Showing 1–1 of 1 results for author: Romeijn, J

When is an Example a Counterexample?

Authors: Eric Pacuit, Arthur Paul Pedersen, Jan-Willem Romeijn

Abstract: In this extended abstract, we carefully examine a purported counterexample to a postulate of iterated belief revision. We suggest that the example is better seen as a failure to apply the theory of belief revision in sufficient detail. The main contribution is conceptual aiming at the literature on the philosophical foundations of the AGM theory of belief revision [1]. Our discussion is centered a… ▽ More In this extended abstract, we carefully examine a purported counterexample to a postulate of iterated belief revision. We suggest that the example is better seen as a failure to apply the theory of belief revision in sufficient detail. The main contribution is conceptual aiming at the literature on the philosophical foundations of the AGM theory of belief revision [1]. Our discussion is centered around the observation that it is often unclear whether a specific example is a "genuine" counterexample to an abstract theory or a misapplication of that theory to a concrete case. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 10 pages, Contributed talk at TARK 2013 (arXiv:1310.6382) http://www.tark.org

Report number: TARK/2013/p156