-
Watching the Watchers: Nonce-based Inverse Surveillance to Remotely Detect Monitoring
Authors:
Laura M. Roberts,
David Plonka
Abstract:
Internet users and service providers do not often know when traffic is being watched but desire a way to determine when, where, and by whom. We present NOISE, the Nonce Observatory for Inverse Surveillance of Eavesdroppers, a method and system that detects monitoring by disseminating nonces - unique, pseudorandom values - in traffic and seeing if they are acted upon unexpectedly, indicating that t…
▽ More
Internet users and service providers do not often know when traffic is being watched but desire a way to determine when, where, and by whom. We present NOISE, the Nonce Observatory for Inverse Surveillance of Eavesdroppers, a method and system that detects monitoring by disseminating nonces - unique, pseudorandom values - in traffic and seeing if they are acted upon unexpectedly, indicating that the nonce-laden traffic is being monitored. Specifically, we embed 64-bit nonces innocuously into IPv6 addresses and disseminate these nonces Internet-wide using a modified traceroute-like tool that makes each outbound probe's source address unique. We continually monitor for subsequent nonce propagation, i.e., activity or interest involving these nonces, e.g., via packet capture on our system's infrastructure. Across three experiments and four months, NOISE detects monitoring more than 200k times, ostensibly in 268 networks, for probes destined for 437 networks. Our results reveal: (a) data collection for security incident handling, (b) traffic information being shared with third parties, and (c) eavesdrop** in or near a large commercial peering exchange.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2020; v1 submitted 15 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
How Do Tor Users Interact With Onion Services?
Authors:
Philipp Winter,
Anne Edmundson,
Laura M. Roberts,
Agnieszka Dutkowska-Zuk,
Marshini Chetty,
Nick Feamster
Abstract:
Onion services are anonymous network services that are exposed over the Tor network. In contrast to conventional Internet services, onion services are private, generally not indexed by search engines, and use self-certifying domain names that are long and difficult for humans to read. In this paper, we study how people perceive, understand, and use onion services based on data from 17 semi-structu…
▽ More
Onion services are anonymous network services that are exposed over the Tor network. In contrast to conventional Internet services, onion services are private, generally not indexed by search engines, and use self-certifying domain names that are long and difficult for humans to read. In this paper, we study how people perceive, understand, and use onion services based on data from 17 semi-structured interviews and an online survey of 517 users. We find that users have an incomplete mental model of onion services, use these services for anonymity and have varying trust in onion services in general. Users also have difficulty discovering and tracking onion sites and authenticating them. Finally, users want technical improvements to onion services and better information on how to use them. Our findings suggest various improvements for the security and usability of Tor onion services, including ways to automatically detect phishing of onion services, more clear security indicators, and ways to manage onion domain names that are difficult to remember.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Anomalous keys in Tor relays
Authors:
George Kadianakis,
Claudia V. Roberts,
Laura M. Roberts,
Philipp Winter
Abstract:
In its more than ten years of existence, the Tor network has seen hundreds of thousands of relays come and go. Each relay maintains several RSA keys, amounting to millions of keys, all archived by The Tor Project. In this paper, we analyze 3.7 million RSA public keys of Tor relays. We (i) check if any relays share prime factors or moduli, (ii) identify relays that use non-standard exponents, (iii)…
▽ More
In its more than ten years of existence, the Tor network has seen hundreds of thousands of relays come and go. Each relay maintains several RSA keys, amounting to millions of keys, all archived by The Tor Project. In this paper, we analyze 3.7 million RSA public keys of Tor relays. We (i) check if any relays share prime factors or moduli, (ii) identify relays that use non-standard exponents, (iii) characterize malicious relays that we discovered in the first two steps, and (iv) develop a tool that can determine what onion services fell prey to said malicious relays. Our experiments revealed that ten relays shared moduli and 3,557 relays -- almost all part of a research project -- shared prime factors, allowing adversaries to reconstruct private keys. We further discovered 122 relays that used non-standard RSA exponents, presumably in an attempt to attack onion services. By simulating how onion services are positioned in Tor's distributed hash table, we identified four onion services that were targeted by these malicious relays. Our work provides both The Tor Project and onion service operators with tools to identify misconfigured and malicious Tor relays to stop attacks before they pose a threat to Tor users.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2017; v1 submitted 3 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
The Effect of DNS on Tor's Anonymity
Authors:
Benjamin Greschbach,
Tobias Pulls,
Laura M. Roberts,
Philipp Winter,
Nick Feamster
Abstract:
Previous attacks that link the sender and receiver of traffic in the Tor network ("correlation attacks") have generally relied on analyzing traffic from TCP connections. The TCP connections of a typical client application, however, are often accompanied by DNS requests and responses. This additional traffic presents more opportunities for correlation attacks. This paper quantifies how DNS traffic…
▽ More
Previous attacks that link the sender and receiver of traffic in the Tor network ("correlation attacks") have generally relied on analyzing traffic from TCP connections. The TCP connections of a typical client application, however, are often accompanied by DNS requests and responses. This additional traffic presents more opportunities for correlation attacks. This paper quantifies how DNS traffic can make Tor users more vulnerable to correlation attacks. We investigate how incorporating DNS traffic can make existing correlation attacks more powerful and how DNS lookups can leak information to third parties about anonymous communication. We (i) develop a method to identify the DNS resolvers of Tor exit relays; (ii) develop a new set of correlation attacks (DefecTor attacks) that incorporate DNS traffic to improve precision; (iii) analyze the Internet-scale effects of these new attacks on Tor users; and (iv) develop improved methods to evaluate correlation attacks. First, we find that there exist adversaries who can mount DefecTor attacks: for example, Google's DNS resolver observes almost 40% of all DNS requests exiting the Tor network. We also find that DNS requests often traverse ASes that the corresponding TCP connections do not transit, enabling additional ASes to gain information about Tor users' traffic. We then show that an adversary who can mount a DefecTor attack can often determine the website that a Tor user is visiting with perfect precision, particularly for less popular websites where the set of DNS names associated with that website may be unique to the site. We also use the Tor Path Simulator (TorPS) in combination with traceroute data from vantage points co-located with Tor exit relays to estimate the power of AS-level adversaries who might mount DefecTor attacks in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2016; v1 submitted 26 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
