The Effectiveness of Embedded Values Analysis Modules in Computer Science Education: An Empirical Study
Authors:
Matthew Kopec,
Meica Magnani,
Vance Ricks,
Roben Torosyan,
John Basl,
Nicholas Miklaucic,
Felix Muzny,
Ronald Sandler,
Christo Wilson,
Adam Wisniewski-Jensen,
Cora Lundgren,
Kevin Mills,
Mark Wells
Abstract:
Embedding ethics modules within computer science courses has become a popular response to the growing recognition that CS programs need to better equip their students to navigate the ethical dimensions of computing technologies like AI, machine learning, and big data analytics. However, the popularity of this approach has outpaced the evidence of its positive outcomes. To help close that gap, this…
▽ More
Embedding ethics modules within computer science courses has become a popular response to the growing recognition that CS programs need to better equip their students to navigate the ethical dimensions of computing technologies like AI, machine learning, and big data analytics. However, the popularity of this approach has outpaced the evidence of its positive outcomes. To help close that gap, this empirical study reports positive results from Northeastern's program that embeds values analysis modules into CS courses. The resulting data suggest that such modules have a positive effect on students' moral attitudes and that students leave the modules believing they are more prepared to navigate the ethical dimensions they will likely face in their eventual careers. Importantly, these gains were accomplished at an institution without a philosophy doctoral program, suggesting this strategy can be effectively employed by a wider range of institutions than many have thought.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2023; v1 submitted 10 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
Toward a Rational and Ethical Sociotechnical System of Autonomous Vehicles: A Novel Application of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis
Authors:
Veljko Dubljević,
George F. List,
Jovan Milojevich,
Nirav Ajmeri,
William Bauer,
Munindar P. Singh,
Eleni Bardaka,
Thomas Birkland,
Charles Edwards,
Roger Mayer,
Ioan Muntean,
Thomas Powers,
Hesham Rakha,
Vance Ricks,
M. Shoaib Samandar
Abstract:
The expansion of artificial intelligence (AI) and autonomous systems has shown the potential to generate enormous social good while also raising serious ethical and safety concerns. AI technology is increasingly adopted in transportation. A survey of various in-vehicle technologies found that approximately 64% of the respondents used a smartphone application to assist with their travel. The top-us…
▽ More
The expansion of artificial intelligence (AI) and autonomous systems has shown the potential to generate enormous social good while also raising serious ethical and safety concerns. AI technology is increasingly adopted in transportation. A survey of various in-vehicle technologies found that approximately 64% of the respondents used a smartphone application to assist with their travel. The top-used applications were navigation and real-time traffic information systems. Among those who used smartphones during their commutes, the top-used applications were navigation and entertainment. There is a pressing need to address relevant social concerns to allow for the development of systems of intelligent agents that are informed and cognizant of ethical standards. Doing so will facilitate the responsible integration of these systems in society. To this end, we have applied Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) to develop a formal Multi-Attribute Impact Assessment (MAIA) questionnaire for examining the social and ethical issues associated with the uptake of AI. We have focused on the domain of autonomous vehicles (AVs) because of their imminent expansion. However, AVs could serve as a stand-in for any domain where intelligent, autonomous agents interact with humans, either on an individual level (e.g., pedestrians, passengers) or a societal level.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
