-
Experiences in Using the V-Model as a Framework for Applied Doctoral Research
Authors:
Rodrigo Falcão,
Andreas Jedlitschka,
Frank Elberzhager,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
The pervasive role played by software in virtually all industries has fostered ever-increasing development of applied research in software engineering. In this chapter, we contribute our experience in using the V-Model as a framework for teaching how to conduct applied research in empirical software engineering. The foundational idea of using the V-Model is presented, and guidance for using it to…
▽ More
The pervasive role played by software in virtually all industries has fostered ever-increasing development of applied research in software engineering. In this chapter, we contribute our experience in using the V-Model as a framework for teaching how to conduct applied research in empirical software engineering. The foundational idea of using the V-Model is presented, and guidance for using it to frame the research is provided. Furthermore, we show how the framework has been instantiated throughout nearly two decades of PhD theses done at the University of Kaiserslautern (RPTU Kaiserslautern) in partnership with Fraunhofer IESE, including the most frequent usage patterns, how the different empirical methods fit into the framework, and the lessons we have learned from this experience.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
A Systematic Identification of Formal and Semi-formalLanguages and Techniques for Software-intensiveSystems-of-Systems Requirements Modeling
Authors:
Cristiane Aparecida Lana,
Milena Guessi,
Pablo Oliveira Antonino,
Dieter Rombach,
Elisa Yumi NakagawaA
Abstract:
Software-intensive Systems-of-Systems (SoS) refer to an arrangement of managerially and operationally independent systems(i.e., constituent systems), which work collaboratively towards the achievement of global missions. Because some SoS are developed for critical domains, such as healthcare and transportation, there is an increasing need to attain higher quality levels, which often justifies addi…
▽ More
Software-intensive Systems-of-Systems (SoS) refer to an arrangement of managerially and operationally independent systems(i.e., constituent systems), which work collaboratively towards the achievement of global missions. Because some SoS are developed for critical domains, such as healthcare and transportation, there is an increasing need to attain higher quality levels, which often justifies additional costs that can be incurred by adopting formal and semi-formal approaches (i.e., languages and techniques) for modeling requirements. Various approaches have been employed, but a detailed landscape is still missing, and it is not well known whether they are appropriate for addressing the inherent characteristics of SoS. The main contribution of this article is to present this landscape by reporting on the state of the art in SoS requirements modeling. This landscape was built by means of a systematic map** and shows formal and semi-formal approaches grouped from model-based to property-oriented ones. Most of them have been tested in safety-critical domains, where formal approaches such as finite state machines are aimed at critical system parts, while semi-formal approaches (e.g., UML and i*) address non-critical parts. Although formal and semi-formal modeling is an essential activity, the quality of SoS requirements does not rely solely on which formalism is used, but also on the availability of supporting tools/mechanisms that enable, for instance, requirements verification along the SoS lifecycle
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
How practical is it? Machine Learning for Identifying Conceptual Interoperability Constraints in API Documents
Authors:
Hadil Abukwaik,
Mohammed Abufouda,
Thejashree Nair,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
Building meaningful interoperation with external software units requires performing the conceptual interoperability analysis that starts with identifying the conceptual interoperability constraints of each software unit, then it compares the systems' constraints to detect their conceptual mismatch. We call the conceptual interoperability constraints (the COINs) that can be of different types inclu…
▽ More
Building meaningful interoperation with external software units requires performing the conceptual interoperability analysis that starts with identifying the conceptual interoperability constraints of each software unit, then it compares the systems' constraints to detect their conceptual mismatch. We call the conceptual interoperability constraints (the COINs) that can be of different types including structure, dynamic, and quality. Missing such constraints may lead to unexpected mismatches, expensive resolution, and running-late projects. However, it is a challenging task for software architects and analysts to manually analyze the unstructured text in API documents to identify the COINs. Not only it is a tedious and time-consuming task, but also it needs knowledge about the constraint types. In this article, we present and evaluate our idea of utilizing machine learning techniques in automating the COIN identification, which is the first step of conceptual interoperability analysis, from human text in API documents. Our empirical research started with a multiple-case study to build the ground truth dataset, on which we contributed our machine learning COIN-Classification Model. We show the model's robustness through experiments using different machine learning text-classification algorithms. The experiments' results revealed that our model can achieve up to 87% accuracy in automatically identifying the COINs in text. Thus, we implemented a tool that embeds our model to demonstrate its practical value in industrial context. Then, we evaluated the practitioners' acceptance for the tool and found that they significantly agreed on its usefulness and ease of use.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Towards a Multi-criteria Development Distribution Model: An Analysis of Existing Task Distribution Approaches
Authors:
Ansgar Lamersdorf,
Jürgen Münch,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
Distributing development tasks in the context of global software development bears both many risks and many opportunities. Nowadays, distributed development is often driven by only a few factors or even just a single factor such as workforce costs. Risks and other relevant factors such as workforce capabilities, the innovation potential of different regions, or cultural factors are often not recog…
▽ More
Distributing development tasks in the context of global software development bears both many risks and many opportunities. Nowadays, distributed development is often driven by only a few factors or even just a single factor such as workforce costs. Risks and other relevant factors such as workforce capabilities, the innovation potential of different regions, or cultural factors are often not recognized sufficiently. This could be improved by using empirically-based multi-criteria distribution models. Currently, there is a lack of such decision models for distributing software development work. This article focuses on mechanisms for such decision support. First, requirements for a distribution model are formulated based on needs identified from practice. Then, distribution models from different domains are surveyed, compared, and analyzed in terms of suitability. Finally, research questions and directions for future work are given.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
GQM+Strategies: A Comprehensive Methodology for Aligning Business Strategies with Software Measurement
Authors:
Victor Basili,
Jens Heidrich,
Mikael Lindvall,
Jürgen Münch,
Myrna Regardie,
Dieter Rombach,
Carolyn Seaman,
Adam Trendowicz
Abstract:
In software-intensive organizations, an organizational management system will not guarantee organizational success unless the business strategy can be translated into a set of operational software goals. The Goal Question Metric (GQM) approach has proven itself useful in a variety of industrial settings to support quantitative software project management. However, it does not address linking softw…
▽ More
In software-intensive organizations, an organizational management system will not guarantee organizational success unless the business strategy can be translated into a set of operational software goals. The Goal Question Metric (GQM) approach has proven itself useful in a variety of industrial settings to support quantitative software project management. However, it does not address linking software measurement goals to higher-level goals of the organization in which the software is being developed. This linkage is important, as it helps to justify software measurement efforts and allows measurement data to contribute to higher-level decisions. In this paper, we propose a GQM+Strategies(R) measurement approach that builds on the GQM approach to plan and implement software measurement. GQM+Strategies(R) provides mechanisms for explicitly linking software measurement goals to higher-level goals for the software organization, and further to goals and strategies at the level of the entire business. The proposed method is illustrated in the context of an example application of the method.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
A Rule-based Model for Customized Risk Identification in Distributed Software Development Projects
Authors:
Ansgar Lamersdorf,
Jürgen Münch,
Alicia Fernández-del Viso Torre,
Carlos Rebate Sánchez,
Markus Heinz,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
Many project risks in distributed software development are very different from the ones in collocated development and therefore are often overlooked. At the same time, they depend to a large extent on project-specific characteristics. This article presents a model for identifying risks early in a project. This model systematically captures experiences from past projects and is based on a set of lo…
▽ More
Many project risks in distributed software development are very different from the ones in collocated development and therefore are often overlooked. At the same time, they depend to a large extent on project-specific characteristics. This article presents a model for identifying risks early in a project. This model systematically captures experiences from past projects and is based on a set of logical rules describing how project characteristics influence typical risks in distributed development. Thus, the model is able to assess risks individually for each project. It was developed by applying qualitative content analysis to 19 interviews with practitioners. An evaluation using expert interviews showed that the risks identified by the model matched the actual experiences in 81% of the cases; of these, 40% have not been regarded yet at project start. The article describes the concepts of the model, its instantiation and evaluation, followed by a conclusion and future work.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Estimating the Effort Overhead in Global Software Development
Authors:
Ansgar Lamersdorf,
Jürgen Münch,
Alicia Fernández-del Viso Torre,
Carlos Rebate Sánchez,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
Models for effort and cost estimation are important for distributed software development as well as for collocated software and system development. Standard cost models only insufficiently consider the characteristics of distributed development such as dissimilar abilities at the different sites or significant overhead due to remote collaboration. Therefore, explicit cost models for distributed de…
▽ More
Models for effort and cost estimation are important for distributed software development as well as for collocated software and system development. Standard cost models only insufficiently consider the characteristics of distributed development such as dissimilar abilities at the different sites or significant overhead due to remote collaboration. Therefore, explicit cost models for distributed development are needed. In this article, we present the initial development of a cost overhead model for a Spanish global software development organization. The model was developed using the CoBRA approach for cost estimation. As a result, cost drivers for the specific distributed development context were identified and their impact was quantified on an empirical basis. The article presents related work, an overview of the approach, and its application in the industrial context. Finally, we sketch the inclusion of the model in an approach for systematic task allocation and give an overview of future work.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
A Decision Model for Supporting Task Allocation Processes in Global Software Development
Authors:
Ansgar Lamersdorf,
Jürgen Münch,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
Today, software-intensive systems are increasingly being developed in a globally distributed way. However, besides its benefit, global development also bears a set of risks and problems. One critical factor for successful project management of distributed software development is the allocation of tasks to sites, as this is assumed to have a major influence on the benefits and risks. We introduce a…
▽ More
Today, software-intensive systems are increasingly being developed in a globally distributed way. However, besides its benefit, global development also bears a set of risks and problems. One critical factor for successful project management of distributed software development is the allocation of tasks to sites, as this is assumed to have a major influence on the benefits and risks. We introduce a model that aims at improving management processes in globally distributed projects by giving decision support for task allocation that systematically regards multiple criteria. The criteria and causal relationships were identified in a literature study and refined in a qualitative interview study. The model uses existing approaches from distributed systems and statistical modeling. The article gives an overview of the problem and related work, introduces the empirical and theoretical foundations of the model, and shows the use of the model in an example scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Linking Software Development and Business Strategy Through Measurement
Authors:
Victor R. Basili,
Jens Heidrich,
Mikael Lindvall,
Jürgen Münch,
Myrna Regardie,
Dieter Rombach,
Carolyn Seaman,
Adam Trendowicz
Abstract:
Most of today's products and services are software-based. Organizations that develop software want to maintain and improve their competitiveness by controlling software-related risks. To do this, they need to align their business goals with software development strategies and translate them into quantitative project management. There is also an increasing need to justify cost and resources for sof…
▽ More
Most of today's products and services are software-based. Organizations that develop software want to maintain and improve their competitiveness by controlling software-related risks. To do this, they need to align their business goals with software development strategies and translate them into quantitative project management. There is also an increasing need to justify cost and resources for software and system development and other IT services by demonstrating their impact on an organisation's higher-level goals. For both, linking business goals and software-related efforts in an organization is necessary. However, this is a challenging task, and there is a lack of methods addressing this gap. The GQM+Strategies approach effectively links goals and strategies on all levels of an organization by means of goal-oriented measurement. The approach is based on rationales for deciding about options when operationalizing goals and for evaluating the success of strategies with respect to goals.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Integrating Inspection and Test Processes Based on Context-Specific Assumptions
Authors:
Frank Elberzhager,
Jürgen Münch,
Dieter Rombach,
Bernd Freimut
Abstract:
Inspections and testing are two of the most commonly performed software quality assurance processes today. Typically, these processes are applied in isolation, which, however, fails to exploit the benefits of systematically combining and integrating them. In consequence, tests are not focused based on early defect detection data. Expected benefits of such process integration include higher defect…
▽ More
Inspections and testing are two of the most commonly performed software quality assurance processes today. Typically, these processes are applied in isolation, which, however, fails to exploit the benefits of systematically combining and integrating them. In consequence, tests are not focused based on early defect detection data. Expected benefits of such process integration include higher defect detection rates or reduced quality assurance effort. Moreover, when conducting testing without any prior information regarding the system's quality, it is often unclear how to focus testing. A systematic integration of inspection and testing processes requires context-specific knowledge about the relationships between inspections and testing. This knowledge is typically not available and needs to be empirically identified and validated. Often, context-specific assumptions can be seen as a starting point for generating such knowledge. Based on the In2Test approach, which uses inspection data to focus testing, we present in this article how knowledge about the relationship between inspections and testing can be gained, documented, and evolved in an analytical or empirical manner. In addition, this article gives an overview of related work and highlights future research directions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
A Survey on the State of the Practice in Distributed Software Development: Criteria for Task Allocation
Authors:
Ansgar Lamersdorf,
Jürgen Münch,
Dieter Rombach
Abstract:
The allocation of tasks can be seen as a success-critical management activity in distributed development projects. However, such task allocation is still one of the major challenges in global software development due to an insufficient understanding of the criteria that influence task allocation decisions. This article presents a qualitative study aimed at identifying and understanding such criter…
▽ More
The allocation of tasks can be seen as a success-critical management activity in distributed development projects. However, such task allocation is still one of the major challenges in global software development due to an insufficient understanding of the criteria that influence task allocation decisions. This article presents a qualitative study aimed at identifying and understanding such criteria that are used in practice. Based on interviews with managers from selected software development organizations, criteria currently applied in industry are identified. One important result is, for instance, that the sourcing strategy and the type of software to be developed have a significant effect on the applied criteria. The article presents the goals, design, and results of the study as well as an overview of related and future work.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
