-
Identification of Challenging Highway-Scenarios for the Safety Validation of Automated Vehicles Based on Real Driving Data
Authors:
Thomas Ponn,
Matthias Breitfuß,
Xiao Yu,
Frank Diermeyer
Abstract:
For a successful market launch of automated vehicles (AVs), proof of their safety is essential. Due to the open parameter space, an infinite number of traffic situations can occur, which makes the proof of safety an unsolved problem. With the so-called scenario-based approach, all relevant test scenarios must be identified. This paper introduces an approach that finds particularly challenging scen…
▽ More
For a successful market launch of automated vehicles (AVs), proof of their safety is essential. Due to the open parameter space, an infinite number of traffic situations can occur, which makes the proof of safety an unsolved problem. With the so-called scenario-based approach, all relevant test scenarios must be identified. This paper introduces an approach that finds particularly challenging scenarios from real driving data (\RDDwo) and assesses their difficulty using a novel metric. Starting from the highD data, scenarios are extracted using a hierarchical clustering approach and then assigned to one of nine pre-defined functional scenarios using rule-based classification. The special feature of the subsequent evaluation of the concrete scenarios is that it is independent of the performance of the test vehicle and therefore valid for all AVs. Previous evaluation metrics are often based on the criticality of the scenario, which is, however, dependent on the behavior of the test vehicle and is therefore only conditionally suitable for finding "good" test cases in advance. The results show that with this new approach a reduced number of particularly challenging test scenarios can be derived.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Automatic Generation of Road Geometries to Create Challenging Scenarios for Automated Vehicles Based on the Sensor Setup
Authors:
Thomas Ponn,
Thomas Lanz,
Frank Diermeyer
Abstract:
For the offline safety assessment of automated vehicles, the most challenging and critical scenarios must be identified efficiently. Therefore, we present a new approach to define challenging scenarios based on a sensor setup model of the ego-vehicle. First, a static optimal approaching path of a road user to the ego-vehicle is calculated using an A* algorithm. We consider a poor perception of the…
▽ More
For the offline safety assessment of automated vehicles, the most challenging and critical scenarios must be identified efficiently. Therefore, we present a new approach to define challenging scenarios based on a sensor setup model of the ego-vehicle. First, a static optimal approaching path of a road user to the ego-vehicle is calculated using an A* algorithm. We consider a poor perception of the road user by the automated vehicle as optimal, because we want to define scenarios that are as critical as possible. The path is then transferred to a dynamic scenario, where the trajectory of the road user and the road layout are determined. The result is an optimal road geometry, so that the ego-vehicle can perceive an approaching object as poorly as possible. The focus of our work is on the highway as the Operational Design Domain (ODD).
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Systematic Analysis of the Sensor Coverage of Automated Vehicles Using Phenomenological Sensor Models
Authors:
Thomas Ponn,
Fabian Müller,
Frank Diermeyer
Abstract:
The objective of this paper is to propose a systematic analysis of the sensor coverage of automated vehicles. Due to an unlimited number of possible traffic situations, a selection of scenarios to be tested must be applied in the safety assessment of automated vehicles. This paper describes how phenomenological sensor models can be used to identify system-specific relevant scenarios. In automated…
▽ More
The objective of this paper is to propose a systematic analysis of the sensor coverage of automated vehicles. Due to an unlimited number of possible traffic situations, a selection of scenarios to be tested must be applied in the safety assessment of automated vehicles. This paper describes how phenomenological sensor models can be used to identify system-specific relevant scenarios. In automated driving, the following sensors are predominantly used: camera, ultrasonic, \radar and \lidarohne. Based on the literature, phenomenological models have been developed for the four sensor types, which take into account phenomena such as environmental influences, sensor properties and the type of object to be detected. These phenomenological models have a significantly higher reliability than simple ideal sensor models and require lower computing costs than realistic physical sensor models, which represents an optimal compromise for systematic investigations of sensor coverage. The simulations showed significant differences between different system configurations and thus support the system-specific selection of relevant scenarios for the safety assessment of automated vehicles.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2020; v1 submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
