning motions for the needle that aim to minimize the modeled needle-to-tissue force explicitly, our method plans needle paths that may reduce the risk of significant tissue damage while still reaching desired targets in the body. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2022; v1 submitted 6 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 12 figures, preprint of an article submitted for consideration in Journal of Medical Robotics Research (JMRR) in 2022

Approximate bi-criteria search by efficient representation of subsets of the Pareto-optimal frontier

Authors: Oren Salzman

Abstract: We consider the bi-criteria shortest-path problem where we want to compute shortest paths on a graph that simultaneously balance two cost functions. While this problem has numerous applications, there is usually no path minimizing both cost functions simultaneously. Thus, we typically consider the set of paths where no path is strictly better then the others in both cost functions, a set called th… ▽ More We consider the bi-criteria shortest-path problem where we want to compute shortest paths on a graph that simultaneously balance two cost functions. While this problem has numerous applications, there is usually no path minimizing both cost functions simultaneously. Thus, we typically consider the set of paths where no path is strictly better then the others in both cost functions, a set called the Pareto-optimal frontier. Unfortunately, the size of this set may be exponential in the number of graph vertices and the general problem is NP-hard. While existing schemes to approximate this set exist, they may be slower than exact approaches when applied to relatively small instances and running them on graphs with even a moderate number of nodes is often impractical. The crux of the problem lies in how to efficiently approximate the Pareto-optimal frontier. Our key insight is that the Pareto-optimal frontier can be approximated using pairs of paths. This simple observation allows us to run a best-first-search while efficiently and effectively pruning away intermediate solutions in order to obtain an approximation of the Pareto frontier for any given approximation factor. We compared our approach with an adaptation of BOA*, the state-of-the-art algorithm for computing exact solutions to the bi-criteria shortest-path problem. Our experiments show that as the problem becomes harder, the speedup obtained becomes more pronounced. Specifically, on large roadmaps, we obtain an average speedup of more than $\times 8.5$ and a maximal speedup of over $\times 148$. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2021; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Provably Constant-time Planning and Replanning for Real-time Gras** Objects off a Conveyor Belt

Authors: Fahad Islam, Oren Salzman, Aditya Agarwal, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: In warehouse and manufacturing environments, manipulation platforms are frequently deployed at conveyor belts to perform pick and place tasks. Because objects on the conveyor belts are moving, robots have limited time to pick them up. This brings the requirement for fast and reliable motion planners that could provide provable real-time planning guarantees, which the existing algorithms do not pro… ▽ More In warehouse and manufacturing environments, manipulation platforms are frequently deployed at conveyor belts to perform pick and place tasks. Because objects on the conveyor belts are moving, robots have limited time to pick them up. This brings the requirement for fast and reliable motion planners that could provide provable real-time planning guarantees, which the existing algorithms do not provide. Besides the planning efficiency, the success of manipulation tasks relies heavily on the accuracy of the perception system which is often noisy, especially if the target objects are perceived from a distance. For fast moving conveyor belts, the robot cannot wait for a perfect estimate before it starts executing its motion. In order to be able to reach the object in time it must start moving early on (relying on the initial noisy estimates) and adjust its motion on-the-fly in response to the pose updates from perception. We propose an approach that meets these requirements by providing provable constant-time planning and replanning guarantees. We present it, give its analytical properties and show experimental analysis in simulation and on a real robot. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2020; v1 submitted 18 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Task-Informed Fidelity Management for Speeding Up Robotics Simulation

Authors: Abhijeet Tallavajhula, Adrian Schoisengeier, Sung-Kyun Kim, Anirudh Vemula, Levi Lister, Oren Salzman

Abstract: Simulators are an important tool in robotics that is used to develop robot software and generate synthetic data for machine learning algorithms. Faster simulation can result in better software validation and larger amounts of data. Previous efforts for speeding up simulators have been performed at the level of simulator building blocks, and robot systems. Our key insight, motivating this work, is… ▽ More Simulators are an important tool in robotics that is used to develop robot software and generate synthetic data for machine learning algorithms. Faster simulation can result in better software validation and larger amounts of data. Previous efforts for speeding up simulators have been performed at the level of simulator building blocks, and robot systems. Our key insight, motivating this work, is that further speedups can be obtained at the level of the robot task. Building on the observation that not all parts of a scene need to be simulated in high fidelity at all times, our approach is to toggle between high- and low-fidelity states for scene objects in a task-informed manner. Our contribution is a framework for speeding up robot simulation by exploiting task knowledge. The framework is agnostic to the underlying simulator, and preserves simulation fidelity. As a case study, we consider a complex material-handling task. For the associated simulation, which contains many of the characteristics that make robot simulation slow, we achieve a speedup that can be up to three times faster than high fidelity without compromising on the quality of the results. We also demonstrate that faster simulation allows us to train better policies for performing the task at hand in a short period of time. A video summarizing our contributions can be found at https://youtu.be/PEzypDyqc3o . △ Less

Submitted 27 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Planning, Learning and Reasoning Framework for Robot Truck Unloading

Authors: Fahad Islam, Anirudh Vemula, Sung-Kyun Kim, Andrew Dornbush, Oren Salzman, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: We consider the task of autonomously unloading boxes from trucks using an industrial manipulator robot. There are multiple challenges that arise: (1) real-time motion planning for a complex robotic system carrying two articulated mechanisms, an arm and a scooper, (2) decision-making in terms of what action to execute next given imperfect information about boxes such as their masses, (3) accounting… ▽ More We consider the task of autonomously unloading boxes from trucks using an industrial manipulator robot. There are multiple challenges that arise: (1) real-time motion planning for a complex robotic system carrying two articulated mechanisms, an arm and a scooper, (2) decision-making in terms of what action to execute next given imperfect information about boxes such as their masses, (3) accounting for the sequential nature of the problem where current actions affect future state of the boxes, and (4) real-time execution that interleaves high-level decision-making with lower level motion planning. In this work, we propose a planning, learning, and reasoning framework to tackle these challenges, and describe its components including motion planning, belief space planning for offline learning, online decision-making based on offline learning, and an execution module to combine decision-making with motion planning. We analyze the performance of the framework on real-world scenarios. In particular, motion planning and execution modules are evaluated in simulation and on a real robot, while offline learning and online decision-making are evaluated in simulated real-world scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2020; v1 submitted 21 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

A Planning Framework for Persistent, Multi-UAV Coverage with Global Deconfliction

Authors: Tushar Kusnur, Shohin Mukherjee, Dhruv Mauria Saxena, Tomoya Fukami, Takayuki Koyama, Oren Salzman, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: Planning for multi-robot coverage seeks to determine collision-free paths for a fleet of robots, enabling them to collectively observe points of interest in an environment. Persistent coverage is a variant of traditional coverage where coverage-levels in the environment decay over time. Thus, robots have to continuously revisit parts of the environment to maintain a desired coverage-level. Facilit… ▽ More Planning for multi-robot coverage seeks to determine collision-free paths for a fleet of robots, enabling them to collectively observe points of interest in an environment. Persistent coverage is a variant of traditional coverage where coverage-levels in the environment decay over time. Thus, robots have to continuously revisit parts of the environment to maintain a desired coverage-level. Facilitating this in the real world demands we tackle numerous subproblems. While there exist standard solutions to these subproblems, there is no complete framework that addresses all of their individual challenges as a whole in a practical setting. We adapt and combine these solutions to present a planning framework for persistent coverage with multiple unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). Specifically, we run a continuous loop of goal assignment and globally deconflicting, kinodynamic path planning for multiple UAVs. We evaluate our framework in simulation as well as the real world. In particular, we demonstrate that (i) our framework exhibits graceful coverage given sufficient resources, we maintain persistent coverage; if resources are insufficient (e.g., having too few UAVs for a given size of the enviornment), coverage-levels decay slowly and (ii) planning with global deconfliction in our framework incurs a negligibly higher price compared to other weaker, more local collision-checking schemes. (Video: https://youtu.be/aqDs6Wymp5Q) △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2019; v1 submitted 24 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 12th Conference on Field and Service Robotics, 2019

Toward Asymptotically-Optimal Inspection Planning via Efficient Near-Optimal Graph Search

Authors: Mengyu Fu, Alan Kuntz, Oren Salzman, Ron Alterovitz

Abstract: Inspection planning, the task of planning motions that allow a robot to inspect a set of points of interest, has applications in domains such as industrial, field, and medical robotics. Inspection planning can be computationally challenging, as the search space over motion plans that inspect the points of interest grows exponentially with the number of inspected points. We propose a novel method,… ▽ More Inspection planning, the task of planning motions that allow a robot to inspect a set of points of interest, has applications in domains such as industrial, field, and medical robotics. Inspection planning can be computationally challenging, as the search space over motion plans that inspect the points of interest grows exponentially with the number of inspected points. We propose a novel method, Incremental Random Inspection-roadmap Search (IRIS), that computes inspection plans whose length and set of inspected points asymptotically converge to those of an optimal inspection plan. IRIS incrementally densifies a motion planning roadmap using sampling-based algorithms, and performs efficient near-optimal graph search over the resulting roadmap as it is generated. We demonstrate IRIS's efficacy on a simulated planar 5DOF manipulator inspection task and on a medical endoscopic inspection task for a continuum parallel surgical robot in anatomy segmented from patient CT data. We show that IRIS computes higher-quality inspection paths orders of magnitudes faster than a prior state-of-the-art method. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: RSS 2019

Generalized Lazy Search for Robot Motion Planning: Interleaving Search and Edge Evaluation via Event-based Toggles

Authors: Aditya Mandalika, Sanjiban Choudhury, Oren Salzman, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: Lazy search algorithms can efficiently solve problems where edge evaluation is the bottleneck in computation, as is the case for robotic motion planning. The optimal algorithm in this class, LazySP, lazily restricts edge evaluation to only the shortest path. Doing so comes at the expense of search effort, i.e., LazySP must recompute the search tree every time an edge is found to be invalid. This b… ▽ More Lazy search algorithms can efficiently solve problems where edge evaluation is the bottleneck in computation, as is the case for robotic motion planning. The optimal algorithm in this class, LazySP, lazily restricts edge evaluation to only the shortest path. Doing so comes at the expense of search effort, i.e., LazySP must recompute the search tree every time an edge is found to be invalid. This becomes prohibitively expensive when dealing with large graphs or highly cluttered environments. Our key insight is the need to balance both edge evaluation and search effort to minimize the total planning time. Our contribution is two-fold. First, we propose a framework, Generalized Lazy Search (GLS), that seamlessly toggles between search and evaluation to prevent wasted efforts. We show that for a choice of toggle, GLS is provably more efficient than LazySP. Second, we leverage prior experience of edge probabilities to derive GLS policies that minimize expected planning time. We show that GLS equipped with such priors significantly outperforms competitive baselines for many simulated environments in R2, SE(2) and 7-DoF manipulation. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2019; v1 submitted 4 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: Accepted at International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling (ICAPS) 2019

Provable Indefinite-Horizon Real-Time Planning for Repetitive Tasks

Authors: Fahad Islam, Oren Salzman, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: In many robotic manipulation scenarios, robots often have to perform highly-repetitive tasks in structured environments e.g. sorting mail in a mailroom or pick and place objects on a conveyor belt. In this work we are interested in settings where the tasks are similar, yet not identical (e.g., due to uncertain orientation of objects) and motion planning needs to be extremely fast. Preprocessing-ba… ▽ More In many robotic manipulation scenarios, robots often have to perform highly-repetitive tasks in structured environments e.g. sorting mail in a mailroom or pick and place objects on a conveyor belt. In this work we are interested in settings where the tasks are similar, yet not identical (e.g., due to uncertain orientation of objects) and motion planning needs to be extremely fast. Preprocessing-based approaches prove to be very beneficial in these settings. They analyze the configuration-space offline to generate some auxiliary information which can then be used in the query phase to speedup planning times. Typically, the tighter the requirement is on query times the larger the memory footprint will be. In particular, for high-dimensional spaces, providing real-time planning capabilities is extremely challenging. While there are planners that guarantee real-time performance by limiting the planning horizon, we are not aware of general-purpose planners capable of doing it for indefinite horizon (i.e., planning to the goal). To this end, we propose a preprocessing-based method that provides provable bounds on the query time while incurring only a small amount of memory overhead in the query phase. We evaluate our method on a 7-DOF robot arm and show a speedup of over tenfold in query time when compared to the PRM algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2019; v1 submitted 22 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Lazy Receding Horizon A* for Efficient Path Planning in Graphs with Expensive-to-Evaluate Edges

Authors: Aditya Mandalika, Oren Salzman, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: Motion-planning problems, such as manipulation in cluttered environments, often require a collision-free shortest path to be computed quickly given a roadmap graph. Typically, the computational cost of evaluating whether an edge of the roadmap graph is collision-free dominates the running time of search algorithms. Algorithms such as Lazy Weighted A* (LWA*) and LazySP have been proposed to reduce… ▽ More Motion-planning problems, such as manipulation in cluttered environments, often require a collision-free shortest path to be computed quickly given a roadmap graph. Typically, the computational cost of evaluating whether an edge of the roadmap graph is collision-free dominates the running time of search algorithms. Algorithms such as Lazy Weighted A* (LWA*) and LazySP have been proposed to reduce the number of edge evaluations by employing a lazy lookahead (one-step lookahead and infinite-step lookahead, respectively). However, this comes at the expense of additional graph operations: the larger the lookahead, the more the graph operations that are typically required. We propose Lazy Receding-Horizon A* (LRA*) to minimize the total planning time by balancing edge evaluations and graph operations. Endowed with a lazy lookahead, LRA* represents a family of lazy shortest-path graph-search algorithms that generalizes LWA* and LazySP. We analyze the theoretic properties of LRA* and demonstrate empirically that, in many cases, to minimize the total planning time, the algorithm requires an intermediate lazy lookahead. Namely, using an intermediate lazy lookahead, our algorithm outperforms both LWA* and LazySP. These experiments span simulated random worlds in $\mathbb{R}^2$ and $\mathbb{R}^4$, and manipulation problems using a 7-DOF manipulator. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2018; v1 submitted 13 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 16 pages; typos corrected; revised text; results unchanged

Effective Footstep Planning Using Homotopy-Class Guidance

Authors: Vinitha Ranganeni, Sahit Chintalapudi, Oren Salzman, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: Planning the motion for humanoid robots is a computationally-complex task due to the high dimensionality of the system. Thus, a common approach is to first plan in the low-dimensional space induced by the robot's feet---a task referred to as footstep planning. This low-dimensional plan is then used to guide the full motion of the robot. One approach that has proven successful in footstep planning… ▽ More Planning the motion for humanoid robots is a computationally-complex task due to the high dimensionality of the system. Thus, a common approach is to first plan in the low-dimensional space induced by the robot's feet---a task referred to as footstep planning. This low-dimensional plan is then used to guide the full motion of the robot. One approach that has proven successful in footstep planning is using search-based planners such as A* and its many variants. To do so, these search-based planners have to be endowed with effective heuristics to efficiently guide them through the search space. However, designing effective heuristics is a time-consuming task that requires the user to have good domain knowledge. Thus, our goal is to be able to effectively plan the footstep motions taken by a humanoid robot while obviating the burden on the user to carefully design local-minima free heuristics. To this end, we propose to use user-defined homotopy classes in the workspace that are intuitive to define. These homotopy classes are used to automatically generate heuristic functions that efficiently guide the footstep planner. Additionally, we present an extension to homotopy classes such that they are applicable to complex multi-level environments. We compare our approach for footstep planning with a standard approach that uses a heuristic common to footstep planning. In simple scenarios, the performance of both algorithms is comparable. However, in more complex scenarios our approach allows for a speedup in planning of several orders of magnitude when compared to the standard approach. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2019; v1 submitted 1 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 17 pages, 8 figures

Anytime Motion Planning on Large Dense Roadmaps with Expensive Edge Evaluations

Authors: Shushman Choudhury, Oren Salzman, Sanjiban Choudhury, Christopher M. Dellin, Siddhartha S. Srinivasa

Abstract: We propose an algorithmic framework for efficient anytime motion planning on large dense geometric roadmaps, in domains where collision checks and therefore edge evaluations are computationally expensive. A large dense roadmap (graph) can typically ensure the existence of high quality solutions for most motion-planning problems, but the size of the roadmap, particularly in high-dimensional spaces,… ▽ More We propose an algorithmic framework for efficient anytime motion planning on large dense geometric roadmaps, in domains where collision checks and therefore edge evaluations are computationally expensive. A large dense roadmap (graph) can typically ensure the existence of high quality solutions for most motion-planning problems, but the size of the roadmap, particularly in high-dimensional spaces, makes existing search-based planning algorithms computationally expensive. We deal with the challenges of expensive search and collision checking in two ways. First, we frame the problem of anytime motion planning on roadmaps as searching for the shortest path over a sequence of subgraphs of the entire roadmap graph, generated by some densification strategy. This lets us achieve bounded sub-optimality with bounded worst-case planning effort. Second, for searching each subgraph, we develop an anytime planning algorithm which uses a belief model to compute the collision probability of unknown configurations and searches for paths that are Pareto-optimal in path length and collision probability. This algorithm is efficient with respect to collision checks as it searches for successively shorter paths. We theoretically analyze both our ideas and evaluate them individually on high-dimensional motion-planning problems. Finally, we apply both of these ideas together in our algorithmic framework for anytime motion planning, and show that it outperforms BIT* on high-dimensional hypercube problems. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Minimizing Task Space Frechet Error via Efficient Incremental Graph Search

Authors: Rachel Holladay, Oren Salzman, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: We present an anytime algorithm that generates a collision-free configuration-space path that closely follows a desired path in task space, according to the discrete Frechet distance. By leveraging tools from computational geometry, we approximate the search space using a cross-product graph. We use a variant of Dijkstra's graph-search algorithm to efficiently search for and iteratively improve th… ▽ More We present an anytime algorithm that generates a collision-free configuration-space path that closely follows a desired path in task space, according to the discrete Frechet distance. By leveraging tools from computational geometry, we approximate the search space using a cross-product graph. We use a variant of Dijkstra's graph-search algorithm to efficiently search for and iteratively improve the solution. We compare multiple proposed densification strategies and empirically show that our algorithm outperforms a set of state-of-the-art planners on a range of manipulation problems. Finally, we offer a proof sketch of the asymptotic optimality of our algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2018; v1 submitted 18 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Generalizing Informed Sampling for Asymptotically Optimal Sampling-based Kinodynamic Planning via Markov Chain Monte Carlo

Authors: Daqing Yi, Rohan Thakker, Cole Gulino, Oren Salzman, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: Asymptotically-optimal motion planners such as RRT* have been shown to incrementally approximate the shortest path between start and goal states. Once an initial solution is found, their performance can be dramatically improved by restricting subsequent samples to regions of the state space that can potentially improve the current solution. When the motion planning problem lies in a Euclidean spac… ▽ More Asymptotically-optimal motion planners such as RRT* have been shown to incrementally approximate the shortest path between start and goal states. Once an initial solution is found, their performance can be dramatically improved by restricting subsequent samples to regions of the state space that can potentially improve the current solution. When the motion planning problem lies in a Euclidean space, this region $X_{inf}$, called the informed set, can be sampled directly. However, when planning with differential constraints in non-Euclidean state spaces, no analytic solutions exists to sampling $X_{inf}$ directly. State-of-the-art approaches to sampling $X_{inf}$ in such domains such as Hierarchical Rejection Sampling (HRS) may still be slow in high-dimensional state space. This may cause the planning algorithm to spend most of its time trying to produces samples in $X_{inf}$ rather than explore it. In this paper, we suggest an alternative approach to produce samples in the informed set $X_{inf}$ for a wide range of settings. Our main insight is to recast this problem as one of sampling uniformly within the sub-level-set of an implicit non-convex function. This recasting enables us to apply Monte Carlo sampling methods, used very effectively in the Machine Learning and Optimization communities, to solve our problem. We show for a wide range of scenarios that using our sampler can accelerate the convergence rate to high-quality solutions in high-dimensional problems. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

The Provable Virtue of Laziness in Motion Planning

Authors: Nika Haghtalab, Simon Mackenzie, Ariel D. Procaccia, Oren Salzman, Siddhartha S. Srinivasa

Abstract: The Lazy Shortest Path (LazySP) class consists of motion-planning algorithms that only evaluate edges along shortest paths between the source and target. These algorithms were designed to minimize the number of edge evaluations in settings where edge evaluation dominates the running time of the algorithm; but how close to optimal are LazySP algorithms in terms of this objective? Our main result is… ▽ More The Lazy Shortest Path (LazySP) class consists of motion-planning algorithms that only evaluate edges along shortest paths between the source and target. These algorithms were designed to minimize the number of edge evaluations in settings where edge evaluation dominates the running time of the algorithm; but how close to optimal are LazySP algorithms in terms of this objective? Our main result is an analytical upper bound, in a probabilistic model, on the number of edge evaluations required by LazySP algorithms; a matching lower bound shows that these algorithms are asymptotically optimal in the worst case. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Online, interactive user guidance for high-dimensional, constrained motion planning

Authors: Fahad Islam, Oren Salzman, Maxim Likhachev

Abstract: We consider the problem of planning a collision-free path for a high-dimensional robot. Specifically, we suggest a planning framework where a motion-planning algorithm can obtain guidance from a user. In contrast to existing approaches that try to speed up planning by incorporating experiences or demonstrations ahead of planning, we suggest to seek user guidance only when the planner identifies th… ▽ More We consider the problem of planning a collision-free path for a high-dimensional robot. Specifically, we suggest a planning framework where a motion-planning algorithm can obtain guidance from a user. In contrast to existing approaches that try to speed up planning by incorporating experiences or demonstrations ahead of planning, we suggest to seek user guidance only when the planner identifies that it ceases to make significant progress towards the goal. Guidance is provided in the form of an intermediate configuration $\hat{q}$, which is used to bias the planner to go through $\hat{q}$. We demonstrate our approach for the case where the planning algorithm is Multi-Heuristic A* (MHA*) and the robot is a 34-DOF humanoid. We show that our approach allows to compute highly-constrained paths with little domain knowledge. Without our approach, solving such problems requires carefully-crafting domain-dependent heuristics. △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 2018; v1 submitted 10 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

An Efficient Algorithm for Computing High-Quality Paths amid Polygonal Obstacles

Authors: Pankaj K. Agarwal, Kyle Fox, Oren Salzman

Abstract: We study a path-planning problem amid a set $\mathcal{O}$ of obstacles in $\mathbb{R}^2$, in which we wish to compute a short path between two points while also maintaining a high clearance from $\mathcal{O}$; the clearance of a point is its distance from a nearest obstacle in $\mathcal{O}$. Specifically, the problem asks for a path minimizing the reciprocal of the clearance integrated over the le… ▽ More We study a path-planning problem amid a set $\mathcal{O}$ of obstacles in $\mathbb{R}^2$, in which we wish to compute a short path between two points while also maintaining a high clearance from $\mathcal{O}$; the clearance of a point is its distance from a nearest obstacle in $\mathcal{O}$. Specifically, the problem asks for a path minimizing the reciprocal of the clearance integrated over the length of the path. We present the first polynomial-time approximation scheme for this problem. Let $n$ be the total number of obstacle vertices and let $\varepsilon \in (0,1]$. Our algorithm computes in time $O(\frac{n^2}{\varepsilon ^2} \log \frac{n}{\varepsilon})$ a path of total cost at most $(1+\varepsilon)$ times the cost of the optimal path. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: A preliminary version of this work appear in the Proceedings of the 27th Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms

Effective Metrics for Multi-Robot Motion-Planning

Authors: Aviel Atias, Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We study the effectiveness of metrics for Multi-Robot Motion-Planning (MRMP) when using RRT-style sampling-based planners. These metrics play the crucial role of determining the nearest neighbors of configurations and in that they regulate the connectivity of the underlying roadmaps produced by the planners and other properties like the quality of solution paths. After screening over a dozen diffe… ▽ More We study the effectiveness of metrics for Multi-Robot Motion-Planning (MRMP) when using RRT-style sampling-based planners. These metrics play the crucial role of determining the nearest neighbors of configurations and in that they regulate the connectivity of the underlying roadmaps produced by the planners and other properties like the quality of solution paths. After screening over a dozen different metrics we focus on the five most promising ones- two more traditional metrics, and three novel ones which we propose here, adapted from the domain of shape-matching. In addition to the novel multi-robot metrics, a central contribution of this work are tools to analyze and predict the effectiveness of metrics in the MRMP context. We identify a suite of possible substructures in the configuration space, for which it is fairly easy (i) to define a so-called natural distance which allows us to predict the performance of a metric. This is done by comparing the distribution of its values for sampled pairs of configurations to the distribution induced by the natural distance; (ii) to define equivalence classes of configurations and test how well a metric covers the different classes. We provide experiments that attest to the ability of our tools to predict the effectiveness of metrics: those metrics that qualify in the analysis yield higher success rate of the planner with fewer vertices in the roadmap. We also show how combining several metrics together leads to better results (success rate and size of roadmap) than using a single metric. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2017; v1 submitted 29 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: Extended version for the Robotics: Science and Systems conference, 2017

Efficient motion planning for problems lacking optimal substructure

Authors: Oren Salzman, Brian Hou, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: We consider the motion-planning problem of planning a collision-free path of a robot in the presence of risk zones. The robot is allowed to travel in these zones but is penalized in a super-linear fashion for consecutive accumulative time spent there. We suggest a natural cost function that balances path length and risk-exposure time. Specifically, we consider the discrete setting where we are giv… ▽ More We consider the motion-planning problem of planning a collision-free path of a robot in the presence of risk zones. The robot is allowed to travel in these zones but is penalized in a super-linear fashion for consecutive accumulative time spent there. We suggest a natural cost function that balances path length and risk-exposure time. Specifically, we consider the discrete setting where we are given a graph, or a roadmap, and we wish to compute the minimal-cost path under this cost function. Interestingly, paths defined using our cost function do not have an optimal substructure. Namely, subpaths of an optimal path are not necessarily optimal. Thus, the Bellman condition is not satisfied and standard graph-search algorithms such as Dijkstra cannot be used. We present a path-finding algorithm, which can be seen as a natural generalization of Dijkstra's algorithm. Our algorithm runs in $O\left((n_B\cdot n) \log( n_B\cdot n) + n_B\cdot m\right)$ time, where~$n$ and $m$ are the number of vertices and edges of the graph, respectively, and $n_B$ is the number of intersections between edges and the boundary of the risk zone. We present simulations on robotic platforms demonstrating both the natural paths produced by our cost function and the computational efficiency of our algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2017; v1 submitted 7 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Open problem on risk-aware planning in the plane

Authors: Oren Salzman, Siddhartha Srinivasa

Abstract: We consider the problem of planning a collision-free path of a robot in the presence of risk zones. The robot is allowed to travel in these zones but is penalized in a super-linear fashion for consecutive accumulative time spent there. We recently suggested a natural cost function that balances path length and risk-exposure time. When no risk zones exists, our problem resorts to computing minimal-… ▽ More We consider the problem of planning a collision-free path of a robot in the presence of risk zones. The robot is allowed to travel in these zones but is penalized in a super-linear fashion for consecutive accumulative time spent there. We recently suggested a natural cost function that balances path length and risk-exposure time. When no risk zones exists, our problem resorts to computing minimal-length paths which is known to be computationally hard in the number of dimensions. It is well known that in two-dimensions computing minimal-length paths can be done efficiently. Thus, a natural question we pose is "Is our problem computationally hard or not?" If the problem is hard, we wish to find an approximation algorithm to compute a near-optimal path. If not, then a polynomial-time algorithm should be found. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2017; v1 submitted 15 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Densification Strategies for Anytime Motion Planning over Large Dense Roadmaps

Authors: Shushman Choudhury, Oren Salzman, Sanjiban Choudhury, Siddhartha S. Srinivasa

Abstract: We consider the problem of computing shortest paths in a dense motion-planning roadmap $\mathcal{G}$. We assume that~$n$, the number of vertices of $\mathcal{G}$, is very large. Thus, using any path-planning algorithm that directly searches $\mathcal{G}$, running in $O(V\textrm{log}V + E) \approx O(n^2)$ time, becomes unacceptably expensive. We are therefore interested in anytime search to obtain… ▽ More We consider the problem of computing shortest paths in a dense motion-planning roadmap $\mathcal{G}$. We assume that~$n$, the number of vertices of $\mathcal{G}$, is very large. Thus, using any path-planning algorithm that directly searches $\mathcal{G}$, running in $O(V\textrm{log}V + E) \approx O(n^2)$ time, becomes unacceptably expensive. We are therefore interested in anytime search to obtain successively shorter feasible paths and converge to the shortest path in $\mathcal{G}$. Our key insight is to provide existing path-planning algorithms with a sequence of increasingly dense subgraphs of $\mathcal{G}$. We study the space of all ($r$-disk) subgraphs of $\mathcal{G}$. We then formulate and present two densification strategies for traversing this space which exhibit complementary properties with respect to problem difficulty. This inspires a third, hybrid strategy which has favourable properties regardless of problem difficulty. This general approach is then demonstrated and analyzed using the specific case where a low-dispersion deterministic sequence is used to generate the samples used for $\mathcal{G}$. Finally we empirically evaluate the performance of our strategies for random scenarios in $\mathbb{R}^{2}$ and $\mathbb{R}^{4}$ and on manipulation planning problems for a 7 DOF robot arm, and validate our analysis. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2017; v1 submitted 31 October, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Submitted to The International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA) 2017

Collision detection or nearest-neighbor search? On the computational bottleneck in sampling-based motion planning

Authors: Michal Kleinbort, Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: The complexity of nearest-neighbor search dominates the asymptotic running time of many sampling-based motion-planning algorithms. However, collision detection is often considered to be the computational bottleneck in practice. Examining various asymptotically optimal planning algorithms, we characterize settings, which we call NN-sensitive, in which the practical computational role of nearest-nei… ▽ More The complexity of nearest-neighbor search dominates the asymptotic running time of many sampling-based motion-planning algorithms. However, collision detection is often considered to be the computational bottleneck in practice. Examining various asymptotically optimal planning algorithms, we characterize settings, which we call NN-sensitive, in which the practical computational role of nearest-neighbor search is far from being negligible, i.e., the portion of running time taken up by nearest-neighbor search is comparable, or sometimes even greater than the portion of time taken up by collision detection. This reinforces and substantiates the claim that motion-planning algorithms could significantly benefit from efficient and possibly specifically-tailored nearest-neighbor data structures. The asymptotic (near) optimality of these algorithms relies on a prescribed connection radius, defining a ball around a configuration $q$, such that $q$ needs to be connected to all other configurations in that ball. To facilitate our study, we show how to adapt this radius to non-Euclidean spaces, which are prevalent in motion planning. This technical result is of independent interest, as it enables to compare the radial-connection approach with the common alternative, namely, connecting each configuration to its $k$ nearest neighbors ($k$-NN). Indeed, as we demonstrate, there are scenarios where using the radial connection scheme, a solution path of a specific cost is produced ten-fold (and more) faster than with $k$-NN. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2016; v1 submitted 16 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

New perspective on sampling-based motion planning via random geometric graphs

Authors: Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: Roadmaps constructed by many sampling-based motion planners coincide, in the absence of obstacles, with standard models of random geometric graphs (RGGs). Those models have been studied for several decades and by now a rich body of literature exists analyzing various properties and types of RGGs. In their seminal work on optimal motion planning Karaman and Frazzoli (2011) conjectured that a sampli… ▽ More Roadmaps constructed by many sampling-based motion planners coincide, in the absence of obstacles, with standard models of random geometric graphs (RGGs). Those models have been studied for several decades and by now a rich body of literature exists analyzing various properties and types of RGGs. In their seminal work on optimal motion planning Karaman and Frazzoli (2011) conjectured that a sampling-based planner has a certain property if the underlying RGG has this property as well. In this paper we settle this conjecture and leverage it for the development of a general framework for the analysis of sampling-based planners. Our framework, which we call localization-tessellation, allows for easy transfer of arguments on RGGs from the free unit-hypercube to spaces punctured by obstacles, which are geometrically and topologically much more complex. We demonstrate its power by providing alternative and (arguably) simple proofs for probabilistic completeness and asymptotic (near-)optimality of probabilistic roadmaps (PRMs). Furthermore, we introduce several variants of PRMs, analyze them using our framework, and discuss the implications of the analysis. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Motion Planning for Multi-Link Robots by Implicit Configuration-Space Tiling

Authors: Oren Salzman, Kiril Solovey, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We study the problem of motion-planning for free-flying multi-link robots and develop a sampling-based algorithm that is specifically tailored for the task. Our work is based on the simple observation that the set of configurations for which the robot is self-collision free is independent of the obstacles or of the exact placement of the robot. This allows to eliminate the need to perform costly s… ▽ More We study the problem of motion-planning for free-flying multi-link robots and develop a sampling-based algorithm that is specifically tailored for the task. Our work is based on the simple observation that the set of configurations for which the robot is self-collision free is independent of the obstacles or of the exact placement of the robot. This allows to eliminate the need to perform costly self-collision checks online when solving motion-planning problems, assuming some offline preprocessing. In particular, given a specific robot type our algorithm precomputes a tiling roadmap, which efficiently and implicitly encodes the self-collision free (sub-)space over the entire configuration space, where the latter can be infinite for that matter. To answer any query, in any given scenario, we traverse the tiling roadmap while only testing for collisions with obstacles. Our algorithm suggests more flexibility than the prevailing paradigm in which a precomputed roadmap depends both on the robot and on the scenario at hand. We show through various simulations the effectiveness of this approach on open and closed-chain multi-link robots, where in some settings our algorithm is more than fifty times faster than the state-of-the-art. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2015; v1 submitted 24 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Efficient high-quality motion planning by fast all-pairs r-nearest-neighbors

Authors: Michal Kleinbort, Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: Sampling-based motion-planning algorithms typically rely on nearest-neighbor (NN) queries when constructing a roadmap. Recent results suggest that in various settings NN queries may be the computational bottleneck of such algorithms. Moreover, in several asymptotically-optimal algorithms these NN queries are of a specific form: Given a set of points and a radius r report all pairs of points whose… ▽ More Sampling-based motion-planning algorithms typically rely on nearest-neighbor (NN) queries when constructing a roadmap. Recent results suggest that in various settings NN queries may be the computational bottleneck of such algorithms. Moreover, in several asymptotically-optimal algorithms these NN queries are of a specific form: Given a set of points and a radius r report all pairs of points whose distance is at most r. This calls for an application-specific NN data structure tailored to efficiently answering this type of queries. Randomly transformed grids (RTG) were recently proposed by Aiger et al. as a tool to answer such queries and have been shown to outperform common implementations of NN data structures in this context. In this work we employ RTG for sampling-based motion-planning algorithms and describe an efficient implementation of the approach. We show that for motion-planning, RTG allow for faster convergence to high-quality solutions when compared with existing NN data structures. Additionally, RTG enable significantly shorter construction times for batched-PRM variants; specifically, we demonstrate a speedup by a factor of two to three for some scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Asymptotically-Optimal Motion Planning using Lower Bounds on Cost

Authors: Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: Many path-finding algorithms on graphs such as A* are sped up by using a heuristic function that gives lower bounds on the cost to reach the goal. Aiming to apply similar techniques to speed up sampling-based motion-planning algorithms, we use effective lower bounds on the cost between configurations to tightly estimate the cost-to-go. We then use these estimates in an anytime asymptotically-optim… ▽ More Many path-finding algorithms on graphs such as A* are sped up by using a heuristic function that gives lower bounds on the cost to reach the goal. Aiming to apply similar techniques to speed up sampling-based motion-planning algorithms, we use effective lower bounds on the cost between configurations to tightly estimate the cost-to-go. We then use these estimates in an anytime asymptotically-optimal algorithm which we call Motion Planning using Lower Bounds (MPLB). MPLB is based on the Fast Marching Trees (FMT*) algorithm recently presented by Janson and Pavone. An advantage of our approach is that in many cases (especially as the number of samples grows) the weight of collision detection in the computation is almost negligible with respect to nearest-neighbor calls. We prove that MPLB performs no more collision-detection calls than an anytime version of FMT*. Additionally, we demonstrate in simulations that for certain scenarios, the algorithmic tools presented here enable efficiently producing low-cost paths while spending only a small fraction of the running time on collision detection. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2014; v1 submitted 30 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Asymptotically near-optimal RRT for fast, high-quality, motion planning

Authors: Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We present Lower Bound Tree-RRT (LBT-RRT), a single-query sampling-based algorithm that is asymptotically near-optimal. Namely, the solution extracted from LBT-RRT converges to a solution that is within an approximation factor of 1+epsilon of the optimal solution. Our algorithm allows for a continuous interpolation between the fast RRT algorithm and the asymptotically optimal RRT* and RRG algorith… ▽ More We present Lower Bound Tree-RRT (LBT-RRT), a single-query sampling-based algorithm that is asymptotically near-optimal. Namely, the solution extracted from LBT-RRT converges to a solution that is within an approximation factor of 1+epsilon of the optimal solution. Our algorithm allows for a continuous interpolation between the fast RRT algorithm and the asymptotically optimal RRT* and RRG algorithms. When the approximation factor is 1 (i.e., no approximation is allowed), LBT-RRT behaves like RRG. When the approximation factor is unbounded, LBT-RRT behaves like RRT. In between, LBT-RRT is shown to produce paths that have higher quality than RRT would produce and run faster than RRT* would run. This is done by maintaining a tree which is a sub-graph of the RRG roadmap and a second, auxiliary graph, which we call the lower-bound graph. The combination of the two roadmaps, which is faster to maintain than the roadmap maintained by RRT*, efficiently guarantees asymptotic near-optimality. We suggest to use LBT-RRT for high-quality, anytime motion planning. We demonstrate the performance of the algorithm for scenarios ranging from 3 to 12 degrees of freedom and show that even for small approximation factors, the algorithm produces high-quality solutions (comparable to RRG and RRT*) with little running-time overhead when compared to RRT. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2015; v1 submitted 1 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Finding a needle in an exponential haystack: Discrete RRT for exploration of implicit roadmaps in multi-robot motion planning

Authors: Kiril Solovey, Oren Salzman, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We present a sampling-based framework for multi-robot motion planning which combines an implicit representation of a roadmap with a novel approach for pathfinding in geometrically embedded graphs tailored for our setting. Our pathfinding algorithm, discrete-RRT (dRRT), is an adaptation of the celebrated RRT algorithm for the discrete case of a graph, and it enables a rapid exploration of the high-… ▽ More We present a sampling-based framework for multi-robot motion planning which combines an implicit representation of a roadmap with a novel approach for pathfinding in geometrically embedded graphs tailored for our setting. Our pathfinding algorithm, discrete-RRT (dRRT), is an adaptation of the celebrated RRT algorithm for the discrete case of a graph, and it enables a rapid exploration of the high-dimensional configuration space by carefully walking through an implicit representation of a tensor product of roadmaps for the individual robots. We demonstrate our approach experimentally on scenarios of up to 60 degrees of freedom where our algorithm is faster by a factor of at least ten when compared to existing algorithms that we are aware of. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2014; v1 submitted 13 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: Kiril Solovey and Oren Salzman contributed equally to this paper

Sparsification of Motion-Planning Roadmaps by Edge Contraction

Authors: Doron Shaharabani, Oren Salzman, Pankaj K. Agarwal, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We present Roadmap Sparsification by Edge Contraction (RSEC), a simple and effective algorithm for reducing the size of a motion-planning roadmap. The algorithm exhibits minimal effect on the quality of paths that can be extracted from the new roadmap. The primitive operation used by RSEC is edge contraction - the contraction of a roadmap edge to a single vertex and the connection of the new verte… ▽ More We present Roadmap Sparsification by Edge Contraction (RSEC), a simple and effective algorithm for reducing the size of a motion-planning roadmap. The algorithm exhibits minimal effect on the quality of paths that can be extracted from the new roadmap. The primitive operation used by RSEC is edge contraction - the contraction of a roadmap edge to a single vertex and the connection of the new vertex to the neighboring vertices of the contracted edge. For certain scenarios, we compress more than 98% of the edges and vertices at the cost of degradation of average shortest path length by at most 2%. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

On the Power of Manifold Samples in Exploring Configuration Spaces and the Dimensionality of Narrow Passages

Authors: Oren Salzman, Michael Hemmer, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We extend our study of Motion Planning via Manifold Samples (MMS), a general algorithmic framework that combines geometric methods for the exact and complete analysis of low-dimensional configuration spaces with sampling-based approaches that are appropriate for higher dimensions. The framework explores the configuration space by taking samples that are entire low-dimensional manifolds of the conf… ▽ More We extend our study of Motion Planning via Manifold Samples (MMS), a general algorithmic framework that combines geometric methods for the exact and complete analysis of low-dimensional configuration spaces with sampling-based approaches that are appropriate for higher dimensions. The framework explores the configuration space by taking samples that are entire low-dimensional manifolds of the configuration space capturing its connectivity much better than isolated point samples. The contributions of this paper are as follows: (i) We present a recursive application of MMS in a six-dimensional configuration space, enabling the coordination of two polygonal robots translating and rotating amidst polygonal obstacles. In the adduced experiments for the more demanding test cases MMS clearly outperforms PRM, with over 20-fold speedup in a coordination-tight setting. (ii) A probabilistic completeness proof for the most prevalent case, namely MMS with samples that are affine subspaces. (iii) A closer examination of the test cases reveals that MMS has, in comparison to standard sampling-based algorithms, a significant advantage in scenarios containing high-dimensional narrow passages. This provokes a novel characterization of narrow passages which attempts to capture their dimensionality, an attribute that had been (to a large extent) unattended in previous definitions. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2014; v1 submitted 23 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: 20 pages

Motion Planning via Manifold Samples

Authors: Oren Salzman, Michael Hemmer, Barak Raveh, Dan Halperin

Abstract: We present a general and modular algorithmic framework for path planning of robots. Our framework combines geometric methods for exact and complete analysis of low-dimensional configuration spaces, together with practical, considerably simpler sampling-based approaches that are appropriate for higher dimensions. In order to facilitate the transfer of advanced geometric algorithms into practical us… ▽ More We present a general and modular algorithmic framework for path planning of robots. Our framework combines geometric methods for exact and complete analysis of low-dimensional configuration spaces, together with practical, considerably simpler sampling-based approaches that are appropriate for higher dimensions. In order to facilitate the transfer of advanced geometric algorithms into practical use, we suggest taking samples that are entire low-dimensional manifolds of the configuration space that capture the connectivity of the configuration space much better than isolated point samples. Geometric algorithms for analysis of low-dimensional manifolds then provide powerful primitive operations. The modular design of the framework enables independent optimization of each modular component. Indeed, we have developed, implemented and optimized a primitive operation for complete and exact combinatorial analysis of a certain set of manifolds, using arrangements of curves of rational functions and concepts of generic programming. This in turn enabled us to implement our framework for the concrete case of a polygonal robot translating and rotating amidst polygonal obstacles. We demonstrate that the integration of several carefully engineered components leads to significant speedup over the popular PRM sampling-based algorithm, which represents the more simplistic approach that is prevalent in practice. We foresee possible extensions of our framework to solving high-dimensional problems beyond motion planning. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 18 pages